"Bridgerton" Costumes Are Both Better And Worse This Season
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 27 мар 2022
- yo I just binged it on Friday and I'm busy this week so wanted to share my thoughts while I'm at it 💅
become a member: / karolinaŻebrowskax
_____________
My Instagram: bit.ly/2Qo9rrI
My nudes: bit.ly/2Dvakv0
My merch: bit.ly/2CCq5jE
I think another reason Kate constantly wore brighter and darker colors was because she thought she was always meant to return to India, so they incorporated traditional Indian colors and patterns into her wardrobe. As compared to Edwina, she always happily recalled India, her childhood, and her mother there to other people and Edwina seemed to know that her future was bound to England so that could be why her color palette was more traditionally regency.
Also from the beginning Kate made it very clear she was not a demure pastel flower on the marriage market. I think that affected her color scheme as well.
You guys made great points!
They could've done it a bit better
Completely! I did not think of the colours representing India, but I totally saw that now. I thought that the contrast between the shapes and colours of the two sisters represented their outlooks - Kate is the 'older' sister/mother of Edwina, hence she is wearing darker, more stronger colours - a similarity to Lady Danbury's colour palette with its jewel tones and rectangular cuts. Edwina is largely innocent, the younger sister following her sister's advice - hence her pastel pink and more flowy shoulders for example?
Also Kate is Edwina's half sister, and their dad is indian. Likely Kate's bio mom as well, while Edwina's bio mom (and Kate' step/adopted mom) is english, meaning Edwina is half english while Kate is not.
I know they just “don’t do bonnets” but every time they were squinting in the sunshine, I was like… there is a solution for this. 😂
lol, yes. 😆 I get that they obstruct the face a little (a very little) which is a problem on camera, but it turns out they also block . . . sunshine! 🤯
Also, have you seen Micarah Tewers (sp?) review/rant over the costumes in the most recent Little Women? she’s driven so crazy over the lack of bonnets that in the end she constructs one herself (in like an hour) just to demonstrate it can be done 😂 Your comment made me think of it and I had to watch it again and laugh :)
Modern sunglasses, like Karolina wears with her vintage dresses, of course! This is fantasy after all. 😉
Hollywood’s hatred of bonnets needs to END
@@carelsby #JusticeForBonnets
There were so many scenes where they were all just standing around chatting in direct sunlight for what looked like hours. Can't relate. I would never.
I think Kate and Edwina's outfits were a bit saree inspired. In several scenes Kate was wearing a woven banarasi brocade as an accent fabric. Both she and Edwina wore very typical Indian jewelry (not the best kind, but definitely Indian styles).
Yup, Charithra Chandran, Edwina, gave her personal jewellery as samples to inspire the Indian influence in the jewellery! I liked the delicate pearl pieces
Yes exactly!
@@ad6252 you can see it in the jhumka earrings and her bangles in some scenes, and her choker she wears in some.
I liked the Indian colors. Marigold colors, temuric gold
I *loved* the brighter Indian-inpired fabrics/jewelry on them. The text of the show was very much "we're not going to talk about colonialism bc frothy fantasy" but I was half expecting Edwina to wear bright red and/or a saree to the wedding.
I think the differences between Kate's and Edwina's costumes was to show how different they are. Kate was in darker and more saturated colors to probably show how mature she is and when she is out, her hair is less intricate than Edwina's. She also wears fabrics that are a little stiffer than Edwina's. Oh and she also REPEATS outfits. Which I think is a nice touch because she wasnt there to catch a man, she was only there for Edwina so who cares what Kate is wearing.
Edwina's costumes were soft and flowy and more innocent, but her hair was also so intricate, probably to try to look older but it just makes her look younger all together.
Also she wears a lot blue which is the Brigertons color :)
I also thought the sleeves patterns in Kate's dresses were meant to be a nod to her Indian heritage since she was dead set on going back while Edwina was meant to grow an English Woman
@@kuddlecat Yes! Kate’s jewel tone dresses reminded me a lot of the beautiful Indian saris!
@@nardagates6143 the color and the fabric of the dress she wore to the ball of the featheringtons also reminded me of saris
I just feel like what she said about looking like they didn't fit her was on point. It feels like it's nit exactly her size or something and the fabric plus the color palet they chose looked weird on her even though it shouldn't, they could've easily made it look good its not a hard color palet especially with her skin tone. They looked a bit more like costumes than clothes that didn't fit her great and i dont get why. I think they were meant to have "indian fashion" elements and i like that especially considering her character, i just think its another reason why i dont get how they made it look bad. It feels like they just didn't try that much to make it look good
Further on in the article about the corset it said this, "Ashley's costume was a team effort and she said she needed a lot of help from the wardrobe department “because when you're in a corset, you can't put your shoes on.”"
What on earth are these costume designers doing?! Poor, working women would wear corsets every day and had no problem. Except for some specific examples, none of which were worn during regency era, corsets should not limit movement and should actually make you feel better because it's giving you back support.
