DRIVEN #1: Toyota Vios vs Proton Suprima S vs Honda Jazz Hybrid
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 окт 2024
- Driven is back! In this episode, we compare the new Toyota Vios, Proton Suprima S and Honda Jazz Hybrid. Which one should you spend your money on? Shock verdict awaits. Read more Malaysian car news and reviews at paultan.org/
I think the Suprima S is a good car despite what they say, it had a look and feel of a serious car, but sadly, its too heavy which really bog down fuel efficiency :(
Malaysia is not a place where fuel is cheap, but consider Vios had aftermarket value, is no surprise lo...... Stil I thinking of Suprima S as a good choice for those who wants a less expensive sporty ride. Just prepare to burn some cash......
sorry to be offtopic but does anyone know a tool to log back into an instagram account??
I was dumb forgot the login password. I would love any tricks you can offer me!
@Brady Korbin Instablaster ;)
Hey guys, seriously, not a bad review show, keep up the good work and you got yourself another subscriber! loved the ending btw.. good laugh!
their point are more focus onto fuel consumption thus make vios a winner but 6 airbags + ABS + EBD + ESC + Hill Assist + price + Handling + safety + 5 star ANCAP are not important. alasan turbo + fuel economy are not practical
Bought this car (suprima S) 2nd hand last year as my first car. After 1 year of use. It is comfortable and sporty at the same time. Depends on tour driving style. For me as a hot blooded in the 20’s i really like as the pick up of the car started from 2000 rpm. And always blasted the car at Bukit Jambul at 3 am for a touge session 😂. The handling is superb, the power have enough pokeyness for and enjoyable driving pleasure. Keep the good work proton
Bro so far how's the car any issues?
Good beginning Paul and your team, kudos and very entertaining (especially the dress up part...LOLx)
Enjoyed this episode very much. Refreshing to see a fair review of the cars and love the ending! Hahaha
well done! simple, informative & well-edited clip. i (probably most malaysian) honestly waited this kind of local reviews. love the last part too. good job!
Can't really compare those three cars together, very very different car segment all together. A hatchback vs a sedan vs a hybrid? are you kidding me? Just because they all have quite the same price and you want to compare them? No, just no.
still you just can't compare them fairly
aiya, buy silvia or evo lh. can drift sumore. lol!
Anecdotal experience: most people buy cars based on the budget they can fork out, car segments are secondary. Bad comparison, techinically, but practical in Msia.
well yeah i think i could agree to that
***** i think what Azwad SW were saying is not about the budget but instead about the car segment
The last part is hilarious!! Good Job!
Good job guys! good review i must say. Practice to present more naturally in the future. and the intro need a bit of work. Presenters blocked the car during the intro. I love the ending! Harvinder looks very elegant in that white dress! lol
looking forward for your next reviews
nice one Paul Tan. Hopefully Driven will always give honest review to us!
harvinder u crazy singh...u made my computer screen smothered with coffee!!!!
was this show on TV? superb car show, very interesting, informative and proffesional.
ok, the last part is definately the goodies~ well done guys!
To be honest, Good review but bad representation. You guys should speak more naturally and confidently, and I think Harvinder did that right. But nonetheless, keep it up guys. Would really like to see Driven getting more and more popular. (Y)
Do agree, a little bit too stiff on the presentation, but it's acceptable as they are car reviewers, not actors.
yea not actors we need some real of you guys
I would love to see free speech because it really looked like its heavily scripted. The concept is great, its okay to add a bit of top gear flavor into it.
The ending, speechless because its awesome. Haha
Good job guys. Keep it coming. For those who want more info,pls read up on paultan. Dont expect this video to tell a lot about what u want.
for me, subject to what u want, if you are girl, go for Jazz, if your mindset like your grandma or grandpa-it should be toyota (& no one can change grandpa mindset), if you like fast, suprima turbo is the choice (if you are young & does not care of the engine sound).
well done guys.. finally a malaysian car review that is worth watching..
I really see Vios as the winner just because of the stable gearbox and better interior. But I do think, this is a victory for Proton in any way because they proved that Proton is improving. Only thing they whine about is the gearbox and the interior. Good power, good ride and handling, and all the safety features in Proton.
