I came across this song when I was in Hetalia fandom. l never actually listened to it with full attention, until I found this video. The funny thing is, I watched it after completing Oliver Twist series. It was a strange feeling.
I'm so conflicted about this because it's so good but knowing what the original lyrics are about I don't want to associate Flutters with that Send help
What's the reading you've been given about the song? There's been no officially-stated meaning to the lyrics, and my readings of them are usually to do with struggling with depression or mental disability.
Dee Cross There's also the whole bit about wanting to "stop her breath", which ... I guess could /not/ be a reference to suicide, but seems very suggestive.
Filay Minion the original song is about a girl who is sad about her life in this world. Being nothing, just a another face in the crowd. she got tired of it. The line 'I can stop breathing now' is strongly hinted that she died in the end. My explanation may not make sense. I found out about it on Akidearest's channel she has a list called '5 songs that change the way you see Vocaloid' that where I got the explanation.
The Minus Kai It is; in essence, the original song is about a girl who is abused/bullied and often uses the term “rolling” to refer to her going on for another day. In the original, a boy is used as the Rolling Girl’s inner conscience of sorts, a representation of her depression. Rolling Girl is considering suicide as an option, and, in the end, the final couple of lines allude to the representation of her depression stopping her breathing, meaning her succumbing to it and ultimately following through. The song can be seen as open ended, but most agree that the very end of the song means that the Rolling Girl has committed suicide in some way or another.
There are also a few hints in the song. 息を止める translates to ‘stop breathing’ but it could just be holding a breath. The bigger hint is ‘呟いて’ which means to whisper versus at the end of the song with ‘呟いた’ which means whispered
When I first joined to brony fandom I remember watching this video almost daily. I still enjoy it and even prefer it to the original music video, and every time I watch I get bought back to a much happier time of my life. This is probably my favorite video to come out of the brony fandom. After years of watching this video I just wanted to comment thank you for making this. It has truly left an impact on my life as a whole.
Oh my god... This is utterly stunning. I'm not a Brony/Pegasister in any way, but I am quite the Vocaliod fan. This reminds me of Hetaliod (I'm a Hetalian, and a proud one), using only the audio from the show you managed to too have her sing. This is amazingly done.
Me neither. Mostly, I applaud this person for all the effort she went to it. They took the effort to actually extract her voice, edit out the music, tweak them into samples of an ENTIRE OTHER LANGUAGE and remake an ENTIRE SONG USING IT. Now that I see they can do longer sounds, this person essentially just invented Pony vocaloids, and maybe opened a world of other sample-based vocaloids.
Borto I think the only thing I have against it is that putting this character in the song kind of ignores the original meaning of the song, which was a big part of the song, but all the work put in it is great!
This is beyond amazing and creative, I mean mixing Fluttershy's lines to fit the vocals for rolling girl? I can't imagine how much time and effort this took
I don't care if ponies or not...The amount of effort and work that went into this are ASTOUNDING to say the very least. Seriously. How much heart did you put into this? It's amazing!
This was very well made! The music makes my ears melt and the animation is simply to die for. Oh and Fluttershy is now a vocaloid that kinda cool I guess.
yo i used to love this show, and like 5 years later i just stumbled upon the original rolling girl and thought it sounded familiar and the. i saw this in the recommended and - i remember everything bro WHAT
wow.......making every syllables to a word must have been a hard work to do it...I wish that Fluttershy will be a part of an UTAU family... and your work is excellent! I've seen many versions of Rolling girl MV but your version is great...the singer and the video... :3
For this version (which I never knew I'd ever see) of Rolling Girl, it seems to be about the rise of Fluttershy. It shows her overcoming her fears. For the original version of Rolling Girl (spelt "Rollin'Girl"), it's about how young Miku is bullied and possibly abused and eventually her depression gets the better of her and she commits suicide. I'll let that sink in for a moment.
