This is How the United Kingdom Ends... If it does
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 май 2024
- The Island of Britain has more than 1 country on it. As if that was not enough, there is a new culture growing in the United Kingdom, which not only threatens to caused ethno-religious conflict across England, but with whom Scottish and Welsh Nationalists are clearly aligning alongside neo-Marxists, and that is cultural Islam. This is happening whilst Conservatives push through a Brexit that is the opposite of what most of England wanted in Brexit, which is to slow cultural and ethnic change. Instead, an ideological faction of the Tory Party genuinely believes in a pure form of capitalism so much that it wants cheap labour precisely from the nations which are bringing cultural change the United Kingdom without ever addressing ongoing growth of new populations and ethno-religious divides within Britain itself. All of these things are slowly fusing together to cause a ticking demographic timebomb which, if the UK ends, this is how.
00:00 Beginning
00:43 Chaotic Britain
04:29 How the Welsh lost England
10:45 British Conservatives & Islam
27:19 Celtic Nationalism & Islam
38:25 The Future
Join me on Patreon: / benllywelyn Be a member of the channel: / @benllywelyn
Buy Me a Coffee www.buymeacoffee.com/benllywelyA Business enquiries: ben.llywelyn@gmail.com
Equipment: Canon2000D: amzn.to/3ndGZep Rode VideoMic Pro Plus camera microphone amzn.to/3uvkRjq
Osmo Ambitful tube lights: amzn.to/3lJkZel amzn.to/3OJgwEs DJI Action 2 amzn.to/3qPP7Y6
Equipment: Canon2000D: amzn.to/3ndGZep Rode VideoMic Pro Plus camera microphone amzn.to/3uvkRjq Osmo Ambitful tube lights: amzn.to/3lJkZel amzn.to/3OJgwEs DJI Action 2 amzn.to/3qPP7Y6
Credits
Special thanks to @theDronalist for quality work and RUclips CC.
Brexit vote: Mirrorme22Nilfanion: from CC BY-SA 3.0 commons.wikimedia.org/w/index...
Birthrates By Tweedle - Own work data taken from Conceptions in England and Wales: 2020, CC BY-SA 4.0, commons.wikimedia.org/w/index...
Africa 1920 by Simeon Netchev
www.worldhistory.org/image/18...
Keith Vaz MP By Chris McAndrew - CC BY 3.0, commons.wikimedia.org/w/index...
British Muslim by origin breakdown: By BinSultan92 - Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, commons.wikimedia.org/w/index...
Footage: Pixabay, Pexels, RUclips CC
Music. uppbeat.io
The civil war you talk about, will not be confined to the UK, it will happen in Ireland and across Western Europe.
Hope not civil war. But across the West, this is similar.
There will not be a civil war over other English cities becoming non English, just like there wasn't when London and Birmingham became non-English cities. This is low IQ thinking.
yea but the uk seems to be the most hopeless
Here’s the problem. Using the templates of previous centuries to judge the present one. The civil war you speak of is already happening, dotted around too many places and too many incidents to even count. The inquiries a decade ago which looked into racially targeted child exploitation of native kids, without describing themselves as such, called the abuse so horrifying that, “it is only ever seen in war.”
Everyone looks for this big burst-out conflict as the trigger, when continually downward shuddering, with just more and more dramatic deterioration, is what’s on the menu. Not just some similar Gavrilo Princip moment.
@@belstar1128 Only in your stupid mind.
With Enoch Powell he wasn't calling for bloodshed..he was warning , of bloodshed ..
This is an amazing account of all that has occurred ,you put alot of thought, time and research into this and It's great , so thank you sincerely 💐
Thank you kindly.
@@BenLlywelyn Yes this is true about Enoch Powell,it was a warning not a calling. Also true about your great and informative video.
Ok - considering the Wars of the Roses, the English Civil War, WW1, WW2 and the Troubles in Northern Ireland, it would appear that we're living in far more peaceful times despite mass immigration.
Who is encouraging bloodshed? Is it the immigrants, or the far-right?
Britain seems screwed
Enoch Powel was right in what he predicted
I'm American but I'm ancestrally English and while we have problems on this side of the pond I feel immense pain when I see England hurting.
❤
You won’t be far behind us while Biden is in charge especially with that open border - build the wall!
You are a massive country compared to the UK but you have droves of invaders coming over your borders by the day
It’s a shame 😰 🇺🇸
Don't buy all the doom and gloom. There are certain elements that needs the UK to fail to justify their world views, itinerant Welsh nationalists, such as this presenter, among them.
America? I never seen so much racial anger as on my flight from Washington DC to Atlanta. It was awful tension.
@@markaxworthy2508 yeh did you hear at the beginning where he says England is getting karma or something along those lines
The enemy of your enemy is not your friend but your future enemy.
Sometimes so.
Demographics are destiny. Europe can't survive and turn back Islam if they don't have their own children, and it's not a coincidence that this kind of cultural self-termination happened when Europe rejected its fundamental belief system in Christianity.
The démographie superiority of islam is a big lie because in one or two generation they make aq children as an european
There is hope. Be strong. Have courage.
The demographic problem isn't a problem in one or two generation immigrates have as children as an european. The True problem is immigration himselfe. They get bigger because of that
Part of that though is addressing the high cost of childcare in some countries.
Entire Europe is shattered culturally and demographically, dramatic shifts hapened in Holland, Belgium, Switzerland, Ireland then France and UK, Italy, Sweden changed beyond unrecognisable. Unfortunately, there's not much indication that we will return to the same state between 1969-1990 's . Since 2000's our decline is accelerating by 2030 we might be almost the same.
From 2030-2050 white native European would became minority in this continent. Conversion to Islam would be compulsory. From 2050-2100 no one would speak any of Indigenous languages of this continent.
I emplore anyone looking for root causation of this madness, to research Hayaks 'constitution of liberty' and understand what Blair really did to Westminster, the country, and the union. In short, Blair undid everything, which has made it so difficult for anyone conservative to overturn. The fact that our current government eats from Blairs hand doesn't help (Cameron had him as an advisor). In short, everything Blair did needs reversing, and we need a government capable of delivering that. The man is a complete traitor.
Blair reigned at a moment in history in which we thought history was over - that is the context. He genuinely believed these things.
He needs jail
@@BenLlywelynI've heard he's now Starmer's handler/advisor in the shadows
@@blondie7341 Not much doubt about that, imo.
Blair also needs to be on trial for war crimes. When will his day come??
Not only Europe and the United Kingdom, remember how beautiful countries Iran and Afghanistan were?
Before colonised, yes.
@@casteretpollux😊😊
Reminder: there's more Pakistani nationals in UK, than there are self identified Welsh
Rally? Can we have some stats and sources, please?
The official stats do not say Pakistanis are that high. The muslim population is 3.9 million, same as the Welsh. The figures are easily searchable on Google.
@@wkw2693 if you limit yourself to official stats, then all is well in the world.
Official statistics. I didn't say that were truthful
@@penzorphallos3199 So, what do you go on? You put it up. Justify it. Well?
"There is no such thing as a moderate Muslim". We are all disbelievers and fair game. I remember the Rushdie years well, why that didn't send warnings beats me..
There are moderate Muslims. In fact most are. Racist nonsense like most of the video itself.
Thank you so much for this video, it was incredibly insightful and useful. I'm a Gen X American immigrant who moved to the London area back in March 1995 and have adopted this country as my own. My children were raised here. I've now lived longer in the UK than in my birth country. The UK has changed so much over that short 30-year space of time. It's the same in the US, which is virtually unrecognizable from the America in which I grew up, our culture, the values we were taught, the flag we saluted in school each morning. The most heartbreaking part is learning that it's our leaders -- our own people -- who've betrayed us and knowingly sold us out.
For me, as a non-British, it is hard to wrap my head around what is going on in Britain with all these crazy things in the streets of London and across the UK. Your video was very helpful, thank you.
I witnessed kind of rehearsal for this balagan in 2014 in mainland Europe when Israel launched the Protective Edge operation. So I was aware of what would happen next after Israel retaliated, but nevertheless, I was surprised by the scale of this mass psychosis. And I was shocked that the old red-green alliance achieved such success.
I grew up in the USSR and I was a teenager when the Red Empire collapsed in front of my eyes. A few years later in independent Ukraine, people started to get rid of all that soviet stuff from the schools and public libraries. As a result of that process, I have some interesting books in my collection. Two books about Israeli Colonialism and Zionism are taking a special place in it.