It really feels like they're just saying this crap cause that's what people believe. It's annoying as heck
Most actors seem to have zero education when it comes to even fantasy historical dress. Wearing, and being comfortable in, a corset has a definite learning curve to it for the person and the corset. Remembering to put your shoes and stockings on FIRST is a Thing To Remember when dressing with corset in the loop. Of course those poor actors needed help.
It is annoying, though.
We have to remember that the costume designers aren't in control, it's ultimately up to the director and producer and the story they want to create.
I flashed back to the photos of women playing SPORTS in corsets and was very confused lol.
There's a common phrase "boots before corsets" because corsets can limit your forward bend so it can be tricky to put shoes on after having the corset on. I've struggled to put shoes on after because my torso is short and my legs are long so there's just a lot of distance to reach which I usually rely on being able to fully bend myself forwards to put on shoes. But if I do it the other way round, that's it no mobility issues and I can do stuff like run to catch a train whilst dragging a suitcase whilst wearing a corset. So its definitely not that limiting.
In the case of these stays though, they're basically just longline bras. They shouldn't be preventing any forward bending because they finish well above the waist which is the bit you'd bend at. I could imagine that the shoulder straps which hold the shoulders in a backwards position could take some getting used to, but again, nothing that carefully planning couldn't solve because you just don't lace up the straps until you've done with the bits which require greater forward shoulder mobility (like the putting on of shoes).
It really does feel like they were just parroting things that aren't really true or are only partially true. Like maybe the actress who said about not being able to put your shoes on read that somewhere and just presumed you can't do it at all rather than thinking of changing up the order. Its so normal today that shoes are the last thing you put on that people forget there are other orders of doing things which might work better in certain contexts. Like if I'm going to be wearing quite a high heeled shoe then I will definitely need to put those on before lacing up my corset because it changes my posture enough that doing so after can be uncomfortable (because the corset is holding me in a different position than the heels want me in). But if I'm wearing flatter shoes then if I forgot, I'd just need some help getting them on, but wouldn't really need to reverse the order for comfort reasons. This is all in steel boned modern corsets though. Not half stays stiffened with string. lol
They're completely historically wrong, but I kind of like them. They're colourful and very different to usual period drama costumes. But I think you hit the nail on the head (of course), in that it works very well for the show
The usual corset complaining from the actors was slightly infuriating though
I think they're more "princess dresses" rather than historical.
That is a matter of getting the producers to put more colors into period dramas then, but keep it historically correct though. "Emma" did that very well.
I like it. They're obviously not going for historical accuracy in this show. Nothing is correct. So they might as well go all the way with it
@@nienkehuijbens301 yeah, I think it's very obvious they're going for historically inspired over historically accurate and honestly I'm fine with that?
don’t be mad at the actresses for complaining about the corsets. be mad at the producers/costumers for putting them in painful corsets.
As a corsetiere, things like Bridgerton just piss me off. I get customers who are recommended to the corset business I work at for medical reasons by their doctors, who are told that they should get a corset for relief from their pain (scoliosis and fractures are often the cause), and STILL expect something out of Bridgerton or Pirates of the Caribbean, with the constricted breathing, and the blood and bruises. They come to their appointments so nervous, expecting me to hurt them, and I hate it. I wish that trope would go away. It is actually chasing people away from corsetry, including people who could actually really benefit from it.
My mum is a physiotherapist who has publised work on the benefits of corsets in children with scoliosis. I'm pretty sure she still believe a lot of the bullshit myths about "old" corsets! Then, to be fair, my family are proud members of the itty bitty titty committee, so I've never really known her to even feel the need for a bra, so maybe it makes a bit more sense to her.
Yeah, the correct information needs to be spread. Sadly, a good chunk of people seem misinformed on it. It's a shame and it's quite damaging, because corsets can help people with back problems if fitted well. I wish you well with your business and in future, I hope you get less ignorant customers. It must be exhausting having to explain to them constantly that the tropes are a load of rubbish and not even true.
I think the customers are more at fault than the tropes really. I also see the tropes everywhere and I believe that at the time it could be uncomfortable but I would never think about today's corset for scoliosis being like that I mean we live in the 21st century people, if it's a medical device then of course it helps. The ignorant customers would find these unwanted sources elsewhere..
what annoys me is that there are people like you around, who know how a corset works, who can manufacture and fit it properly so why do movies and tv series not refer to the pros? if your 'normal' costumer has no clue about corsets then bring in someone who knows or leave them out entirely. heck, in Bridgerton they could have worn strapless bras and none would have been the wiser.
I have pretty heavy scoliosis and a lot of pain, and I wear a medical belt thing. What kind of corset would you recommend for these issues? I'm very curious. I've never met a corsetmaker who had any experience with scoliosis.
What made me so sad is that they used more make up. I loved the natural looks they did before. And dont even get me started on how bad Eloise's wig was. That was horrible. A crime, I would say.
Agreed, they used so much make-up on Kate's actress especially. She has a beautiful natural look, she didn't need all that foundation make-up.
oh yeah they weren’t even trying with the wig
WAIT what wig?