furattaa gaaru wa itsu mademo todokanai yume mite sawagu atama no naka wo kaki mawashite, kaki mawashite "mondai nai" to tsubuyaite kotoba wa ushinawareta? wait for me, wait for me machigai sagashi ni owareba mata mawaru no mou ikkai, mou ikkai watashi wa kyou mo habataki masu to shoujo wa iu, shoujo wa iu kotoba ni imi wo kanade nagara madamada saki wa mienai node iki wo tomeru no ima furattaa gaaru no nare no hate todokanai, mukou no niji kasanaru koe to koe wo mazeawasete, mazeawasete "mondai nai" to tsubuyaita kotoba wa ushinawareta dou nattatte iindatte sa machigai datte okoshichaou to sasou aozora mou ikkai, mou ikkai watashi wo douka mimamotte to shoujo wa iu, shoujo wa iu mukuchi ni imi wo kasane nagawa mousugu nanika mieru darou to iki wo tomeru no ima mou ikkai, mou ikkai watashi wa kyou mo habataki masu to shoujo wa iu, shoujo wa iu kotoba ni emi wo kanade nagara mou iikai? mou iiyo sorosoro kimi mo tukaretarou ne hane wo tatamu no ima
I AM JUST LOVING BRONIES RIGHT NOW! Every day im just watching videos and then i stumble upon a channel like this and BAM i fall in love with what ever im watching. Good job u earned a sub. Brohoof /)
This video is just so nice! And Flutterdash aside is still a beautiful reminder of how far Fluttershy's come and what she's achieved since the show's beginning with the help and support of her friends. ...heh, after all my denial I'm as proud of her as the rest of the fandom undoubtedly is! ^_^
This was kinda awesome actually. Nice work on the animation and music! And - for those - like me - who didn't notice that there are english subtitles in the captitions .. well, there are, heh. Now, to rewatch it with subtitles! Again though, awesome video ;)
im both of a vocaloid fan and a brony, i watched both this and rolling girl. I love them both, but i think i liove tjis just 15% percent better. You worked hard for this, Great job!
Shiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiet. How much effort can you bring into just one video? Great recreation of the original and twist of it, too. If there were stars, you'd deserve all 5 of them.
I'm not even a fan of My Little Pony, but the level of effort that went into this is impressive.
FUCKIN GOD LIKE EFFORT YO MEAN XD
Yeah.
Right?
he probably took 2 weeks doin this cuz he is an expert
well i will recreate this and itll probably took 2 years for me
yeah me to
Funny thing is, this was the first version of Rolling Girl I've ever heard. xD
same!
+Lobie5 yeah, mother of god how deeply in love I fell with it and later vocaloids
+Lobie5 i saw vocaloid first
lol me too
I came across this song when I was in Hetalia fandom. l never actually listened to it with full attention, until I found this video. The funny thing is, I watched it after completing Oliver Twist series. It was a strange feeling.
I'm so conflicted about this because it's so good but knowing what the original lyrics are about I don't want to associate Flutters with that
Send help
What's the reading you've been given about the song? There's been no officially-stated meaning to the lyrics, and my readings of them are usually to do with struggling with depression or mental disability.
Apparently (in most translations I've seen) rolling is a term for self-harm?
Apple's Life Secrets This is one that's new to me, but it does work. I can see why you don't want Fluttershy attached to that.
Dee Cross
There's also the whole bit about wanting to "stop her breath", which ... I guess could /not/ be a reference to suicide, but seems very suggestive.
Filay Minion the original song is about a girl who is sad about her life in this world. Being nothing, just a another face in the crowd. she got tired of it. The line 'I can stop breathing now' is strongly hinted that she died in the end. My explanation may not make sense. I found out about it on Akidearest's channel she has a list called '5 songs that change the way you see Vocaloid' that where I got the explanation.
I forgot how truly creative some people on YT used to be. Nobody makes anything as creative as this nowadays.
This shit still holds up. I remember being obsessed with it
I can actually see fluttershy fitting this song.
Rolling girl is about a girl pushed to suicide, and I really feel she fits the song.
Eek
nonsensicaldreamer/just-4-teh-lulz holy fuck
Wait this is about suicide? Holy fucking shit dude
The Minus Kai
It is; in essence, the original song is about a girl who is abused/bullied and often uses the term “rolling” to refer to her going on for another day. In the original, a boy is used as the Rolling Girl’s inner conscience of sorts, a representation of her depression. Rolling Girl is considering suicide as an option, and, in the end, the final couple of lines allude to the representation of her depression stopping her breathing, meaning her succumbing to it and ultimately following through. The song can be seen as open ended, but most agree that the very end of the song means that the Rolling Girl has committed suicide in some way or another.