All these gaslighting and protecting narratives about genocide, apartheid, and the Zionist colonial state that the Islamist and woke agitators are spreading across the college campuses are in these books.
The great irony and tragedy that even Islamists seems to believe that bullshit that supposedly should target only the Western public. The Islamists were the guys who used to consider themselves the sword in the hand of Allah and by destroying the Jews they were fulfilling Allah's will. Now they genuinely do not understand why the Zionist colonizers haven't yet fled back to Poland.
Initially, it was almost a red-red alliance against the West. Ba'ath party, the PLO. The Soviets bankrolled and trained almost every far-left terrorist group from the Red Brigades to the Black September and supported many autocratic leaders who pledged to fight with 'Western Imperialism' from Hafiz Asad to Idi Amin. The darkest and the biggest Empier of the 20th, the Prison of Nations declared war on European colonialism and Imperialism, and pan-Arabian imperialists allied with the Red Empire. Nothing confusing.
After the Socialist project in the Arab world collapsed the alliance became red-green.
The Islamic Caliphate is more suitable for the Arab world than the Union of Arabic Social Republics. And the Islamists, like the Muslim Brotherhood, and Hizbut Tahrir have joined the Bolsheviks. For the Islamists, the Bolsheviks are the way to widen their influence on the young non-Muslim people for the Bolshevcs the Islamists are their new proletariat.
Thank you for this insight. Had heard of the red green alliance’s from other source. People have forgotten the world was split and lots of Mus” backed the communist s. Strongly anti west. I have meet many who think the anti west are weak poor relics of history. What is happening is a surprise to them.
I'd love to see the extra video on Celtic nationalism and Islam personally
Yeah definitely
I think the Celts ultimately want to kick the English off the island for good.
@@GrahamDowd-yo2pq Where will the English go?
@@GrahamDowd-yo2pq A union with Ireland, Scotland, Wales, Britanny, and the Galaecos in Galicia, would be great.
@@chrissmith-td3iuAmerica, Canada and Australia
Da iawn Ben for raising the difficult topic. We have to save the beautiful UK 🇬🇧
Diolch am wylio.
Thank you for watching.
That's interesting, why should we save it? I'm just being the devils advocate.
Is it because British culture is the best thing since sliced bread, is there no better alternative out there?
Also interesting that culture 'the way we do things around here' is always changing, our way of life is vastly different from 100 years ago and again from thousands of years ago. New freedoms, old customs, new technology, the atomisation of family & friendships, improved transport, healthcare, greater appreciation of the challenges and difficulties faced by others, etc. All have an effect on culture.
So I think it would be far better to understand whatever is the ideal culture for the UK.
London culture is different from Cumbria, as is Wales to England.
But unless we can identify what we mean by Culture then we can hardly defend it as the surrounding environment is ever changing.
For any 100 people we were to ask you would get 100 competing suggestions as to what it is. But we might then identify the core elements that most could agree upon.
Whereas being swamped by foreigners is a readily understandable fear, it is at least far clearer in having named that fear.
So while I don't want to be swamped in that way, having done so I could now go on and articulate what it is I do not wish to lose. But we don't seem to assert these things as being the Best of British.
If we made a start then wouldn't that be a good thing we could use to preserve and protect our Britishness.
Immigration statistics do not lie: Brexit was not about taking back control over the UK borders. It was all about replacing polish plumbers with Nigerians and Pakistanis.
Whilst I do not think Brexit was for replacing Polish workers with Nigerian or Pakistani ones. It has been a side effect as we are not training people locally to do these jobs nor have we invested in this.
@@BenLlywelyn Have not really been training people for over forty years.
I left school aged 16 in 1969, chuck a job and get another the same week in those days.
How right you are! This should have been obvious to anyone with half a brain and who wasn't eaten up with the lies and propaganda of the Leave campaign. Pre-Brexit, there were two strands of legal immigration into the UK - EU immigration and non-EU immigration. Non-EU immigration was always higher than EU immigration, and was always under the full control of the govt. The govt chose not to control it. In addition, EU immigration was a net contributor to the economy, non-EU immigration a net drainer. One could also perhaps argue that culturally EU immigration was less disruptive, as that seems to be the premise of this video. So, was Brexit good or bad, from this point of view? Go figure.
Pakistani Daleks
Enoch Powell was right!🤔😒🇬🇧
He was too blunt for his time.
@@BenLlywelyn The World War 11 Generation were often blunt or ironic, it cannot be fun loosing family and friends when you are very young,some today are still kidding themselves at thirty five.
Enoch Powell was arguing that immigration would lead to mass bloodshed because of the failure of different cultures to integrate.
That doesn't however explain why Britain was a much more violent place before mass migration - e.g. the Wars of the Roses, the English Civil War.
Not does it explain why the areas of the UK, where violence against the person is highest, have very few immigrants - Blackpool, Thanet, Portsmouth, Southampton, etc
We haven't seen anything like the bloodshed of the English Civil War. I realise a few posters on here would love to kill a Muslim child, but Enoch essentially was wrong.
@@olibranchoharadedog5886 wrong
@@clay119 - Explain why then genius
The West better unite, or else👍🏻
🤣🤣
@@StreetfussballThird world grifter I see😄
Another thing, being of British roots, in the early 1970's I went to London to work (from Rhodesia). I had to tolerate lectures from lefties about us terrible colonialists. I asked the source of their information, turned out none had ever left UK....just media propaganda. Cultures do not mix easily...all are products of laws of nature in different parts of the world over millenia. Assimilation is not a political problem.
London in the early 1970s would have been a different world. Lucky you saw it before both neoliberalism and cultural Marxism kicked in.
@@BenLlywelyn The guys on the Greek vases, sucking each other off - do you think they were "cultural Marxists"? 😀 You guys crack me up.
The Isles were colonised by the Greeks and they ruled them uninterrupted to this day. From time to time, when the locals got to awake and organised, they would call the cavalry. They called the "Romans" on the Welsh, and the "Normans" on the English, now they are building a new army which is also Greek of the making. The 3 "Abrahamic"..."Religions" are actually the Greek temples of Apollo✝, Artemis☪ and Cronus✡.
"Hebrew" is actually related to Esperanto and Klingon - it is an artificially constructed language. The Greeks used it for encrypted trade/intelligence mail, to and from their colonies. The "Hebrew" script, like the Greek script is modified Lydian script. The "Greek" identity is very similar to the "British" identity. The Lydians invented it when they subverted and colonised South Trace (modern Greece). So they put all the Thracian tribes under this artificial Greek identity theme, just like they put you in this artificial British theme on the Isles.
Notice that I call them Greeks, even though it is an artificial identity, it is their most preferred one. I am not trying to confuse you. They also like to go by their other artificial identities - British, Roman, Jewish, Phoneticians. But "Greek" is their flagship.
Shame what happened in Rhodesia and South Africa. I met some Indian and Black South African Coppers and Railway Workers in London in 1975. They clued me up on Reality as a 22year old. A few had served in The Rhodesian Forces.
@@BenLlywelyn It was B - - - - - Fantastic so was Wales,mind you North Wales was unspoiled round about 2003 ! And I am a Scot,with English Relatives.
I am disappointed at your uncritical acceptance of the Establishment's and MSM's defamation of Tommy Robinson. Keir Starmer called him 'a racist thug'. However, Starmer would not dare say this outside the protection of Parliamentary privelege, as it is transparently defamatory.
We have lost our country's without a fight.. Invited in the enemy
You have not lost yet. Grow a spine.
Your leader is a foreigner not welsh
You mean traitor governments did
@@user-zi1xl1im2q Sounds like a Southerner,don't think you'll find many accents like that in Southern India.
@@BenLlywelynYush never give up
There's nothing wrong with nationalism and loving you're country
Everybody apart from the English do it, apparently!
I employed a black teenager in South Africa. He was originally from Malawi and told me he was on his way to UK. I did not like his personality but admired his determination....he probably made it.
Determination is a good attribute.
If this continues the europeans are gonna be like the basque, a remnent of a long forgatten past
Indo-Europeans. The clue is in the name where we come from.
@@BenLlywelyn I know, I just wanted to make the compersion because the indo europeans mostly wiped out or assimlated the old peoples of europe
And whats happining now makes me think that this may happen to the europeans of today if the imegration from the middle eadt and other lands comtinues
speaking of Basques they seem to have the same problem as the welsh with their strange confusing mix of political correctness and nationalism
@@justaduck1664 look what happened to the Kingdom of Mercia too. How long did that last? Who remembers it now? Those Mercians should have built more dykes and burgs if you ask me.
