The US Lottery is a Lie
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 авг 2024
- Why the Government Loves the Lottery
Go to our sponsor betterhelp.com/johnnyharris for 10% off your first month of therapy with BetterHelp and get matched with a therapist who will listen and help.
Seeing the billion dollar jackpots pop up all over the news had me wondering: why does the government run the lottery and what do they do with all that money?
My next video is live on Nebula NOW! It's about the UN's failures with the War in Bosnia. Watch now on Nebula (a portion of your subscription goes directly to support our channel): nebula.tv/johnnyharris
Check out all my sources for this video here: docs.google.com/document/d/1y...
Get access to behind-the-scenes vlogs, my scripts, and extended interviews over at / johnnyharris
Custom Presets & LUTs [what we use]: store.dftba.com/products/john...
About:
Johnny Harris is an Emmy-winning independent journalist and contributor to the New York Times. Based in Washington, DC, Harris reports on interesting trends and stories domestically and around the globe, publishing to his audience of over 3.5 million on RUclips. Harris produced and hosted the twice Emmy-nominated series Borders for Vox Media. His visual style blends motion graphics with cinematic videography to create content that explains complex issues in relatable ways.
- press -
NYTimes: www.nytimes.com/2021/11/09/op...
NYTimes: www.nytimes.com/video/opinion...
Vox Borders: • Inside Hong Kong’s cag...
NPR Planet Money: www.npr.org/transcripts/10721...
- where to find me -
Instagram: / johnny.harris
Tiktok: / johnny.harris
Facebook: / johnnyharrisvox
Iz's (my wife’s) channel: / iz-harris
- how i make my videos -
Tom Fox makes my music, work with him here: tfbeats.com/
I make maps using this AE Plugin: aescripts.com/geolayers/?aff=77
All the gear I use: www.izharris.com/gear-guide
- my courses -
Learn a language: brighttrip.com/course/language/
Visual storytelling: www.brighttrip.com/courses/vi...
The best way I ever heard someone describe the lottery was as a tax on hope...
Just the "its a tax on the poor" is a little demeaning to the poor. It's a tax on gamblers, and it just so happens that there are more lotery gamblers among the statistical group of the poor than among the rich (perhaps there are just as many rich gamblers too, just gambling on cassinos or horses, or shit, stock markets?). But saying its a tax on the poor implies all poor people are irresponsible gambling fools that waste the money away at scrach offs, which is very incorrect, the high amount of money spent on lotery by the poor on the statistics is raised that high by a small cohort of that population.
It's a tax on the ignorant. Anyone who understands odds and probabilities would never give a dime to the lottery.
@@eduffy4937 People who are perpatually poor, often are like you desctibe. Some others are just temporarily poor, but slowly taking steps into higher incomes. Just as some people are rich not because they manag their money well, but because their grandpa did, and they themselves are just chipping away at what they inherited for free. Socio-economic inertia is a thing.
Nah it's a tax on the stupid.
It’s a poor person’s 401k plan.
Here in Florida, some of the money raised by the lottery is used for scholarships. I once heard someone say: "The lottery is low-income people sending middle-income people to college." That has stuck with me ever since.
True indeed
Most state lotteries were setup to benefit education in some way
300 million $ went to Missouri schools from the Missouri lottery in 2022 alone. I don't like the word scam cause it carries a negative connotation. Sure someone getting rich, but its 1000x better than pretty much every other business in terms of overall contribution to society imo.
@@PherPhur yeah only if in your head a new whatever $300 million business is not going to decrease the prices of that product.
Probably in your head collages and university are not money making business either.
Basic question if you have excessive amount of collages, dairy, or some other products or specific food in your area will it going to be cheap or expensive?
They volunteer for it though
Thank you so much for calling this out for what it is. The thing about the lottery that bothers me the most is that the people more likely to regularly buy tickets are those who struggle enough financially that their biggest problems *would* be solved if they won...despite the fact that what they spend on these tickets is overall a bigger loss than it would be for someone who is well off financially. The entire thing feeds on desperation...and I don't blame anyone for feeling compelled to participate. But it's all just the same trap as gambling, and any attempts the government makes to distinguish it from gambling only make people even more vulnerable to it. It's all just a way to get the people with little money to spare to take a disproportionate role in funding the government (and others involved in the lottery).
But he is not "calling it out for what it is". The lottery is not a tax on the poor. Taxes are mandatory, the lottery is not.
@@Thewinner312 While participation in the lottery is technically voluntary, its regressive nature, disproportionate impact on low-income individuals, and broader societal implications suggest that it functions, to some extent, as a tax on the poor.
@@Mr_T. You have just said literally nothing. You have only queued up a few pseudo-intelligent words that don't mean anything. Like how is something "technically" voluntary? Either you have to do something or you don't. Nobody has to play the lottery, making it voluntary. Just saying the word "technically" before a fact, doesn't change that it's a fact.
@@Thewinner312 Damn conservatives, always thinking in black & white. Gemini seems on the mark for a pseudo-intelligent AI.
There are situations where an act appears voluntary on the surface but may have underlying factors that limit true free choice. Here are a few examples, including the lottery:
1. The Lottery:
Limited Economic Opportunities: For people in poverty, the lottery might appear as a chance for a better life, a way out of their economic hardship. However, the odds of winning are very low, making it an unrealistic solution. This lack of realistic alternatives creates a situation where the lottery, despite its low success rate, seems like the only option.
2. Unfair Contracts:
Power Imbalance: Someone in a desperate financial situation might agree to a loan with unfair terms because they urgently need the money. While they technically agree to the contract, the unequal bargaining power creates pressure that limits their ability to make a truly free choice.
3. Coercive Advertising:
Exploiting Vulnerabilities: Advertising that preys on insecurities or fears can manipulate people into buying unnecessary products. The act of purchase might be voluntary, but the underlying pressure or emotional manipulation reduces genuine free will.
