Don't forget the untold time you lose when creating a character for the first time. One of the hardest things to choose in skyrim is which race you gonna end up stealth archering
I feel like I’m the only person that always bounced off stealth archer builds. I would always get bored a good way into my play through. My favorite was always a conjuring battle mage. Conjure some atronochs, conjure a sword, fireball and slash.
Lol, 你的笑话. It's not hard to pick a race in Skyrim his name in that complex is not like the races are different it is as shity passives. Unless you actually use the mods are the character overhaul that bring back the traits for the characters then I would see that'll be a hard choice but vanilla try again.
That Walking Dead finale broke me. There's already something about the man/surrogate daughter dynamic that's compelling, but Clem being thrust into such a horrific world at such a young age, and being so innocent up to that point, and you know in Lee's final moments he has one last chance to better her odds, but he has to ask her to do something traumatizing in order to accomplish that, followed up by Clem's whimpers.... Dude, that scene was incredible.
I played that whole first season and that ending fucked up the series for me. I tried playing season 2, but I just couldn't. I ended up watching the series later, tho.
Most decisions in Witcher 3 were nightmares for trying to figure out what to do. Always hidden information, underlying motives, and pros and cons to everything. Great list Falcon!
i can think of many from Cyberpunk 77 as well that were insanely hard to choose; crucifying that convict, whether or not to tell Mr. Jefferson the truth, trusting the Voodoo Boys or NetWatch, even smaller seeming ones, like where to send Jackie's body were like "whoa i don't know, hold on"
@goldendummy2099 not really he is a great character, people hate him because he does his job. be the bad guy, and he does a great job at it. amazing character.
At one point during Telltales TWD I put my controller down, sobbing, saying “I don’t wanna do this, don’t make me choose” Such a gut wrenching series of games
I honestly think the telltale walking dead aged really poorly, I didn't care about Lee at all in my most recent playthrough and alot of the side characters are unbearable in season 1 especially Kenny. I actually like Clementine she was a decently written character and lilly was also pretty likeable and I found myself siding with Lilly way more than Kenny. There were also alot of really poor character decisions. Like instead of just smashing Larry's head just stand over him which the box raised over his head and if he wakes up with the infected eyes then smash his head. It honestly felt like Kenny was really just trying to murder Larry cause he doesn't like him which is why I sided with Lilly. Lilly killing Carly also came out of nowhere since Carly was never mean to Lilly. Katja killing herself did make sense and worked well, but the ending really fell flat for me since I just didn't care about Lee they honestly did a horrible job with his character and his voice acting was so flat and wooden.
The Walking Dead was brutal and brilliant. Some people turn their nose up at the graphics, but the story is so immersive and gripping. Even in the shop, where you have to choose between saving the guy or the woman who’s being attacked by walkers. Either way, it’s not a great outcome later on. The game is amazing.
facts, gotta be honest. never really wanted to play it bcs of the graphics and the comic styles game. but about a year ago game was on massive discount and I thought 'fuck it, imma buy it'. and thank god I bought it, honeslty really loved it. truely one of the best story games I ever played in my opinion. cried a lot, laught a lot
The walking dead had great ones, it was always so hard and you had that timer running, sadly it didnt matter too much after making a choice but still it felt so much more like YOU are the character and had to make those tough choices and then feel bad about it afterwards.
A sad little fact about the ending of TWD: Season 1 is right as the game fades to black, you can hear Lee one last time letting out his last breath. But that's actually his voice actor crying as they were recording the lines and they decided to leave it in the game because it was so emotional.
Never forget Paarthurnax. he was so chill and deserved to live 100%. “What is better: to be born good or to overcome your evil nature through great effort?” - Paarthurnax
fuck that traitor. If one minor minor thing was changed then i'd be indifferent. If dragons killed by dragonborn didn't in lore, told many many many times to you, outright proven, that once killed unlike any other creature in skyrim...they gone for good because you're "duh ultimate dragonslayer" is such a disappointment. Dragonborn should side with dragons or least be given a choice for
Egh i thought so as well but i think the majority of us can agree that we let him live, siding with the Blades had no real benefits whereas letting Paarthanux live i believed he granted you some stat boost? Cant remember what it was exactly but overall it wasn’t necessarily a difficult choice but rather an easy choice
@@teddgrambmx I was actually looking forward to play as "dragonborn" like super hype sure the trailers show him fighting a dragon but lets be real if someone was "dragonborn" but stuck in a non dragon body absolutely going ham on a few dragons to show dominance doesn't exactly seem out of the norm
One decision that wasn‘t mentioned for me, was in Detroit: Become Human, when you play as Connor, you have to shoot an innocent robot, I sat in front of my TV for 10 minutes and didn‘t know what to do
Fun fact about Clementite-Lee situation is that if you don't pick either option to shoot or leave Lee, Clementine will pick one of the option herself based on how you interacted and what you taught her as Lee. as for Mass Effect 1, I always pick Ashley, and the reason is that I don't really find Kaiden that useful. He's not terrible as NPC, starts off dull but once he opens up he has some really cool backstory, however when it comes to gameplay, he's Sentinel bio-tech hybrid, and is overshadowed by both Liara and Tali in both field, and both of them can be recruited very early in the game. If you play as Sentinel or Engineer you don't need Kaiden at all, because Bio\Tech will be fulfiled by either Liara or Tali, and second slot will go to either Wrex or Garrus, both who can do limited bio (Wrex) or tech (Garrus). So Kaiden is literally the least useful member of the group, because Ashley is pure soldier class, so she is pretty tough and high dps in endgame and can wear heavy armor, and in ME3 she is super tanky with right build.
I mean it also depends what class do you play at the moment. When I play as a soldier, I save Kaidan, when I play as a biotic, I save Ashley. At least for me that's one of the factors to consider.
I always save Ashley. Yeah, she's a something of a xenophobe, but at least she has an actual character arc over the course of the games. Kaiden is just bland. He starts out as bland in ME1 and by the end of ME3 he's still bland. And how the hell is *that* choice number 1 on the list?! The Lee-Clementine choice is far, far, faaaar worse!
Hell you could have the euthanasia in the alternate timeline as a tough choice imagine that your talking to your friend paralysed in pain and she asks you to turn off her life support machine and set her free A huge moral dilemma
It's not hard at all. Is there a cure? if no. Is she gonna get better eventually or is it something that gets worse day by day? If there is no cure and no way of healing naturally then yes. I would do it for her. You don't let animals suffer, why would you let a human? @@kurtpunchesthings2411
the interesting thing about Kaiden and Ashley is how each character is presented in the first game. While Pressly is the ship's XO, Kaiden is very much Shepard's right hand man and both of them have friendly conversations and maybe a light romantic tone if you want to go for that. Ashley on the other hand in the first game is very capable but she questions Shepard at many turns, especially when it comes to the aliens of the universe, leading to her feeling annoying and insubordinate, but her real growth is seeing her in ME2 and 3 as in two, she's a lot more adaptable and responsible, and in 3, she's openly helping protect the council members of the citadel, showing how she grew into a better person and more conscientious soldier.
I knew it was a big decision but my simple first playthrough brain said "I wanna bang Liara as Femshep, Ashley is female so might be able to smash later. Sacrifice Kaiden. But next time I play through I'll give Kaiden a go. The beer cutscene in the dlc seems like a bit of fun.
I mentioned this on my post about this, but I legit find Kaiden useless. He's descent NPC, he's bit dull at first but once he opens up he has interesting backstory. He's just bit more reserved. However when it comes to gameplay, he's kinda useless. He is Sentinel class, and mix of bio and tech, however you get access to both Liara and Tali in the early game, and Liara is x5 better biotic and Tali is 5x better tech. So Kaiden is simply overshadowed. If you yourself play either Sentinel or Engineer, you will no doubt be strongest of said class, which once again makes Kaiden redundant, because you'll pick either Liara or Tali in 2nd slot to fill in the bio\tech spot, and you will pick one fighter class, which would be either Wrex or Garrus, and both can do limited, but useful bio\tech skills. There's literally no need for Kaiden in any situation, outside having him as NPC all up to ME3. However, once again, he's kinda useless in ME3, because once again you have Liara, Tali and Garrus, and on top of that you have EDI of even more specialized tech npc. So Ashley is pretty much better option in both ME1 and ME3, because she's pure soldier (fighter) class, and she's tanky in both games, especially ME3 where you can either build her up as very tank squad member or high dps npc, whichever you need more. I had one or two games where Kaiden lives (typically when I play fem Shep), but outside one or two first missions where you pretty much HAVE to use him (Eden Prime in ME1 or Mars in ME3), I've literally never used Kaiden.
Try WItcher 2. It's a smaller game, but its got tighter writing, lots of hidden info, and is basically 1.5 games; As a key choice will give you a completely different half of the game the other choice will lock you out of, and vice versa. shame Cd projekt, because they wanted to make W3 the new flaghip t get in new players scrapped the plot that was building up in W2 (and W1). There was huge decisions in 2, that were meant to really alter W3.
