The Strange Case of America's First Murderer

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 8 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 1,6 тыс.

  • @TheCasualCriminalist
    @TheCasualCriminalist  2 года назад +93

    The first 1,000 people to use this link will get a 1 month free trial of Skillshare: skl.sh/thecasualcriminalist03221

    • @_i_am_unceded
      @_i_am_unceded 2 года назад

      Simon I King of Utubia
      Honor and Respect 🙏
      Please do a dive off the Monon High Bridge of Delphi Indiana.
      🆕
      Two Girls Again
      it is our own fault
      if he kills two girls again
      we will share the blame
      we will all be one with the sin
      if he kills
      two girls again
      let's go back
      to where we all began
      the video of two seconds
      of the bridge
      the video
      two seconds of the man
      identify before
      again
      the killer can
      ruclips.net/video/cGu7tJh4d_Y/видео.html
      🔺🔺🔺❤️🔺🔺🔺

    • @SkunkApe407
      @SkunkApe407 2 года назад +1

      Spot on, Fact Boi! The official date of American Independence is 4 July 1776.
      As an added bonus factoid, the UK officially recognized US Independence in 1783, and our two nations established diplomatic relations in 1785.
      Since then, the US has had no closer ally. Conversely, the US is the UK's staunchest ally. Despite some good-natured ribbing, Brits and Yanks share a fraternal bond that is nigh unshakable.

    • @RHCole
      @RHCole 2 года назад +2

      Britain burned the White House down in 1812, dude.

    • @SkunkApe407
      @SkunkApe407 2 года назад +1

      @@RHCole yes, there have been bumps in the road, but that doesn't change anything about what I said. Look past the trees and try seeing the whole forest, bud.

    • @--enyo--
      @--enyo-- 2 года назад

      So if you’re into chilled out/casual history could you bring back the first iteration of the Biographics Podcast? 😉 I really enjoyed that.

  • @draconisxc
    @draconisxc 2 года назад +1614

    "This isn't the 'Murder Porn Podcast'."
    Nah, it's the "One Hour of a British Man Wrestling with his Personal Feelings about the Death Penalty Podcast".

    • @Cec9e13
      @Cec9e13 2 года назад +64

      And we love it!

    • @Thyranel
      @Thyranel 2 года назад +19

      Danny should take some points on this, a 10 minut introduction dont cut it any more :P

    • @austinwagner3231
      @austinwagner3231 2 года назад +66

      Im just here for the "British man cant figure out how to pronounce proper nouns"

    • @Cec9e13
      @Cec9e13 2 года назад +67

      @@austinwagner3231 and "British man has hilariously no idea where things are in the U.S., or sometimes other places."

    • @andrewbillington5422
      @andrewbillington5422 2 года назад +37

      @@austinwagner3231 He's the first person to get my last name right. Probably cause it's british. All the call center people call and ask for Mr. Billingsley.

  • @IanAlcorn
    @IanAlcorn 2 года назад +180

    45 minutes in, and finally to the first murder. David has vastly outdone Danny on the intro.
    Legend.

    • @dillongage
      @dillongage Год назад +9

      Now we just need to see Sam and Jen go head to head with the memes.

  • @maximustiberius3036
    @maximustiberius3036 2 года назад +570

    Simon one year ago:"I don't believe in the death penalty"
    Simon after 650 horrific murders: "Let's hang them"

    • @theConquerersMama
      @theConquerersMama 2 года назад +1

      "gas them. Hang them" too.

    • @therealdeal3672
      @therealdeal3672 2 года назад +20

      Hell yeah! The death penalty is reasonable to use in certain circumstances!

    • @gonkdroid4prez539
      @gonkdroid4prez539 2 года назад +12

      yeah before watching these I was shaky on it, now I think we should bring back the chair or hanging for some specific people

    • @h.w.6563
      @h.w.6563 2 года назад

      @@gonkdroid4prez539 I'm afraid if you just bring it back, it'll be applied way too broadly and innocent people will be killed and incompetent people will botch executions, because doctors aren't allowed to administer the injections etc. etc.
      There would have to be a very well defined new category for cases like these. I think there is something like "aggravated murder" in some states already.

    • @mta4562
      @mta4562 2 года назад

      no, if it is wrong for them to kill, it is wrong for us to kill them. lock them up under the jail and throw away the key, but if you kill them, you become them.

  • @codycollinson1862
    @codycollinson1862 2 года назад +120

    "I can't go back in time and change the things that went wrong because that would change the things that went right" is a sentiment that is proof of a life well lived.

  • @michaelpetrey6787
    @michaelpetrey6787 2 года назад +427

    Everyone that works on this is amazing but...as someone who dabbles in editing I reeeeeally appreciate everything Jen does so much lol always does such a great job

    • @Sniperboy5551
      @Sniperboy5551 2 года назад +20

      @Michael petrey I thought that you were gonna say “someone who dabbles in murder as much as David“ 😆😆

    • @christopherengel7436
      @christopherengel7436 2 года назад +18

      Jen rocks! Her back must be killing her from carrying Simon. I wonder if she is a captive in the basement with the writers?

