The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Atomic Layer Deposition

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 21 сен 2024

Комментарии • 216

  • @andrewpinto50
    @andrewpinto50 Год назад +121

    Always nice to see the industry I’m in being represented so well

    • @Taiyōken-Dai
      @Taiyōken-Dai Год назад +4

      Ditto

    • @CraigChrist8239
      @CraigChrist8239 Год назад +1

      Were either of you the guy at 3:05 who's eyes glazed over and approved a project anyway?

    • @curiodyssey3867
      @curiodyssey3867 Год назад

      You wish

    • @tidel32
      @tidel32 Год назад

      Yes Yes, it has to do with pizzas and cake, don't let the narrative distract you from the images! :P :)

    • @ntabile
      @ntabile Год назад

      Instrumentation Oy! What a name!

  • @andersjjensen
    @andersjjensen Год назад +320

    As a programmer your videos about the never ending toils and tribunals of the lithography world reminds me not to wasteful with system resources. It's clear that at some point we're going to hit a wall called "physics don't care about your computing needs", so while I've seen stupendous performance gains from my Commodore 64 to my Ryzen 7950X3D that party is tapering off.

    • @clintcowan9424
      @clintcowan9424 Год назад +13

      Moore's law prob has a limit.
      Quantum physics might break that physics, who knows

    • @SammyGDude
      @SammyGDude Год назад +19

      @@clintcowan9424 I think that people forget how small chips are currently. Even when we hit that limit, a double in size every every 2 years for the first 10 years will result in chips the size of an orange; I doubt that for our lifetime computing power to size to power requirements will pose an issue.

    • @andersjjensen
      @andersjjensen Год назад +22

      @@clintcowan9424 Moore's law is an observation that turned into a cadence target. Moore actually revised it twice in the early years. And, depending on how exactly you interpret it, it tapered off a decade ago.
      But it is precisely quantum phenomena that starts screwing things up. Since electrons have this uncanny habit of "teleporting" themselves through barriers classical physics say they can't penetrate, at a certain point the thickness of the oxide insulator, needed for ever smaller gates, becomes a problem. We're already having massive leakage problems. Once we start reaching those thicknesses that is going to get exponentially worse.

    • @andersjjensen
      @andersjjensen Год назад +18

      @@10001000101 Room temperature superconductors won't help us unless we also find lower leakage gates and a much faster switching semiconductor. And even then we eventually run into the problem that signals propagate at the speed of light (in that medium), so if we want faster... there is only smaller distances to help us, as we cant speed up light.

    • @autohmae
      @autohmae Год назад +6

      Depending on the interpretation of Moore's Law, in machine learning, Moore's Law is alive and well, actually, things are going faster than Moore's Law:
      "Subsequently, the overall trend speeds up and doubles every 4 to 9 months,” they say. That significantly outperforms Moore's Law".
      This is because of the huge amount of money pouring into machine learning in the past years...
      Those in the comments saying: quantum computers, ...: remember quantum computers are not general computers, they are highly specialized.
      Probably even more specialized than the hardware used for machine learning.

  • @justinklenk
    @justinklenk Год назад +40

    I really love your channel. It's just a spectacularly direct, no-bullshit, yet polished conveyance of what we really yearn and love to learn.
    Thank you. 👍

    • @robert-wr9xt
      @robert-wr9xt Год назад

      Pure red meat or if you prefer pure pea protein.
      ps burn that steak good

    • @FloridaMeng
      @FloridaMeng Год назад

      Here here!

  • @arandomperson8336
    @arandomperson8336 Год назад +6

    I love your videos but as a professional chemist I feel compelled to point out that ALD is an adsorptive process. When something is absorbed is goes into the bulk material, like dipping a sponge in water. When something is adsorbed it adheres to the surface but doesn't go into the bulk material.