4. Limited Education or Information:
Deceptive Marketing: Someone might agree to a service or product based on misleading marketing. Without complete information, their decision is not based on a truly free choice.
5. Addiction:
Compulsive Behavior: People struggling with addiction may engage in harmful behaviors voluntarily, but the addiction itself limits their ability to make rational choices.
Key Points to Consider:
Voluntariness and Pressure: The presence of pressure, limited options, or manipulation can make an act appear voluntary but cast doubt on the true freedom of choice involved.
Context Matters: The context surrounding a decision is crucial. A seemingly voluntary act might be less so when considering the underlying circumstances.
The lottery example highlights the limitations of free will when economic hardship restricts realistic options. People are "voluntary" in their choice, but the context of poverty makes the lottery seem like a more viable option than it truly is.
By understanding these complexities, we can have a more nuanced understanding of human behavior and decision-making.
@@Thewinner312 The most humane thing we can call the lottery. And I mean calling it for what it really is. A fraud....or a theft.
My wife & I would always tell my grandmother she needs to stop buying loterry tickets & giving 10% of her income to her church bc she was already in so much debt. She got to the point where she would scream at us trying to convince us she does neither. After she passed, we find all kinds of receipts & paperwork that she indeed did both. She gave away so much money & played the lottery like a psychopath thinking she was going to win canceling out all of her debt.
My wife & I both refuse to do any kind of gambling, nor do we voluntarily give away any of our money to anybody or business/corporations that have their hands out. We work hard for our money & the government already STEALS more than enough in taxes from hard working middle class families as it is, so we will never give not even an extra penny willingly. It's absolutely ridiculous how much extra money the government gets from various "deals," yet we are still trillions in debt.
For a college course, I wanted to investigate how Pennsylvania allocated its lottery funds "to benefit seniors," as the ads put it. I contacted the state revenue service to request some data, and I was pretty much treated like a terrorist. Everyone I spoke to was evasive at best, but usually downright rude. "Why did I want it," was the usual retort to the request; often they wanted my phone number for a callback. Finally, I received by mail a single sheet document with columns of numbers but without any context as to time periods covered and so on, much less where the money went. Years later I discovered that funds were used to supplement seniors' prescription costs, but eligibility was stringent with high deductibles AFTER Medicare D plans. Terrific video!
Sounds like your research for that class did not go well. Honestly, part of that is probably simply because you were a student who government bureaucrats do not have to take seriously. Credentials would have gotten you further. And if not, you could have used some of the skills journalists develop (if they are any good.)
@@RobespierreThePoof You shouldn’t need credentials to access records that they publicize as public. If they want it to be private they shouldn’t promote it as such.
@@TheArob yeah, that’s pretty sus for a government to be covert about public information
Is there such a thing as FOIA requests for state documents?
Yeah, so the funds barely did what they said it did. A tiny little vein of help for the seniors and I suppose the main majority of the funds went elsewhere.
Johnny: "we have to make lottery tickets a business expense"
Team: "okay"
If he wins it’s a personal expense. If he loses it’s a business expense. 😂
*Team: "bet"
Irs: you might regret this
Johnny has it all figured out. His life is a business expense from the electronics to the travel.
Good fucking luck explaining that to the tax man
Like they told me in the Marines... NEVER TRUST YOU'RE GOVERNMENT.
Isn't your job literally to trust the government and carry out its orders?
@@lordice5 Not that simple!
YOUR government!
You def are a jarhead, but yes. Never trust em.
The lottery is a tax on people who can’t do math
It's better than a tax where you don't get a chance to become rich overnight. And it's a tax people get to choose to pay. And it's a tax that helps keep other taxes from being raised. How's my math?
The worst part is if you tell people who buy the lottery regularly that its the government's way of taxing them, they go into denial mode... and usually these are the same folks that hate the government or think they're so smart that they're not paying actual taxes to the government... I always say the government is the one having the last laugh.
The "anti-government" crowd are usually the most susceptible to other money scams too like MLM, pyramid schemes, and other Ponzi and get rich quick schemes. Best not to mention that to them, it's fun for them and education for you.
It's just annoying seeing our income being taxed multiple times over in numerous states.
I don’t want to be stating the obvious, but the government isn’t the only one that runs lotteries. It would just be another private corpo. Like the PNE with their free house lottery? Have you seen that? The only practical solution would be to ban lotteries altogether
@@popopop984 We cannot do that anymore. Look at what happened when alcohol was banned. lmao
People.
The best and only path is to educate people, and i'm not talking about schools. Just give the the info, make them realize what they are doing (basically what this video does too).
It's not a tax. The key distinction is that taxes are involuntary and enforced by legal penalty. Buying lottery tickets, while dumb, is entirely voluntary.
You know whats even more hilarious, these people would get upset if you took the lottery away. I used to work at an AMPM when I was 17, we had regulars that would buy tickets. I would ask them if they knew what their odds were, they said yes. One guy told me he knew for a fact he'd never win but the euphoria he got from daydreaming about winning was worth the money. That to me sounded crazy at the time but as an adult now, I can see its allure lol
When you get to that state you should look at yourself from 3rd person view and realize that you're just fooling yourself and it's unproductive in long run.
Life is not a race it's a marathon
If they spent that money and time wasted daydreaming trying to actually build a business or get a better paying career or better themselves they’d be in a greater position. Problem is a lot of people are just lazy and want the easy way out of things.
@@b-rare if youre happy daydreaming then thats winning life
It is hard to argue that those people are not making an informed decision. It is not the economically optimal decision, but neither is paying for lessons in watercoloring, or a huge ass Wroom-car or collecting pokemon cards or whatever other things people spend (waste?) their money on. From a certain point of view, buying a lottery ticket in order to derive greater enjoyment from watching the lottery on tv is not much different from paying for a netflix subscription or membership of a golf club.