There are also a few hints in the song.
息を止める translates to ‘stop breathing’ but it could just be holding a breath.
The bigger hint is ‘呟いて’ which means to whisper versus at the end of the song with ‘呟いた’ which means whispered
When I first joined to brony fandom I remember watching this video almost daily. I still enjoy it and even prefer it to the original music video, and every time I watch I get bought back to a much happier time of my life. This is probably my favorite video to come out of the brony fandom. After years of watching this video I just wanted to comment thank you for making this. It has truly left an impact on my life as a whole.
To me it sounds like lots the sounds and words Fluttershy makes is broken down into parts and put into the song. If that's the case its genius.
It is.
+Lia the Grey wolf I KNEW IT
MOVING CHANNELS no it isn’t look at the description yes a vocaloid
Janyah Murrpet ...thats how vocaloid works lmao
Vocaloid + MLP = My happiness
Such tiny face. XD
AMEN!!!!
REAL
IS THIS IS FREAKING FLUTTERSHY UTAU?
This is amazing!!
Yeah!
Who's that?
@@ayegofelix223 ruclips.net/video/HaV4YPU7bWs/видео.html
I hate that I love this. Brand new respect for MLP fans.
Wat? ·~·
You can choose on what part of the fandom you focus, i for once have decided to focus on this talented side, you can do the same
3 years ago i grew out of ponies, i was bored and came back for one song. And get blasted by nostalgia
It doesn't if you can't understand it or not, it's the emotions that it conveys through the notes and the voice.
The visuals really tell a story, even though I don't speak Japanese.
+jeramahia123 theres a closed captions button that translates the video into english :]
+Ashley Benzen but i'm on mobile :(
+Cindy Le my mobile still shows captions?
+Raven Jay I've figured it out a month ago it's fine now
Here comes the ship..... HERE COME THE SHIP....... FLUTTERDASH COMFIRMED!
xD
Or "RainbowShy"
.....NO
-starts slapping- iTS FLUTTAHJACK (in my opinion :P)
+Skythegamerfox this has nothing to do with Apple jack. it's rainbow and flutter
Usui Takumi She says that she prefers FluttahJack v:
1:12 aww she sounds so cute
At least it had a happier ending than the original (I think).
Agree (・Д・)ノ
+Vutava Than the original? :0
i dont understand why this doesnt have over 1M views
Back here after years.
😔👉👈
Same.
This is so awesome, there is so much effort put into this
Parnas1us, you GOTTA COME BACK! We miss your awesome videos!
bgbl
I can vividly remember watching this back in 2015 while eating peanuts
Oh my god... This is utterly stunning. I'm not a Brony/Pegasister in any way, but I am quite the Vocaliod fan. This reminds me of Hetaliod (I'm a Hetalian, and a proud one), using only the audio from the show you managed to too have her sing. This is amazingly done.
Can’t believe Flutterloid is 8 years old.
OH SHIT THE NOSTALGIA
Que haces aca xd?
@@Xx_Ak4emy_xX y tu tmb q haces aca
As a fan of both MLP and Vocaloid, this is a beautiful crossover! I hope you are proud with the result, because it's amazing!
Fluttershy is now a Vocaloid. Yes. - Deal with it Brony-hating-Vocaloid-fans! -
ROCK ON, FLUTTERLOID! /)
I agree flutterloid is cool
Stephon Tungsten If you really think so, why did you come to this video in the first place? (there we go again... I hope not btw.)
Milly "Tailey" Prower the fox agree
I mean c'mon, why go to a video that includes TWO things ya dislike. That's just plain weird right?
DANG IT THIS PMV WAS SO GOOD IT MADE ME CRY!!
same
I'm not a brony but this is so... i don't know how to express.
