Sense of honor was overwhelming in this scene. I really felt bad seeing those enemy ships go down with such loyal crew. Domel was a noble character who was just a pawn in the game but at least he knew it.
I HATE when they sing in anime. But this so glorious, so fitting, so GOOD. It perfectly describe militaristic ways of Garmillons. And it shows that "bad guys" ar not a mindless monsters. Best anime 2012/2013.
They aren’t really bad guys, they are only fighting for their cause. When looking further into this, you would actually find the Gamillans under Domel being very honourable and rational (not you Berger), they respected the Yamato’s fighting prowess, hell when Domel lost to it he even wished Yamato luck! But the song really is good, it shows just how loyal the Gamillans are to their cause, it shows their militaristic ways.
@@HomeCookOtaku2003 do you know that Berger fight with Yamato together later? No im not talking the 2202 version, im talking about the movie that takes place betwen ep 24 and 25. It was the first time Yamato fight with a fleet and the first time Gamilas and Earth figh together against Gatlantis
I love how you can watch the change of attitude and the absolute pride swelling in the officers as they join in with the junior crew they were denigrating only a moment before. The common bond of warriors.
I strongly believe that this is an Easter Egg refering to the scene from the film : Battle of the Bulge, where one German soldier start singing the Panzerlied, then everybody is up to it.
I'm not surprised if it is, the whole rainbow cluster battle was a reference to the Battle of Midway: Carriers vs Yamato... Sounds familiar right? Because it was how WW2 Yamato got sunk
@@HomeCookOtaku2003 wrong battle. The Rainbow Cluster Battle is a reference to the Battle of Leyte Gulf though ultimately is an alternate-history if you will, since Yamato destroys the fleet successfully rather than escape the battle. Of course, Yamato 2199 is chock full of historical allusions, Gamilas is clearly the Nazi regime, Deslar is Hitler, Dommel is Rommel, etc. The Cosmo Falcon refers to the WW2 Hayabusa (Falcon) fighter, called the Oscar by allied forces, the Cosmo Zero is the WW2 A6M Reisen (Zero-fighter, for its year of entry into service based on the imperial calendar), Gamilas dive bombers have inverted gull wings, like the German Stuka did, etc.
On my third watch of the season, I noticed something. The Zaltz soldiers begin singing to break the tension after Domel's officers make clear their prejudices about serving alongside non-gamilan people. Of course referencing the Panzerlied in Battle of the Bulge movie, but also: The Zaltz are from the 442nd Special Warfare Group - likely a reference to the 442nd "Nisei" Division. A division completely of Japanese American volunteers despite the internship, though many did had family who were locked up. Regardless, the 442nd ended the war with over 18,000 awards in less than 2 years including 21 MoH awards. It saw some of the heaviest fighting in the war against Nazi Germany, and to this day is still the most decorated unit of its size in US history. Often thrown into the thickest fighting, with its 100th Infantry Battalion being known as the "Purple Heart Battalion" from the sheer number of wounded they had. The 2199 writing team really did their homework, and It adds a whole new layer to the Quest for Iscandar arc now that its historical allusions are clearer and more explicit than in the original, not to mention countless more that weren't in the original but help to flesh out the Gamilan and Human characters and factions.
Someone did something right here but there are plenty of instances of bad writing in the show. Like in the first ep where within seconds of being told humanity is months away from extinction we get shown ppl who act like they're in highschool, not a care in the world
@@Palora01 first episode? Mind reminding me what that scene was because I think the first episode only was about Operation M, recovering the core and the beginning of the carrier attack. Anyhow, we as viewers are told of Earth's condition but there is a massive misinformation campaign ongoing, most of Yamatos crew only find out when they are called to serve. (I also wouldn't say that the entire thing is WELL written, but more CAREFULLY written where it matters. The historical parallels are endless, both visually and thematically, and i could go on for hours explaining each and every one I've found yet)
@@briantien7146 it's towards the end, after they recover the pod, and Okita reaches the underground base. Rewatching that part now it's not as egregious as the first time I watched it but it still feels off after hearing "humanity will go extinct within the year".
@@Palora01 I'm gonna admit that there are some scenes that are significantly more "anime" than it should realistically be, but nonetheless the show has a strong and mature message when deconstructed. But I digress - we all still love the show for its big explosions, kewl ships and good characters. The underlying message is something unique to Quest for Iscandar (because of the original version's context I guess) and I just figure that its something worth pointing out.
He holds all non-Gamilloids, like humans, in contempt, even if they are devoted imperial subjects. He didn't want to sing along, since these humans initiated it.
@@MrCantStopTheRobot That guy doesnt. He clearly did not contempt any of them on the ship he is on(the Dimensional Submarine) since his captain likes to pickup those who had been abandoned.
@@sarki4816 Your right. I think he (Heini, I think was his name) is just an awkward guy to begin with. His behavior kinda gives me Michelangelo vibes from ninja turtles, he’s always gung-ho with a laid back kind of attitude.
@@DMW-iq2ie Yep, and I mean in a future episode when that same young non zaltz guy was about to get hit again by that warden dude, he was about to last out at the warden so he definitely cares about his crewmates hence that non-pureblood aka Noran.
I mean... that's how every evil empire gets it's soldiers, pay, bribe, threaten or trick them into thinking they're fighting to protect something. It doesn't make them less evil or "in the wrong".
