Anime Analysis - Swordgai (Commentary)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024

Комментарии • 73

  • @theluckiesteh9058
    @theluckiesteh9058 2 года назад +20

    The series' creator is Toshiki Inoue, a longtime writer for anime and tokusatsu whose writing ranges from being great to downright terrible.
    He was actually the head writer for Death Note.

  • @cheechorino3710
    @cheechorino3710 2 года назад +21

    Nice to know shadowacs is posting still for a decade really helped me get into anime and what to look for in anime so I appreciate that

  • @a.utobotm7233
    @a.utobotm7233 2 года назад +2

    man . i have not watched this channel in ages ! it’s good to be back .

  • @bobbyakins1991
    @bobbyakins1991 2 года назад +17

    Sorry to say this but that's actually a thing in Japanese mythology that if it's always bathed in enough innocent blood it will become a type of demon that must feed upon the more and more blood I agree that the show is stupidly edgy but still that is actually a thing in Japanese mythology

    • @HxH2011DRA
      @HxH2011DRA 2 года назад +4

      To be fair, and I say this with all due respect, Japanese mythology is probably some of the edgiest there is (and definitely the weirdest)

  • @metalman6698
    @metalman6698 2 года назад +8

    Fuck me man I was afraid that this anime was actually good and I just missed something. Glad to see I'm not insane.

  • @BlueMoonSamurai
    @BlueMoonSamurai 2 года назад +5

    Honestly, a story about demonic swords and an insane character who genuinely believes that his real mother was a demonic sword is a fun idea. Maybe not a masterpiece but it could be decent.

  • @Oisc.
    @Oisc. Год назад +1

    ShadowACS is the “Mr. Enter” of RUclips anime reviews.

  • @sjvermazen
    @sjvermazen 2 года назад +5

    Me and my friend have been looking for an anime to roast together so thank you lol

  • @AceMitten99
    @AceMitten99 2 года назад +5

    Perfect Friday night!!! New ShadowACS video

  • @alibrennan5977
    @alibrennan5977 2 года назад +6

    What a way to start off the new year…
    Right?🙃

  • @davidtimmer596
    @davidtimmer596 2 года назад +4

    I think one action fantasy anime you may like is Chivalry of a Failed Knight.

  • @filibertomontoya2131
    @filibertomontoya2131 2 года назад +2

    any word on "DarknessDragoonRose" still miss him

  • @alibrennan5977
    @alibrennan5977 2 года назад +10

    Btw why is it called “Swordgai the animation”? Isn’t “the animation” part reserved for adaptions from video games? But from what I looked into, it was just based off a manga. Like you don’t call Fullmetal Alchemist “Fullmetal Alchemist the animation”. So even the title name itself is poorly handled

    • @jf4132
      @jf4132 2 года назад +1

      yeah I never got that either. just seems really dumb

  • @CRSB00
    @CRSB00 2 года назад +10

    I actually disagree that the "sword that kills too much becomes sentient and evil" premise is stupid, Saika from Durararara!! was a very interesting character
    also you fail to mention that the "semi possessed warriors eventually sucumb to the sword's evil and become the very monsters they hunt" was ripped off from Claymore

    • @treadingwater86
      @treadingwater86 2 года назад +4

      The idea of household-items taking on life of their own after either centuries of use or some sort of bloody tragedy is a part of japanese folklore, that is where the concept that many yokai comes from.
      And not to mention the legend of the Muramasa-blade who was rumored to curse the wielder with insatiable bloodlust, it even had to shed blood before it could be returned to its scabbard. If that doesn't sound like part of the premise of SwordGai, I don't know what is.

    • @CRSB00
      @CRSB00 2 года назад +3

      @@treadingwater86 one type of yokai, actually, tsukumogami and they usually act as guardians of sort as a form of gratitude for raking such good care of them

    • @plains7000
      @plains7000 2 года назад

      I've already Durarara! Here on wco stream.

  • @grilledavocado6125
    @grilledavocado6125 2 года назад +1

    I’ll be honest, I binge watched most of this show before dropping it. Why did I watch so much of it? I don’t know and I still couldn’t tell you what it’s about.

  • @jf4132
    @jf4132 2 года назад

    the only reason I gave this anime the time of day was because Keita Amameiya, the creator of the Garo franchise, was the character and creature designer of this series.

  • @davidtimmer596
    @davidtimmer596 2 года назад +5

    There are ways to make standoffish asshole main characters funny or likable. Kazuma from Konosuba is an example. The comedy comes from the fact that it's making fun of typical isekai anime tropes. Or Yuri from Tales of Vesperia, or Velvet from Berseria. Yuri can be a bit of a dick, but he doesn't cross the moral event horizon, and multiple times, he has shown to be kind when the situation's appropriate. Velvet's case is she was a loving big sister who worked painstakingly hard to take care of her sickly brother before her world fell apart due to the Scarlet Night. Yes, Tales of Berseria is known for being edgy, but its edginess makes sense.

