Ranking Every Dusttale take (From Worst to Best)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 1 тыс.

  • @Military_base01
    @Military_base01  Месяц назад +273

    Just a comment to clarify some stuff and explain why some Dusttales were NOT in the video:
    "Why are there not Undertale 2014 and Herald of Gigyas"
    Undertale 2014 isn't a dust au and herald of Gigyas is simply Dusttale inspired apparently
    "Why aren't there Last genocide or Flawless Genocide?"
    I consider Last genocide to be more of a mix between Last breath and Dusttale rather than its own take on Dusttale.
    as for Flawless Genocide (also applies for HyperDust, Dustdust etc.) i think it's more of a Dusttale AT rather than its own take on such.
    "why is there not Dustdust"
    that's also a dust AT
    "Why aren't there Dusttale AUS like HorrorDust, Dustfell an-" Those are not takes.
    If I forgot to credit something or someone or you're just searching for something in the video and can't find it in the DESCRIPTION just ask/ tell me.
    There may have been some takes i just FORGOT to include or that got new stuff added as I was making the vid and i didn't know or it was too late to include it (I went back and redid the rankings like 4 times cus of UT!Dusttale or cus i changed my mind about where a dusttale should rank etc lol)

    • @migosp43
      @migosp43 Месяц назад +3

      based.

    • @strikiller411
      @strikiller411 Месяц назад +2

      @@Military_base01 why u didnt mention SP! DustTale - the Finale: Posthumous btw?

    • @Shiryuu-x5o
      @Shiryuu-x5o Месяц назад +1

      @@strikiller411 that’s in the video bruh

    • @Shiryuu-x5o
      @Shiryuu-x5o Месяц назад +1

      Nvm i didn’t read your comment properly there wasn’t the “finale” in his vid mbmb

    • @inciniumz4671
      @inciniumz4671 Месяц назад +2

      Herald of Giygas is pretty underground

  • @Brendanowl
    @Brendanowl Месяц назад +510

    Papyrus: why are you killing me?!
    Dust sans: well I I I uh.. You see I uh... The human was like uh... I i... It wasnt... I uh... I didn't mean... The human gemosided. You... And like.. Uh. I uh... I can uh stop that...

    • @gregheffley715
      @gregheffley715 Месяц назад +49

      Peak

    • @DaviUndertale
      @DaviUndertale Месяц назад +35

      MY SANITY, WHAT DID YOU DO TO MY SANITY?

    • @hybridvenom9
      @hybridvenom9 Месяц назад +27

      Dust Sans: "Uhhh I have to kill you because....Plot."

    • @nathanpierce7681
      @nathanpierce7681 Месяц назад +5

      if dust sans wasn't being carried by his delusions he'd genuinely fall apart over what he just did lmao

    • @Meri637
      @Meri637 Месяц назад +2

      absolute cinema

  • @edwin2red
    @edwin2red Месяц назад +538

    “WHAT IS HIS/HER PROBLEM?” 🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥💯💯💯

  • @funnyboneman93
    @funnyboneman93 Месяц назад +510

    dusttale is an amazingly cool concept even if it "doesn't make sense", most people hate on it because some takes are ass- when there are multiple really cool ones that people ignore.

    • @nosoydes9916
      @nosoydes9916 Месяц назад +11

      This is so true it can be so fun to play with the concept

    • @extremempsilvamps5851
      @extremempsilvamps5851 Месяц назад +6

      But sans plan is shit

    • @funnyboneman93
      @funnyboneman93 Месяц назад +30

      @@extremempsilvamps5851 not... really...?
      he tried everything else possible. and i think i'd be also very confused and take drastic actions if i remembered my and my friend's deaths 327 times-

    • @Watcher-pt6uq
      @Watcher-pt6uq Месяц назад +10

      One of the best ones I recall was some old fan animation that did a pretty typical Dustfall story, until the twist near the end that Frisk wasn't surprised by it at all. Cause Dustfall is just an event that happens every 1000 genocides or so, and Frisk had gone through so many genocides that they weren't bothered by it at all. So yeah, this concept can be done well.

    • @axelinedgelord4459
      @axelinedgelord4459 Месяц назад +3

      before this video, i thought so too, and believed good dusttale takes were few and far between.
      i was very, very wrong.

  • @Yuti640
    @Yuti640 Месяц назад +327

    I'll be the first to admit my Papyrus writing suuuuuucks, probably should've given that some more time to cook but I'm generally just not too good at Papyrus
    by the by, as for Flowey resenting CHARA, that's due to this geno reset cycle being done 27 times now, Flowey fearing CHARA over and over and seeing their scary face again and again, at this point he's felt that his best friend is just completely gone, so wants to take their SOUL and simply end everything

    • @x-gigaraptor8843
      @x-gigaraptor8843 Месяц назад +51

      I honestly think that scene was done incredibly well. There's a lot to consider when making these characters interact. Papyrus's last line got to me honestly, despite the comedic moments beforehand. All you really had to go off of what was flowey had stated about papyrus, and I think you nailed it.

    • @breadmaster5614
      @breadmaster5614 Месяц назад +9

      I think tour dusttale is awesome and has loads of potential!

    • @kaled8839
      @kaled8839 Месяц назад +23

      i guess half the issue with papyrus is that its very hard to confront him with tragedy, we don't know how he truly reacts to it. The best we currently have is the neutral ending where papyrus is told all his dead friends are "on vacation" and for half a second talking about them, his expression drops and he loses what i interpret as a tough facade. I don't think he's as stupid as he unfortunately comes off as in your papyrus scene, mostly an incredibly tough exterior. This video didn't have the foresight of the anomaly video explaining why sans didn't do a thing though, which definitely wouldve added to this. Sans is characterised PERFECTLY, which is incredible considering you peeled back his personality, part of his appeal is the mystery behind him. my yap session is over now

    • @Yuti640
      @Yuti640 Месяц назад +8

      @@kaled8839 yeah, the anomaly video was in the works before this one came out but I was just too slow

    • @gnlpsmff0808
      @gnlpsmff0808 Месяц назад

      Strange, flowey/asriel is the type to not want anything to end.