Thats the logic of someone with almost no hope left, the odds dont matter when its the only way out you can see
In the small town I live in I see the lowest income people spend the most money on scratch offs.
Is it only the US that flat out lies about the size of the jackpot? In other coutries, Canada for example, if you win $50 million, you get a cheque for $50 million and you get to keep all of it, no tax!
I stopped buying lottery tickets a year after I started buying them regularly. I learned I was losing more than I was winning and got bored of the losses. I realised it wasn't worth it, so I ditched the habit, worked overtime a lot for a long time, and now I have back all my losses. The way to win the lottery is not to play.
We should do a RUclips , how much money I save from not buying a lottery ticket , so basically save the the same money over 10 years I bet it’s 20-40 k
@@MediaMusik777 I've kind of already done that without the RUclips video, and before and after I started buying lottery tickets.
@@MediaMusik777 Anyone who wastes between 20k and 40k on lottery in ten years needs to sort out their priorities. That sort of money could go towards paying off a mortgage or ending some kind of debt.
Some people win from buying FIRST EVER TICKET!!!!
So? It's still extremely rare and doesn't mean that millions are still being conned out of their losses. It still doesn't justify all the poor gambling addicts whose lives are ruined.@@elenaefremova7463
I work at a bar, and I see the same people come in to exclusively play the video lottery. They rotate between a few other spots to avoid some embarrassment, but I know a good chunk of their money goes into those machines.
The saddest part is seeing their gambling slow down, they hit, and the cycle starts all over again.
Yep, the worst thing to happen to a gambling addict is them actually winning something, they double down and spend the winnings and more
they felt too rich to spend their money on themself,
therefore, just throw away that trash money into a gambling paper
I’m in Guatemala right now and it’s so interesting to see people selling lotto tickets from a huge stack on the side of the street.
It's not a scam. It's a dumb purchase
My grandfather used to call the lottery "The Fool's Tax." It's the only tax you don't have to pay.
I used to work part time at a supermarket, and people coming to buy/check their lottery tickets were the WORST clients. A couple even called me stupid for not understanding their weird lottery jargon… yeah, because I’m not the one spending hundreds on that… rightttt
😒 they have habit of pulling tickets out there ass or asking for another ticket right as you close the transaction
@@aleks-wy6uf 🤣 yeah bro, yet they keep complaining that they have no money and they need a winner and shit
¯\_(ツ)_/¯ buts it's probable I'm stupid
Same experience. People won 10$ and buy more to tickets from that smh
"Yo, I need a pick 3 double down power play."
Oh man same. I worked a service counter and never once understood the lottery lingo.
Don’t play the lottery lol
*"You have the same chance of winning the lottery whether you play or not."*
*-Groucho Marx*
That’s true because I once stepped on someone’s dropped lottery ticket at a car wash that ended up being a $500 winner.
@@PauloBerni699bullshit. What a weird thing to lie about
my father was a brave worker and he spent a good part of these wages on lottery and horse races, today he is over 70 years old, has never won a single faith and lives in social housing, it is one of my best life lessons 😊
better than cigarettes i guess
Cancer?
@@charlesgale4257 Yeah my father smoked so much, that he could have probably bought a house if he saved all that money over the years. Can't say what's worse.
@@alittleeager1485 And you should say that about everything. It's just that cigarettes are way worse than any of those things. Super expensive, and you are still hungry after you smoke. At least if you are eating a burger each day you took care of one of your basic needs.
The fed an state tax rate is true
Imagine if Johnny had won the multi million dollar lottery while filming. The video probably would have taken a totally different turn. 😂
Alternate universe
I would hope if he had, he'd pull a Mr. Beast and help some poor people with eye surgery or something good like that.
@@deivclayton I would hope if he had he spend it on a big fireworks show, and a lifetime supply of doritos
He wouldn't complain if he did.
Why was I really hoping this would happen?! 😂😂
I worked in an office of about 25 people and the lottery got to $100 million, so one co-worker collected $5 from everyone to buy tickets. After I gave my money another co-worker commented it is a bad idea for the whole office do this, because if we win, we quit!
But I bet you didn't win and are just $5 poorer.
What’s the problem? Jobs replace ppl like they never knew the ppl existed 🥴
People ALWAYS way over estimate their chances of winning
@@itsoktobehappy461The odds are zero it's all a hoax. Like Santa and the tooth fairy. Anyone who gets a payout has invested past the point of no return. The big ones Powerball and Megamillions. You have a better chance of swimming to mars and recording a hit record.
God is pretty pissed off. God bought a Powerball ticket and when the lottery saw he had the correct# they reached in and pulled a couple numbers out. I think the rapture is coming!
The best explanation of how the lottery scam works. Thankyou! ❤ I am from the UK just did my research and they too use the clever wording of "good causes" and not charity etc. Makes me wonder what they're really funding. In the UK 12% profit goes straight to the government in "lottery duty", 4% to the vendors and 1% net profit goes to the operators and the rest to players & "good causes"
That's a scam on a big scale 😮
My question is ... What if the lottery stopped? 😬😬😬
I wouldn't even say it's a case of lack of education, but rather a case of exploiting desperation. I know I spent the most on the lottery when I was about to lose my own house. I knew that the chances were almost impossible that I would win, but it was like I was hoping for a miracle to change my situation. A miracle I could opt into. That 5$ I was spending on the ticket wasn't going to get me out of my situation, even if I saved it, but even it was unlikely, it could resolve everything if I had won.
So yeah, I think reframing it from "uneducated" to "desperate" would change a few perspectives.
Thank you, I was going to make this point as well, but you nailed it.
