@@sanuagarwal8618 Dear Sanu, Nehru made reforms to reduce the power of the army. So the person above is correct. Nehru is the one to thank for our democracy. And when it comes to Nehru's other decisions, I wont claim that everything he did was golden. There were some mistakes but a lot of the foundation of our democracy is owed to him. You must understand the cultural differences between all different Indian states and the pressure to get back all the princely states. Only an exceptional person and an exceptional team can do this. He was an excellent statesman who understood the importance of drafting a constitution as early as possible. Pakistan struggled a lot with constitution and even when it finally drafted one, it couldn't guarantee a democracy independent of army interference and equality. Your prejudice might be due to the anti-Nehru/Gandhi propaganda ran by the current ruling party. They like to boost the Nehru/Gandhi mistakes but never admit to all the great things that happened under the leadership. Always learn to question things and seek answers for yourself. We are a civilization of seekers and learners. Not blind followers.
@@affanzaman6683 we had our issue with army till 1999 and we accept that our army wasn't properly armed and we accept that we lost land to China in 1961.....atleast we can accept that but a islamic neighbour country can't even do that because they know their army is biggest thief of their country where last three retired Generals have settled abroad.....
Excellent interview! Hats off to Mr Ahmed for his honest and straightforward analysis and speaking the straight truth. This is one of the rare channels where you are honest and transparent and truthful. Most Pakistani channels live in la la land and keep harping the Army lies
Not Kargil, but 1965 war was the biggest blunder of Pakistan. In its efforts to grab Kashmir, Pakistan left East Pakistan completely defenseless. This was the spark that led to the civil war and birth of Bangladesh.
@@Hacker776-o2l East Pakistan was discriminated by west pakistani punjabi"s and linguistic divide was apparent. Urdu was imposed on then east Pakistan along with atrocities.
@@vineetraina119 to mai kab bol rha hu ki ye sab nhi hua .. bhai maine bola ki usne 1971 war ke baare me likha hai to tum bina padhe kyu puch rhe ho what about 1971 war.. bss yeh bol rha hu.. ye history maine bhi 8vi mein pdh li
The West destroyed the Soviet Union bymaking the Soviets overspend till it became bankrupt India doesnt need to fight to recuperate Indian territory occupied by Pakistan .Now India is rearming at a higher rate and Pakistan is still taking top slice of Pskistan,s revenues and profuctivity have suffered as investment is dwindling at an alarming rate and the pace Pakistan,s army is milking Pakistan,smeagre revenues the proverbial revenue cow will run dry and Pakistan will disappear like so many failed states(M.Taijah)
India tested its nuclear in response to China's nuclear tests. As China and India both had a conflict not too long ago so it was pretty reasonable for India to give a response to China. Pakistan reacted exrta ordinary.
Kashmir is bread and butter for Pak army so it was not just extra ordinary but extremist way “ghas khyenge par bam banayenge” and literally now fighting for atta. So people of both countries must understand that there will never be good relations between us.don’t waste your valuable time in creating such podcast.
Being and Indian i really enjoyed listening to this. Keep it up. All my ancestors have been in the Army and served India. Unfortunately i could not, but i love reading military history. I had heard that in 1965 Opr Gibraltar and Grandslam were supposed to be a Blitzkrieg offensive into India. Blitz is combined arms warfare where Airforce plays a major role. Then why did they not involve the Air force?
Most people think it was Ishtiaq, but that blunder happened thankfully during the British Raj. Somebody had to demonstrate the worst possible attributes of being born in Lahore. Most are good.
A great video with factual picture (thanks to Dr. Ahmed's research and dedication) about the events that lead to the Kargil fiasco. This video comes on Pandit Nehru's birthday - a man who was one of the greatest statesman of his times. I hope Pakistan and its citizens realize that India has never violated the Radcliff Award unlike Pakistani establishment which has violated the borders many a times that lead to many wars and uncountable skirmishes. India was offended and deeply hurt in 1999 when the heights were illegally captured by Pak Army esp. when our erstwhile PM Late AB Vajpayee jee was visiting Pak and looking for peace in the region.
Major Mohammad Akram , Nishan e Haidar , of Battle of Hilli in the Bangladesh sector was honoured on Indian recommendation. It was said ,' Hilli se Pakistan army nahin hilli. '
Pakistan is still not realizing that it is under undeclared Indian sanctions and declared isolation campaign by India against Pakistan. 77 years of Pakistan's Kashmir policy had literally made it bankrupt but still it is not revising its Kashmir policy which is completely vague and doesn't stand against the India's narrative.
