Dispersion Effect: Photoshop Tutorial

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 22 авг 2024
  • In this Photoshop Tutorial, I will teach you how to create a dispersion effect. This effect has become very popular. It looks fairly complicated, but it's actually quite simple. I believe the hardest part was finding the perfect free brush set for the effect. Which I have provided below. A few things we'll be doing is creating the effect using brushes and masks. We'll also be using a broken glass texture. I will then add a nice gradient for the image, then for the final step, I will sharpen the image and effect to make it stand out much more. I hope you like this tutorial.
    ►Unlimited Downloads on Envato Elements, Photoshop Actions, Brushes, Stocks and much more! bit.ly/2RUXGcR
    Audio Provided By:
    / audiolibrary

Комментарии • 2,4 тыс.

  • @NewWorldOps
    @NewWorldOps  7 лет назад +394

    Follow me on my personal instagram, or contact me! instagram.com/its.michael.x

    • @koldeagle8257
      @koldeagle8257 7 лет назад +8

      Dude i like your simple explanations *Subbed*

    • @trex1237
      @trex1237 7 лет назад +4

      and a like you forgot it :)

    • @NewWorldOps
      @NewWorldOps  7 лет назад +5

      Thanks for subscribing! :)

    • @NewWorldOps
      @NewWorldOps  7 лет назад +3

      Yes those are good too! :D

    • @MrKhawarwains
      @MrKhawarwains 7 лет назад +5

      please tell me your Ps version

  • @PhotoReflectionsPQ
    @PhotoReflectionsPQ 7 лет назад +296

    It´s amazing how you deconstructed the process and explained it so well. The workflow is very solid and logic.
    So well done Photoshop Tutorials! Thumbs up for you!

    • @NewWorldOps
      @NewWorldOps  7 лет назад +9

      Thank you very much for the kind words! :)

    • @joecooper6917
      @joecooper6917 7 лет назад +1

      Photo Reflections I found this tutorial very shity and not useful at all

    • @hazza9949
      @hazza9949 7 лет назад +9

      Maybe you're just shit at photoshop

    • @Yeatalations2093
      @Yeatalations2093 7 лет назад +3

      Hazza9949 - Vlogs and Gaming ooohhhh just got rekt
      also u cant say anything if u dont like this video go and watch another one

    • @michaelreyes8525
      @michaelreyes8525 7 лет назад +3

      Here is the best photo editing tutorial that you can check out: HootPhoto. info

  • @yuhanqiu7526
    @yuhanqiu7526 7 лет назад +4

    Best PS tutorial I have watched. In order to create the dispersion effect for my poster, I have watched 3 to 4 similar tutorials but none of them are as detailed and clear as this one! Great Work! Much Appreciated.

    • @NewWorldOps
      @NewWorldOps  7 лет назад +1

      Thank you very much for the nice feedback!! :D

  • @g2000edwin
    @g2000edwin Год назад +2

    Thanks for the way you were patient in teaching and NOT going at JET speed! Now to applied what you've have shown us and taught. Though, it may take a minute to get it as smooth as you did! Again, truly, thank you!

  • @DanIliev
    @DanIliev 2 года назад +3

    this tutorial started my filmmaking career, back in 2017... stumbled upon it, couldn't resist dropping a big thank you!

  • @JustinOdisho
    @JustinOdisho 7 лет назад +93

    Nice one, the shatter detail was a nice touch!

  • @LaMarchelle14
    @LaMarchelle14 6 лет назад +4

    Finally, a tutorial that is clear, concise and easy to follow. Thank you for all the frustration and confusion that you helped me to avoid.

  • @faigyamzalak3
    @faigyamzalak3 6 лет назад +2

    This is an amazing tutorial- so easy to follow and there are no unnecessary parts that aren't relevant to the video. Thx for the help

  • @Zirgonde
    @Zirgonde 7 лет назад +6

    I have watched this video around 10 times to do it myself, probably the best photoshop video out there! :D

  • @AmmarShauqi115
    @AmmarShauqi115 7 лет назад +26

    I like it how detail this tutorial is. Deserve a sub.

    • @NewWorldOps
      @NewWorldOps  7 лет назад +12

      Thanks so much! :)

    • @3366Marina
      @3366Marina 7 лет назад

      Photoshop Tutorials why did I even thought my photo would look like yours from the first try hahah

    • @flabbergabbot1242
      @flabbergabbot1242 6 лет назад +1

      Yes For Sure!

