The "Anti-Batman" Dilemma

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 21 янв 2025

Комментарии • 1,4 тыс.

  • @TheBatspecter
    @TheBatspecter  Год назад +1006

    Apologies in advance for the louder/compressed parts of the video. Moments like those will not be in future videos.

    • @lusansart536
      @lusansart536 Год назад +28

      Man this is some good work. If you keep it like this I'm sure you'll find the right audience ! Love the vid ! Don't give up :)

    • @metelineblue294
      @metelineblue294 Год назад +17

      VENOMMM

    • @theindiankid5852
      @theindiankid5852 Год назад +27

      I thought it was funny

    • @killerbean4328
      @killerbean4328 Год назад +3

      All good bro

    • @Ratteler
      @Ratteler Год назад +63

      EQ it in Audacity and re-upload. That was a nightmare.

  • @corven03
    @corven03 Год назад +1556

    your talk is good, but killer moth is the greatest simply because he was in lego batman. were the others in lego batman? didn’t think so.

  • @kenj0165
    @kenj0165 Год назад +2727

    Owlman is the most interesting doppelganger to me and has so much potential.

    • @jimbenzo
      @jimbenzo Год назад +110

      Especially the Lincoln March version, I love the idea of him being the secret brother that Bruce doesn’t wanna accept.

    • @matthewschwartz6607
      @matthewschwartz6607 Год назад +19

      @@jimbenzo- Does he still know Batman’s secret identity ?

    • @absoluteedgelord9981
      @absoluteedgelord9981 Год назад

      ​@@matthewschwartz6607yes

    • @jameslight4391
      @jameslight4391 Год назад +9

      @@matthewschwartz6607 probably not it would be cool if he did

    • @brawlco3176
      @brawlco3176 Год назад +2

      He really got nothing on nightowl

  • @jamemhm
    @jamemhm Год назад +4856

    Fun fact: Catman wasn't originally made to be a Batman doppelganger, only created one year after Batman and belonging to a completely different publisher. Catman originally was just a man raised by cats, and he was a hero who had his own comic line with a sidekick named kitten. This comic was actually extremely popular, but the publisher eventually went out of business and catman fell into the public domain. This is why you can find the character in multiple different IPs, from DC comics to Fairly Oddparents.

  • @kingbash6466
    @kingbash6466 Год назад +1263

    The Batman Who Laughs has such a cool design, but they ran him into the ground because of how popular he became, he's sorta treated like how Injustice Superman is treated by fans. In my opinion, Owlman is the perfect doppelganger for Batman. Not only since owls are seen as predators to bats, but they both are based on animals that operate the best during the night and are often be used as symbols of fear and darkness.

    • @Acacius1992
      @Acacius1992 Год назад +4

      Just Injustice Superman (as flawed he is) is the only way i can stand Superman.

    • @salt6186
      @salt6186 Год назад +98

      @@Acacius1992 Go read Superman For All Seasons or All-Star Superman. I’m not a big Superman fan, but even I can tell that a lot of the time movies miss the point of him. Especially Snyder.

    • @danger_1189
      @danger_1189 Год назад +45

      @@Acacius1992injustice superman isnt super badly written (besides the obvious caveat of behaving out of character), but also wtf superman slaps

    • @nielsjensen4185
      @nielsjensen4185 Год назад +20

      Judge Death wore it best. To me, the design of TBWL is just, "We got Judge Death at home."

    • @nielsjensen4185
      @nielsjensen4185 Год назад +23

      @@Acacius1992 There are a LOT better versions of a "Superman but evil." The Injustice Superman is the vastly inferior version of Lord Superman from Justice League Animated.
      The inspiration for the Injustice Superman is the Superman from, "What's So Funny about Truth, Justice, and the American Way?" which was later adapted into the animated movie "Superman vs the Elite." The story perfectly captures everything the modern "Superman but evil" fails to understand. Superman's behaviour is a choice so, when he behaves like a boy scout it's a conscious choice he's made, likewise, when the good guy turns bad it's a conscious choice as well of him choosing to embrace everything his powers can do. In the intro to the JLA episode where Lord Superman appears when he was just Superman his final words to Lex Luthor were, "I liked being a hero," and then he heat-visioned him to save the world from being nuked. That's a lot more chilling than Injustice Superman who did a murder in a state of grief.
      While Homelander does seem like the typical "Superman but evil" it's a subversion of expectations since he's "Trump but superpowers" and that's fucking scary.

  • @billyboleson2830
    @billyboleson2830 Год назад +900

    The problem with these bizzaro Batman types is that Batman himself already looks like a villain so it’s hard to make an evil doppelgänger of him. Another reason they never caught on is Batman already has WAY WAY too many “rival” type characters as is. Let’s see we got Bane, Ra’s, Hush, red hood back when he was mostly an antagonist, Failsafe (who’s just a poor man’s D.A.V.E.) ghost maker, owlman, Prometheus, wrath, kgbeast, BMWL, Talon, and sadly as much as I don’t like deathstroke being a Batman villain I have to count him too and I’m probably MISSING some here! He really doesn’t need anymore!

    • @kaison12205
      @kaison12205 Год назад +67

      Failsafe is more like amazo. Like he’s not an anti Batman as he doesn’t kill. And actually was built to work within the Batman framework
      I would replace him with zur

    • @billyboleson2830
      @billyboleson2830 Год назад +36

      @@kaison12205 honestly agreed, maybe throw in anarky in there as well tbh. Or Azrael….. and David Cain/Orphan God the list just keeps getting bigger

    • @ShockwaveFPSStudios
      @ShockwaveFPSStudios Год назад +1

      Bizzaro Batman?! You fake fan! His name’s Batzarro. FAKER

    • @ShockwaveFPSStudios
      @ShockwaveFPSStudios Год назад +9

      @@billyboleson2830but Azarel did became Batman… once.

