Why I ditched Fractal for good.

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 17 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 71

  • @mattwright466
    @mattwright466  17 дней назад +3

    I get $10 every time someone comments XYZ is better before watching the whole video. 😂
    NOTE: This video was not paid for or sponsored in any way whatsoever. I bought all of the equipment with my own money and these are my own opinions.

  • @baimun
    @baimun 17 дней назад +4

    As a singer/guitarist, the Kemper Stage was a gigging godsend the week it was released. I set five different sounds per band/gig/venue from crystal clean, Matchless clean, maybe an 80's chorus or funk sound, Marshall rhythm, and Soldano solo... then I use the morph as "More" so each sound will have a combination of solo boost, wetter delays or whatever is needed to step forward when using that tone (without having to look down and tapdance). What also made a huge difference was loading up Michael Britt profiles that were gig ready with some favorite Matchless or Soldano tones even before the Rig Exchange was a thing. I've also changed the order of the delay/reverb/always on effects loop in the effects block so I can easily patch my external looper for solo gigs and each looped track is after the cab sim. ☮💜🎶

    • @mattwright466
      @mattwright466  17 дней назад

      It's so EASYYYYYYY, right? :D

    • @baimun
      @baimun 17 дней назад +1

      @@mattwright466 Absolutely! When I'm not running direct to FOH, I run the monitor out to the FX return on a Mesa tube combo so I have a guitar cabinet over my shoulder instead of an FRFR and everything feels natural with knobs and not like I've been poking at menus in an application. ☮💜🎶

  • @buddyslowhand7647
    @buddyslowhand7647 2 дня назад +1

    I absolutely feel the same about the Kemper. It's so much easier to use because you don't have to tweak a lot. But nonetheless it's incredibly versatile, if you want.

  • @poulwinther
    @poulwinther 15 дней назад +2

    For a lot less money you could get ToneX and VP4 though, to have superior captures and the best effects - on a smaller board. (You may need to add a Mimiq for the doubling but it's still not much money or space). If you ever had stage divers you would not want that huge exp. Kemper board out front.

    • @mattwright466
      @mattwright466  14 дней назад

      The problem with that setup is if you need to switch multiple amps and effects instantly. You cannot do it with that setup.
      For example: Distortion guitar + chor and delay on --> Acoustic only.

    • @poulwinther
      @poulwinther 14 дней назад +1

      @@mattwright466 I don't think I understand? You just need a simple midi board out front (with a single cable or even Bluetooth if you dare) which saves your gear from getting trampled on. I think it was in 89 I learned that the hard way playing the metal club circuit.
      Anyway, just a suggestion.

  • @2550marshall
    @2550marshall 17 дней назад +4

    Congrats on finding the gear that works best for you. I did the opposite. I had a Kemper Stage and then got a Fractal Axe FX III. I sold my Kemper the next day. I purchased the kemper for the profiling. It did that job horribly, which can be summed up in one word...inconsistent. I have a Tonex and it does the profiling thing ...perfectly.... every time. The key to using a Fractal are 3 things: 1) find the right IR (factory ones IMHO-Suck), 2) Make sure you are using the correct Speaker Impedance Curve for the IR you choose and 3) roll tubes and adjust bias as you would in a real amp.

    • @mattwright466
      @mattwright466  17 дней назад +2

      Sure - But where would I find any of that info? lol
      Fractal does a horrible job educating their customers about this stuff.

    • @2550marshall
      @2550marshall 16 дней назад +1

      @@mattwright466 That is understandable. There is just so much that it can do it could be overwhelming to some users. When it comes to sculpting amp/cab tones with the Fractal it helps a lot if you have real world experience. For instance, I have been a long-time real Marshall amp user. When I looked at the power tube bias at the factory setting of 50% I knew that was wrong. They may ship new that way but bumping that bias up to 65-70% does the job. If you want to do that AC/DC thing then bump that bias up to 85-90% and don't have to worry about blowing your tubes.