They were even inspired by some lines from Battle of The Bulge Battle of the Bulge: "Boys, too many boys." "Their first battle will turn them into men!" Space Battleship Yamato/Star Blazers: "We have old ships, and new recruits. Can they fight?" "You once said that there's nothing like a battlefield to turn children into men! They'll learn quick, sir."
In each time I succumb to the fact that the Japanese Anime has finally hit the bar of creativity, quality, and dedication I found myself before another magnificent work like Yamato 2199...... Gale Japan !
Our noble home Planet where the blue flowers blossom. Sing a song of joy! May God's grace always be with us. Ghale Garmillon! Hail to the victory of our home.
Very Reminiscent of the Movie "Battle of the Bulge" There is a Scene where the German Panzer Division is freshly trained and quiet, then one begins singing the song "PanzerLied" To which everyone joins.
I'm not surprised honestly, considering that Gamilon is a nation inspired by the Third Reich it's not so weird for the authors to make referrings to wwll films/events
Just saw the Odyssey of the Celestial Ark movie, I never would have thought that Berger, the Gamillas guy with a cut in his face, would have such a sad backstory. The movie also made me feel bad for Celestella and Mirenel (the Jirel sisters). Freaking Dessler, always manipulating, brainwashing, or forcing good people to fight in wars for him.
Dessler never brainwashed them. The sisters and him, like everyone else, most likely thought Jirel as an Extinct race. Him saving them and letting them love as 1st class citizens in a empire where their kind were feared most likely made them feel as if they had a debt to him, a grave one. As he saved their lives. So thats most likely why they went into service at first. But over time they most likely developed a love for Dessler (non-romantic) leading to why they would die for him. *SOILERS of 2202* Plus he was fighting for his people and their survival as well. With 72 years left for Gamillas and the very small chances of a planet orbiting a star like salizar. Ruthlessness became nessicary for survival.
Among all of them, there's only a handful few that's still alive. The Mustache sub captain, Flekken The old gramp, forgot his name Fomt Berger, the major All that's left of Domel's fleet. This series has more body count than AOT.
Aoki hana saku daichi Kedakaki waga kokyou yo Hibike kanki no uta Kami no kago wa warera to tomo ni ari tsudzuken Gaare gamiron Tatae yo sokoku no shouri wo ....
Acording to the producers the Darold (the red carrier) was the prototype vessel of the Celvades class carrier ..and thats why its painted red (prototype-experimental).. also why it was relegated to training vessel.. I guess UX-01 (dimensional ship) wasnt painted red because it actually was used in the battlefield
either that or the UX-01's red paint kept flaking off or causing problems whenever it went in-between dimensions so they had to make a different laminate coating to preserve hull integrity or energy.
Earlier before This Scene, Domel's subordinate complained that the Imperial Guard (The Gamilas SS) won't let them borrow their ships despite the fact that Regular Army's fleet is 3 months away to get back, which is too late to intercept Yamato. Those Carriers Domel "Forced" to use are training ships with new recruits and retired old soldiers, hence I said that he has understrength army. If he had his own fleet with him, well, we already see what he can do with it in Ep.15 had we not?
:D It's not my translation, the only work I did was upload the bit. I think the translation was done by the Nubles sub group, all of the work belongs to them and the creators of Yamato 2199 ofc. Speaking of translation, there is some curiosity about the full version of the song (the 'discussion' about it is in Lumotaku's comment) care to wade in?
i think this scene is a tribute tu panzerlied'scene in "battle of bulge". if you pay attention, you can see other tributes to masterpieces of cinema and literature in outher yamato 2199 episodes. for example i love captain okita when responds in a offensive manner the gamilas during the pluto's battle (there is also in old series), like general cambronne during waterloo battle. simply awesome.
+machaiping Actually Domel didnt brought the carriers to front line, they tried to justify it in 2199 by having the 2 carriers follow behind the Domellus and Darold (red battlecarrier) for protection.. then Yamato blows the Darold wich causes Domel's fleet to evade and disperse.. Shuderg (blue carrier) is not lucky and collides with Darold's wreck.. then with the Lambea and Domellus separated Yamato picks Lambea and damages it (forcing it to abandon the battle) before the Domellus could react.. The Balgrey (green carrier) had separated earlier to launch the fighter decoy force and was hiden ..but was found and destroyed by Yamato's air wing it was a bit of streeth but at least they tried to make sense.. wich is better than the absurdity of the original (Darold blows up without even tryinf to avoid the drill missile and the explosion takes out all other 3 carriers).. also they fully used the Domellus, where in the original they forgot about not only the Domellus but about Domel's entire fleet
I can kinda live with the battle, it was the way it was for the sake of dramatic tension, and I can live with the plot armor/decisions, barely, what really turned me on was the 'Fighting Spirit trumps all, including quality and numbers' attitude and the inappropriate tone, for ex in the very first ep you hear some news report that "The human race may become extinct in the next year" and then you see all these 'battered','defeated','struggling','survivors' all being really happy and content for no reason. To be fair the anime is decent, I did watch everything until after they beat Domel, and I'm the kind of person who stops watching if I get annoying to much or bored to much.