  • @jimboreaddabible777
    @jimboreaddabible777 6 лет назад

    First thing I always tell people about PS is, "learn mask layer". What an awesome tool!

  • @OttleyInkTV
    @OttleyInkTV 5 лет назад +4

    Took me AWHILE but I got it!!! Appreciate you for this bro!!!! 🙏🏿

  • @wahyuichsanfauzi7092
    @wahyuichsanfauzi7092 7 лет назад +3

    perfect tutorial (Y) ,great video quality,great text,and to the point (Y)

  • @M4ST3RX
    @M4ST3RX 7 лет назад +3

    Wow wow wow! Looks awesome and very easy to learn! Thank you so much!

    • @NewWorldOps
      @NewWorldOps  7 лет назад +1

      Glad you like it, thanks for watching. :)

  • @fluxosrpk.181
    @fluxosrpk.181 2 года назад

    TNice tutorials is the best tutorial. Simply explained to a newbie, great job man.

  • @sarukesh6893
    @sarukesh6893 Год назад +1

    Woah, great video mate!

  • @Abdulaziz2003
    @Abdulaziz2003 7 лет назад +116

    Dang, using subtitles instead of a voice makes way better instruction(ing?) than using a voice!

    • @NewWorldOps
      @NewWorldOps  7 лет назад +21

      Glad you find it helpful. Thank you for watching! :D

    • @adilkong7560
      @adilkong7560 7 лет назад +1

      hey! I was just thinking, maybe you can do a stream where people ask you how to do diffrent things. I tink this will be good for you and help other people aswell. xx

    • @mrzora89
      @mrzora89 7 лет назад +1

      100%

  • @geekhightv9484
    @geekhightv9484 7 лет назад +3

    Thank you so much! This was a great video to watch - simple and easy tutorial :)

    • @NewWorldOps
      @NewWorldOps  7 лет назад +1

      Glad you like it, thanks for watching. :)

  • @Nikolostyle
    @Nikolostyle 4 года назад +1

    I just used photoshop today without any expectations but it was excellent.You are amazing thanks for all tips !

  • @smritiagarwal8005
    @smritiagarwal8005 6 лет назад

    Best photoshop tutorials on youtube.....just loved it...!!

  • @FUNKSW
    @FUNKSW 7 лет назад +10

    This effect came out so beautifully. I want to marry this video 😮
    TY for the tuto.

  • @rhongasparez6387
    @rhongasparez6387 5 лет назад +5

    I was able to follow the tutorial as best as I could. I realise that I have to practise and eventually I will get it and I am grateful for the tutorial. However, it would have been helpful to have the tutorial narrated along with the captions. The focusing was much having to read, look at the results of each step and make sure I don't make a mistake in the process.

  • @SADESIGN9999
    @SADESIGN9999 2 года назад

    his is very cool! I followed the steps and got a great photo

  • @flabbergabbot1242
    @flabbergabbot1242 6 лет назад

    Thank you So Much Photoshop Tutorials!!!!!!!!
    That was a great topic people have been finding tutorials for!

  • @UncleShish
    @UncleShish 6 лет назад +713

    Mr. Stark, I don't feel so good...

    • @RickRodGaming
      @RickRodGaming 6 лет назад +4

      Came for this

    • @falcon2point062
      @falcon2point062 5 лет назад

      @Cartonz Proz The dang download doesn't work it says FORMAT damaged

    • @jabiktpm
      @jabiktpm 4 года назад

      Check this on
      ruclips.net/video/b_qjzHJwkcw/видео.html

    • @sergejdragutinovic6117
      @sergejdragutinovic6117 4 года назад

      Duck you now im crying ;-;

    • @RasTaKFiroozi
      @RasTaKFiroozi 5 месяцев назад

      😊​@@falcon2point062

  • @graphicdesignexplorer4699
    @graphicdesignexplorer4699 5 лет назад +5

    This is amazing, so awesome. I have seen many versions of this and would love to try it soon. Thank you

  • @DROPZ475
    @DROPZ475 Год назад

    So simple and detailed video, it's now going to help to start working wid softsoft!!