    • @DevilSlayer502
      @DevilSlayer502 Год назад +2

      @@kaison12205he did kill Batman after Batman fell from space

  • @wdcain1
    @wdcain1 Год назад +481

    Each anti-Batman needs to represent a different facet of the Bat. Prometheus is the big-time evil Bat that can wreck any hero with prep time, Killer Moth is works the streets by protecting crooks, and the Wrath is the soldier who's waging war on Gotham's police.

    • @zachbahamutson5477
      @zachbahamutson5477 Год назад +46

      So basically if we could find a way to write a character with these three facets we would have a true anti Batman, I will say that would be interesting.

    • @anonymousoff-brand7538
      @anonymousoff-brand7538 Год назад +40

      i mean, part of the issue is. the reason batmans entire rogues gallery is as great as it is is that basically every big villain is an 'anti-batman' in this sense.

    • @nkemnoraulmanfredini7286
      @nkemnoraulmanfredini7286 Год назад

      Almost every villain of Batman@@anonymousoff-brand7538

    • @ibn_adham
      @ibn_adham Год назад +3

      ​@@anonymousoff-brand7538Uh, did you watch the whole video?

    • @rizkiramadhan9266
      @rizkiramadhan9266 Год назад +6

      Killer moth is a completely different beast altogether

  • @21eienni
    @21eienni Год назад +222

    A real shame Killer Moth wasn't really in the Arkham games. Like, he was mentioned, there were easter eggs, etc, but it could have been pretty cool to have a whole side mission about him.

    • @ulyssesveracruz8343
      @ulyssesveracruz8343 Год назад +23

      He was mentioned but red hood already killed him 😢

    • @21eienni
      @21eienni Год назад +12

      @@ulyssesveracruz8343 Yeah, I hate that

    • @ulyssesveracruz8343
      @ulyssesveracruz8343 Год назад +14

      @@21eienni yeah me too its a shame because killer moth could work in the arkhamverse 😔

    • @hyhena-gaming9986
      @hyhena-gaming9986 6 месяцев назад +7

      Oh gif imagine if we had him as the Arkham knight instead

    • @Thatboxlady
      @Thatboxlady 4 месяца назад +4

      ​@@ulyssesveracruz8343 nah he's alive, red hood could never take Killer Moth
      Probably faked his own death fr fr

  • @gimmeyourrights8292
    @gimmeyourrights8292 Год назад +821

    Call me boring, but I think its more interesting to have a character who is a moral and philosophical dark mirror to a superhero than just "Hero but evil." Because a lot of dopplegangers fail on what makes their rival interesting philosophically but understand it visually.

    • @TheBatspecter
      @TheBatspecter  Год назад +214

      There's room for both honestly

    • @billyboleson2830
      @billyboleson2830 Год назад +65

      This is why rival characters are more popular then recolor villains

    • @thephoenix4093
      @thephoenix4093 Год назад +22

      @@billyboleson2830 eh, venom is extremly well known. and he's basically a black spiderman with teeth.

    • @mariogariazzo2024
      @mariogariazzo2024 Год назад +66

      ​@@thephoenix4093 not really? It depends on the writer, but normally, Venom is literally the hatred and frustration Peter was feeling during his time with the symbiote. And when they fight, the dillema is that Peter gave up on all that power because it makes him less responsable (yea I said the thing)

    • @thephoenix4093
      @thephoenix4093 Год назад +8

      @@mariogariazzo2024 normally, venom is just an angry bad spiderman. he's just a mirror.

  • @dc7981
    @dc7981 Год назад +1165

    Prometheus was intended to be a parody of the typical “anti Batman” trope but then he just kinda stopped being that and turned into exactly what he was supposed to be a satire of
    Btw the best anti Batman is Bane and it’s not even close (yes I think he counts they literally compare their backstories and mirror them multiple times) and no deathstroke fans slade isn’t a “Batman but evil!” Character….

    • @shadowclaw7210
      @shadowclaw7210 Год назад +161

      Death stroke is anti Captain America if anything

    • @loganr746
      @loganr746 Год назад +90

      I always considered Anarky to be the anti-Batman but less from personality and more based off their conditions. Anarky was born into a dysfunctional family with violence and crime being fairly commonplace. Batman’s solutions to crime (I’m generalizing here, I know this is different with every story) is more or less a band aid solution. He finds people doing crimes, then he stops them and locks them up. Anarky kind of realizes how pointless this is and seeks to combat the causes of crime (poverty, desperation, power, etc). Now, he’s incredibly radical in his approach and can sometimes miss the point but his existence kind of serves as a counter to Batman’s entire existence, he’s challenging Batman’s logic in a way that few other vilains can. Anyways, that’s my long winded explanation of how I few the sociology of a comic book world, hope you enjoyed.

    • @christianvondruska8244
      @christianvondruska8244 Год назад +23

      He's not even consistently a Batman villain.

    • @rent6114
      @rent6114 Год назад +26

      Actually bane ended up becoming Batman in a Arkham comic which was pretty dope to see

    • @dc7981
      @dc7981 Год назад +33

      @@shadowclaw7210 thank you! You’d be surprised how many people think deathstroke is a peak human and not a superhuman it’s ridiculous. I remember back in the origins days when people would say that he’s an anti Batman a lot and like …. How? They pretty much have jack in common

  • @Pufferfish_King_Kraken_Fan
    @Pufferfish_King_Kraken_Fan Год назад +287

    Killer Moth actually really works at what he is - the comedic relief underdog - the loveable loser we all root for. I don't get why so many people online insist on making him a serious threat as if Batman Mythos really needed him to be one. Moth has found his niche within the rogues gallery and he works pretty well within that niche.
    Also - I don't think it's the design why Anti-Batmen don't really stick - it's their personality. Their Anti-ness is so superficial that it is actually really boring. I mean, it is just as you said, so many of Batman's villains already clearly reflect his personality that a pure "Evil version" isn't needed. And what is the purpose of an Anti-Batman anyway? To have a Villain that is a true equal? Both in physical ability, access to resources, and tactical ability? Well in that case we already have an Anti-Batman who managed to stick around as a serious threat. It's Bane. Bane is everything you would get out of an Anti-Batman with the sole exception that his silhouette isn't a straight-up recoloring of Batman's.
    Aslo also, dude - the entire loud equals funny joke really hurts your video, man.

