Klipsch The Nines vs. The Sevens | Answering to Andrew Robinson
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 окт 2024
- When I saw Andrew Robinson's review of Klipsch's The Nines and The Sevens powered speakers and he suggested The Sevens were better? I just had to find out for myself. I respect Andrew Robinson's takes on tech tremendously, and his video questioning whether reviewers got it wrong with The Nines felt personal, even though I knew very well it was not. It was, however, a great opportunity to have some fun while also comparing The Nines vs. The Sevens for myself. Turns out, I don't agree entirely with Andrew Robinson on this, but I sure do appreciate the inspiration for this video, as it's been a real eye-opener. Hopefully it will be for you, too!
Buy now:
🛒 Klipsch The Sevens: amzn.to/437UbUG
🛒 Klipsch The Nines: amzn.to/3Lyh4f4
🛒 Klipsch KS Series speaker stands: www.gopjn.com/...
===
Watch more:
Klipsch The Nines review: • Klipsch The Nines Revi...
Klipsch KS Series speaker stands: • Klipsch The Nines vs. ...
@andrewrobinsonreviews's review: • New Powered Speakers! ...
Read more at digitaltrends.com:
Klipsch The Sevens reviewwww.digitaltre...
Klipsch The Nines review: www.digitaltre...
Music by Yung Mil: / yungmilonstage
===
SUBSCRIBE FOR THE LATEST VIDEOS
bit.ly/DTYouTub...
VISIT DIGITAL TRENDS
www.digitaltre...
Digital Trends may earn a commission when you buy through links on our channels.
FOLLOW US!
/ digitaltrends
/ digitaltrends
/ digitaltrends
channelstore.r...
#technology #klipsch #audiophile #tech #hometheater #speakers #thenines #thesevens #musiclover #musiclovers #digitaltrends #review @andrewrobinsonreviews
GREAT VIDEO! Sorry to have "triggered" you 😂. IMHO, this is a masterclass in how to reply to other hifi/home theater 'Tubers. Anyway, loved the video and once things settle down for the both of us, it's on like Donkey Kong!
@GreenArrow181 Well said. I bought a Sonos Arc and Sub, and it's disappointing. Maybe me, maybe the room, maybe both. But I'm going to move on from it.
Thanks, Andrew! Always a pleasure interacting with you guys.
@@stevethomas2285 If you want Sonos functionality and a sound improvement, the Sonos Amp is a chunky amplifier that can turn any passive speaker (and 1 sub) wireless and hook up to you TV by HDMI.
NO! WE want you to settle this with a boxing match!! 😂😂
@@danielhenderson8316
I had the Sonos Arc, a pair of their Ones, and their sub and felt like I had left a cult when I very happily sold them.
I hadn’t intended to have to “move on” but at some point I couldn’t wait to do so.
Just got a pair of The Nines. They're pretty fantastic. Without any adjustments in the app and in my room I think I hear the "cabinet resonance" they are referring to. To my ears it's more of a congestion in the low mids.
I quickly resolved it and even think I've found the secret sauce for amazing separation and depth.
I actually turned ON the Dynamic Bass EQ, then I set the room config to "corner" which drops the low end 6db. And then did very slight EQ adjustments to taste.
Added lots of frequency separation and depth. Almost like a high pass filter in a way.
I have had The Nines for a few months now. Spectacular detail and clarity for a powered system. I found that leaving the bass and mids flat and boosting the treble by a notch creates a holographic experience that is nothing short of magic. They are paired with Klipsch's new Reference Premiere 12-inch subwoofer. Movie theaters are now nonessential.
How would these compare to like a Nakamichi Dragon 11.1.1 soundbar....these are kind of half the price of the Nakamichi but not sure if its even close.
Loved this video. It’s a great example of how everyone’s experience and hearing tastes are subjective. As Andrew always says, the only person who has to like the sound of your system is you. Would love to see some future friendly head butting
I’ve had The Nines for a month and love them. Very happy with the purchase.
Want to pull the trigger on these. Would use these equally for music, movies, sports and just regular tv watching. Would you say they perform well across the board? Assume the bass is plenty without a sub? Trying to be minimal as possible.
@@alonzosaiz77 I believe it’s excellent at everything. Just no surround sound. Excellent bass. I’m very happy. To get the deepest bass May need sub.
I have these on order, soo excited!
I hate that other guy he never gives a good recommendations, always just complains about bs
I have recently begun watching a lot more of Andrew Robinson's content and enjoy both his style of review and yours. Kind of fun to see how they compare so I am definitely in support of more collabs or reactions!