It's not "desperate." I'm poor, but I can also do math, so it's a tax on people who are stupid. This often includes poor people, and we should be realistic about who is paying for these things.
@@CharliMorganMusic This to me sounds like somebody telling someone else that professional wrestling is fake. The vast majority of people who watch wrestling know its fake, and still chose to enjoy it, while I know a ton of people that know full well that their chances of winning the lottery are close to nil, and yet choose to participate anyways.
It's the same kind of comment that leads addicts to hide their addiction, because they're afraid of being seen as dumb (as often repeat that kind of comment to themselves, leading to worse outcomes). Assuming that everyone who plays the lottery is "dumb" isn't realistic, it's detrimental, and leads to avoiding the problem instead of resolving it.
It's a tax on hope from the poor.
@@CeeJayLerod Yeah but Wrestling is fun to watch and is worth the money. I get what you are trying to convey though and you are right to some extent, but while the majority of people who play lottery fully know it is unlikely to win, not that much know that it's more likely that they get struck by lightning twice than to win the jackpot.
Interesting topic and very informative. Here in Japan, the lottery winner is kept secret and there are no taxes paid on winnings. You could win and not have to worry about long lost relatives suddenly showing up on your doorstep! 😂
The potential to just keep it all and pretend there are secret winners is too great as goverment is by definition ritualized corruption and manipulation of the general public. Power always corrupts and there is never enough money or power for the corrupted to be satisfied.
You don't live in Japan quit lying you weaboo.
I think that means that nobody’s winning.
Announcing who won the lottery is honestly pretty screwed tbh.
@@henvdemon AFAIK in US, in many states you can refuse to be announced. But because lottery is mostly used by low education people, they usually don't understand they can refuse to be announced and don't hire lawyer before collecting their winnings. There are lawyers who specialize on lottery winners and will help you to do everything without broadcasting your name, but most winners just rush in, agree to everything and get the money, without any planning or hiring the lawyer/adviser, because, well, they are mostly low education part of the society.
There are also options on taking the winnings using trust instead of as a person. But yeah, even in states that allow this, many people still go with media rush.
And even if your name is announced as a winner, the only things announced are name, city and the store you got the ticket. You can simply move the state/city and change the name after that, you will have money for that.
im gonna remember that 66 bathtubs thing next time i start feeling lucky
Like they say "Someone will win the lottery, just not you".
yep. but once in a while, someone is wrong.
Funny enough actually, I did win the lottery. My name's Shane Missler, and I won 450 million, several years ago.
@@O2TGif u were winning even a million u wouldn't came in the comments and reply to proof the reality of lottery u could be quite busy for that haha
@@akamali7016 The lottery is fake...all the technology is used to make an unfair game. But the truth is that, there is no game. Give up before you start is the best solution. The lottery should be called "nope"....
In The Netherlands this was actually criticised in the news a couple of years ago. Now the government passed laws to make their lotteries less attractive, by having limited commercials without celebrities and the lottery stands should be less prominent sight in stores.
Most of this video is fluff... like at least 80%+
@@Monkehrawrrr Huh?? What's ya problem with this vid? He has to put some entertainment value in it or no ones gunna watch it. And he came to the right conclusion. Did ya want it to just be 30 secs long and for him to say the lottery is a tax on the poor, stupid and desperate and that's it with no context......100% of your comment is incomprehensible. 🤷♂
Down here in Australia we literally have the highest rate of gambling in the world and there's heaps of gambling ads on the TV followed by some quick "gamble responsibly" bs and a gamblers help line phone number the Government forces em to up to pretend they care even though the Government makes a shitload outa taxing gambling. There's slot machines or poker machines or pokies as we call em in every pub or club. Most countries like the U.S. only allow em in casinos. But they're bloody everywhere down here.
Or if they just stopped, that would be another good option.
Another thing the Dutch has done right
I use to work at a gas station. One customer would come with $700 in cash, and would put it on Powerball tickets every week.
It was a pool of 14 workers at some company that tried to win the lottery.
You see on each ticket would win 15% to 25% back, as I was the one scanning the tickets.
That's actually phenomenal return for them. At my job we would pool together half that amount for Powerball, about 35 of us, $10 each, and every time we would win between $6- $15. So the people you're talking about did very well
Edit- I don't mean $6 - $15 EACH, I mean total for us to split 🤣
Lottery, the only tax people likes to pay.
While I agree with everything portrayed in this video, I can truly say that when you purchase a lottery ticket, and I’ve done so a handful of times over the years, the excitement of dreaming what to do with your potential winnings is what drives people to buy a ticket, especially when the pot gets over $250,000,000. Clearly the statistical odds of winning are horrible, but the thought of winning the prize is a rush. The same rush gamblers get. And that’s why I don’t play anymore. I might as well give a few bucks to someone that is downtrodden. That would have more redeeming value than buying a lottery ticket.
You're more likely to be attacked by a shark in the middle of the desert.
But if you win, you can help millions of more. It all starts with a dream honey, you will never win if you don’t play. A two dollar play is worth multi million dollar possibility to me.
@@montaiahypolite5275 you are not going to win the lotto!
It's a chance you do not need any knowledge or anything else it's all about your luck why do you scam?!
@@montaiahypolite5275 It's all fake. Every one of us would have known someone by now who has won. Maybe not next door. But it's a small world. They fight tooth and nail...to keep you from winning $500.00 on a pick3 game. Hundreds of one off tickets. You can spend $500.00 every night and like a miracle, the number falls on the other side of the spectrum!...The odds are not 1-1000 . The odds become zero. So...in light of that... I do not believe they would let just anyone win Mega or Powerball. There is a club. And we are not in it!
Here in the Philippines, part of the lottery money goes to helping people with their medical bills. People line up to ask for financial aid every day. As a cancer patient, it has been immensely helpful for me.