    • @matthewschwartz6607
      @matthewschwartz6607 Год назад +5

      Isn’t he supposed to be Batgirl’s arch-enemy?

    • @Pufferfish_King_Kraken_Fan
      @Pufferfish_King_Kraken_Fan Год назад +24

      @@matthewschwartz6607 Some of Batgirls most notable stories feature him but that doesn't mean that he isn't still a member of Batman's rogues gallery.

    • @nkemnoraulmanfredini7286
      @nkemnoraulmanfredini7286 Год назад

      NO!@@matthewschwartz6607

    • @vinegarenthusiast7043
      @vinegarenthusiast7043 Год назад +39

      killer moth doesn't need to be this super-imposing ultimate threat, but if a guy's entire job is to protect criminals from batman he should be competent enough to win once in a while. even if he'd lose a straight fist-fight, his use of underhanded tactics batman avoids on principle (like guns) should give him enough of an edge to go toe-to-toe.

    • @Pufferfish_King_Kraken_Fan
      @Pufferfish_King_Kraken_Fan Год назад +8

      @@vinegarenthusiast7043 or he could just be really bad at his job because that would be way funnier.

  • @lukedofboom6053
    @lukedofboom6053 Год назад +152

    great video but the sudden changes in volume made it hard as a headphone user. jokes would probably turn out the same without the volume spike maybe have camera shake for emphasis instead so it’s a visual display instead of auditory. either way can’t wait to see the next video

    • @mgreysanders
      @mgreysanders Год назад +20

      Fr. The bass boost was way too much a headache while just saying the joke would've been hit and the same and would be just as if not funnier. Good stuff though especially moth edit

    • @JustATreeMann
      @JustATreeMann Год назад +12

      ​@@mgreysandersloud=funny, duh ?

  • @TooMannyForYou
    @TooMannyForYou Год назад +161

    DC Catman is a really weird but fun take of the character but I prefer the orginal David MerryWeather - Catman from the 40s. Keep up the great work I learned a lot watching this.

  • @philiphockenbury6563
    @philiphockenbury6563 Год назад +90

    The one thing that bothers me about the wrath is that the killer is connected to one of the established characters. One of the most important characters. The cop that did it has to be a Joe Chill. A do nothing nobody who’s only act of note was making Batman/Wrath. But his character being someone who hates the police because one of them got away with murder essentially scot free is amazing. And very deliberately uncomfortably realistic. Any person in the wrong place at the wrong time can get shot and Justice is hard to get.

    • @Private-Potato
      @Private-Potato Год назад +23

      You could definitely make a great story with Wrath if you change the costume to look more Batman-ish, and make it not Gordon that killed his parents. A random corrupt cop would work much better with the parallels between him and Bats.

    • @pedrovallefin8406
      @pedrovallefin8406 2 месяца назад +3

      ​@@Private-PotatoPlus, it dirties Gordon character too much that he killed a couple in front of their kid and got away scott free. It doesn’t work with the modern take of him as a incorruptible cop.

    • @Private-Potato
      @Private-Potato 2 месяца назад +1

      @@pedrovallefin8406 exactly

  • @SailHatinSoap
    @SailHatinSoap Год назад +98

    I think black mask is the best one. Instead of witnessing his rich parents deaths, he orchestrated it. Rather than use the inheritence to fight crime, he uses it to buy his way in essentially. And where you have the "batman's mask is Bruce Wayne," black mask's mask is... his whole personality now. I think he's perfect reflection. He's the perfect anti for both Bruce and batman

  • @BlastBoyX
    @BlastBoyX Год назад +111

    Don't forget Batzarro, who killed his own parents in order to solve the crime, uses guns that have a "!MALB" sound effect, says everything he is thinking out loud, and wears a futility belt!

    • @cronsterkintar
      @cronsterkintar 4 месяца назад +4

      The best batman ever

    • @omegaminoseer4539
      @omegaminoseer4539 18 дней назад +1

      Batzarro is probably the purest version of Anti-Batman. He uses guns, barely solves crimes, and is generally a super-mutant who runs around, ending lives in the name of his own goals.

  • @Van-Marker
    @Van-Marker Год назад +213

    Killer moth is still the greatest

  • @SilverHairedFreak25
    @SilverHairedFreak25 Год назад +81

    I still think The Batman's version of Wrath is the best "Evil Batman" we have that's not a _literal_ evil Batman like Owlman or The Batman Who Talks. He's a great amalgamation of the other anti-Batmen you mentioned. He's got the backstory and look of the original, but the color scheme of Catman helps him stand out against the Dark Knight while not looking completely garish like his comics counterpart. Not to mention Scorn's monochromatic color scheme is a great contrast to the bright and colorful Robin as well, so kudos there. And he's got the inverted morality and M.O. of Killer Moth as a protector of criminals, which really digs into the motivation of Batman and warps it. Wrath's parents were arrested/killed like Bruce's, so he dedicates his life to protecting others against those who wronged him in the past. The catch is, he's protecting evil people from those who wish to seek justice. It's much more interesting than him just being a glorified serial killer with a hate boner for cops.