  • @blooddrawer
    @blooddrawer Год назад

    everybody here needs to watch the anime and then re watch it and see how you think of it cause it is a gem that has stood out to me like white in black

  • @Waaagh40KRed
    @Waaagh40KRed 2 года назад +1

    Can't wait to see you review Record of Ragnarok. Fantastic premise, from a popular manga, translated into a disappointing anime.

  • @plains7000
    @plains7000 2 года назад +4

    Oh wow ShadowACS talking about this Swordgai explains the reasons why I dropped Black Lagoon after 7 episodes. It wasn't just because of the facts that I hated the character of Revi and the bad language that the shows cast used and the cigarettes in it. It was also because it was too dark and edgy. I found Black Butler and Black Cat to be better because while they were still dark they had good humour and plot too I also preferred them because also had no cigarettes or bad language.

  • @jacara1981
    @jacara1981 2 года назад +4

    Can you do Komi can't Communicate? It's on netflix

  • @HxH2011DRA
    @HxH2011DRA 2 года назад +2

    I mean hey at least "Idontcarewhogivesafuck" is a unique name XD

  • @moonstonepearl21
    @moonstonepearl21 2 года назад +3

    The only thing it has going for it is that I do believe that there is Japaeses lore about swords being sentient. Someone correct me if I'm wrong. Otherwise, it sounds like a real mess of an anime. You've wanted some atrocious ones over the years. Maybe it's time for an update of some sort of worst anime top 10. Maybe even a best anime of some form top 10.

  • @OlTimeyChara
    @OlTimeyChara 2 года назад +1

    8 years, man

  • @stevenchoza6391
    @stevenchoza6391 2 года назад +7

    Dude, just pick something that is good, notoriety or uniqueness be damned.

    • @r-saint
      @r-saint 2 года назад +3

      Or at least average, lmao.

  • @coffeeallen6166
    @coffeeallen6166 2 года назад +2

    I definitely want to know what you think of a newer anime called "To Your Eternity". I've heard it compared a lot to Mushishi(which I havent seen) but its by far my favorite anime. Its written by the author of A Silent Voice as well

  • @kurofan4235
    @kurofan4235 2 года назад +1

    Yes! A new video!

  • @daneyal7162
    @daneyal7162 Год назад

    I finished the anime yesterday. It has elements that I really liked, like the Busoma designs, but I have to agree that it's not a well made anime. One of my main issues is, like you said, the "relationship" between Gai and his stepsister, Sayaka. I just didn't felt any chemistry between them. I actually felt more chemistry between Sayaka and Shin, until he too sadly fell victim to the power of the second shiryu. I really wish that someone would've rewritten show and made it better, because like I said, there are elements in it that I liked.

  • @dylanfleurentin647
    @dylanfleurentin647 2 года назад +3

    Would you say this is worse than Seven Deadly Sins season 3?

  • @leonardojuan92
    @leonardojuan92 2 года назад +3

    To be honest while this anime! It drove me to watch black clover! Let me explain in context: while after finishing the series I wanted something to take away the taste of the anime and I said (fuck it) I’ll watch Black clover (several episodes later) and I became a fan of the series!

  • @avrinrose5457
    @avrinrose5457 2 года назад +2

    Can you talk About Kaitou Joker?

  • @matthewbraith0411
    @matthewbraith0411 2 года назад +2

    Edgy actually means on edge... even the internet term is supposed to be someone or something trying to be cool but failing.

  • @Pyropuca
    @Pyropuca 2 года назад +2

    Khoi Dao is in this 😔😔

  • @zackthezabarak739
    @zackthezabarak739 2 года назад +1

    Oh I saw this when it first came out!( I gave up after the first episode but that was just because I started watching ozark.) but I guess I appreciate that I didn’t waste my time and watch it.

  • @takumidoutou4412
    @takumidoutou4412 2 года назад +2

    I’d love to see your reaction to Vanitas no Carte

  • @GhostPact
    @GhostPact 2 года назад +1

    I don’t know why but I actually liked the anime

  • @plains7000
    @plains7000 2 года назад +1

    The Seraph of the End Guren Ichinose light novels I found to be more interesting than the anime that had the Hyakuya brothers. Also The demons who were in those weapons the characters used had interesting personalities.

  • @blooddrawer
    @blooddrawer Год назад

    ruclips.net/video/5JrXZK3Pzek/видео.html well the first thing you see or that helps you when you call is your mother and when you want comfort you go to your mother the sword to gai gives him comfort and helps him when he calls to him the sword is more of a mother than his actual mother

  • @moviesrocks2
    @moviesrocks2 2 года назад +2

    Wow! Tell us how you really feel about it! I haven’t heard you hate in an anime since dears. Hopefully the next one will be better. Can’t be worse can it?

  • @canaryqueen4050
    @canaryqueen4050 2 года назад +1

    Well I kind of feel the same way over promised Neverland seasons whoever want it in the community was roasting it but I remember that show I didn’t even know there was a season two I only watched two episodes of season one I was weird it out and I I feel like I wanted to watch the remake of shaman king than that again

  • @Mitch-K
    @Mitch-K 2 года назад +3

    Who still says the word 'edgy' post 2003?