I'm sorry to hear about cancer. I know it has to be tough and exhausting, physically and mentally. And yeah, I believe that any financial stuff should always be the LAST thing a person fighting cancer should be thinking about. That's so much extra stress to put up with on top of it all. Anyway, I hope everything is going well for you ♡ 💪Keep fighting, hun and much love and hugs to you! ♡
And FUCK CANCER. I hope and pray for a cure someday very soon.
Sadly, we have this instead of socialized healthcare
That's shit mate. No one deserves fuckin cancer. Hope the money helps you kick it's arse. Good luck with the fight and I hope the universe lets you win the lottery of life 🙏🙏🙂
Yep a portion of money being used, are for charitable works. And also recently almost 400 people won the jackpot on a single night. You better check it out.
the harms of gambling outweigh the benefits by a thousandfold
I sort of knew the lottery was a tax on the poor, but had never thought about how the money is taken away from poor areas and given to programmes that dont benefit them. Really interesting way of framing it.
*tax on the uneducated
@@quasii7 he gets it. If you wanna play deconstryction games, then go all the way with them. Don't just switch one bad generalization for another.
i also have a feeling that people who win are actors!
hg
I don't like the lottery because it takes advantage of the uneducated, but I think calling it a tax is silly when it is voluntary. (Setting aside those who do or don't believe in free will vs determinism) no one forces people to buy a lotto ticket. To me it is less a tax, and more just a predatory scheme.
I only came across your channel yesterday and ive been hooked' so the answer to your question is because the content is brilliant and theres obviously so much time and research goes into each one'
When I was a kid in the 3rd grade, my math teacher asked us what the lottery was? We all answered things like a way to get rich ect. He procceded to tell us it was a tax on the poor and explained the math like in this video. It stuck with me and even tho my state has gambling machines everywhere I don't play. I wonder if any of my classmates remember that lesson.
Fun fact: in Germany the lottery winner is not taxed from the government because according to German laws everything that you win in Germany its tax free
Winnings are tax free in most countries I think
@@ZachBobBob not in any country some countries tax your winnings for example the USA
@@altrimdjaferi8167 Yeah the USA is an outlier is what I'm saying
Same as Canada
@@altrimdjaferi8167 the usa would tax us on air we breathe if they could. Nothing is off the table for those parasites.
Just a note about better help (your sponsor). They have been giving away patient data to social media companies. IE they are giving your medical information to Facebook so they can advertise to you based on your private medical data. (Targeting you specifically knowing you have some diagnosed disorder) Don't use them, the company is shady AF.
source?
@@adikul358 search up denver7 betterhelp.
There is an article about it.
@@adikul358 there are many, a quick search will show you some studies
Advertising therapy is trendy these days… we all need to talk to someone about our feelings 🤡
Burden of proof is on the accuser. Yes, I looked it up and you have a valid point, but all the people reading your comment without a source is shady in itself. That's how disinformation spreads.
I have a friend who’s dad is a state representative and I don’t know all the details but he recently tried to get a bill or something passed in our state to get rid of the lottery for these exact reasons and it was struck down SO FAST… at the very least we can hope that it raised even an ounce of awareness during it’s short existence…
😢😢😢 They would not have nothing on it never will hear about it
The charity aspect is good
I'm really liking this channel. Simple, well produced👍
I hate being at a convenience store in line behind a lottery fanatic. They always take FOREVER!!
Amen
Totally agree
Move out of the way!
😂 funny I always say the same
Just the other day I was at the train station trying to buy my sandwich and coffee before I caught my train and the person in front of me was cashing in their tickets and deciding how many more tickets to buy with their "winnings" 🤦♀️ I was getting super antsy thinking I'd miss my train. The line behind me grew to like 7 people when it started with just the one lady. I really don't think these transactions should happen person to person at a place like a train station 😅
"The lottery makes taxes fun." That may have been my favorite line. Thank you for this video and for the insightful look into this tragically unethical form of taxation.
I do not think it is unethical, it is a service you can take it or leave it. The government has to use their more wisely and addicts are a problem.
There is also a good reason for higher earners to not take the service as for me 20M more would not change my life significantly. It will most probubliy mean more work.
rather have the lottery instead of taxes personally. Be alot more appealing tbh.
It's not a tax literally nor figuratively. You pay a set fee for a chance at a set reward. That's literally it. Where that money goes is irrelevant. A tax is money paid directly to a government for a service. This is not that. And I think it's on ethical to deny people who are poor the chance to win millions of dollars for a tiny charge. It's also arrogant because you're assuming that the poor are stupid and don't know what they're doing. They know the odds of winning are incredibly low.
I’m an accountant who should never been seen in a casino
Yes! Tax doesn't have to be taxing. Another one tobacco especially in Australia,Ireland and the UK. Its over $20 dollars for a pack of cigarettes in Aus
“For the powerful, crimes are those that others commit.”
― Noam Chomsky,
just a quick correction, it wasn’t just “england” it was the entirety of britain, or more precisely the uk.
It would be interesting to see a followup video covering the outcomes of people who _do_ win the lottery. I often hear that for a lot of them, it doesn't end well, because they aren't used to having so much they spend through it all very quickly and can end up poorer than they were before, or they get hounded by relatives and it can ultimately break their social life. Not sure how often that is vs better situations, but it would be interesting to see a data-driven breakdown if there is one.
Ive even read that its way, way more common for lottery winners to end up worse vs the opposite. Like only a few make the right choices
They also are swarmed by scammers. Rich people can hire loyal advisers because those advisors know that they can achieve a long successful career advising people with stable and high income. Also conventionally rich people have connections to other powerful people who can share the reputation of these advisors. Not only are lottery winners less financially aware, there's no practical reason for anybody else to give them good long term advice.
I've heard of lottery winners waiting to come forward, and paying someone to claim it for them to be anonymous.