Palora Yeah, also to be a "do or die" mission with the goal of save all humanity and earth nontheless i found quite odd that the Yamato had such luxury installations as cinema, sauna, japanese baths, observation longes and high quality food producing machines.. is like "we have to build this ship wich is our very last chance of survival.. lets make sure it has sauna and cinema and they really eat well".. up to including the embarrasing swim-clothing of episode 24 (i like to think those were made in the moment and werent there before)
Ok, wth was it with the final 3-4 episodes. Was Domel the final boss? Was it that way in the original as well? It's like the decided to rush the ending and so only had some token fighting and Wave Motion Gun firing and then changed their mind and decided to have a long ending with a lot of boring, cliche dialogue, fan favors, pointless left field "shocking" information with no real implication and a bunch of equally pointless, illogical battles. I wanted to like the series, I really did, but it's just full of boring cliches, repetitive, illogical and pointless most of the time, but at least the explosions look nice (that ramming looked gorgeous), but the new CGI Harlock movie was more exciting. It feels very dated in it's execution, very dated. Time to go searching for something good. To bad Yang Wen-li pisses me off so very much.
Palora Trust me ...its much much better than in the original. In the old one Domel was the comander of a 130 ship fleet (including the Domellus)).. then after some fruitless chases Domel simply challenged the Yamato to come to the Rainboy cluster and fight him to death.. Okita acepts the Challenge and Domel simply uses 4 carriers and a ridicolous comand "yath" (in 2199 the detached bridge of the Domellus) and dies .. In 2199 at least they provide reasons why Domel only had the carriers, uses the Domelus to the end and why the rest of the fleet is gone
+sparrowlt Its an improvement for sure ,but what really REALLY irks me is that they couldnt scrounge up a few destroyers or whatever to screen for the battle, I know the main fleet was stuck at Balun but there had to be at least a FEW knocking about to support the carriers.
And it was the might of the Imperial Astrofleets that held the line to the last against Gatlantis at the gates of Earth. Had Dommel been in command still, they would've turned the tide outright.
I need to find the instrumental version of this when Domel is about to die. The music reminds of the theme from Das Boot. So damned epic! Desslok! Desslok! Desslok! Desslok!
Melberlaze deyn Garmillon kash ya vamzas dam Salezar kharma det lept zestas Kliva dena Frideon, Gatlantis z Teron ya bass legens ornied Ghale Garmillon! grag dorlein nida bolmen-don-rieha
I've added a link to a full version of the song in the description as well as in an annotation link in the first 10 seconds of the video. I think that is the original song.
Did anyone else notice the blue hitler guy fucking cheated on his holo chess thing? He moved his piece, and then a second later he moved it again despite his opponent not moving any pieces yet!
I love this scene You realize that bad guy song is the nation anthem Than you remember the last time we heard it When a planet full of people was bombed to ash
Did you all realize how it looks like the Das Boot theme? Not by chance, the first time this music plays the dimensional submarine is on the screen :-D
@@Palora01 No, they did want to take us over. Shultz (the Zaltzian commander) only resorted to asteroid bombardment after suffering a catastrophic defeat at Mars. He even questioned why Earth didn't just surrender like his planet did in the past. Not all Gamilon are Gimleh.
there are so many people with 1 brain cell who are losing their mind when the media is humanlizing the "villians" they wanted one dimensional villians, brainless story with flashy explosion and nothing to give the battles meaning
Oh yeah, I remember that, but I assumed there weren't many of those , and/or that they are tied down to the defense of the home world and not easily released to other tasks, especially something as risky as attacking the lone ship that inflicted horrible damage to the regular fleet and stranded it there.
our home noble mighty strong and true with our majesty when the blosms bloom sing a song and over come may the grace of the gods who look down from above ever march to our drummm Gharle Gamilas, Glory be with us eternal gloryyyy GHARLE GAMILAS GHARLE GAMILAS GHARLE DESSLAR
As is usually the case, the Gamilas people were mostly a decent sort while the leaders were the real evil. Poor Domel... sent into battle with a rag-tag crew and old junk ships.
to be fair in the first fight with domel his dreadnought was able to go blow for blow with Yamato for a little bit in the end it was domels cockiness that screwed him over
Don't bother clicking the link. The video's been removed for "vIoLaTiNg YoUtUbE's PoLiCy On HaTe SpEeCh," because RUclips is a fucking joke that can't tell the difference between a 50's war movie and an actual Nazi propaganda video
I readed that earth had developed good armour and damage control by the end of the war. Kirishima for example takes several direct hits and didnt blew or became dissabled (ok it was Okita's ship so it had plot armor). Any Gamilas ship is destroyed by a single hit from their own ships so the Kirishima allready had way better armor than the Gamilas ships, Yamato was the next step much bigger with even thicker armor
6 years later, but whatever. The ships who fought Kirishima were not elite ships like Domelaze, Desura or etc. When they are shot by Kirishima, they bounce. Yamato has big guns, so it makes sense the ships are oneshotted, but when yamato shot Domelaze, it bounced the front
@@desura5417 The Gamilas ships could bounce earlier Earth ships shots.. but they couldnt survive hits from Yamato or even themselves as even in the first episode we see a heavy cruiser destroyed bu a single shot from another Gamilas ship.. the Zoelgut class super dreadnought aparently has a impressive front armour that could bounce even Yamato 19" guns.. it couldnt survive however the flame gun from Gatlantis
I don't know about understrength ^^. The Yamato is just one ship, that happens to be better armed and armored then the enemy ships against which all other Terran ships don't have a chance, but that's plot armor for you. :D
Those are Training ships, they don't need to be that dull compare to those that send to warzone anyway. Think about mock combat exercise, so the recruits can know who's who without checking IFF. Red Carrier may signify that it can beat something up even without planes, as its flight deck isn't "normal" at all.