  • @KomradZX1989
    @KomradZX1989 Год назад +18

    Next video should be called: “The reasonable effectiveness of Asianometry’s videos to hold my interest without fail” 😂❤
    Great video man, your tickle my nerdy interests EVERY SINGLE VIDEO. 11/10

  • @AllocatorsAsia
    @AllocatorsAsia Год назад +70

    Praise you Jon for breaking down complex topics for simpletons like me to understand. You the real MVP

    • @Nick-gj6je
      @Nick-gj6je Год назад +4

      Joking aside, regardless of background, anyone with the genuine curiosity required to watch these videos is not a simpleton.

    • @omniyambot9876
      @omniyambot9876 Год назад +1

      This is not complex but interesting and sometimes hard to find/combine history..

    • @Nick-gj6je
      @Nick-gj6je Год назад

      @@omniyambot9876 while I agree with you, try telling my girlfriend that

    • @dieSpinnt
      @dieSpinnt Год назад

      @@Nick-gj6je She obviously can't talk for herself. But why is she good as an example? Oh, maybe we can detect "simpletons" by the fact that they can't understand that people have different interests and EXPERTISE (PERIOD!!!!)? Btw, can you please explain to me why you feel so "special"? Combining your stereotypes with your misogynistic views and bragging about that online isn't really the pinnacle of human culture. Wait! No! You're disgusting! By the degenerated eff ... how can be the properties (if meant derogatory or not) of your partner be an answer to a question that @omniyambot9876 never asked.
      Sorry, I may be totally wrong. Possibly you are just joking on the cost of your girlfriend. In front of total strangers ... As......!!!
      ( It is unbelievable, what socially underdeveloped disgusting animals wander the Interwebs nowadays )

  • @christopherleubner6633
    @christopherleubner6633 Год назад +3

    Man a lot has changed since running CVD machines in the nineties and early 2000s. Used to make arsenide laser chip wafers. Once the trimethyl aluminum injector misfired adding two extra shots to a batch of 635nm laser wafers and since it was for the active layer we went with it to see what would happen. At first we thought they were bunk but when we lowered the temperature of the test die to about 15 degC we got pure orange laser light at 612nm. If you got it extremely cold like -77 deg C the wavelength dropped to 602nm which was bright orange.The place was Polaroid lasers then Boston lasers if you were wondering ❤

  • @couchetard1984
    @couchetard1984 Год назад +13

    I am truly enjoying gaining a light grasp of chip design and production. As an electrician, I have grown tired of my ignorance and your channel is an excellent stepping stone towards enlightenment. Your work is excellent. I cannot immagine how busy you are to be so prolofic while maintaining quality. Thank you.

    • @0neIntangible
      @0neIntangible Год назад +2

      Comment liked and same sentiments being said by a retired electrician.

  • @samfedorka5629
    @samfedorka5629 Год назад +11

    I was waiting for the ALD episode after I listened to the Ian Cutress interview. Always good to hear more about semiconductor processing techniques that I work with.

    • @dosgos
      @dosgos Год назад

      Ian wrote some great articles at AnandTech. I just found his RUclips channel. Thanks!

  • @robertb6889
    @robertb6889 Год назад +10

    As someone who has worked directly with ALD for memory chips, you did a great job discussing the topic. And there are actually quite a few more applications and materials out there (that I probably can’t detail on an open web page due to IP concerns.)

    • @scottieb6442
      @scottieb6442 9 месяцев назад

      ALD for thermoelectric devices and as a potential boon for advancing the refractory industry seem interesting.

  • @jmlinden7
    @jmlinden7 Год назад +3

    9:18 source-to-drain leakage is a different phenomenon than gate oxide leakage. If you use the light switch analogy, source-to-drain leakage would be the amount of electricity flowing into the lightbulb even when the switch is off, while gate oxide leakage would be if your finger could zap electricity into the lightbulb when you touch the switch.
    A better designed gate oxide helps reduce both of these leakages though

  • @joseestrada2542
    @joseestrada2542 Год назад +10

    Lol cant believe asianometry knows about olympia tool set. Made me feel proud of the group im working with hehe. Hopefully the predecessor to olympia takes off. Wish us luck! :)

    • @craigslist6988
      @craigslist6988 Год назад +1

      curious, how wasteful of the reactants are purge cycles normally and is the drum method more wasteful of the reactants and it just isn't very expensive for them?