Apparently you're a lot more likely to die if you win the lottery. Like... By a lot. For money reasons.
@@Dominator9572 That's a pretty smart move, and taking the money over time is the only way to go... How could anyone possibly need so much at once that they'd be willing to lose half of it altogether?
As someone with major depression and given up all hope, I am completely immune to gambling.
Lol you may be hopeless but at least you still funny
Jesus can give you hope. No depression can stay when you find your identity in Him! There's so much purpose for you.
i like how u saw the positive here. i bless u
The mental health equivalent of being immune to malaria because of sickle cell anemia
Sounds like you haven't found the right game or type of gambling! ;)
I always wondered why there is no lottery ticket machines at Whole Foods.
in the uk the national lottery uses its money for local causes such as community centres, building restoration, etc. An example was then giving alexandra palace £1million for restoration/renovation
Excellent, here they should give to the elderly
I've been wondering why schools never seem to have enough funding to do what they need to get done. This was a great investigation. Thank you.
They do have enough funding. Public schools have even more funds available than private schools.
@@LisaCulton maybe where you're from schools have enough money but not here in America
@@Primo_extracts That was in South Carolina where my son had been enrolled in both a public and an expensive private school and I looked up the (publicly available) spending per student in the public schools... And found out that thousands more were spent on the public school children as compared to the upscale private school. Very interesting.
No government institution will ever have "enough funding."
@@LisaCulton In SC, are private schools that don't discriminate with student enrollment allowed to claim some form of government funding?
But, I wouldn't be surprised, since most things are supplied by the school in public schools, but you have to pay for almost everything in private schools. I don't actually know if your private schools include extraneous expenses in tuition costs. Most of the private schools I know are pretty expensive since tuition doesn't cover the other costs like equipment, food, books, specialized uniforms, etc.
To me, the lottery is like "selling hope". My dad is strongly against any type of addictive substance (alcohol, tobacco) yet he's been sucked into the lottery for as long as I can remember (even before big names such as MM or Powerball were released). I don't blame him as he had to work multiple jobs to stay afloat back in the 80s. The fact that he sees the lottery as an "investment" can illustrate what addiction does to a person.
Daaanng .
It's soo strange to me how a person can be against drugs and alcohol and other Addictions yet they themselve are stuck in gambling(which in your dad's case is lottery) and they don't even realise thats what addiction is.
@@forrestyt1302 Mental gymnastics.
Alcohol, Ciggaretes = bad
Lottery = good
The worst thing like this I’ve ever seen was a game in France- I can’t remember what it was called but it’s similar to bingo and runs automatically EVERY 5 MINUTES. The tickets were very expensive- 5 or 8 euros I believe, for a chance to win “only” 100,000 euros. The issue was that the odds of winning were ONE IN 6 BILLION.
kino
I would bet the odds were zero. And that the greed machine does not wish to even take a one in six billion chance of having to give that money to a person.
This was satisfying to watch 😅😅😅 love your sense of humor. When u lost that lotto was the sweet spot 🤣🤣🤣
I live in Alabama where we don’t have a lottery but everyone around me begs about a lottery and I have always seen it as a scam. Like whenever we would go out of state we would get one and get nothing
Bing joker lottery
Win Win Win Win
Johnny lottery Pottery
Win 20 million dollar.
It's good thing because we made money part time.
Start tickets for 1$ buck to 10$ dollar
Spam
It is a scam, pray it never gets okayed in your state
Whether you save those few dollars for a beer, an investment or give it away to a church or homeless stranger, you will have done yourself a service, Mr Friday.
@@Alsatiagent for some reason people around me beg for it
2:26 Do one on the ‘Therapy Scam’ 😂😂
You probably have a higher chance of getting abducted by aliens then actually winning the lotto
This man explained it so honestly and im thankful
The good thing about german Lotto is that the winners can stay anonymous, they don't need to pay taxes on the win, the lottery has really strict advertisement rules and the lottery has to pay taxes which helps the federal state in which the people spend the money.
Wow we are over taxed here our founding fathers are rolling in their graves
LOL at whoever added the highlight on SB 😂 saved me 20 minutes
My did hit the mega millions for 250K back in 2010. It was interesting to say the least. How much they took for taxes was crazy.
Something that I think is intresting is what happened in the UK.
Camelot was/is the company behind the national lottery which was the first lottery we had in the 90s
It was up for renewal several years ago and Branston wanted to buy it and call it the people's lottery. His concept was more winners of a million and a million cap on the prize.
This absolutely didn't happen.. He was villanised in the media instead and the national lottery just exploded with bigger games and lower chances of winning
I wonder if things will change now scamolot have lost the lottery. I have played both the lottery and euromillions from the start and never won more than £200 and in fact have only won twice both being under that 200 quid. I feel that it is just a tax on the poor and they play on the fact that the poorer element of society play it in the almost impossible belief that oneday those numbers will come up. But they won't will they.
Idk my mom's allotment has had loads of funding from the lottery so it's good occasionally sometimes
A lot of recent British Olympic success was bankrolled by the lottery. It allowed athletes to give up their part time jobs and train full time.
The public has no say when it comes to where the money goes. If you look into who/what gets lottery funding you'd be very surprised, if not shocked and even outraged.
In GB instead of buying lottery tickets you can just make a one off investment in Premium Bonds. These go into a monthly draw FOR LIFE, the prizes range between £25 and £1m. Your heirs get the money back when you die. So all you lose is the interest you would have got on your investment.
4:43 aight bet!! That was perfect context. I've been saying "bet" since like 10. I'm 42 now... Ok going back to watching the rest of the show now.