  • @That_Girl_Robin
    @That_Girl_Robin Месяц назад +149

    Yo, Co-Owner of Dusttale Remastered here, thanks for the mention, as of now the game is definitely shaping up to be pretty good imo, and even an entirely different secret route planned for if you do something in a certain fight
    Either way, we are having Evan himself oversee production, so look at this as the semi-official remaster and rewrite of the game
    Currently doing mixing updates to a few songs and then grassdude will get go work on coding, hoping to have it out by the end of next year

    • @ElPeloXD
      @ElPeloXD Месяц назад +2

      seems cool enough!

    • @RalseiDRsocoolWOW
      @RalseiDRsocoolWOW Месяц назад +9

      Keep my memories scene or I scream

    • @That_Girl_Robin
      @That_Girl_Robin Месяц назад +3

      @@RalseiDRsocoolWOW It'll stay in some capacity but it'll be heavily rewritten

    • @Ryquiche
      @Ryquiche Месяц назад +3

      @@That_Girl_Robin my memories!

    • @sodiumhydride1
      @sodiumhydride1 Месяц назад +3

      ​@@Ryquichewhat did you do to my memories?!

  • @CoolGuy37123
    @CoolGuy37123 Месяц назад +105

    1:20:26
    “what are you doing?”
    “pissing.”
    wait his writing.. is this fire..?!?!

    • @Yuti640
      @Yuti640 20 дней назад +3

      Asgorenotpiss

    • @DaviGamingOFC
      @DaviGamingOFC 16 дней назад +5

      bro lost his sanity but not his humor

  • @ElMasterTrolaster
    @ElMasterTrolaster Месяц назад +67

    Hey, director of Reimagined here!
    Honestly, I never thought that there were actually this many DUSTTALE Takes out there lol
    It's really interesting to see the different iterations and ideas that everyone has for this Undertale AU
    And it's really cool to see Reimagined being one of them! xD
    Ngl I never actually thought that my take would get as much recognition as it did, but I'm so happy that people like my silly ideas! :D
    I love that you added the Betrayal-kill thing! I don't think that enough people are talking about it, and fun fact, it's going to be a pretty big mechanic (also yes, you'll be able to use the dash in ANY battle + in the OW)
    The Sans fight is actually a genocide fight, but we need to re-do the script for it (once we're done with the Demo) to fit better in the game
    We're currently working on remaking some songs in the OST (not saying which ones we're remaking) and hopefully we'll be releasing a Devlog in the late half of November - the first half of December!
    Can't wait for y'all to see what we have in store! ;)
    (Also minor thing but Friendliness Pellets was actually done by Bannerman, not Fazzy LMAO)

  • @haloboi3803
    @haloboi3803 Месяц назад +156

    i’m a proud top 5 take. the bonus in my dustbelief isn’t official, it was a concept

    • @I_existokay
      @I_existokay Месяц назад +3

      The ost goes hard for ur take

    • @slikibo1
      @slikibo1 Месяц назад +2

      swapdust

    • @cla_6
      @cla_6 Месяц назад +1

      its liminal.

    • @sirtopoftheworldegg
      @sirtopoftheworldegg Месяц назад +1

      cant believe the first time i saw you was in scratch... and then i got indirectly involved...

  • @ThatGabrielGuy_1985
    @ThatGabrielGuy_1985 Месяц назад +205

    Meh, we all know that the best dusttale version is-
    *"MY MEMORIES!!! WHERE ARE MY MEMORIES!!! AAAAAAAAAAAA-"*

  • @dodo3095
    @dodo3095 Месяц назад +208

    I feel like a Dusttale take with Prunsel would be an interesting idea. He doesn’t… kill people directly persay reality just rots away and degenerates around him and the underground is trying (and failing) to survive this. He acts a sort of parasite that infects timelines, slowly rotting them until nothing is left. Meanwhile sans is playing along with idea that Prunsel is his brother out of fear while subtly trying to warn the human. It could even be hinted at that Prunsel is actually a FUN event originally meant to affect Papyrus that glitched somehow.

    • @NonObjectiveName
      @NonObjectiveName Месяц назад +13

      concept goes insanely hard i’d love to see this get real

    • @thelazyguy72
      @thelazyguy72 Месяц назад +13

      how did you cook this hard we need someone to make this a reality

    • @DaviUndertale
      @DaviUndertale Месяц назад +5

      ​@@thelazyguy72 this guy cooked, Toriel level too

    • @funny250wall
      @funny250wall Месяц назад +1

      No he’s just papyrus cousin he doesn’t do alat

    • @Crimson-jf1sl
      @Crimson-jf1sl Месяц назад

      Cooking is going hard

  • @davidholanda1
    @davidholanda1 Месяц назад +61

    Based_Guy is without a doubt the #1 DUSTTALE fan
    bro managed to count every take of it or anything inspired by it, but have to rank the ones that truly counts

  • @NamelessDragon21
    @NamelessDragon21 Месяц назад +72

    HOLY SHIT, he actually found the novel dust comic which is actually peak that you, made this the greatest day of my life

  • @Ars5577
    @Ars5577 Месяц назад +86

    The owner of dusttale: the murderous comedy is here. Well, I'm happy with my 11th place finish. Also, thanks to you, I realized what my dusttale problem is. If I may say so, I notice the fly, in the form of various visual minutiae, and try to improve it, but I don't notice the elephant, in the form of terrible dialog.

    • @xfhhf-r2i
      @xfhhf-r2i 23 дня назад +4

      W creator taking advice like that and using it to better their creation. I think when MC comes out, it has the potential to be really good

  • @alext794
    @alext794 23 дня назад +24

    Please check out “Doctor Megalo” a Alphys Dusttale Take by ArtsyRean. It was fun read with a different story than the usual “OH GOD SANS IS KILLING” and explores Sans in a way that’s way more interesting then the usual while still fleshing out other characters. Letting Alphys be the villain was honestly pretty interesting and uses her strengths pretty well. Overall a great AT and a great reimagining of the Dusttale Formula.