    • @mattwright466
      @mattwright466  16 дней назад

      @@2550marshall Amazing comment! :-)

  • @208414
    @208414 17 дней назад +1

    You don't need an external expression pedal to fade in and out effects on a Fractal device. There are internal modifiers that can be mapped to effect parameters and you can control the ramp rates and whatnot. It is a more advanced bit of programming, but totally doable if you take a few minutes to read the manual or watch a RUclips tutorial.

    • @mattwright466
      @mattwright466  17 дней назад +1

      Exactly- More advanced programming.

  • @Harrysound
    @Harrysound 17 дней назад +2

    Axe change is available directly inside Axe Edit. You can audition other people presets without any of the complications you mention here. Not saying other peoples presets are any good though.
    Sounds to me like you just want to play rather than faff around.

  • @nele4470
    @nele4470 16 дней назад +1

    Great video! btw I did same for me Kemper sounds great. I owned all fas products and never worked for me.

  • @StoneXue
    @StoneXue 17 дней назад +5

    At this point pretty much everyone has an opinion of what works best for them. The beauty of the age we live in is there are so many choices. Go full stack traditional with traditional pedals, go hybrid, go Kemper, L6, Fractal, ToneX, Headrush, QC and everyones ear thinks one of these is best and if that works for you then it is the best.

    • @mattwright466
      @mattwright466  17 дней назад +1

      Somebody gets the point of the video! Gold star for you! ⭐

  • @AlbertFrontier2
    @AlbertFrontier2 15 дней назад +1

    I use my Mesa Mark IV and one pedal (delay), I am glad did not fall for the modellers hype. I just want one tone well done, Mesa gives me that.

    • @mattwright466
      @mattwright466  15 дней назад

      Nice. Check out the tone demos at the end of the video and lemme know your thoughts.
      They're Revv Generator, not Mesa, but I'm not really a big fan of how a lot of the Mesa stuff sounds in low mids.

  • @jonalexander8935
    @jonalexander8935 17 дней назад +1

    It's sad we have to defend our rigs. We are all different. The people that bark the loudest are the ones that don't have a clue. Great video. Love my Kemper because it works for me!

  • @Davidlovesmusic311
    @Davidlovesmusic311 16 дней назад +1

    I get your pain I spend more time trying to dial in tones on digital stuff when I went right back to my tube amps then I can capture montonexe or whatever when I want but I definitely get where you're coming from

  • @mrchrisbeaver
    @mrchrisbeaver 17 дней назад +1

    Kemper added a fixed latency around 12 years ago, at the time some people were complaining that when reamping using different profiles with the same stem there was a phasing issue when combined as the latency would change pending on what you had loaded so Christoph added the constant latency mode

  • @ericajohnson7535
    @ericajohnson7535 17 дней назад

    I am a fan of scribble strips, once you use them, they are just so convenient

  • @SamHooperGroup
    @SamHooperGroup День назад +1

    Awesome information! Thanks

  • @guitartoneSA
    @guitartoneSA 16 дней назад

    On the Kemper Player you have five switches, 1/2/3 and dual 1/2 and 2/3.
    Plus if you add a two switcher pedal for $20.00 you'll have seven switches.
    And that's the stock Player with no paid upgrades.

    • @mattwright466
      @mattwright466  14 дней назад

      You're totally correct - The only reason it doesn't work for me is if I add an external switch, I block the MIDI in function. So, the Stage makes more sense for me. :-)
      Also, call me crazy, but 1/2 and 2/3 is absolutely silly. They should just do hold functions like virtually every other pedal on the market lol