As the old saying says, The engine and the gearbox is the heart of a car. There is no point having so many things with a bad heart.
Lol, those words are true in every car, except when it have the Proton logo. Now, just imagined that Suprima is Vios and vice versa, will people will still say the words that you have stated? Or they just starts bitching about safety, boring bla bla bla bla?
Dzulhelmi Ismail kecoh la dizul.. wakakak
gungrave10 Without the protection of Cukai Eksaiz, Proton is losing on every aspect
Not really. Proton remains the cheapest between these three brands. Proof? Open all these three company official website from Australia and compare the prices.
great to see a car review video from our homeland... keep it up!!
The ending is hilarious!! Nice!! Keep it up!!!
Great stuffs guys! Certainly love the last part :) Looking forward for more!
Glad to see this and looking forward to next episode.
Next... lets look at price range between 60k to 80k? Love the last 'image test' part! :D :D :D
And yea... I'd probably go for Vios too among this 3 cars.
Love to see their review...keep it up !!
Nk ckp suprima tu ini..yg lancer sportback pon tiru bulat2 yg sedan punye tak pk lak.dpn sme sbjik..blkg je lain..dashboard dlm pon plastic korang tanak bising lak..puiiihhhhj
I love that Vios even more, because the style, the space, and the performance as well, compare of Suprima, and Jazz. Way to go!
little suggest here , You can change the number plate to the DRIVEN logo , because is make me keep looking at the WXY468 =D and I m so happy to have this kind of video from Malaysia , Thumbs up
Harvinder is a lot more natural than the two other hosts. Taper down the euphemisms, sometimes straight forward use of words works better . sounds a bit scripted but im sure you guys will improve . keep it up .
The awesome ending earned you a subscriber.
Haha, I like the IMAGE TEST... Great job, guys!
Good effort! I I guess what a lot of folks here were expecting was something very Top Gear-esque, but it's very reminiscent of the first two seasons of the Top Gear reboot.
So a buddy and I were being arm-chair critics and wanted to add a few comments.
1) Lapel mics, get them
2) Transitions are a bit too janky and the walks into the cameraview just don't feel right
3) Some friendly banter maybe? (I know it's the TopGear-expectation, but a little more, "My car is better than your car!" may work well.)
LOL at least you guys made me laugh la, good job overall, thanks guys :)
Nice to see some Malaysian car reviews for a change
Good job guys.... This is a very good start for Malaysia's automotive video review! Would be better if the cars can be expressed like how you write your reviews, which is much more instinctive, not just relying too much upon the facts as those are well documented in your posts... don't try too hard when presenting, just be yourself :) good luck!
i hope to see the 1 series, v40, a250 review one day!
i would to watch the comparison between Nissan Almera, Toyota Vios and Honda City, I think this will be fair, sedan segment
good pilot episode.
but i would prefer they stick with their initial car at least 2/3 of the time.
hafriz - suprima
harvinder - vios
paul jazz-
then suddenly changed to harvinder - suprima: hafriz - jazz: paul - vios.
then for driving, another change :(
One thing that makes me proud of proton is handling...so far i could say proton handling.is way better than vios and city which are bit dull...... I know the quality always been issue for proton.... for me,proton should improve build quality,material wise and SC if they want to be on par with their competitors.
LOL~ I literally LOL at the ending there! Good stuff guys! XD
hahaha! last part very funny. nice idea and concept. the video quality can be improve! keep it up! :)
I just love the looks of the Proton Suprima S. It is top notch. Wow Harv you don't look like the female type do you? Awesome guys.
"the G will tickle your spot" i see what you did there hahaha i like the last bit though very creative but if you guys are gonna do this review the top gear way i think it should be more casual and less scripted. cheers for the review and comparison
They do not think in terms of safety, they just thought of only in terms of fuel economy, it is the reason why they chose vios, which turned out in terms of security, there is no comparative with SUPRIMA s, it is the mentality of people now, more concerned with the economy of salvation.
