I have a feeling they’re going to keep the live action to just the East Blue saga. Kind of a “if you want more, there’s *literally* over *1000* episodes/chapters of the source material.”
Netflix doesn't get money from people reading the source material and there's plenty of other places to watch One Piece, they're not going to treat it like an OVA or Single Season show just to promote the original, like companies do in Japan. If they cancel it early, it'll be because they didn't want to spend anymore money on it.
The CG budget would balloon if they tried to do any Grand Line arcs. Once things start to get really crazy you can't do regular actors and sets without moving away from the source material. The world of One Piece is simply too fantastical and the body proportions of most characters are weird so there would be no good fits for the roles.
@@Japaneseanimeguy true that. Whether they acceptably adapt Arlong and his crew will be a huge indicator of how well they could continue the show. Tackling Chopper will be a huge uphill battle, but if they can make Chopper work, I don’t really think they have too many big obstacles until after Skypiea. After that though… things basically become impossible.
8 episodes are enough. 1 Episode for Romance Dawn. 1 Episode for Alvida and Zoro episode. 1 Episode for Buggy. 1 Episode for Syrup Village. 1 Episode to Baratie. 2 Episodes for Arlong Park and 1 Episode for Logue Town. Yes 10 episodes would be ideal but besides Arlong Park everything else can be done in one episode. I just wonder if they will make Romance Down as episode 1 or will be a condense flashback after Luffy's introduction.
Romance Dawn doesn't have anywhere near an hour of content... Even in the anime it's one episode I believe, and it's not even the full episode (though it's close)
mariokarter13 said it best "Because Funimation lied about a man and ran him out of the industry." (In a nutshell it was a Witch Hunt.) Well hes apart of his own dubbing studio with Anime Matsuri so not out of the industry just the major studios of it.
It’s gonna be on Switch. An online game store dropped images of a game you can preorder soon thing of P3R and it included all the big systems. Even Switch.
A "30 minute" anime is actually only about 20 minutes of animation. One Piece in particular ranges between 22 and 24 minutes per episode with a 1 minute and 30 second OP and ED. For a total of between 19 and 21 minutes of narrative time. Let's call it 20 minutes. If the Netflix adaptation is actually a full hour long then you'll get nearly three times the narrative run time. So more like 24 anime episodes worth for an 8 hour long episode run. Not that it makes much of a difference to the point you were trying to make.
I think if they'd gone bright it would have cheapened the look somewhat. It would have pushed it into too much cheese factor like Full Metal Alchemist area i think. I rather like the gritty look, it helps balance the brightness of the characters and the somewhat cosplay look some of the characters give. I don't have huge expectations esp seeing it's only 8 eps, but I do think the trailer wasn't too bad. We will just have to wait and see how people will react to how much will have to be left out.
If they do get a second season, I see one of two things happening one instead of making chopper. CGI, I think they might go a sweet tooth option. The sweet toot option is a Netflix show that's off of a graphic novel where animal human hybrids start to appear in a post-apocalyptic world and the main character is a half-deer half boy in the graphic novel. He's more deer than boy but in the live action series on Netflix they just use small practical effects and makeup like deer antlers and fur which they could go that route and it'll be fine and perfect. Just give him a blue nose and call it a day or two and the option that I'm really scared of they might do Netflix will cut out drum Island and chopper entirely for budget reasons :(
So each episode of the Netflix adaptation would have to cover on average 6.625 episodes of anime content (its confirmed that season 1 will cover east blue). After cutting openings, endings and recaps 3 episodes of the anime take about an hour so this show will be about double the pace of the anime which is fast paced but i dont know that its completely unreasonable to do.
I sure do look forward to that one piece show brought to you by the streaming service almost exclusively known for cancelling shows after 1 or 2 seasons and even if by some miracle it isn't, it has zero chance of ever having a satisfying or complete story. That is unless it decides to completely ignore the manga/anime and do it's own thing (it doesn't look like that) which is a decision that has always worked out well for other live action adaptations of anime/manga.
Tbh i always saw it more as a just the east blue saga thing. I don’t think there is a need for more and even less the whole story. I also don’t think that’s the motivation behind the live action. If it ends up getting a sequel I hope they will get till brooks recruiting bc that mean we have all Pretime members. I think it should end at the latest with the end of the pretime skip. If the show is a success and I really do wish that for everyone that worked so hard on it and the cast that clearly have so much love and emotions for the story, their characters and each other, I hope we’ll get to at the very least water 7 and ennies lobby. I need this arc(s), which is not only my fav arc but generally one of the best arcs. 🙈
Oda the goat. I’m hoping the live action OP does well, but like everyone else I am extremely jaded towards mainstream media’s inept producers that only care about squeezing as much money as they can out of successful IP
I would say in One Piece anime there’s only about 10-15 minutes of new content each episode. So an hour episode could cover 4-6 episodes worth, so maybe an initial arc could be covered in an hour of Netflix episode.