このシーン、ガミラス人たちも人であり戦わなければならない理由があるっていうのがめっちゃ伝わってきて好き
バルジ大作戦
彼らの元ネタはハワイの第442連隊です。
「日系部隊」とも呼ばれていますが、日米戦開戦当初日系人は差別を受けていて、これに対し「俺たちもアメリカ人だ！」と日系二世が大挙して軍に志願しました。
これに応じて新編された連隊です。
彼らの人数が少ないのはヨーロッパの第100大隊がモチーフです。
当初捨て駒のように扱われるも、どのような激戦地に送られても彼らに「撤退」の二文字は無く、日系人の立場を回復すべく戦った結果古今米陸軍において最大の損耗率を記録しています。(その勇猛さは現在米陸軍で真っ先に教わるそうです)
ある戦地で将軍の閲兵があったときあまりの人数の少なさに将軍が理由を問い質したところ、動ける者がそれだけだったことを告げられ急遽彼らの処遇が見直されたそうです。
後には彼らの中からも昇降が出るようになりました。
二等臣民から歌い始めるってなんかいいなw
I just love how the "real" gamilian soldiers joined in without a second though.
Zar belk!
Zar belk!
ZAR BELIK
ZAR BELK!
Why are Humans fighting alongside the Blue-Skins?
@@stephenbyrne2170 they were conqured
種族の違いで差別意識がなさそうなフラーケンがかっこいい。
ドメル配下も多分そう。
おじいちゃんたちも。
一触即発の事態を招いたバーガーも、ザルツ義勇兵が歌い始めたあの瞬間の表情で、即座に改心したことが伺えますね。
Sense of honor was overwhelming in this scene. I really felt bad seeing those enemy ships go down with such loyal crew. Domel was a noble character who was just a pawn in the game but at least he knew it.
They're digging their own graves if they're facing off against the Yamato. Honor is just another word, for *STUPIDITY.*
@@stephenbyrne2170 Ok edgelord.
@@yrm1594 That's me name. Don't wear it out.
@@stephenbyrne2170 Ok edgelord.
@@alicorn3924 Yup, that's me.
I HATE when they sing in anime.
But this so glorious, so fitting, so GOOD.
It perfectly describe militaristic ways of Garmillons.
And it shows that "bad guys" ar not a mindless monsters.
Best anime 2012/2013.
inaliann Nah, just "best anime".
They aren’t really bad guys, they are only fighting for their cause. When looking further into this, you would actually find the Gamillans under Domel being very honourable and rational (not you Berger), they respected the Yamato’s fighting prowess, hell when Domel lost to it he even wished Yamato luck!
But the song really is good, it shows just how loyal the Gamillans are to their cause, it shows their militaristic ways.
The Kingdom Of Ants this is why I love garmillas
@@HomeCookOtaku2003 do you know that Berger fight with Yamato together later? No im not talking the 2202 version, im talking about the movie that takes place betwen ep 24 and 25.
It was the first time Yamato fight with a fleet and the first time Gamilas and Earth figh together against Gatlantis
Best anime....original is best too! This is my favorite universe, all the stuff from Leiji......
フラーケンの副官の焦って歌い始める感じすこ
ハイニだ
フラーケンに忠実だからねハイニは
@@gatolan2459 ハイニはフラーケンに軍事法廷から助けてもらったことがあるからな
My authoritarian pops in Stellaris when i "adopt" a few pops from the United Nations of Eeath and they assimilate perfectly.
+ militarist
Humanity is authoritarian by nature.
@@milotura6828 Someone's been playing too much HOI4, perhaps?
@@subjetividadobjetivaconmak4259 what it's true, Iron Law of Oligarchy
@@milotura6828 Helghastian even.
バルジ大作戦をモデルにしてるだけあってかなりいい雰囲気ができてる
I love how you can watch the change of attitude and the absolute pride swelling in the officers as they join in with the junior crew they were denigrating only a moment before. The common bond of warriors.
I strongly believe that this is an Easter Egg refering to the scene from the film : Battle of the Bulge, where one German soldier start singing the Panzerlied, then everybody is up to it.
Indeed, it's probably is
Nothing like a flash mob to motivate the troops!
I'm not surprised if it is, the whole rainbow cluster battle was a reference to the Battle of Midway: Carriers vs Yamato... Sounds familiar right? Because it was how WW2 Yamato got sunk
@@HomeCookOtaku2003 wrong battle.
The Rainbow Cluster Battle is a reference to the Battle of Leyte Gulf though ultimately is an alternate-history if you will, since Yamato destroys the fleet successfully rather than escape the battle.
Of course, Yamato 2199 is chock full of historical allusions, Gamilas is clearly the Nazi regime, Deslar is Hitler, Dommel is Rommel, etc.