It made me so annoyed that they didn't even try to disguise the wig by at least sometimes pinning her hair up - it was so irritating how she had her hair in her face all the time and not very camera friendly. It also doesn't really make sense for the character - why wouldn't she want her hair away from her face, it's more practical
Truuuuue. The full make up in baths and beds was annoying.
Karolina is flexin' on us just by wearing her dress and she doesn't realise it . Hun got time travel level beauty
I just got into a fight with my history teacher about corsets being torture instruments. I'm still angry. I'm glad that there is a community of people that know enough about this to know that that's bullshit. Thank you Karolina for creating this chanel
Shout out to you - hang in there - it is so , so hard to get folks to hear truth on this subject. And it is so very exasperating. Some folks won't so don't let them stress you too much. Truth is a properly fitting pair of stays or corsets would likely help us all have better posture & in turn, fewer back issues.
You could try to show some sources, this channel and some others often point towards articles.
Not that you have to, sometimes we need to accept people just say inaccurate things. But it’s annoying when it’s a teacher who ought to know better and who will spread misinformation.
I went to a corset construction course held by Jill Salen (who has written a book which has patterns taken from antique corsets) and even she thought that anything more than a 2" reduction was massively extreme and impossible to achieve without damaging yourself. I wanted to make my corset I was doing have a 6" reduction as that was what I had with my custom corsets and they'd fit totally closed, but I was wearing them with a 2" gap. I turned up in one of them on the first day and she basically accused me of having a fetish as if it was disgusting. But my waist is just quite squishy, so I can lace down quite easily. She didn't totally believe me on the size of the corset I was wearing, so eventually we settled on me making it have a 20" waist for a 4" reduction and patterned so it would fit fully shut. Got to the try on stage and she thought she'd teach me a lesson by lacing it fully shut (thinking it would meet with resistance) and it closed so easily that in the end she did apologise and admitted that I was probably right about what reduction I could handle. But she still muttered about making sure noone else went smaller than 2" reduction.
It made me so angry that she could be spreading such misinformation when she was meant to be one of the experts on historical corsetry. Let alone a teacher. And she had some other questionable choices such as making all the seam allowances a minimum of an inch wide each (she tried to persuade me to do a 2" seam allowance but I didn't want to waste fabric like that). Her insistence on it was because she made corsets as costumes for performances where the same corset would later be altered to fit different people. But it was only ever going to be worn by me because the proportions were just very unlikely to work for anyone else that I knew. And I don't share my corsets. I was so excited to have lessons with someone who was sort of famous in the corsetry world and then just bitterly disappointed when it turned out like that.
I am wondering if in 200 years historians will fight over if Bras are just torture devices?
@@AlexaFaie *Hug*
Excuse me how aCkTuALLy dare you show up with a GORGEOUS neckline like that and not show the full outfit. The pink, the flowers, im dying, im dead.
I am only one ep in to this season but I was surprised to learn they even had them wearing corsets, it seems unnecessary as you say and especially given that it sounds like they are not properly fitted etc!
Yeah, why aren’t they just wearing stays?
Their dresses don't even hug their midriffs, what is literally the point 🧐
I think they made Edwina's fashion more heavily Regency inspired to go along with the fact that she was the diamond of the season. Daphne also tended to wear more pastel Regency gowns and was also a diamond! Visually, it's a great way to show that Edwina embodies what a woman is supposed to be. Characters who don't really fit in, like Eloise and Kate, are given dresses that don't really match history. And then the Featherington girls and Cressida wear absurd colors, unrealistic plastic flowers, crazy hairdos, etc to show that they're trying to overcompensate but still don't meet the standards set. I love that Bridgerton doesn't try to be too realistic with its costumes (or other visual elements), music or stories. Just give me pretty sparkly dresses, violin covers of Taylor Swift, and romance troupes!
I liked how Kate and Edwina's costumes had a lot of Eastern influence to them; the neckline cuts, the colors and sleeve treatments, and the jewelry was also very much what you would see in India, which makes sense for this interpretation of these characters.
Yes, Kate’s sleeves to me seem highly influenced by the Indian blouses that I think are called choli.
@@jaybee4118 It's interesting that they were so short though. Choli blouses (especially those that are in fashion now) have sleeves that are usually a bit longer - either 1/3 or 3/4
I keep seeing ppl saying this and I can see it when I’m reference to the fabrics, jewelry and general design but her dresses just end up looking cheap to me. Maybes it’s because of the structure of the dresses but it just looks modern in a really awkward way to me.
@@darcybhaiwala7057 because it's summer, so they're going for short sleeves I assume, but also probably going for still more of the western look with an Indian feel, so shorter sleeves. I've lived in a very indian area of a British city surrounded by many indian clothing stores and saw many choli with cap sleeves.
I never understood bridgerton as trying to do regency accurately, and tbh I love the costumes. They have issues, but I love how intensely commited to the look and the vibes of mixing history with modern (in the music, the makeup, the costumes, the hair…) they are. Despite this my costume highlights are actually Kate’s light white cotton dressing gowns that look the *most * regency accurate. Wanna make one of those for myself
I thought the same about the cotton gowns! I want all of them.