The Basques still exist
I think this is one of the most concise analyses I've seen on the situation in the UK. I have had to fight within myself something I would call a "self civil war" because of my 100% Irish background whilst being a naturalised Londoner. I've had to get this schism out of myself and be neutral. I don't want to side with Marxism and I see that anyone who does in this era is nothing more than a useful idiot. The Celtic nations and Woke England are fair game for the manipulators at this time. I feel more of an affinity with populist England than I used to, and it's bad they're being undermined in the way they are. But I fear you're right to think it could implode.
I can understand why you find the English annoying. My favourite parts of England have always been blue collar working class areas. They usually take people as they find them and don't look down their noses at people. But Middle England is a horrible, toxic, passive-aggressive snidey environment. This class division seems exclusive to England and could be like a tinderbox - especially as it's taking the world's problems on its shoulders now. Ultimately I see Islam using anyone who buys into the far left as its useful idiots until the end game has been achieved and then throwing them under the bus. It amazes me how many people can't see that. It amazes me even more that corporate, academic and the political classes are so blind to this.
I'm not there anymore myself. I think the West is finished. I was more optimistic a few years back, but that has been waning over time.
As a proIndy Scot who has set that aside whilst we have a larger fight on our hands (and of course the Humza disaster!), who worked for more than a decade in London dealing with the class prejudices peculiar to the English (Scotland = working class to the Westminster mind) and who is fully aware of the history of useful idiots in revolutions and the fate of the red side in the red-green alliance once the green get what they want....I AGREE WITH YOU FULLY ON ALL POINTS!
If you think "class division seems exclusive to England" then you need to read and travel more. Marx was describing a universal phenomenon, not a peculiarly British one.:
"Historically, Ireland does not have a strongly defined social class hierarchy, and the term ‘social class’ is rarely used. Muntaner, Lynch, and Oates (Citation 2020) argue that social class is a taboo subject in Ireland that is kept hidden, and if discussed, it is in euphemisms that hide it’s the reality of its existence. This is compared to countries like the UK and mainland Europe, where class inequalities are an integral part of political debate. ‘When people talk about class-based injustices, they are accused of making political debates “ideological”’ (Muntaner, Lynch, and Oates Citation2020, 3). Senator Lynn Ruane (Citation2013) states that despite statistics pointing at social class issues in the country, as a society there is a failure to recognise the role class plays in accessing adequate healthcare, education and general life prospects. Therefore, despite a lack of obvious delineation or recognition of class structures, Ireland appears as divided as the UK and mainland Europe."
@@markaxworthy2508 I’m not reading all of that. Pompous presumptious midwit. I’ve two degrees from prestigious universities, have been travelling all my life, for pleasure as well as government business and have been nursing £100/month book habit since I cried my heart out in nursery school that they were teaching us reading too slowly.
Fact is the English have their own unique take on class division rooted more in social position than wealth. It’s more akin to the Hindi caste system than Marx’s economic analysis.
And your appeal to authority citations?!!! 😂🤣😂 indication of an easily indoctrinated mind.
@@shelleyscloud3651 Thank you.
@@markaxworthy2508 I really despise smug, sanctimonious academics who give it large with their citations and speak down to people like they are inferior beings. There is no way you could enlighten me that way about the two cultures I have been immersed in all my life. Incidentally I have been to over 15 countries. How much more should I travel eh? I bet you're no fun at parties.
the thing that is really sad about the uk is that there seems to be no backlash from people with any political power in most western countries you can some right wing party trying to stop this even if they fail to get elected or are unable to do what they wanted because of a coalition or things that would violate the constitution or outside pressure in the smaller countries. but in the uk it seems impossible to start a right wing party every attempt has failed so far another thing that blows my mind is how the welsh and Scottish independence movements got hijacked by the far left while these guys say they had the local culture and people how could this happen this ideology makes no sense .
i personally stopped learning welsh because all the modern stuff is very woke and i hoped i would just be able to watch older movies but it seems like the welsh language has way more speakers now than a few decades ago so there is a gap in welsh movies and literature and it seems like the golden age was before the printing press certainly before movies were a thing so i just had enough and developed an irrational dislike for welsh in a bigger language like English or Arabic or even Danish you can find subculture stuff that is not mainstream even if the mainstream culture is bad like Arabic atheists or German baseball but with smaller languages this is not possible. i had similar issues trying to learn Samoan but in this case the society seems too right wing and religious and everything has to involve the bible somehow.
i also think brexit is really strange they left the eu despite being such a liberal country and copying all the bad decisions from the eu but non of the good ones while in the conservative eu countries the people are not even considering leaving the eu .i think brexit probably stopped a lot of authoritarian ideas in the eu that were made but by British politicians or at least would be voted in by them. it seems like the politicians in the uk are just very out of touch with the people they are all from an elite class
Yes, the Welsh Language needs more material without social justice preaching in it; I agree. As leftwing nationalists and the rest - it took me a while to even understand how Welsh Nationalism went far left, but... Marxist victim vs oppressor stuff is how conquered people think. And it will takez a lot of work to cure it, to get folk to look at the world as free men with financial responsibility and moral impurity.
@@BenLlywelyn i think the left wing nationalist mindset made sense in the past. but these days these guys seem to hate on the local cultures and people. and it just seems like a copy of American politics and the nationalism is just fake. like a 2nd hand t shirt with some logo you don't know the meaning of.
Well, you are a person of unique background, so your perspective is surely unique. I've at least have never met a Brit who'd describe the problems of UK from the same point of view as you did. Are you the one who got it right? We'll see soone enough, I think.
I’m British and I have the same perspective
Hi ben really enjoy your videos mate
Just wondering was you brought up in wales
❤
Thank you. No, I was raised in Texas.
@@BenLlywelyn ye bit of a twang
You can see the welsh is in your blood
Ta ben
🏴
Ever hear the song by Tracy Chapman "Talking about a revolution"?
In a whisper
This is the problem with people pinning their hopes on Reform - they’re the second kind of economic liberal brexiter that will make things worse for the working class. They’re still going to allow migration in the hundreds of thousands! I wish people were more aware of the SDP’s policies because I think they’re far more aligned with what the majority want (economically centre left, socially centre right), what we need & have fully worked up policy proposals across the board rather than just shallow sound bites. FAR stricter on immigration than Reform too.
I agree - the SDP are a good alternative, but the reality is they'll get nowhere. They're also quite moderate and I don't think there are any moderate solutions left.
Same here. I wish it was the SDP instead of Reform.
Hey Ben , very good video . I can do better editing in your videos which can help you to get more engagement in your videos . Pls lmk what do you think ?
Before watching the whole thing, I thought my favourite person cymraeg started using clickbaits
edit: also, being Bharatiya I was confused why you'd criticise decolonialism, but that example of the Arfikaans certainly reminds me that, people are ineeded emboldened to boast about upcoming genocide thanks to fake history, talking about the anti-Bramhan sentiment here..
edit 2 cus idk if you'll see my other comment, given the muslims were 14% of Bharat's population in 2011(with the actual population touching 20% At least), how long do you think the process to make them Bharatiya first and muslim second will take if at all such an undertaking is possible?
Islam in the subcontinent is complex and out of respect to India I do not claim to know more than Islam there began with bloodshed and that tensions are ongoing. Hope for peace.
I don't personally know any Muslimin for whom Islam is not their primary loyalty.
@@howtoappearincompletely9739 tbh I don't know any "Muslim"with that either, unless the're irreligious
Yeah, exactly the problem many many are fighting against. Not just losing national identity, but united cultural identity. Not even the hills will be safe for the Welsh to run to. 😉
The sooner folk understand the better.
@@BenLlywelyn Farage is not ethnocentric at all, he is there as controlled opposition to stop real ethnonationalism.
@@BenLlywelyn Look up Clann Eireann Justin Barrett's new party.
@@BenLlywelyn Mate, I am so impressed you are not one of those DEI people. I just assumed you were one of those because you study linguistics. You aren't, nice one.
@@Hermanubis1 0:45 watch his head. You still think he's ethnocentric for Celts & Anglos?
Your accent shows you did not spend your teenage years in Wales. The Welsh are and allsways have been an intensely patriotic people - no way would they align themselves with Muslims look what happened at LLanelli
Many have, and many have not.. Wales is a big place, actually.