Cowboy Bebop is example. As the studio that did that live action is doing this One Piece Netflix. Cowboy Bebop original was 26 episodes that Netflix forced into 10 episodes. Which is biggest problem trying to adapt anime.
The second season curse for Gundam series is so real…pretty much the only exception I can think of is Zeta, but that’s more like a sequel than a seasonal continuation
My thoughts on the One Piece trailer? It looks like they actually cared about what they were doing. I can absolutely respect and appreciate when an adaptation does it's best to be true and faithful to the source material, even if it utterly fails. The effort is what matters to me, and I see actual effort being made here. That said, it looks _ridiculous_ but I am willing to accept that there is no way to translate the cartoonish nature of One Piece into live action without looking incredibly silly, so I can suspend that critical part of my brain and judge it for what it is.
I'm of same mind I can understand not being able to translate insane visuals of it but what pains me most is that place these adaptations always fails is translating feel of fights and actors don't capture vibe of characters, like their expressiveness. like zoro raging around yelling on top of high lungs at idiots, or making fluffy not look like complete moron on every shot. Characters are not that deep but getting these things right is what makes it or breaks it.
By the time Oda sees the work done and sent to him for approval. The Netflix team would have spent the budget. Oda would have to tell them to do it over again knowing the budget is spent. So he won’t reject stuff, so his approval won’t actually happen. I literally got into comment war with one of the one piece Netflix guys on other Weebs and Waifus channel. Just for saying this live action wasn’t made for us One Piece fans. It is made for the normies that aren’t anime fans.
you do realise the showrunners are One Piece fans themselves right? also Oda had say in terms of scripting as well, in fact he would send them notes and those notes would come in the form of storyboards
I think that a live action adaptation of One piece just should cover the East Blue arc and leaving an hoping open ending with the message of trying to accomplish your goals and dreams the rest of story can be deduced by the audience and having his own conclusion.
i think Alabasta should still be practically possible...because i think ending the whole live action series with that Vivi farewell will be absolutely hopeful and bittersweet.
Pretty sure the live action One Piece is going to adapt only the 100 chapters or 50 anime episodes spanning East Blue Saga. That is still a lot of content even we are to assume 1 hour long episodes. Even if we take out the OP/ED credits and recaps and also round down one anime episode to be only 20 minutes of content that will still be about 17 or so 1 hour long episodes worth of material. So functionally speaking they have to cut or skip half the content which means that it is gonna feel incredibly rushed. The structure, pace and the writing will suffer. I am assuming/hoping that they can at least give sufficient time to Baratie and Arlong Park., at least 2 -3 episodes each. I have a strong feeling that they will try to rush to reach these arcs as they most popular arcs in early one piece and the main hooks for new readers/watchers.
if they ever get a season 2 I totally expect them to brighten up the colors to help show that vast difference between the normalcy of East Blue and the absolute fantastical ride the Grand Line will be.
A Mr. Fantastic-type of stretchy character only works well when covered up in a suit...which isn't the case with Luffy. And wait, Oshi No Ko isn't number one forever? What.A.Shocker.
I love the chemistry in the One Piece trailer. I love that they all seem to kind of hate each other and that they lamp-shaded the attack name thing. Because I think they had to. But I don't think the stretching looks good. I have to see on a big screen when the VFXs are finished. But I also saw a reacter make the point that the pan and slo-mo we see in the trailer is probably the best look we will see of it. Because of the elastic of Luffy's rubber, it will probably be so fast you can barely see what's happening. My biggest concern is how theyre going to fit the whole Saga Blue into 8 episodes.
I read it was 10 episodes? And do we know how long the episodes will be? Just asking. I have no clue. But if we consider the East Blue saga takes about 50~ episodes, with 15 minutes of content each. There would need to be 12.5 1-hour-long episodes for a shot-for-shot remake... So with some clever choices, it should be squeazable in 8-10 episodes? Depending on the length, of course.
Looks fine. I'm withholding judgement till we see more of what changes to the story they make to adapt a serialized Shonen Manga to be a Television Series for Males Ages 18 to 54. Like I'm out if they try to make the Marines into Heroic Characters or whatever.