  • @farmerboblol
    @farmerboblol Год назад +104

    4:08 Killer Moth
    7:22 Catman
    10:08 Wrath
    15:34 Prometheus

  • @legogoka-boomstudio1838
    @legogoka-boomstudio1838 Год назад +93

    I think there is also an at least decent anti Batman in “Batman: Detective”. Essentially a criminal that Batman didn’t let die, killed the family of a merc woman who actually trained with Batman before he was Batman, and she decides to wear a full white bat suit and attempts to kill everyone Batman has saved (more street level saving with records rather than universe scale). It kinda ends up being a less valid version of the red hood concept but still has some interesting tidbits.
    Hell you could consider red hood an evil Batman (he even has done it directly at times) but it’s not much of an exact and he’s usually a good guy nowadays.

  • @mricicl9642
    @mricicl9642 Год назад +15

    I think that killer moth is the perfect anti-Batman. Who is the opposite of a confident, well respected superhero, a failing unrespected super villain.

  • @StriderStryker
    @StriderStryker Год назад +173

    Good thing you didn’t talk about The Batman Who Laughs. He was so complicated that he became The Darkest Knight.

    • @alexblake5369
      @alexblake5369 Год назад +64

      The Batman Who Laughs is a perfect example of a great idea DC had, run into the ground due to DC having zero sense of self-control. Like the concept and execution of The Batman Who Laughs first appearance is great. Granted his final battle in The Metal series wasn't great but I would argue that the metal series as a whole didn't land great. Still DC knew they had a home run with this character, so if they used him sparingly he could become Batman's Darkside; but instead they milked the character concept to death and overused it to the point where comic fans rolled their eyes and visibly grew annoyed when they saw the character.

    • @charlesman8722
      @charlesman8722 Год назад +31

      @@alexblake5369he was never a good idea

    • @bibbyboxx2219
      @bibbyboxx2219 Год назад +37

      @@charlesman8722I agree. His origin story is contrived and is much more concerned with being “cool” and edgy than actually telling a compelling story about Batman descending into madness.

    • @redjirachi1
      @redjirachi1 Год назад +40

      The Batman Who Tries To Hard isn't so much an anti-Batman as he is the meme that "Batman/Joker can beat anyone with prep time" given flesh

    • @mihailos8701
      @mihailos8701 Год назад

      I think similar thing is currently happening with Miles Morales and Gwen as Ghost-Spider - too much, and too fast @@alexblake5369

  • @megaultradamn
    @megaultradamn Год назад +11

    What i hate about these doppelgangers is that you don't really need them to exist. Every villain has the potential to be a dark reflection of the hero. Doc Ock is what Spiderman could've been if he let his resentment stew for years. Green Goblin is what Peter could be if he let his obsession with scholastic excellency over take everything he holds dear, just to prove he wasn't a loser. Two-Face is Batman's zealousness for justice taken to its extreme.
    These so called doppelgangers are played mostly for aesthetics. You see their costume on the cover, with a spalsh page that says "The coming of Nega-Batman!" And you think "woah! Its like our hero was turned evil! Aint that something!"

  • @TurbopropPuppy
    @TurbopropPuppy Год назад +25

    I think an interesting angle that could be explored for an Anti-Batman is for his "no killing" policy to be funhouse-mirrored. You don't have to kill anyone to be a villain, and there are fates some might consider worse than death.

  • @jackb555
    @jackb555 Год назад +7

    imagine batman turned you into steven hawking💀

  • @ejam4345
    @ejam4345 Год назад +1194

    Azrael was also a great anti-Batman. Knightfall is a great read

    • @plasticweapon
      @plasticweapon Год назад +38

      the best.

    • @sosa2mars
      @sosa2mars Год назад +48

      Yeah I’m surprised he didn’t bring him up

    • @billyboleson2830
      @billyboleson2830 Год назад +44

      It’s funny we have all these red hood fans now when azrael was doing his schtick years before he was a thing

    • @GingeryGinger
      @GingeryGinger Год назад +48

      ⁠@@billyboleson2830you mean azrael was emotionally hurt through Batman’s no-kill rule which lead to misunderstanding between him and bat,an?

    • @thegamingprozone1941
      @thegamingprozone1941 Год назад +1

      Yes agreed 👍

  • @A_Son_of_Demeter
    @A_Son_of_Demeter Год назад +20

    Wrath is also a part of The Batman show from the 2000s alongside his own version of Robin

  • @sagenerd419
    @sagenerd419 Год назад +19

    Even though calendar man was basically just an elaborate plot device, he works so well that way in the long halloween
    I loved him as a narrative device that is a part of the pacing and the tone

  • @amaze2173
    @amaze2173 Год назад +21

    Great video, you did great with it. (The stutters and stuff in the voice over gave the video a lot of charm)

  • @jacobburt1523
    @jacobburt1523 Год назад +72

    The problem I'm getting from this is that most of their motivations are just stupid: Killer Moth was basically trying to be a mercenary with a "Batman but for criminals" gimmick, Catman was just board (my mom owns his debut issue and he actually considers becoming a crime fighter before deciding that since Catwoman was reformed at the time he should just fill the void she left), the Wrath's parents were killed by Gordon (ostensibly in self defense) so now he wants to kill all cops, Prometheus was basically raised by his parents to hate justice (without him ever actually learning the meaning of the word). With this in mind, I think that the version of Wrath from The Batman had the best motivation: his parents were criminals who committed crime to support him and his little brother, so as Wrath and Scorn they run interference on Batman and the police because they see super villains like Joker and Penguin as folks trying to make ends meet.

  • @kingofhearts3185
    @kingofhearts3185 Год назад +88

    This was really good, looking forward to your next video.
    If I can make a small request, don't bass boost as hard on the Bruce Wayne joke. I have headphones on and the volume spike was a bit much.