  • @SussyAmogusmapper-qs1sm
    @SussyAmogusmapper-qs1sm Месяц назад +365

    missed opportunity to call the dustales "dusttakes"

    • @Military_base01
      @Military_base01  Месяц назад +110

      how did i not think about it sooner

    • @The_Joshuan_Empire
      @The_Joshuan_Empire Месяц назад +14

      ​@Military_base01 WELL CHANGE IT ALREADY IT SHOULDNT TAKE YOU A HOUR TO MAKE THE TITLE "reviewing dusttakes" OR SUM IDK

    • @The_Joshuan_Empire
      @The_Joshuan_Empire Месяц назад +5

      ​@@Military_base01btw w video watched the whole thing

    • @gnlpsmff0808
      @gnlpsmff0808 Месяц назад +2

      LOL

    • @YellowClovers
      @YellowClovers Месяц назад +3

      🔥

  • @TheSpicyDeveloper
    @TheSpicyDeveloper Месяц назад +793

    MY MEMORIES!!1! 😮😮😭😭
    WHAT DID YOU DO TO MY MEMORIES?!?!?!??!?!🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥💯💯💯

  • @ellen_UT
    @ellen_UT Месяц назад +130

    Hi there, Owner and Coder of Team Delusionals DUSTTALE here
    Yeah i completely agree with the ost part, some of the tracks will be remade someday
    I kinda am surprised td was in this since we havent shown a lot so its hard to base rating on it VS other dusttales, but still nice to see
    As for the final encounter thing, yeah literally everything in it is outdated lmao, i am not proud of that in any way and showing a final fight to a full length game was a very stupid choice
    As for the skelebros video i hate that last line i added now LOL probably gonna change it or remove the line all together, its very unfitting and just a bad line + DTGE does the same thing which i forgot about lol

    • @theshadownator
      @theshadownator Месяц назад +1

      Great to hear that u guys are improving on it!

    • @jardthefard
      @jardthefard Месяц назад +1

      Hello ellen dusttale

  • @jardthefard
    @jardthefard Месяц назад +112

    The creator of brotherly love said that there is a pacifist route where you catch up to sans and fight him early. That's why there are so many encounters, some will for genocide, and some for pacifist

    • @SpectroliteDS
      @SpectroliteDS Месяц назад +10

      There's also some Neutral Route exclusives as well

    • @goldendarius
      @goldendarius Месяц назад +15

      Hi as the co writer of dtbl me and sharky have agreed to just have "route dependant" mixes of the same tracks so we can clean the soundcloud page

  • @MaxHardcore44
    @MaxHardcore44 Месяц назад +43

    we are DUSTING the TALE with this one!!!!
    Glad you enjoyed dtge! We'll surely cook smth quite unusual there just you wait......

  • @YellowClovers
    @YellowClovers Месяц назад +82

    My dusttales...WHAT DID YOU DO TO MY DUSTTALES!?
    ~Spoilers for 1~
    I MISS YOU my GOAT!!!

  • @stretch6706
    @stretch6706 Месяц назад +62

    Just wait till the game comes out 💪

    • @AdrianBurner-q7r
      @AdrianBurner-q7r Месяц назад +3

      I hope to see what you all have been cooking up 😎 I wish you best for your dustale take!

    • @CaioSam901
      @CaioSam901 Месяц назад +1

      Truly a deserved #1 place! Excited for your project since the start.

    • @Axasio
      @Axasio Месяц назад

      Keep cooking 🔥

    • @goldendarius
      @goldendarius Месяц назад +3

      I take back what I said some months ago you know what you're doing just wish I had looked into it a lil deeper. But please for the love of God the papyrus head.... change it.... please.....

    • @rascamedi0
      @rascamedi0 Месяц назад +2

      I LOVE DUSTTALE I MISS YOU‼️‼️

  • @Eternatus00
    @Eternatus00 Месяц назад +77

    An hour and a half long video about undertale fangames? My autism is very happy

  • @rarewubbox6413
    @rarewubbox6413 Месяц назад +9

    All Dusttale Timestamps:
    - *SPOILER* -
    - MEH DUSTTALES -
    26: Dusttale, Fractured Queen - 2:15
    25: Dusttale, Spear of Vengeance - 4:42
    24: Dusttale, Ask Dusttale - 7:47
    23: Original Dusttale/Evan's Dusttale - 8:20
    - NICE DUSTTALES -
    22: SP!Dusttale - 11:07
    21: SP!Dusttale Take - 16:30
    20: Dusttale by Del - 17:48
    19: Dusttale by Lovegeezer - 20:11
    18: Dusttale: Reprisal - 23:06
    17: IDUTSHANE - 25:42
    16: LACRIMOSA (i think) - 27:05
    15: Dusttale by Team Delusional - 28:52
    - GOOD DUSTTALES -
    14: Dusttale Reimagined - 30:26
    13: Dusttale Renewed - 33:28
    12: UT!Dusttale - 38:15
    11: Dusttale, The Murderous Comedy - 43:52
    10: Undertale: Collapsed - 47:31
    9: Dusttale, The Genocide's End - 51:48
    8: Dusttale: I Miss You [Epik SnacK's take] - 59:49
    7: Dusttale, Kazakhstan - 1:02:26
    6: Dusttale: The ID - 1:06:47
    - HONORABLE MENTIONS -
    - Solunary's Dusttale - 1:08:57
    - Dusttale (Roblox Game) - 1:09:11
    - Dusttale Abyss/Dusttale OMEGA - 1:09:32
    - Dustwawa - 1:09:42
    - Dusttale DUSTSTORM - 1:10:03
    - TOP 5/GOD TIER DUSTTALES -
    5: Dusttale (Haloboi3's Take) - 1:10:25
    4: Dusttale: Brotherly LOVE - 1:14:30
    3: Novel Dust - 1:16:29 (TEXT JUMPSCARE)
    2: Dusttale Mortemobire/David's Dusttale - 1:17:38
    1: *Dusttale: I Miss You/Stretch's Dusttale* - 1:21:18
    If you find any mistakes, would be greatly appreciated to correct them in the replies. Thanks!