I like to think of these live action anime movies as kind of plays or specials that retell a small part of the anime. No one talks about it but I really enjoyed the Bleach live action. Bleach is what got me into anime and I thought it was a fun little chunk of the story.
Cowboy Bebop is my favorite thing ever, and I'm hoping that the One Peice Netflix show is just as ass as Bebop was so I can watch the OP fans get their turn
how did cheat skill surpass My Home Hero, i mean i'm a trash enjoyer and i've been enjoying cheat skill but how the hell did it surpass My Home Hero??? with any luck now that the final ep is out maybe things will change but what the heck man
Thank you for mentioning the lack of a female main character in Persona 3. Not many people seem to have an issue with this but I think it’s very disappointing.
I just wish the all the Persona Anime was Dubbed so I can watch them, I don't mind continuity lock out. I am most curious about the first 2 and the game that is effectively Persona 0.
I think your math is wrong there, epsecially when it comes to early One Piece. You accidentally said an hour long episode x8 would equate to 16 episodes. But since an anime episode is around 20min without ED and OP it would be 24 and not 16. Then factoring in how much time early One Piece wastes, those 8 episodes could very well cover about 30-35 episodes. It seems like they'll stop before reaching Chopper though as that will most likely be a CGI horror hell and they don't want it to become an entire series, cause why would they? Just watch the anime at that point
The biggest problem I have with live action anime adaptations a lot of it comes down to CGI use CGI is a tool in most cases it doesn't work when half the show is CGI Don't give me wrong there have been a couple decent CGI anime but for some reason it always just looks kind of wrong
What is this bizarre obsession with making anime into live action? I just don't understand it. Nothing, and I mean NOTHING that has been converted from anime/manga into live action has held up. Just like most of those video game movies not called Sonic! Hurts my brain just thinking about it.
As far as I'm concerned, the best arcs in One Piece (at least that I have seen) are effectively the "rescue Nami" and "rescue Robin" arcs lol. But early/OG OP imo is the best. Basically, up until around the time they go to recruit Chopper, I'm good. Then I drop off pretty hard until Rescue Robin... then when they go off to train for 2 years after the donut incident, I'm out again. Probably because around the Enel/Eneru stuff was when it just seemed to stop airing dubbed on CartoonNetwork for like 18 months and I stopped caring lol. (I know that's before. After I started being able to watch stuff online I basically just skipped to the Rescue Robin stuff because that was the next bit that sounded interesting to me) So honestly, as much as I kinda liked the cat claw guy and everything, and Usopp basically going from The Boy Who Cried Wolf (Pirates) to hero... I honestly think if I was only getting 8 episodes I'd do 1 where Luffy recruits Zoro, focus on why he's cool, kinda skip over recruiting Usopp with potential for a flashback arc in s2 or whatever, and kinda barely touch on Nami... then the rest, episodes 2-8 would basically be the Nami/Arlong Park arc. If they can't get that right, they can't get OP right, imo. They'd never do Sniper King justice or anything. Like the easiest heart & soul of One Piece moments are Shanks inspiring Luffy, sacrificing his arm (stupidly, because he clearly could've taken down a Sea Emperor at that point lol so he clearly did it to drive home a specific point for Luffy) but that's like the 5 minutes Ep 1 opens with, when Nami cries because Luffy puts his hat on her head and says he'll come back for it, and when Robin cries that she wants to LIVE! But that's way too far out. So they need to nail the Nami arc, imo. And if they aren't even trying to, then it's not going to be good.
The actor for Luffy didn't have enough manic energy. Luffy is a goddamn psychopath and is literally bursting with child-like energy and wonder. I did not get that kind of energy off of this actor. He felt more....generic...hero.
You haven’t seen The Last of Us adaptation from HBO, and they did a fantastic job on that show, they’re not doing the Star Wars thing for the most part when filming the One Piece adaptation, you care way too much on anime, and not on other non-Japanese content.
So are we going to mention that some anime (and animation in general) works because it is animated? Not everything has to be "live" action and honestly some things just shouldn't be.
Kinda annoys me how info like story coverage etc. has been out for literally years and a Google search away yet ppl still refuse to look at least a little deep into things before speaking about them.
I was glad the whole cast got recasted for p3r. Atlus avoided all the headache from both sides of the mob that is twitter. Arkada implied that more than one might needed to be recast so they recasted them all, but who else tho. Besides Vic who else would be controversial?