It's funny because now they champion safety.
salam hey love your reviews but a more natural casual review would b better without the scripts.. also you guys could take the opportunity to highlight some beautiful areas or scenery that people would enjoy driving.. great job
The dubstep music is just pure awesome, I need to know the name and the artist.
Major improvements on proton...I am really proud :)
suprima is better than vios. honda n suprima hurmm. the drive experience. i choose suprima. i drove all the cars n i know how the feel..
Without the protection and cukai eksaiz Suprima will lose badly on the price comparison
Kai Meng Chee Dude U dunno Proton also got Tax? High As 85%??? PS:If I didt rmb wrong
benrt hecht pakai 5 tahun 6 tahun da bunyi2 sana sini , itu proton , ak ada proton dri 90 an lg , thu mcm mana , nk jual tkda value , ak stick ngn imporrt jer lepas ne , da frust
Selambee moon kenapa beli kereta mesti kaitkan resale value? mmg kita beli kereta untuk dijual balik ke? mmg kita beli kereta semata2 kerana RV? saya punya "imported" car pun banyak bunyi selepas 5 tahun ke atas mmg lumrah la bangs
suprima mmg power dan selamat..torque dia kasi org jeles..hrg mmpu milik..full load dgn feature..tp syg saya terbeli preve exec jea x ckp duit masa tu..preve pun memadai dah.
hi there..loving the videos/programmes that you guys have come out with..it gave us lot a preview of the car before making our mind up on cars to buy..but i think i have to agree with mohd taufik here..its just unacceptable for u guys to compare a sedan (1.5) a hatchback (1.6 soft turbo) and a hybrid car..maybe you guys are looking into the price range (below rm90k)..but i think its suitable to do it based on value for money purchase on cars..having to look into suprima s..i would say comparing it with the same 1.6 litre car would be more appropriate..let say a kia forte or a mazda 3 maybe..while a vios be compared to honda city..and the list goes on..
its just my humble opinion on maybe the next episode could be..btw, im loving the videos again guys!keep on coming up with new ones!!
Gotta love this channel ! :)
Lovely and awaiting for the New VW Beetle review with its type competitor... can't wait! Good Job Guys! Keep it up...
cannot unsee the ending.
I think Proton Suprima is coming close to being a truly competitive car quality-wise, if it weren't for tacky interior and less than desired drive train. I would, hands down, go for Vios. Honda's Hybrid looks nice, but I would imagine maintenance costs be quite high.
My suggestion for Paul Tan and friends: it would be nice if there are some research about the maintenance costs to go along with review articles.
Keep it up!
vios handling sucks & lazy engine plus it has just 2 airbag for safety. jazz is so overpriced but still good in handling. proton is just being playsafe and neutral. suprima s have 6airbags, 5star Ancap safety rating, punchy engine torque response in tiptronic mode(still good performer in auto D mode), superb handling(trust me, i drive like pro, u can test) build quality is acceptable. still good & neutral. simple to operate dash, not too much button touch and adjust.
totally disagree with the result, it just being typical, there is so many cars that is better than the vios. you all did not even mentioned about that old gearbox and engine. do better nx time guys.
I am just wondering...if Honda Jazz can give 20++KM/L..and yet it is the best of all when comes to fuel consumption..why it's not economical ?
most expensive of the bunch m8
In my opinion the execution in the beginning the was great. It had relevant information for the viewer, and visual cues. In general visuals were awesome and interesting. In the final part having Harvinder wearing a dress was a yikes for me, however it made the episode daring and comical.
The only part I would like to see less are bias comments, and more on the car's strong point or things that are relevant for the viewer or the typical driver. I find that Harvinder reviews on the car's ride was more pleasing to listen.
Overall great first episode and hoping to see the next. Well done!
hi paul, epic ending to the pilot!
just a quick question, the fuel consumption for the new vios in this episode is 17.3km/l while you recently managed 11.6km/l in your October 10th post (paultan.org/2013/10/10/2013-toyota-vios-fuel-sound-test/).
thats quite a gap, any particular reasons?