He has showen the eletes siding with the Muslims and anti colonialists. The man who created the anti colonialists movement oppenly said his movement should be milatent and violent and based on revenge with no surrender. He used his knowlage of psycology to fuel this movement. Anyone who beleves anti colonism feels disgust for you if your Euorpean. Heard an Irish comentator say they are called colonisors and told to repent for there past. The Irish now say FY and tell them to get out. The capture of the elete is what he is decribing very well.
I'm welsh and trust me, we have plenty of brainwashed people here too, most are middle class if I'm honest but they're all over really. It's pathetic, they're traitors.
@@BenLlywelyn Whence did you emigrate, may I ask?
There still significant pockets of Ancient Briton outside of Wales. For example, I looked into the DNA in my home area of Stoke. This makes sense as these people were pushed back westward. Almost in a level line from Lincoln along what is the A50 now. I guess other areas of England, this side of the Welsh border must have similar origins.
Great video. Many good, succinct, points made throughout.
Glad you enjoyed it!
Hello Ben, I am an American of Scot/Norwegian ancestry. I am very concerned with the changes going on in the world. Your content and presentation was refreshing, I look forward to your future podcasts.
Thank you. Norway had a very long period of centre-left rule, and it may be interesting to look at.
You’re on the right track but unfortunately these days you really need to do your own research & not just swallow the lines fed by the media. Two especially egregious examples:
1) Enoch did not advocate for trouble, he warned we were on a path that would lead to it & the quotes attributed to him are actually him quoting the fears expressed to him by his constituents
2) Tommy R is probably the most mischaracterised & maligned of all. I fell for thé propaganda against him too and I recommend you do what I did and go learn for yourself from his own mouth. There’s plenty out there, including his own documentaries, a launching off point could be his address to the Oxford Union.
I’m not attacking you, in both these instances I too bought the lies for a while. Fox still isn’t to my taste and whilst I’ll never forgive Farage, nor do I trust his economic policies, I’ve come to see him as less of the unreconstructed r-ist, beyond-the-pale bigot that I once did.
Definately,Enoch was no fool,an intellectual towering above Mr Average !
One of his closest friends was a British Indian Army Officer like himself,however an Asian.
So much for The RacistTheory. The Usual Bolshevik Lies and Propoganda, Stalin made great use of such skulldugery.
It would not be the first time in history that some Africans or Asians, sided with Europeans in a struggle, El Cid in Spain for example,hundreds of years ago,Syrians during the Crusades or with The Romans.
For myself I care little for a mans skin or nationality. If he believe's the same things as I he is my friend and allie.
Debate Mark Collett
Okay this is a surprising cross over. What specific contention is under debate between the two? I'm sure Collett will find Llywelyn's choice of head gear interesting.
@@CuFhoirthe88 About world war two and jewish history
@@CuFhoirthe88 This Welsh youtuber seems to worship the holocaust religion of ww2 and jewish victimhood
Is it true that the Welsh language is very similar to the language spoken in Israel? I ask this because I've heard it said many times.
No. It is not similar. It has some canny grammatical similarities, but nothing beyond that. Certainly not vocabulary.
@@BenLlywelyn Thanks for clearing that up for me.
The Welsh language is Indo-European while Hebrew belongs to the Semitic languages. They can sound superficially alike, but they are not closely related.
Remind the world that fairness, justice, and freedom are more than words, they are perspectives.
Great video. Sadly it is inevitable. Islam will rise. England will implode. Wales cannot survive as a 1st World country and the biggest cities are already falling. Where do we go for safety? The country side? New zealand? In what's coming I doubt there will be anywhere safe. Conflict is inevitable at this point. What really boils my piss is that no one I speak to can see it.
The West will get through this. It will be difficult, but on the otherside things will get better. After a few hard decades.
@BenLlywelyn I hope so but not in its current form. This will be a crucible event.
will not take over inspite of its bluff and blustering unless we Brits 'allow' it to happen .The British are already beginning to 'wake up' to the threat Islam poses but I do fear that ignorance of this foul creed could lead to unnecessary violence.The British people deserve to know exactly just what lies ahead and this 'religion 'must be exposed.The crusaders of 900 years ago knew just what they were fighting for.
@@rogerwoodhouse7945 I hope you're right but honestly I doubt it. Where I live they are everywhere and they are far more united and physically capable than the soft, decadent people many of our neighbours have become. Last time I went to the Gym, I was one of only 2 Westerners there. Twice I've walked down a main city street and seen no native Brits at all. The statistics are a wild set of lies. Sure parts of the countryside are okay but the cities are already lost.
Islam will rise? Yes, but so will Atheism. Islam is also a very divided religion. Most UK Muslims are Sunnis who make up 3% of the population. That's about 2.5 million versus 55 million non-Muslims in England and Wales.
The Shia Muslims won't cooperate with Sunnis.
Let's look at how Christianity (another religion from the Middle East) gained power in Britain. Firstly, a much smaller population existed in Britain.
Secondly, Christianity had the eventual backing of the Roman Empire to help convert the native population.
Thirdly, people were religious and superstitious. They didn't have the benefit of literacy, rationality or the freedom to object.
OK, why won't Britain become Muslim. Firstly, there aren't enough Muslims to force conversion on the population.
Secondly, Islam doesn't have the backing of an Imperial state like the Roman Empire, or in previous years in Europe, the Ottoman Empire.
Thirdly, the indigenous English don't go to church anymore. We're not religious. We're now en masse rational atheists.
If you look at places in Europe with very large Muslim populations, over 40%, Bosnia, Macedonia, Albania, they're not like that because of mass immigration, but because the conquered people converted under Ottoman domination. And they've been like that for centuries. Also bear in mind the majority of those countries are still non-Muslim.
So my advice is don't worry - ;)
It goes back to the Yalta Conference in 1945 when the future of Europe was decided by the
non Europeans of the US UK and USSR...
The French reaction to this geo political snub was to unite the French empire with Europe
and they sold the idea over the years to other Eu States and they, all of them, signed up for it
including Britain and Ireland...
The first gathering was in 1973 where the diffusion of the Ara b language into Western culture
in Paris was discussed.
Historically Islam was spread by the sword and then the native population was slowly worn down under Sharia law as second class citizens (dhimmi).
Read about The Pact of Umar for more information.
This happened as recently as 1979 in Iran, but also in more recent history Lebanon.
Iran is a sad history, yet its people still fighting back is remarkable.
@@BenLlywelynHopefully one day, hopefully soon.
@@BenLlywelyn The Late Shah warned of this at least two years before it happened.
Amnesty International were however obsessed with S A V A K The Shahs Security Police and their somtimes harsh methods. We now Know what the late Shah and his security apparatus were suppressing.
What of Human Rights now ? Especially for WOMEN ?
much like Christianity then!
No mention of the recent 24000 Welsh job losses in Port Talbot. A move by Tata which, I guess, is run by Hindus. A UK city on its knees and a corner of Wales which has always been open to immigration.
The fate of Port Talbot's steel is sad.
That Leanne woods was a disaster for Wales im a Welsh nationalists but i didn't like her one bit we needed a strong man not a victimised woman. And yes im a Welsh nationalist but i don't hate English people they should have their own country as well
Nothing wrong whatever with women being political leaders. It is when either sex uses victimisation to consolidate power that issues begin.
Its God vs Satan people, race is irrelevant at this point.
'Let’s explore the concepts of the Antichrist and the return of Christ in both Christianity and Islam:
Antichrist in Christianity:
Definition: The Antichrist refers to a figure who is satanically inspired and sets himself up as God. It encompasses both a spiritual aspect (false teachings denying Christ’s deity) and a future earthly leader who will demand worship and persecute God’s people.
The Great Tribulation: Before Christ’s return, there will be a period known as the Great Tribulation. It will be a time of unprecedented difficulty affecting Israel and all nations. Its purpose is to prepare Israel for her Messiah.
Second Coming of Christ: Jesus will return with the hosts of heaven and the Church to establish the Messianic Kingdom on earth. His reign will last for a thousand years. At this Second Coming, the Antichrist will be cast into the Lake of Fire, and Satan will be bound for a thousand years.
Antichrist in Islam:
Maseeh ad-Dajjal: In Islamic tradition, the return of Jesus (Isa) will be preceded by a powerful figure of falsehood and temptation called the Maseeh ad-Dajjal (The False Messiah). Muslims believe that Jesus will return to defeat and kill the Dajjal.
