Why is the book community so messy?!? | J.K Rowling, Jack Edwards and the Freydís Moon controversy

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 окт 2024
  • Thank you for watching!
    previous video: • Is Booktok turning pub...
    become a channel member - / @renfrances
    THE OPEN BOOK PODCAST - podcasters.spo...
    MY OTHER SOCIAL MEDIAS:
    TWITTER - / renfrances_
    TIKTOK - www.tiktok.com...
    INSTAGRAM - / renfrances_
    Intro and end screen music is 'Anymore' by Windshield used from Epidemic Sound with a valid subscription and license.

Комментарии • 6

  • @eloiseklassen8681
    @eloiseklassen8681 4 месяца назад +6

    the fast fashion argument also doesn't really make that much sense to me because the reason these brands are able to produce so fast is in part because they steal designs and then make them for cheap, so unless the author is plagiarising or copying other writers it isn't really comparable to fast fashion?? this is just working fast. love the comparison to brandon sanderson and stephen king, all of a sudden when it's a woman we have to find a reason to devalue this accomplishment ://

  • @Jay32954
    @Jay32954 4 месяца назад +4

    I don't know anything about the racist author mentioned in the video. But the idea of them pretending to be another race, and publishing under a pseudonym, is incredibly gross, but not at all surprising. Its the same mindset that used to underpin minstrel shows, before we collectively, and correctly, decided they weren't okay anymore.

  • @PumpkinMozie
    @PumpkinMozie 4 месяца назад +5

    JKR never fails to baffle me. I used to idolize her, in part because she had always seemed to me as a genuinely good person. Maybe I was just naive. It floored me when she outed herself as a TERF. I still feel betrayed by it. My inner child wants to say her money changed her, that she was a good person who was corrupted by wealth. But maybe this was always who she was. It’s sad.

    • @renfrances
      @renfrances  4 месяца назад

      @@claudeyazthere is legitimately so much transphobia in everything she says. she literally denied elements of the holocaust existed to try and deny the existence of trans people. if you can’t see what’s wrong with what she’s saying maybe you have a thing or two to work on as well

    • @PumpkinMozie
      @PumpkinMozie 4 месяца назад

      @@renfrancesoh absolutely, I’m in no way trying to defend her. There is no doubt in the world that she is not only transphobic but going out of her way to hurt trans people. I meant by my comment that it was really hard for me to accept that she wasn’t who I thought she was and I tried to give her the benefit of the doubt at first, and she just kept proving that she was a bigot.

    • @renfrances
      @renfrances  4 месяца назад

      @@PumpkinMozie i’m so sorry!! this response was to someone else who i think has deleted their comment!! someone replied to you and said that she wasn’t transphobic at all so i stepped in to say they were wrong!! your comment wS 100% right and i agree with you! i’m so sorry you thought my comment was aimed toward you because it wasn’t at all!! 🩷🩷