    • @guitartoneSA
      @guitartoneSA 14 дней назад

      @mattwright466
      I agree the Stage is definitely a better option for you. 👍

  • @KingdomOfHydra
    @KingdomOfHydra 17 дней назад

    Hi Matt!
    I was stoked when receiving your mail when releasing a new Video! I saw a high quality picture with the Kemper and Fractal in it!!
    Soooo I pushed immediately on the link.
    The first thing you mention was spot on! A lot of players buy Fractal because of their guitar heroes! Petrucci, Dave Murray,Metallica, Def Leppard… list goes on! because all those big artist using it!
    Yeah they are 100’s of different amps to use,a lot of effects .. but a HUGE amount of parameters! You can tweak.. and tweak.. and tweak.. -> years later… hmmm 🤔 I think I’ve got my sound… then there is a new update… so re-tweak everything..
    You made very interesting topics on difference in Kemper/Fractal! I see why a lot of people makes the change on that. Like useage on footswitches.. also Kemper can used with an mobile App something what fractal doesn’t have (not officially)
    So big thanks for making things clear! So when thinking by myself.. Will Matt doing an Comparison! And YES Offcourse! I was blown away on the Kemper test! That sound was huge! I thought that the fractal would sound better! But 🤔.. it was so thin.. not really what I expected! Blown away by that Kemper sound!
    So Matt! Thanks for this video! I really enjoy it! Please keep making those!
    for people who didn’t know that much about Matt! He is a very honest and a very great guitar player!
    He has also a course on “Perfect Picking”!
    His knowledge is HUGE! His videos are not just a post! It’s always with the intention to make you a better player! He shows a lot of what to do and what not! Like holding everything correctly. He talked to a lot of neurologists. Every moves you make is because of bones and muscles. To it’s very cool to listen to his talk!
    If I had known this man so many years earlier! I would definitely be a better player!
    I support Matt on his work! Please give him a follow on RUclips,Instagram.. he also responds very quickly!
    Big respect!
    Jason.

    • @PondoSinatra680
      @PondoSinatra680 17 дней назад

      I think we found Matt’s second account.

  • @208414
    @208414 17 дней назад +1

    At the end of the day you should use what works for you and what inspires you to play.

  • @GrantConklin
    @GrantConklin 17 дней назад +1

    If your ears are 6 feet away from the speaker, this adds another 6.6 ms of latency. Is this really perceptible?

    • @mattwright466
      @mattwright466  17 дней назад

      Key word...! Adds! So you still end up with the same latency advantage. Shop by your needs.
      If you get a chance to really spend time with a Kemper, I highly recommend it. If I was lying, I wouldn't have stories of three other experienced musicians to reference... Plus measurement data.

    • @ericajohnson7535
      @ericajohnson7535 17 дней назад

      with time latency will be 1ms. for now it all adds up. The more stuff you add to your preset, the slower it gets on most modellers. Add to that the latency from the digital mixer, to PA or your in-ears....

    • @GrantConklin
      @GrantConklin 16 дней назад +1

      @@mattwright466 I'm not saying you're lying. I'm a sound guy, not a guitarist. I would challenge people to spend time listening at 3 feet vs. 9 feet to see if they can percieve that latency difference. If 2 sounds are playing simultaniously with differing latencies, it will be percieved as smearing the sound, or adding something funky to the sound. But to actually notice the differences when listening only to 1 sound at a time, with different latencies... I don't think I personlly could detect a 5 ms difference. 30ms probably. But then again, if one feels the guitar vibrating, and hears the sound coming 5ms later... That could account for the perception.

    • @mattwright466
      @mattwright466  16 дней назад

      @@GrantConklin Great insight. I guess a counterargument to that would be... What kind of smearing happens when I'm playing with my band?
      Keyboards is running a laptop with Kontact patches. I'm running Kemper. Singer is a mic DI, and drums are not mic'ed for now. Interesting q...
      Typically, my Headrush cab is just pointed directly at me and I'm spending time quite close to it. To be clear, I don't expect the Headrush to be sound-accurate like my Yamaha monitors... I want it to be cheap and loud. lol

  • @kirkwilliams4942
    @kirkwilliams4942 18 дней назад

    Hey Matt, have you tried the Hedrush Core or Prime? I'm looking at the Core and a SurfyBear Metal Spring reverb.