  • @ihsanbacha1437
    @ihsanbacha1437 4 года назад

    thats mind blowing bro hats off

  • @harshmalik284
    @harshmalik284 5 лет назад +3

    the intro part was amazing!!

  • @FRISHR
    @FRISHR 6 лет назад +433

    I got an Infinity War ad for this video.

    • @nayaka-zna
      @nayaka-zna 6 лет назад +1

      FRISHR same :v

    • @EnoughAshish
      @EnoughAshish 6 лет назад

      ruclips.net/video/fRqMFU5gyEM/видео.html

    • @roxwize
      @roxwize 5 лет назад

      I got a business ad for this video.

    • @kitchentoast
      @kitchentoast 5 лет назад

      but... I have no ads....

  • @redtsundere
    @redtsundere 5 лет назад +2

    A perfect idea for profile picture. Thanks man!

  • @PSDburger
    @PSDburger 4 месяца назад

    Thumbs up for this fantastic video!

  • @MultitalentVideo
    @MultitalentVideo 6 лет назад +7

    Nice Photoshop tutorial

  • @Fishnetfreud
    @Fishnetfreud 7 лет назад +4

    Thank you for this. So much fun!

  • @damienanckaert1191
    @damienanckaert1191 3 года назад

    Always on the Top.

  • @electrifiedpro4811
    @electrifiedpro4811 6 лет назад

    I like how yo explain, and the second step to the dispersion made the picture even better.Congratulations you made a good job.

  • @thedonzhorzh
    @thedonzhorzh 6 лет назад +11

    The "Mr. Stark, I don't feel so good" effect

  • @frostyfeet7984
    @frostyfeet7984 6 лет назад +3

    This is so well done! Great job. Truly inspiring. Subscribed!

  • @originalsbysean1336
    @originalsbysean1336 6 лет назад +2

    this is amazing tutorial. so easy to learn. thank you so much!

  • @ledpromosgift
    @ledpromosgift Год назад

    man I missed this kind of tutorials lol. Great work here, thanks!!!

  • @stharlyn4894
    @stharlyn4894 Год назад

    I am very glad that I stumbled upon your video

  • @samdubs
    @samdubs 6 лет назад +1576

    Who's here from Avengers

  • @spartandraws7012
    @spartandraws7012 6 лет назад +16

    GIMP: Mr. Adobe, i dont feel so good
    Photoshop: You're alright.
    *Gimp fades away*

  • @alexandernassar6619
    @alexandernassar6619 2 года назад

    basics it's encouraging to learn a little bit more! Well done!

  • @sohag3356
    @sohag3356 Год назад +1

    You are a legend sir 磊🏅

  • @Samaker
    @Samaker 7 лет назад +47

    I could imagine doing this on someone who is jumping towards or running away from something.

  • @Brian-db9fm
    @Brian-db9fm 7 лет назад +45

    dude i was lost for ages wondering why the brush is not working.
    u should mention to turn the opacity up to 100

    • @NewWorldOps
      @NewWorldOps  7 лет назад +8

      Thanks for the advice. :)

    • @koshinnn
      @koshinnn 7 лет назад +1

      that works only for the 1st layer on "Man" but not on the second layer "dispersion effect" i have alrd changed the foreground to white as well help plz

    • @joepvandijk
      @joepvandijk 7 лет назад

      Sorry, but what version of photoshop is this? Also, really great videos! thanks for your help^^

    • @guriqbalsingh7909
      @guriqbalsingh7909 7 лет назад

      plz tell me,i am facing the same problem

    • @WinnyAogah
      @WinnyAogah 7 лет назад

      ko shin I'm facing the same problem

  • @grantedmonston1
    @grantedmonston1 6 лет назад +2

    Great video, easy to follow, so easy to do and thanks for the links for the particle brushes. Got a new follower in me :)

  • @laurin.s
    @laurin.s 3 года назад

    Our teacher have us this fresh tutorial to learn.

  • @HansBjorgman
    @HansBjorgman 7 лет назад +5

    The only thing I did wrong was make it ugly. Thanks for the tutorial, though. Maybe next I will download some better brushes and also take my time (as you suggested).

    • @NewWorldOps
      @NewWorldOps  7 лет назад +3

      Well at least you know how to do it! :D Hope it turns out great for you next time.

