Vancouver woman fighting Stage 4 cancer denied medically-assisted death at Catholic hospital
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 17 окт 2024
- A cancer patient was forced to transfer from a Catholic-affiliated hospital for MAID. Shannon Paterson hears from the family who's outraged.
Subscribe to CTV News to watch more videos: / ctvnews
Connect with CTV News:
For the latest news visit: www.ctvnews.ca/
For a full video offering visit the CTV News Network: www.ctvnews.ca/...
CTV News on Facebook: / ctvnews
CTV News on TikTok: www.tiktok.com...
CTV News on Twitter: / ctvnews
CTV News on Instagram: / ctvnews
CTV News on Reddit: / ctvnews
---
CTV News is Canada's most-watched news organization both locally and nationally, and has a network of national, international, and local news operations.
I think the hospital should be free to choose based on their beliefs but the person and her family should be able to take of it them selfs.
All these stories are designed to encourage maid and make it sound like it's so needed
This story is exposing the desire of the establishment to rid our culture of any Judeo-Christian values and any influence from Judeo-Christian institutions.
Don't use their words. It's called suicide.
@@anyfriendofkevinbaconisafr177 totally 👌
You want to die while *stoically battling cancer, ALS etc, and endure pain that is absolutely inconceivable, that is absolutely your right. But it is also every single individual's right to have a dignified, pain free death where they don't have to suffer the horrible attrocities that accompany these diagnosis's.
As someone who has done research on this for a research paper, I can confidently say that it isn’t just “suicide.” I am part of Hope Squad which works to prevent suicide, but I strongly believe in MAID. It isn’t about ending it all, it’s about going out with dignity and taking control of what happens to you no matter your situation. I understand that religion can change someone’s perspective on this, but there is a lot of evidence and arguments that fight against these beliefs. I encourage you to research and understand both sides.
Congrats to the hospital for sticking with their principles.
Dear BC government thank you for the religious exception to this barbaric practice.
*principles ....Or did you mean the province supports school principals?
I hope you can someday develop a sense of what ethical behavior really is and practice it. Your ideology is truly monstrous.
Oh please. I'm a Catholic and this is getting ridiculous.
Ur sick
I am sorry for your loss.
Well in this case the hospital has the right. It is a privately funded hospital that doesn't believe in suicide. They should have the right to refuse this service and not being forced by law.
I am extremely sorry for this young lady situation, and I pray she gets what she needs. However, you cannot shame and bully a Catholic institution, who believes in the sanctity of life from birth to natural death they would not provide abortions not medically assisted suicide. They operate under a religious charter for healthcare. They provide healthcare to the public and they receive funding, but they don’t have to provide care or a service that goes against their religious beliefs and that is protected. That is not in their mandate and they have every right to exercise that religious principal. They are not the beholden to patients to provide that service, and if they have to transfer them to get it it’s within the rights to do it. Why do news services feel the need to shame Catholic healthcare institutions for not providing a service that they know, goes against their fundamental beliefs? The parents calling it an idiotic policy, shows their lack of respect for this institution. If she was transferred to a facility that can provide it what is the issue? Why are they making such a shame and bully situation for services they have a religious mandate to not provide. Providence healthcare has the right to refuse services that goes against their religious beliefs. Patient may not like that and they will always guide them to services were they will be provided. But this is just ridiculous and shame on the news for making this a problem.
So it's ok that priests sexually abuse CHILDREN, but it's not ok for a dying women in PAIN to end her life? Oh and by the way, I AM Catholic.
@@gsdmomb530no you're not you're Jewish
@@gsdmomb530 yes we all know the bad situation and so did Anglicans and so did other denominations do that you cannot use that to conflate it. The lady was transferred over to another facility and gave her MAID so what is the problem? The religious charter of the hospital states that they believe in the sanctity of life from birth to its natural end and ending it with MAID is goes against their charter. They took her to a facility, where that would be given to her. Your argument would have better weight if you could provide evidence that they refused to transfer her to a facility where she would receive that care. It’s called continuity of care and continuity of care mandates if you cannot provide the service you transferred to a site where it will be and that’s exactly what providence healthcare did. There was no violation of her rights as a patient and she got the service that she was requesting.
@@gsdmomb530who said it was ok for priests to abuse children lol you’re the only one saying that
Recovering Catholic, you mean. 🤣
R.I.P.
Whats a "Catholic" hospital? Who runs it?
The pope
Most hospitals were started by Catholics lol
CATHOLICS. The clue is in the SAINT patron in the title. Look up Providence Health care.