I do think that Oda is not that powerful when it comes to adaptation. He is , in the end, the mangaka only. He can say his dissatisfaction but I don't think he has the skills to suggest a positive change. Coz live-action adaptation is NOT in Oda's skillset
I feel like this might be as good as you could make One Piece Live Action. One Piece being One Piece makes me feel this Doomed from the start. One Piece is just designed to be a Manga let's be real even when the anime is Good, the Manga leagues Better, and Live Action is just another layer of restrictions. The Acting seem fine, Stage Design seems Fine, the Writing so far does not make me Cringe. But god Luffy's Stretch effect is ugly but when has that ever worked in fairness.
I think the ONE PIECE live action is a great opportunity to introduce more people to a great series. For the longest time, the biggest hurdle of getting into ONE PIECE is the length, and if this show can act as a spring board to catch people up on the last 20+ years of manga and hop onto reading it afterwards. Anime is a lot more popular now than it was, so introducing a new generation to ONE PIECE through a live action show could be awesome.
Luffy's accent kinda doesn't make sense (unless they give him an immigrant backstory, or give everyone is his hometown the same accent), but the actor does an excellent job at capturing the essense, (just a great performance and vibe, I love him) so I can prolly supsend my disbelief. What I can't suspend my disbelief for is how clean everything is. Like Zorro's been hanging on in the gallows for days (weeks?) and yet there is not a speck of dirt on him let alone blood. Where is the blood? It feel like they heavily censored and watered down everything to make it as gen and kid friendly as possible. Less manga inspired and more 4Kids dub version. It feels less like anime and more like something produced for Disney Channel.
I have a feeling they’re going to keep the live action to just the East Blue saga.
Kind of a “if you want more, there’s *literally* over *1000* episodes/chapters of the source material.”
Also depending on the success of this, it can keep going in seasonal increments like this.
The producers want to continue the series. It's just up to the reception it receives or netflix themselves.
Netflix doesn't get money from people reading the source material and there's plenty of other places to watch One Piece, they're not going to treat it like an OVA or Single Season show just to promote the original, like companies do in Japan. If they cancel it early, it'll be because they didn't want to spend anymore money on it.
The CG budget would balloon if they tried to do any Grand Line arcs. Once things start to get really crazy you can't do regular actors and sets without moving away from the source material. The world of One Piece is simply too fantastical and the body proportions of most characters are weird so there would be no good fits for the roles.
@@Japaneseanimeguy true that.
Whether they acceptably adapt Arlong and his crew will be a huge indicator of how well they could continue the show.
Tackling Chopper will be a huge uphill battle, but if they can make Chopper work, I don’t really think they have too many big obstacles until after Skypiea. After that though… things basically become impossible.
8 episodes are enough. 1 Episode for Romance Dawn. 1 Episode for Alvida and Zoro episode. 1 Episode for Buggy. 1 Episode for Syrup Village. 1 Episode to Baratie. 2 Episodes for Arlong Park and 1 Episode for Logue Town. Yes 10 episodes would be ideal but besides Arlong Park everything else can be done in one episode. I just wonder if they will make Romance Down as episode 1 or will be a condense flashback after Luffy's introduction.
Romance Dawn doesn't have anywhere near an hour of content... Even in the anime it's one episode I believe, and it's not even the full episode (though it's close)
Man, Yuri Lowenthal is just EVERYWHERE.
He also voices the Railroad Man from my favorite podcast, Old Gods of Appalachia.
It's amazing.
Can anyone explain what he was talking about when he said one of the p3 VAs needed recasting anyways?
One of them was Vic Mignogna
@@crazysmith5408 I can't believe Vic ate a jellybean at a con once. Truly horrendous.
mariokarter13 said it best "Because Funimation lied about a man and ran him out of the industry." (In a nutshell it was a Witch Hunt.) Well hes apart of his own dubbing studio with Anime Matsuri so not out of the industry just the major studios of it.
It’s gonna be on Switch. An online game store dropped images of a game you can preorder soon thing of P3R and it included all the big systems. Even Switch.
Maybe they're waiting to announce it at tomorrow's Direct.
A "30 minute" anime is actually only about 20 minutes of animation. One Piece in particular ranges between 22 and 24 minutes per episode with a 1 minute and 30 second OP and ED. For a total of between 19 and 21 minutes of narrative time. Let's call it 20 minutes. If the Netflix adaptation is actually a full hour long then you'll get nearly three times the narrative run time. So more like 24 anime episodes worth for an 8 hour long episode run. Not that it makes much of a difference to the point you were trying to make.
You forget that One Piece has openings going over 2 minutes.
the Gum Gum Pistol CGI is somewhat on par with the Fantastic Four live-action movie's Mr. Fantastic's stretching powers.