    • @nicksund1469
      @nicksund1469 2 года назад +20

      @@christopherengel7436 she is trapped in a middle floor. She isnt in the basement, but she isnt in the house, theres a small door on the landing between staircases to the basement. She was in the house, but one time in the early days of casual criminalist she made a mistake and was banished to the middle floor where she will never be seen again

    • @dr.davidbaker86
      @dr.davidbaker86 2 года назад +8

      @@Sniperboy5551 hahahahahahha

    • @satutoivonen9679
      @satutoivonen9679 2 года назад +7

      Loved the burning horses 🔥🐎 edit on this one. 😂

  • @DariusHasDogs2
    @DariusHasDogs2 2 года назад +150

    Honestly I'm loving this True History podcast episode. Would love just hearing heavily detailed stories about individuals who aren't as well known as kings and famous people but still there's heavy details about their exploits and lives. Humanizes the past

    • @ashlynparrott7130
      @ashlynparrott7130 2 года назад +4

      Okay so it might not be exactly what you're looking for, but I think it's great: Puppet History (By Watcher) on RUclips. Not all the episodes are about individuals (some are about events) but the whole thing is just great. My favorites are the one's about St. Nicolas and Cardinal de Rohan (Diamond Necklace Affair)

    • @miristtotallw
      @miristtotallw 2 года назад +3

      You should check out "Forgotten Lives" and "Unfortunate Ends" here on RUclips (same creator). It's difficult to retell stories of lesser known people from back in the days since their lifes weren't as well recorded, but the creator behind the two channels typically tries to put in lots of information from what seems to be mostly academic sources.

    • @blitzofchaosgaming6737
      @blitzofchaosgaming6737 Год назад

      This is nowhere close to true or history. "The United States Of America". So many people ignore the word 'of'. America is a place that has existed since Pangea separated. It didn't spring into existence in 1492 when that racist scum Columbus decided it was India. It didn't spring into existence when the first country that Europe recognized as independent was formed by Europeans. You racist white supremacist Eurocentrists are all totally delusional.

  • @joseybryant7577
    @joseybryant7577 2 года назад +301

    Good to see I'm not the only person curious about this. The French detective that arrested himself, after discovering that he killed a man in his sleep, would be a great video. Said he wouldn't let the criminal get away, and he didn't.

    • @alantremonti1381
      @alantremonti1381 2 года назад +9

      That sounds like a great idea. Now I'm gonna impatiently wait for it.

    • @TheTynell1
      @TheTynell1 2 года назад +3

      prety sure he already did that one

    • @rambi1072
      @rambi1072 2 года назад +8

      Sounds like a early 1900s crime mystery book lol

    • @the4tierbridge
      @the4tierbridge 2 года назад +3

      @@TheTynell1 link?

    • @RoseKeely
      @RoseKeely Год назад +2

      @@TheTynell1 link please?

  • @taliaryn3699
    @taliaryn3699 2 года назад +233

    Simon & Team,
    You're all really helping me right now.. between bombs, air raid sirens, checking on family/friends to see if they are still alive.. these videos, even if I can't watch them in full all at once, they pull me away from the war and the horrors of what's going on in Ukraine right now. even if it's only for a few minutes at a time.
    I wish there were words to express how much these videos are appreciated.
    Thanks 🇺🇦

    • @alanareid3747
      @alanareid3747 2 года назад +21

      Sending love and support. I have no way of really knowing what you are feeling but I stand with you.

    • @JustKrista50
      @JustKrista50 2 года назад +14

      Stay safe. ❤

    • @esmith712
      @esmith712 2 года назад +16

      Know that people care. That we are with you in spirit & hoping for this horrible situation to end quickly - with the defeat of fascist Putin. I'm so sorry you are going through this! Stay safe! Keep hope!
      🇺🇦🙏 Praying for you! Prayers for Ukraine 🙏🇺🇦

    • @dr.davidbaker86
      @dr.davidbaker86 2 года назад +37

      The writer here. Will keep my fingers crossed for you. Let me know if there is anything I can do to directly help.

    • @Vondracar
      @Vondracar 2 года назад +14

      Hang in there! Slava Ukraini!

  • @kratrina
    @kratrina 2 года назад +276

    I'm here for the next podcast hosted by Simon, "Fact Boy's Hot Take on History". Honestly though, I'd watch/listen to you doing a history podcast in the same form as this and Decoding the Unknown.

    • @BKimRogers
      @BKimRogers 2 года назад +19

      I am so game *if* Simon actually includes his hot takes 😅

    • @omfgstrid
      @omfgstrid 2 года назад +15

      Saaaaaaame that seems like such an excellent idea. God knows my RUclips is already SimonTube so why not? I’m in!

    • @--enyo--
      @--enyo-- 2 года назад +13

      He actually had something similar in the past already. From 2019 there was the Biographics Podcast. The first thirteen episodes were him after taping the Biographics video just having a chilled-out chat about the person. I really enjoyed those and was really sad when they stopped (after that it was just the audio straight from the video because they were too time consuming or something). But now maybe Simon has enough followers for his ‘casual’ channels he could bring it back?

    • @helmut7983
      @helmut7983 2 года назад +4

      Yesssss please keep him busy so he gives us content and doesnt see his family

    • @TheCasualCriminalist
      @TheCasualCriminalist  2 года назад +72

      Soon.

  • @doesitmatter3642
    @doesitmatter3642 2 года назад +112

    I enjoyed this one - part history lesson, part CSI. Also definitely a lot more light hearted which I personally think is a nice reprieve

    • @mikieswart
      @mikieswart 2 года назад

      after the night stalker episode? smothering kittens would be a nice reprieve after that

    • @autmnmoon2368
      @autmnmoon2368 11 месяцев назад

      This episode has been a very nice palate cleanser from all the extra gruesome murders

  • @danfosh9826
    @danfosh9826 2 года назад +156

    Can't get enough of this awesome show, knowing fact boy lives in the Czech Republic would love to an episode about some Czech criminals!