  • @alvinnorin8820
    @alvinnorin8820 Год назад +4

    I was JUST going to search if there were any videos on this topic, and then just before I search, I see this recommended to me; uploaded 20 minutes ago.

  • @lawrencefrost9063
    @lawrencefrost9063 Год назад +8

    Ey it was invented in Finland? In my location? This makes me happy. Great video.

  • @mdharrisuiuc
    @mdharrisuiuc Год назад +4

    I used to manage an ALD about a decade ago. They're really simple to run and maintain, the only real issue being sustained chamber temperatures causing the chamber o-ring seal to degrade over time. Periodically testing the films (we were primarily doing Al2O3 with trimethyl-aluminum and water) for carbon contamination in a ICP-MS is a good check to replace the seal, although it is easier to just replace the seals somewhat frequently.

    • @EkiToji
      @EkiToji Год назад

      Well pump maintenance can be an issue because even with pretty good filters or trying to thermally decompose the precursors you can still end up with deposition on the pump. Granted they're not even particularly expensive pumps since you don't need or even want high vacuum.

  • @alanparker3130
    @alanparker3130 Год назад +4

    Excellent, as ever. I was expecting a mention of a much older technique for molecular deposition : Langmuir-Blodgett layers. It was started off by a German teenager (Agnes Pockels) doing beautiful experiments in her kitchen and finally sending her results to Lord Rayleigh, who got them published in Nature. It's a great story.

  • @fiasco2003
    @fiasco2003 Год назад +50

    I really enjoyed "The Unbearable Lightness of Being". The sequel has been a long time coming. So I hope that my expectations for "The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Atomic Layer Deposition" are not unwarranted.

    • @yyyyyeeeee4060
      @yyyyyeeeee4060 Год назад +9

      It's a reference to a famous 1960 article titled The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Mathematics in the Natural Science - highly recommend a read.

    • @stevengill1736
      @stevengill1736 Год назад +2

      OK, cool, but is there really a sequel? ;^[}

    • @fiasco2003
      @fiasco2003 Год назад

      Aha. That oblique reference went straight over my head. Thanks!!@@yyyyyeeeee4060

  • @stevenjackson8226
    @stevenjackson8226 Год назад +1

    Super cool. I add another thanks for doing this. I saw epitaxial deposition layering way back in the early 1980s at Bell Labs, Murray Hill, NJ. I was taken through the process by the engineers producing GaAs substrate FETs for use in Hughes Aircraft satellites. It's amazing how much further this has improved and what can be done today.

  • @dadawoodslife
    @dadawoodslife Год назад +2

    I remember working at Nottm University, Physics Dept in the 1980s when they were doing MBE. I never know how groundbreaking it was, this just made me realise.
    The same department also invented NMR imaging, what we call MRI today.

  • @JudgeJor
    @JudgeJor Год назад +4

    Good stuff! It could have been emphasised that ALD specifically uses self-limiting surface reactions. This means that each cycle creates precisely a certain thickness of film and that the deposition is extremely conformal. These characteristics are especially useful for high aspect ratio structures or cavities (which were discussed).

  • @mikebarushok5361
    @mikebarushok5361 Год назад +4

    I remember when the higher quality and less expensive electroluminescent panels replaced incandescent illuminated switch and circuit breaker lighting in general aviation aircraft. I never heard anything about the technological break through required to make them practical.

  • @stevesloan6775
    @stevesloan6775 Год назад

    One minute in and I’m already refreshed how you paid respect to the people that first had the concept.
    So many videos on RUclips miss out the most critical information.
    It’s seems so disrespectful to me.
    Thank you.
    🇦🇺🤜🏼🤛🏼🍀😎

  • @sprk373
    @sprk373 Год назад +1

    He "kind of" looks like Colonel Sanders? Thats a 100% match in my book. Great job dude as always

  • @da1otta
    @da1otta Год назад +1

    It never ceases to fascinate me what humanity is capable of achieving.