Live Action Luffy looks like he could believably break out into the One Piece Rap.
YA-YO YA-YOOOOO DREAMIN'!
I think if they'd gone bright it would have cheapened the look somewhat. It would have pushed it into too much cheese factor like Full Metal Alchemist area i think. I rather like the gritty look, it helps balance the brightness of the characters and the somewhat cosplay look some of the characters give. I don't have huge expectations esp seeing it's only 8 eps, but I do think the trailer wasn't too bad. We will just have to wait and see how people will react to how much will have to be left out.
I'm excited to see the one piece live action, but fear it if it were to get a 2nd season as that would mean creating a CGI chopper
If they do get a second season, I see one of two things happening one instead of making chopper. CGI, I think they might go a sweet tooth option. The sweet toot option is a Netflix show that's off of a graphic novel where animal human hybrids start to appear in a post-apocalyptic world and the main character is a half-deer half boy in the graphic novel. He's more deer than boy but in the live action series on Netflix they just use small practical effects and makeup like deer antlers and fur which they could go that route and it'll be fine and perfect. Just give him a blue nose and call it a day or two and the option that I'm really scared of they might do Netflix will cut out drum Island and chopper entirely for budget reasons :(
It could be worse, like a dude with furry makeup like cats lol
They should absolutely make a puppet. Just. A plush Chopper.
So each episode of the Netflix adaptation would have to cover on average 6.625 episodes of anime content (its confirmed that season 1 will cover east blue). After cutting openings, endings and recaps 3 episodes of the anime take about an hour so this show will be about double the pace of the anime which is fast paced but i dont know that its completely unreasonable to do.
I sure do look forward to that one piece show brought to you by the streaming service almost exclusively known for cancelling shows after 1 or 2 seasons and even if by some miracle it isn't, it has zero chance of ever having a satisfying or complete story. That is unless it decides to completely ignore the manga/anime and do it's own thing (it doesn't look like that) which is a decision that has always worked out well for other live action adaptations of anime/manga.
Tbh i always saw it more as a just the east blue saga thing. I don’t think there is a need for more and even less the whole story. I also don’t think that’s the motivation behind the live action. If it ends up getting a sequel I hope they will get till brooks recruiting bc that mean we have all Pretime members. I think it should end at the latest with the end of the pretime skip. If the show is a success and I really do wish that for everyone that worked so hard on it and the cast that clearly have so much love and emotions for the story, their characters and each other, I hope we’ll get to at the very least water 7 and ennies lobby. I need this arc(s), which is not only my fav arc but generally one of the best arcs. 🙈
Oda the goat. I’m hoping the live action OP does well, but like everyone else I am extremely jaded towards mainstream media’s inept producers that only care about squeezing as much money as they can out of successful IP
The cast looks great. Voices match and the actors kind of look like what they would like in a real life version of them in my head.
I would say in One Piece anime there’s only about 10-15 minutes of new content each episode. So an hour episode could cover 4-6 episodes worth, so maybe an initial arc could be covered in an hour of Netflix episode.
Have you stopped doing reviews??
Live Action Adaptions are always a risk. This is suppose to be the first saga
Cowboy Bebop is example. As the studio that did that live action is doing this One Piece Netflix.
Cowboy Bebop original was 26 episodes that Netflix forced into 10 episodes. Which is biggest problem trying to adapt anime.
@@Amoneywilson00lol one piece as 1000+ episodes and chapters.
@@davidesparza3637 I read everything single chapter too.
The second season curse for Gundam series is so real…pretty much the only exception I can think of is Zeta, but that’s more like a sequel than a seasonal continuation
My thoughts on the One Piece trailer? It looks like they actually cared about what they were doing. I can absolutely respect and appreciate when an adaptation does it's best to be true and faithful to the source material, even if it utterly fails. The effort is what matters to me, and I see actual effort being made here. That said, it looks _ridiculous_ but I am willing to accept that there is no way to translate the cartoonish nature of One Piece into live action without looking incredibly silly, so I can suspend that critical part of my brain and judge it for what it is.
I'm of same mind I can understand not being able to translate insane visuals of it but what pains me most is that place these adaptations always fails is translating feel of fights and actors don't capture vibe of characters, like their expressiveness. like zoro raging around yelling on top of high lungs at idiots, or making fluffy not look like complete moron on every shot. Characters are not that deep but getting these things right is what makes it or breaks it.
