@@lilianaoaida732 She very obviously insinuated it! Why else would she bring up a single culture in this context when in reality broth/bone broth is a thing in multiple cultures around the world. She was obviously being ignorant and thought it 'belongs' to Asia (which also is ignorant, she most likely was equating Asia with South East Asia. Or do you think she had Iran, Turkey, Azerbaijan and Iraq in mind? 😑😑😑)
@Trinity M there are many ancient civilizations. Mesopotamia (Iraq) the Aztec/Mayan/Olmecs (Mexico) Peru, India, Egypt. Major cooking inspiration and cultivation of flavours and spices from Mexico and India and Turkey. We need to come together and love and share our food and create peace.
@@Darling_Nicci I believe that host is Chinese descent which as you said, doesn’t represent all of Asia. I’m sure she meant “Asian” = East Asians but I wish people would generalizing Asians. Indians, Israelis, Filipinos, Lebanese, Pakistanis, Vietnamese and many and more are all Asian as well.
I am not a Goop fan but listen to the podcast. She doesn’t mention that she ONLY eats soups and bone broth. She mentioned veggies, fish, soups and yes, bone broth. Intermittent fasting has been used for ages by everyone, there’s an educational aspect to it but it works for some people like me (diagnosed with RA). Just get the whole story first… basically “nothing to see here”
AMEN! People are not listening and o what she is saying. She has cheat days and she is doing it for Health reasons. I’m working on a 18 hr fast now lol. Bone broth is good for us. It has all kinds of Collagen and Nutrients.
How is bone broth exclusive to „Asia“. People have been cooking/drinking bone broth all over the world for centuries, it was always a huge part of meals because there simply wasn’t a lot of choosing to do
Huh? Bone broth is strictly Asian? Since when? I’m pretty sure many cultures make bone broth.. because back then you couldn’t waste any food. So you would cook out the bones with vegetable scraps. No matter if you lived in Asia, Europe or anywhere else
Cooking at work while listening to this today. Just never heard of ANYONE that claims bone broth could be culturally appropriated? Quite possibly the strangest remark ever. Hope you are joking. Sure broth goes back to prehistoric and ancient cultures, with China being one but also Mexico, Egypt, Turkey, Greece, Germany, Peru,Japan but virtually every culture has broth based recipe from either animal/seafood or plant sources for nutrition. Of all the things Paltrow(of Jewish culture) has presented this is not offensive at all. It is extremely nutritious. Many cultures drink broth. Kudos to Chinese Won Ton Soup but let's not forget 'Jewish Penicillin' or Chicken Soup. A good stock is relatively colourless except for beef which is light brown. Fasting is a practice in many cultures and religions and is done for limited period. One of the many ways to reach out to people everywhere is to share our food with love and peace. Also loved the segment with Palin, she's a wonderful cook.
I wish people would stop generalizing all Asians. Indians, Israelis, Filipinos, Vietnamese, Lebanese and many more Asian too. Many Asians don’t use bone broth and many non-Asians use it. The woman who said this looks East Asian but East Asia doesn’t represent all Asians.
I can’t believe that no one on the panel called this out for what it is, disordered eating dressed up as “wellness.” Starving yourself until noon and then breaking your fast by only drinking black coffee and drinking bone broth is not a healthy practice. Her only meal for the day is a lot of vegetables at an early dinner.
I have been eating g this way for years now the thing is you can eat what ever you want in the hours before fasting we don't need to eat three meals a day you don't fill the car up until it needs it it is the same thing
She's gotten older and looks really sick in that podcast, if her health isn't in question I've got no problems. However, nothings wrong with her putting on a few pounds as long as it's controlled and she's exercising to stay in shape. People said the same thing about Ariana Grande when she lost all that weight, maybe she just doesn't like having any access weight on her personally, who knows. Telling someone they look "healthy and beautiful" to not hurt their feelings isn't doing them any favors. "No one has the right to tell what’s good for her!"? That's the problem with close minded people, nobody can tell them anything, it's a very arrogant trait to have.
Intermittent fasting has shown a lot of health/aging benefits actually…you basically just don’t eat anything from dinner to lunch. Been doing it for a decade now. Intermittent fasting + bone broth lunch IS a bit much though 😅
I’m Italian… on both sides of my family. We’ve made bone broth since I can remember, this is not exclusive to Asian culture. This is how you make broth for soups and stews around the world. I also make bone broth weekly, and drink it every morning with my breakfast. It’s full of protein and very hydrating, and great for your skin. Not saying to have only this as a meal (not healthy), but bone broth is not a new thing.