  • @tykjpelk
    @tykjpelk Год назад +19

    Oh my god I love ALD almost as much as I love atomic layer etch. There are things I want to do with this technology that were discarded by better nanotechnologists just because it's too damn slow for the scales needed by photonics. Still hopeful.

  • @tylermyers3106
    @tylermyers3106 Год назад +3

    Excellent video as always! I love that I work in ALD. It's an elegant technique with seemingly endless applications, and the community is one of the best scientific communities I've had the pleasure to interact with. I run a podcast interviewing ALD folks, called ALD Stories. Some excellent people to listen to!

  • @craigslist6988
    @craigslist6988 Год назад +1

    just FYI there is a difference between absorption and adsorption, and this is one of the times where it's useful to know the difference. The molecules in ALD are adsorbed.

  • @yuema2078
    @yuema2078 Год назад +2

    Good video as usual. A couple of suggestions: add some equipment suppliers information will be nice (ASM, Beneq, Picosun, which was bought by Applied Materials). Also ALD is a self limiting process therefore it does not have deposition uniformity concerns as in PVD or CVD. This unique feature could be mentioned as it gives ALD a huge advantage over CVD. Lastly, on spatial alternation method, it does not have to be rotation drum + multiple chambers - there have been single chamber linear systems used in the industry for at least 7, 8 years. An example is PERC process in thin film solar panel manufacturing equipment, where substrates move back and forth in a liner chamber with zones separated by purge gas curtains.

    • @alfredcpr837
      @alfredcpr837 Год назад

      Hello Yuema, we see many different ALD players in the industry (Also LAM, Eugene...) but can we assume that ASM and Oxford Instruments own the best solution (Aspect Ratio / Deposition Rate / Step Coverage) ? Because every time you listen AMAT, they are pretty confident to their ability to gain market share, that's why they bought Picosun right ?

  • @armamentarmedarm1699
    @armamentarmedarm1699 Год назад

    "ALD as we know it was invented in Finland"
    Immediately made me imagine a hydraulic press crushing the material down to one atom thick.

  • @richardwhitehouse8762
    @richardwhitehouse8762 10 месяцев назад

    I just wanted to say, as someone who really didn't pay enough attention to chemistry and physics at school but who is interested now in how things like semi conductors work, thank you for producing this amazing content. It gives a complete non-techhie like me a chance of grasping something about it. So, many, many thanks.
    PD I loved the bit about the Finnish Dr looking at the periodic table for inspiration. Its a bit the same as when as a musician you look at a score and find the underlyning patterns.

  • @redlogicsquare
    @redlogicsquare Год назад +3

    Valentin Borisovich Aleskovsky is also winner of most Russian name award.

  • @hai-duynguyen8429
    @hai-duynguyen8429 Год назад +1

    This speaks to me on a number of levels. I don’t work on ALD but epitaxy. I can appreciate the difficulty of nano scale growth

  • @chillphil967
    @chillphil967 Год назад +1

    love your channel. just added the “bell” to my notification settings.
    thx from detroit 🤙

  • @woolfel
    @woolfel Год назад +4

    another good video explaining some complex stuff.

  • @largezo7567
    @largezo7567 Год назад +5

    I'm a Finn, but I had never heard of this remarkable invention before.

    • @tylermyers3106
      @tylermyers3106 Год назад +1

      Tuoma Suntola earned the Millennium Prize for the ALD invention!

    • @brodriguez11000
      @brodriguez11000 Год назад

      Interesting how the inability to patent and hence facilitate a transition from academia to commercial made all the difference. Something some in the states complains about because all academic work should belong to the public.

    • @MarcCastellsBallesta
      @MarcCastellsBallesta Год назад

      ​@@brodriguez11000 I had a boss years ago who told me that the technology transfer from academia to industry is called is called "The valley of death".
      Many industries have needs academia has already solved, but either they don't communicate enough or there's a scaling problem.