Gog and Magog: After defeating the Dajjal, Jesus will disperse the ancient tribes of Gog and Magog (Yaʾjūj Maʾjūj).
Peace and Justice: Jesus will rule with justice and fairness according to Islamic teachings. His return is a fundamental belief for Muslims.
Both religions share the expectation of a significant figure (Antichrist/Dajjal) preceding the return of Jesus. While there are differences in details, the anticipation of these events plays a crucial role in shaping eschatological perspectives.' (AI)
What's your point?
Can Civic Nationalism be a possible solution? Or does it have to end in ethnic conflict? I am not a native Briton myself, but I ascribe to civic nationalism to be the solution. One MUST ready to resists the tidal wave of those who wear the crescent. They are ultimately the force that can break the UK because every other group can "assimilate," but they will not.
With a Muslim population well below %10, civic nationalism and peace is absolutely a solution, yes. It can still be done. But we need awareness this cannot go much further now.
Civic nationalism is dead in the water , it was powerless and stood by while everything happened against the British people because its individualism was too weak to fight the changes.
PS, that was a brilliant piece and very intuitive. Thank you.
“…goes around asking homeless people if they work in finance.”
Brilliant 😆
Thanks again, Ben! Keep up the good work.
Glad I may 1 fellow human laugh today. Thank you.
I didn’t need a weatherman to tell me which way the wind was blowing. I voted with my feet n left years ago.
Where did you go?
@@BenLlywelyn Suggestions welcome.
Lots of anti English sentiments which saddened me. I could understand if they were directed at the appalling English governments present and past . So no sub or tick from me. Being English though, I do give credit for the presentation, which I have to say was pretty good.
I married an Englishman.
@@BenLlywelyn That's a great rebuttal to being accused of hating the English.
I tried pointing out to a friend how all the oldest place names in England and even up to Scotland as far as I know , had Welsh sounding names and were of old welsh . She couldn’t understand the fact that the early welsh / Britons were speaking the same old language and were the same people . She was so anglocentric that she was unable to understand anything beyond the English history taught only from one perspective .
Is there also a similarity with the cultural incursions of the Viking and the ways they held a lot of the North to the midlands and imposed the Danelaw , as Saxon law held in southern England . We see again the incursions of different culture and demands for alternative judicial system ? History does seem to repeat itself in many ways and learning this perhaps gives us a way to foresee future aims of,people and strategies to attain them .
If you look at the SNP leadership election a few years ago, there are also conservative Scottish Nationalists as well as leftwing ones.
When you get nationalists and socialists combined, do they make National Socialists?
Good vid, Ben. A sad one, too. Go to Romania!😂
As an enthusiast of British history and lover of all things Welsh, I too had seen the similarities of how Britons lost to their island to the English. I consider myself pretty left-leaning but despite that, I'm strongly against immigration and the watering down of native cultures, to the point that some may even call me a nazi (you know how it goes in online circles).
Before this video I was under the impression that these muslims and immigrants were hurtful to Scotland's and Wales' independence attempts as they'd like to remain under the UK, seeing these independence movements as attempts to establish quasi-ethnostates and thus would vote to remain in the UK to prevent that. I also saw their arrival and proliferation in the country as something that would eventually water down the distinct celtic identities as more and more of them arrived and the proportion of pro-independence celts became a minority within their own countries, making a secession vote impossible.
This perspective kinda blew my mind and showed me I was more ignorant about these issues than I thought (mind you I'm not from the UK, let alone from Europe). I never realized the leaders of these independent movements would willingly jeopardize their distinct identities by siding with the immigrants. Great video.
Thank you. It is a complex issue and i hope more like you have will think about without politically correct restrainta imposed by self-righteous virtue signaling. Kind of you to watch it.
This is very well made & fascinating.👍
I am Romanian and I see how in the last decades being proud of your country and your culture is being taught to be bad. All people are taught nowadays is to be ashamed of their country and culture. While there is nothing bad in criticising defects, this overall mentality of shame is not good for any nation. What was wrong in being proud of one's culture? The only way any nation can survive is to have a strong identity and to culturally integrate newcomers. Migration has always happened, but in 2 or 3 generations the immigrants were culturally assimilated. It help when they were the same religion as the host country. But how can any country assimilate newcomers if they are indifferent to their own roots and distinctiveness? If you don't assimilate immigrants, they will assimilate you.
This is what happened to the Romanised Gauls with the Franks, and the Greeks of Anatolia.
How exactly is calling for the freedom of the Palestinian people anti-Semitic ???!!!
Hamas began the war. All their chants call for Israel's end. They even use Nazi terminology and salutes.
Hamas did not begin the war. It began from 1948 with the arrival of huge numbers of Jews into Palestine.
And Israel refuses over and over to stop expanding into whats left of Palestine.
@@bernardmolloy6241actually it was the Palestinians ancestors who first caused what we have today, with the invasion and colonisation of the area of modern day Israel/Palestine in the 7th century by the Muslim Arab empire.
@@BenLlywelynHamas is not Palestine
@@MrSentiaIsrael didn’t exist in the 7 century ! It was a roman territory
The term 'British' was coined by the Scottish King James I after he also became king of England. Therefore uniting all the countries of the the British isles under one crown. It's not used instead of English as you claimed, because England as a Sovereign state was abolished along with Scotland under the Stuart dynasties one United Kingdom.
John breteton that is unionist lies the Stuart's became king of England the UK is a fraud of a union
The Kingdom of Great Britain did not come into existence until the Acts of Union of 1707. The word "British" goes back to Old English, attested as "Brettisc" and "Bryttiscne" in two versions of a text from the mid-9th century. The point Ben Llywelyn was making is that there has been plenty of English nationalism, it's just that it *called itself* "British patriotism".
@@howtoappearincompletely9739
The actual word British goes back much further, right to the ancient Greeks and Phoenicians. However, it wasnt used to describe the Kingdom of Great Britain until the Scottish King James IV 1566-1625 became James I of England united the two crowns in 1603 to become the first King of the whole of the British isles and so afterwards styling himself King of Great Britain and Ireland. In 1707 the two nations finally agreed to the Act of Union which the English had resisted for 100yrs. Though the Stuart's had been using this term since 1603. English nationalism and British patriotism are two different things, many Scots, Irish and Welsh proudly used the term British but they never forgot their national identities, just as the English didn't either.
difficult subject done calmly and with class. nice one.
Brilliant analysis, please make another video on Celtic and islamic alliance
I often wonder how you can really strictly deliniate between the Scottish, Irish, Welsh and English. I was born and grew up in north west England but most of my DNA is Scottish, Irish and Welsh...so what am I then? I reckon there are loads of people in my part of England with similar ancestry, especially the Irish component. I spent most of my childhood hols in Wales and still go there all the time and my in laws live there, if i get my childhood wish of moving to Wales plus the DNA and do my best to learn the language am i now Welsh? I find it confusing. Also the demonisation of 'the english' is wierd, its always the ruling elites making all their nefarious plots and schemes to shaft everyone thst are the problem, they use and exploit their own population just as much as they do other populations, generally your average member of the public has very little power over what those in charge do and often are opposed to what their government is doing but cant do anything as no power.
DNA is far less important than culture.
B - - - - - Lucky,are'nt we ? Go anywhere on this island,still be at home !
Ask yourself. Where do your loyalties lie? There's your answer. Sunak is an Indian but chose to operate in England. If u ask him to chose one country or the other then u will get his honest answer.
@kazapeach9487 As far as I'm concerned, fluency in Welsh and a wish to be deemed Welsh are the two necessary and sufficient criteria of being Welsh. I would welcome you warmly if you met them.
@@melanieah5501 I don't detect loyalty to any country in Rishi Sunak.
Yes please do do a video on Celtic nationalism and Islam. I recognize that the Celtic nationalists have been captured by the NeoMarxists and that there is a red green alliance between the Marxists and Islam,but have always found it strange that the leftists would side with Islam as Islam will eat the left once it gains power as happened in Lebanon in the 70's,it seems suicidal,so I would appreciate an in depth understanding of this.
Regards.
Thank you. I will need to look more at how this happened.
We need a United Republic of Greater Britain and Northern Ireland, with an invitation to Eire to join us when they leave the EU. Governed by the people for the people.