I have the fives for my PC, they are amazing. I will be buying the nines for our living room. I have nothing but positive things to say about Klipsch.
Watched both Andrew's video and yours, and I'm glad you made this follow-up, because I think like yourself I'd be more inclined to go for the Nines. I think Andrew is great at articulating his experiences though, and his ears have been honed to a very particular taste I think, he knows exactly what he likes and doesn't at this point. Klipsch aren't neutral to begin with, so I imagine the Nines are a tank more than a sportscar so to speak. Won't be to everyone's tastes.
For me is just matter of taste only, that y both of u hv a different opinion. Is like food, some say that food is yummy n some might say yucky. But it doesn't really matter as long as we enjoy it rite. That is what important.
Great video! Music is certainly subjective and as you both point out the room is a huge factor in how any speakers system sounds. I would be interested in hearing a comparison between the Fives and the Sevens or Nines. I have the Fives with a sub and the ports blocked. I prefer their sound this way but would be interested in a pair of their larger siblings as well. I rarely play them very loud but when I do they do tend to struggle a bit.
Yeah, Caleb should definitely pick a fight with Andrew. A cage match between the two would be far more entertaining than one between Musk and Zuckerberg.
AR would hide behind his wife and cry.
I have the Sixes and the Nines. The Nines replaced the Sixes in a music only system. They have a lot more presence than the Sixes in every way. More detail and of course bass. The Sixes found a home as TV speakers for my elderly Mom. They work well her.
I feed the Nines with my Roon library and use a Wiim Pro for streaming. They sound great at any volume level! I'm happy with the 9's even though I initially ordered the 7's. There was a stocking issue and the seller gave them to me for the Sevens price. The walnut is a beautiful finish and saved me a few bucks by sticking to that finish.
Agreed, The Nines are better.
I love my Sevens. If I had a bigger room I would have gone with the Nines probably.
I’ve had them since early March. I want to eventually add a subwoofer to compliment them.
From my understanding they have a built in crossover at 80hz.
I also want to add a turntable or possibly a CD player.
Otherwise I primarily stream music via Tidal Hifi from my personal computer via USB or when working I utilize the WiiM Mini for Tidal Connect via my iPhone.
I love the look of these speakers and in my opinion you can’t find a better looking pair of power “bookshelf” speakers.
Alas beauty is in the eye of the beholder. To each their own.
I must say as soon as I got them I knocked my knuckles on them and they felt rather stout.
Even at high volumes the cabinet is rather sound. I find that resonance occurs more thru the bottom of them than it did with the Fives.
I need better speaker stands because I can feel them thru my floor.
I want the Ultimate Support MS80/36s.
Helloo! I have a dumb question i am a newbie I have the nines they are amazing for its size... i have a rotel ra1572 mk2 with xlr balanced outputs... the question is: can i connect the rotel as external amplifier via xlr? Ofc with the nines internal amp turned off will they play or i will blow something?
Very well done explaining in a way thats helpful for everyone trying to make that decision.
Honestly.... you both nailed it.... you're 100% right.... the nines vocals are just more balanced.... it flows highs to mid much better... that's vocals.... crank up the maiden and the cabinet resonance is a deal beaker for me.... the 7s just fit me better.... Can you both be right???? I think yes🤙🤙🤙🤙
Yes, this is going to sound crazy, but I'm doing it anyway. I plan on using the nines for my rear speakers using Mt Yamaha A8A. My reasoning is that sometimes I just want more rear Chanel impact, like when a dragon roars or a big gun fight. All I would have to do is turn up the volume in my remote, then back again without interrupting the movie. Then, most importantly. When listening to music or playing my games, I'm thinking it will go to eleven. Especially mixed in with my other speakers and my 2 subwoofers.
Thanks for your videos, this, and your review on the nines. I'm hopeful that I can use the analog hookups. If not, then these will be zone 2 speakers for my bedroom or outdoor listening.
Great content. You both do great reviews so it’s nice to see differing opinions. Keep it up! 9’s for me all day…
"Your room will have a Significant impact on your sound"....lol Yesssss, a smidge
It's a really good call out. I think a video on how that works would be awesome. Thanks for your brutal honesty as always!!
You need colab with Tech Steve since he purchase so many 2023 TV's.
Maybe rent most of them from Steve and avoid waitng free samples for so long.
Have you reviewed the sixes? I bought the sixes a couple of years ago just comparing the on paper specs of the fives and sixes and i really enjoy them. Wondering how different the sixes are to the nines
I think i heard that the sixes are discontinued
He's totally wrong the fives are better than both, what a fool.