The Cosmo Falcon refers to the WW2 Hayabusa (Falcon) fighter, called the Oscar by allied forces, the Cosmo Zero is the WW2 A6M Reisen (Zero-fighter, for its year of entry into service based on the imperial calendar), Gamilas dive bombers have inverted gull wings, like the German Stuka did, etc.
I originally thought it was a callback to episode 1 when the Yukikaze stays behind to cover the Kongo and one crewman starts singing the Galaxy March.
On my third watch of the season, I noticed something.
The Zaltz soldiers begin singing to break the tension after Domel's officers make clear their prejudices about serving alongside non-gamilan people. Of course referencing the Panzerlied in Battle of the Bulge movie, but also:
The Zaltz are from the 442nd Special Warfare Group - likely a reference to the 442nd "Nisei" Division. A division completely of Japanese American volunteers despite the internship, though many did had family who were locked up. Regardless, the 442nd ended the war with over 18,000 awards in less than 2 years including 21 MoH awards. It saw some of the heaviest fighting in the war against Nazi Germany, and to this day is still the most decorated unit of its size in US history. Often thrown into the thickest fighting, with its 100th Infantry Battalion being known as the "Purple Heart Battalion" from the sheer number of wounded they had.
The 2199 writing team really did their homework, and It adds a whole new layer to the Quest for Iscandar arc now that its historical allusions are clearer and more explicit than in the original, not to mention countless more that weren't in the original but help to flesh out the Gamilan and Human characters and factions.
Someone did something right here but there are plenty of instances of bad writing in the show. Like in the first ep where within seconds of being told humanity is months away from extinction we get shown ppl who act like they're in highschool, not a care in the world
@@Palora01 first episode? Mind reminding me what that scene was because I think the first episode only was about Operation M, recovering the core and the beginning of the carrier attack.
Anyhow, we as viewers are told of Earth's condition but there is a massive misinformation campaign ongoing, most of Yamatos crew only find out when they are called to serve.
(I also wouldn't say that the entire thing is WELL written, but more CAREFULLY written where it matters. The historical parallels are endless, both visually and thematically, and i could go on for hours explaining each and every one I've found yet)
@@briantien7146 it's towards the end, after they recover the pod, and Okita reaches the underground base. Rewatching that part now it's not as egregious as the first time I watched it but it still feels off after hearing "humanity will go extinct within the year".
@@Palora01 I'm gonna admit that there are some scenes that are significantly more "anime" than it should realistically be, but nonetheless the show has a strong and mature message when deconstructed.
But I digress - we all still love the show for its big explosions, kewl ships and good characters. The underlying message is something unique to Quest for Iscandar (because of the original version's context I guess) and I just figure that its something worth pointing out.
That’s fascinating that you found that. It’s always cool when shows take from real history
Love the guy at 0:17
"Huh? Are we singing? Uh, what are the words?"
He holds all non-Gamilloids, like humans, in contempt, even if they are devoted imperial subjects. He didn't want to sing along, since these humans initiated it.
@@MrCantStopTheRobot That guy doesnt. He clearly did not contempt any of them on the ship he is on(the Dimensional Submarine) since his captain likes to pickup those who had been abandoned.
Zaltzis actually, but yeah. There certainly the problem of racism within the Gamilas Empire and it's subjects.
@@sarki4816 Your right. I think he (Heini, I think was his name) is just an awkward guy to begin with. His behavior kinda gives me Michelangelo vibes from ninja turtles, he’s always gung-ho with a laid back kind of attitude.
@@DMW-iq2ie Yep, and I mean in a future episode when that same young non zaltz guy was about to get hit again by that warden dude, he was about to last out at the warden so he definitely cares about his crewmates hence that non-pureblood aka Noran.
好きすぎて何回も見てしまう
Anyone else getting some SERIOUS Battle of the Bulge vibes here??
+Cody Hartig only if they were stomping their right feet in unison. :)
I def did
Yep
To bad for them all thier singing didn't amout to shit. 'Murica.
It's an homage
Seeing some of the Gamillian officers smiling before joining in makes it wonderfully clear that they consider the trust debate to be settled.
地球視点だと侵略者だけどここを見るとガミラスにも守るものがあるように見える
I mean... that's how every evil empire gets it's soldiers, pay, bribe, threaten or trick them into thinking they're fighting to protect something. It doesn't make them less evil or "in the wrong".
互いに正義がある
このシーン好き
They were even inspired by some lines from Battle of The Bulge
Battle of the Bulge:
"Boys, too many boys."
"Their first battle will turn them into men!"
Space Battleship Yamato/Star Blazers:
"We have old ships, and new recruits. Can they fight?"
"You once said that there's nothing like a battlefield to turn children into men! They'll learn quick, sir."
yeah, the panzerlied scene almost 1:1
And in both scenes, by the time the singing is over, the commander knows EVERYTHING he will ever need to know about those men.
二頭ガミラス人のほうが先に歌い出すのがミソ
ここで足踏みして歌ったら、完全にあれだよね笑
雰囲気的に。
全員が協力する気持ちにさせられた場面
どこかのやつが言うには
(歌って、いいね)
In each time I succumb to the fact that the Japanese Anime has finally hit the bar of creativity, quality, and dedication I found myself before another magnificent work like Yamato 2199...... Gale Japan !