Simple. Most probably difference between city driving and highway driving. The mix ratio of them is crucial. Previous gen vios can achieve 12kml in pure 100% city and 18kml in pure 100% highway. This is why some veteran car review publication used the same route, same time and maybe same weather to do fuel consumption testing.
yeap. just wanted to clarify. since the video stated it to be "a mixture of city & highway", while in paultandotorg was perhaps more city-ish (sub100km).
I like "the image test" the most!!!
Malaysians are all almost of the same minded; looking down on its own product, When was Proton established and how long it takes for them to be almost in the same par with other international cars? Give them a chance as they are indeed improving and try looking at a better picture here. Yes yes, Vios deserved the winning place but calling proton a piece of shit? You may have your opinion in cars and you can buy some other car if u desire, but dont go calling ur own product a shit.
if they call their own product is shit... it means that that person is a shitty too.... dont you agree??
rush aztech nope. if your boss calls you stupid, he/she is stupid? LOL cannot brain your opinion wor
First impressions on a brand have lasting consequences on the buyer. Proton has a lot to do to clear its image. Rebadging cars and taking advantage of the higher tax for foreign cars is not helping for a car company that has the purported national car status. However, things are looking up. I think that the Suprima S and the Iriz are steps in the right direction for our national car company.
Kishel Raj Mohan yes totally agree. Looking at how much proton has done in the wee years since they started probably is the reason why we should give it more time to mature. but malaysians expect things to improve in a jiffy albeit their minded has gone no way at all near impressive and probably thats why we cant thrive. Change the attitude and mind first then only you can expect change in other aspect
Sanusi Zulkifli they didnt call the Proton shit also.
keep it up Paul! Next Accord vs Camry vs 508?
A hope the quality of the cars is better the quality of this production
not a bad show ... great job Paul tan
Great job guys except for the last part which very nearly made me lose my lunch hahaha.
The vios had 13.2km/l in a previous video.. Different trim level?
NO HARVINDER... NOOOOOO.... so hillarious haha.. i prefer the safety of suprima s. 6 airbags, abs, ebd for sub 90k. it's a real catch.
does that explain why at 120-130kmph, there is a distinct shake on the preve, but no more shake above 140kmph ?
Sorry Paul, i don't think it's a fair comparison as it's different segment altogether. The ideal comparisons are Vios vs City vs Forte / Cerrato vs Mazda 2 Sedan vs Ford Fiesta Sedan vs VW Polo Sedan
I love the ending, but i must say the result is quite bias because color will affects the decision in terms of image though..
great reviews and funny too but a little softer music when people are talking would be better
Spec to spec/ seg to seg compare should be Suprime VS Civic VS Altis, price to price compare only happen @ Malaysia
I love the ending! LOL
Hey paul and geng. good job on the vid. enjoyed it much. no doubt there alot of better scripting to be done and u guys should be more spontaneous and less nervous. as an over all, its a good vid. looking forward for more vids..
i like it that u guys were not buyers against proton, and tell the truth about them. haha..
Mr. Paul... could you do a review on volkswagen polo sedan, honda city, toyota vios and nissan almeria?
actually the vios looks a bit to large for a 1.5. Not much complaints about the suprima except that it should have been slightly more efficient due to the presence of a turbo. The jazz only looks good if it has the mugen bodykit or else it's too dull.
1.5 wif turbo is not good enough for fuel efficiency.
***** its a 1.6 turbo. but yeah. you've got a point.
sorry, i forgot suprima is 1.6 litre engine.
I like the image test.. LOL kinda funny.. Great job guys.
What's wrong with comparing car with almost same price range? Doesn't most people will consider car pricing as one of their main priority when they want to purchase a car?
Presentation could need more improvement so that it won't sound so wooden. Could also add more Malaysian flavor in the script also feel more engaging and alive too.
Btw, love the ending. Keep up the good work, There's much potential. *thumbs up*
those three cars are totally from different segment.. on what basis u want to compare??
Wait, the Vios wins, despite being the (by far) least safe car? And the safety equipment isn't even mentioned as a plus point for the Suprima S? And... finally: If you want more space, get the Preve. Same protection, more space, lower price. So what if the Vios feels a bit more refined... if that's what you are going for, why not let it compete with the Peugeot 208?
what about the maintenance , which one save more money ??