Actually there is a the 3rd option you missed here in the Bloody Baron quest. The one where they rescue Anna and the Baron takes her with him up to the Blue Mountains to see a wise man about curing her mind. But even THAT option isn't all great either for sure, as is the case for most of the big quests in Witcher 3 lol
@@mickidoesmedia It's the only option that gives a sliver of hope that woman will be cured. And even if she never will be cured Baron will take care of her till the end of his days.
The one that always stuck with me was choosing the life to save between Hannah and Irish in Battlefield 4.. you spend a large portion of the game with both of them and eventually with them together in your squad, learning about each of them in their dialogues and see their relationship progress. In case you’re wondering, you have to drop one of them in to manually detonate an explosive, resulting in one of their untimely deaths. Each play through of that game I struggle to make that choice…
Another one that really got to me was the ending of Life is Strange where you have to choose between sacrificing Chole or Arcadia Bay. Choosing between a town of innocent people, or your best friend. It's tough.
I would say it was more annoying because it was pretty obvious which choice was considered the right one lol, like thanks for making me feel guilty about choosing my girlfriend 💀
Honestly, even though I knew it wasn't the most moral choice, I would have chosen Chloe over the town, IF IT WASN'T FOR THE FACT that she literally begged you to save her mom.
Personally, I found the earlier decision of whether to euthanize alt!Chloe significantly harder, possibly because it's the kind of decision you might actually be expected to make in real life.
i found the last two by far the easiest to make. Kaiden alenko i found really boring to the point where in a few playthroughs i actually forced myself to get to know him better. As for Lord Shimura, i always felt that Jins story was how he doesnt have to do things the samurai way. The samurai showed that their way wouldnt work against the mongols, and while yes in some ways Jin dishonoured himself by resorting to the methods he chose ultamately it also freed him to spare the life of a good man in a way a samurai never would have.
Exactly. Shimura lives on and names you an outlaw but continues to live and rule whereas the other option results in the shogun replacing him with a worse ruler who's loyal to him and not the people he rules. Shimura was well loved if you pay attention
Choosing whether to save Fergus or Wyatt in Wolfenstein was a tough one too, obviously you can play both timelines, but it’s still so tough, even throughout the rest of the play-through you get reminded of it by the protagonist you chose to save.
What made it especially tough to choose was that the game took good care to make both Wyatt and Ferguson pretty upstanding lads, which made being compelled to sacrifice one of them at gunpoint all the more painful.
Just played this earlier tonight actually. I set my controller down for a good two minutes waiting for something to happen before I realized, oh crap they're actually making me choose.
14:11 there's a third scenario that I think fewer people knew about, I only heard it from someone else, but Clementine can actually choose for herself based on her seeing Lee's actions throughout the game. You just don't decide on much of anything and then Clementine (if she's seen Lee do harsh stuff she'll act accordingly, or if more merciful she'll opt out of killing) will make her own choice Edit: That was the reason for those "Clementine will remember that." messages during rough parts
The Bloody Baron quests were the BEST PART of that entire game. I loved his entire story and it made me forget I was supposed to be finding some emperor's daughter or something. He had a hard story with his wife and in the end, I felt sorry for his situation. For someone from the OLD DAYS he was a fairly decent ruler.
The decision in infamous 1 to choose between saving your wife and saving a group of doctors still stays with me. One of the few games that showed you how hard it can truly be to be a super hero. It didn't matter how strong you got you couldn't save her. You had to make the right choice
The best thing about InFamous is the ending and working out why you couldnt save Trish no matter which choice you make. Because the bad guy is actually you from the future and knows what choice you would make he will always make sure you have to lose her in order to make you stronger. Its a great twist that allows you to have a choice and influence your karma level but at the same time makes your choice an impossible one.
If you got it on pc someone recently made a Guiding Wind mod ala Ghost of Tsushima, makes leaves and particle effects fly toward your quest objective. Been playing it with all the HUD turned off such a gorgeous game.
Yeah but I got the distinct feeling the entire game was supposed to be that detailed, but CDPR bit off more than they could chew and we only got that one most Witcher 1-ish quest. Still one of the best games ever though.
Bruh, the children in the NieR Automata Pascal sceen did not turn on eachother, they commited suicide. And the reason they did is because of fear. Pascal over instilled a sense if fear in them, and that was the consequence, which makes Pascal not just heartbroken but feeling guilty. I hate well the annoying "well ackchyually" guy, but that small change makes a huge difference when you examine this moment alongside others and the themes of NieR Automata.
Man, I love how the game made you feel awful making pascal live in a life of blissful ignorance where he talks about how much he cared for the children, too, and you're all like... "Man, did I do the right thing?"
@@acrane3496 "you manage to defeat all the attackers, but when you return you find all the children dead. They all went mad and turned on eachother." That is the direct quote from this video. Try listening to what he actually said in the video that i was commenting on before trying to correct someone. Because they're either wrong, or they're putting events out of order.
He also left out the choice between 9S and A2 at the top of the tower. I know you're supposed to go back and choose the other you didn't choose, but that first choice is tough and such a sad unexpected choice that puts a lot of weight on that moment. Then there's the final choice of whether or not you should sacrifice your data to save someone else you don't know.
No matter how many times I have replayed TWD season 1 from Telltale, I ALWAYS cry at the end when I have to shoot Lee. Telltale does such an amazing job of really making you connect emotionally with Lee and Clem, that makes the choice so sad and difficult.
The Gears of War 5, save Del or JD scene came out of nowhere and I was NOT prepared for it. Probably one of the hardest decisions I've had to make in gaming honestly.
Same dude, I was playing with a buddy and I(both playing the game for our first time when it first came out) asked him did he know about this decision and at first he said no and after letting the timer countdown over and over, an me saying this is BS and then I finally chose and I chose to save Del cuz he's been with me(Kait) through the whole game. Then of course my buddy said he actually knew about this specific part and didn't want to tell me. Definitely should've been mentioned in this video.
The Walking Dead Series had so many tough choices. I remember in season 2 where you have to choose whether to share your food with the dog and resetting and trying every path to try and find the positive outcome (there isn't one). Also, the end fight scene between Kenny and Jane i was so torn i literally couldn't decide who to help so i just took the cowardly path and chose to do nothing every time I had to make a choice.
i feel like season 2s choices were more universally bad though, like in a sense that the consequence happens anyway. a good example is however you handle your job and the other girls job at the department store, Carver will just toss Kumail Nanjiani's character off the roof. definitely agree with you about having a real hard time choosing Jane or Kenny though, they were both really bad choices for Clem as Kenny's stability was so far past unstable, that i'd never feel safe with him. on the other hand, Jane's a survivor, not a companion so theres no warmth between the two.
When I made my decision with Kenny and Jane the first time, I chose to save Jane. It was really hard to do, but watching Kenny go ballistic over something, while tragic, he was told was an accident made him seem unstable and dangerous to be around. Not that it was his fault at all considering everything he had been through. It just was a matter of everyone's safety. Only to find out it was over a complete lie and Jane had set him up. And it really annoyed me there wasn't a dialogue option for "You know you dun goofed, but I'm keeping you around for AJ's survivability, not because I forgive you". I had to just sit in my room and mentally process what I just did for a good hour after I finished that game.
of all the big releases so far, IMO the only two worth talking about are Jedi Survivor and Tears of the Kingdom. ill allow those ff16 though, ive never been a huge fan but i know those who are. anything else worth talking about is in the indie/much cheaper categories.
The Baron quest does have a somewhat good ending option. If you free the tree spirit before starting the crones of crookback bog quest you will save the kids and Anna doesn’t get killed
There is a “good ending” for the bloody baron quest, you’ve gotta be precise in the order of how to you do steps layed out to you prior to going to save his wife. You save her, the kids and his daughter opens up to the idea of starting again with her dad. Although his wife needs mental help after the whole ordeal the baron says he knows a Sage in the blue Mountains that could help so, in my mind it’s the best ending for them.
Yeah no that’s not how the mission works unless you mod the game somehow. You choose to save the kids and the wife turns to a hag and baron offs himself or you let the kids be taken and the barons family stays together. There’s no “good ending”
@Redfield_Bloodline The kids survive if you choose to free the spirit in the tree BEFORE starting the quest. So if you miracously stumble across it like I did and choose to save the spirit, she'll rescue the children. In my ending, everyone survived.
In my opinion, Life is Strange had the toughest choice at the end, and the Game even shows stats how other players made choices in the Game. That Last choice was 50/50 in stats.
It actually was a choice between your past and present. If you are too attached to your past, you will destroy your present. And to save your present you have to break up with your past.
i disagree. While Chloe really grew on me as time went by, i never cared enough about her to do anything but save the rest of Arcadia Bay. Like Warren's a decent dude who deserves life, Chloe's mom is a wonderful person, even David Madsen is a really good guy buried under a layer of PTSD and bad parenting. Chloe was just kinda a bitchy teenager.