  • @nayhem
    @nayhem Год назад +1

    Cake in an ALD demonstration, but no mention of flouring the pan. Those first layers of grease and flour can literally make or break the cake.

  • @KevinLyda
    @KevinLyda Год назад +3

    Wild, I didn't know chip makers and lawyers both depended on depositions...

  • @cpt_bill366
    @cpt_bill366 Год назад +4

    They missed the opportunity to name a company ALD Incorporated, or ALDI

  • @teddy0819tw
    @teddy0819tw Год назад +1

    I love all these series. Will there be another nice introduction on atomic layer etching?

  • @hansbleuer3346
    @hansbleuer3346 Год назад +2

    Hut ab.
    Didaktisch hervorragend gestaltetes Video.

  • @MarcCastellsBallesta
    @MarcCastellsBallesta Год назад

    Your video would have been so helpful when I was studying nanomaterials back at university...
    Really well done!

  • @zallen05
    @zallen05 Год назад +3

    I would love to see you cover PVD as well.

  • @artbanks27
    @artbanks27 Год назад

    I was wondering if this was even possible I'm glad it is.
    Thanks for your explanation mate.

  • @drmosfet
    @drmosfet Год назад +1

    When seeing your thumbnail photo I thought this might be about taking that electron tunnelling microscope technique of making atoms sized greeting cards to the next level in manufacturing. But still very interesting.

  • @AaronSchwarz42
    @AaronSchwarz42 Год назад

    Most excellent description of ALD with graphics professor John :)

  • @KomradZX1989
    @KomradZX1989 11 месяцев назад

    Wait so they were working on flat panel displays way back in the 1970s?!?!?!
    MIND BLOWN 🤯

  • @mururoa7024
    @mururoa7024 Год назад

    Thanks for breaking it down for us in such simple and understandable terms. 👍👍

  • @SUNRISE-ADVENTURES
    @SUNRISE-ADVENTURES Год назад +4

    TOP NOTCH WORK!!! This stuff makes my brain hurt...LOL

  • @MrSuperBrite
    @MrSuperBrite Год назад +5

    Sun in Suntola is pronounced the same way Sun in Sun Yat-Sen.

  • @budlaumer
    @budlaumer Год назад

    Thanks for making me think.

  • @miinyoo
    @miinyoo Год назад +2

    I'm a little surprised no one has yet figured out a reliable way to "air brush" atoms onto a substrate. Of course I don't mean using actual air as the motive medium since it has to be done in as near perfect a vacuum as possible. Argon might be too big of an atom to use so Helium seems a superior option since it can escape minute barriers. Pure H2 could be cheaper if the substances aren't proton reactive at the temperatures of adequate deposition. Either way, one would need to ensure the "bubbles" are so small that they don't affect the final product. Sans that, annealing can help remove the nano-cavities created by the distribution "air". Or, as is done with particular plasmas, an electrostatic "air brush" working with ions. Tune the power down so instead of crashing into a substrate displacing other atoms, they land softly accompanying a neutralizing spray of electrons to lock it all in place. Purge, rinse, repeat in very much the same idea as creating seasoning on a cast iron pan.
    Of course I may be way off base since we're dealing with so many variables on an atomic scale most of which aren't relevant once you get to the micron scale.

    • @mduckernz
      @mduckernz Год назад

      You could consider the plasma technique mentioned to be roughly equivalent

  • @ag3127
    @ag3127 Год назад +1

    Can you talk about the chip used by Huawei 60 Pro - who made them?

  • @TomLynchIsAwsome
    @TomLynchIsAwsome Год назад +4

    BANGER VIDEO

  • @Jaxon220
    @Jaxon220 Год назад

    I work for a company that makes deposition equipment and I’m only slightly disappointed I didn’t see one of our systems in this video 😢

  • @usercid640
    @usercid640 Год назад

    Man, you're learning more than me about deposition

  • @KepZubel
    @KepZubel Год назад +1

    I am assuming you will release a video on Huawei’s 7nm chips, right?