That poor mother feels like she has to continue to defend her daughters dying choice. After the tragedy of seeing your child through the pain of a terminal illness, no parent should have to endure this on top of it. When righteousness gets in the way of rights it's very very wrong.
Idiotic policy?!!! It's our religious belief. Have some decency of respect for our beliefs even when you clearly have no respect for life.
Respect for life? Seeing a terminally ill woman die in agony? Wow such respect! 🤡
My dad was offended that someone asked him this once in hospital. He told them no its against my religion beliefs
Cool. It's against his own beliefs. He can choose not to. Don't impose yours on others.
It’s a private hospital. If you don’t like the service go somewhere else. It sticks but out in BC this is what two tier healthcare looks like
it's not a private hospital at all.
Canada has universal care?? That means taxes pay for it.
If you believe in the afterlife and the souls process in death, I think it's much better to let someone pass in hospice with the right medication. Rather than forcing death (AKA MURDER) to end life earlier than it is meant to be.
Believe in LOL
Sounds sadistic.
Ridiculous!
Exodus 20:13
English Standard Version
13 “You shall not murder.
No mercy
Religious beliefs are now idiotic policy lol wtf
Unbelievable eh?!
These folks are deluded by their tragic grief. They need our prayers.
It's a private hospital so I have to agree with the hospital here, I mean they knew it was Catholic hospital. If they transferred her then that got what they wanted. So they are trying to push their beliefs and make this hospital do stuff like this, I definitely disagree. Especially when there are other places that do it. Thats why we have options.
it's not a private hospital. where did you get that idea?
I always read that the patient had to be able to assist themselves with the medication’s that are given to self unaliving? That, the patient has to be able to take the concoction on their own?? Hence, assisted and not Jack Kevorkian type stuff🤨. They said she never came out of being unconscious! So who actually gave her the concoction and does that mean it was murder? I guess the laws are different there.
keep this thought in mind blasphemy and denial of the Holy Spirit is unforgivable Suicide is unforgivable because once it is done there's No repentance. its was bad enough to be in an Occult like the vatican for her to hear a priest denying Calvary took place every time he claims the power to forgive sin, what this pathetic society has wiped away is Accountability and Consequences! everything a person says thinks and dose every motive even dreams are brought into the light of judgement, and when that priest denies Calvary took place and the other agrees to it both are guilty of denying Calvary and there is no repentance just pointless lip service and both walk in condemnation! the judgement that he believed a priest and rejected Gods word and depart from me after giving an account for their actions!
That is stupid that should change.
Religious people......I'm sure we can do much better without them !!
Your bigotry and intolerance is noted.
You are so bigoted and deluded.
I hope they didn't harvest her organs while she was still alive.........as per their MAID contract
There is no "MAiD contract" that stipulates the donation of organs. In fact a person who chooses MAiD rarely even knows that donating their organs is an option. And given that her body was riddled with cancer, she wouldn't have been a candidate for organ donation anyways
@@tommygirl6659 you are incorrect
@@thehazelnutspread How so? I have done a ton of research into this, so please tell me where I'm wrong
@@tommygirl6659 I did respond but it seems to have disappeared. I'll try again
@@tommygirl6659 my replies keep getting deleted
Its a riliogion cromazone
Happy birthday cancer is when u wernt born on the light side gota change religion bible is on the light side
Religious beliefs should only effect an individuals private life/choices. When it comes to choices that effect others/the public, then we need separation of church and state, so that we can be inclusive to all different kinds of individuals.
This report hit me hard, and I want to express my condolences. I hope that access to maid becomes available in public health care for those with terminal illnesses.
It is a private catholic hospital and they chose to put their dying child there to be euthanised. This begs the question on how much research they made before they chose this hospital like??? Then they go on tv to complain. That's lunatic behaviour.
What about the personal beliefes of a health worker? How far can you force them to do as they are ordered against their beliefes?
This is stupid.
You cannot divorce human dignity to some stupid, self contradictory, baseless, humanistic principle that has no value according to itself.
You cannot justify ANYTHING objective about morality without relying on Theistic ideas.
🙏🙏🙏😔😔😔🙏🙏🙏
Happy birthday cancer
Traumatic for both the Patient looking for comfort and peace before final hours and for the Parents (loved ones) who brought her into this world/loved her dearly. When the System/Institutions make these decisions, they seem to forget that they not only traumatize the patient but they go on to traumatize the loved ones around them. Often times non-traumatized individuals become traumatized after these situations and it costs the system more. Impact is key. I feel embarrassed for our System.
Where is the mention of the hospital sticking to its principles?
😥😥😥😥😥
💞💞💞💞💞