Educate yourself on Siachen! Siachen according to maps was unoccupied. Only thing was a few European tourists used to hike from Pakistan side. India looked at the maps. Pakistan doesn't show those maps😢 anymore. India followed the maps and occupied only a day or so before.
No relations with Pakistan. Enough of this drama. We want absolutely nothing to do with Pakistan. Musharaff had briefed Nawaz, he knew everything . Backstabbers
Regarding Imran khan as an Indian ..apart from his Anti india rants at UN😂 which is but natural ..he is really a fighter .. army helped him to gain power..BUT HE HAS SOME SPINE that he wanted to rule country through People's mandate and NOT THROUGH ARMY DICTUM . INDEED he could be a turning point for pakistan..
I really want to understand what Musharraf’s thoughts were. As a chief of the Pakistan Army he must have thought of (1) Indian might (2) what would be plan-B or C if attack does not go as planned. (3) India is a nuclear bomb carrying country as well. My thoughts: (1) Pakistan Army didn’t think of options B and C. Which can happen only when only idiots were involved in decision making. May be because not many military executives may have been involved. (2) Musharraf might have relied on too much on Quranic thinking. Particularly, battle of Badr. In that battle Mohammad ( original one ) fought a big army of 1000 with his 300 soldiers and won. So Musharraf thought this may happen again because Allah will send for his angels to fight with the Muslim Pakistani Army against the Kafirs. And all the generals involved in decision making might have agreed with the decision. In one interview Musharraf said that, “only when a small army beat a big army then that is worth Bragging about.”
I am glad he is not on main stream media in Pakistan i seriously thought he indian. Yaar aik bhi Pakistani point of view nahi diya is banday nay and host didnt do cross questioning.. is say acha hai mein directly india media daikh laita..waist of time
I hope now the misguided youth of Pakistan understand why their army and by default the Pakistanis are not trusted by anyone.The generals enjoy life and the soldiers are just cannon fodder to them.
Abrogated.. and people are happier with that decision of removing article 370.. now foreign investment flows in and mega projects are built.. chenab bridge which is the highest bridge in asia is in kashmir.. there are highways in the mountainous region now.. now, life is better
There is an army, which has soldiers, arms, equipment and a nation. This army has a nation and name of nation is Pakistan. This army uses everything, i.e. arms, equipment, and nation to terrify everything in and around it. 😂😂
Sir sirf ek mohalle main rahe nahin hai, ek ma ki auladain hain hum. I am also not surprised that india is not involved in Balochistan. Maine US main 2005 main pakistan made bedsheet khareedi thi. Aaj tak rakheen hain, bas yeh sochke ki mere apno ne banayi hain. Samajh sakte ho kabhi aap yeh dil ka dard?
سکولوں اور ہسپتالوں پر پیسہ خرچ کرنا کوئی فائدہ نہیں دینےوالا۔ یہ سرکاری ملازمین ہرگز کام کرنےوالےنہیں۔ ہاں البتہ صحت اور تعلیم میں پرائیویٹ سیکٹر سے کام کروانا چاہیئے۔ جیساکہ صحت کارڈ سکیم۔ گوکہ اس میں مزید بہتری بھی لائی جاسکتی ھے۔
Ishtiaq sahab, pakistan army inhuman nahin ho saktee?? Balochistan main hazaron log gayab hain sir. Ma behne ro rahi hain. Maar maar ke chat pe phenk di lashain. Yeh hai pakistani army. Aaj un logon ki rooh ki hai lag rahi hai sir. Generals aapke yahan ke billions of dollars kha ke europe move kar jate hain. Humare general aisa nahin karte sir.
Lol which war. You guys got your ass kicked on live TV. I assume you guys alsonwom 1971- wow do they teach anything in pakistan other than becoming a mullah or terrorist
Acha chal ye to maaana pahale ki kargil shuru to kiya tha na ,jo army apne soilders ki dead body claim nahi kr sakti wo Indian army ko fall karegi @@KBambaar
Thank god to our Indian army ,
🙏🏽..they never followed Pakistans path and they could have usurped power in the last century. But they never did .
thx to Nehru
@@myspace6862 Nehru? Nehru is reason we lost our army land and respect and financial crises in 1991
@@sanuagarwal8618 Dear Sanu,
Nehru made reforms to reduce the power of the army. So the person above is correct. Nehru is the one to thank for our democracy.