This is precisely why people should be more informed about reviews specially with regards to speakers. Speakers are very room DEPENDENT. The ROOM is the single biggest factor in how a speaker sounds. A great well made speaker will most definitely sound bad in a non treated room.
No right or wrong..we like what we like simple as that..respect reviews then make your own mind up.
I did the 7s with an svs sub and holy cow fills my 20x50 room ahhhhmazingly . The depth of the 9s is made up for by the sub and having the tone clarity with the 7s adds the "vinyl" warmth that i love .but imo really , you can't go wrong with either set up... go listen to them and make your choice.
I enjoy watching both your and Andrew Robinson's reviews (as well as Kristi). I haven't heard the Sevens or Nines, but it seems reviewers are all in agreement that they're pretty great for the $. I had to convince the wife to let me get the Fives, and she's in love with their styling. She's in love with that walnut finish and textured black face - enough so that she would prefer that in our living room over our soundbar now. Such a gateway drug!
I’m getting the Nines delivered tomorrow and I think I want to pair it with a Speedwoofeer 12s sub what do you think?
This or the RP-8000F IIs.
I have the nines and love them. I haven't listened to the sevens. The nines are great for music and blows my mind. I honestly prefer my high end soundbar for movies and TV. The nines shake my house with the bass all the way up with dynamic bass on. No need for a sub.
Which soundbar do you use?
@@aoalr Samsung HW-Q990B
@@campman1thank you!!
@@campman1 But that can't possibly sound better than a speaker with 6" or larger speakers inside like the Klipsch? 🤔
It's all about the Atmos in the movies. Like I said the nines are incredible with music. They just don't have Atmos effects.
One statement that I would like to get another opinion on is about when Robinson said that the Nines seemed to garble the dialogue in movies somewhat. Did you experience that at all, or was it there but not really a bother for you? Asking because I would be using either of them for both music and television regularly.
This. I would like reviewers to compare exactly this. I heard Andrew mention that as well but I’ve heard or read no one else make reference to it.
Ive had the nines. Why does Music sound crystal clear and amazing but voices in Movies is not, its muffled in most scenarios. Same HDMI cord, same setup profiles
No center channel on the Klipsch so it has to "guess" how to process dialog while music is almost always mixed as stereo.
@@danielhenderson8316 hmm well unfortunately movies suck on these speakers because of dialogue
@@ZackCrainMovie dialogues suck on any system without a center speaker, that's just the way surround sound is mixed. Some AV receivers can counter that by mixing the dialogues about 7-10db louder when outputting into stereo or 2.1. But the klipsch 7 or 9s don't have that function, so all dialogues are quiet and muffled.
@@versaleyang that's unfortunate because otherwise they are beyond outstanding
Good question. I’ve read the 7s handle movie dialogue better. But I’ve not experienced them myself just what I read. I’m still going back and forth about which of the two to buy.
I recently bought the SEVENS. I face problem with customised EQ settings. Every time I switch on the speakers, the app shows the custom EQ are saved but infact the sound coming from speakers is FlAT. I need to move EQ up/dowm little bit to remind speakers to give sound thats aligned with custome EQ.. does anyone face similar problem ?
The Nines or KEF LS50 Wireless II?
Speakers sound their size. I have a pair of the powered Klipschs and with their ablity to control the crossover and volume of the sub, they are fine for TV or gaming but not hifi music. I prefer two 15" woofers in each of my music speakers as I like to CRANK IT UP while still sounding natural and effortless.
GREETINGS FROM THE BEAUTIFUL EMERALD COAST OF NORTHWET FL! Awesome comparative analysis as BOTH of you always state it's about your room & ears! Audiophiles should take note. this is how you respectfully disagree on perspective. Well done!
i am interested in THE NINES / THE SEVENS / THE FIVES....what i want to use them for is TV speakers for movies and sports....are the fives acceptable for this or would i need to go with the sevens or nines. I may also add a subwoofer and if i do which would you recommend and what size .....thank you...cheers from Canada
This would have been so funny if Andrew had walked on the set at the end of the video and Caleb and Andrew listened to music offering their respective opinions.
Collaboration between, Andrew Robinson, JoeNtell & Erin's Audio Corner Do a tower or bookshelf
speaker shootout in a couple of affordable price categories..Goal to try to achieve agreements on the pics... Use Steve Gutenberg use as a back up . Joe
8:27 The biggest take away is everyone room is different everyone's ears are different. Reviewers like Andrew Robinson, yourself and myself (when i review movie's) is we're just here to help guide you but at the end of the day you have to be the one who makes the final decision! P.S. i would love to collaborate with you if your up for the challenge Caleb!