    • @theUglyGypsy
      @theUglyGypsy 2 года назад +9

      Or the Prague golem

    • @danfosh9826
      @danfosh9826 2 года назад +6

      @@theUglyGypsy I was thinking someone more like Ivan Roubal or Jaroslav Stodola and his wife Dana.

    • @winsalot84
      @winsalot84 2 года назад +2

      @@theUglyGypsy I can Google this but I like human interaction soooo..... Whoa that? Lol

    • @winsalot84
      @winsalot84 2 года назад +2

      @@theUglyGypsy who's *

    • @danfosh9826
      @danfosh9826 2 года назад +10

      @@winsalot84 A legendary, supernatural figure that "allegedly"once stalked the crooked alleyways and dark corners of Prague's Jewish ghetto

  • @Wolffangs100
    @Wolffangs100 2 года назад +32

    Honestly I got so caught up in the story i forgot I was listening to CC. A history podcast would be amazing!

  • @Graveyard94
    @Graveyard94 2 года назад +122

    The different levels of crimes/changes of pace from each episode definitely keep things interesting when you aren’t sure what you’re gonna get and how Simon will turn parts of it into his own tangents
    An idea for a heist episode could be the Great Train Robbery in the UK. It’s got action and also Simons favourite, criminals making mistakes and getting caught!

    • @debbiejones7269
      @debbiejones7269 2 года назад +3

      I live in the town near where the Great Train Robbery happened, the local Wetherspoons has a whole wall of framed newspaper cuttings about it. It's pretty interesting, if anyone ends up in this neck of the woods I'd reccomend checking it out.

  • @ChopBassMan
    @ChopBassMan 2 года назад +22

    Although I know that Simon often complains about the hour + episodes of CC, but I enjoy them more than the shorter ones. This one has all kinds of educational information in it - history, geography, ballistics, anatomy, genealogy, the slow mental decline of a 35 year old English dad due to his recent foray into parenting, etc., etc.

  • @rochelle586
    @rochelle586 2 года назад +1024

    "When was America?" is the most British thing I've ever heard LOL

    • @--enyo--
      @--enyo-- 2 года назад +38

      I’m Australian and my thoughts mirrored Simon’s most of the episode. 🤣

    • @dJF117
      @dJF117 2 года назад +7

      I’m descended from Stephen Hopkins.

    • @theinquisitor18
      @theinquisitor18 2 года назад +27

      To me, as an American, it's September 3rd, 1783. I personally don't recognize July 4th, 1776. The British colonies declared independence. Cool! There's still a shit ton of loyalist and loyalist forces here. The Treaty of Paris truly legitimized the United States' existence, so that's what I personally go off of, but that's just my take.

    • @DXMXNXXN
      @DXMXNXXN 2 года назад +28

      You take the fact boi out of imperialism but you can't take the imperialism out of fact boi

    • @GrandPrixDecals
      @GrandPrixDecals 2 года назад +10

      America is independent!?

  • @Nefville
    @Nefville 2 года назад +36

    I liked this one, hearing about David's family history and the colonies. Interesting. Its good to do one that's not Ed Gein wearing another persons skin as a hat or some demented child killer.

  • @buddyzilla4557
    @buddyzilla4557 2 года назад +172

    Everyone is discovering themselves in this video! Jen is Pocahontas reincarnated, Danny decended from the Mayflower Murderer and Simon..decides that it is nice to have some quite fun time away from the kids once in a while and appreciates Dutch bluntness but realizes he is too Brittish to participate..I just realized in this chanel that the writers are the sandwhich filling, Jen is the seasoning and condiments and Simon is the toasted white bread we use to consume it.

  • @myticia93
    @myticia93 2 года назад +16

    I really enjoyed the format of this episode. I loved the history behind the "alleged" murder. I would definitely love more scripts like this. That being said, I enjoy all of the episodes on this channel!

  • @PeachM0de
    @PeachM0de 2 года назад +49

    Great script as always, David. It was really cool getting to learn about your family at the same time.

    • @dr.davidbaker86
      @dr.davidbaker86 2 года назад +8

      Thanks!

    • @andrewbillington5422
      @andrewbillington5422 2 года назад +1

      They didn't hang him before he could reproduce. Think of how the world could have turned out if they had removed those Billingtons. A perfect world was within reach.

    • @PeachM0de
      @PeachM0de 2 года назад +3

      @@dr.davidbaker86 of course; cheers my friend.

  • @pamelamays4186
    @pamelamays4186 2 года назад +20

    Simon, your writers have the most interesting back stories.
    I do enjoy a little history mixed in with some dastardly deeds. I also got a bit of Megaprojects sprinkled in too this episode. I didn't know the back story of the Mayflower voyage, and that there was another ship involved. Hey, maybe you could do a Sideprojects about the Speedwell.

  • @krystinreed8300
    @krystinreed8300 2 года назад +57

    I am related to the man that saved the Donner Party. So that’s cool. We all have something. Also, please do a history podcast!!! I’d be all over that!