And when it comes to Nehru's other decisions, I wont claim that everything he did was golden. There were some mistakes but a lot of the foundation of our democracy is owed to him. You must understand the cultural differences between all different Indian states and the pressure to get back all the princely states. Only an exceptional person and an exceptional team can do this. He was an excellent statesman who understood the importance of drafting a constitution as early as possible. Pakistan struggled a lot with constitution and even when it finally drafted one, it couldn't guarantee a democracy independent of army interference and equality.
Your prejudice might be due to the anti-Nehru/Gandhi propaganda ran by the current ruling party. They like to boost the Nehru/Gandhi mistakes but never admit to all the great things that happened under the leadership.
Always learn to question things and seek answers for yourself. We are a civilization of seekers and learners. Not blind followers.
@@sanuagarwal8618Lost our army land when was you army deployed there😂😂? .?
@@affanzaman6683 we had our issue with army till 1999 and we accept that our army wasn't properly armed and we accept that we lost land to China in 1961.....atleast we can accept that but a islamic neighbour country can't even do that because they know their army is biggest thief of their country where last three retired Generals have settled abroad.....
Excellent interview! Hats off to Mr Ahmed for his honest and straightforward analysis and speaking the straight truth. This is one of the rare channels where you are honest and transparent and truthful. Most Pakistani channels live in la la land and keep harping the Army lies
Not Kargil, but 1965 war was the biggest blunder of Pakistan.
In its efforts to grab Kashmir, Pakistan left East Pakistan completely defenseless. This was the spark that led to the civil war and birth of Bangladesh.
😅😂 What about the 1971 war?
@@vineetraina119bhai pura comment to padle.. usne 1971 ki hi baat ki hai aage😂
@@Hacker776-o2l East Pakistan was discriminated by west pakistani punjabi"s and linguistic divide was apparent. Urdu was imposed on then east Pakistan along with atrocities.
@@Hacker776-o2l Geographically too then east Pakistan was too far off from west pakistani.
@@vineetraina119 to mai kab bol rha hu ki ye sab nhi hua .. bhai maine bola ki usne 1971 war ke baare me likha hai to tum bina padhe kyu puch rhe ho what about 1971 war.. bss yeh bol rha hu.. ye history maine bhi 8vi mein pdh li
After Kargil war, the India -Isreal partnership solidified. Good for India.🎉
If it was India china war Israel would have never helped India. Find the reason why? 😂.
The West destroyed the Soviet Union bymaking the Soviets overspend till it became bankrupt India doesnt need to fight to recuperate Indian territory occupied by Pakistan .Now India is rearming at a higher rate and Pakistan is still taking top slice of Pskistan,s revenues and profuctivity have suffered as investment is dwindling at an alarming rate and the pace Pakistan,s army is milking Pakistan,smeagre revenues the proverbial revenue cow will run dry and Pakistan will disappear like so many failed states(M.Taijah)
What a professional army
Who disowned its own dead soldiers
But they are never ashmed of their own army actions
India tested its nuclear in response to China's nuclear tests. As China and India both had a conflict not too long ago so it was pretty reasonable for India to give a response to China. Pakistan reacted exrta ordinary.
Kashmir is bread and butter for Pak army so it was not just extra ordinary but extremist way “ghas khyenge par bam banayenge” and literally now fighting for atta. So people of both countries must understand that there will never be good relations between us.don’t waste your valuable time in creating such podcast.
Rogue Pakistan 🇵🇰 Army
Being and Indian i really enjoyed listening to this. Keep it up. All my ancestors have been in the Army and served India. Unfortunately i could not, but i love reading military history. I had heard that in 1965 Opr Gibraltar and Grandslam were supposed to be a Blitzkrieg offensive into India. Blitz is combined arms warfare where Airforce plays a major role. Then why did they not involve the Air force?
Most people think it was Ishtiaq, but that blunder happened thankfully during the British Raj. Somebody had to demonstrate the worst possible attributes of being born in Lahore. Most are good.
Jio aur jine do. this is hindu philosophy about all creatures.
A brilliant presentation , as usual , by Dr Ishtiaq Ahmed.. on Kargil -1999 .