Our noble home
Planet where the blue flowers blossom.
Sing a song of joy!
May God's grace always be with us.
Ghale Garmillon!
Hail to the victory of our home.
maybe a transcript from japanese can be posted
Very Reminiscent of the Movie "Battle of the Bulge"
There is a Scene where the German Panzer Division is freshly trained and quiet, then one begins singing the song "PanzerLied"
To which everyone joins.
I had exact same moment of realization watching that episode.
I guess authors really like to push such small nods to our culture.
Well, it's all good as long as it's a well made tribute.
I'm not surprised honestly, considering that Gamilon is a nation inspired by the Third Reich it's not so weird for the authors to make referrings to wwll films/events
@@hoshyro Its also a call back to what Kodai said about human and gamilon cultures having so many similarities
It was a direct, intentional reference by the anime writers. Consider it an homage.
Just saw the Odyssey of the Celestial Ark movie, I never would have thought that Berger, the Gamillas guy with a cut in his face, would have such a sad backstory. The movie also made me feel bad for Celestella and Mirenel (the Jirel sisters). Freaking Dessler, always manipulating, brainwashing, or forcing good people to fight in wars for him.
quehay45 this one went past me, time to check it out.
+katchaner where can i find it?
there is also a movie for a quick recap of the entire series in a few hours if you dont want to spend time watching all 26 episode
Dessler never brainwashed them. The sisters and him, like everyone else, most likely thought Jirel as an Extinct race. Him saving them and letting them love as 1st class citizens in a empire where their kind were feared most likely made them feel as if they had a debt to him, a grave one. As he saved their lives. So thats most likely why they went into service at first. But over time they most likely developed a love for Dessler (non-romantic) leading to why they would die for him.
*SOILERS of 2202*
Plus he was fighting for his people and their survival as well. With 72 years left for Gamillas and the very small chances of a planet orbiting a star like salizar. Ruthlessness became nessicary for survival.
Well if you think of dessler that way I’ll assume you haven’t watched 2205
Holy Britannia ain't got shit on Gamilas.
Gale Gamilon!
Fedorahatter Zar Belk!
Primus Productions Rud Iscandar!
HydraliskMarineKrieg LOL LONG LIVE AMURO THE FIRST INNIVATOR
Among all of them, there's only a handful few that's still alive.
The Mustache sub captain, Flekken
The old gramp, forgot his name
Fomt Berger, the major
All that's left of Domel's fleet. This series has more body count than AOT.
What do you expect from the series that kills off most of the human population in the backstory? :D
Honestly my most favourite sci-fi anthem ever
such a powerful scene
Aoki hana saku daichi
Kedakaki waga kokyou yo
Hibike kanki no uta
Kami no kago wa warera to tomo ni ari tsudzuken
Gaare gamiron
Tatae yo sokoku no shouri wo
....
The one thing the reboot did MUCH better than the original is give you the Garmillon and their empire's motivation and internal conflict.
ハイニの歌い始め好き
バルジ大作戦
Best scene in the whole Anime.
Acording to the producers the Darold (the red carrier) was the prototype vessel of the Celvades class carrier ..and thats why its painted red (prototype-experimental).. also why it was relegated to training vessel..
I guess UX-01 (dimensional ship) wasnt painted red because it actually was used in the battlefield
either that or the UX-01's red paint kept flaking off or causing problems whenever it went in-between dimensions so they had to make a different laminate coating to preserve hull integrity or energy.
Curse you, Dessler! Curse you for wasting the lives of these fine soldiers!
"Sing."
"Louder!"
zchen27 refrence gotten
A nice nod to Battle of the Bulge and Panzerlied
I swear, the Very Second That guy started singing I sang along as well
バルジ大作戦のパンツァーリートかよ
周りに領土を広げ過ぎて自国を守る兵が少なくその残ってる戦力の殆どを親衛隊が牛耳ってるからねぇ…、おまけにガトランティスまで領土の端っこで調子に乗ってるしまつ、だからバルジ大作戦みたく少しのベテランと学徒生しかいなかった、一年戦争時のジオンと殆ど同じ道を辿ってる
実際オマージュというか、バルジ大作戦がモデルらしいですよ
ガミラス自体ドイツモチーフでさしね。
i don't give a f* to how nazi gamilasians are, this scene is so intense and so epic...one of my favourite
Why am I crying?
Because you know how many of these men will be dead in a few episodes or by the end of the series
Earlier before This Scene, Domel's subordinate complained that the Imperial Guard (The Gamilas SS) won't let them borrow their ships despite the fact that Regular Army's fleet is 3 months away to get back, which is too late to intercept Yamato.
Those Carriers Domel "Forced" to use are training ships with new recruits and retired old soldiers, hence I said that he has understrength army.
If he had his own fleet with him, well, we already see what he can do with it in Ep.15 had we not?
To quote a movie that influenced this series:
"Boys. Too many boys."
Nice to see our translations match up. I added a translation track to my cover.
:D It's not my translation, the only work I did was upload the bit. I think the translation was done by the Nubles sub group, all of the work belongs to them and the creators of Yamato 2199 ofc.
Speaking of translation, there is some curiosity about the full version of the song (the 'discussion' about it is in Lumotaku's comment) care to wade in?