Are you Harvinder Singh from VI?
Good job guys. Keep en coming..
Ahhhhhh man, I don't wish to be mean, but I am disappointed with this new Driven. The old one was a lot more dynamic and entertaining. In any case, this is still a good, serious and highly informative show. A great first effort ! I liked the puns and general humour here and there, but what I loved most was the emphasis on car safety. Dua tangan thumbs up for that ! Looking forward to episode 2. :]
good show! funny and informative, just dial down the music especially when someone is talking
Felt comfortable with Harvinder explanation, so what if the slang isn't international i am more incline to talk with people with such tone.
Very good guys.. keep up the good job!!!
Do the " DRAG RACE " after done the comparison. Looks more excitin'.
good review, lot of information. Maybe I am used to how top gear presenting the show, I preferred more of the friendly chit-chatting among you guys, rather than presenting the car with scripts. Good ending touch thou.
sama mcam top gear season1..nnt ok laa ni :D
keep it up guys! looking fwd for new video
Dh ok dh video paultan skrg
Wait how do you know the future 2016 Vios in 2013? Now in 2016 and 17 only we know leh how?
Now Paul Tan championing safety, but 5 years ago they said inferior safety Vios is better than Suprima? Lol.
A good pilot episode, but seeing that this is made for local viewing it would not hurt to have a little manglish here and there. Relax a bit more when making puns and especially a punch line to a joke. All in all the information in this series is just as good as your website's.
i like proton suprima
i think for fuel consumption vios is the number one..1 liter (highway) can go for 20/21 KM
bagi sy proton suprima the best kalau nak lawan minyak memang la suprima kalah.. tp bayang kan lah suprima turbo memang lah makan minyak da nama nye turbo.. kereta yg toyota n honda da ckp terang2 hibrid n toyota plak enjin biasa yg save minyak.. kalau nak banding kan suprima dgn vw gti laa... tengok mana makan minyak.. n test power sape pegi dulu.. i da try proton suprima dgn vw gti yg harga lebih 100k still tak bleh lawan dgn suprima.. baru betul lawan n tengok harga keta n minyak... betull takkkk...
Btul tu bang saya sokong...
thanks.. patut lawan dgn pesona rm15 kl to klia go n back
Walaupun proton suprima minyak x save sangat....tapi dia laju berbanding vios ngan jazz...sekali tu penah nmpk suprima tapau honda vtec...kat highway....
sy pernah nampak tapau vw gti turbo 2.0 pe cite kereta yg berharga rm250k.. n sy tau byk complain vw masalah gearbox pecaya tak..
+Arman Dis Alwi daripada pkai vw baik pakai proton.....vw bukn laju pon.... dengan proton wira 1.6 pown klh.... hmmmmm...
How on earth did u manage 17.3 km/L on the vios? been using the it for almost 6 months and only managed 16.6km/L and that's on cross country.
this comparison based on price or apple to apple spec?
Looking at the price range, I would recommend to buy Honda City 1.5E since Honda currently doing promotion of 8K rebate. Plus, City got the VSA safety feature compared to Vios. Of course, there'll be new City next year but who cares as long as the car has economical fuel consumption.
hi, can you help to review hyundai elantra?? thanx u ....love your videos
In my honest opinion, it feels and looks heavily scripted (most probably is). I'm sure for 3 car guys like you all, it's easy to do a casual, impromptu review with free speaking. It will look more professional this way too, as audience will know that the 3 hosts actually knows their stuff (which you guys definitely do). But good job overall!
***** Keep up the good work. It'll become more natural as you go along. One option you can do is to try going through a stream of consciousness presentation as opposed to saying what you've scripted initially. Might use up a lot more tape but it would feel a lot more natural.
***** Also love the last part!
great review guys, but i still go for the Suprima in-terms of performance and the looks. I hope Proton will come out the R3 version of it.
It is not fuel efficient
Why not you try to compare new previa new odyssey serena s hybrid and exora ???it would be awesome comparison for choosing the best and right mpv for family
Owh ...i forget about the biante..but if you can make for us it will be nice..tq