What she said was pretty ignorant, as if one continent owns bone broth. Also. When she meant ‘Asian’ she probably meant East Asia because I doubt she meant India, Turkey, Israel or the Philippines, among other countries.
You ladies need to educate yourself on how fasting works and why people fast and the Health benefits of it and bone broth. And also listen to what she is saying.
Bone broth is simply a good thing to break your fast with. I fast between 12 and 16 hours 3 or 4 times a week. It's a great way to maintain gut health..
I didn't really agree with any of them. Obviously, GP is not a doctor. I don't think she is trying to claim bone broth as her own. It is significant to many people and cultures, not just in Asia. Also, GW is unapologetically out of touch with reality, it's a part of her charm.
I was shocked when I heard that interview too. I went back and watched her what she eats in a day for Harpers Bazaar interview from 3 years ago. It was really similar and a lot more reasonable and realistic. I think she just didn't got into in-depth details, perhaps because she has before.
I completely agree with the systemic problem of doctors not listening to women and women being dismissed. It’s a real issue and women are dying because of it.
Look she got asked the questions in an interview and she answered. She's not promoting or telling anyone they have to eat bone broth and do IVs to be healthy...she's just saying what she does. Yeah it's out of touch because no one has time or money for that but that's why celebrities are stupid influencers or people to look to for answers
I don't fast, and yet I lost 40 lbs in 8 months. Everything we've been taught about food is wrong. Even the low carb Atkins diet had it only partially correct. Focus on the protein, limit your carbs, and watch your calories. There is no such thing as an essential carb. Carbohydrates have no essential nutrients that the body cannot make for itself. To heal injuries and grow muscle, you need protein. Carbs are just energy to fuel your workouts. Not working out? Cut back the carbs, but keep the protein if you want to stay healthy. Intermittent fasting may be helpful in short bursts, but I wouldn't want to make it a regular habit.
I grew up in asia and we NEVER consumed bone broth. What are you guys on about 😂😂. All of the people at the table drink bone broth but don’t want to speak about it due to hurt feelings. One lady literally promotes it on her social media. This was hilarious. Also doctors are weight loss experts, since when…
I wish people would stop generalizing all Asians. Indians, Israelis, Filipinos, Vietnamese, Lebanese and many more Asian too. Many Asians don’t use bone broth and many non-Asians use it. The woman who said this looks East Asian but East Asia doesn’t represent all Asians.
Gwyneth needs some fried chicken on her bones! However, I don't see anything wrong with "Wellness people and Guru's." Thank goodness people remind us about how great broth and natural things can do for us. They remind us of the good old home remedies that our grandma's taught us and have worked forever. Good old chicken soup has vitamins and nutrients for you. Doctors will prescribe medicine and make money from pharmaceutical business as well. And sometimes they don't know how to treat you. Health also has to do with the mind and making sure we're treating our bodies and feeling good. Fried chicken is good for the soul too.
It's obvious she has an eating disorder because she could easily eat more, portioned food and not gain weight at all (grain free, no added sugar) but she doesn't even do that. It seems like she really wants to eat as little as possible :( I hope she gets better.
Jeez….could they get any more ignorant? Keep laughing ladies, you’re just laughing yourself to your graves and unfortunately bringing all the poor lost souls at your talk shows with you. This is really upsetting. Just being CIVIL here….
This is absurd, bone broth isn't exclusive to Asia 😑😑😑 Also, what do you mean by "Asia" exactly? 🙄
So true, it’s also a traditional Mexican dish
She did not say it was exclusive to Asia, she just spoke from the perspective of her culture. Never said this is not a thing in other cultures.
@@lilianaoaida732 She very obviously insinuated it! Why else would she bring up a single culture in this context when in reality broth/bone broth is a thing in multiple cultures around the world. She was obviously being ignorant and thought it 'belongs' to Asia (which also is ignorant, she most likely was equating Asia with South East Asia. Or do you think she had Iran, Turkey, Azerbaijan and Iraq in mind? 😑😑😑)
@Trinity M there are many ancient civilizations. Mesopotamia (Iraq) the Aztec/Mayan/Olmecs (Mexico) Peru, India, Egypt. Major cooking inspiration and cultivation of flavours and spices from Mexico and India and Turkey. We need to come together and love and share our food and create peace.
@@Darling_Nicci I believe that host is Chinese descent which as you said, doesn’t represent all of Asia. I’m sure she meant “Asian” = East Asians but I wish people would generalizing Asians.
Indians, Israelis, Filipinos, Lebanese, Pakistanis, Vietnamese and many and more are all Asian as well.
Nobody owns the rights to bone broth and you can consume it in any way you like ………….