  • @dELTA_V-h5u
    @dELTA_V-h5u Месяц назад +10

    Artist for i Dusttale IMY here, thank you so much for your support its really nice seeing people enjoy my shitty little animations and sprites. Great video im definetly not biased

  • @shiny1556
    @shiny1556 Месяц назад +20

    We loving our brother with this one!
    Really happy to see the Dusts I like get rated so high. I love Brotherly Love and I MISS YOU. Brotherly Love is Brotherly Love but I MISS YOU is just special to me, it fills that edge but also that serious melancholy, plus it’s fairly memey and reminds me a ton of Postal which does a lot for me. I am so excited to see it as a full game.
    I don’t know enough IDUTSHANE outside of thinking the name is dumb but I love the visuals it has. It is creepy and reminds me a lot of what I love from Postal.

  • @DusttaleSov
    @DusttaleSov Месяц назад +43

    Official Spear of Vengeance account here!
    I hope you enjoy the memes and their Sov power here!!!
    Ok Ok, on a more serious note, I hope that when people see what Spear of Vengeance will be, they don't stay with what its Legacy version was.
    Because we even created a Dusttale take from scratch, just for this! There are things that at first glance people will tell us "edgy Dusttale goes brrr", but they are actually possible things and it is simply the way that we handle the characters!.
    also fun fact: Edirstoteles initially did NOT know that Evan Dusttale was not official, so Legacy Sov occupies Evan Dusttale xd (currently we use our own take, Sov/Eg!Dusttale!)

    • @DusttaleSov
      @DusttaleSov Месяц назад +4

      Son Of Vengeance, why you say my mistake?? ;-;
      - Edirstoteles

    • @DusttaleSov
      @DusttaleSov Месяц назад

      Because you are NNNNNNNIIIGGGAAAHHHH
      - Glitch

    • @Many_Miles_Hedgehog_Official
      @Many_Miles_Hedgehog_Official Месяц назад +1

      To help clarify there are 3 versions with for eras. Old Legacy/Legacy, Pre-Definitive and Definitive. As someone who has been on the team I really recommend checking out the channel, reading the community posts and supporting the game when it releases. And hey same goes for most of these takes and fangames. Maybe even try becoming a team member for one or two of them need it.

    • @DusttaleSov
      @DusttaleSov Месяц назад +2

      @@Many_Miles_Hedgehog_Official 4* Old Legacy and Legacy are different lmao (Old Legacy it's the era of Sov of the previous owner. Legacy it's the animation era)

    • @DusttaleSov
      @DusttaleSov Месяц назад +1

      Because you are idiot, Edirs, How the hell don't you realize that Evan's game that SAYS IN HIS GAMEJOLT THAT IT'S NOT OFFICIAL, YOU TAKE IT AS OFFICIAL
      -Daniel/Glitched

  • @Average_French_Person
    @Average_French_Person Месяц назад +39

    OMG YOU ADDED DUSTTALE RENEWED/MEMORIES IM A SPRITER also uh since jaym did some "bad things" the trailer is scrapped and they got fired from the team

    • @Military_base01
      @Military_base01  Месяц назад +11

      Sorry to hear he did some bad things, hopefully you will move on eventually..

    • @overuseanimations4590
      @overuseanimations4590 Месяц назад +2

      I KNEW IT I KNEW ITTTT
      THE MINUTE I SAW HIS COMMUNITY POST FULL OF WEIRD ASS PEOLE I KNEW HE WILL BECOME A PEDO GGHAHAHDHSBDB
      anyways, the sprites are pretty well done. You did an amazing job on them!!

    • @NamelessDragon21
      @NamelessDragon21 Месяц назад +1

      Huh someone explain what did Jay M do?

    • @overuseanimations4590
      @overuseanimations4590 Месяц назад +1

      @@NamelessDragon21 I don't know but when I originally glanced at his channel, I knew there is something off

    • @Average_French_Person
      @Average_French_Person Месяц назад

      @@NamelessDragon21 he sended spicy drawing to minors

  • @ninjawolfgame
    @ninjawolfgame Месяц назад +49

    1:23:48
    "oh god, this is the part where he kills us!" Chara
    "hello, this is the part where i kill you" Sans
    Achievement unlock, the part where he kills you

    • @PhuongChan-m6p
      @PhuongChan-m6p Месяц назад

      im gonna fuck you
      -sans says if he was diddy

  • @DankFirewolf
    @DankFirewolf Месяц назад +26

    watching this entire video made me realize just how many dusttale takes there are, not even including fanmade dustale AUs or ATs

  • @DEL866917
    @DEL866917 Месяц назад +12

    I am happy to see my take on this list. Thank you!
    Now, a little bit about the lore of “del's DUSTTALE: Anathema”...
    In Dusttale, as you all know, Sans slaughters monsters, and this take strongly expresses his internal feelings about Sans' actions.
    How can you not develop a sense of guilt or rejection for such a crazy act in a normal way?
    I will take a deeper look at the price he pays, his emotions, and those...
    (This take is currently being worked on!)