Me neither. Mostly, I applaud this person for all the effort she went to it. They took the effort to actually extract her voice, edit out the music, tweak them into samples of an ENTIRE OTHER LANGUAGE and remake an ENTIRE SONG USING IT. Now that I see they can do longer sounds, this person essentially just invented Pony vocaloids, and maybe opened a world of other sample-based vocaloids.
i don't know how to express²
Borto I know, this is just so awesome...Like the original song could not be deep and awesome enough...
Borto I think the only thing I have against it is that putting this character in the song kind of ignores the original meaning of the song, which was a big part of the song, but all the work put in it is great!
these things you make have no right being this good
THIS IS IMPRESSING
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
AND DEPRESSING
This is beyond amazing and creative, I mean mixing Fluttershy's lines to fit the vocals for rolling girl? I can't imagine how much time and effort this took
Thank You for All, Wowaka /)
I don't care if ponies or not...The amount of effort and work that went into this are ASTOUNDING to say the very least.
Seriously. How much heart did you put into this? It's amazing!
This was very well made! The music makes my ears melt and the animation is simply to die for. Oh and Fluttershy is now a vocaloid that kinda cool I guess.
Although I don't LOVE My Little Pony, this literally blew my mind away. Adding this to my iPod for sure.
This is the video that introduced me to Vocaloid, and therefore indirectly to anime. Thank you!!!
yo i used to love this show, and like 5 years later i just stumbled upon the original rolling girl and thought it sounded familiar and the. i saw this in the recommended and - i remember everything bro WHAT
This was the first version of rolling girl I heard, I admit it. Like this for no reason? X3
Literally the best thing to come out of the fandom yet. I mean this is just incredible on multiple levels.
wow.......making every syllables to a word must have been a hard work to do it...I wish that Fluttershy will be a part of an UTAU family...
and your work is excellent!
I've seen many versions of Rolling girl MV but your version is great...the singer and the video... :3
Luna's moon, I'm speechless at how awesome this is. Great job. AMAZING job.
WHY IS THIS MUSIC SO DEPRESSING?!
Yeah... i know how you feel.
Fantastic quality as always parnas1us. Glad to see you're still challenging yourself. :) Can't wait to see what's next haha
I’m still here.
My first PMV ever. Saw it right after watching season 3 episode 10. it has a special place in my heart .
For this version (which I never knew I'd ever see) of Rolling Girl, it seems to be about the rise of Fluttershy. It shows her overcoming her fears.
For the original version of Rolling Girl (spelt "Rollin'Girl"), it's about how young Miku is bullied and possibly abused and eventually her depression gets the better of her and she commits suicide.
I'll let that sink in for a moment.
The amount of effort put into this is just amazing!
This is so kickass I can't contain myself
This deserves much more views! Rolling Girl is an awesome song and now you made it to Flutter Girl.. This is best idea.
furattaa gaaru wa itsu mademo
todokanai yume mite
sawagu atama no naka wo
kaki mawashite, kaki mawashite
"mondai nai" to tsubuyaite
kotoba wa ushinawareta?
wait for me, wait for me
machigai sagashi ni owareba
mata mawaru no
mou ikkai, mou ikkai
watashi wa kyou mo habataki masu to
shoujo wa iu, shoujo wa iu
kotoba ni imi wo kanade nagara
madamada saki wa mienai node
iki wo tomeru no ima
furattaa gaaru no nare no hate
todokanai, mukou no niji
kasanaru koe to koe wo
mazeawasete, mazeawasete
"mondai nai" to tsubuyaita
kotoba wa ushinawareta
dou nattatte iindatte sa
machigai datte okoshichaou to
sasou aozora
mou ikkai, mou ikkai
watashi wo douka mimamotte to
shoujo wa iu, shoujo wa iu
mukuchi ni imi wo kasane nagawa
mousugu nanika mieru darou to
iki wo tomeru no ima
mou ikkai, mou ikkai
watashi wa kyou mo habataki masu to
shoujo wa iu, shoujo wa iu
kotoba ni emi wo kanade nagara
mou iikai? mou iiyo
sorosoro kimi mo tukaretarou ne
hane wo tatamu no ima
Kenji Okabe what
+Arlene Cardona Lyrics...
Alright, time to memorize.
RIP four hours of my life.
Well shit. I'm speechless yet again. This is really outstanding!