The US government takes tax on a person’s lottery winnings? That’s outrageous! It’s not like that in the UK. Not that I should care since I’ll never win anyway 😭
And the state government, and in some places the city government, as well.
the bet joke got me. you pulled it off smooth until you kept repeating it 😂😂 you CAN BE in touch brooooo
To play the lottery weekly (some daily) for years on end is actually insane. A poor mindset will truly keep you poor forever.
I worked as a coding contractor at the biggest lottery business in Australia and learned a lot from the existing staff I worked with. We went through the actual calculations and statistics of winning Powerball, mind blowing stuff. I’m not a gambler so I have only ever bought 2-3 tickets in my life. You have a higher chance of being hit by lightning twice before winning Powerball in Australia, it would be significantly worse in the US (24M vs 330M population)
Do they rig the lottery ?
@@kawaiipoop3160 Well, for the powerball it's not really rigged.. everyone buys it making the prize bigger, until they show the winning numbers but the odds of being that special person are very very low.
@@kawaiipoop3160no, the mathematical and statistical odds are just shit for the gambler
I love how people win lotto every week, but apparently lots of people are getting struck twice by lightning every week. Must be such a boring news topic that nobody even bothers to report on it anymore. Your statistics suck.
@@kawaiipoop3160they don't need to. just do the math. here where i live they have to legally put the odds in the little thing you put the numbers in
it's simple school maths, just apply to the lottery your curious about to see how hard it is
I'm still here because I enjoy listening to your voice. Thank you for all the educational videos you put it out.
In the UK, the football (soccer) pitch at our school came from national lottery funding.
I've never bought a lottery ticket or even bothered to follow up on tracking the random ones I've gotten as "gifts". They always seemed like a wasteful scam to me.
Honestly it's depressing seeing people throwing their money away like that especially when they clearly need their money and are already extremely poor.
Yup. Tryna talk my friend out of this habit but he wont listen. Lottery preys on willing, desperate, and broke people making them even more broke. Sad stuff.
@@Jspec03 If they are already broke they are broke either way.... Even if they win something that might not change....
Insightful, well researched and important. Thank you! By the way, in Canada you don't pay taxes on lottery earnings as it would be considered double taxing.
I believe here in quebec the prize money is taxed as it counts as revenue
@@blueburyrs949 Quebec is a waste of resources, too.
@@blueburyrs949 False, In Quebec, it is TaxFree
@@SpaceXToMars thank you for the correction
@@blueburyrs949 my pleasure
The lottery is a tax on the poor.
I used to say that the lottery was a tax on dumb people but this is really sad actually
the fact that you imagine spending all the money is like the main reasons I usually buy one lottery ticket at the end of the year. in the Netherlands, the biggest price is 30 milion at the end of the year, it's tax free as well
That is the psychology behind it. The imagination of being able to spend an ungodly amount of money is what convinces people to buy for the first time. It's fine if you can spare those few dollars a year but if becomes dangerous if you lack self control. The addiction pitfall you could end up in is horrible and very difficult to get out of.
@@brosaus Pretty much the only time I ever touch the lottery is when it gets really large and coworkers start doing pools to try and win it. And mostly for the joke of "you aren't winning and quitting and leaving me here by myself", I don't ever expect to actually win or start thinking about what I could do with it. And I never even think about the stupid thing when one of those work pools isn't happening. I could take the $2 and buy a candy bar or something. Still mostly a waste of money and bad for me, but at least I get to enjoy eating it for a few moments and that's more pleasure than a lottery ticket will likely ever give me.
WOOOHOOOO! Thanks man! I feel STRONG after watching this video, I was born poor, I NEEEEVER purchased a lotto ticket nor scratch things in my 51 years of life, many of my Hispanic family members have spent "mucho dinero" all their life buying everything, all the lottos and scratch tickets possible, I worked hard all my life and became a business owner so now at 51 I just receive money from my properties so I don't have to work just keep my renters happy, sadly most my uncles still poor at 70 buying lotto tickets with the social security check...is sad...the Government (Republican or Democrat) always taking from the poor...
Glad you lived(living) a good life with no lotto scams
@@imibuks-replit Thanks! I Thank GOD because he made me too "cheap" to buy lotto tickets LOL! for this reason I have never visit Las Vegas, no way Jose! : )
@@TheMELTDOWN911 I tried gambling when I was a kid, and I like to say that I was lucky to have never won any money. So in a sense, I really got lucky early. People who got "lucky" early, are still hooked hopping they can repeat that.
The thing with me is, I barely respect the money I earn, and I still spend excessively. If I were to get a huge pile of money, it would destroy me completely. It's not just the money, but it would revive my ego and my illusions that universe does look after me after all. I would never recover my working habits, as I would now live in a universe where it is indeed possible to gain a lot of money without putting in a serious effort. I could never focus on work, because I would knew that there is a easy way out. It would make me a gambling addict forever.
So, I prefer living this boring life, where I have to work hard for everything.
@@julius43461 You are the leader of your own destiny, never give up, but respect money, I guess I do respect money because when was a kid had nothing, my dad left us, so most of my childhood had nothing no toys no new clothes no fancy tennis shoes, only could afford buying second hand clothing, my childhood and teenager years were really bad, I even thought to be a drug dealer, Thank GOD I had a Mother who kicked my behind all the time, now at 51 and retired from work only living from the rent of my properties, really appreciate the way mom raised me, with a frickig belt on the hand at all times, I suffered a lot as a kid, I could even say I was abused, but Thanks to that, I live free now, good luck my friend and please respect money is the only way to be free, see I can afford a new Mercedes or BMW, but I drive a 2008 Ford Focus....
I only and always buy a lottery ticket after going to court. I love fantasising about how much i could rip those agencies apart with a measurable amount of wealth.
Okay but nobody forces you to pay it.
So it's not a tax, unless you want to call it a tax on stupidity.
I cannot stop imagining the timeline where Johnny actually won the 20 mil and how fucking wild that would have been.