Just ignore the fact you both have different rooms , set ups what not.
I have The Sixes paired with the SPL 15" sub. No reason to upgrade. Haven't even been using my Klipsch LaScala's paired with a 24" sub.
You both are pretty good reviewers on the latest technology, i think its all in what you personally like and enjoy you don't have to be a salmon swimming upstream with the rest in your choices. You just have try things out and go with your liking
I don't typically listen to pop or rap music and recently bought The Fives, and one day I was listening to some top 40 music and a heavy bass song came on and the bass was so low my neighbor started yelling to turn my subwoofer down. I laughed and then listened closely in other rooms of my apartment and was amazed at the bass reproduction I was hearing. So I think it depends on what music you are listening to and where you are listening to it. Also I use these straight out of my Mac Mini M2.
Robinson compares all audio to his reference B&W 800 series speakers. According to Robinson, Klipsch is unworthy of being in the same house as his B&W's.
Only one way to sort this out once and for all: send both to Danny at GR Research, he will test all the drivers individually, he will check out the crossover components and he will add 'Anitres' to the inside of the cabinet to deal with resonating cabinet.
That dude is a snake oil salesman.
@@hong_kong_phooey ok
Andrew is annoying and the stats prove it.
Would be lovely if you could get rsl subs in for review especially with these klipsch's. Predominantly the new 12".
Listen to the latin version of i aint worried with becky, flat, no dbb and tell me with a straight face these need a sub or are not simply amazing at this price point.
How do these compare to highend soundbars?
Maybe call out Andrew on his facial expressions when Kristy's doing her commentary in the reviews.
My listening range is four metres. You think sevens are enough for that? I cannot fit the nines to my book shelf, but there is room for sevens.
Love the content! Will you also be making a Samsung S90C review? 🙌🏼🤞🏼🙌🏼
Andrew's takes on products I've heard were consistently so different than mine that I have a hard time taking his channel for anything more than entertainment.
It's not so much what is said. It's how one responds to what is said. Iron sharpens iron. Good job, gentlemen. ;)
I think the answer's simple... A Mk-2 of The Fives, Sevens & Nines in a year or two, with better cabinet bracing. I just pulled the trigger on a pair of The Fives & a sub. They will tide me over until I can afford a much better overall system of separate hi-fi components. However, if they do a Mk-2 I would like the volume/sub level/input indicator lights on the front, where we can see them and also, it's really annoying that the internal amp turns itself off after no sound has been playing for a minute or so - the amp should only shut off if I press the power button on the remote. On a separate but related topic, like Andrew has asked, I will also keep repeatedly asking Klipsch to make a powered Heritage line of subwoofers.
Excellent comparison between the sevens and nines, but what is the best surround sound system for you? , klipsch, Sonos, Nakamichi
Wow now im more confused the good thing I love klipsch so win win!
meow...
I like chesty vocals so 9s for me all day long!
Well that might affect Diana Krall or Astrud Gilberto’s voices.
im considering the fives the sevens and nines are too large for my tiny apartment
SEVENS FTW!!! 💯✌❗
Fight fight fight fight! Kidding love both of your reviews. 👍
Gee Caleb, to paraphrase some random guy on YT, “the only person to whom you need to justify your opinion is, you” - in other words, “it’s OK to be wrong😂, bless your heart.”
Seriously, nicely presented, and I can see a future in more reaction collaborations - including maybe even Randy CAM; just be prepared for Kristi to chime in with “ yah, but here’s what y’all missed …..”, am I right Andrew?
😅
Better question is it worth going with the McLaren Edition of both speakers or stay with the regular ones?
I think it’s all cosmetic so it’s just a matter of how big of a McLaren fan you happen to be! IMHO Klipsch should have gone with the Gulf livery of pale blue, orange waves and black highlights.
@@techsamurai11 They did go from a paper-ish cone to a carbon fiber cone and I'm wondering how much it changed the sound on the low end. The tweeters are both the same, so I doubt the high end is different. As for the Gulf livery, they're a Williams sponsor now and I don't think that would be allowed.
@@danielhenderson8316Hard to tell by looking at the Williams but you're right 🙂
Yeah, you're right - they changed the cone. I guess you'd have to audition them to tell the difference.
If you want ugly speakers for more money by all means get the McLaren ones
Klipsch are best home theatre system and cheap .❤ 7.2❤. But I am Panasonic for EVER
🇯🇵❤_ PANASONIC _❤ 🇯🇵
If someone uses the 9s for mostly movies....do they not have a center channel... nor any rear speakers? Thanks.