Frank raw we should resolve this fraud of a UK and make England pay up what they stole from Scotland
Eire spent over 600 years throwing the British out. Why would they want to be part of a United Republic of Great Britain?
🤨😮💨🤢🤮
Excellent video. Mad accent you've got there man - sort of a cross between American, Scottish and Central European or something.
A life of turns.
They have this ideological idea of multi culturalism. Apparently, all cultures and people are the same.
Cultures are not the same, and that should be celebrated, not saying any culture is better than any other.
But Globalisation and the migration of millions of Muslims to Western Europe, will mean the end of our European cultures.
They are not the same, that is the issue.
@@BenLlywelynThe word "I am a multiculturalist" is quite common at the moment. Whatever that means.
No, If they were all the same it would be mono-culturism. Multi-culturism is not at all the same and, in a fractured world, it is the only hope for a sane and decent future. Sadly, most of the people on here appear to disagree.
Multiculturalism has been a disaster for the West.
This is not to say that any culture is better than any other, we should celebrate the way different cultures develop, let a million flowers bloom.
But when we import on mass, people who are very different religiously, culturally and historically from ourselves, we are lossing our Welsh, British, European Christian cultural identity.
Jewish people have long assimilated and been accepted into Britain, they practice their faith, maintain their culture in the home, but participate in British culture happily.
But when people come here in large numbers, people who do not want to assimilate, who do not share European Christian culture, then we see conflicts from around the World fought out on British soil.
Prince Charles is turning the west wing of Buckingham palace in to a mosque 🕌
Oh?
That wouldn't surprise me ,he said he reveres Islam and wants to be king of all faiths
Is he really?
@@BenLlywelyn It's BS. The OP presumably call Charles III "the WEF king", too.
I nearly switched off when you used the non-word "irregardless", but I'm glad I gave you the benefit of the doubt.
Irregardless, thank you. :)
Ghost Town yes, exactly! Thanks for explaining
Excellent, thank you for noticing.
Alright man. I gave this a chance and you actually had me throughout for the most part until you started linking Irish and wider Celtic sympathy for the human rights of the Palestinian people (which Israel *has* indeed violated numerous times since 1948, heard of the Nakba? Shabra and Shatiilla? The *murdering* of innocent Palestinians in Gaza, and I mean *murder*, there's no other words to describe their slaughter of Christian and Muslim worshippers attending services there), it came of as a sad and pathetic attempt to get a one up on your political foes, which is unfortunate because you are undoubtedly a man of high intellect and a sincere love for the Celtic people.
Given the inifinite complexity of Israel and Palestine, there is nothing wrong with us disagreeing on an issue not even the greatest men of the 20th century could figure out.
@@BenLlywelyn There's nothing wrong with disagreement. There is something wrong with deliberately misrepresenting and smearing the position of your opponent.
Mae hwn yn ardderchog ac yn ddiddorol iawn a chredaf ei fod yn gynrychioliad cywir o'r ffeithiau a'ch disgrifiad o'n dyfodol posibl.
Rwy’n ofnus ac yn bryderus iawn am ddyfodol Cymru, y Deyrnas Unedig a gweddill Gorllewin Ewrop.
Arhoswch am sefydlu Plaid Islamaidd. Byddant yn cefnu ar y pleidiau presennol ac yn cefnu ar bob esgus.
Mae hynny'n hollol bosibl, a byddai'n sbardun cythrwfl echrydus petai plaid o'r fath yn tyfu i fod yn blaid fawr.
Ydy, mae'n gwbl bosibl.
@@BenLlywelyn Mae'n amlwg nid oes rhaid im ofyn am safon eich Cymraeg!
Other Western countries such as my own 🇦🇺 need to learn from Europe and England because we will be next if we don’t stop this.
We have eachother, and in Australia / New Zealand there will be others if you find them, to discuss, organise, build a front that values our liberal democratic and pro-Western values.
No chance that would ever happen, as much as certain groups would like to think so. We are a United Kingdom, with all the same aims. That is keeping our cultures intact. We have been betrayed, by our governments. Unfortunately, for them, the British people are waking up to that fact.
The next few decades will be most turbulent and the otherside very good.
Comment for the algo
Britains decline began with the Reform Acts in 1832 which allowed Roman Catholics to vote .Elizabeth 1st a welsh tudor alllowed the Protestant Bible in welsh helping to preserve the Welsh language . Unfortunately she did not allow the Bible in Irish Gaelic and alienated tThe Irish people and contributed to the decline of their language . Language is vital to culture . How can you claim to be Scottish or Welsh if you speak English ?
"How can you claim to be austrian if you speak german"
Sorry - are you blaming the Catholic emancipation of 1829 for the decline of our country ?
Elizabeth I was around WAY before that (1533-1603)
So can you explain clearer please
@@kyx-001 The word "Germany" has taken on a narrower and narrower meaning. In Roman times, it meant the area dominated by Germanic-speaking tribes. In more modern times, the word meant "any German-speaking country (city-state) other than Switzerland". Later changed to "any German-speaking country that is neither Switzerland nor Austria". Modern Germany did not exist before 1871.
They still retain their identity strongly though so it’s not changed that to a great effect. Just to an effect that it can be ‘reintroduced’ later at some point in which is what we are seeing today
Scottish, English, Welsh and Irish are all primarily ethnicities rather than a language. Therefore it is absolutely possible to be Scottish and still only speak English.
Ach, the Celtic Football Club founded in 1887 now 136 years ago, by Irish immigrants, what a wonderful beacon of multiculturalism, how these people have integrated seemlessy into Scottish society, you'll often hear about the friendly banter their fans have with fans of our royal blue wearing Glasgow team.
I'm sure many are good folk. Some are not.
@@BenLlywelyn most important thing is that people never take themselves too seriously!
So why do the barbarian invastions in other celtic roman provinces end differently. Visigoths, Franc Vandals. ? France Spain and Tunisia aren't speaking a germanic language now.
Semplicemente perché in Italia Spagna e Francia la popolazione romana era troppo densa perché i barbari potessero imporre le loro lingue... Ad esempio i Longobardi erano pochi e non conquistarono mai tutta l' Italia.... Mai Napoli Roma Venezia o Palermo. Per questo in italiano abbiamo solo tre parole di origine longobarda e nessuna di origine ostrogota Dal Nordafrica i vandali furono spazzati via dai bizantini, poi l' arrivo degli arabi spazzo via anche questi ultimi... In nord africa si estinsero greco, latino e copto sopravvive solo il berbero.
Because they are and were different lands with their own socio-economic and faith-political situations. The Empire was not homogenous.
Because of two reasons: (1) Britain was less Romanized and compares best to North Africa, especially the Mauretanias than to Gaul, Hispania or Italia, (2) Eastern Germanics were already Christianized (Arian proselytism in Pannonia) while the Franks and other West Germanics (Allamani-Sueves) were not but had a long history of direct interaction with Rome (they were Romanized in other ways therefore). The Saxons and Angles (roughly Frisians) were also roughly in this group but they met a more barbaric or remote, barely Christianized, province where different rules applied therefore.
Clovis (first great king of the Franks) conquered what was effectively the last bit of the Western Roman Empire, their former allies against other barbarians often, and thus they annexed them in full, including Latin and Catholicism (Clovis famously converted soon afterwards) and took advantage of the priestly "caste" for administrative purposes and to hold the devastated cities barely alive but alive anyhow. They still suffered from many barbaric issues, notably gavelkind succession, which fragmented their realm over and over and caused endless civil wars, but otherwise they had a good plan and Frankish long term success is no doubt testimony to their constructive opportunism.
Similarly the Goths, both Western and Eastern ones, were strongly entangled with Imperial politics. The Visigoths arrived as "refugees" but not in a long-term drip but in bulk and great numbers. And they were armed and Constantinople tried to destroy them but failed, and then they decided to bribe them and send them packing in Westward direction, where they looted Rome for the first time since Brennus and then were bribed again with lands in Aquitaine.
As Basque I'm not happy with any of this, mind you, but that's how it was. It wasn't the gradual drip of slaves and other migrants who created the barbarian hordes: they were real armed nations on the move, pushed by another armed "refugee" nation: the Huns, expelled by the Chinese a century earlier or so. In the Basque Country we made a revolution (the only successful bagauda or peaasant uprising against feudalization) and thus "miraculously" survived, but in Britain there was nothing like that apparently, rather Romano-British continuity, which, even in the Arthurian legend (for whatever kernel of truth it may have) is not a rule of the people but a rule of a handful of charismatic oligarchs. By comparison even the barbarians surely looked if not good, at least not that bad.
stori debyg oedd gan y Cymry a'r Iraniaid ond llwyddodd un i gicio'r goresgynnwr allan tra methodd y llall fy nghyndeidiau cicio'r Arabiaid allan efallai un diwrnod y gall y Cymry gael eu gwlad
Mae pobl Iran, nid eu llywodraeth, yn bobl hynod o dda. Diolch.