That is exactly why gambling is so popular, you can imagine winning. But in reality it will not happen.
@@p3rtang I guess some people can. I've never had an interest in gambling. I was taken to Casino in Canada for my 18th birthday and given 100 dollars to gamble with. I kept the money, didn't play a single game. Used it later to buy a camera.
I have many vices but gambling has never been one of them. I do revel in Irony though and love it when expectations are subverted, especially when someone is trying to prove a point.
@@eafortson yeah me neither I really dislike gambling as well, except for some tickets I got from a new years. The numbers never added up for me. In belgium luckily the chances of winning are always printed on the back so Its easier to know whether is super unlikely to win are near impossible lol
in my town in the uk the government rebuilt a pier using lottery money
Yes I really must say this really can't apply to us in the UK, we have a wonderful lottery program that not only does real visual good (like that) but also funds a lot of the arts that get no funding from anywhere else. Just don't play it yourself!
Money well spent
That stray strand of Johnny's hair had my attention for a major chunk of the video 😂😂
Good ole Colarado 13:05
I was super addicted to gambling for over 10 years, being fooled by my own crazy mind chasing that jackpot’ it’s disgusting how badly it can take over your life’ I made a gambling addiction support group if anyone here struggles with gambling! This video is awesome man! ❤
Do you play baccarat 😉
Usernamecheckout
@@NAT-turners-Revenge I did for several years!
@@Tristanboskie nice nice 😁 I just quit 2wks ago.... did all the neccessary things to stop myself from going to play
@@NAT-turners-Revenge I had to do the same thing brother, I was convinced I was a baccarat god until I ended up destroying all my savings. 50k in a month gone. I was given a trial of pain medications and lost total control. Self exclusion is what gave me my life back! I appreciate you sharing this my friend! I hope all is going well now brother!
I've only bought a ticket once and the mindset i had going into it was "If I don't win more than what the ticket cost, I'm not meant to play the lottery again"
The balls have magnetic paint and the computer decides the winning numbers before the draw even takes place.
As an Australian where the government isn't involved in lottery it is crazy that the government runs them.
8:57 Americans will use anything to measure except the metric system.
Another great video! My parents taught me this very thing when I was 15-16 yo. No voluntary extra taxes for me
This is probably the smallest of details but in the video when mentioned Colorado (min 13:03) it shows "ColArado"
No matter who wins the lottery, the govt always wins the jackpot
The sad reality is if you have a choice of no hope or paying 1-2 dollars for an obscure chance you're going to pay no matter how low your chances are. It's a really sad system that I wish was illegal. It really feeds on those already suffering and benefiting off their false hopes.
I am an economist from Sri Lanka and I find your knowledge in economics just amazing ! I love how you are educating the public !
I think I remember him saying in a video that he has a degree in business or economics, something like that
I don’t know man ya should of hired more economists for sure
@@ronjose51 and you should HAVE hired an english teacher
Btw, how is the economic situation in Lanka right now? Hope it's all good.
@@bhavanarayanasripada1354 It's actually looking a little bit more promising, our inflation is reducing and the LKR is appreciating against the dollar. We are really tightening our belts, we have high import bans, but on the converse our exports increased due to the earlier LKR depreciation against the dollar. Also all eyes are on the government, they know they cannot afford another mistake ridden with political myopia. We are doing our best! Also thank you so much for your concern. It's really nice of you to inquire.
I win the lottery every time I don't buy them. Except when I'm in the store behind the patron at the register that does
In Portugal many years ago… on a weekly lottery tv day, they came with number zero! Zero did not even existed as a possible number to bet on!!! 😂😂😂
In Georgia, if you have a decent gpa coming out of high school, in-state tuition is completely covered by the lottery.
Which is funny cuz those are the people least likely to play the lottery
Excellent
The sad thing is I have a better chance of winning the lottery, than my boss giving me a holiday bonus.
Amazing all the things you never hear about in the news regarding government spending and involvement. I was tempted to try the lottery then I see this and am having a slight physical reaction to the duplicity of the system.
There should be transparency and a accountant that investigates the lotto.
In Australia, it’s quite interesting because we have undergone privatisation of almost all of our state and National lotteries (Western Australia being the exception). I never realised why governments had the lottery beforehand but it does make me realise what a short sighted decision it was to sell off so we don’t even get the benefits anymore in tax. Thanks for the video Johnny ❤
That's pretty similar to most privatisation that occurred under the LNP. From CommBank to the power companies, they seem to love giving nationalised things to their buddies on the cheap
@@infernalstan886 same in the UK. Conservatives here love selling our public utilities and public services to private groups and their buddies. Rotten lot they are
That's not true. The Lott is a State Government owned corporation. QLD.
Some goes to state coffers whilst the rest goes to charities.
They just award contracts for people to run it. Still state owned.
Who checks the legitimacy of the lotto and how prone are they to bribes?!
I grew up in Reno, Nevada and learned really quickly that the "odds are always with the house", meaning the entity running the game wins much more than they pay out. I have news for you, most of your taxes are not tracked well and kind of disappears. This is no different.
The lottery has particularly bad percentages. Good casino games generally return 95-98% of total bets to players. Still the odds are with them, don't get me wrong, but if I wanna gamble I'll always go to a casino- I've had some nice wins over the years.
@@mateyp3365 coping comment. "some nice wins over the years" most certainly means "lost money in total"
I lost a couple hundred at the blackjack table trying to impress a cute blonde girl. Soon my money was gone and so was the girl lmao
This is your best yet! The government just get worse, leaches...
My grandpa used to say it's a tax on the stupid, that really hit me as a kid, and I've never even gotten a scratch off, lmao
I love that bit with Johnny waiting on the lottery number and he already lost on the first number. that's so funny! 🤣