    • @thegnosticalien
      @thegnosticalien 2 года назад +3

      Ahaha I guess they aren’t podcasts technically but TopTenz, Today I Found Out, highlight History, geographics, biographics are all history based shows for the most part, and decoding the unknown is history that Simon doesn’t believe is real😂
      with that said if he started another podcast just literally reading stories from history I’d also watch

  • @NickyBoy83087
    @NickyBoy83087 2 года назад +17

    I would totally be on board with a new channel that focused on Simon commenting on history. That would be awesome!

  • @Vee_of_the_Weald
    @Vee_of_the_Weald 2 года назад +78

    Well this was really interesting. I honestly didn’t mind the fact that there was only one murger - allegedly - and no gore whatsoever. Just like Simon, I got sucked in. This was fascinating, in fact. Well written, entertaining and educational.

    • @dr.davidbaker86
      @dr.davidbaker86 2 года назад +7

      Thanks!

    • @Cellaghney
      @Cellaghney 2 года назад +2

      @@dr.davidbaker86 coincidence, my great grandmother was a Billington, but a Lancashire one...

  • @terryenby2304
    @terryenby2304 2 года назад +7

    Thank you Jen, David and Simon for a very interesting episode! Not sure it was a regular episode lol, but I definitely enjoyed listening and watching your hard work!

  • @emlenemc
    @emlenemc 2 года назад +48

    i'd love a history podcast- i thoroughly enjoyed today's episode!

    • @adamwhite2364
      @adamwhite2364 2 года назад +1

      If Fact Boi is ranting, I'll be listening.

    • @lisapop5219
      @lisapop5219 2 года назад

      Except his podcast failed

    • @--enyo--
      @--enyo-- 2 года назад +1

      Check out the first thirteen episodes of The Biographics Podcast. It’s a very chilled out chat about the Biographics person recorded after Simon tapes the episode. I really enjoyed them (but he stopped doing them due to lack of time/interest so after thirteen they just became the audio of the Biographics video).

    • @sallyh.6362
      @sallyh.6362 2 года назад +6

      Have you met Simon's other 9 channels?

    • @emlenemc
      @emlenemc 2 года назад

      @@sallyh.6362 yes but i need like a more chaotic take on history topics from him lol

  • @Bull-me8tz
    @Bull-me8tz 2 года назад +10

    I've lived in Massachusetts my entire life, and all of this history is shoved down our throats starting at an early age. Its so funny to hear someone learn it for the first time.

  • @katiek4538
    @katiek4538 2 года назад +20

    American here...we effectively still have debtors' prison. Folks who have fines or court costs outstanding and don't keep up with their payment plans regularly have warrants issued for their arrest. The same is true for people behind on child support. Also, those on probation or parole can be given a violation and incarcerated or even resentenced for non-payment. It makes as little sense as it did back then.
    Just one of the reasons the justice system in the U.S. often becomes a revolving door for folks below the poverty line. 🤷‍♀️

    • @--enyo--
      @--enyo-- 2 года назад

      It seems about every other of the LastWeekTonight episodes deals with this in some way.

  • @891Henry
    @891Henry 2 года назад +7

    Really liked this one! The history/crime combo is great. Thanks

  • @lanicotton8507
    @lanicotton8507 2 года назад +48

    I’m one of those descendants from the Mayflower Puritans, though not Billington. And my 9th great grandfather straight back was a Puritan preacher.
    I’m also supposed to be related to a man who was executed for the murder of his mother. He was found guilty on the basis of a dream.

    • @morgans.9842
      @morgans.9842 2 года назад +3

      Seems like a legit form of evidence lol

    • @Bob-Jenkins
      @Bob-Jenkins 2 года назад +2

      I'm a descendant from one of the first free settlers to Australia, and back through 150 years of British low to middle class people. My Slavic knowledge is to the depth of my great great grandmother, and that is on the word of my grandmother because none of them have birth certificates. To the extent that my mother spent months trying to get hers, and discovered that she was not born in the city, let alone the country she was told about her whole life. Luckily one of the five languages she speaks is from her birth certificate. My grandmother told me stories of one of her relatives who had a castle and bathed in the blood of virgins. That woman has been in her own episode of this show and frighteningly her story matches that of my grandmother's bedtime stories. Or, my memories have changed to suit her (the bather's) stories better - that is the more logical result.

    • @mechengr1731
      @mechengr1731 Год назад

      Lulz

  • @saritacruz3020
    @saritacruz3020 2 года назад +7

    Love the historical story in this format! Great job, David!

  • @thedeadgentleman3188
    @thedeadgentleman3188 2 года назад +20

    I feel super related to this episode. My 9th great grandmother was Dorothy Tolby, the 3rd women murderer in the colonies, and first to have her execution published in the news paper. Her execution is described in House of the Seven Gables, and John Winthrops journal.
    And my 15th great grandfather was the sherif of Lincolnshire.

    • @gomahklawm4446
      @gomahklawm4446 Год назад

      Let me guess. She wasn't a cultist and the cultists kled her for that....

  • @jbeach9402
    @jbeach9402 2 года назад +3

    Listening to Simon go off on 20 minute tangents in a podcast about history would be the absolute best!!

  • @Outcry4truth
    @Outcry4truth 2 года назад +5

    "Someone in my past must have been an amazing whistler" 🤣🤣🤣🤣 this line floored me 🤣🤣🤣

  • @jessicatouart3841
    @jessicatouart3841 2 года назад +2

    One of my favorites so far!!! Love that it's both history and criminal history. Keep it coming.