It's confirmed to be East Blue in its first season
By the time Oda sees the work done and sent to him for approval. The Netflix team would have spent the budget. Oda would have to tell them to do it over again knowing the budget is spent.
So he won’t reject stuff, so his approval won’t actually happen.
I literally got into comment war with one of the one piece Netflix guys on other Weebs and Waifus channel.
Just for saying this live action wasn’t made for us One Piece fans. It is made for the normies that aren’t anime fans.
Wow people still use the word normie unironically? Ew
totally headcanon
@@PredictableEnigma exactly what a normie would say.
you do realise the showrunners are One Piece fans themselves right? also Oda had say in terms of scripting as well, in fact he would send them notes and those notes would come in the form of storyboards
@@friendlyotaku9525 you have no idea how productions work.
Passing by to say that I'm becoming a fan of Hector Montemayor, simply because his name stands out : D
I thought I’d let you know about Crunchyroll news. Don’t know if it’s here because of the Reddit situation but I thought I should let you know
I think that a live action adaptation of One piece just should cover the East Blue arc and leaving an hoping open ending with the message of trying to accomplish your goals and dreams the rest of story can be deduced by the audience and having his own conclusion.
i think Alabasta should still be practically possible...because i think ending the whole live action series with that Vivi farewell will be absolutely hopeful and bittersweet.
It'll all depend on how well the series does. If it does well then a Season 2 will absolutely happen.
i almost managed to forget the original cgi sonic, how dare
I need to know your thoughts on the One Piece live action adaptation now that it's been out.
loving the news show!
In all honesty, there's a lot of kuro and arlong that can trimmed down
8 hour long episodes would be 24 episodes of anime as most are ~20 minutes.
Yay! He’s still alive!
Very interested in checking out persona 3 remake it looks really good so far and curious how the Eng dub will hold up
Pretty sure the live action One Piece is going to adapt only the 100 chapters or 50 anime episodes spanning East Blue Saga. That is still a lot of content even we are to assume 1 hour long episodes. Even if we take out the OP/ED credits and recaps and also round down one anime episode to be only 20 minutes of content that will still be about 17 or so 1 hour long episodes worth of material. So functionally speaking they have to cut or skip half the content which means that it is gonna feel incredibly rushed. The structure, pace and the writing will suffer.
I am assuming/hoping that they can at least give sufficient time to Baratie and Arlong Park., at least 2 -3 episodes each. I have a strong feeling that they will try to rush to reach these arcs as they most popular arcs in early one piece and the main hooks for new readers/watchers.
if they ever get a season 2 I totally expect them to brighten up the colors to help show that vast difference between the normalcy of East Blue and the absolute fantastical ride the Grand Line will be.
Otaku Elf really deserves more love
Luffy’s clothes are based on the manga panels at the start of each chapter.
A Mr. Fantastic-type of stretchy character only works well when covered up in a suit...which isn't the case with Luffy.
And wait, Oshi No Ko isn't number one forever? What.A.Shocker.
They really be doing Otaku Elf dirty. Not just that one either, Birdie Wing dropped 5 spots all the way down to 24.
How dare you expose us to Sonic's Human Teeth without a content warning.
I love the chemistry in the One Piece trailer. I love that they all seem to kind of hate each other and that they lamp-shaded the attack name thing. Because I think they had to. But I don't think the stretching looks good. I have to see on a big screen when the VFXs are finished. But I also saw a reacter make the point that the pan and slo-mo we see in the trailer is probably the best look we will see of it. Because of the elastic of Luffy's rubber, it will probably be so fast you can barely see what's happening. My biggest concern is how theyre going to fit the whole Saga Blue into 8 episodes.
here's hoping their about a hour long or more episodes
I read it was 10 episodes? And do we know how long the episodes will be? Just asking. I have no clue.
But if we consider the East Blue saga takes about 50~ episodes, with 15 minutes of content each. There would need to be 12.5 1-hour-long episodes for a shot-for-shot remake... So with some clever choices, it should be squeazable in 8-10 episodes? Depending on the length, of course.
Since anime trending closed polls will u cover top characters and couples?
I feel that the new persona 3 is followin the RE method.
Looks fine. I'm withholding judgement till we see more of what changes to the story they make to adapt a serialized Shonen Manga to be a Television Series for Males Ages 18 to 54. Like I'm out if they try to make the Marines into Heroic Characters or whatever.
I like to think of these live action anime movies as kind of plays or specials that retell a small part of the anime. No one talks about it but I really enjoyed the Bleach live action. Bleach is what got me into anime and I thought it was a fun little chunk of the story.