@MarsRL the only decision in the end that really matters is whether you started the game or not. The lead developer said he considers turning the game off at any point is a valid ending. Essentially Walker sees the futility of it all and he and his men abandon Dubai. That's pretty much the only good ending in that game. God that game is so fucked up.
That was the easiest decision for me. Chloe is one the WORST characters I’ve had to interact with in games. That said, even if she was likable, I don’t think its worth it to allow the destruction of an ENTIRE town and possibly a few hundred people over one person
@@jake.p13 Yes and without Max seeing Chloe get shot in the bathroom, she would have never discovered her power so they were connected from the very beginning
I cant believe Fable 2's final wish didn't make the list. "Ultimate power, enough money to buy the largest castle in the game as a personal home, or revive your dog who sacrificed himself for you in the last mission"
@@zackjames5976 the lil sister became the blind seeress in the other 2 games but there was another choice or 2 on fable 2.... all the people ressed from the Tower, your family ressed
I totally expected Fable 2 to be on here, especially since the choice from Black Ops 2 doesn't end up mattering much in the end. Fable 2's choices just felt more impactful.
Speaking of Mass Effect, having to shoot Mordin Solus if you wanted to prevent him from giving the super-breeder powers back to the Krogan was also an interesting moral choice.
Letting him cure the genophage and die doing so is just as heartbreaking, if not more. My favorite variation of that scene is pushing him to sabotage the cure until he admits "I MADE A MISTAKE". For some reason, hearing Mordin using a personal pronoun is really strong.
If Wrex is in charge, between him, Grunt, and Eve, I think you can trust the Krogans for a few generations at least. And I mean Krogan Generations. So like, a couple hundred years, not a few dozen lol.
@@johnwolf10 i agree, i think the reason kaidon or ashley is more interesting than just about every other choice in ME because there is no paragon/renegade dichotomy, so it really does become a personal choice.
Man, I never played that Walking Dead game, but that short scene made me wince and tear up. It’s so brilliantly directed, you aren’t feeling as bad for the dying character as much as for the child.
Ah geez, thanks Gameranx for making me relive that ending with Lee and Clem. Oh my gosh, I have cried again, it breaks my heart into piece every single time... its been son long since I played the first time I can't imagine how much I sobbed
I'm glad that LISA: The Painful has been getting more attention since its remake announcement. The game is nearly damn perfect in terms of story telling and I think is a must play for most people who are into stories in video games, provided you don't accidentally enable pain mode at the start and have to suffer through the whole game.
I'm not afraid to admit that I cried at the end of the Telltale Walking Dead season 1 ending. If anyone didn't cry at the end, they have no soul. lol The choice for Mass Effect was easy for me, I saved Ashley without any hesitation lol
no point in comparing, but they did a great job in building Lee and Clem characters and their bonding that, it break my heart at the end. I know shooting is the right choice from the start but to have Clem pulling the trigger? God that pain my heart
@@todeskult2818 immersion. You dive into that hypothetical scenario and ignore the fact it's not real while playing or watching. That's how you get scared in horror movies and sad when characters die. Maybe you can't immerse yourself in a scenario like that but the people who can feel real emotions even tho they know it's not actually happening. That's how.
oh man, its been what feels like and probably close to a decade since ive played the walking dead and that cutscene still made the feels come rushing back . Lee Everette is the kind of man we should all aspire to be like.
Probably because no sane human being would even CONSIDER saving Chloe at the end of that game. Save one unbelievably shitty person over saving a whole town of (mostly) innocent people? If you thought that was a hard choice there is something seriously wrong with your moral compass.
I just beat ghost of tsushima for the first time a week ago and I was fr crying leading up to the fight and then honoring Lord Shimura's final wish was difficult.
Honestly Witcher 3's moral dilemmas are pretty realistic in that as I heard someone say recently, "There are often no solutions, only tradeoffs." I mean how many people in real life get an actual happy ending in this world, which is full of so much violence already, but especially so during a time of war?
In Mass Effect 1 I always save Ashley, and here's why. She has a more fleshed out story over the course of the three games. She starts out xenophobic and incredible prejudiced due to her upbringing. After the events of 1 you can find data entries that show that she has moved past that and learned that her prejudices were unfounded and would save/die for any one of them. Kaiden has the personality of a wet mop throughout the series. No change whatsoever.
@maelkew3337 she's really xenophobic at the start and becomes quite jealous if you romance another character. Like to keep her around so she can watch then even with full Paragon during the events of 3 you have an opportunity to off her and its satisfying
Baldur's gate 2 choice was not as bad as you are depicting it: sure, 1 dex and 15hp are never funny things to lose, but by that point you are so powerful that those would hardly make a difference, expecially considering the other bonuses you get for completing the trials. Losing one of your 5 companions, on the other hand, is quite a harsh blow to your fighting strength. The selected party member is also always your love interest, if you had one
The walking dead ending was WAY MORE than a tear jerker, that shit had a grown ass man sobbing 😭 I STILL haven’t experienced something like that out of a game since then. It’s like the saddest masterpiece
I absolutely missed the Shadow thing in FFVI the first time around because he's like "You guys go on ahead, don't worry about me, I'll be fine!" and I trusted that guy implicitly. Was quite confused when I realised he never got off that island. Great list!
I think the decision to rewrite or destroy the geth heretics in ME2 is by far the more interesting choice. Brings up so many aspects of morality and philosophy. Not to mention the most important aspect (at least to me anyways) of whether our moral standards hold any weight when dealing with an entire different species with their own upbringing and beliefs. It may not carry the emotional weight as the Virmire decision, but from a philosophy standpoint it is by far the more interesting decision.
its definitely more interesting to think about fs, but thanks to the fact that theres a paragon option and a renegade option, the actual choice still boils down into are you good shep or bad shep, because if you want to make the most effective choices in 2 and 3, you need to be min/maxing paragon or renegade.
Yeah - it is not the most emotionally impactful one, but I remember thinking about this one for a longer time than perhaps any other such choice in any computer game, before I made a decision, because there are so many conflicting concepts here.
I've always found it to be an easy choice. Rewriting the Geth means they can always change their minds again later and is obviously going to benefit the Geth, while just destroying them doesn't really get the Geth anything but getting an enemy out of the way and those Geth are just plain dead and thus can never make a choice again. Not much of a moral dilemma.
I would like to mention that both The Walking Dead and Mass Effect decisions you quoted are not minor, they both have big ramifications in games farther in the series. Some choices and conversations cannot happen if you chose the other option.
There is a "good" ending to Bloody Baron. You can do other quests that change the ending to the Baron leaving with his wife to try and find a cure for her mind.
I was going to say, that was the ending I got the first time I played and after reading up later on, I found the other endings to be insanely worse. That ending wasn't good but bittersweet at best.
I’m terrible at making decisions in games. I used a guide for Heavy Rain because I was so worried I’d make the wrong choice. When Detroit came around I decided to trust my gut and I got Kara killed at the beginning of the game (“Ohhh, I was supposed to go upstairs and try to save the girl…OOPS!”)
@@MikeRaist and the decision is not really hard. either you pick edgy blue hair teenager or save the entire town worth of people. Adding also the fact that saving town is also favored by the blue chick in question and also has a better and longer ending cutscene is enough to say that this is not a hard choice. honestly the choice of killing or not killing paralized chloe is alot harder or choosing to tell her step dad that she is dead or not.
@@ZeppeliGamingthen explain why the last choice has a 50/50 pick rate… It’s not an easy choice. Personally I saved Chloe, I just bonded too much with her and I think that the connection Max had with her was too valuable to throw away, even for an entire town
That one mission from battlefield where you’re dangling above a giant yacht and you got like 10 seconds to choose either your squad mates or all the people on your boat, and if you don’t choose anything I think it blows up anyways and kills everyone
I never found the Mass Effect Kaiden v Ash that particularly difficult. First time I came across that decision, I chose based on numbers of people getting saved rather than the character. Made much more sense to try and save whoever was with the commando squad at the time, because you would be dooming them along with whoever was there (Ash or Kaiden).
Interesting, I usually chose the person by the bomb with the thought that "I better make sure this thing goes off" (I know K/A says it will go off regardless, but I'm not leaving that up to chance; what if the geth somehow disarm it with their advanced technical know-how?).
Meh, let kaiden blow himself up with the bomb and save Williams. Neither character has much of a part in later events like the rest of the team, so let that man die a hero. Mass effect 3 had the toughest choice of all with regards to geth vs quarian fleet for the final battle
yeah but you get to choose who goes where at the beginning of that mission, so if you want to save the maximum number of people, you send the party member you ultimately want to save with the commando squad.