  • @maximum-brian6155
    @maximum-brian6155 10 месяцев назад +7

    Are you telling me that Wraith and Prometheus are more popular than *Scream this* KILLER MOTH AND CATMAN WHO MIGHT I ADD HAVE HAD MORE ADAPTIONs THAN THOSE TWO KNUCKLES NUTTS!!

  • @KillerMoth3663
    @KillerMoth3663 Год назад +24

    Killer Moth is the greatest batman villain and should be respected. I am dressing up as him for Halloween, and it's sick

  • @MEGATRONFORTNITEAWESOME
    @MEGATRONFORTNITEAWESOME 10 месяцев назад +7

    Killer Moth needs the BTAS Mr Freeze treatment i love him sm and he has insane potential

  • @modernemcee
    @modernemcee Год назад +26

    I always thought anti Batman was....Man-Bat? Joking partially, I loved this video and get what you're saying lol

    • @nkemnoraulmanfredini7286
      @nkemnoraulmanfredini7286 Год назад +3

      Man-Bat was an anti-Batman

    • @KeatonGraves
      @KeatonGraves 5 месяцев назад +1

      Yeah he really is because unlike Batman who just wears a bat themed costume and uses bat themed gadgets Man Bat is an ACTUAL bat man with bat powers like flight and echolocation. In fact in one of his first appearances Man Bat actually tells Batman that he is more bat than him.

  • @calebe4266
    @calebe4266 Год назад +6

    You know a way killer moth could be more menacing? Do you know how much people say batman is just a rich man that likes to beat people to a pulp? Make it be killer moth. Make him be a crazy rich guy with a boring life that wants to get out of this boredom by killing innocent people, all to lure batman into a confrontation. A fight with batman might be a great way to get out of boredom

    • @uncannydcmarvelous5732
      @uncannydcmarvelous5732 Год назад +4

      The "crazy right guy with a boring life" kinda sounds like the Terrible Trio too

    • @calebe4266
      @calebe4266 Год назад

      @@uncannydcmarvelous5732 Yeah, but are they a thing? When was the last time they appeared on comic books?

  • @rgama1173
    @rgama1173 11 месяцев назад +12

    I could swear that Bane was the anti-batman

    • @billyboleson2830
      @billyboleson2830 10 месяцев назад

      He kinda is

    • @combatchuck777
      @combatchuck777 3 месяца назад +1

      Not in this context. His back story has zero parallels to batman. Think hush or black mask imo

  • @TheHirohikoAraki
    @TheHirohikoAraki 7 месяцев назад +12

    Unpopular Opinion: As much as I see a lot of them (which includes Owlman and The Batman Who Laughs), the real Anti-Batman will forever be *Bane.*

  • @Kitty255Again
    @Kitty255Again Год назад +45

    Calendar Man? A joke? He's genuinely terrifying, and could actually exist, unlike POISON IVY!

  • @Soulessblur
    @Soulessblur Год назад +32

    It's funny, Batman doesn't really have a singular popular anti-Batman, but they've tried to work the concept multiple times. Like, there's probably as many evil Batmen as there are Spider-Man clones. I'd love to see a sequel vid. Outside of the ones briefly mentioned but not discussed in the video, a couple more come to mind.
    Flashpoint Batman isn't a villain, but being Thomas Wayne, he is a Batman who lost son, instead of his parents, and is a Batman willing to kill. IIRC, he even tries to stop Bruce from being Batman at one point to "save" his son? Azrael is a pretty ruthless character who was meant to replace Batman, and I love his depiction in the Arkham games. Jason Todd tries to replace Bruce a couple times, he wears a sick batman outfit after Batman "dies" to Darkside in the main continuity and poses as Batman in Injustice 2. There's also Zur-En-Arrh or whatever he's called. A weird alien/alter ego batman. I haven't read it yet, but I believe Batman Down Below involves a creepy Cthulhu inspired Batman, one who's the embodiment of everything Gotham fears Batman is. Sort of a "Mario the man vs. Mario the idea" scenario.
    Great video man, looking forward to what other stuff you make.

  • @phantomgamer4463
    @phantomgamer4463 Год назад +12

    catman is originally a publish domain comic he got alot of adaptation/take from other media

  • @InvertedHorizons
    @InvertedHorizons 9 месяцев назад +5

    The reason Killer Moth could afford all that bs was because he just.... kept taking out loans. Loans with banks, loan sharks, and even big villains. It's actually mentioned once that they kept coming after him to get their money back and all his shit gets repossessed

  • @crangejo
    @crangejo Год назад +10

    oh my god dude use the disarm and destroy combo takedown please just break their shields and tasers

    • @TheBatspecter
      @TheBatspecter  Год назад +7

      you're like the first person here to actually talk about the gameplay so you have my respect for that LOL

    • @crangejo
      @crangejo Год назад +6

      @@TheBatspecter lmaoo I don't think it's below average but if you play these games on the regular that's my first tip, break their weapons, cause you ain't even doing instant takedowns. It's the first thing I ever upgrade on any of these games

  • @unhipstatue955
    @unhipstatue955 Год назад +14

    Honestly a really good starter kind of video, I can see your content popping off in the future as long as you keep at it!!

  • @GoldProduct9999
    @GoldProduct9999 Год назад +18

    Great video. I’ve always hoped we could see more from Wrath. While I do think the New 52 version was a major step down, I did like the addition that he considers his sidekicks completely replaceable. He will murder his Scorns without a second thought, and then replace them. Completely opposite Batman, who actually cares for his robins (but also immediately replaces them when they die)

  • @zeeke.tv_4842
    @zeeke.tv_4842 Год назад +4

    I was NOT expecting to hear Batman Rize of Sin Tzu music

  • @tristancanning7615
    @tristancanning7615 Год назад +14

    This was hilarious! As someone who also spends maybe a little too much time thinking about/reading Batman, I'd really love to see another video from you.