  • @LuciFeric137
    @LuciFeric137 Год назад +1

    Love these historical looks

  • @cosmicmuffet1053
    @cosmicmuffet1053 Год назад

    We have reached the edge of comprhensable limits.

  • @brandonpalafox8932
    @brandonpalafox8932 Год назад

    The chemical commonly used is HMDS. Which has a byproduct of ammonia so we gotta test for amines after application.

  • @EkiToji
    @EkiToji Год назад

    At around 5:44 you mean to say adsorption and not absorption. Absorption has a fluid permeate into a substance but adsorption is surface adhesion.

  • @badrinair
    @badrinair Год назад

    Thank you

  • @GodmanchesterGoblin
    @GodmanchesterGoblin Год назад

    Candidate for RUclips "Video Title of the Year"! And a very informative video too.

  • @tomholroyd7519
    @tomholroyd7519 Год назад

    as they shrank, they shrunk

  • @al4x5
    @al4x5 Год назад

    I really like your videos. I think they are always very information rich and easy to understand.
    Could you make some videos about different wafer bonding techniques one day perhaps?

  • @davieb8216
    @davieb8216 Год назад

    The stock footage you used at 6:20 didn't demonstrate your point very well. The first pour looked smoother relative to its thickness.... Anyway thanks for making this stuff interesting.

  • @BlahBlahBleh317
    @BlahBlahBleh317 Год назад

    The only RUclips channel currently worth watching!!

  • @dndboy13
    @dndboy13 Год назад

    look the topic is interesting and all but there's a part of me deep down that's thrilled about a Soviet Commissar Sanders lookalike.

  • @FeintMotion
    @FeintMotion Год назад +2

    she layer on my deposits until I atom

  • @nexusyang4832
    @nexusyang4832 Год назад

    ngl, i think i may have to listen to this lecture a few times to sink in.....

  • @AlexGheorghe
    @AlexGheorghe Год назад

    waiting to hear the credits just to learn about the fate of hair and makeup!

  • @alexandruraresdatcu
    @alexandruraresdatcu Год назад +1

    I would be a bit skeptical about russians claiming to have invented something a couple of years before someone actually getting a patent for that process....

  • @werre2
    @werre2 Год назад

    The company is Väisälä

  • @fkknsikk
    @fkknsikk Год назад

    That is one of the worst sauce applications I've ever seen on a pizza.

  • @robert-wr9xt
    @robert-wr9xt Год назад

    Mass content week. Awesome.

  • @fundingsecured7072
    @fundingsecured7072 Год назад

    Whats your take on Huawei's new CPU? Can you make a video about it?

  • @emeraldwind
    @emeraldwind Год назад

    Are you going to release a video about Huawei's new 7nm phone?

  • @AaronSchwarz42
    @AaronSchwarz42 Год назад

    Molecular precision manipulation of atoms to make very high precision products like chips or chipsets or IC or integrated circuits (eg ECU, GPU, SOC, Sensors, ETC) // the most complicated & complex products made!

  • @JamesOliverLindsey
    @JamesOliverLindsey Год назад

    why do the atoms want to assemble DNA strands etc? does everything just boil down to some 1s and 0s math equation that defines all interactions?

  • @KokkiePiet
    @KokkiePiet Год назад

    Could you do a video on optical coatings, like on lenses or heat reflective windows?

  • @awah4676
    @awah4676 Год назад

    I really have no use for this information... But I'm gonna watch it anyway

  • @Renormal
    @Renormal Год назад

    I operated an MBE machine during my internship.

  • @aloksharma4611
    @aloksharma4611 Год назад

    Thanks!

  • @williamwoosleyiv6150
    @williamwoosleyiv6150 Год назад +3

    modern lithography probably has some odd connection with the inception of lasagna. or some other more ancient layered recipe, with an understanding of science/engineering LOL.