@@BenLlywelyn Our problem with the Iranian government is that they want to make Iran very conservative but the people are conservative but not as much as the government. The people do not want to lose who they are by becoming “westernised” but still connected to the world. It is a complex situation for us. Because nationalism in Iran is very diverse. You have Sunni nationalism Shia nationalism Turkic nationalism Iranian nationalism and the other ethnic nationalism and they can pose a very big problem when trying to deal with a large amount of ethnic groups in a country.
A good example is the Azeris. Turk nationalists think that the Azeris are Turks (they are) but the Iranian nationalists think that they are Iranian. But the true story of what happened is that the Old Azeris and Iranian people got replaced by being exterminated by the waves of Turks into Iran. The Old Azeris are a minority of Azeris today and a lot of have become associated with many other ethnic groups assimilation.
Iranian politics are a mess.
And the Celts of British isles getting independence is not easy because when the majority is English of Wales or other parts of the UK that were Celtic speaking they do not want to be a part of a new country.
@@BenLlywelyn And many people think that we hate the Jews we do not. We have a native Jewish population here who have been here for centuries even longer and same with Christians and the Zoroastrianism the old Iranian religion that is hanging on for its life
One of your questions was where a country without a larger than 15 percent Muslim population had not riots or violent activities was Iran. And those protests in the 50s was made by the USA it is not a conspiracy the USA released half unclassified documents about how they did it. And that one break away state was made by the USSR to have more communist states but the USA said to pull out of Iran and they did and those states died with them. The revolution was related to how the country under the Shah was starting to go into a recession.
To point something out I am not very religious nor am I nationalist. I think Iran should get rid of this religion driven government and replaced with a government to keep Iran the way that the people like it. I do not know exactly what but we are not having a monarchy nor a theocracy.
@@qpdb840aren't the Azeris in Iran more like native Iranians genetically who just lost their native language when a Turkic ruling class took over the region?
Come to Romania, the last island in Europe.
I would enjoy the opportunity. Multumesc.
@@BenLlywelyn We have something secret, that's why we resist among all migratory peoples.
And Hungary.
excellent, thank you, subscribed
Thanks for the subscription!
I'm a Dane and shocked to see how blind the politicians are everywhere and especially in England and Sweden. I lived in India in the 60s and experienced the consequences. In Denmark, we do a lot to ensure that newcomers want to assimilate to our legislation and cultural values if they want a citizenship, this does not include their faith.
The politicians and bureaucrats mistakenly and short-sightedly believe that the management of development can be done with the help of Economy, i.e. the management of the limited goods, and by buying the cheapest goods and labour. That's not how reality works. The development of our industry and society is controlled through self-sufficiency, and which entails exports.
The Nordic Union should only consist of trade and international affairs between sovereign countries like EFTA. The countries should have their own legislation and currency and be facilitated locally in the municipalities. Scotland, Wales, Ireland, the Baltic countries, the Netherlands and others are welcome to join a Nordic Union of sovereign countries. It is probably too late for England.The USA, UK, EU and other World Powers are unfortunately going in a different direction. Trade with India, Africa and more should be initiated quickly and with mutual respect.
I do think there is a problem with historical victim-hood being used as a social/political currency, and this definitely expresses itself in celtic nationalist movements. However to conflate it with support for actual, currently oppressed people around the world is poor. Celtic football club, for example supporting Palestine is not supporting Islam - it is supporting an independence movement. There are not the same thing.
Supporting the independence movement in Palestine = the destruction of the state of Israel . No Muslim can agree to a jewish state . The Mahdi cant come until the jews are defeated worldwide
It is anti-zionism. Which is anti-semitism.
@@BenLlywelyn Never have I seen that false identification more explicitly made.
@@BenLlywelyn Absolutely not. Many Jews are anti-zionist, and furthermore the creation of a greater Israeli state requires the displacement of millions of native inhabitants from the area. The idea that these people are anti-semetic because they don't want to be forced out of their homeland is laughable. The Palestinians deserve our support in the face of zionist colonialism. That is in no way the same as being anti-semetic.
doesn't this imply that the immigration rate and birth rates stay the exact same for at least a 70 years ? (which wont happen)
a very interesting programme. thank you.
Why is England the only nation that is terrified of its own independence? Do we have something in Scotland that they need?
England's Saxon and Norman groups are still even today quite distanced from each other. If England were a nation these two large groups would have no choice but to agree on what England is.
I’m English my family dates back before 1066. From very early Danish Ancestry. Pre Viking. I don’t have any Scottish Welsh or Irish Ancestry. I don’t see my self as British. The union Flag doesn’t really represent me. But my family has payed a high price to be here. 15 members of my family lost their lives at the Battle of the Somme 1915 WWI. Royal Lancashire Regiment. WWII one of my uncles is still on HMS Royal Oak. A Revenge class Battleship. At Scapa flow. One of uncles served on HMS Ark Royal. Served during the Norwegian campaign. And sent to hunt for the Bismarck. He survived the sinking of the Ark Royal. But was killed during the invasion of Italy. Drowning German forces away from the channel for the D-Day Landings. As an Englishman I have no problem with an independent England 🏴. To be honest I don’t think the English were asked if we wanted a union with Scotland in the first place. I believe it was forced upon us. When the Scottish empire failed. You may hate the English but our families have payed a high price to be here. An independent England 🏴 I would accept
@@paulspillier708 I think we'd all be better off going our separate ways: an amicable divorce.
Scottish and Welsh nationalism exist because of English oppression. This is why English nationalism is different, the English in Britain are not historically oppressed.
Brexit? This was about severing ties with the EU. If anyone voted thinking it would stop immigration from outside the EU then that's their error. They weren't conned. Remainers pointed out that immigration would go up from non-EU countries because of labour shortages, and because we would have t give sweeteners to places like India and Pakistan to secure trade deals. Apparently that was "Project Fear".
Culture under attack? How is that happening? English culture could be defined as Shakespeare, Milton, Byron, Thomas Hardy, Turner and Constable. Are we being denied access to these things? No.
Modern English culture has changed enormously in the last 60 years too, despite immigration. We don't attend Church. We take drugs, have sex before marriage, no longer persecute gays, women go out to work. All of these things we take for granted, were seen as abhorrent by traditional conservatives.
You're confusing hatred of the other with a legitimate claim to victim-hood. It just isn't reality. People in England are marginalised and depressed because they are poor, not because Islam is stopping them from going to festivals, or banning Morris dancing, or forbidding the speaking if English, or shutting pubs.
We are now a nation of rational Atheists. Will Islam take control? No.
Why? Because we're no longer a nation of illiterate peasants with no arguments against the dominance of religion, as was the case in Medieval England when we were subject to all manner of dogmatic lunacy.
Tell me you don't know anything about English nationalism without telling me you don't know anything about English nationalism go read about 1066
@@clay119 - Is that even English? I gather you're talking about the Norman conquest. Yes, that had dire consequences for the Anglo-Saxon ruling class, and there was also the genocide carried out during the harrowing of the North.
However, when people talk about the English versus the Scots at Bannockburn, or the defeat of Owen Glendower, we're looking at a period when the Normans had pretty much become English, rather than French, overlords.
@@user-cu5nw7kq5b lmao you just proved that you know nothing about us go read a history book
@@user-cu5nw7kq5b and the Normans didn't become English and neither did they preserve original English culture stop trying to lecture me about my history neo Marxist
@@clay119 - You're not coming up with a counter argument. Prove your point - if you can.
Some fascinating perspectives. Including an excellent treatment of how the Brythonic "Welsh" originally lost England. Which despite a moderate degree of overemphasis re the size of the residual indigenous population left living under early "Anglo-Saxon" rule by the late C6th+, still has many VERY clear and cogent lessons for all modern British people today; Welsh, Scots, English AND most recently, N. Irish (AND Southern Irish) too. In particular, also some very cogent rebuttals of the lying Marxist vermin who've hijacked Celtic national movements.