    • @CashelOConnolly
      @CashelOConnolly 2 года назад

      It’s factually a load of balls! The people on the Mayflower weren’t fleeing persecution their dogma couldn’t tolerate England’s more accepting ways towards other religions. They were zealots and bigoted idiots

  • @Amethyst_Dragon_
    @Amethyst_Dragon_ 2 года назад +9

    Absolutely brilliant episode..!! David is an excellent addition to the basement crew..

  • @stacyrussell460
    @stacyrussell460 2 года назад +4

    Wow, great job David. This one was fascinating. And Jen? You're killing it with the editing!

  • @will2Collett
    @will2Collett 2 года назад +20

    I often drove down route 3, passing near Plymouth and there was a sign that identified Billingtons sea. I really wondered why it had that name. This is an amazing coincidence.This is cool. "Plimoth" is a really beautiful places. Thanks Simon Whistler.

  • @mollywantshugs5944
    @mollywantshugs5944 2 года назад +1

    17:45 I also appreciate that kind of directness because I’m autistic and social subtlety often bewilders me

  • @movieswithshannon
    @movieswithshannon 2 года назад +19

    Alright late to the party but I love this! Time for more Simon deciding his own personal feelings on capital punishment with an audience.

  • @malditoduende2140
    @malditoduende2140 2 года назад +1

    Simon, idk if you will read this but your videos have helped me so much in the past year. I suffer from anxiety and finding relief is becoming more of a struggle but for whatever reason, your videos always zen me out. I also love how friendly and funny everyone is in the comments. It’s not just a podcast, it’s my therapy

  • @vamp459
    @vamp459 2 года назад +9

    I'm descended from Billington too! I was so excited just reading the title. I found out by doing a family tree on Ancestry. I got at least one generation farther than him too. On the other side of the family, I can't trace any earlier than grandparents or great grandparents. It depends a lot on the country in regards to finding records. Wonderful video, as always.

  • @alexandrialucius8351
    @alexandrialucius8351 2 года назад +3

    This one has many things. It had history, information to think about, random information and murder. How perfect. Great script David.

  • @lamiagumbo
    @lamiagumbo 2 года назад +6

    I would absolutely watch a history channel from you, you're so much fun to listen to! I don't even like true crime but I watch you because I love your commentary

    • @Arc115YT
      @Arc115YT 2 года назад +5

      Might I recommend Biographics, Geographics, Warographics, Highlight History, and Into the Shadows? These are other channels by Simon with more of a history slant.

    • @lamiagumbo
      @lamiagumbo 2 года назад +2

      @@Arc115YT I do really enjoy the biographics, and i'll definitely check out the other channels you listed. Thank you for the suggestions!

    • @--enyo--
      @--enyo-- 2 года назад

      If you like this more casual vibe check out the first thirteen episodes of The Biographics Podcast. Originally it was Simon having a casual chat about the subject after he recorded the video. I really enjoyed them, but I believe due to time constraints after the thirteenth episode they just became the audio from the Biographics videos.

  • @craftyisascraftydoes5604
    @craftyisascraftydoes5604 2 года назад +1

    I love these episodes and I think everyone does a great job, but Jen's editing was just amazing on this one.

  • @Cec9e13
    @Cec9e13 2 года назад +8

    David, you are my hero, because in over four decades in the great American Experiment, with a mom who marinated me in the Mayflower story, I have NEVER fully understood the Holland thing. Why Holland? Why then leave again? How and why, any of that? And your true crime script made that segment of proto-American history make perfect sense. BRAVO.
    Also, I have my own British ancestor transported to the New World - Simon Speed, Chicken Thief. Stole a chicken, pan, and apron.
    We love that story.

    • @bayersbluebayoubioweapon8477
      @bayersbluebayoubioweapon8477 2 года назад +2

      Christ, your ancestor was hungry and branded as a criminal, though I don’t support thievery I am thankful for the difference in times.
      (Let me ignore people near me being arrested for shoplifting food during the holidays.)

    • @Cec9e13
      @Cec9e13 2 года назад +2

      @@bayersbluebayoubioweapon8477 yeah I mean that's part of what we love about the story. He was a PRACTICAL chicken thief, who intended to eat.

    • @dr.davidbaker86
      @dr.davidbaker86 2 года назад +1

      That's really great to hear :)

    • @scrossman27
      @scrossman27 2 года назад

      @@bayersbluebayoubioweapon8477 interested in the story behind your handle.

  • @charliehunter9257
    @charliehunter9257 2 года назад +2

    Thank you. I love the differing things that get covered on this channel. As an American, I can truly appreciate the whole take here. Thank you David. Thank you Simon. Thank you Jenn.

  • @TheGhostOfFredZeppelin
    @TheGhostOfFredZeppelin 2 года назад +14

    Is David's "How to be a serial killer and get away with it" class on Skillshare? Asking for a friend

    • @dr.davidbaker86
      @dr.davidbaker86 2 года назад +1

      Nah. It's just a closed group on Facebook.

  • @LilyJaneH
    @LilyJaneH 2 года назад +2

    I found this extremely compelling. Thank you all.

  • @templarw20
    @templarw20 2 года назад +13

    "Pay no attention to my internet search history. I'm a writer, not a serial killer."

  • @brendakrieger7000
    @brendakrieger7000 2 года назад +2

    This was very entertaining! Thank you David😊

  • @boundsofreason8431
    @boundsofreason8431 2 года назад +11

    Security Tip: "your mother's maiden name is literally the security answer that..." you don't have to answer accurately. Answer "mother's maiden name" with, say, Honda Civic, or something equally absurd but consistently-answered when asked and you'll never have to worry about someone learning your mum's maiden name again!