    • @HansBjorgman
      @HansBjorgman 7 лет назад

      Photoshop Tutorials Thanks! I may try it again sometime in the future.

    • @ruts2212
      @ruts2212 7 лет назад

      Photoshop Tutorials where can I download those brushes

  • @Dickymint1000
    @Dickymint1000 7 лет назад +41

    Brilliant video ~ many thanks

    • @chrissysmith1373
      @chrissysmith1373 6 лет назад

      Here's a great photo editing tutorial that you can check out: HootPhoto.info

    • @husansingh555
      @husansingh555 6 лет назад

      James Y. Welch
      this tuto is very nice but if you want learn more you can see this now
      ruclips.net/video/tv-LDWksvVo/видео.html

    • @zackjohnson4452
      @zackjohnson4452 6 лет назад

      If you want the best photo editing tutorial online then go here now: HootPhoto.xyz

    • @EnoughAshish
      @EnoughAshish 6 лет назад

      ruclips.net/video/fRqMFU5gyEM/видео.html

  • @akashdeepsingh1733
    @akashdeepsingh1733 3 года назад

    Nice. Got it in 1st attempt!! Great job

  • @Potencyfunction
    @Potencyfunction Год назад

    I need to see it because i was cooking while watching the strategi. Good value man for disspertion in PS.

  • @n1sha.ace33
    @n1sha.ace33 6 лет назад +10

    Mr... I don't feel so good....
    Btw, dont stop making vids, subbed bro...

  • @Chickboom34
    @Chickboom34 6 лет назад

    Appreciate the text to accompany the steps. Very helpful. Thank you.

  • @toddeswe
    @toddeswe 2 года назад +1

    Nice guide, have remade it 4 times now because of my picture from sideway gets a line in the final picture between the hair and the neck and it's so anoying. :) Thanks for this!! It realy got under my skin.

  • @moefromdagrieve
    @moefromdagrieve 5 лет назад +62

    DAMNNNN IM TRYING TO FIND COMMENTS ON THE ACTUAL VIDEO!! NOT ABOUT DAMN AVENGERZZZZZ!!!!

  • @pristine6331
    @pristine6331 7 лет назад +12

    This is a pretty good tutorial
    Only thing I did wrong was do it terribly
    :D

    • @NewWorldOps
      @NewWorldOps  7 лет назад

      Haha! Try again? Btw thanks for the feedback. :)

  • @franciscovaladez6133
    @franciscovaladez6133 2 года назад

    Bro I really do appreciate you for this help, Thanks! I subscribed and Liked the video.

  • @insularmarcferdinanda.5494
    @insularmarcferdinanda.5494 6 лет назад

    One of the best out there you earned a subscription

  • @ghostmangaming2341
    @ghostmangaming2341 6 лет назад +36

    Everyone is talking about avengers infinity war and I’m over here thinking how I could use this for a dark souls RUclips series

  • @user-hf2bp3qq8w
    @user-hf2bp3qq8w 7 лет назад +5

    Thank you !!! THANK YOUUUU !!! :)

  • @adamdono2090
    @adamdono2090 5 лет назад

    this video was really helpful iam first year photography student and it helped me finish my assignment in 3 hours thanks

  • @icefreezingice
    @icefreezingice 2 года назад

    thanks, Thanos, glad you're getting into soft instead of...well...

  • @BastiaanNetjes
    @BastiaanNetjes 6 лет назад +31

    "Mr. Stark, I don't feel so good."

    • @artemrqc2574
      @artemrqc2574 6 лет назад

      I`m from Ukraine, so I very bad know English, but I can understand your comment) :D

    • @gigiharungbumi9249
      @gigiharungbumi9249 6 лет назад

      lol

    • @ethan2163
      @ethan2163 5 лет назад

      @DatGurl Nigga what?

  • @thaunglinhein
    @thaunglinhein 7 лет назад +3

    Hello!I just found out your tutorial and i find it very amazing! however there seems to be a problem when i use the explosion brushes. All the effects keep turning the shapes of black inks all over the place. which brush tool did u use?

  • @StorybookStudios
    @StorybookStudios 6 лет назад +1

    Oh my gosh this is such an incredible picture, great job!!

  • @editorskillls8903
    @editorskillls8903 6 лет назад

    NICE You have done the wonderful job....👌

  • @Meqanich
    @Meqanich 7 лет назад +10

    When I downloade the Bursh Explosion tool (wich is mentoined in the start). How to i add it into PS?