  • @nrthy
    @nrthy Месяц назад +8

    Honestly, I never really gave a damn about Stretch's DustTale, wasn't really interested in checking it out. But HOLY SHIT when I heard 1:25:58 with fucking Wario Land 4 samples, my mind just went "Sorry, IDUTSHANE, Stretch's DustTale is my new best friend!" I was definitely missing out on a golden 'DustTake' (pun intended :] ) and I need to go add these songs in my playlist RIGHT NOW! Awesome video by the way :)

  • @mohamadparadox2453
    @mohamadparadox2453 Месяц назад +12

    god the dusttale kazakhstan ruins theme blew me away, as well as the silence introspection (also known as jalene carter for some reason) looking forward to it

  • @TheSpoopyCat
    @TheSpoopyCat Месяц назад +24

    27:15 SP!Dusttale sans in the corner: *are* *you* *fucking* *kidding* *me*

  • @inciniumz4671
    @inciniumz4671 Месяц назад +31

    I think the reason Dusttale has the reputation it does is not because it's an inherently bad concept, but because it's often executed poorly or predictably. Many Dusttale AUs (don't even get started on Dusttrust) are rather lazy, and have poor writing, like Evan's Dusttale, creating an over saturation of mid. However, there's also a good chunk of creative and/or high effort executions like most of what you've shown. Dusttale is very subject to the concept of "there are no bad ideas, only bad executions", and this video is proof of that.

    • @JustStrikez69
      @JustStrikez69 Месяц назад +7

      Evan's dusttale is the main reason why people hate dusttale.
      Tbh dusttale shouldn't be as hated as it is right now, people should hate on insanity and something new more

    • @Yuti640
      @Yuti640 20 дней назад +4

      Coming from someone who made my take to go against the oversaturation, my main problem is that it doesn’t really make sense on a fundamental level for sans to remember you’re genocides, and yet everyone has gone with sans and everything just feeling like sans-topia
      I think if someone would want to do a more accurate to lore dusttale take with sans, maybe he comes to a realisation that there’s something up by the very weird way the human seems to be very indifferent to everything, all these big new things they’re just walking right through and just mindlessly killing monsters, not because of “evil chara” but just because they’ve seen it all before
      but that comes to my second big fundamental problem and that’s just that sans wouldn’t kill people if he found out about what you did, he would likely just sink into even further depression because, by finding out what you did, it means even the end of the world doesn’t matter, which, if we remember Undertale, was the only reason he fought you, because he thought this would be the ONE permanent thing
      Knowing that it isn’t the one permenant thing wouldn’t make him fight more, it’d make him fight less!

    • @KeefeRudyardDelaCruzDigital-Ar
      @KeefeRudyardDelaCruzDigital-Ar 17 дней назад +1

      @@Yuti640 I can agree with simply for how it takes. However, and its my own take due to how I understand Sans and Murder Sans, its that the reason why Sans is chosen not because he is Sans, but because of the exact reason you said about him, being depress about a never ending loop of destruction.
      We often love characters who went from a depress state to actually trying and keep on fighting no matter the cause. The reason why Sans is pick is due to to its paradoxical nature of things and how he deal with situation such as this. Seeing Sans being tired of nothing matters (Ironically) so he take it to his own hands, as he tried literally every option available, thanks for him to transcended beyond even people like Flowey who only remember Resets and not True Resets. And for that reason alone shows the Dusttale take's potential. Its sad how people now didn't see its true beauty and just replace him with someone else like Flowey, while failed the implication of why. That one thing is what make it work in the first place.
      So, TLDR, its pretty much a good story sense and in character sense in a way if your like Sans and that your tired of all the BS that it bring.

  • @xinos_slayer4874
    @xinos_slayer4874 Месяц назад +17

    Another man that enjoys Dusttale Novel? fully deserved rank.

  • @brad377
    @brad377 Месяц назад +8

    The creator of deez nuts here thanks for reviewing my dusttale omg I'm so happy

  • @CaioSam901
    @CaioSam901 Месяц назад +3

    Hey man, I wanna congrats you for making this, it's pretty fun seeing cool content like that! Since I'm not into Undertale comunity these times... but it fills me with joy when I see so many cool histories, projects, people and so on doing so much to keep the fire burning. Anyways, wish you the best and take care!

  • @BIG_JUMBLE
    @BIG_JUMBLE Месяц назад +88

    clearly, chara mustve removed your memories cus evans dust deserves #1
    (my memories!)

    • @Teshiaby
      @Teshiaby Месяц назад +6

      My memories!

    • @reinybongos1953
      @reinybongos1953 Месяц назад +7

      What did you do to my memories?! 🦅🇺🇸🔥

  • @Just_rex_Bv
    @Just_rex_Bv Месяц назад +7

    we started with MY MEMORIES to "help from the void but dust"

  • @cinotrashductions744
    @cinotrashductions744 Месяц назад +10

    1:30:29 "SEEEEE HOW I LAUGH AT YOUUUU
    YOU'LL NEVER UNDERSTAND
    NO YOU'LL NEVER UNDERSTAND
    NO YOU'LL NEVER EVER EVER
    UNDERSTANNDDDDD.." 🗣🔥

  • @knightmarin
    @knightmarin Месяц назад +19

    I wish these were voice acted😔 would be amazing stuff to listen to while drawing

  • @XpathTheChojiro
    @XpathTheChojiro Месяц назад +14

    Spear of Vengences Dialog is very... Human

  • @BenjaminIzquierdo-nb6tq
    @BenjaminIzquierdo-nb6tq Месяц назад +20

    Ut dusttale just released a new showing why sans didn’t show up, and it elevates the papyrus death scene imo. Also the entire series so far is completely in character which is amazing!

    • @Yuti640
      @Yuti640 Месяц назад +4

      yeah, but the papyrus scene does still suck, i stand by the parts of it pre-capture since it has this lingering horror vibe and Papyrus is very papyrus but I make it go on for way too long post-capture and put way too much lightheartedness post-capture, I think I was just trying to put all of the Papyrus quirks into the scene (since it’s his only one) and just fumbled having a concrete vision

    • @BenjaminIzquierdo-nb6tq
      @BenjaminIzquierdo-nb6tq Месяц назад +1

      @@Yuti640 I still think it’s great, and if you want you can just edit some bits

    • @BenjaminIzquierdo-nb6tq
      @BenjaminIzquierdo-nb6tq Месяц назад +1

      @@Yuti640 amazing series by the way!