    • @mattwright466
      @mattwright466  18 дней назад

      I have not! None of my local friends have had them, but what I've seen on Headrush looks great. Latency is low and a good friend of mind in a touring band uses Headrush live.
      I'm always open to trying something new, but plenty happy on Kemper for now. :-)

  • @parmeshgurung
    @parmeshgurung 14 дней назад +1

    Fractal fanboys are gonna rip you apart :D

  • @justmehere6094
    @justmehere6094 17 дней назад

    I ran both for quite awhile, back in Axe FX 2 days. I kept to the Fractal for several actual reasons. 1. The Kemper's limited routing capability just wasn't sufficient. 2. It was only as good as the profiles and profiler that made them. SO, SO many that are just awful, including those I made. 3. Needing multiple Profiles to get the true range of eq interaction, gain structure and response of an amp. 4, No abilty in Kemper to more or less create my own FX pedal, or even amp. With the fractal having toe ability to change down to essentially the circuit level I could.5. Kemper software was just useless.

    • @mattwright466
      @mattwright466  14 дней назад

      And that's why this video isn't about one being better than another - It's about decision making, and how I made my decision.
      Routing on the AXE FX III is definitely superior to any Kemper unit, but it's beyond what I need.
      I am very happy with the outputs I get from Stereo + SPDIF and the different stack options.

  • @musiccreation1198
    @musiccreation1198 16 дней назад

    Whatever works best for you, cool...but I can't imagine making such a move.

  • @algorithm007ify
    @algorithm007ify 17 дней назад +2

    Kemper is better...as someone who had both. Also, Kemper is assembled in Germany, not China (like Fractal). The selling point for Kemper are the great profiles, liquid profiling, Kemper Kone (cab in the room simulation), and clear/simple workflow. The Player is also amazing, with wireless/bt editing. I can also confirm that the latency is much better with Kemper...feels more "real".

  • @shorerocks
    @shorerocks 17 дней назад +2

    To me, there is only one prio: The amp sound. Kemper, to this date, for me, is #1. Then, why does PLINI not play one? One of the greatest instrumental song writers and player? Well, because for the longest time he never played a tube amp (got that from an Intevals interview). What happens, if you are young, and don't have the budget, today you use plugins, as it is the most affordable entry point. Therefore THAT sound you hear of a "Marshall" model becomes your REFERENCE. So, the whole perception on what a good amp tone is changed for the generations to come. Mind you, I am not criticizing. I remember what an immense effort it was to buy my first Marshall Artist 30W / cab back in 1987. After decades playing tube amps and transistor amps, in rehearsal, loud and very loud, recording more or less successfully, of course my reference is the real amp, not the modelled / emulated one. I cannot undo this. And I do not need to, ha ha. One advantage in being an old fart is you can just buy what you want (and the wife allows). Cheers from Germany!

    • @mattwright466
      @mattwright466  17 дней назад

      He may not play one for sheer convenience. Fractal just came out with the VP4... So now you can have Fractal FX with Kemper amp sound. Theoretically, you could send MIDI commends to a Kemper player AND to a Fractal VP4 on one rig... It would just be stupid complicated.
      I have spent a little time on real amps. The latency is interesting. They're faster because there's no oversampling.
      Also, size is a huge factor for a lot of people.
      A huge driver for me not using a real amp is 1) flexibility 2) direct recording (and limited processing after the fact) and 3) size.
      --------
      I've got a German pedalboard and now a German car. Can't wait to visit one day!

    • @Vertigo504
      @Vertigo504 16 дней назад

      Plini doesn't play one because he is a neural dsp artist (quad cortex)

  • @hexchad765
    @hexchad765 17 дней назад +4

    eh, buddy, fractal has the Axe Exhcnage built right into the interface of axe-fx-edit. It also has "AUdition"

    • @mattwright466
      @mattwright466  16 дней назад

      My bad. Never new.
      I'm aware of the audition feature. It's clunky. They should just add a damn "next" button to increment and decrement the cabs...
      And that same critique goes to Kemper.

  • @BaianoPR
    @BaianoPR 17 дней назад

    Congratulations, you found the "reasons" to stay with Kemper. I suggest doing a blind AB test to see if you can really notice the difference in latency.