Yeah it's very sophia coppola gone regency, not historically accurate but still brilliant.
Again, bridgerton is just a fantasy.
I think understanding the mix is huge. They are not going for 100% and I think it works because its bringing this world (regency) up to where the masses can understand it without feeling overwhelmed. My favorite moment has been using the music "thank you, next" for the first ball in season one. because the marriage mart was similar to the themes in that song.
That show shouldn’t try to claim it’s a regency drama or even copy fashion elements, it looks like you’d put white women in geisha outfits and call it a medieval japanese drama, it’s in such poor taste. It’s gaudy as hell costumes-wise and the casting choices are insanely inaccurate. I couldn’t watch it, honestly it’s the worst show netflix put out imo, or at least one of the worst since I haven’t watched everything on Netflix. I normally give everything a try but this, I couldn’t watch past ep 3
Karolina telling us the scoop looking like a delicate butter creme wedding cake.
Interesting conjectures as always :)
I’m definitely not an expert but I think the cocoon-like sleeves on Kate’s dresses are a nod toward traditional Indian clothing. The dress colours too. They fit her characters, balanced between past in India and now being in England.
Her sister on the other hand is trying to fit perfectly into the English society so hers are more “proper debutant” with paler shades and more traditional cuts.
I noticed it too❤
Exactly though they’re trying to mix cultural dresses there
you wear it better than anyone
Of course she would, there's a reason why people from the original era look better and more natural in their respective fashion than the more modern people/j
@@VIII-SANANDACHAKRABORTY wym "/j" she was FROM that era😌
@@darkhairedsiren Oh, sorry, my bad lol, I forgot
Why can't we have a shift? I feel like we aren't asking for much. At this point I'm worried about the actresses skin. After seeing Daphne's bruised and bloody back from the material chafing her skin.
It's the producers who have a say in that. The costume designers don't even get much time to properly measure the actors and get them a good fit, since the producers probably rush them. The producers want their artists to suffer, rather than let them have well fitted costumes, it seems. That's why I can't watch periodic dramas like this, because it's always the same thing; ill-fitted corsets, some cheap material that looks like it came from a Halloween shop, lack of research and pushy producers who just don't seem to care at all. It's tiresome and I grow tired of it. Plus, it only makes people buy more into the same, exhausted trope about how "corsets are bad." It needs to stop. Like, corsets, if fitted properly can work wonders on a person's back and can be comfortable or they could use stays, which work well too. But nope, the ignorant producers won't have that. :'( Also, tl;dr, I agree with your comment about a shift. I feel so bad for the actresses.
oh i thought that was a visual choice to represent how much unseen effort Daphne is putting in to being the diamond/get married
I liked most of them, my main issues are only with two things: daywear and evening wear worn at any time of the day, that bugs me a lot. :'D And ill-fitting costumes, though thankfully there were much less than in the first season. Otherwise, I completely agree, I watch it as fantasy romance. :D
The lack of bonnets and hats really bugged me. Dunno why, but it really did.
yeah this was especially noticeable during the wedding scene where everyone wore....their usual clothes. normally a wedding scene gives to opportunity to dress up the characters in especially pretty clothes, jewelry and decorations but since they were always dressed up like a sparkling christmas tree there really was naught any difference.
So recently I read a lot about regency gothic and it totally changed my mind about a lot of period dramas but Bridgerton especially. During the 1800s a lot of critics were actually just as horrified by the visual arts of the time as many historical enthusiasts are by Bridgerton now. Regency gothic was characterised by this: a time period would be set for a novel/play/painting but then the actual story wouldn't keep up with it at all. One person would be wearing a dress from 1700s, a cloak from 1500s and talk about drinking coffee, all supposedly set in 1200s. It was done on purpose - for aesthetics. It was supposed to create this feeling of something old and nostalgic while also being close enough for the reader so that he could relate to the book/art and believe the events happening there could also happen to him. It influenced fashion as well, especially in the 1810s, they'd add ruffles and lace to everything because even to them it felt vintage and romantic. Regency gothic was ahistorical on purpose to make you feel excited and inspired (fitting for romanticism as well). That's basically what Bridgerton is doing and I have a feeling fans of gothic in the 1800s would absolutely be fans of this series. Nowadays, we have this victorian, purist way of thinking about art recreating history but to be honest - it's art, not a documentary. As long as the artists behind it don't say "we're showing you 100% historical truth here", it really doesn't have to be realistic. It's not even necessarily a failed attempt at recreating history - it's just a completely different genre. So it's ok to just relax and like it without having to feel guilty cause it's not historically accurate or something. It's not attempting to be anyting, it's its own thing.
I really liked the costumes in both seasons! There was an extra wearing a really pretty pink dress that looked like it belonged to late victorian regency nostalgia painting, and they paired it with a modern necklace (from Les Nereides by the look of it), it looked really cute. What's with the corsets though? Not only are they pointless, they make the dresses fit unwell around the bust area. And they're apparently badly fitted since the actresses are in so much pain. You're right, they should just go for some stays/bra combo next time.
i love your take on this!!! so much
Where did you read this? Mainly about regency gothic. Would love to read more / know if it was a certain book
@@immy4098 Jeffrey Nigro wrote several really good articles for Jane Austen Society of North America, he has one on regency gothic! It's called Mystery meets muslin, you can find it online :)
I'm a wig maker and the giant wigs are actually very light! The inside is made of hollow shapers then the hair is draped over top and pinned. Its harder to not hit someone with it than it is on your neck to wear it.