This thoughts been brewing for awhile but I just love that Falcon is the type of person that you can have on a channel like this and no one pressures to do a face reveal. I'm sure many people probably asked over all this time and stuff but no ones really tried to make it high demand. I feel like that can feel very pressuring for anyone. I'm fine with Falcon continuing to be the personification of a bird it especially helps with the emotive artwork they put up. Lol.
Besides the listed choiced I'd like to throw Life is Strange's hat in the ring. The obvious choice would be the end, but I'll take the alterate reality Chloe situation where you have the choice to make unalive herself with the drugs or not. That was one of the many gut punches you can suffer in this game and while choosing Arcadia Bay left me empty and sad for a good while I'm kinda happy that I didn't encounter too many of the other ones as there are seemingly way more traps, but I avoided many.
An awful moment, but for me, at least, an obvious one. It's essentially the choice between your own mental comfort and the good (well, ending the suffering) of a close one. I would do it in the real life, even though I'd get a prison sentence for manslaughter.
@@polymorphesquirrel I did the same here, but in RL it would be a far tougher choice even though I have a suspicion that I'd do the same there. Besides the obvious helping a friend you'd also have to face the family/partner/whatever and while you and the friend may be ready the others may not, so yeah ... tough shit no matter what you do.
Oh man yeah 1 & 4 were the hardest for me. Lee is an awesome character and I didn’t want him to become a walker. On my first play-through I did let Clementine shoot Lee but I changed my mind because I thought that choice was too dark. As for Mass Effect yeah I like both characters. That was a though one. However I did save Ashley because my Shepard romanced her in 1-3.
I also let Clem shoot Lee. I always thought of it as a last Mercy for Lee and the first time i assumed that later in the story Lee would come back as a walker if you didnt shoot him
One thing I've learnt is that when given a chance to save either character A or B is that it doesn't really matter. One of those guys is gone, from a developer point of view unless the characters are interchangeable they aren't going to waste much time further developing a character. Take ME3, it's a big ask for Bioware to have put resources into Ashley when in a lot of people's games she would have been dead for nearly a decade. Can't believe Far Cry 3 doesn't make it on your list.
Yeah that’s a great point, it usually locks in certain design choices. It’s unlikely they’d have two totally different versions of the story structure that play out depending on who you pick. MGS just came down to some cutscene differences, but by the next game it’s clear there was a canon option. Players don’t want to be locked out of parts of the game because of a decision they made 2-3 games ago. Definitely seen this with character development too, and even in something like Sea of Stars where you pick which one is the party leader but keep both, the characters feel a little generic early on because they need to be interchangeable for story purposes.
You should've put in the list the final Life is Strange choice. Arcadia Bay vs Chloe. You develop a long time bond with Chloe to and is even worse because 90% of the game we fight for her life.
hint: choose Kate. Niko has just spend the better part of a year or whatever reckoning with Roman lying to him about the quality of life in America, dealing with Roman's irresponsibility with his money, and Roman's lack of ambition to do anything, even protect his own relationship. letting Niko live with Kate in the end at least promises a happier life for Niko.
@@Ferrindel like he's a super well written character, he's get depth and shit, but i found myself constantly annoyed by him in the first half of the game, and in the second half he just always interrupts what im doing asking if i wanna go drinking or something.
The Shadow decision is pathetically simple in the age of the internet, but when FF6 was new and info about games wasn't really shared around, it was a tough call. You were on the clock, the whole island was tearing itself apart underneath your feet, and yeah.... he cuts it very, VERY close. Though honestly, I wasn't sure if that was even the Shadow decision you meant, since it's also a tough call whether or not to help him regain his lost memories. Since, ya know.... doing so means he ultimately decides to atone for past sins by sacrificing himself in the ending anyway.
I can't believe a plague tale requiem wasn't on this list... literally had to pause it cause I couldn't stop crying, I still get depressed thinking about the choice at the end 😭
I never really had a hard time with that decision I was always going to let Mordin make up for his past mistakes plus I never let Wrex die so I am not going to sacrifice two amazing characters in vain.
@@jameslars7391 i agree if youve never accidently killed rex it isnt that hard but if you have reave makes such a atrong case for you to keep the genophage and mordins loss is always felt. Ive let him live a few times lol
I started my first ever Mass Effect playthrough and yeah i clicked on this video to see if it would make the cut and im happy to know this is number 1 since it was so hard knowing its for the rest of the games 😅
I'm just playing through the life is strange series now. I'd already heard of the decision you need to make, and knew which was the right outcome. But after the before the storm prequel and all 5 chapters in the original, I'd spent 20 + hours getting to know Chloe. Spoiler alert for a near 10 year old game: It was hard to let Nathan pull the trigger
I made the same decision. But I'm convinced now it is the wrong one. Look at Joel Miller. This is not a Trolley Problem. The whole world can go to hell if its about someone I truly care about.
I only missed the choice at the ending of Life is Strange. Well it's basically the whole game for the trolley problem, but it was hard nonetheless. Great list! Could have a 10 more list in the future.
It was kind of cheap, because it was basically the end of the game. Reload and you do both ;) In a very old adventure (point and click) Sword of Shannara there is a similar choice, but in the middle of the game: save your love interest and end the game, knowing you won't save the world and likely have only a few years for each other, or continue playing. These are heart-wrenching moments, but easy choices, really. It's like having a third choice: just turn off the game and never return to it. I can see myself doing it in certain moments in GTA games, but I have no desire to play them, so no problem.
Another thing to note in the BG2 choice is that certain character classes, like paladin and monk, lose their abilities if they shift alignments like that. So you have to lose someone else and lose all your abilities or you lose levels and stats.
There was also an exploit so that, if you were a mage and cast "Spell Immunity from Abjuration" or something like that on yourself, you were simply immune to the Dexterity reduction... I don't know if that also stopped the alignment shift, but it probably did.
I was about to say the same thing. The difficulty in my choice came not from who I wanted to save more but who I wanted to get rid of more. It was a tough choice.
There is more to that choice in the witcher 3. If you save the kids, the spirit also kills all the people in the village close by a bit later in the story. So the real choice becomes, a village worth of people vs the handful of kids.
@pekmenfan63 how much of it is their freewill, and how much of it is the control of the crones? Correct me if I'm wrong, but they hold power over the entire land. If the villagers don't "honor" the crones, then what would their punishment be? Would they even be allowed to flee if they tried? It seems to me that they were prisoners of circumstance.
IIRC the Bloody Baron got his name not from being especially cruel, but from a war fight he managed to survive - it is like Gerald being the "Butcher of Vladiken". The brilliant quest line intermingling main and side quests in a very clever way does not necessarily end with the Barons demise. The "best" ending (for the Baron) one can get is having the Baron taking his wife gone crazy to the "Blue Mountains" searching for a hermit to cure her. Drawback of that ending: the children abducted by the witches died horribly.
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
Don't forget the untold time you lose when creating a character for the first time. One of the hardest things to choose in skyrim is which race you gonna end up stealth archering
I feel like I’m the only person that always bounced off stealth archer builds. I would always get bored a good way into my play through.
My favorite was always a conjuring battle mage. Conjure some atronochs, conjure a sword, fireball and slash.
Chicken nuggets?
*takes 3 hours to make perfect character*
*puts on dark brotherhood armor immediately*
@@D71219ONE I moved onto a battle mage build too. A melee battle mage to be precise
Lol, 你的笑话. It's not hard to pick a race in Skyrim his name in that complex is not like the races are different it is as shity passives. Unless you actually use the mods are the character overhaul that bring back the traits for the characters then I would see that'll be a hard choice but vanilla try again.
That Walking Dead finale broke me. There's already something about the man/surrogate daughter dynamic that's compelling, but Clem being thrust into such a horrific world at such a young age, and being so innocent up to that point, and you know in Lee's final moments he has one last chance to better her odds, but he has to ask her to do something traumatizing in order to accomplish that, followed up by Clem's whimpers.... Dude, that scene was incredible.
Thats not the finale...
I never even played that game and watching it almost made me cry
I played that whole first season and that ending fucked up the series for me. I tried playing season 2, but I just couldn't. I ended up watching the series later, tho.
Aj made me so proud in the end, lee would’ve been so proud of Clem 😢
@@ericpadilla2454It quite literally is the finale of season 1...
Grown man who shed a few tears a couple of times playing TWD games reporting in. Such a good series of games that was. I should replay it sometime.
Clementine's VA performance was amazing, I can still here the tone in her voice while she was holding that gun
it’s ok to cry 🤦♀️
Ive never cried at a videogame lol
Not much of a man crying over a video game son
@@10a17aoh shut up you suck
Most decisions in Witcher 3 were nightmares for trying to figure out what to do. Always hidden information, underlying motives, and pros and cons to everything.
Great list Falcon!
i can think of many from Cyberpunk 77 as well that were insanely hard to choose; crucifying that convict, whether or not to tell Mr. Jefferson the truth, trusting the Voodoo Boys or NetWatch, even smaller seeming ones, like where to send Jackie's body were like "whoa i don't know, hold on"
Bro omg the amount of saves I had to go back for and the ones where I couldn't drove me crazy
That's CD Projekt Red for you haha
The one with the baby!