  • @SuzanaHarcum
    @SuzanaHarcum 2 года назад

    This was my favorite episode yet for the casual criminalist, and this has been one of my favorite podcasts of yours (I say one of, because I mostly listen to your podcasts these days). Absolutely would love a similar history style podcast from you, especially exploring historical figures and their modern ties. I've never seen something like that (I'd love some recommendations if anyone knows of one), but I'd be extremely interested in one from you and your team! This was a really interesting video and I love the personal notes in the script.
    I don't comment much (I may need to rectify this for the algorithm gods) but I love your videos. You're a great host, but it's also the great video editing and scripts that make these channels my go-to. Thanks to you and your team for making my work easier with great videos to listen to!

  • @jodilewis5593
    @jodilewis5593 2 года назад +5

    Fascinating! We are able to track our maternal family tree all the way back to William the Conqueror (there's a book written in 1941 which sets all this out). There has been someone from that family line in the US sonce 1637, but in Jamestown, not Plymouth (which is in Massachusetts, BTW). But, don't feel bad, Simon. On my father's side, I can't go back past my great-great-grandfather... Yes, I too love Ancestry.

  • @eetadakimasu
    @eetadakimasu 2 года назад +1

    I love Simon's train of thought on his videos 😂, that and how he banters with the script writers, make it so much more interesting and fun! Thanks for the great content on all of your channels!

  • @--enyo--
    @--enyo-- 2 года назад +11

    This was a really interesting episode! Like a lot of others loved the history involved. And as an Australian glad it was all spelt out for me, because a lot of channels cater just to US audiences who already know this stuff. 😅
    If there’s enough interest in a casual history podcast maybe Simon could bring back the original iteration of the Biographics Podcast?

  • @vthors3000
    @vthors3000 2 года назад +1

    Yes do the history podcast. I always enjoy listenling to you 1h+ vids at work

  • @sadfaery
    @sadfaery 2 года назад +9

    One of my Irish ancestors went to America under a 7 year period of indentured servitude as well. He lucked out, though. He managed to marry the daughter of the wealthy family he was indentured to. He is famous for founding a city and his sons are more infamous for something else, which is why there are more records to be found for his family. I'm descended from his daughter. Not his son. But if he hadn't made a name for himself, I would likely never have been able to learn that much about him.

  • @EVermeulen13
    @EVermeulen13 2 года назад +1

    Giving a like for this episode for a few reasons: 1.) Made me chuckle A LOT 2.) As someone from Dutch Descent, Dutch Bluntness is real (even though I'm Dutch Canadian) 3.) Also have a connection to the Salem Witch Trials, so same time period and hearing about the early colonists and how they survived in North America is WILD like this story. Well done guys! (Also a huge fan of genealogy, curious about the Mayflower Society now)

  • @thelifeandtimes.ofazombiegirl
    @thelifeandtimes.ofazombiegirl 2 года назад +5

    I'm definitely down for a history podcast from Simon and crew! J.

    • @--enyo--
      @--enyo-- 2 года назад +1

      In the meantime you can listen to the first thirteen episodes of The Biographics Podcast. It’s Simon after recording the video having a more casual discussion of the subject of the episode. But after the thirteenth episode due to the amount of time they took it because just the audio footage from the videos. Still good, but I miss the original iteration.

  • @christiangriffith7491
    @christiangriffith7491 Год назад

    Yes please Simon add more of your comments and thoughts in these videos. Always entertaining and can give relatable thoughts!

  • @daftirishmarej1827
    @daftirishmarej1827 2 года назад +8

    "don't Podcast your crimes" 😂😂

    • @JK-gm6kk
      @JK-gm6kk Год назад

      Now it's all the rage to share that shit on social media for clout
      Edit: King Von and other active chiraq gang members are a perfect example. Von was actually interviewed for a doc for a rival gang member, knowing full well that he killed her the entire time. Man was a demon

  • @johngoetz4462
    @johngoetz4462 2 года назад

    Great video! Simon is my favorite light-hearted yet enthusiastic priss on the internet

  • @tiffinyharrington9307
    @tiffinyharrington9307 2 года назад +3

    Please do more podcasts/YT channels where you (Simon) are being you, going off on tangents and such. I dig the other channels but it’s so much better when you go off script.

  • @jonathonbenfield6110
    @jonathonbenfield6110 2 года назад +2

    This was one of the most interesting episode you and your team have done Simon great job

  • @ignitionfrn2223
    @ignitionfrn2223 2 года назад +4

    5:40 - Chapter 1 - Meet John Billington
    12:35 - Chapter 2 - Meet the puritans
    23:00 - Mid roll ads
    26:00 - Chapter 3 - The past was the worst
    34:30 - Chapter 4 - The bad news billingtons
    44:45 - Chapter 5 - A murder in new england
    53:35 - Chapter 6 - Exonerating John Billington
    57:15 - Dismembered appendices

  • @philliprobertson2594
    @philliprobertson2594 2 года назад

    Excellent vid. I listen all the time and this is the first time I've watched. Your facial expressions are very genuine. I enjoy the concept of a "cold read" and it accentuates your skills at narration. Thanks again.