Im not even bothered they're not historically accurate anymore. Its the fact that THEY ALL LOOK THE SAME that bothers me most (also WHY ARE THERE NO HATS)
I need "Shadow and Bone" review from Carolina and how they did Imperial Russia's costumes
because they didn't 😂
the show is still fine though
I need "The Courtship" review.
God, that prom dress she is wearing at the ads made me scream in rage.
@@NankitaBR I watched the show before it was moved off Hulu and it’s strange that the Heroine (I forget her name, Remy j think?) wears modern prom dresses but everyone is somewhat historically accurate. At the very least men are wearing tights and women wear empire waist gowns and bonnets
@@NankitaBR oh I would love her to review the Courtship😂😂
Those are not historically accurate costumes, they are fantasy too. A bit inspired by Russian vibe.
Kate's dresses were beautiful. Their colors reminded me of India. I'm a simple woman and I love the aesthetics of the show (from sets to costumes, etc).
It seems like they also completely let go of all semblance of period makeup too. I was really taken aback by some straight-up red lipsticks.
I saw a lot of beauty guru looks on the dancefloor!
When they met in the library in the middle of the night it took me a moment to realize that she wasn't meant to be in her underwear. I was like WHY ARE THEY NOT MORE SCANDALIZED?? Why is she just roaming about in a shift?
I did appreciate that they actually lowered the waist on Penelope’s dresses to actually be under her bust! The first season was such a travesty for her
in one of the episodes of the 2nd season, when Penelope was at the market in town, I've spotted a maid wearing a BUSTLE. yes, my friends. to be exact, the second era bustle
I don't mind the clothes being historically inaccurate, I just found them a bit ugly.
Same, they looked so cheap with all the plastic decoration..
Yeah, it all felt a bit late 90s/early 00s prom to me. All the bling and intense colors are just not my taste!
The whole fudgeload of bedazzling and plastic flowers? The garish fabrics, the horrible super saturated dyes ? Haven’t watched this new season yet (I didn’t like the last season so I’m not extremely eager ahah) but they look even uglier 💀😅
From the few references to the series I've seen, they do look incredibly cheap and tacky to me.
T A C K Y
I can excuse the shift-less stays, the fenty x savage silk underpants, and the lack of bonnets (this one really hurts tho), but I cannot and absolutely will not let go of the fact that Eloise's hair, was just 2022 modern beach wave with the fringe, I HATE IT. Every time I look at her and everyone around her, the contrast was just jarring, but not in the intended 'she's not like other girl/quirky' way, in an aesthetically unpleasing way.
I have to agree 100% with your assessment.
@@elsagreen1476 not only hair down but also with the 80s wedding hats lol
Bro yes.
I think it was done to show her unwillingness to 'grow up' and start hunting for a husband. In S1 her mother mentions 'how beautiful she will look with her hair up' like Daphne's, i.e., when she makes her first appearance at court as a debutante.
@@JuliesTales I totally understand their intension as in making her more stand out and kinda quirky to suit her character arc atm, but it just visually did not work for me😂It was quite jarring looking at her modern hairstyle with the little hats, it was interesting in concept, but the execution was not there.
Shonda Rhimes has been clear that she's not going for historical accuracy at all, however, the first season had a lot of really bad construction and poor tailoring.
That’s the costume department’s fault, allegedly they didn’t have any time to do any proper fittings and such and you can see a drastic fit difference in season 2, although Kate’s weird square sleeves bother me, just how can she raise her arms?
It’s the aesthetic of a bodice ripping romance novel cover. Absolutely gorgeous and unrealistic. Just need some guys with long Fabio hair.
As a fantasy version of 1814 where racism doesn’t exist, I REALLY wish sexism didn’t exist either, although I realize that many plot points would be impossible, like women being forced to marry a man just because they were in the same room unchaperoned. Homophobia too, but maybe the queen will declare that gay is ok and it can go away just like racism did.
Racism will never go away. Unless you want to have everyone become one big melting pot of humanity.
@@blacktigerpaw1 big melting pot of humanity sounds great to me
@@blacktigerpaw1 on the show, people of all races are at all levels of society and as far as I can remember, race has not been mentioned at all except by the elder duke in a flashback of season 1. So on this show, which is what my comment is about, racism does not exist.
Melting pot of humanity sounds great to me too.
@@ileeeenify It sounds great in practice, it doesn't work in reality. Hence why it's fiction.
@@v1ped Of course it does.
Until you actually experience it.