  • @dr.archaeopteryx5512
    @dr.archaeopteryx5512 Год назад +3

    Anti-Batmen are kinda funny, because a lot of people write Batman so out of character that specific Batman versions could easily pass as a separate Anti-Batman character, without even changing their backstory or onscreen appearance all that much.

  • @futurewario9591
    @futurewario9591 6 месяцев назад +6

    0:49 You forgot Wa someones.

  • @darthpikachu3007
    @darthpikachu3007 10 месяцев назад +5

    Wrath was in the animated tv show "The Batman" with the same M.O. as original killer moth

  • @OdaKa
    @OdaKa Год назад +5

    Why can't we get an anti-batman who dresses in bright colors and wrongs rights in the daylight

    • @dc7981
      @dc7981 Год назад +2

      Basically nemesis

  • @guybrushthreepwood362
    @guybrushthreepwood362 Год назад +6

    the anti-batman is Tab-man who ran up such a high tab by having no money that he can do nether good nor evil

  • @SUBARASHI2016
    @SUBARASHI2016 7 месяцев назад +7

    2:05 Batman why tf are you so 𝓕𝓻𝓮𝓪𝓴𝔂?

  • @doopdoopdopdop7424
    @doopdoopdopdop7424 6 месяцев назад +5

    I think if Wrath went with a devilish design, using horns rather than ears, then he’d be perfect.

    • @retrorampage.9332
      @retrorampage.9332 3 месяца назад +2

      That's a great idea, would help keep a similar look to Batman, if they wanted the uncanny effect Bizzaro and Reverse Flash have. They could even have him be based of a gargoyle?

    • @doopdoopdopdop7424
      @doopdoopdopdop7424 3 месяца назад +1

      Batman’s already a sort of Gargoyle with his humanoid bat look. Maybe Wrath could have more personal melee weapons like a trident or a sword? Embody a demonic look to match the sin of his namesake. Then Batman takes on a sort of old testament angel feel.

  • @Xlen-omega
    @Xlen-omega Год назад +7

    WARNING TO HEADPHONE USERS!!!! TURN YOUR VOLUME DOWN!!
    RIP headphone users.
    A warning would of been nice.

    • @TheBatspecter
      @TheBatspecter  Год назад +1

      I didn't think the louder parts of the video would be as loud as they were by the time I uploaded, so that's on me. Loud parts like those won't be in future videos

  • @stanleyteriaca2184
    @stanleyteriaca2184 Год назад +11

    The Batman Who Laughs is more an Anti-Joker than an Anti-Batman.

    • @markusbonnet439
      @markusbonnet439 4 месяца назад

      Not really ,he's more similar to joker

    • @Аноним-д3я
      @Аноним-д3я Месяц назад

      ​@@markusbonnet439 Which is not making him anti-batman

  • @DAYV3EN
    @DAYV3EN Год назад +7

    Honestly, I like the Hannibal lector calendar man. Great vid, btw

    • @lppstudios3006
      @lppstudios3006 Год назад +3

      Yo wassup fellow Lego animator 💪🏼🗿

    • @DAYV3EN
      @DAYV3EN Год назад

      @@lppstudios3006 ayyyyy

    • @lppstudios3006
      @lppstudios3006 Год назад +2

      @@DAYV3EN YOOO also they talked about my bro Prometheus 💪🏼🗿

    • @DAYV3EN
      @DAYV3EN Год назад +1

      @@lppstudios3006 catman and killer moth are my goats.

    • @lppstudios3006
      @lppstudios3006 Год назад +1

      @@DAYV3EN FR

  • @tailsd0lls
    @tailsd0lls Год назад +6

    youre telling me a bat this man?

  • @TheAmgus
    @TheAmgus Год назад +5

    This video was amazing! I’m definitely subbing and hope to see more soon

  • @therealglosetik
    @therealglosetik 22 дня назад +1

    1:59
    "Ursuchagudboi4me..."
    "Ooyeaurmomysgudboi..."
    *"I'm Batman-"*

  • @matti.8465
    @matti.8465 Год назад +6

    The perfect Batman doppleganger to me would be someone who came up with the bat vigilante shtick shortly before Bruce did, and is upset that everyone calls him a Batman knockoff when he did it first.

    • @misterboxhead3045
      @misterboxhead3045 Год назад

      Owl man? Didn't he got mad that the batman who laugh got all the spotlight and not him?

  • @Turkeyham11
    @Turkeyham11 Месяц назад +2

    I know this is an older video and it's probably gotten better, but jeez is the whole random loud audio thing super obnoxious in an otherwise pretty good video.

  • @9TXONE
    @9TXONE Год назад +3

    My favorite anti-batman character is Plummcorp's Bat Talk

  • @conradojavier7547
    @conradojavier7547 Год назад +14

    Instead of making New Villians, why not fix Forgotten Villians.

  • @MiguelGonzalez-du8de
    @MiguelGonzalez-du8de Год назад +4

    The problem with Owlman is that he's from an alt universe where EVERYONE is their opposite, he doesn't feel special when he lives in the same world with an evil Superman, evil Wonder Woman, etc.

    • @TheBatspecter
      @TheBatspecter  Год назад +3

      Isn't that sort of the whole point of Earth-3? By that logic, the main Batman doesn't feel special when he lives in the same world as Superman & Wonder Woman

    • @MiguelGonzalez-du8de
      @MiguelGonzalez-du8de 11 месяцев назад

      @@TheBatspecter Basically yeah, in my opinion Owlman doesn't feel unique in the same way that Catman and Killer Moth are. They actually exist in the same world as normal Batman so their comparison with him makes sense and actually succeed in portraying an "anti-Batman" or "Batman with a different facet". Owlman's entire reason for being evil is just because he's from a world where every hero is evil, and villainy is expected instead of being good. Don't get me wrong, he's a cool character and a good way to see a villainous Batman, but his world is so inherently different from Bruce's that I can't really count him as an anti-Batman. Maybe if he actually lived in a world similar to ours, where goodness is expected from people, yet he still chose to become the evil Owlman, then I would count him as a different facet of Batman

  • @josheaster1547
    @josheaster1547 Год назад +9

    Jason todd is definately an anti-batman.