At 0:20 all I did was salute at full attention. all hail garmillon.
i think this scene is a tribute tu panzerlied'scene in "battle of bulge".
if you pay attention, you can see other tributes to masterpieces of cinema and literature in outher yamato 2199 episodes. for example i love captain okita when responds in a offensive manner the gamilas during the pluto's battle (there is also in old series), like general cambronne during waterloo battle. simply awesome.
+machaiping Actually Domel didnt brought the carriers to front line, they tried to justify it in 2199 by having the 2 carriers follow behind the Domellus and Darold (red battlecarrier) for protection.. then Yamato blows the Darold wich causes Domel's fleet to evade and disperse.. Shuderg (blue carrier) is not lucky and collides with Darold's wreck.. then with the Lambea and Domellus separated Yamato picks Lambea and damages it (forcing it to abandon the battle) before the Domellus could react.. The Balgrey (green carrier) had separated earlier to launch the fighter decoy force and was hiden ..but was found and destroyed by Yamato's air wing
it was a bit of streeth but at least they tried to make sense.. wich is better than the absurdity of the original (Darold blows up without even tryinf to avoid the drill missile and the explosion takes out all other 3 carriers).. also they fully used the Domellus, where in the original they forgot about not only the Domellus but about Domel's entire fleet
I can kinda live with the battle, it was the way it was for the sake of dramatic tension, and I can live with the plot armor/decisions, barely, what really turned me on was the 'Fighting Spirit trumps all, including quality and numbers' attitude and the inappropriate tone, for ex in the very first ep you hear some news report that "The human race may become extinct in the next year" and then you see all these 'battered','defeated','struggling','survivors' all being really happy and content for no reason.
To be fair the anime is decent, I did watch everything until after they beat Domel, and I'm the kind of person who stops watching if I get annoying to much or bored to much.
Palora
Yeah, also to be a "do or die" mission with the goal of save all humanity and earth nontheless i found quite odd that the Yamato had such luxury installations as cinema, sauna, japanese baths, observation longes and high quality food producing machines.. is like "we have to build this ship wich is our very last chance of survival.. lets make sure it has sauna and cinema and they really eat well".. up to including the embarrasing swim-clothing of episode 24 (i like to think those were made in the moment and werent there before)
Ok, wth was it with the final 3-4 episodes. Was Domel the final boss? Was it that way in the original as well? It's like the decided to rush the ending and so only had some token fighting and Wave Motion Gun firing and then changed their mind and decided to have a long ending with a lot of boring, cliche dialogue, fan favors, pointless left field "shocking" information with no real implication and a bunch of equally pointless, illogical battles.
I wanted to like the series, I really did, but it's just full of boring cliches, repetitive, illogical and pointless most of the time, but at least the explosions look nice (that ramming looked gorgeous), but the new CGI Harlock movie was more exciting.
It feels very dated in it's execution, very dated. Time to go searching for something good. To bad Yang Wen-li pisses me off so very much.
Palora
Trust me ...its much much better than in the original. In the old one Domel was the comander of a 130 ship fleet (including the Domellus)).. then after some fruitless chases Domel simply challenged the Yamato to come to the Rainboy cluster and fight him to death.. Okita acepts the Challenge and Domel simply uses 4 carriers and a ridicolous comand "yath" (in 2199 the detached bridge of the Domellus) and dies ..
In 2199 at least they provide reasons why Domel only had the carriers, uses the Domelus to the end and why the rest of the fleet is gone
+sparrowlt Its an improvement for sure ,but what really REALLY irks me is that they couldnt scrounge up a few destroyers or whatever to screen for the battle, I know the main fleet was stuck at Balun but there had to be at least a FEW knocking about to support the carriers.
this peaceful oh love it im puting on loop
Sing.
*sings*
LOUDER!
*sings louder*
In the end it wad a win win. Earth and Garmillas became allies at the cost of many lives
And it was the might of the Imperial Astrofleets that held the line to the last against Gatlantis at the gates of Earth. Had Dommel been in command still, they would've turned the tide outright.
青き花咲く大地気高き我が故郷よ
響け歓喜の歌
神の加護は我らと共に
あり続けん
ガーレガミロン讃えよ祖国の勝利を
バジル大作戦を思い出す
I need to find the instrumental version of this when Domel is about to die. The music reminds of the theme from Das Boot. So damned epic! Desslok! Desslok! Desslok! Desslok!
ガレガミラス
When the ''bad guys'' are touching usually means it is a great movie... And the hell it is! :-D
Never forget: Earth's shoots First!
ALL PRAISE THE GAMILAS!
I mean, they ARE Xenos, but humans are even worse, so... I think I'll remain neutral.
Melberlaze deyn Garmillon
kash ya vamzas dam Salezar
kharma det lept zestas
Kliva dena Frideon, Gatlantis z Teron ya bass legens ornied
Ghale Garmillon! grag dorlein nida bolmen-don-rieha
未履修ですが、これは「バルジ大作戦」の戦車の歌のシーンと同じニュアンスのカットでしょうか。
I've added a link to a full version of the song in the description as well as in an annotation link in the first 10 seconds of the video.
I think that is the original song.
Yes
Ghale Garmillion! Hail to the victory of out home
Ghale Garmillon!
ThatRandomDude Zar Belk!