  • @reg4211
    @reg4211 2 года назад +3

    Some quality hobbies David 😎 great episode.
    i have an RAF story too. my grand uncle (from Poland) went over to serve in the RAF in '39 as a plane mechanic so he could get involved after Poland was invaded. I have a unique sweetheart bracelet made with steel chain, brit coins and hearts carved from broken spitfire windshields.

    • @dr.davidbaker86
      @dr.davidbaker86 2 года назад +2

      That's awesome

    • @reg4211
      @reg4211 2 года назад +2

      @@dr.davidbaker86 😎🤙🏻 loving yr episodes

  • @AlexLostInWonderland
    @AlexLostInWonderland Год назад +1

    As a local history society employee I love how excited Simon is about his family history. A solid chunk of the members at my history center are people who grew up in town and want to know the history of their houses and their families and who donate family records and such when they find them. The connection to long since passed family members is a really cool, surprisingly powerful thing.

  • @edmcgowan1570
    @edmcgowan1570 2 года назад +3

    The Murderer In The Family Tree Apologist meets the Casual Criminalist! Well done, crew!

  • @rebecca7948
    @rebecca7948 2 года назад +1

    I would love a history one, there are so many interesting historical incidents that would do well with your insights.
    Plus you can always mix it up with some murders too!

  • @davidthill5403
    @davidthill5403 2 года назад +18

    In reference to surnames, my last name means “the wooden pole that attaches two or more draft animals to a load-bearing cart.” And I can’t imagine what in the hell my forebears did to get that name.

    • @zarasbazaar
      @zarasbazaar 2 года назад +5

      Perhaps they invented it and people were like "Hey, now we can attach more than one animal to a cart! This is genius!".

    • @Temiztimez
      @Temiztimez 2 года назад

      They probably just were long and slim..

    • @debbiejones7269
      @debbiejones7269 2 года назад +8

      Could be their job was making them? Trade-based surnames are pretty common.

  • @brondroid
    @brondroid 2 года назад +2

    Dear David,
    You covered this so brilliantly! Your script really brought this antique murder tale to life... Which made me wonder if you're familiar with the grisly tale of Antoine LeBlanc, of New Jersey - another grim tale from the annals of American history, which I thought you might find interesting... 😉
    Best to you all!

  • @elfdream2007
    @elfdream2007 2 года назад +5

    I'm descended from John Doane, the guy Mrs. Billings supposedly slandered. Husband is descended from John Howland, best known as the guy who fell off the Mayflower. He was obviously rescued. ;) Another ancestor was on the Speedwell, but he went back to Leidan where he died. His widow and children came to Plymouth Colony a few years later. (the other side of my family is Indigenous American. Thanksgiving is always interesting ;)

  • @toko_ribbon
    @toko_ribbon 2 года назад +2

    David-I love this episode very funny and historical! 😂👌Thou I enjoy the darker ones you’ve written including the HK and Gein one, this was a pleasant change of tone but still interesting and engaging. Cheers from Tokyo 🍻🏙

  • @sdhariwillingham5448
    @sdhariwillingham5448 2 года назад +10

    Would love to hear your take on some historical crimes like the death of Amy Dudley

  • @djdissi
    @djdissi Год назад

    David and Simon, this was so impressive... truly riveting and funnyI was glued 👏👏👏

  • @user-dg9pu4pe9d
    @user-dg9pu4pe9d 2 года назад +5

    There is always the hobby of drinking to excess and going on a ghost tour with the intent of being mean to ghosts. Best Decoding the Unknown episode.

  • @Solonneysa
    @Solonneysa 2 года назад +1

    This is great! Loved the delve into history. I found my way to true-crime because I enjoyed documentaries about people, which wound up in documentaries about history, and history is...well...rather bloody. Now I guess I like finding out about history in new places through people who sometimes do heinous things. Great script :D

  • @derekblack2000
    @derekblack2000 2 года назад +12

    You should do Ken McElroy 40 people where present when he was shot and everyone said they did not see a thing

    • @Cec9e13
      @Cec9e13 2 года назад +6

      Watching Simon learn that story would be absolute GOLD.

    • @MissBee13
      @MissBee13 2 года назад +4

      A man so dreadful, that everyone just shrugged and said, “good heavens, that bullet just didn’t like him”.

    • @christinebenson518
      @christinebenson518 2 года назад +2

      @@MissBee13 We have a town bully that my mom is convinced this will happen too. Plus, he keeps antagonizing the cops, which isn't too bright.

  • @noraelliott7304
    @noraelliott7304 2 года назад +1

    Loved your family history ,David.

  • @mattelder1971
    @mattelder1971 2 года назад +9

    I've managed to trace my family history back nearly as far, back to the late 1600s in Ireland, at least on my father's side. It really isn't that hard if you do a bit of research.

  • @ValhallaExpress9923
    @ValhallaExpress9923 2 года назад +2

    Quite literally I'll binge watch just about any content you create

  • @leonidasi6170
    @leonidasi6170 2 года назад +8

    This was the “pilgrim” character I was assigned in 5th grade. My crush was assigned to the man he killed. Anyways I got bullied so much during the few week roleplay we had that they changed my character to some old man. Good times.

  • @captmorgan3515
    @captmorgan3515 Год назад

    I’d love for any of your other channels to be seat up in this format.
    It’s so much easier to retain and keeps my attention so much better than the list of facts recited straight faced on other channels

  • @jessejoyce1295
    @jessejoyce1295 2 года назад +7

    I found this episode very interesting, it sounds like David's family history is pretty similar to my own (lots of Plymouth Colony ancestors, mine stayed in America though). Also, I prefer this to the blood and gore horror episodes, which honestly I can't always make it through if it's too awful.