You can't praise diversity while wanting it all to be a huge melting pot.
honestly, the corset drama with the show is one of the main things keeping me from watching. the fact that we're almost immediately hit with a tightlacing scene (for regency stays???) season one is SUCH a massive turn-off for me. and these reports of injury due to corsets are either due to extreme negligence on the part of the costumers - to the point where I'm completely confused as to HOW they managed to fuck up that badly - or it's all just lies to make a stir in the media
Glad to see I'm not the only one feeling this way.
I definitely think, with Kate's dresses, that they tried to do an Indian inspired/fusion sort of thing because she's a very proud Indian woman! I loved that nod to her heritage.
For sure, it's not supposed to be real-life Regency London. It's an imaginary world where Britain didn't oppress most of the planet and instead had friendly relations with other countries. A world where class society still exists but where the Britain of the time welcomed other cultures openly and integrated people of all races in its society. And where string orchestras play 21st Century pop music.
How's that working out?
@@blacktigerpaw1 Well the show is a success so I'd say pretty well?
It's a fairy tale for adults. Not at all real which makes it so fun.
@@kathleenkalt3852 Exactly. Like watching a Disney movie but for adults
@Alex Kot it’s not it’s actually refreshing
During the entire time I spent watching this season I was already waiting for this commentary video. I was particularly excited to see the thumbnail mention the plastic flowers. I enjoyed tracking the many appearances of floral embellishments in the costumes throughout each episode. I could have made it a drinking game - if I wanted to get very drunk.
This pretty much sums up how I feel about the costumes in “Our Flag Means Death”. It’s historical fanfic, so why not have fun with it.
WAIT are you implying pirates didn't actually wear leather biker jackets and studded belts (on their heads)?!
Bridgerton reminds me of those period movies that were done in the 1960s and 1970s, like BBC's Jane Austen series. The hair, the fabric, the mannerisms were all very 1960/1970.
Persuasion even had that big ass bouffant wig straight out of my grandma’s closet 😂
*Plot twist: The costume designers saw her Bridgerton video from a year ago and made changes.*
The thing that always pops into my head, and I blame Downton, is that only married women wear tiaras. Every single time I see Kate or Edwina wearing one it shoots through my brain and shakes me out of it
I love how amazing your English is and then every once in awhile a vowel goes feral. We all know what you're saying and love hearing you say it. I think you should own it like bridgertons wardrobe owns machine embroidery and saturated colours and not blink or apologize when a vowel slips its leash and goes for a run. 😉
I'm taking a break from writing a midterm right now, and may I PLEASE borrow whatever it is that allowed you to phrase that so elegantly?!!?!? 😭🙏
Aww you're sweet. You'll kick that paper's ass up and down the block until it falls in line. You've got this.
@@erinestes7598 Thank you so much, I'm nearly there!!
@@erinestes7598 Quick update: I was expecting something close to a 90 on the paper, but I actually got a 107 out of 100 somehow!! I blame you! 😹😹
Would love to hear your review of the costumes from The Gilded Age. Is it accurate or a modern interpretation?
It's WAY more realistic, would love to hear Karolina's take though. I highly recommend the video by
Vintagebursche on the men's costumes in Gilded Age! quite quality
@@anomalily wow that's cool, modern or not, the costume are beautiful. Thanks for the recommendation.
I agree!! I just binged that as well and loved the costumes, even if they weren’t all my taste
Mostly inaccurate; there are some that are very close to being historically accurate, but they took a lot of liberties.
@@BiologicalClock True, but at least most of the inaccuracies were intentionally made to denote New Money from Old Money. They weren't done well at all, but they made sense.
I watched Bridgertons in one day, my brain was too slow to notice all details x.x Thank you for the video Karolina
Wait, they made them wear corsets? Why? I was really happy to see the half stays in the show, I assumed that was what they'd opted for throughout cause it would make sense. Kinda disappointed that they made a point to put them in there but didn't legitimately use them in the overall costuming.
As someone who has worn corsets extensively for classical theatre- if it is laced and fitted correctly it should not hurt. It doesn’t leave any more marks on the skin than a modern bra does and honestly it helped my posture and my neck pain from hunching over all the time. You don’t tightlace like they show in movies anymore than you would buy a bra too small on purpose. You also have to remember that the initial tight feeling goes away as you get used to it and that doesn’t mean you need to lace it tighter the next time (hello heartburn) not does it mean you’ve “stretched out” the lacings. 30 minutes of corset safety from any costume shop manager will set the record straight
@@lixak6307 To clarify I have nothing against properly worn and fitted corsetry, I just find it odd that they made a decision not to show them in the show but reportedly used them anyway, and the more bra-like undergarments arewhat would have been worn with the dresses they're wearing. Not that period accuracy's much of a thing, but it's a werid decision to show one thing on screen whilst the actual costumes had completely different undergarments.
@@aqualilac48 no I totally agree! It’s super weird and I’ve not understood the decision either. Maybe it was cheaper to rent a bunch of pre-made corsets? Who knows….
Still shocked about the corset thing it literally makes no sense to make her wear it (specially a bad one) if it's not goibg to make any difference like the dress isn't gonna change either she wears the cirset or not
I'm OBSESSED with the sleeves that look like an upside-down tulip I LOVE THEM
The only thing that really annoys me is that in the world of Brighton there is no race discrimination (which is amazing) and yet weight is still discrimated against.