I'm afraid you can't really use a center speaker for these speakers or surrounds
Where are the measurements ? I have no clue if these speakers are any good. Erins audio, now he reviews speakers to a high standard.
For real. Erin gave the nines a shining review.
Thank you. Subscribed 👍🏾
I absolutely LOVED this review!!! (A particular hallelujah!!!!🥳😜) I think it’s a great idea to compare the Sevens and the Nines, and with a little collab action with the congenial Andrew Robinson! I actually found him through you and enjoy his reviews (with Kristi) very much. I think it would be great to do this kind of thing if it is done with a reviewer/creator who is doing it in good fun as this was! Of course, I can’t comment on the qualities of either of these speakers unless I can hear them in person but it was really fun to get both perspectives. I am suffering from analysis paralysis in the upgrade of my dedicated listening only station but still thinking of getting an integrated amp with passive speakers with enough bass that a subwoofer is just not needed (is that even possible??). I have a really good ear, but I am so ignorant of products and terminology I am stuck. Already down a rabbit hole, albeit a fun one. Thanks again for a very fun review!!💕
❤
In my own experience, if your stereo speakers can reproduce down to around 45hz qualitatively, a sub isn't necessary for dedicated music listening, unless you listen to mostly modern electronics with lots of sub bass. But for most music genres, a sub isn't required.
@@versaleyangthank you for responding!
I’m leaning towards the 7s. I initially liked the 9s, but the Andrew Robinson review did scare me away towards the 7s. They’d prob fit better with my 15’x20’ room anyway.
The things I heard Andrew mention that no one else seems to mention at all is….supposedly the 7s handle movie dialogue better than the 9s. I’d love other reviewers to touch on that particular comparison detail.
Cheap audio man also loves the 9s. Lots of people seem to love the 9s.
I’m probably gonna have to just go to some store that has them set up and try sampling them. Even so as said in this video my room will have an effect. Argh decisions.
I have the Sevens and FWIW I have never once had a problem hearing dialogue. They are amazing.
Excellent observation. Speakers are so subjective. The only real way to know if you'll be happy is to listen to them in your own space.
Only time will tell.
If you can't afford 9 go with 7
That was fun more collaborations!!
Listening to this on the 5ives lol
thanks Pal, that was very good.
Ill go for the nines
Thank God for both of you !!!
Thanks!
Throw the smack Caleb!
No smack thrown here!
九號比七號好對吧👍
NO!
Neither because if I'm spending $1,500 on speakers then I will buy the Nakamichi Shockwafe Ultra 9.2.4 Channel Dolby Atmos/DTS:X Soundbar with Dual 10" Subwoofers (Wireless), 4 Rear Surround Effects Speakers, eARC and SSE Max Technology
Liking this challenge review.
Next?
Boxing or MMA match between you and other reviewers, a la Musk Vs. Zuckerberg grudge match. Bring it.
Hi I loved both the reviews on 9s vs 7s from you and Andrew. I was just about planning to buy the Klipsch RP 8000F, and then i see this very interesting powered speakers. Do you think passive speakers like the 8000F / floor standing speakers would be a better choice than active speakers? The 9s and 7s are lower priced than RP8000F here in India - besides the 9s are neither bookshelf nor conventional floor standers.... Requesting an opinion.
Andrew is a dweeb. Rock on, Caleb.
yes you are... and Andrew is correct. Klipsch sending you speakers directly? Cherry picked and tweaked... thanks for sharing your world.
Robinson just likes to hear himself talk in that ridiculous radio talk show host voice.
lol, these reviewers are both pretty cringe, but somehow I don't hate them, dare I say enjoy them 😄
Yeah it’s very cringe
2 guys who can say nothing concrete in 10 minutes of constant chatter. ymmv of course or its just my opinion and its all relative. ugh
Good point
This is a reason I'm a subscriber to your channel and not his. Keep doing what you're doing!
U does your more accurate but Andrew always uses lots of nasa words more big words than the actual review lol he’s picky, the lady is more inline I like her she is accurate, Andrew better jus don’t it plain and simple like u
I also watch @robinsonbrand and enjoy his work. Collaboration videos would be fun some of the time. You both put out great work.
None given.
For the size of the "9", Klipsch should have made a tower speaker instead, saving people from having to buy a stand for it. I love deep bass, so for my money I would just buy the "7" + a subwoofer.
Not sure I would go that far, but I do think the Nines should be a 3 way speaker with a dedicated midwoofer.