    • @dr.davidbaker86
      @dr.davidbaker86 2 года назад

      :)

    • @DivideThatBy9Please
      @DivideThatBy9Please 2 года назад

      I agree! And I guess we're all distant cousins... I have three ancestors from the Mayflower too

  • @ilovejack100
    @ilovejack100 2 года назад

    I loved this history/criminalist podcast. So cool to get some historical context. We don't need that for modern crime but certainly for the crime that goes that far back. Well done!

  • @buddyzilla4557
    @buddyzilla4557 2 года назад +4

    I imagine "Independence Date" was the title of a scrapped "Epic Movie" that parodies both Alien invasion Sci-fi movies and Romcoms.

  • @BoyProdigyX
    @BoyProdigyX 2 года назад +1

    I love Jen's various "cameos". The Kathy Bates "Um, no I didn't." one was my favorite haha

  • @briarrose8154
    @briarrose8154 2 года назад +10

    I’m a mayflower society member. Its kinda fun to go to the yearly trips but it always devolves into a bizarre pissing match of who can trace back to the most settlers. Its like trying to prove who is the most inbred. Weird flex but ok 🤣

  • @mandaroberts4596
    @mandaroberts4596 2 года назад

    I love how much you talk about the love you have for your children Simon. You are an AMAZAZING dad!😁

  • @pamelamays4186
    @pamelamays4186 2 года назад +3

    "Don't podcast your crimes."
    The tips just keep on coming!

  • @dragonlover7196
    @dragonlover7196 2 года назад +1

    i love how 3/4ths of this episode is providing the context leading up to how john and john even met

  • @crystalf8102
    @crystalf8102 2 года назад +6

    Sure David we believe you
    With the family history stuff, my grandma has a journal from her families history written around 1850-1880, from ancestors in Prussia. Also many family trees. She’s let me borrow it. And it is fascinating

    • @cynthiasimpson931
      @cynthiasimpson931 2 года назад +2

      As the family's genealogist, I'd give my eyeteeth and all three livers for something like this on my family. I've got my great-grandma's farm log from the 1920s and some letters from my great-great-grandfather to my great-grandfather from between 1901 and 1910, and those are fascinating, but I'd like to read something from the mid 1800s.

    • @crystalf8102
      @crystalf8102 2 года назад +1

      @@cynthiasimpson931 it is amazing. He has his written history from his forefathers as well telling how life was like for his grandparents. The original journal, travels by horse, camels, train and boat yo end up in North America.

  • @Highest-Priestess
    @Highest-Priestess 2 года назад +2

    Loved this episode!! I've been doing some ancestry research and knew everything you were talking about, except the guy who got murdered. Baby Oceanus born on the Mayflower, the first Witch of Windsor burned at the stake, being a relative of one of the Culper Spy Ring, kissing cousins, Irish Republican Army, Presidents and politicians, so many rabbit holes. The real question is did the first husband who was killed in a silo accident, an accident, or perhaps it was murder!

  • @lostbutfreesoul
    @lostbutfreesoul 2 года назад +9

    Simon, word of advice:
    Don't answer those security questions correctly, instead answer them with a piece of information known only to you.

    • @photobombr
      @photobombr 2 года назад +1

      That's what I do now after my social medias were hacked 😂

    • @trishapellis
      @trishapellis 2 года назад +1

      The problem then, though, is that you have to remember which piece of information you used as an answer to which question where. Like, I literally caught myself with using the real name of a friend of mine whom I only ever call by a nickname.
      Me, creating my account: "Hah, let the hackers figure out that this is her name but not the name I call her all the time!"
      Me, six months later: "What do you mean it's not her name? I was sure it was her name. Would I have picked another friend's name? What's going on? Has someone hacked my account and changed my answers to these questions?"
      Big brain.

    • @mschaefer4656
      @mschaefer4656 2 года назад +1

      Or ... make up a different identity specifically for security questions. Such as - for reservations and coffee orders, I go by something like "Mary Jones." No one ever asks me to spell it or mispronounces it - quick, easy, less hassle for everyone. I gave old "Mary" an odd maiden name, and odd favorite things - her tastes never change, unlike mine that change constantly - it's easier to remember, and hackers be damned.

  • @kalvds9345
    @kalvds9345 2 года назад

    Love this one Simon, thanks for making it!

  • @lizzyfp3542
    @lizzyfp3542 2 года назад +5

    Havent heard from Callum in a while, he must have escaped the basement!!

  • @lordofdunvegan6924
    @lordofdunvegan6924 2 года назад

    Great vid, Simon. Informative and entertaining.

  • @maryscott9430
    @maryscott9430 2 года назад +10

    Aww jen you used Sean Connery in a clip!❤️ my grandpa looked so much like him that people stopped him daily for autographs. My grandpa even dressed like his charecter dressed in indiana jones! Hes passed now, but it makes my heart happy seeing pics of sean connery, esp from those movies. Thank you jen for that moment, in an otherwise messed up murder video. I dont know how ive never heard this case!!

    • @JK-gm6kk
      @JK-gm6kk Год назад

      Did your gpa pull with the ladies, that you know of?

    • @maryscott9430
      @maryscott9430 Год назад

      @@JK-gm6kk yes he did. He was dashing and so charismatic!