Thalberg a composé de nombreuses transcriptions d’opéras comme Liszt puisque c’était la seule façon de se remémorer les airs entendus à l’époque et de briller lors de concerts de salon . Katsaris signe ici de son talent une merveilleuse interprétation !
The shimmering runs at the finale (13:51) with the Minuet is absolutely beautiful. Although shamefully an underwhelming coda, buildup could've been more ecstatic, which can lead to a more cathartic climax. A fault that is by no means Katsaris' fault, whom has performed gracefully here, he really made the finale shine.
there is one video with a midi on bili bili website. I can't post links but if you searched there you will find the video and maybe you can ask for the midi from the creator. The video was a comparison between this, thalbergs op 14 and liszt's don juan fantasy.
That is simply false. This is very pretty, but is nowhere near close to the Genius of what Liszt does with Don Juan. RUclips is not the space to debate this, but a proper study of the two works would clearly show that Liszt outshines Thalberg in this piece.
A great example of Thalberg’s famous 3-hand effect 7:21
Thalberg a composé de nombreuses transcriptions d’opéras comme Liszt puisque c’était la seule façon de se remémorer les airs entendus à l’époque et de briller lors de concerts de salon . Katsaris signe ici de son talent une merveilleuse interprétation !
The shimmering runs at the finale (13:51) with the Minuet is absolutely beautiful. Although shamefully an underwhelming coda, buildup could've been more ecstatic, which can lead to a more cathartic climax. A fault that is by no means Katsaris' fault, whom has performed gracefully here, he really made the finale shine.
Underrated in every aspect.
Peculiar. Intriguing, almost mesmerizing in its own way at first hearing, but peculiar.
Hey just letting you know this video is unblocked here! (UK)
That's great to know! Thank you for your comment and for watching!
@@Pianifico also here in italy!
@@AsrielKujo vero :)
@@AsrielKujo Asriel Kujo
この作品がいつ出来たのかは知らないが後半のフレーズがアルカンに見られるものだったので関係が気になりました。それにしても素晴らしい作品だ👏👏👏👏👏👏
1841
Didn't like the piece much, but the section at 10:43 is pretty nice 😊
Indeed.
Agree.
Does someone know the first theme at the beginning of the fantasia? 1:22
Variation of the Serenade??
I wish I could get a MIDI for this piece. (Does anyone have a MIDI for this, or know where I can find a MIDI for this piece?)
There are midi converters around.
there is one video with a midi on bili bili website. I can't post links but if you searched there you will find the video and maybe you can ask for the midi from the creator. The video was a comparison between this, thalbergs op 14 and liszt's don juan fantasy.
@@prammar1951 could you tell me what I’d search like “bili bili thalberg MIDI” would I search something like that?
@@prammar1951do you think you could email me the link? I’d love to acquire this MIDI and upload it on my channel.
@@prammar1951 could you email me this link?
This better than Liszt's Don juan
Nope. Can say categorically.
+Absolutely
@@mobilephil244 I would object.
That is simply false. This is very pretty, but is nowhere near close to the Genius of what Liszt does with Don Juan. RUclips is not the space to debate this, but a proper study of the two works would clearly show that Liszt outshines Thalberg in this piece.
Yes 100%. Liszt’s Don Juan is fine in its own right, but it’s too heavy and over-bombastic.
Alkan>Thalberg>Liszt>Chopin
Isn't the sign reversed?
@@정-e7y nope.
Liszt was basically the greatest innovator of piano music during the 19th century. Your opinion is very biased
@@charliegold3227all opinions are biased
Liszt = Chopin > Alkan > Thalberg