Great video looking at a lot of interesting perspectives on a complex issue. I particularly liked the analogy of the slow Anglo-Saxon take over of Britain & how there are some similarities to the current wave of arrivals. I'd like to add some points of my own, you forgot to mention the takeover of Pictland by the Scots which to some extent mirrored to Saxon takeover further south. Apparently, Pictish was a Brythonic language similar to Welsh before it disappeared. & of course there is also the Norwegian Viking influence on Britain & the Danes. Plus the Norman conquest greatly affected England and put an end to Anglo Saxon rule. Getting back to the present day some places are fast heading towards Muslim majority status. Although this mainly affects England there are pockets of Islamic influence in Newport, Swansea & Cardiff & in Glasgow.
Very interesting video Ben
Diolch. Thank you kindly.
I may hate the united kingdom but i also dont want it to die, since in the end the inhabitwnts of the uk are still people
It is good to value human life.
@@BenLlywelyn yeah and this is coming from a muslim and an egyptian one like I hate the british museum with every fiber of my body
@@justaduck1664but why do you hate the UK? The museums I can understand but the everyday Brit or even English are not the same as the greedy elites !
@@majortom6262its how they think unfortunately. Muslims without anger issues don’t exist 😂
Yeah well hate the political parties and the elite all you like but the English people are shit on on from the same height as you !!
At a certain point the prime ministers of Great Britain and Eire were of Indian ancestry, that of Scotland of Pakistani ancestry, that of Ulster a Catholic lady!
That amused me to no end.
Enjoy it. Peace and love is ending. What comes next? I don't know.
And that of Wales a half-black man (Vaughan Gething).
Really interesting perspective and excellent manner of presentation. Subbed to your channel. I’m a migrant as well but I certainly wouldn’t want the Britain to loose its traditional culture and institutions.
I think the decline of the traditional aristocracy and the rise of the middle / merchant class was also a big factor in all of this as well. Thatcher also hated the aristocracy.
Thank you for joining.
The aristocracy destroyed the Anglo-Saxon ruling classes and social system. They're literally descended from the French conquerors of 1066.
However, tell me which parts of traditional British culture you believe are under attack, or being lost, because of immigration.
09:40 Battersea Reach Drone footage!
A very intereting talk! I guess you would call me a Celtic Nationalist, with ties to Wales (Caerfyrddin) and Ireland (Fermanagh) where I livee now You do not understand Ireland, which will be unified soon, with Sinn Fein at the helm. Living in the bordeer llands I heear all iew points. NI will go first, then Scotland, then Wales. We will have close cultural ties through lsngusge (not english) music,, songs, and stories. As forr the engliish ....... ?
I enjoy your knowledge of Welsh language and culture but your islamaphobia is out of place in our multicultural world of today. Muslims are essential to our NHS system and in most cases are excellent business owners and do not abuse themselves with alcohol, gambling and drugs. In many ways they are model citizens. Please apply your great research to the study of English, Welsh and Scottish Muslims. I myself have multiple identities. I have English, Cornish and Danish ancestry and I am also a first generation muslim. Please be kinder to newcomers to this country or those with different beliefs. You may find they are more similar to you than you would think.
True👍
In 2001, the original Constitutional & perpetual Magna Charta1215 was lawful invoked,
due to serious breaches of our natural unalienable Common Law Constitutional principles,
including those within our Constitutional Coronation Oath.
Lawful authority has now been transferred to all those that have lawfully declared their standing
under & behind our natural unalienable Common Law Constitutional principles,
especially those within the 2001 lawfully invoked Magna Charta1215,
and are promoting this & lawfully compelling all others to do so, to the best of their abilities
& are lawfully distressing the criminal regime & all that support it
& lawfully distraining all public buildings, lands, assets & funds, .. that are necessary,
to help lawfully restore, as peacefully & quickly as possible,
all our natural unalienable Common Law Constitutional principles, rights & freedoms,
including proper lawful Trial & Annulment by Jury
& arrive at a satisfactory lawful remedy, to this Constitutional Crisis, asap.
^ sovereign-citizen lunacy ^
I think the die is cast and Islam will leave England a divided, troubled society - indeed, it already is. However, Wales and Scotland won't be immune from the turmoil and nor will any other European country. I fear for my children's future in the UK.
Do not be afraid. Have courage and hope to the last.
I stopped watching at 20 minutes because it's a waste of time continuing any further. You're trying to explain where Britain is today from an internal point of view. Whether the Conservatives or Labour are in power in Britain that doesn't explain why the rest of Europe is experiencing the same level of change. The US is experiencing the same. The movement of people around the world is speeding up because of better, faster and cheaper modes of transport and you only have to look at the development of the US from the 19th century to see that. Be honest would you have come to Wales if you had to spend weeks on a sailing ship and there was a big chance that you could die in a storm?
Yes, it is good to focus on Britain in this context. Yes, there Are other nation states with this problem and different angles.
It's hard to say what the figures on ethnicity/religion are for the protests in the U.K. against Israel's recent actions in Gaza are but they are certainly not all muslims or people "controlled" by muslims. They are people from just about every background, there are literal holocaust survivors protesting against Israel's actions. In America it is a majority white non muslim people protesting I wouldn't be surprised if that is the case in some even many areas of the U.K. as well. People are protesting against genocide because it is the moral human thing to do.
The muslim population across the world is not some homogeneous group of people all with the same thoughts and attitudes a muslim from Turkey or Tunisa is not going to share every viewpoint of someone from Afghanistan or Saudi Arabia or a second generation guy living in Bradford. You partially alluded to this but I'm not sure you believe it.
I wouldn't disagree that too much migration to an area in a short space of time can be a bad thing. Just on an available resource level alone if not potential cultural conflicts. Wales has 20% English identifying population that most certainly has an effect on our politics etc.
The demise of the tory party being bad for Wales is the most laughable thing you have ever said.
The "anti zionist mobs" as you call them are in response to a genocide, trying to lump that in with great replacement theories is pathetic. England needs to come to term with it's past for its own sake and future prosperity, that has nothing to do with a muslim takeover.
This video was just an excuse to trash people you dislike rather than a genuine look at U.K. At this point I'm not sure what people you do like...? A very narrow band of right wing celts, american's, english people, europeans, pro westerners and Israeli's who happen to be pro zionist, anti muslim (their art's okay though) but non neo liberal... and definitely no one capable of left wing thought. That doesn't leave too many people. Someone who is not concerned with the genocide of a group of people could be called a misanthrope wouldn't you agree?
At this point the channel's content is more Ben Shapiro than Ben Llewelyn, too much right wing propaganda for me. I skipped the two sections in the middle it got too much honestly I wished I skipped the video entirely. I think you might need some self introspection time.
If the Tory Party dies, I assre you something that is actually anti-Welsh will take its place.
@@BenLlywelyn Ah I see your game now is a gambit for the Torah party. ZERO SEATS!
I agree with a lot of your points and won't seek to argue the others, but here's something to remember: European people are not a monolith either, but despite this, after a few centuries in North America (and for some more recent arrivals, decades) their distinct identities essentially seized to exist and they all blended into an amorphous "White" blob. Sure, some love to claim being Irish on St. Patrick's Day, others clamor about their grandma's pasta sauce, and others will explain you the meaning behind their French sounding last name, but at the end of the day they're all "White" now.
The same can be said about the descendants of the emancipated slaves that were brought over from all corners of Africa, from Mauretania and Senegal, all the way down to the Congo and Angola, and around the Cape to Mozambique and beyond. Their culturally, linguistically, and religiously diverse cultures eventually fused into what we know simply know as "Black" or "Black/African American Culture."
Who's to say that over the coming decades and centuries these distinct Muslim peoples coming to the UK and the rest of Europe don't too coalesce and begin blending together to exert their power in a better manner.
Remember, the history books speak about Jutes, Angles, and Saxons, but that's a later fabrication, there were so many distinct Germanic peoples coming over beyond just those three tribes, and in the end they're all now simply known as the English, one people. One people who over the centuries seized Britain from the Britons and called them Welsh in their tongue, literally "Foreigners."
@@BenLlywelyn If you don't think the Tory Party is anti-Welsh you haven't been paying enough attention. The Tories are not a roadblock to British extremism/nationalism/exceptionalism they are a champion that is in power.
I am horrified that Welsh politics have been so shameful, I hope things improve in the future.
Likewise. Thank you.
Good skills mate, thanks
Thank you