Gāre fezeron!
This scene inspired by the old film "Battle of the Bulge".
Did anyone else notice the blue hitler guy fucking cheated on his holo chess thing? He moved his piece, and then a second later he moved it again despite his opponent not moving any pieces yet!
It's alien future chess. Different rules, also, he's the Emperor he does what he wants :D
I love this scene
You realize that bad guy song is the nation anthem
Than you remember the last time we heard it
When a planet full of people was bombed to ash
Fantastic!
Why does this remind me of the moment in battle of the bulge when the Germans started singing panzerlied?
Because it's very likely inspired by it. :D
Did you all realize how it looks like the Das Boot theme? Not by chance, the first time this music plays the dimensional submarine is on the screen :-D
Thanks for the annotation!
Good thing they can be restored ^w^
With how the earth currently is I honestly wouldn't mind an intergalactic empire coming to take us over.
The problem is that this empire didn't really wanna take us over as much as wipe us out as a species.
@@Palora01 No, they did want to take us over. Shultz (the Zaltzian commander) only resorted to asteroid bombardment after suffering a catastrophic defeat at Mars. He even questioned why Earth didn't just surrender like his planet did in the past.
Not all Gamilon are Gimleh.
GESCHAN JUMP!
So fucking inspiring.
Chills.
there are so many people with 1 brain cell who are losing their mind when the media is humanlizing the "villians"
they wanted one dimensional villians, brainless story with flashy explosion and nothing to give the battles meaning
Oh yeah, I remember that, but I assumed there weren't many of those , and/or that they are tied down to the defense of the home world and not easily released to other tasks, especially something as risky as attacking the lone ship that inflicted horrible damage to the regular fleet and stranded it there.
Give it a couple of weeks an I will release a English version on my second account
Good old space natzis
He a honourable soilder and man
our home noble mighty strong and true
with our majesty when the blosms bloom
sing a song and over come
may the grace of the gods who look down from above
ever march to our drummm
Gharle Gamilas, Glory be with us eternal gloryyyy
GHARLE GAMILAS
GHARLE GAMILAS
GHARLE DESSLAR
Helghan: I've been compelled
バルジ大作戦のオマージュ？？？
As is usually the case, the Gamilas people were mostly a decent sort while the leaders were the real evil. Poor Domel... sent into battle with a rag-tag crew and old junk ships.
Is it me, or is this scene based on "Battle of Bulge" Panzer Lied scene?
Sound like singing Panzerlied
to be fair in the first fight with domel his dreadnought was able to go blow for blow with Yamato for a little bit in the end it was domels cockiness that screwed him over
英語のコメント多いけど彼らにはどんなふうに聞こえてるのかな？
Prototype of this scene - ruclips.net/video/YPzTGx96P6U/видео.html
Don't bother clicking the link. The video's been removed for "vIoLaTiNg YoUtUbE's PoLiCy On HaTe SpEeCh," because RUclips is a fucking joke that can't tell the difference between a 50's war movie and an actual Nazi propaganda video
Interesting, thanks for sharing ;-)
バルジ大作戦を彷彿とさせる映像ですが、同時の米軍の442連隊で酷い差別を受けながら戦った部隊を模している。
絶望的だが、それでも信じる“祖國”の為に兵士達は戦うと言うのを表している。
上手い導入だったと思いますね。
Like to see a dub version of this
We need the slow instrumental version
@@shasotirgis didn't even know there was one
I readed that earth had developed good armour and damage control by the end of the war. Kirishima for example takes several direct hits and didnt blew or became dissabled (ok it was Okita's ship so it had plot armor). Any Gamilas ship is destroyed by a single hit from their own ships so the Kirishima allready had way better armor than the Gamilas ships, Yamato was the next step much bigger with even thicker armor
6 years later, but whatever. The ships who fought Kirishima were not elite ships like Domelaze, Desura or etc. When they are shot by Kirishima, they bounce. Yamato has big guns, so it makes sense the ships are oneshotted, but when yamato shot Domelaze, it bounced the front
@@desura5417 The Gamilas ships could bounce earlier Earth ships shots.. but they couldnt survive hits from Yamato or even themselves as even in the first episode we see a heavy cruiser destroyed bu a single shot from another Gamilas ship.. the Zoelgut class super dreadnought aparently has a impressive front armour that could bounce even Yamato 19" guns.. it couldnt survive however the flame gun from Gatlantis
I wish they sang it into Gamilas language!
It'd be AMAZING
バジル大作戦思い出す😅
Elk Domel and the captain of the submarine are badass even though the want the Yamato destroyed.
Also glorious mustache.
Best hymn ever
Gare Gamilon!!! Soto Banzai!!!
Eh, I actually like the Macross Anthem more, it's less derivative (afaik) and more solemn.
ruclips.net/video/ee55r9G48Oc/видео.html
I don't know about understrength ^^. The Yamato is just one ship, that happens to be better armed and armored then the enemy ships against which all other Terran ships don't have a chance, but that's plot armor for you. :D
Those are Training ships, they don't need to be that dull compare to those that send to warzone anyway. Think about mock combat exercise, so the recruits can know who's who without checking IFF.
Red Carrier may signify that it can beat something up even without planes, as its flight deck isn't "normal" at all.
Galè desler!