  • @plains7000
    @plains7000 2 года назад +1

    This reminds me of when I watched and read the books of Sao Alicization when Eugeo told Cardinal to turn him into a sword to kill Quinella. Though afterwards the sword transformation broke some of Eugeo's spirit life remained with the blue rose sword which was part of sword transformation spell of Cardinal's. I own the sao light novels and I do read them in my free time. I was happy that whatever was left of Eugeo in that blue rose sword was able to snap Kazuto Kirigaya out of his coma. Its just I still feel as though Eugeo was wasted potential. Eugeo had good character when he was still alive in general. I know Memories are everlasting. Hopefully Eolyne has better roles in Unital Ring when I finally get to reading V3/24 and V4/25 in April and rest of the future. Look have I different opinions to most people when it comes to Kirito deal with it. I found his character interesting throughout all seasons of Sao, books and the anime adaptations.

    • @MoltenBox
      @MoltenBox 2 года назад

      Agree. If reki still put kirito in a coma. Then he could leave eugeo with s30 alice. I believe s30 alice wanted to give her body back to the original. With kirito gone eugeo would have to find out on his own if he should listen to what s30 wants. Or deny it saying it's wrong that it's basically the same thing as murder. His moral compass could be challenge which would have been very interesting

    • @plains7000
      @plains7000 2 года назад

      @@MoltenBox I do see your points and agree. Tbh it was depressing to me seeing Kirito as a vegetable in a wheelchair. I was literally relieved when he eventually got better and stopped Gabriel Miller Emperor Vecta/Subtilizer and Poh/The Man in the Black Poncho/Vassago/Laughing coffin leader from wreaking more havoc in underworld with how monstrous they were. Those 2 were the 1st straight up dark villains in Sao. I still wonder if Mutasina is dark when I do eventually get V24 and V25 in the future. I am a subscriber of Gamerturk. I have heard a huge lot of information from him.

    • @MoltenBox
      @MoltenBox 2 года назад

      @@plains7000 like wise I've heard a lot too. I'm all but certain that the star king had something to do with eolyne looking exactly like eugeo. And I really wonder why?

    • @plains7000
      @plains7000 Год назад

      ​@@MoltenBoxI've finished 24, 25 and 26 and wow the Unital Ring Books and they eventually got released over the years leading to my purchases of those books and they really invested me in this Eolyne's character sorry if I got off topic I guess Swordgai seems okay. Eolyne being a Eugeo lookalike with an accomplishments being one of the winners of that swordfighting Zakkaria Unification tournament and an Integrity Pilot Commander wow Reki has gotten good with this Eolyne.

  • @thathumanizedpanda9890
    @thathumanizedpanda9890 2 года назад +2

    What are your thoughts on To your Eternity?

  • @Aria_ariesmagi
    @Aria_ariesmagi 2 года назад +2

    I was already disappointed with persona 5 anime I thought it was gonna be great like the video game, but it was a little bit off. I can't put my finger on it, I really love persona 4, and it was really funny, and it was adapted really great

  • @hottiekitty96
    @hottiekitty96 2 года назад

    Love your content! Keep it up💖

  • @orvaldurgumundson1809
    @orvaldurgumundson1809 2 года назад +1

    I really recommend fruit basket for you.

  • @blooddrawer
    @blooddrawer Год назад

    yes it got two seasons

  • @jackofalltrades417
    @jackofalltrades417 2 года назад +1

    Is every anime with "Sword" in the title a fucking train wreck?

  • @veda_fluff_asmr5064
    @veda_fluff_asmr5064 2 года назад +1

    The characters are popping up like ocs pfft 🤣

  • @knight6087
    @knight6087 Год назад

    One of the most f*ck up anime I've ever seen really!

  • @pokemongirl5674
    @pokemongirl5674 2 года назад +1

    I avoided this anime like the plague since I first looked at the opening theme for the 1st season, since it looked quite uh...bad. Needless to say, glad that I didn't watch the anime. The dub sounded very stilted based on the clips shown but yet again, it felt like the vas had like nothing good to work with.

  • @zemox2534
    @zemox2534 2 года назад +2

    Just by looking at the thumb nail, I knew this anime would be complete rubbish.

  • @Alloutgamer-ur8vu
    @Alloutgamer-ur8vu 2 года назад +1

    Review meta runner

  • @blooddrawer
    @blooddrawer Год назад

    ruclips.net/video/5JrXZK3Pzek/видео.html ok i have to agree with you hear cause it is obvious

  • @Monhamd1000
    @Monhamd1000 2 года назад +1

    That's how shounen is in nutshell

  • @veda_fluff_asmr5064
    @veda_fluff_asmr5064 2 года назад

    All edgy 13 year old boys watching 👁👄👁

  • @veda_fluff_asmr5064
    @veda_fluff_asmr5064 2 года назад

    Ehh seems pretty cheesy hmmm the animation isn't bad I guess ^^;