@Karasuza_sora Are they hard to get?
The hardest choice is not pulling out a real gun and shooting your tv every time you see Micah in RDR2.
Dont say this he is the best boi
@@gdxnskno, he’s the worst character and everyone but you can agree
@goldendummy2099 not really
he is a great character, people hate him because he does his job. be the bad guy, and he does a great job at it. amazing character.
@@gdxnskthe fuck are u talking about
Fuck Micah...
At one point during Telltales TWD I put my controller down, sobbing, saying “I don’t wanna do this, don’t make me choose”
Such a gut wrenching series of games
Damn really that bad?
@@vicentegeonix yes. I am heartless and I still sobbed
I honestly think the telltale walking dead aged really poorly, I didn't care about Lee at all in my most recent playthrough and alot of the side characters are unbearable in season 1 especially Kenny. I actually like Clementine she was a decently written character and lilly was also pretty likeable and I found myself siding with Lilly way more than Kenny. There were also alot of really poor character decisions. Like instead of just smashing Larry's head just stand over him which the box raised over his head and if he wakes up with the infected eyes then smash his head. It honestly felt like Kenny was really just trying to murder Larry cause he doesn't like him which is why I sided with Lilly. Lilly killing Carly also came out of nowhere since Carly was never mean to Lilly. Katja killing herself did make sense and worked well, but the ending really fell flat for me since I just didn't care about Lee they honestly did a horrible job with his character and his voice acting was so flat and wooden.
And then everyone in the room clapped
@@mattwallis1791
Not applicable
The Walking Dead was brutal and brilliant. Some people turn their nose up at the graphics, but the story is so immersive and gripping. Even in the shop, where you have to choose between saving the guy or the woman who’s being attacked by walkers. Either way, it’s not a great outcome later on. The game is amazing.
I remember when you had to stop clementine from eating the human meat, it was crazy but very good and realistic
if you played all 4 seasons you'll know the end of season 4 is probably the hardest you've cried for anything
facts, gotta be honest. never really wanted to play it bcs of the graphics and the comic styles game. but about a year ago game was on massive discount and I thought 'fuck it, imma buy it'. and thank god I bought it, honeslty really loved it. truely one of the best story games I ever played in my opinion. cried a lot, laught a lot
@@robertoakes537 Man that decision...
The walking dead had great ones, it was always so hard and you had that timer running, sadly it didnt matter too much after making a choice but still it felt so much more like YOU are the character and had to make those tough choices and then feel bad about it afterwards.
A sad little fact about the ending of TWD: Season 1 is right as the game fades to black, you can hear Lee one last time letting out his last breath. But that's actually his voice actor crying as they were recording the lines and they decided to leave it in the game because it was so emotional.
Never forget Paarthurnax. he was so chill and deserved to live 100%. “What is better: to be born good or to overcome your evil nature through great effort?” - Paarthurnax
fuck that traitor. If one minor minor thing was changed then i'd be indifferent. If dragons killed by dragonborn didn't in lore, told many many many times to you, outright proven, that once killed unlike any other creature in skyrim...they gone for good because you're "duh ultimate dragonslayer" is such a disappointment. Dragonborn should side with dragons or least be given a choice for
Egh i thought so as well but i think the majority of us can agree that we let him live, siding with the Blades had no real benefits whereas letting Paarthanux live i believed he granted you some stat boost? Cant remember what it was exactly but overall it wasn’t necessarily a difficult choice but rather an easy choice
@@teddgrambmx The whole "dragonborn" thing is a dick mov to permasteal dragon souls
@@silverscalederg8632 you’re not wrong bout that 😂
@@teddgrambmx I was actually looking forward to play as "dragonborn" like super hype sure the trailers show him fighting a dragon but lets be real if someone was "dragonborn" but stuck in a non dragon body absolutely going ham on a few dragons to show dominance doesn't exactly seem out of the norm
One decision that wasn‘t mentioned for me, was in Detroit: Become Human, when you play as Connor, you have to shoot an innocent robot, I sat in front of my TV for 10 minutes and didn‘t know what to do
Yes! This
Chloe didn’t deserve to die. 😢 spare her every time
@@Okthatscool-kw8ci it’s weird coz I spared her but I didn’t let her leave the main menu so 🤔
Yeah I might have some wrong with me cause I lit that mf up😂😂😂😂
Fun fact about Clementite-Lee situation is that if you don't pick either option to shoot or leave Lee, Clementine will pick one of the option herself based on how you interacted and what you taught her as Lee.
as for Mass Effect 1, I always pick Ashley, and the reason is that I don't really find Kaiden that useful. He's not terrible as NPC, starts off dull but once he opens up he has some really cool backstory, however when it comes to gameplay, he's Sentinel bio-tech hybrid, and is overshadowed by both Liara and Tali in both field, and both of them can be recruited very early in the game. If you play as Sentinel or Engineer you don't need Kaiden at all, because Bio\Tech will be fulfiled by either Liara or Tali, and second slot will go to either Wrex or Garrus, both who can do limited bio (Wrex) or tech (Garrus). So Kaiden is literally the least useful member of the group, because Ashley is pure soldier class, so she is pretty tough and high dps in endgame and can wear heavy armor, and in ME3 she is super tanky with right build.
I mean it also depends what class do you play at the moment. When I play as a soldier, I save Kaidan, when I play as a biotic, I save Ashley. At least for me that's one of the factors to consider.
Oh I didn't know Clem actually decided, if you don't that's pretty cool actually
I don't think about who I would save lol
I always save Ashley. Yeah, she's a something of a xenophobe, but at least she has an actual character arc over the course of the games. Kaiden is just bland. He starts out as bland in ME1 and by the end of ME3 he's still bland.
And how the hell is *that* choice number 1 on the list?! The Lee-Clementine choice is far, far, faaaar worse!
I play sentinel but I save Kaiden lmaoo. I don't put that much thought into team match-ups, I just pick who my Shepard would make the call to save
Can't believe Life Is Strange isn't on this list. That game absolutely wrecked me.
Hell you could have the euthanasia in the alternate timeline as a tough choice imagine that your talking to your friend paralysed in pain and she asks you to turn off her life support machine and set her free
A huge moral dilemma
Yeah, the decision between "Belgian Waffles or Bacon Omelette" and between "Pancakes or Eggs and Bacon" should occupy spots 1 and 2 for sure.
It's not hard at all. Is there a cure? if no. Is she gonna get better eventually or is it something that gets worse day by day? If there is no cure and no way of healing naturally then yes. I would do it for her. You don't let animals suffer, why would you let a human? @@kurtpunchesthings2411
@@kurtpunchesthings2411i turned it off every time bc i don't like her
i mean fair enough but why did you play the game till that point if you didn't like Chloe @@_xkikix_
the interesting thing about Kaiden and Ashley is how each character is presented in the first game. While Pressly is the ship's XO, Kaiden is very much Shepard's right hand man and both of them have friendly conversations and maybe a light romantic tone if you want to go for that. Ashley on the other hand in the first game is very capable but she questions Shepard at many turns, especially when it comes to the aliens of the universe, leading to her feeling annoying and insubordinate, but her real growth is seeing her in ME2 and 3 as in two, she's a lot more adaptable and responsible, and in 3, she's openly helping protect the council members of the citadel, showing how she grew into a better person and more conscientious soldier.
I knew it was a big decision but my simple first playthrough brain said "I wanna bang Liara as Femshep, Ashley is female so might be able to smash later. Sacrifice Kaiden.
But next time I play through I'll give Kaiden a go. The beer cutscene in the dlc seems like a bit of fun.
@@joshsg6525 i liked kaiden because hes Carth from Knights of the Old Republic, same personality, same voice, etc.
If Biotics were better in 1, Kaiden might have lived through more playthroughs, but they weren't and Ashley was my shooter so she lived.
I mentioned this on my post about this, but I legit find Kaiden useless. He's descent NPC, he's bit dull at first but once he opens up he has interesting backstory. He's just bit more reserved. However when it comes to gameplay, he's kinda useless. He is Sentinel class, and mix of bio and tech, however you get access to both Liara and Tali in the early game, and Liara is x5 better biotic and Tali is 5x better tech. So Kaiden is simply overshadowed. If you yourself play either Sentinel or Engineer, you will no doubt be strongest of said class, which once again makes Kaiden redundant, because you'll pick either Liara or Tali in 2nd slot to fill in the bio\tech spot, and you will pick one fighter class, which would be either Wrex or Garrus, and both can do limited, but useful bio\tech skills.
There's literally no need for Kaiden in any situation, outside having him as NPC all up to ME3. However, once again, he's kinda useless in ME3, because once again you have Liara, Tali and Garrus, and on top of that you have EDI of even more specialized tech npc. So Ashley is pretty much better option in both ME1 and ME3, because she's pure soldier (fighter) class, and she's tanky in both games, especially ME3 where you can either build her up as very tank squad member or high dps npc, whichever you need more.