A great video with factual picture (thanks to Dr. Ahmed's research and dedication) about the events that lead to the Kargil fiasco. This video comes on Pandit Nehru's birthday - a man who was one of the greatest statesman of his times. I hope Pakistan and its citizens realize that India has never violated the Radcliff Award unlike Pakistani establishment which has violated the borders many a times that lead to many wars and uncountable skirmishes. India was offended and deeply hurt in 1999 when the heights were illegally captured by Pak Army esp. when our erstwhile PM Late AB Vajpayee jee was visiting Pak and looking for peace in the region.
R&AW tapped Musraf's call 🇮🇳
Major Mohammad Akram , Nishan e Haidar , of Battle of Hilli in the Bangladesh sector was honoured on Indian recommendation. It was said ,' Hilli se Pakistan army nahin hilli. '
You are an excellent host, keep it up! Very good interview !
Musharraf also was presented with beheaded soldiers heads.
Pakistan is still not realizing that it is under undeclared Indian sanctions and declared isolation campaign by India against Pakistan. 77 years of Pakistan's Kashmir policy had literally made it bankrupt but still it is not revising its Kashmir policy which is completely vague and doesn't stand against the India's narrative.
Educate yourself on Siachen! Siachen according to maps was unoccupied. Only thing was a few European tourists used to hike from Pakistan side. India looked at the maps. Pakistan doesn't show those maps😢 anymore. India followed the maps and occupied only a day or so before.
Very logical and balanced analysis.
No relations with Pakistan. Enough of this drama. We want absolutely nothing to do with Pakistan. Musharaff had briefed Nawaz,
he knew everything . Backstabbers
No cricket no trade no relati9ns
Foreign policy is controlled by Pakistan army not politicians
Regarding Imran khan as an Indian ..apart from his Anti india rants at UN😂 which is but natural ..he is really a fighter .. army helped him to gain power..BUT HE HAS SOME SPINE that he wanted to rule country through People's mandate and NOT THROUGH ARMY DICTUM .
INDEED he could be a turning point for pakistan..
I really want to understand what Musharraf’s thoughts were. As a chief of the Pakistan Army he must have thought of (1) Indian might (2) what would be plan-B or C if attack does not go as planned. (3) India is a nuclear bomb carrying country as well.
My thoughts: (1) Pakistan Army didn’t think of options B and C. Which can happen only when only idiots were involved in decision making. May be because not many military executives may have been involved.
(2) Musharraf might have relied on too much on Quranic thinking. Particularly, battle of Badr. In that battle Mohammad ( original one ) fought a big army of 1000 with his 300 soldiers and won. So Musharraf thought this may happen again because Allah will send for his angels to fight with the Muslim Pakistani Army against the Kafirs. And all the generals involved in decision making might have agreed with the decision.
In one interview Musharraf said that, “only when a small army beat a big army then that is worth Bragging about.”
Excellent Analysis by Dr Ishtiaq Ahmed as always!
Realy great podcast ❤
Thanks for listening
Loved his Jinnah and partition episode! Looking forward to this one
Kindly give a brief introduction of speaker before starting the podcast
You’re right! Will keep that in mind for the future.
He’s been on before as well. He’s a scholar, analyst and author.
Thanks
Let us know if you want more content like this!
Do a video on how Pakistani army's hold can be broken in pakistan..and made subservient to Citizens
Yes, please make a video on old cities of pakistan.
@@VidhyaDevi-dj6fwthat’s a great idea 🙏🙏
I am glad he is not on main stream media in Pakistan i seriously thought he indian. Yaar aik bhi Pakistani point of view nahi diya is banday nay and host didnt do cross questioning.. is say acha hai mein directly india media daikh laita..waist of time
Kargil top peaks still Pakistani control since 1999
Point 5353
Point Aftab
Yes.
Source:: Pakistan Studies😂😂
Think 🤔.. use your brain … dont dumb yourselves with fake narrative from the hate mongering PakiArmy
@@guruaus2659 asmani kitab
😅😅😅
I hope now the misguided youth of Pakistan understand why their army and by default the Pakistanis are not trusted by anyone.The generals enjoy life and the soldiers are just cannon fodder to them.
India took over Juna garah . Hyderabad.