    • @Meqanich
      @Meqanich 7 лет назад

      Brush tool*

    • @gamingedgehd8419
      @gamingedgehd8419 7 лет назад +10

      MeqanichHD go to the brush menu and click on load brush and select the brush

    • @Meqanich
      @Meqanich 7 лет назад +2

      Gaming Edge HD I found it, Thanks mate!

    • @FahadAli-wf3wu
      @FahadAli-wf3wu 7 лет назад

      watch on RUclips how to place brushes

    • @Meqanich
      @Meqanich 7 лет назад +27

      fahad kashtkar I SAID I FOUND IT
      * high girly screaming*

  • @colt6644
    @colt6644 7 лет назад +3

    nice vid bro

  • @m4rtinbugar
    @m4rtinbugar 6 лет назад

    Dude this is the most exciting process that i have ever seen. Good job. Thanks for inspiration.

  • @mousumicute2230
    @mousumicute2230 5 лет назад

    Excellent idea....!.💚💚💚

  • @thesaw0314
    @thesaw0314 6 лет назад +5

    mr stark i don’t feel too good

  • @ibrahimkhalil2732
    @ibrahimkhalil2732 7 лет назад +22

    hey i stucked at adding dispersion(after using dispersing brush) to man it wont brush any dispersion

    • @NewWorldOps
      @NewWorldOps  7 лет назад +1

      Try changing your foreground and background color to either black or white. Also make sure the mask is selected.
      Let me know if this works for you :)

    • @ibrahimkhalil2732
      @ibrahimkhalil2732 7 лет назад +3

      Photoshop Tutorials changed background and foreground color, had checked that the mask selected. but when i brush on the mask or at layer, there's nothing changed :( pls help me

    • @GeromeYu
      @GeromeYu 7 лет назад +2

      Same here.
      ?????

    • @MedDelfin
      @MedDelfin 7 лет назад +1

      same here...nothing fixes it.

    • @milindjha1128
      @milindjha1128 7 лет назад +1

      still nothing is happening

  • @VisionProGamingGuy
    @VisionProGamingGuy 3 месяца назад

    love it . going to try it witth a RUclips thumbnail for my next vid

  • @Artrick.design
    @Artrick.design 6 лет назад

    awesome!!!!!......you made my day, breaking everything down step by step - best dispersion tutorial ever,

  • @sarz22222
    @sarz22222 7 лет назад +4

    At 5:10 after I select dispersion mask and change the foreground color to white nothing happens when I use the brush... what should I do?

    • @octopus1182
      @octopus1182 7 лет назад

      Andrei Ichim is it the right layer?

    • @thexareaz2321
      @thexareaz2321 7 лет назад

      I have exactly the same issue :(

    • @kanecastillano1354
      @kanecastillano1354 7 лет назад +1

      Sorry for answering late... You need to select the Dispersion effect layer and then click the right picture (mask)

  • @AndresOrSmthn
    @AndresOrSmthn 6 лет назад +5

    Mr. Stark, I don't feel so good

  • @nicolasocampo2470
    @nicolasocampo2470 Год назад

    Really nice job. I did so stuff with MIDI/DAW/soft banks wayyy back in like 99/00 in college and was ok at it. I bought soft soft last

  • @TheMightyMagno
    @TheMightyMagno 6 лет назад

    just..............BRILLIANT

  • @ClemsDZN
    @ClemsDZN 6 лет назад +66

    I dont wanna go

  • @wenbinkang9914
    @wenbinkang9914 7 лет назад +3

    Good music

  • @jeffrywong5156
    @jeffrywong5156 5 лет назад

    Love your videos

  • @leaaabea
    @leaaabea 6 лет назад +1

    Bruh. I'm blown tf away.. Thanks a mil for this inspo tutorial. It's 12:25 am & I feel like going & attempt this rn 😅😅

  • @R_HeavyBones
    @R_HeavyBones 7 лет назад +54

    very nice video but i would like some voice :)

    • @NewWorldOps
      @NewWorldOps  7 лет назад +23

      Thank you for your feedback. :)

    • @Lord_Aizen
      @Lord_Aizen 7 лет назад +2

      Photoshop Tutorials on the liquidfy effect why is mine dragging the whole photo instead of parts like yours 3:02

    • @justynakuroczko8374
      @justynakuroczko8374 6 лет назад +1

      its better without the voice :)

    • @alfred9482
      @alfred9482 6 лет назад

      TeamUp Gamers ::

    • @DarthDaFatCow
      @DarthDaFatCow 6 лет назад

      lower the brush size

  • @marielsalem9053
    @marielsalem9053 7 лет назад +3

    brush is not working :( , my foreground color is black but nothing happens

    • @pascalhagen4264
      @pascalhagen4264 7 лет назад

      Make sure you select the right layer.