I had one or two games where Kaiden lives (typically when I play fem Shep), but outside one or two first missions where you pretty much HAVE to use him (Eden Prime in ME1 or Mars in ME3), I've literally never used Kaiden.
Ironic that Ashley is totally useless in ME3 and Kaidan finally comes into his own.
Curing the Genophage or sacrificing Mordin, in Mass Effect 3, just broke my heart.
You mean sacrificing Mordin/Mordin Student from ME2 by curing the Genophage or Lying to Wrex/Wrex Brother.
Had to be him, someone else might've gotten it wrong.
Yeah that was tough.
Not even hard for me. But it's a heartbreaking loss
Killing mission, or making the wookie do it
The Baron quest in Witcher 3 was the one that really hooked me. Unendingly interesting and insanely tragic
Try WItcher 2. It's a smaller game, but its got tighter writing, lots of hidden info, and is basically 1.5 games; As a key choice will give you a completely different half of the game the other choice will lock you out of, and vice versa.
shame Cd projekt, because they wanted to make W3 the new flaghip t get in new players scrapped the plot that was building up in W2 (and W1). There was huge decisions in 2, that were meant to really alter W3.
One of the hardest decisions for me was choosing a horse while replaying Ghost Of Tsushima, knowing it was gonna die. Shit hurts man. 😭
Same for rdr2 😢
@@K_Catapilla I think you can save it if you stable it and use another one for the last mission
Take a page out of Geralt's Book of Equine Ambivalence: just call EVERY horse Roach
I miss you Kage
@@JasonwithaJay i chose Kage too 🥹
Actually there is a the 3rd option you missed here in the Bloody Baron quest. The one where they rescue Anna and the Baron takes her with him up to the Blue Mountains to see a wise man about curing her mind. But even THAT option isn't all great either for sure, as is the case for most of the big quests in Witcher 3 lol
I feel like it is the best option of the three though
@@mickidoesmedia Most definitely!!
@@mickidoesmedia It's the only option that gives a sliver of hope that woman will be cured. And even if she never will be cured Baron will take care of her till the end of his days.
This guy misses so much shit when playing games it's kinda frustrating
It's the best option.
He didn't do proper homework on this one.
The one that always stuck with me was choosing the life to save between Hannah and Irish in Battlefield 4.. you spend a large portion of the game with both of them and eventually with them together in your squad, learning about each of them in their dialogues and see their relationship progress.
In case you’re wondering, you have to drop one of them in to manually detonate an explosive, resulting in one of their untimely deaths. Each play through of that game I struggle to make that choice…
Oh yes that choice I have the game I completed it and that was a long time ago
War... war never changes
you can also sacrifice yourself
Or neither and ship go boom.
I still remember the feeling of making the Lee decision all these years later. That was an amazing story.
Yeah, me too! I thought the choice of amputation would save him!😢
@@Hillbot98 me too
The ending of the game always gets me 😔
@@Takarr yeah.🥺
The game did make me tear up, amazing that we can have these emotions in video games
Another one that really got to me was the ending of Life is Strange where you have to choose between sacrificing Chole or Arcadia Bay. Choosing between a town of innocent people, or your best friend. It's tough.
I was about to say, why is the end of life is strange 1 not in here. That choice at the end is fucking brutal
yeah and after the sequence selecting chloe even made me tear up even tho I wasn't really fan of her lol
I would say it was more annoying because it was pretty obvious which choice was considered the right one lol, like thanks for making me feel guilty about choosing my girlfriend 💀
Honestly, even though I knew it wasn't the most moral choice, I would have chosen Chloe over the town, IF IT WASN'T FOR THE FACT that she literally begged you to save her mom.
Personally, I found the earlier decision of whether to euthanize alt!Chloe significantly harder, possibly because it's the kind of decision you might actually be expected to make in real life.
i found the last two by far the easiest to make. Kaiden alenko i found really boring to the point where in a few playthroughs i actually forced myself to get to know him better. As for Lord Shimura, i always felt that Jins story was how he doesnt have to do things the samurai way. The samurai showed that their way wouldnt work against the mongols, and while yes in some ways Jin dishonoured himself by resorting to the methods he chose ultamately it also freed him to spare the life of a good man in a way a samurai never would have.
Exactly. Shimura lives on and names you an outlaw but continues to live and rule whereas the other option results in the shogun replacing him with a worse ruler who's loyal to him and not the people he rules. Shimura was well loved if you pay attention
Choosing whether to save Fergus or Wyatt in Wolfenstein was a tough one too, obviously you can play both timelines, but it’s still so tough, even throughout the rest of the play-through you get reminded of it by the protagonist you chose to save.
Yeah it was tough
I was in shock when it happened
I’m glad someone mentioned this, cuz that game was twisted.
What made it especially tough to choose was that the game took good care to make both Wyatt and Ferguson pretty upstanding lads, which made being compelled to sacrifice one of them at gunpoint all the more painful.
Just played this earlier tonight actually. I set my controller down for a good two minutes waiting for something to happen before I realized, oh crap they're actually making me choose.
14:11 there's a third scenario that I think fewer people knew about, I only heard it from someone else, but Clementine can actually choose for herself based on her seeing Lee's actions throughout the game. You just don't decide on much of anything and then Clementine (if she's seen Lee do harsh stuff she'll act accordingly, or if more merciful she'll opt out of killing) will make her own choice
Edit: That was the reason for those "Clementine will remember that." messages during rough parts
I only knew this because I literally couldn’t choose. I was leakinggggg
Yep. I've played through Season 1 particularly multiple times for practically every outcome and that one was the one that I cried the hardest
What I've always thought is, can't Lee just shoot himself? Like, why are you making the poor child do it man
@@JosebalbeI guess cuz one arm is handcuffed and the other arm is missing
@@sauce6746 but he can just move his head closer to the hand
The Bloody Baron quests were the BEST PART of that entire game. I loved his entire story and it made me forget I was supposed to be finding some emperor's daughter or something. He had a hard story with his wife and in the end, I felt sorry for his situation. For someone from the OLD DAYS he was a fairly decent ruler.
Some Emperor's daughter? He might be her father, but sure as hell isn't her daddy.
the most overrated game to ever exist
The decision in infamous 1 to choose between saving your wife and saving a group of doctors still stays with me. One of the few games that showed you how hard it can truly be to be a super hero. It didn't matter how strong you got you couldn't save her. You had to make the right choice
Yes it's called my wife. Family -> everything else
The best thing about InFamous is the ending and working out why you couldnt save Trish no matter which choice you make. Because the bad guy is actually you from the future and knows what choice you would make he will always make sure you have to lose her in order to make you stronger. Its a great twist that allows you to have a choice and influence your karma level but at the same time makes your choice an impossible one.
@@WardragonLog101nope. Even Trish hates him for saving her after. Saving 1 doctor over 10 is stupid when the whole city is sick
@@calebrichardson5259 it might be stupid but I'm still saving my family over a doctor. Don't care.
@@WardragonLog101 how about saving her over a school full of children
Man the Bloody Baron questline is literally the best sidequest ever. Time to replay W3... again :D
If you got it on pc someone recently made a Guiding Wind mod ala Ghost of Tsushima, makes leaves and particle effects fly toward your quest objective. Been playing it with all the HUD turned off such a gorgeous game.
See you in six months
@@uncleharm8893 thanks i'm gonna check it out
That was the best? Looks like I can stop playing Witcher 3 then🤷♂️
Yeah but I got the distinct feeling the entire game was supposed to be that detailed, but CDPR bit off more than they could chew and we only got that one most Witcher 1-ish quest. Still one of the best games ever though.
You should have put the end choice in a plague tale requiem, this moment was heartbreaking
Bruh, the children in the NieR Automata Pascal sceen did not turn on eachother, they commited suicide. And the reason they did is because of fear. Pascal over instilled a sense if fear in them, and that was the consequence, which makes Pascal not just heartbroken but feeling guilty.
I hate well the annoying "well ackchyually" guy, but that small change makes a huge difference when you examine this moment alongside others and the themes of NieR Automata.
Man, I love how the game made you feel awful making pascal live in a life of blissful ignorance where he talks about how much he cared for the children, too, and you're all like... "Man, did I do the right thing?"
@@acrane3496 "you manage to defeat all the attackers, but when you return you find all the children dead. They all went mad and turned on eachother." That is the direct quote from this video. Try listening to what he actually said in the video that i was commenting on before trying to correct someone. Because they're either wrong, or they're putting events out of order.
Yes, the committed suicide. Pascal blames himself because he installed fear into the children. That why he felt as guilty as he did.
He also left out the choice between 9S and A2 at the top of the tower. I know you're supposed to go back and choose the other you didn't choose, but that first choice is tough and such a sad unexpected choice that puts a lot of weight on that moment.