  • @elijahray5194
    @elijahray5194 Месяц назад +6

    WELL DONE‼️‼️‼️ I'M SO PROUD OF YOU BABY 🗣🔥🔥🔥

  • @guyiguess438
    @guyiguess438 Месяц назад +5

    I like the creators taking the criticisms in the comments big up’s to yall

  • @monkegaming5091
    @monkegaming5091 Месяц назад +5

    37:55 that moment when sans died and said “turn10_text” that moment I realised how beautiful this take it

  • @funnydude69
    @funnydude69 Месяц назад +9

    Ok but bathrobe sans with sunglasses and trident is genius character design

  • @Juliverdi
    @Juliverdi Месяц назад +5

    I've got a good one, it's called "Doctor Megalo" it's new, so i understand that you didn't get to add it, but you should take a look at it, it's fricking cool

  • @yoylecaik
    @yoylecaik Месяц назад +7

    me when im a grandpa with dimentia lying on my deathbed while my grandchildren and children are comforting me and the only thing i can say is "MY MEMORIES!"
    good skideo based guy

  • @Clugster
    @Clugster Месяц назад +14

    32:10 "And I don't regret a second of it."

  • @klaus.sfc01official30
    @klaus.sfc01official30 Месяц назад +14

    The intro is actually funny because if it weren't for someone posting on deviant art that you are a dust AU hater i would have never found your channel. Weird how the world is sometimes XD

  • @Frost-Out1
    @Frost-Out1 Месяц назад +7

    4:42
    I am a spriter in this project,What is shown at the beginning is something very old, everything is being worked on again, from Megalovania to the last upload currently, it is part of the new. xb
    30:32 also.. The only thing I can say about this is that I love working here, I look forward to whatever is released soon.

  • @AncientFire
    @AncientFire Месяц назад +9

    Bro this shit genuinely broke my phone, it didnt respond to any input and the screen froze but the audio was still playing, sans dusttale hacked my phone fr

  • @justhorrorlol
    @justhorrorlol Месяц назад +14

    putting canon that low is a CRIME

  • @fergiexl
    @fergiexl Месяц назад +12

    you could've put Sans spielen's epic megalovania at honorable mentions If you exclude some of the requirements for a dusttale

  • @t0nyxaka90
    @t0nyxaka90 Месяц назад +12

    32:10
    IS THAT AN ACTUAL GODDAMN ULTRAKILL REFERENCE

  • @HARDBRISK
    @HARDBRISK Месяц назад +8

    20:05 oh wow i wonder who coded that!

  • @sharkyssillies
    @sharkyssillies Месяц назад +48

    hi my dusttale was featured
    stuff that i wanna address:
    "wake-up call" was a parody of "disbelief with dust" and wasnt really anything outside of that, it was removed lol and combined with Derelict for it's upcoming V2
    "Disgrace, Humiliation." is just deep within V2, but we thought it'd be funny to make it look like silence introspection because of David is oomf
    "The Murder" was placed too early and has been moved wayyyy further down Snowdin to fix the pacing lol
    Glad i got into top 5 though....... reboot we're coming after a higher place...........

    • @applefied_
      @applefied_ Месяц назад +3

      BROTHERLY LOVE FOR LIFE

    • @thelazyguy72
      @thelazyguy72 Месяц назад +1

      I LOVE MY BROTHER!!!!!!!

    • @CaioSam901
      @CaioSam901 Месяц назад +1

      We love our brothers, Sharky!

    • @TheTrueJ836
      @TheTrueJ836 Месяц назад +1

      I truly do love my bro-
      Oh wait. I don't have one.

    • @goldendarius
      @goldendarius Месяц назад +2

      Don't worry guys I locked sharky in my basement for the reboot it's now even peaker

  • @mongee8
    @mongee8 Месяц назад +4

    thank you for making this, like fr. you introduced me to a whole bunch of cool Dusttale takes to check out, and got to see your opinion on the ones i already have. also thank you for talking about the underrated ones I've never seen talked about much like UT!DUSTTALE or DUSTTALE by Lovegeezer. good video man.
    (thanks for putting all the links in the description so i can research/listen to stuff myself)

  • @miguelpasseroJIJI
    @miguelpasseroJIJI Месяц назад +8

    I expected Stretch's take to be number 1. But i was expecting FDY's Dust Sans battle to appear. Oh well, guess that fangame was to hard it was not added.

    • @MaxOnTop3
      @MaxOnTop3 Месяц назад +5

      Bro FDY dust has no lore and he is just straight up buffed evan's dusttale with phase 2 added

  • @ELJTASS2827
    @ELJTASS2827 Месяц назад +11

    1:30:30
    "bro's king , but what a cost"

  • @luigi9956
    @luigi9956 Месяц назад +6

    “You should’ve brought a million more pants!”
    Bro river person are you 4?

  • @Brick_Nick
    @Brick_Nick Месяц назад +3

    As someone who didn't watch the video, and as someone who works on brotherly love, i totally agree with that

  • @Thatorangejuiceguy118
    @Thatorangejuiceguy118 Месяц назад +25

    My favorite dusttale au (so far) is UT!dusttale

    • @legendarysands4892
      @legendarysands4892 Месяц назад +1

      SAME!!

    • @Nathaniel-hy1gt
      @Nathaniel-hy1gt Месяц назад +1

      Same

    • @GoggyYouTube
      @GoggyYouTube Месяц назад +1

      same

    • @Dragon_Aoi
      @Dragon_Aoi Месяц назад +2

      Fine enough as it’s own thing (still don’t really like it though). As a DustTale take, it is barely like DustTale at all, and don’t really like it.
      And don’t like how sidelined some characters might end up being.
      It’s fine though, just don’t personally like it all that much.