Yeah honestly another thing with P3R is simply "do i want to risk them just doing another edition of P3R WITH that content later" too.
To be fair luffys arm looks rubbery... Because hes made of rubber
I not so sure if a live action remake of One Piece is needed, The orignal anime is somewhere if you like to watch it.
I thought dead mount death play would be further up that list...
Nice news GR
Cowboy Bebop is my favorite thing ever, and I'm hoping that the One Peice Netflix show is just as ass as Bebop was so I can watch the OP fans get their turn
2:32 assuming they are… an Arlong….
Idk y it wouldn’t be on switch, it’s perfect for it. I got 3 and 4 on my switch personally
how did cheat skill surpass My Home Hero, i mean i'm a trash enjoyer and i've been enjoying cheat skill but how the hell did it surpass My Home Hero??? with any luck now that the final ep is out maybe things will change but what the heck man
I hate that cheat skill is more popular than DMDP.
Thank you for mentioning the lack of a female main character in Persona 3. Not many people seem to have an issue with this but I think it’s very disappointing.
I just wish the all the Persona Anime was Dubbed so I can watch them, I don't mind continuity lock out. I am most curious about the first 2 and the game that is effectively Persona 0.
I think your math is wrong there, epsecially when it comes to early One Piece.
You accidentally said an hour long episode x8 would equate to 16 episodes. But since an anime episode is around 20min without ED and OP it would be 24 and not 16.
Then factoring in how much time early One Piece wastes, those 8 episodes could very well cover about 30-35 episodes.
It seems like they'll stop before reaching Chopper though as that will most likely be a CGI horror hell and they don't want it to become an entire series, cause why would they? Just watch the anime at that point
The biggest problem I have with live action anime adaptations a lot of it comes down to CGI use CGI is a tool in most cases it doesn't work when half the show is CGI Don't give me wrong there have been a couple decent CGI anime but for some reason it always just looks kind of wrong
What is this bizarre obsession with making anime into live action? I just don't understand it. Nothing, and I mean NOTHING that has been converted from anime/manga into live action has held up. Just like most of those video game movies not called Sonic! Hurts my brain just thinking about it.
As I am a poor ignorant person, why did Persona 3 need re-casting?
Because Funimation lied about a man and ran him out of the industry.
As far as I'm concerned, the best arcs in One Piece (at least that I have seen) are effectively the "rescue Nami" and "rescue Robin" arcs lol. But early/OG OP imo is the best. Basically, up until around the time they go to recruit Chopper, I'm good. Then I drop off pretty hard until Rescue Robin... then when they go off to train for 2 years after the donut incident, I'm out again. Probably because around the Enel/Eneru stuff was when it just seemed to stop airing dubbed on CartoonNetwork for like 18 months and I stopped caring lol. (I know that's before. After I started being able to watch stuff online I basically just skipped to the Rescue Robin stuff because that was the next bit that sounded interesting to me)
So honestly, as much as I kinda liked the cat claw guy and everything, and Usopp basically going from The Boy Who Cried Wolf (Pirates) to hero... I honestly think if I was only getting 8 episodes I'd do 1 where Luffy recruits Zoro, focus on why he's cool, kinda skip over recruiting Usopp with potential for a flashback arc in s2 or whatever, and kinda barely touch on Nami... then the rest, episodes 2-8 would basically be the Nami/Arlong Park arc. If they can't get that right, they can't get OP right, imo. They'd never do Sniper King justice or anything.
Like the easiest heart & soul of One Piece moments are Shanks inspiring Luffy, sacrificing his arm (stupidly, because he clearly could've taken down a Sea Emperor at that point lol so he clearly did it to drive home a specific point for Luffy) but that's like the 5 minutes Ep 1 opens with, when Nami cries because Luffy puts his hat on her head and says he'll come back for it, and when Robin cries that she wants to LIVE! But that's way too far out. So they need to nail the Nami arc, imo. And if they aren't even trying to, then it's not going to be good.
i have faith in the one piece live action for ONE reason… because it’s ONE PIECE!!!
I... do not blame you for just dodging all the questions of P3's new voice case lol
There is no reason for P3R not to be on switch coz p5R is on it.
Also nintendo direct announcement todat, so there is still hope!
don't blame anyone for being skeptical of the live action one piece at first
I got a twist for you @GlassReflection add 3,2 1 with your introduction
The actor for Luffy didn't have enough manic energy. Luffy is a goddamn psychopath and is literally bursting with child-like energy and wonder. I did not get that kind of energy off of this actor. He felt more....generic...hero.