Still thinking about how this video introduced me to vocaloid and Wowakas music :(
Considering what the original is about, this is really good!
i'm not a huge fan of MLP, but this was the one song that got me to love Volcaloid.
It's been so long since I first watched this video, and it still melts my heart every time I watch it.
So..I'm pretty sure this video was named ''Untitled'' when it first came out.. I swear I remember it that way..
That video is so impressive! All this work, this is just mind blowing! I'll be looking to your future projects! :D
MIKU AND FLUTTERSHY!!!
XD COOL
Just brilliant! You combined two of my favorite things
We need more of THIS in the fandom.
I AM JUST LOVING BRONIES RIGHT NOW! Every day im just watching videos and then i stumble upon a channel like this and BAM i fall in love with what ever im watching. Good job u earned a sub. Brohoof /)
This video is 5 years old.
it is now 11 years now...
@@prettyghostykitten what how
This was literally how I discovered vocaloid and became a fan. Thanks mlp!
ever thought of making one of fluttershy and the song circus monster?
since I can't make such videos...
I love the gothic styling of this! It's so awesome!
Fluttershy is my fav pony xD
Wow, this looks like it was insanely hard to make. Brilliant job :D
who is watching in 2016?
me
me
me
me
I don't know only hundreds of people
I love this, as the song perfectly describes Fluttershy. And her voice just makes a beautiful voicebank~
I'm baaaack.
You get everywhere don't you? lol
Jack Girdlestone We have only always been in the comment section of someone else's video.
Words cannot describe this.
I love it so much.
mikushy.
This video is just so nice! And Flutterdash aside is still a beautiful reminder of how far Fluttershy's come and what she's achieved since the show's beginning with the help and support of her friends. ...heh, after all my denial I'm as proud of her as the rest of the fandom undoubtedly is! ^_^
+TheNoobofHearts um you might not wanna say "flutterdash" cuz tht means you ship them :/
Ashley Benzen Yeeeeeeah no... not a fan of that!
I just assumed Flutterdash was what the video was getting at here.
TheNoobofHearts ok just letting you know
This was kinda awesome actually. Nice work on the animation and music!
And - for those - like me - who didn't notice that there are english subtitles in the captitions .. well, there are, heh.
Now, to rewatch it with subtitles!
Again though, awesome video ;)
I FUCKING LOVE FLUTTERSHY!!!!!!!!!!
im both of a vocaloid fan and a brony, i watched both this and rolling girl. I love them both, but i think i liove tjis just 15% percent better. You worked hard for this, Great job!
I just relized that this was an mlp version of Hatsune Miku's song called "Rolling Girl".
¦I
+that one idiot your name suits that comment
-______-
The annual migration of text whales is underway.
That is some incredible editing. Good job.
I thought of making a flutter shy voice bank for people to play around with:3
Love it, and the text is beautiful too
Better than the original! :D
Watching this feels like looking in a mirror of my life. Thanks for making this, and thanks to Rainbow Dash for showing me how to fly.
bro/girl YOU NEED TO MAKE A ANIME ABOUT MLP
SWEETY BELL: COME ON
Parnas, you are officially the best sentence mixer I've ever seen. Stahp being so beautiful dammit. XD
mYHEARTOMFG
This is by far your best video
bettah dan real rollinggirl
Shiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiet.
How much effort can you bring into just one video?
Great recreation of the original and twist of it, too.
If there were stars, you'd deserve all 5 of them.
Omg this is so cute and awesome!! Great job!!
This is amazing! Keep up the good work.
congratsfor 12k subs!! I was the 12k sub :3
wow this is some SERIOUS effort to make
i know i could NEVER do something like this
i hope this makes it to the front page
:DDDDD
I know the original lyrics and this doesn’t fit Fluttershy
Still this is amzing
IM ASTOUNDED THIS IS
WHY DOES THIS EXIST
this is the best thing i have seen ALL WEEK
Two my lovely fandoms in one video, OMG, it's possible, thaaaaaank you 3
Rolling Girl was Already depressing and now Rolling Girl with Fluttershy?! Amazing work, please keep it up, thank you.
I love it. It brings my two favorite things together vocaloids and mlp fantastic. Great video.
And now the video that got me into Vocaloid..