Oh for goodness sake. Asia didn’t own bone broth, every country has made stock ffs.
Chick be claiming bone broth I cannooott
I am not a Goop fan but listen to the podcast. She doesn’t mention that she ONLY eats soups and bone broth. She mentioned veggies, fish, soups and yes, bone broth.
Intermittent fasting has been used for ages by everyone, there’s an educational aspect to it but it works for some people like me (diagnosed with RA).
Just get the whole story first… basically “nothing to see here”
Are you feeling better with I.F. It helps with pain and rigidity? I want to try it. I also have arthritis and another rheumatic problem.
AMEN! People are not listening and o what she is saying. She has cheat days and she is doing it for Health reasons. I’m working on a 18 hr fast now lol. Bone broth is good for us. It has all kinds of Collagen and Nutrients.
Is she really trying to claim bone broth?? Girlll
How is bone broth exclusive to „Asia“. People have been cooking/drinking bone broth all over the world for centuries, it was always a huge part of meals because there simply wasn’t a lot of choosing to do
But bone broth is big everywhere. Where they be bovine, may there be broth.
Huh? Bone broth is strictly Asian? Since when? I’m pretty sure many cultures make bone broth.. because back then you couldn’t waste any food. So you would cook out the bones with vegetable scraps. No matter if you lived in Asia, Europe or anywhere else
Cooking at work while listening to this today. Just never heard of ANYONE that claims bone broth could be culturally appropriated? Quite possibly the strangest remark ever. Hope you are joking. Sure broth goes back to prehistoric and ancient cultures, with China being one but also Mexico, Egypt, Turkey, Greece, Germany, Peru,Japan but virtually every culture has broth based recipe from either animal/seafood or plant sources for nutrition. Of all the things Paltrow(of Jewish culture) has presented this is not offensive at all. It is extremely nutritious. Many cultures drink broth. Kudos to Chinese Won Ton Soup but let's not forget 'Jewish Penicillin' or Chicken Soup. A good stock is relatively colourless except for beef which is light brown. Fasting is a practice in many cultures and religions and is done for limited period. One of the many ways to reach out to people everywhere is to share our food with love and peace. Also loved the segment with Palin, she's a wonderful cook.
I wish people would stop generalizing all Asians. Indians, Israelis, Filipinos, Vietnamese, Lebanese and many more Asian too.
Many Asians don’t use bone broth and many non-Asians use it. The woman who said this looks East Asian but East Asia doesn’t represent all Asians.
I can’t believe that no one on the panel called this out for what it is, disordered eating dressed up as “wellness.”
Starving yourself until noon and then breaking your fast by only drinking black coffee and drinking bone broth is not a healthy practice. Her only meal for the day is a lot of vegetables at an early dinner.
So basically extremely low calories
I have been eating g this way for years now the thing is you can eat what ever you want in the hours before fasting we don't need to eat three meals a day you don't fill the car up until it needs it it is the same thing
She looks sickly and anorexic as well… and they also don’t mention that she has a daughter. What message is she sending to her?
what works for her, might not work for everyone. but it works for her.
@@deerheart87 basically it's called starving yourself
Why does this lady think bone broth is an asian thing. He narcissism is irritating….
Her*
Gwyneth looks healthy and beautiful and she can eat whatever she wants when she wants to. No one has the right to tell what’s good for her!
She's gotten older and looks really sick in that podcast, if her health isn't in question I've got no problems. However, nothings wrong with her putting on a few pounds as long as it's controlled and she's exercising to stay in shape. People said the same thing about Ariana Grande when she lost all that weight, maybe she just doesn't like having any access weight on her personally, who knows. Telling someone they look "healthy and beautiful" to not hurt their feelings isn't doing them any favors. "No one has the right to tell what’s good for her!"? That's the problem with close minded people, nobody can tell them anything, it's a very arrogant trait to have.
Intermittent fasting has shown a lot of health/aging benefits actually…you basically just don’t eat anything from dinner to lunch. Been doing it for a decade now. Intermittent fasting + bone broth lunch IS a bit much though 😅
People make broth with bones in non-Asian cultures, too.
Um. Bone broth is a part of so many cultures 😭
I’m Italian… on both sides of my family. We’ve made bone broth since I can remember, this is not exclusive to Asian culture. This is how you make broth for soups and stews around the world.
I also make bone broth weekly, and drink it every morning with my breakfast. It’s full of protein and very hydrating, and great for your skin. Not saying to have only this as a meal (not healthy), but bone broth is not a new thing.