And there is still sexism against women too
every single time Karolina posts I get so happy, like my entire day brightens. i see one of her videos and i have to rewatch every video on her entire channel afterwards. thank you so much for being literally the most amazing person ever, Karolina. my comfort youtuber
You are so adorable and fun to watch your channel. Outstanding job young lady and thanks for sharing this with us that watch your electrifying talent at work.
kate's color pallet and jewelry had all influence from Indian clothing and jewels and I loved it it shows how she is from another culture and is proud of that, which made her character stand out even more . not historically accurate but kinda amazing and personal for the character, and if we look at anglo Indians historical pictures ,there are lots of intersting combination between Indian traditional dresses and british ones , so a combination of both cultures is not far away from reality
she honestly reminds me of Kitty Kirkpatrick! she was indian-british who lived sometime in the regency era, and was the daughter of Khair un Nissa, an indian noblewoman who married a British colonel.
I thought of your previous video every time I saw a bodice that seemed to be in the right place 😂 I was so happy to see you made another one for season 2!
I had mixed feelings about the costumes last season, but they clicked for me when I saw all the TikToks people made and realised how accessible the aesthetic is. Just put on a satin dress and a tiara and you can get the vibe. I love 2020 Emma but it's very intimidating to me, a person who loves historical fashion, sews, but has never sewn anything historical (except for a very simple 1920s dress). I found myself this season thinking about how I could put together an Eloise inspired look. I feel like I could thrift a lot of it as well!
Are the costumers trying to influence prom dress fashions similar to what “Reign” did?
That was my exact thought. My sister had a prom dress that looked identical to some of these dresses
This is my problem with them. They look...kinda cheap.
If piece of clothing is causing injury to someone, especially when it doesn’t need to be worn in the first place, someone needs to be fired expeditiously
Something about the womens clothing, hair, jewellery this season didn't quite read as regency to me. A few episodes in I realised it was because it reminded me more about the 1910s (I think because of the hairstyles, sleeves and jewellery).
I do enjoy a modern take on period dramas, if they are done well. It is like you said in your review of Bridgerton season 1, if the right silhouette is there you can get away with crazy, modern fabrics and the likes. I just feel like something is a bit off in this one.
That beeing said, I do enjoy Bridgerton in all its' colourful, sparkly grandeur!
Edit: It also triggers me that every woman in the series is like "Oh we need 5 new dresses for tonights ball! No problem, right?" Are the script writers not aware that everything was hand sewn and a dress probably took weeks, if not months to make? 🙈 Rant over!
Also Karolina, you look so lovely!
To be fair with the dresses for tonight, it seems like a lot of them are pre-made then hemmed in which would take less time.
@@emilylewis5373 During most of our fashion history though there were no pre-made clothing. That started showing up during the beginning of the 1900s. Clothing had to be ordered in advance and were made to fit the specific individual for which it was intended. Making a garment from scratch, including taking measurements and cutting pattern pieces, is very time-consuming. It would be near-impossible to make a ballgown in a day even with a modern sewing machine, and in the early 1800s everything was made by hand and hand sewing is time-consuming, even if you are a very skilled seamstress or tailor. I think Karolina points this out in the video she made about season 1, but I am not 100% sure.
Also I am sure Bridgerton is not the only series that does this. t is however very evident as they feature the dress shop quite frequently.
Sorry for the incredibly long answer, I just wanted to explain myself properly 😅
@@cecilialagerstrom46 oh, I know most of history they were not. But the way the show has set up the world it seems to be that way. it seems like all of Genevieve (the dressmakers) clients have standing dresses being made. So all they have to do is a quick finish and adjustments and boom new dress.
@@emilylewis5373 I did not interpret it like that when watching the show, but if that is the case I see your point 😊
You're really fair with your critiques! They get credit for achieving the look they were going for, but maybe they should stop shoving their actresses into ill fitting corsets. If they don't care about accuracy, just wear some spanks and call it good!
I certainly love the colors and the more fantasy aesthetic. Here's hoping that allows for more colorful costumes in these period dramas. The Gilded Age certainly had the actresses in gorgeous dresses that were bright and vibrant. I also kind of loved seeing Mrs. Russell in styles that had a more modern touch because it makes sense for her character being nouveau riche.
I'm loving your look in this video.
The curls framing the face, the colour of the lips and the light blush.
I wish I could look that graceful, instead at the moment I'm more resemblant of a broom that came out if a washing machine 😎
love your channel! Listening to you always brings up my mood and makes my day!
omg i was just rewatching the other video about season 1 😁
Zastanawiam się czy mogłabyś ocenić kostiumy do serialu "Agentka Carter". Próbowałam sama ocenić czy ubrania pasują do czasu akcji serialu ale po poszukiwaniach jestem głupsza niż na początku...
omg yes
We love you, Karolina! Thank you for your commentary---it's enlightening!