  • @cx019
    @cx019 15 дней назад

    I love modellers like the fractal and especially kemper but they are just too expensive for me. :(

    • @mattwright466
      @mattwright466  15 дней назад +1

      I got my FM3 kit financed through Affirm. :-)
      Interest is very tolerable and applications are easy.
      Just don't get yourself in too deep!

    • @cx019
      @cx019 15 дней назад

      @mattwright466 nah, i will save up further. For the moment i have several amps and cabs plus vsts for recording. Nothing beats my Jim roots Terror with my k100 loaded framus 4x12. :)
      Maybe the Kemper will replace the VST for recording someday.

    • @cx019
      @cx019 15 дней назад

      And if i really wanted, i could buy a Kemper. But i think i use it not enough to justify such a big purchase.

  • @nicolasrivera5310
    @nicolasrivera5310 17 дней назад +3

    🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @TrumpetsInMy4x12
    @TrumpetsInMy4x12 17 дней назад

    Kemper modern high gain tones are terrible comparatively. Having a Headrush turd in your jam room isn't helping your argument.

    • @mattwright466
      @mattwright466  17 дней назад

      1. Why do you not like the Kemper high gain tones? I am very happy with them. Lots of demos at the end of this vid too.
      2. All tone dialing was done on the Yamaha HS5's. :-)
      3. All recordings in this video were done direct into DAW.

  • @crockettproject7278
    @crockettproject7278 15 дней назад

    I have an FM3. I absolutely love it. the best tone I’ve ever had I think what it boils down to is. Everyone is different and has different needs. I thought about using the Kemper player for church, but as I looked into it, they charge you for upgrades or levels of upgrades

    • @mattwright466
      @mattwright466  15 дней назад +1

      Only on the Player are there paid upgrades.
      As a marketer, I really don't love the way they rolled it out... I think it's unclear especially to prospective users of the system..

    • @mattwright466
      @mattwright466  15 дней назад

      Sometimes you just have to get a hands on and try it out.

  • @justmehere6094
    @justmehere6094 17 дней назад

    Odd, you start off, denigrating lookg at who uses a particular device. Then you give a 'pro kemper' story touting how a 'pro musician' liked the Kemper better. Just going to point out there are incorrect statements in this video, One doesn't need an expression pedal to do the equivalent of a morph. Axe exchange can be accessed from Axe Edit, just like mentioned for Kemper.

  • @ericajohnson7535
    @ericajohnson7535 17 дней назад

    XYZ floor is better!

  • @Returnality
    @Returnality 16 дней назад

    I never liked the sounds from Kemper and I can’t support them in any way after their scummy business decisions.

    • @mattwright466
      @mattwright466  15 дней назад

      Are you talking about their pricing for the Player?
      Size is not connected to value in any way. I think a lot of people are seeing it that way and it's silly.
      **That said, I do think the general starting price should be lower for the Player.**
      BUT, after paying for upgrades, it classes ridiculously close to the FM3... And it's smaller. And you won't hit processing power limits.

    • @Returnality
      @Returnality 15 дней назад

      @@mattwright466 Charging extra for capabilities that a unit already had is a wretched business practice and you're absolutely kidding yourself if you think that's good for the market. No other manfucaturer has done that, only Kemper. They are uniquely scummy.

  • @petergrohmuller1372
    @petergrohmuller1372 16 дней назад

    „Why I ditched Fractal for good“. Maybe you're paid for this statement. Right?😊

    • @mattwright466
      @mattwright466  15 дней назад +1

      No. Not paid.

    • @petergrohmuller1372
      @petergrohmuller1372 15 дней назад

      @@mattwright466 That was a joke on my part, of course. 😊 I bought the FM9 for about a year and a half ago and haven't used a physical tube amp since there. The sound of the amp simulations is fantastic. However, if you "only" want to use the incredibly good effects from Fractal Audio on a real amp, the VP4 Virtual Pedalboard is now/soon available. In the end, I think it's a matter of taste which system you choose.