    • @Thatorangejuiceguy118
      @Thatorangejuiceguy118 Месяц назад +5

      @@Dragon_Aoi it’s just dusttale but it makes sense that’s why I like it

  • @Creeps097
    @Creeps097 Месяц назад +3

    22:24 this part goes hard i cant lie

  • @deboracristinacardososanto8685
    @deboracristinacardososanto8685 Месяц назад +41

    evan's dusttale sans: hmmm i think im gonna dust some people so me get powas to reset!1!1!1! Meanwhile idutshane: *dosent talk and is a gigachad*

    • @JustStrikez69
      @JustStrikez69 Месяц назад +8

      Meanwhile novel dusttale: *casually punches a child 1000 kilometers away, destroys a laboratory and oneshot undying with his "funni red eye"*

    • @NamelessDragon21
      @NamelessDragon21 Месяц назад +5

      @@JustStrikez69 he’s just so peak

    • @StandingRylan
      @StandingRylan Месяц назад +2

      @@JustStrikez69[stretch dust in the corner]

  • @Nothingonthischanneldont-hb4pc
    @Nothingonthischanneldont-hb4pc Месяц назад +7

    SAME STRECHES DUSTTALE IS THE GOAT, also the first encounter theme fits himself almost as perfectly as ULC’s take on ruins dust sans (instead of Snowdin)

  • @GoodOlJenkinsYT
    @GoodOlJenkinsYT Месяц назад +24

    A certain being from the powerscaling community would say it's all bad 😂😂😂

    • @waterawesome
      @waterawesome Месяц назад

      true???

    • @Marc19573
      @Marc19573 Месяц назад

      Huh?

    • @MAML_
      @MAML_ Месяц назад +1

      tf is the powerscaling community and anyways grey goo from hungry planet solos everything

  • @RalMaybe
    @RalMaybe 11 дней назад +1

    W opinion. Although Sp!dust tale would probably way higher for me specifically, but I don't like it that much as a dusttale take; I could see it as an insanity sans take or something along those lines, or an entirely different Au, but as dust tale take, I'd probably put it in good tier instead of God tier. I don't care if this is a bad opinion, Necroptosis is such a good song my brains wired and now the Au is registered as top 5.

  • @Distrust2Gaming
    @Distrust2Gaming 19 дней назад +4

    segasonic101 carrying the undertale community casually without elaborating:
    (if you couldnt tell im big fan of segsonc but i also loev all the other cool guy z in the comunity)

    • @rascamedi0
      @rascamedi0 14 дней назад

      i heart segasonic101

  • @AtarAsterlayna
    @AtarAsterlayna Месяц назад

    Thank you, I enjoyed watching that video so much. Keep it up.

  • @Metal-UT
    @Metal-UT Месяц назад +6

    Fire Dusttale rankings, guess i can say "SO MANY DUSTTALEESS"

  • @DonaSussuarana
    @DonaSussuarana Месяц назад

    i spent too many time trying to find the "see how i laugh at you" part thinking it was part of the ost until i realized YOU made it and i gotta say, hats off man.

  • @AnMa.2404gXr
    @AnMa.2404gXr Месяц назад +5

    original sans: er er er er er er dusttale sans: ur... ur... ur... ur.. ur...ur..

  • @DusttaleSov
    @DusttaleSov Месяц назад +6

    7:36 official comic sneak peak!!! 🗣️🗣️🗣️

  • @okitalover-bf5wh
    @okitalover-bf5wh Месяц назад +1

    this vid was such a rabbit hole,from hahaha funny skeleton goes brrr to broken id (I LOVE IT.),halo's dust and HELLLLL YEAH STRETCH'S COOL AS FUCK,overall this vid was a literal rabbit hole for me tysm for it 😭🙏

  • @ratte6090
    @ratte6090 Месяц назад +8

    please tell me idutshane and brotherly LOVE are on here
    edit: YES LETS GO

  • @scoutisred6319
    @scoutisred6319 Месяц назад

    Cool tht you include SP!Dusttale, Imo i think its defineitely one of the better dusttale takes here not juststory wise but how much sans has actually changed, id go as far to say it would be the true dusttale in terms of edginess if that makes sense

  • @JudeEaley
    @JudeEaley Месяц назад +4

    The number of encounters in DTBL is because there is a pacifist neutral and no mercy route, all with loads of different encounters

  • @illumin2-k6ta
    @illumin2-k6ta Месяц назад +3

    this video was so scary, i should've bringed a few million extra pants =}

  • @Southparkfan598
    @Southparkfan598 Месяц назад +9

    45:07 honestly people may see this as a bad thing
    But I think it’s perfect, it shows Sans’ utter breaking point, it shows that he can’t stand by and watch this anymore because he’s seen it again and again
    And knowing the ending he decided to take matters into his own hands, and get stronger
    Basically what I’m saying is it shows how much Sans has broke

    • @CatSlapps
      @CatSlapps Месяц назад

      Sans doesn’t remember your genocide and reset what are you yapping about

    • @Southparkfan598
      @Southparkfan598 Месяц назад

      @@CatSlapps In Dusttale he does

    • @CatSlapps
      @CatSlapps Месяц назад

      @@Southparkfan598 sans is the last person you will see breaking in undertale canon.The reason why this thing exists is because it was in the cringe sans edge times au year.Sans is really out of character.

    • @Southparkfan598
      @Southparkfan598 Месяц назад

      @@CatSlapps My guy it’s not a take on Sans- it’s a take on Dust-

    • @CatSlapps
      @CatSlapps Месяц назад

      @@Southparkfan598 dust sans is really out of character man

  • @RayBlu
    @RayBlu Месяц назад +2

    WAIT, YOU'RE ITALIAN?
    (Also, i work for DT Reimaginated.
    Can't wait to show you guys what we've been cooking.
    The final froggit, Whimsalot and pretty old sans sprite is from me btw).