Iok is an integral part of Pakistan. But still they imposed article 370
Abrogated.. and people are happier with that decision of removing article 370.. now foreign investment flows in and mega projects are built.. chenab bridge which is the highest bridge in asia is in kashmir.. there are highways in the mountainous region now.. now, life is better
There is an army, which has soldiers, arms, equipment and a nation. This army has a nation and name of nation is Pakistan. This army uses everything, i.e. arms, equipment, and nation to terrify everything in and around it. 😂😂
All countries have their army but only army in the world which has a Nation, This Army Has nation name Pakistan.
Ab bhi agar samazh nahi aata to bhai Pakistan to already vad gaya hua hai.
Baba ji.. Pakistan is committing blunders everyday.
Fazool Podcast.
wrong information.
Great choice of guest
🙌
Northern Light Infantry
Brilliant analysis by Dr Istiaq Ahmed. His understanding and judicious narrative can be used as reference. Hope people lesrn.😊
audio poor.
आप किसी चैनल के बुलाए के मोहताज नहीं जय भारत
Sir sirf ek mohalle main rahe nahin hai, ek ma ki auladain hain hum. I am also not surprised that india is not involved in Balochistan. Maine US main 2005 main pakistan made bedsheet khareedi thi. Aaj tak rakheen hain, bas yeh sochke ki mere apno ne banayi hain. Samajh sakte ho kabhi aap yeh dil ka dard?
پاکستان کی نہی فوجیوں کی بدمعاشی
سکولوں اور ہسپتالوں پر پیسہ خرچ کرنا کوئی فائدہ نہیں دینےوالا۔ یہ سرکاری ملازمین ہرگز کام کرنےوالےنہیں۔ ہاں البتہ صحت اور تعلیم میں پرائیویٹ سیکٹر سے کام کروانا چاہیئے۔ جیساکہ صحت کارڈ سکیم۔ گوکہ اس میں مزید بہتری بھی لائی جاسکتی ھے۔
کیا پہلے بھارت نے کارگل کی پوزیشنز کو مستقل نہیں کیا تھا ؟
Rational analysis
Pakistan is nothing but North korea part 2
ڈاکٹر اب پاکستانی نہیں۔
I consider this an intellectual dishonesty by not sharing the fact that it was India who violated the Simla agreement by occupying the glaciers.
As it Pakistan was following it by issuing mountaineering passes to foreigners into a disputed territory without consulting/informing India ?
Pakistan ke karan aaj SAARC khatam ho gaya. Waise yeh Shayan moderator humare purane hero Joy Mukherjee jaisa dikhta hai 😂❤
thank you sir
There is no time in history when pak made any progress or had development.
Good sir ❤
Ishtiaq sahab, pakistan army inhuman nahin ho saktee?? Balochistan main hazaron log gayab hain sir. Ma behne ro rahi hain. Maar maar ke chat pe phenk di lashain. Yeh hai pakistani army. Aaj un logon ki rooh ki hai lag rahi hai sir. Generals aapke yahan ke billions of dollars kha ke europe move kar jate hain. Humare general aisa nahin karte sir.
R&AW tappped the phone call of Mushraff .
Indians kareeb 527 mare gaye they kargil main.
عمران خان نے پاکستان کو کوئی ایسا نقصان جو نہیں پہنچایا؟؟؟
Aur jab Nuclear test hua I was in Pakistan
A bunch of converts fighting a genuine civilisation.
Stupid guest is placing totally distorted Facts...
Bofor guns? Dallay listen to GD Bakshi. He is saying totaaly opposite. LT gen Karishanpal stated that he is not convinced that India ever won the war
Lol which war. You guys got your ass kicked on live TV. I assume you guys alsonwom 1971- wow do they teach anything in pakistan other than becoming a mullah or terrorist
Is krishanpal some God? Don’t write some rubbish have some sense.
@holywarrior5719 He took over when GD Bakshi ran away 🤣 😂
Very true
Bum baar that’s your name
I met Indian Col in US who took part in Kargil. He stated that agar US interve na karta tau kargil mein Indian army fall kar gaye thee
😂😂😂 fool’s paradise
Ya,according to Pakistani studies 😅😅😅
@avinashvarma108 I am not talking about godi media that every Indian believes
@@KBambaarohh really, then believe in your Pakistani media which is controlled by your proud establishment 😅😅😅
Acha chal ye to maaana pahale ki kargil shuru to kiya tha na ,jo army apne soilders ki dead body claim nahi kr sakti wo Indian army ko fall karegi @@KBambaar
Loved his Jinnah and partition episode! Looking forward to this one
Jinnah did a great job of cleaning India of these Muslim monsters