What she said was pretty ignorant, as if one continent owns bone broth. Also. When she meant ‘Asian’ she probably meant East Asia because I doubt she meant India, Turkey, Israel or the Philippines, among other countries.
You ladies need to educate yourself on how fasting works and why people fast and the Health benefits of it and bone broth. And also listen to what she is saying.
Bone broth is simply a good thing to break your fast with. I fast between 12 and 16 hours 3 or 4 times a week. It's a great way to maintain gut health..
She’s starving herself
I didn't really agree with any of them. Obviously, GP is not a doctor. I don't think she is trying to claim bone broth as her own. It is significant to many people and cultures, not just in Asia. Also, GW is unapologetically out of touch with reality, it's a part of her charm.
Does anyone know where I can find the original interview? I cannot find it anywhere
I was shocked when I heard that interview too. I went back and watched her what she eats in a day for Harpers Bazaar interview from 3 years ago. It was really similar and a lot more reasonable and realistic. I think she just didn't got into in-depth details, perhaps because she has before.
This debate is more intelligent and interesting than The View.
Is this a SNL sketch?
😂😂😂
I completely agree with the systemic problem of doctors not listening to women and women being dismissed. It’s a real issue and women are dying because of it.
Look she got asked the questions in an interview and she answered. She's not promoting or telling anyone they have to eat bone broth and do IVs to be healthy...she's just saying what she does. Yeah it's out of touch because no one has time or money for that but that's why celebrities are stupid influencers or people to look to for answers
I don't fast, and yet I lost 40 lbs in 8 months. Everything we've been taught about food is wrong. Even the low carb Atkins diet had it only partially correct. Focus on the protein, limit your carbs, and watch your calories. There is no such thing as an essential carb. Carbohydrates have no essential nutrients that the body cannot make for itself. To heal injuries and grow muscle, you need protein. Carbs are just energy to fuel your workouts. Not working out? Cut back the carbs, but keep the protein if you want to stay healthy. Intermittent fasting may be helpful in short bursts, but I wouldn't want to make it a regular habit.
…whatever works for her sheesh! She never said DO THIS DO THAT…
Is that first girl fr? Pretty much saying Gwyneth is culturally appropriating food??? Like didn’t know that was a thing now…
I grew up in asia and we NEVER consumed bone broth. What are you guys on about 😂😂. All of the people at the table drink bone broth but don’t want to speak about it due to hurt feelings. One lady literally promotes it on her social media. This was hilarious. Also doctors are weight loss experts, since when…
I wish people would stop generalizing all Asians. Indians, Israelis, Filipinos, Vietnamese, Lebanese and many more Asian too.
Many Asians don’t use bone broth and many non-Asians use it. The woman who said this looks East Asian but East Asia doesn’t represent all Asians.
Gwyneth needs some fried chicken on her bones! However, I don't see anything wrong with "Wellness people and Guru's." Thank goodness people remind us about how great broth and natural things can do for us. They remind us of the good old home remedies that our grandma's taught us and have worked forever. Good old chicken soup has vitamins and nutrients for you. Doctors will prescribe medicine and make money from pharmaceutical business as well. And sometimes they don't know how to treat you. Health also has to do with the mind and making sure we're treating our bodies and feeling good. Fried chicken is good for the soul too.
And that's why Asians forever have flawless skin and hair and great figures definitely doing something right 👍
I think Asians also drink a clear bone broth. It is very tasteful.
So I cant eat bone broth now bc its Asian? What this lady said is nuts.
Oh Gwyneth Gwyneth Gwyneth....Please stay in your lane...acting and leave nutrition advice to the professionals Registered Dietitians.
She can't act tho.
A narcacistic rich kid is her only lane
Low vibrational panel
this is worse than the view!!!
Yet you are HERE🤣😂
It’s awful
@@Tyda777 I was just morbidly interested
It's obvious she has an eating disorder because she could easily eat more, portioned food and not gain weight at all (grain free, no added sugar) but she doesn't even do that. It seems like she really wants to eat as little as possible :( I hope she gets better.
I agree with it all ladies!! And thanks for the extra dose of humor!! 😊
Woman should stop complaining about what other woman do this diet works and it is nothing new you can eat more than you think
I need to try her diet
Jeez….could they get any more ignorant? Keep laughing ladies, you’re just laughing yourself to your graves and unfortunately bringing all the poor lost souls at your talk shows with you. This is really upsetting. Just being CIVIL here….
Lime green jelly
I detect Canadian accents…
Sexual health has a Doctor women should all know about!
Drs trained in NaPro Technology
Doing everything she can to stay young and yet it's not working
No girl
Gwen looks frail not sure about IV treatment
I mean she looks great but v slim
❤