  • @frittsdonoghue478
    @frittsdonoghue478 Год назад +2

    Easily your best titled video

  • @LorenStClair
    @LorenStClair Год назад

    THX great topic

  • @quark31
    @quark31 Год назад

    What is the role of ASM Intl here in ALD? How do you view it?

  • @sayrerowan734
    @sayrerowan734 Год назад +2

    It's shrunk, not shrank, in that instance.
    But a very informative video, as usual.

  • @skaltura
    @skaltura 11 месяцев назад

    LOHJA: Cool how close you came, but the J is hard, as is the H. loHJa is closer on the pronounciation. Still, good effort! :)

  • @ibnu7942
    @ibnu7942 Год назад

    i don't understand a thing but i still watch this till the end

  • @BobBob-nr1zt
    @BobBob-nr1zt Год назад

    When paired with "have", "shrank" becomes "shrunk". :-)

  • @temperultor7602
    @temperultor7602 Год назад

    Will you be doing atomic layer etching next?

  • @Asura_vithu
    @Asura_vithu Год назад +2

    Seems like you're philosophy buff as indicated by your title

  • @mefobills279
    @mefobills279 Год назад +2

    The substrate has to be hydrogen terminated before dep. TSMC especially has tried to poach or work around my patent.

    • @craigslist6988
      @craigslist6988 Год назад +1

      what patent is that?

    • @mefobills279
      @mefobills279 Год назад

      @craigslist6988 low temp oxidation of silicon using chemical oxidation and etch, then terminate with hydrogen. Basically, if the surface isn't perfect, then the dep doesn't take. The oems for ald especially want it. Doesn't matter. When you are an employee, you sign your inventor rights away. I did have to defend the invention, even to the point of having my logbooks examined.

    • @craigslist6988
      @craigslist6988 Год назад

      @@mefobills279 that sounds very basic though.. guessing it's the exact conditions and chemical. Still, wouldn't this patent be out of protection by now?

    • @mefobills279
      @mefobills279 Год назад +1

      @craigslist6988 I was vague. Yes, it gets more complex, using ozone, etc. All invention can be reduced to some simple concept. Still active patent. Generally, big companies cudgel each other because they mutually poach. This is why Google bought Motorola to then move in on Apples I phone turf. The Chinese, especially poach. You have to sue, and that takes big bucks. Like Elon says, patents are a cook book, yet Tesla still gets them.

    • @craigslist6988
      @craigslist6988 Год назад

      @@mefobills279 all good. And I don't know of anyone who would file for a patent to protect IP if they thought they could keep it as trade secret. Even patents are not always a cookbook. I have mostly patents that are useless for actually making the things, because key aspects of the method to apply the ideas are left out as trade secret. I don't care to look into Tesla's patents but design, especially mechanical, is impossible to hide so I could see patenting novel inventions there. I wish the patent system was somehow more effective because I know a lot of the details get reinvented as trade secrets in many companies and all it serves to do is let large companies monopolize it. Or in some cases they just invent it and then sit on it until it gets forgotten, even the inventor cannot tell anyone or use it because as you said all companies require full sign over.

  • @zailoleite6770
    @zailoleite6770 Год назад

    I want the recipe for that starfish pizza and I want it now

  • @kevin_6217
    @kevin_6217 Год назад

    Thicknesses is thickness, absolute.
    Thinness is RELATIVE, it's a comparison.

  • @mansurtxafapapaias3517
    @mansurtxafapapaias3517 Год назад

    The planes fly due to a inestable system.
    The chips works due a inestable & doped systems.

  • @chadterry9770
    @chadterry9770 Год назад

    Have shrunk, not have shrank

  • @andrewmelean8259
    @andrewmelean8259 6 месяцев назад

    Awesome

  • @mennowitteveen3313
    @mennowitteveen3313 Год назад

    I am testing timestamp comments. 6:31

  • @werre2
    @werre2 Год назад +1

    TORILLE!