But would that work in Live Action? A cartoonish performance wouldn’t be as enjoyable in a live performer, would come across as fake and forced.
You haven’t seen The Last of Us adaptation from HBO, and they did a fantastic job on that show, they’re not doing the Star Wars thing for the most part when filming the One Piece adaptation, you care way too much on anime, and not on other non-Japanese content.
So are we going to mention that some anime (and animation in general) works because it is animated? Not everything has to be "live" action and honestly some things just shouldn't be.
Sadly the new persona game likely wont be able to bring back Vic Mignogna after all the garbage that went down at funimation.
Otaku Elf is best of this season for me, very enjoyable.
Otaku elf is heavily underrated.
We will get a Persona 3 ReReload after 5 months, just like with Royal. It will have the FemC.😂
I think fully reloaded would be a more appropriate title if an updated re-release happens.
I hope Dangers would get high enough so that Tristan will give it another go
Kinda annoys me how info like story coverage etc. has been out for literally years and a Google search away yet ppl still refuse to look at least a little deep into things before speaking about them.
Will dangers in my heart get dubbed?
I honestly thought CGI was pretty good not the set but action like GUM-GUM Pistol unlike sanic
Not 16 24 anime episodes and east blue is 45 -50 episodes and the pscing was pretty slow
I was glad the whole cast got recasted for p3r. Atlus avoided all the headache from both sides of the mob that is twitter. Arkada implied that more than one might needed to be recast so they recasted them all, but who else tho. Besides Vic who else would be controversial?
Never seen op only played the rpg game intrigued see the live action adaptation
8 episodes eh? They're about 992 short...
More 60min Anime Episode 🎉
With today minimal 12 episode seasons.
Rip 26ep season 😅
It's going to be even worse if One Piece is bad because Oda made it known how deeply involved he was
If we asked Oda himself to make One Piece all over again today, people would probably hate it.
Nah I’m know what Netflix will do to it.
Cheat Skill is not the worst anime this season, stop lying to yourself.
Has there been a single bad live action adaptation yet? Beside's Speed Racer.
(this is sarcasm)
I do think that Oda is not that powerful when it comes to adaptation. He is , in the end, the mangaka only. He can say his dissatisfaction but I don't think he has the skills to suggest a positive change. Coz live-action adaptation is NOT in Oda's skillset
I don't like the pitch black night look in the trailer
I feel like this might be as good as you could make One Piece Live Action. One Piece being One Piece makes me feel this Doomed from the start. One Piece is just designed to be a Manga let's be real even when the anime is Good, the Manga leagues Better, and Live Action is just another layer of restrictions. The Acting seem fine, Stage Design seems Fine, the Writing so far does not make me Cringe. But god Luffy's Stretch effect is ugly but when has that ever worked in fairness.
I think the ONE PIECE live action is a great opportunity to introduce more people to a great series. For the longest time, the biggest hurdle of getting into ONE PIECE is the length, and if this show can act as a spring board to catch people up on the last 20+ years of manga and hop onto reading it afterwards. Anime is a lot more popular now than it was, so introducing a new generation to ONE PIECE through a live action show could be awesome.
I love atlus but the p3 remake is so underwhelming
Now I want an animated Persona 3 series, I know that there are movies but those cut corners of the storyline too much 😑
If they do make a Persona 3 Tv series let's just hope it's nothing like the Persona 5 anime.
@@GenerationZ313eeeh it was okay it didn’t feel rushed but the songs were pretty good 😌
Persona 3 WE ARE SO BACK
Luffy's accent kinda doesn't make sense (unless they give him an immigrant backstory, or give everyone is his hometown the same accent), but the actor does an excellent job at capturing the essense, (just a great performance and vibe, I love him) so I can prolly supsend my disbelief. What I can't suspend my disbelief for is how clean everything is. Like Zorro's been hanging on in the gallows for days (weeks?) and yet there is not a speck of dirt on him let alone blood. Where is the blood? It feel like they heavily censored and watered down everything to make it as gen and kid friendly as possible. Less manga inspired and more 4Kids dub version. It feels less like anime and more like something produced for Disney Channel.
Did vic mignogna dirty. Thats why.
All the one piece characters are gonna suck in live action, you can clearly see the show makers missed the point for all of them.
FIRSTTT‼️
One Piece adaption is a fundamentally bad idea. I have no hope for it and the trailer changed nothing
Unfortunately I didn't like it at all I will never watch for many reasons why.
Atlus refuses to give the people what they want. Her.
First.
DAMNIT I thought I was first 😭