  • @flimblejurbles4048
    @flimblejurbles4048 Месяц назад +12

    Typing this before seeing the video, betting that I miss you is up in the middle-Upper section if it's in the list

  • @alimoneh2852
    @alimoneh2852 Месяц назад +1

    Bruh I have been watching your channel for some time now and I didn't realize I wasn't subbed 😭 🙏

    • @Military_base01
      @Military_base01  Месяц назад +2

      Did you know only a small percentage of my viewers are actua-

  • @wildfire9280
    @wildfire9280 Месяц назад +4

    Cause Dustin' makes me feel good

  • @DeikoMoon47
    @DeikoMoon47 Месяц назад +5

    You know, Dusttale is that AU which in one side of the coin has sense to happen and in the other side, it doesn't have any sense of it, cause when I think about it, yeah, cannon sans doesn't remember what happened after a reset, he doesn't know about the reset, but somehow he knows about it when you do the genocide route with their dialogues during his fight, but it's quite weird how he can talk like that, making the player feel kinda odd, even if you do a real reset, and that's why I never understand sans in genocide due to him knowing the timelines, the resets and the fact that is my fault when he shouldn't remember. It's the infamous rabbit hole after all.

  • @Kevin-The-Cube
    @Kevin-The-Cube 19 дней назад +2

    How did you manage to get atleast a single dev for almost all fangames here in your comment section. Pretty awesome.

  • @nobody7204
    @nobody7204 Месяц назад +6

    30:06 HE REMEMBERS YOUR GENOCIDES 🗣🗣🗣

  • @EoghanDonnelly-m3x
    @EoghanDonnelly-m3x Месяц назад

    Wow, this certainly is a lot of AUs I've never heard of. I wonder how long is lef- I'VE ALREADY BEEN WATCHING THIS FOR AN HOUR! AND THERE IS STILL ANOTHER 30 MINUTES! Screw doing homework, I'm watching this for another half hour!

  • @JustDrew42
    @JustDrew42 Месяц назад +4

    Gerson with a shotgun will forever haunt my dreams… 😞

  • @FinTheRobloxAvatar
    @FinTheRobloxAvatar Месяц назад +2

    10:06 tbh there is a reason why sans is talking like that its because he is not into killing
    he turned into something he hated and he regrets it and it kinda makes sense why he is stuttering it captures the emotion and when he killed his brother he lost it
    but i have to admit there are a few cutscenes that sounds bad

  • @JustStrikez69
    @JustStrikez69 Месяц назад +10

    1:17:16 don't forget the "i didn't mean to fuck you like that!" In one of the translations

  • @raphaelbchini1362
    @raphaelbchini1362 Месяц назад +1

    Honestly, this is one of the reasons of why Dusttale is my favorite AU
    Dusttale is an AU in which every take can be unique in it's own way
    You can make a Dusttale take based around the evolution fights
    You can make it around the lore and turn it into a depressing take or one to make you feel uncomfortable.
    You can chose who's the murderer, who survives, when does the encounters take place and how things should go.
    It's also one of the few AUs where a victory of Sans can actually make sense depending on what you want to do about it
    Dusttale is for me both a cool and a tragic AU, with a base that makes you able to do anything out of it.
    Anyways, that was a very great vid
    (I apologise for the possible bad english in my comment)

    • @maximyllion
      @maximyllion Месяц назад +1

      UT!Dusttale is my fav take on it

    • @raphaelbchini1362
      @raphaelbchini1362 Месяц назад +1

      @@maximyllion It is a pretty good take indeed
      Yet it isn't my favorite simply due to the fact Sans isn't the murderer
      But still a great one

  • @trevorisout5331
    @trevorisout5331 Месяц назад +8

    I had an idea for a Dusttale take.
    It was always weird to me that Sans was able to absorb other monster's magic, and the idea is that Sans has to kind of make the monsters in a trance of some sort, maybe he has to tie Toriel up, and when we attack, he just moved aside for us to hit Toriel. For Asgore, he will flesh him from the inside and wore him like an armor. For Undyne, he can just crucify her (Undyne the Saviour). I haven't think about the rest yet, maybe it's a Horror!Dusttale?
    Edit: Also imagine Sans using bone magic to control their body lolololololol I guess he can't manipulate our bones because magic only attacks the soul?

    • @v3nomshank
      @v3nomshank Месяц назад +1

      he has to WHAT to toriel?

    • @trevorisout5331
      @trevorisout5331 Месяц назад +4

      @@v3nomshank Perhaps that's too edgy and inapropriate

    • @MilenaMcDonald
      @MilenaMcDonald Месяц назад +3

      The absorbing monster magic isn't canon according to the creator of murder/dust sans.

    • @0001Mxrcel
      @0001Mxrcel Месяц назад +1

      Fella what

    • @kingofcrap4414
      @kingofcrap4414 Месяц назад +1

      Monsters turn to dust when they die
      That's why it's called DUSTtale 💀💀💀💀💀

  • @femvey92
    @femvey92 Месяц назад +1

    hi, creator of the dusttale renewed's "mental fight" mockup here
    the version showcased is somewhat outdated
    i haven't touched it since the video of it was released, but i'm planning on going back to it, patching it up nicely and releasing it to the public as a mini-experience
    the ending had already been fixed btw

  • @Guyrr666
    @Guyrr666 Месяц назад +9

    I guess the dust all along was the dusty we made along the way...

  • @theminerwithin9316
    @theminerwithin9316 Месяц назад +2

    To be honest, FantasyVision didn't have the best artstyle, but his Last Breath AU was actually pretty cool and interesting to watch. Edgy af, but still kinda cool. Definitely the most powerful version of Last Breath, too. They knew how to animate very well, but their art left little to be desired. Then Revolver Animations came along and perfected that design by creating The Judge, which was his take on the 4th phase of FV's Last Breath.

  • @pamsteff
    @pamsteff Месяц назад +4

    Personally the reason I think people use flowey a lot for dusttale is because he is a lot more able and willing to go through with. Real undertale sans would never go through with killing toriel, he wouldn’t even have the thought of killing papyrus.

  • @Dabaugh15
    @Dabaugh15 18 дней назад

    1:26:03
    H-H-HURRY UP!
    It's good to know they used WarioLand 4's Hurry Up!'s soundfont, didn't expect that in a Undertale fangame/AU, much less a Dusttale take ngl