Then there's the final choice of whether or not you should sacrifice your data to save someone else you don't know.
what did you guys picked? i just bought the game on the switch
No matter how many times I have replayed TWD season 1 from Telltale, I ALWAYS cry at the end when I have to shoot Lee. Telltale does such an amazing job of really making you connect emotionally with Lee and Clem, that makes the choice so sad and difficult.
The Gears of War 5, save Del or JD scene came out of nowhere and I was NOT prepared for it. Probably one of the hardest decisions I've had to make in gaming honestly.
Yep a huge thing to say ha ha ha😂for all of your hard work and patience
Same dude, I was playing with a buddy and I(both playing the game for our first time when it first came out) asked him did he know about this decision and at first he said no and after letting the timer countdown over and over, an me saying this is BS and then I finally chose and I chose to save Del cuz he's been with me(Kait) through the whole game. Then of course my buddy said he actually knew about this specific part and didn't want to tell me. Definitely should've been mentioned in this video.
The Walking Dead Series had so many tough choices. I remember in season 2 where you have to choose whether to share your food with the dog and resetting and trying every path to try and find the positive outcome (there isn't one). Also, the end fight scene between Kenny and Jane i was so torn i literally couldn't decide who to help so i just took the cowardly path and chose to do nothing every time I had to make a choice.
i feel like season 2s choices were more universally bad though, like in a sense that the consequence happens anyway. a good example is however you handle your job and the other girls job at the department store, Carver will just toss Kumail Nanjiani's character off the roof. definitely agree with you about having a real hard time choosing Jane or Kenny though, they were both really bad choices for Clem as Kenny's stability was so far past unstable, that i'd never feel safe with him. on the other hand, Jane's a survivor, not a companion so theres no warmth between the two.
@@quinnmarchese6313 the amount of psychological obliteration through ptsd kenny dealt with is extreme
@@falloutthewindowcrazy7608 such a tragic character
@@quinnmarchese6313 it is definitely in my top 3 list of most emotional games i've ever played asuras wrath? dem feels
When I made my decision with Kenny and Jane the first time, I chose to save Jane. It was really hard to do, but watching Kenny go ballistic over something, while tragic, he was told was an accident made him seem unstable and dangerous to be around. Not that it was his fault at all considering everything he had been through. It just was a matter of everyone's safety. Only to find out it was over a complete lie and Jane had set him up. And it really annoyed me there wasn't a dialogue option for "You know you dun goofed, but I'm keeping you around for AJ's survivability, not because I forgive you". I had to just sit in my room and mentally process what I just did for a good hour after I finished that game.
I feel lately the hardest decision I’ve had to make is which games to buy. 2023 has been insane with releases!
Currently deciding on Diablo 4 or final Fantasy 16😅
What do you even mean? 90% of the releases are rushed or shovelware
@@ProCrow7 FF16 all day!
of all the big releases so far, IMO the only two worth talking about are Jedi Survivor and Tears of the Kingdom. ill allow those ff16 though, ive never been a huge fan but i know those who are. anything else worth talking about is in the indie/much cheaper categories.
@@quinnmarchese6313 I’m looking forward to lords of the fallen, armored core, & Atlas Fallen. Diablo VI & Resident Evil 4 Remake releases are worth noting too. & yes, FF16 for sure.
The Baron quest does have a somewhat good ending option. If you free the tree spirit before starting the crones of crookback bog quest you will save the kids and Anna doesn’t get killed
There is a “good ending” for the bloody baron quest, you’ve gotta be precise in the order of how to you do steps layed out to you prior to going to save his wife. You save her, the kids and his daughter opens up to the idea of starting again with her dad. Although his wife needs mental help after the whole ordeal the baron says he knows a Sage in the blue Mountains that could help so, in my mind it’s the best ending for them.
But what about the kids then ?
@@Claire_Drawarts honestly f*ck those kids
Yeah no that’s not how the mission works unless you mod the game somehow. You choose to save the kids and the wife turns to a hag and baron offs himself or you let the kids be taken and the barons family stays together. There’s no “good ending”
@Redfield_Bloodline
The kids survive if you choose to free the spirit in the tree BEFORE starting the quest. So if you miracously stumble across it like I did and choose to save the spirit, she'll rescue the children. In my ending, everyone survived.
@@jaycehasteI play unmodded. You can get this by saving the spirit in the tree before ever meeting Anna.
In my opinion, Life is Strange had the toughest choice at the end, and the Game even shows stats how other players made choices in the Game. That Last choice was 50/50 in stats.
Oh yesss! Good callback. I remember that struggle
Yeah, good shout. I had to think about that decision for a bit.
It actually was a choice between your past and present. If you are too attached to your past, you will destroy your present. And to save your present you have to break up with your past.
@NikZedik I was willing to let her die in Ep.2
i disagree. While Chloe really grew on me as time went by, i never cared enough about her to do anything but save the rest of Arcadia Bay. Like Warren's a decent dude who deserves life, Chloe's mom is a wonderful person, even David Madsen is a really good guy buried under a layer of PTSD and bad parenting. Chloe was just kinda a bitchy teenager.
I'm assuming the reason Fable 2 doesn't show up on here is because the choice is extremely easy...you ALWAYS resurrect your dog.
Spec Ops: The Line was full of hard decisions. Awesome video Mr Falcon.
I thought of that, but in the end the decisions don't exactly matter anyway, right?
Spec Ops: The Line is the best game I ever played but... I don't recall there is any decisions? Just a lot of reflection on myself...
@MarsRL the only decision in the end that really matters is whether you started the game or not. The lead developer said he considers turning the game off at any point is a valid ending. Essentially Walker sees the futility of it all and he and his men abandon Dubai.
That's pretty much the only good ending in that game. God that game is so fucked up.
Saving Chloe or saving Arcadia Bay at the end of Life is Strange was a tough one for me.
Chloe was an unlikeable ungrateful unfunny brat who deserved to die even if it wasn't going to save Arcadia Bay.
That was the easiest decision for me. Chloe is one the WORST characters I’ve had to interact with in games. That said, even if she was likable, I don’t think its worth it to allow the destruction of an ENTIRE town and possibly a few hundred people over one person
That was the hardest decision for me as well since I liked Chloe's badass shit she pulled
its an easy choice but makes it difficult cause all max was saying how much she meant to her :(
@@jake.p13 Yes and without Max seeing Chloe get shot in the bathroom, she would have never discovered her power so they were connected from the very beginning
I cant believe Fable 2's final wish didn't make the list. "Ultimate power, enough money to buy the largest castle in the game as a personal home, or revive your dog who sacrificed himself for you in the last mission"
@@zackjames5976 the lil sister became the blind seeress in the other 2 games but there was another choice or 2 on fable 2.... all the people ressed from the Tower, your family ressed
I totally expected Fable 2 to be on here, especially since the choice from Black Ops 2 doesn't end up mattering much in the end. Fable 2's choices just felt more impactful.
Speaking of Mass Effect, having to shoot Mordin Solus if you wanted to prevent him from giving the super-breeder powers back to the Krogan was also an interesting moral choice.
Letting him cure the genophage and die doing so is just as heartbreaking, if not more. My favorite variation of that scene is pushing him to sabotage the cure until he admits "I MADE A MISTAKE". For some reason, hearing Mordin using a personal pronoun is really strong.
Was never a question for me . The Krogen deserved the cure at that point
If you wanted max points you had to let him do it. Not so hard as this on the list.
If Wrex is in charge, between him, Grunt, and Eve, I think you can trust the Krogans for a few generations at least. And I mean Krogan Generations. So like, a couple hundred years, not a few dozen lol.
@@johnwolf10 i agree, i think the reason kaidon or ashley is more interesting than just about every other choice in ME because there is no paragon/renegade dichotomy, so it really does become a personal choice.
Man, I never played that Walking Dead game, but that short scene made me wince and tear up. It’s so brilliantly directed, you aren’t feeling as bad for the dying character as much as for the child.
Should definitely play all the seasons, hands down one of the best series in all of gaming.
Ah geez, thanks Gameranx for making me relive that ending with Lee and Clem. Oh my gosh, I have cried again, it breaks my heart into piece every single time... its been son long since I played the first time I can't imagine how much I sobbed
I'm glad that LISA: The Painful has been getting more attention since its remake announcement. The game is nearly damn perfect in terms of story telling and I think is a must play for most people who are into stories in video games, provided you don't accidentally enable pain mode at the start and have to suffer through the whole game.
I'm not afraid to admit that I cried at the end of the Telltale Walking Dead season 1 ending. If anyone didn't cry at the end, they have no soul. lol The choice for Mass Effect was easy for me, I saved Ashley without any hesitation lol
no point in comparing, but they did a great job in building Lee and Clem characters and their bonding that, it break my heart at the end. I know shooting is the right choice from the start but to have Clem pulling the trigger? God that pain my heart
@@todeskult2818 immersion.