I'm an actor and all I want is to be in a big period drama and find out if everyone is just wearing crappy generically-sized corsets or if they're wearing custom ones and just tightlacing the crap out of them. And then set the record straight in interviews about how corsets weren't some weird patriarchal torture device any more than spanx and bras are now.
one thing I did very much appreciate was that, particularly in the "fancier" ball etc scenes, Kate's clothing tended to call to mind cholis later in the series when she was shot from the waist up, due to the colours, cuts, and embellishments used. I thought it was a great choice for character enhancement as she began to change her mind to wanting to maintain her part of India in England rather than returning to the her former home. it's one of the things I love so much about costume: how it can tell part of the story in a language that some can see and understand and many just absorb without knowing they've done so
Thank you for the Review ♥️I needed that today.I loved the old Session more
Great video, I loved the jewel tones introduced for Kate's family. Also, can you share the details on the fabulous lipstick color. I'm obsessed with that pinky rose shade.
I gotta say, Eloise’s “Star Dress” in episode one is a Favorite of mine this season! The outfits are so much fun and you can see how it really creates the world!
Plus within the context of costuming there is so much it does in emphasizing character beats and truly lovely parts of the series!!! Cant wait for season 3!
I should be studying for my philosophy exam, but this video is definitely more important, thanks for making this day and life better than my philosophy class :))
update: I didn't fail the exam wuu
I hear you (should be studying for 9 exams...)
I’m interested in your opinion on the Dickinson shows outfits, a show I absolutely loved and treasured for its empathetic attempts to modernize the teenagers of the period. I can’t remember if you talked about it beyond a brief mention in a previous episode.
Karolina you look so lovely!! I need a hair tutorial!!
I loved how many of Kate Sharma's dresses have the color and sometimes the fabric of saris. I think the mix of both looks great in general, and even greater on Kate. You're seeing her reminiscing about saris without the sari appearing in the picture.
I accidentally watched some Simone Ashleys video and guess what!!! she complained about the corsets! 😂
Karolina looks more Bridgerton than the cast of Bridgeton this season...
Racist af.
@@usri43 Sorry if this sounded wrong, I meant her costume and nothing else...
I watched all of brigerton season 2 this weekend and immediately thought of you, I didn’t think you were gonna make a video on it but I’m so glad that you did because now I now someone understands me
I'm happy you said how it's fantasy. I think I never understood the outrage because I never saw the advertisements, I just watched it for escapism and was confused that anyone could watch a show that had violin covers of modern music and complain about historical inaccuracy as if it was a mistake
I'd love to see a review on the gilded age!
Was thinking about your costume analysis the entire time watching season 2 😅 great video as always!
I'm obsessed with the upper part of your outfit 😍, and truly need to know what the rest looks like >
I was wearing jeans 😊
I do get you on the “fantasy” description. I got that vibe too, that it’s a pretty painting to look at.
I was binge watching the show all day yesterday and all throughout all I could think of was “I wonder what Karolina thinks of this!” Now I know!
Speaking of stays, I believe the ones that bugged me the most would be Penelope's. Whatever they had her wearing was so long on her torso, she had to recline in chairs or stand lest she be drowned in her own bosom.
I agree! She looked massively uncomfortable. All her costumes were so ill-fitting!!
Honestly, I only clicked on this video because you look amazing ✨ and I wanted see the rest of your dress. I haven't seen bridgerton, but I *need* a dress reveal! 🙏🏻
Just finished watching season 2 and immediately opened youtube to watch this right after 😆 Love your take on these ridiculously and wonderfully lavish outfits, always a pleasure to watch your videos 😘
Fun fact from an video editor: everything looks extra saturated.... because it is. Even grass looks plastic neon green 🤣
I normally hate historically inaccurate fashions but for me I don’t care when it comes to Bridgerton it’s a fantasy version of Regency. It all feels deliberate and not sloppy for I can’t help but I love it. Also with queen Charlotte I love that we see a kinky texture at the root of her wigs.
This outfit looks so beautiful on you Karolina!
Love this
Heck yeah, it's great to see you covering Bridgerton again 👏😁
The people in charge of the show's costumes are probably like:
*N O T E D .*
God we hope
You posted!!!! I’m so happy!!
you look so pretty!! you always do but i love this look
I don’t have any insightful comments, you just look really beautiful Karolina.
I don't watch Bridgerton for the same reason I've never seen The Kissing Booth or After. But from what I've seen in this video, the costumes are becoming basically heavily decorated prom dresses?
café man... I commented this on the cover of her channel the "two reasons to watch your channel"...how random!! I LOVED!!!
I love your look (makeup and hair) in this video! And would love to see a tutorial!
I absolutely think of Bridngerton as fantasy. They can do whatever they like with the design and costumes at this point and I hope it'll be lovely.
Bridgerton's costume department whiteboard has only words KITCH and CAMP written in glitter glue (and I'm okay with it)
I wish Karolina would make a video (or at least make comment) about the attires from the ''The King's Daughter'' movie. Because I honestly have no idea what's going on with the fashion there.
Have you heard of the new “dating” show called the courtship? They basically combined something like the bachelor with Bridgerton