  • @Circaninesix
    @Circaninesix Год назад +23

    The gain trick is funny, you just have to lower the volume when you add that much gain to the recording of your voice.

  • @timklebel879
    @timklebel879 Год назад +6

    lovelovelove this more than almost everything on comic youtube rn, keep it up and ill stick around. but please tone down the voice clipping or drop a compressor over your voice chain because it HURTS :(

  • @williamholtzclaw3029
    @williamholtzclaw3029 Год назад +6

    I love that owlman isn't included in this discussion because he's the clear best anti-batman and the batman who laughes isn't included because he just sucks, they even made a comic where owlman basically says this himself

  • @genericsidecharacter8915
    @genericsidecharacter8915 Год назад +3

    5:25 you said it yourself already. Man watched Andrew Tate sigma grindset TikToks, joined Hustler’s University, made millions, and became a sigma male.

  • @_Nonnez_
    @_Nonnez_ Год назад +7

    Ghostmaker is a new amazing character that rivals Batman and has some anti-Batman elements!!! I say this because as a child Ghostmaker saw his parents get threaten, beaten up, and embarrassed by a wealthy family, that forced them to sell out there business. Despite that traumatic experience, he didn't fight crime because of that. He sees crime fighting as a art form and skill he wants to be the best at.
    If anything Ghostmaker's existence asks the question "what if a hero existed but didn't fight for moral reason?". Which is a interesting idea!!! Especially since Ghostmaker is one of the few characters that is a psychopath BUT isn't a villain and choses to do good, despite his lack of empathy!!! Although to be fair, he does kill criminals because he sees things from a logical not emotional or moral perspective.

    • @dc7981
      @dc7981 Год назад +1

      Basically anti hero version of Azrael and David Cain/Orphan

    • @_Nonnez_
      @_Nonnez_ Год назад +2

      @@dc7981 I agree with the Azeral comparison and David Cain to a degree. I say to a degree because although both Ghostmaker and David Cain tried to make the "perfect soldier" with kids. Ghostmaker never domestically physically abused his side kick Phantom 1 and wasn't cruel with training.
      However Ghostmaker did fail Phantom 1 because he adopted him and was emotionally distance and neglectful as a foster father. He gave him a mansion to live in but never built an actual bound with him because he only was him as a test to make a "better Robin" then Batman. Which obviously is a terrible mentality to have BUT thankfully future Ghostmaker learns to be more considerate and nice to people that he trains (like Clownhunter). Since he realizes being cold hearted isn't going to help teamwork.
      Unfortunately in the past Phantom 1 "dies" because they were after a villain, Phantom 1 goes off the plan and rushes in to get said villain. Then an explosion happens and he gets stuck under rubble and couldn't get out. So Ghostmaker leaves him to die in order save other people in danger infront of him. Sadly for Phantom 1 he never knew that, so he believes Ghostmaker abandoned him for no reason. Since this is a comic book and no one really stays dead, Phantom 1 makes it out alive and plans to get his revenge.
      Interestingly enough, when Ghostmaker finally gets to the villain he's more brutal with his killing, which means he was angry that Phantom 1 died. So in away he kinda does care??? But doesn't feel it or express it in a way we do!!! Also despite Ghostmaker's lack of empathy and morals, he's strongly against sexuality harming children. Since when he fought Slade he insulted him by mentioning how he only goes after children!!!
      Anyway I agree that Ghostmaker has some similarities with both characters BUT his personality is much more different then those characters!!! He's not always serious and can be a playful, sassy, witty, and charismatic asshole!!!
      Btw I don't know much about Azeral to make an analysis on why there similar or what's there differences. However I hope you enjoyed this long response!!!

  • @godwin972
    @godwin972 Год назад +2

    Obligatory comment about how several Batman villains are corruptions of individual Batman traits

    • @dc7981
      @dc7981 Год назад +2

      Yeah like firefly represents the part of Batman that doesn’t want to set people on fire

  • @adragonfruitreal
    @adragonfruitreal 11 месяцев назад +3

    7:36 GOD WHEN THAT PUMPKIN HILL KICKS IN MMMM

  • @sahilhossain8204
    @sahilhossain8204 Год назад +1

    Lore of The "Anti-Batman" Dilemma momentum 100

  • @floating_microwave6783
    @floating_microwave6783 5 месяцев назад +3

    Azrael is crying in the corner

  • @orngcreator6115
    @orngcreator6115 Год назад +11

    I’m surprised you didn’t bring up Anarchy from Beware The Batman. He’s actually a pretty good mirror to Batman not just in ideals but also appearance. Shame the show got canceled after just one season.

  • @ShizzyMcCreepy
    @ShizzyMcCreepy Год назад +3

    This is a good video but please keep in mind that loud does not always mean funny

  • @Nedoiko
    @Nedoiko Год назад +4

    I made a previous comment that I deleted because it was pretty rude towards the noise in this video, as I later read your pinned comment and description, but I would still recommend to avoid doing the "Get closer to the mic to scream" thing, the best way I can put it is that it's an annoying joke

  • @AlfredoPuente8
    @AlfredoPuente8 11 месяцев назад +4

    Killer Moth is the best meta comentary of an evil-mirror character, guy tries so hard to be the antibatman that's pathetic.