    • @Brian-db9fm
      @Brian-db9fm 7 лет назад

      make sure ur opacity is at 100 when trying to use the brush

    • @makethemjlous9172
      @makethemjlous9172 6 лет назад

      please give me the software dowanload link guyzz.

  • @PrimalEdge
    @PrimalEdge 6 лет назад

    i totally hit the like button because you said to in the intro...

  • @gamingnerds5194
    @gamingnerds5194 2 года назад

    Wow. This is a great tutorial. Amazing work

  • @PK_Legend.
    @PK_Legend. 6 лет назад +3

    when i start adding the effect nothing happened !!! help

  • @behatiselder3667
    @behatiselder3667 7 лет назад +6

    When I right click after I did the Laso... I won't let me click on fill....pretty please help. :(

    • @oliverdenandre3911
      @oliverdenandre3911 7 лет назад +1

      I have the same problem

    • @jonah1343
      @jonah1343 7 лет назад +3

      if u still have the problem, make sure you are selecting the background layer

    • @Meaverickk
      @Meaverickk 7 лет назад +1

      Make sure your layer is not a smart object, but a pixel layer.

    • @stijnvanderwulp9364
      @stijnvanderwulp9364 7 лет назад

      thx worked for me!

    • @tuitionkids4999
      @tuitionkids4999 6 лет назад

      I Have The Same Problem

  • @user-md4gu6yb1y
    @user-md4gu6yb1y 6 лет назад

    so amazing!
    thx a lot !!!!!

  • @rklikepainting
    @rklikepainting 3 года назад

    Great tutorial.

  • @calvintony2929
    @calvintony2929 6 лет назад +138

    Here after watching Thanos did his finger snapping thing.

  • @StevenF2529
    @StevenF2529 6 лет назад +4

    I don't wanna go Mr. Stark, please, I Don't wanna go :'v

  • @rodel.sangalang
    @rodel.sangalang 4 года назад

    Really good video...and very simple and straightforward...looking forward to trying it. I'm wondering how many of the so far 5.5 million views so far were from the same viewer watching it at least 2-5 times? Well, I will be one of them. Thank you for posting.

  • @Bodiizles
    @Bodiizles 6 лет назад

    Really good video!

  • @duvisart5051
    @duvisart5051 7 лет назад +21

    Hey random person scrolling trough the comments!!!! 👊🖐
    I hope you have an awesome day!! 😊🙂

    • @paullakers5761
      @paullakers5761 6 лет назад

      Hello there Duvisart, thankyou for this generous comment! i have been looking for someone like you to share my joyful life with. I am a 46 year old male with 3 cats, 4 dogs and a lovely iguana named Earl. I love to go on warm walks on the beach, taking in the lovely sunset. Once a week i go to the club and play chess with my pals from the Anti Depression clinic. Once again, thankyou for the lovely comment even tho it was 1 year ago LOL!

    • @werevertugelin
      @werevertugelin 6 лет назад +1

      fuck you

    • @paullakers5761
      @paullakers5761 6 лет назад

      Thankyou kindly for you feedback i shall take this into consideration!

  • @Andreas-oq2gz
    @Andreas-oq2gz 7 лет назад +3

    why my brush didnt work so well? on layer "man" :(

    • @ConiceLee
      @ConiceLee 7 лет назад

      what you means not so well? maybe you can check the opacity of the brush

    • @Andreas-oq2gz
      @Andreas-oq2gz 7 лет назад

      +Chee Yin Lee thanks the problem is already solved

  • @nonamec4787
    @nonamec4787 Год назад

    production. Thanks again!

  • @user-vn3dg9lp2g
    @user-vn3dg9lp2g 5 лет назад

    thanks for your satisfying explanation