  • @BeigeCube
    @BeigeCube 10 месяцев назад +2

    THE HIP TO BE SCARED NOD WAS PEAK

  • @Havingsights4009me
    @Havingsights4009me Год назад +26

    0:02 the mouth movement was perfectly synced

    • @arc8118
      @arc8118 5 месяцев назад +3

      Bc the sound and the clip are from SpongeBob

  • @danielmachuca2368
    @danielmachuca2368 Год назад +2

    Man for me, the disco lego batman music was peak, great video man 🤝

  • @marty-mcfly357
    @marty-mcfly357 Год назад +6

    Killer moth is the best,cocoon guns ,awesome design ,cool name . He has so much potential to be a bigger threat to batman than he is he ddnt even appear in animated series and in arkham games he at least has a bio and is mentioned a lots of times , he didnt appear in too much at least the lego batman games he appears a lot but its sad that he's forgotten for most people

  • @cyclopsboxhead5318
    @cyclopsboxhead5318 Год назад +13

    When I was reading the Secret Six, I was struck by the realization that Catman is like the reverse of the male-gaze superheroine. He's very consistently depicted with little or no clothes so his peak physique is prominently on display, and in one of his first scenes he's cooking breakfast for the team. Further than that there are two separate characters that see Catman as "the ideal male partner," Cheshire for her own child, and Vandal Savage for his potential grandson/heir. It was just another really cool way Gail Simone plays with gender roles in superhero comics.
    And also goddamn Deadshot physically can't not flirt with other guys on any team he's on, the homoerotic tension between him and Thomas Blake was insane.

    • @hawktalon7890
      @hawktalon7890 Год назад +3

      Yeah I think about half naked Catman a lot. Thanks Gail.

  • @Hi_Just_Fred
    @Hi_Just_Fred Год назад +4

    Learned about Wrath from The Batman cartoon (and the original creation anti-robin Scorn.)

    • @Hi_Just_Fred
      @Hi_Just_Fred 11 месяцев назад

      Took me 3 months to correct a minor spelling mistake, nice.

  • @TheOneTrueClovehitch
    @TheOneTrueClovehitch 10 месяцев назад +1

    I was not ready for 2:00 what has the internet brought me to? 😭

  • @SuperMoshady
    @SuperMoshady 10 месяцев назад +4

    The only legit anti-Batman is Jean Paul Valley

    • @dc7981
      @dc7981 9 месяцев назад +2

      Jean walked so Red hood and ghost maker could....exist

  • @TheDreadyGamer
    @TheDreadyGamer Год назад +1

    I’ve always said that the villain batman most needs is a specific kind of dark mirror.
    A batman who has his skills and a similar origin, and even a similar goal of preventing other people from suffering like he did as a child… but without his “no kill” rule.
    A character who falls under that mindset that “letting the joker live makes you responsible for his victims”
    A character that would force Batman to downright confront if his code of ethics is only leading to more suffering.
    Sure there have been characters like this before, but they’re ALWAYS been either incompetent/in over their heads, or lying about their real, villainous motivations. We need a character without that kind of shortcut that takes the easy way out of that debate, and actually addresses things.
    God I hope we get that character someday.

    • @billyboleson2830
      @billyboleson2830 10 месяцев назад +1

      Isn’t that basically red hood if he stayed a Batman villain at least kinda, anyway the closest would be if punisher was transported to dc

  • @empireartist4793
    @empireartist4793 Год назад +4

    You did pretty good, the video was very informative. Though you did blasted my ears a few times, but I really enjoy the video.

  • @theratmaid
    @theratmaid Год назад +1

    My favorite Prometheus moment is when he shows up in BoP and Lady Shiva says "nah I'd win" because she had new techniques and thinks his data is out of date but Prometheus one shots her and says he got new data. So then huntress and lady blachawk are like shit I guess we lose.

  • @Dlewis77777
    @Dlewis77777 Год назад +4

    I still think Jason represents the concept to a tee.
    Bruce wants to fight and eradicate crime.
    Jason is smart enough to know it’s a losing battle, so the best way to combat crime is to control it. And he kills whoever can’t be rehabilitated

    • @billyboleson2830
      @billyboleson2830 Год назад +1

      And this is why Jason should have stayed as an antagonist

    • @Dlewis77777
      @Dlewis77777 Год назад

      @@billyboleson2830 I agree

  • @Greatworldofficial
    @Greatworldofficial Год назад +2

    I was just thinking of the anti Batman dilemma I’m writing a story about the four anti Batmen teaming up to fight the dark knight

  • @holdthetruthhostage
    @holdthetruthhostage Год назад +6

    OwlMan is fire he should have his own more poetic series

  • @damienlarson4145
    @damienlarson4145 Год назад +1

    Also, one time Prometheus actually met Captain America in JLA/Avengers and Cap kicked his ass.

  • @TooTurntTokyo
    @TooTurntTokyo Год назад +3

    I was literally thinking about just how many anti-batman's there are in DC comics the other day

  • @ryzatheduck5195
    @ryzatheduck5195 Год назад +4

    Killer Moth is peak, best Batman villain 10/10

  • @Jakobey08
    @Jakobey08 Год назад +4

    Great video! But please do not bass boost the audio. I usually listen to yt videos while I'm in the car, so i had to constantly adjust the volume

  • @Cirkaethebest
    @Cirkaethebest 9 месяцев назад +1

    your humorous humility is such a big breath of fresh air, i am so glad to have found another fantastic youtuber to subscribe to

  • @ComaToast712
    @ComaToast712 Год назад +3

    Bro this was a good video, you should absolutely try more of this. You’ve got a solid personality for covering comic stuff. I for one would definitely love to see more of this stuff. Keep up the good work.

  • @misterboxhead3045
    @misterboxhead3045 Год назад +6

    Wrath design is kinda good in the batman 2004