You dive into that hypothetical scenario and ignore the fact it's not real while playing or watching.
That's how you get scared in horror movies and sad when characters die.
Maybe you can't immerse yourself in a scenario like that but the people who can feel real emotions even tho they know it's not actually happening.
That's how.
@@leesasuki Exactly
it was the first time i ever cried in a videogame rip Lee
@@CripticK1ng Same here
oh man, its been what feels like and probably close to a decade since ive played the walking dead and that cutscene still made the feels come rushing back . Lee Everette is the kind of man we should all aspire to be like.
Don't know how Life is Strange is not up there. Definitely one of the most heartbreaking of all.
cause its a piss poor decision
Probably because no sane human being would even CONSIDER saving Chloe at the end of that game. Save one unbelievably shitty person over saving a whole town of (mostly) innocent people? If you thought that was a hard choice there is something seriously wrong with your moral compass.
The choice split is literallynearly 50/50
I just beat ghost of tsushima for the first time a week ago and I was fr crying leading up to the fight and then honoring Lord Shimura's final wish was difficult.
cant believe the cyberpunk ending wasnt included. so many options, none are very ideal, very tough to see
💯
Honestly Witcher 3's moral dilemmas are pretty realistic in that as I heard someone say recently, "There are often no solutions, only tradeoffs." I mean how many people in real life get an actual happy ending in this world, which is full of so much violence already, but especially so during a time of war?
Telltale really hit it out of the park with TWD. I actually stopped playing after Lee died.
Season two is good but not as perfect as one. Three is a mixed bag and 4th is as good as the first. you should give it a try.
you should finish playing through all the seasons the last season satisfied me with the ending
@@kamikazelombardo no it wasn't
Idk if it was a choice but the end of A Way Out really shook me
In Mass Effect 1 I always save Ashley, and here's why. She has a more fleshed out story over the course of the three games. She starts out xenophobic and incredible prejudiced due to her upbringing. After the events of 1 you can find data entries that show that she has moved past that and learned that her prejudices were unfounded and would save/die for any one of them. Kaiden has the personality of a wet mop throughout the series. No change whatsoever.
I save her because she is hot. Evolutionary biology wins there, haha.
@@ihavegymnastics same plus head canon John shepard marries her
I save Ashley so I can shoot her in ME3, more satisfying
@@mudskipperdroneswhy tho just asking never played the games
@maelkew3337 she's really xenophobic at the start and becomes quite jealous if you romance another character.
Like to keep her around so she can watch then even with full Paragon during the events of 3 you have an opportunity to off her and its satisfying
Baldur's gate 2 choice was not as bad as you are depicting it: sure, 1 dex and 15hp are never funny things to lose, but by that point you are so powerful that those would hardly make a difference, expecially considering the other bonuses you get for completing the trials. Losing one of your 5 companions, on the other hand, is quite a harsh blow to your fighting strength. The selected party member is also always your love interest, if you had one
Yep. A slight nerf to your OP PC or losing a full party member? Gimmie that nerf ANY DAY
Oh Telltale Walking Dead... I cried soooooooo hard. It'd been a long time since a game gave me those feels... So well written.
Man, that "The Walking Dead" ending was brutal when I played it for the first time
The walking dead ending was WAY MORE than a tear jerker, that shit had a grown ass man sobbing 😭 I STILL haven’t experienced something like that out of a game since then. It’s like the saddest masterpiece
The hardest choice for me was choosing one between Yennefer and Triss.
I absolutely missed the Shadow thing in FFVI the first time around because he's like "You guys go on ahead, don't worry about me, I'll be fine!" and I trusted that guy implicitly. Was quite confused when I realised he never got off that island. Great list!
Just wait for the last minute, then you save shadow. There’s no choice to make, just be patient.
@@lilkittygirl Thanks lol I'm aware, have saved him multiple times since.
I don't remember, but if you leave Shadow behind do you still get Relm's flashback that implies he's her father?
I think the decision to rewrite or destroy the geth heretics in ME2 is by far the more interesting choice. Brings up so many aspects of morality and philosophy. Not to mention the most important aspect (at least to me anyways) of whether our moral standards hold any weight when dealing with an entire different species with their own upbringing and beliefs. It may not carry the emotional weight as the Virmire decision, but from a philosophy standpoint it is by far the more interesting decision.
its definitely more interesting to think about fs, but thanks to the fact that theres a paragon option and a renegade option, the actual choice still boils down into are you good shep or bad shep, because if you want to make the most effective choices in 2 and 3, you need to be min/maxing paragon or renegade.
Yeah - it is not the most emotionally impactful one, but I remember thinking about this one for a longer time than perhaps any other such choice in any computer game, before I made a decision, because there are so many conflicting concepts here.
I've always found it to be an easy choice. Rewriting the Geth means they can always change their minds again later and is obviously going to benefit the Geth, while just destroying them doesn't really get the Geth anything but getting an enemy out of the way and those Geth are just plain dead and thus can never make a choice again.
Not much of a moral dilemma.
@@immortalfrieza if you consider them sentient, then rewriting them is enslaving them, imagine doing that to people
@@Leo.23232 If they're evil people, I don't see why not
I'm glad someone pointed how nice the Campaign in Black Ops 2 was. That game blew my mind by the end of it.
I loved my time with Witcher 3! 😻
I would like to mention that both The Walking Dead and Mass Effect decisions you quoted are not minor, they both have big ramifications in games farther in the series. Some choices and conversations cannot happen if you chose the other option.
There is a "good" ending to Bloody Baron. You can do other quests that change the ending to the Baron leaving with his wife to try and find a cure for her mind.
I was going to say, that was the ending I got the first time I played and after reading up later on, I found the other endings to be insanely worse. That ending wasn't good but bittersweet at best.
I’m terrible at making decisions in games. I used a guide for Heavy Rain because I was so worried I’d make the wrong choice. When Detroit came around I decided to trust my gut and I got Kara killed at the beginning of the game (“Ohhh, I was supposed to go upstairs and try to save the girl…OOPS!”)
☠️
How the final decision of Life is Strange is not in this, is beyond me.
cause the game is not that good.
@@MikeRaist and the decision is not really hard. either you pick edgy blue hair teenager or save the entire town worth of people. Adding also the fact that saving town is also favored by the blue chick in question and also has a better and longer ending cutscene is enough to say that this is not a hard choice. honestly the choice of killing or not killing paralized chloe is alot harder or choosing to tell her step dad that she is dead or not.
@@ZeppeliGamingthen explain why the last choice has a 50/50 pick rate… It’s not an easy choice. Personally I saved Chloe, I just bonded too much with her and I think that the connection Max had with her was too valuable to throw away, even for an entire town
That one mission from battlefield where you’re dangling above a giant yacht and you got like 10 seconds to choose either your squad mates or all the people on your boat, and if you don’t choose anything I think it blows up anyways and kills everyone
I never found the Mass Effect Kaiden v Ash that particularly difficult. First time I came across that decision, I chose based on numbers of people getting saved rather than the character. Made much more sense to try and save whoever was with the commando squad at the time, because you would be dooming them along with whoever was there (Ash or Kaiden).
Interesting, I usually chose the person by the bomb with the thought that "I better make sure this thing goes off" (I know K/A says it will go off regardless, but I'm not leaving that up to chance; what if the geth somehow disarm it with their advanced technical know-how?).
Meh, let kaiden blow himself up with the bomb and save Williams. Neither character has much of a part in later events like the rest of the team, so let that man die a hero. Mass effect 3 had the toughest choice of all with regards to geth vs quarian fleet for the final battle
yeah but you get to choose who goes where at the beginning of that mission, so if you want to save the maximum number of people, you send the party member you ultimately want to save with the commando squad.
This thoughts been brewing for awhile but I just love that Falcon is the type of person that you can have on a channel like this and no one pressures to do a face reveal. I'm sure many people probably asked over all this time and stuff but no ones really tried to make it high demand. I feel like that can feel very pressuring for anyone. I'm fine with Falcon continuing to be the personification of a bird it especially helps with the emotive artwork they put up. Lol.
Imagine needing to make this comment. You probably *actually* want him to do a face reveal. Why don't you ask him personally❓
Why make such comment than?
Wait, he shows his face all the time, he's a falcon. I am just surprised every time how well a falcon can speak.
An honourable mention for me: Life is Stranger's final decision.
Besides the listed choiced I'd like to throw Life is Strange's hat in the ring. The obvious choice would be the end, but I'll take the alterate reality Chloe situation where you have the choice to make unalive herself with the drugs or not.
That was one of the many gut punches you can suffer in this game and while choosing Arcadia Bay left me empty and sad for a good while I'm kinda happy that I didn't encounter too many of the other ones as there are seemingly way more traps, but I avoided many.
An awful moment, but for me, at least, an obvious one. It's essentially the choice between your own mental comfort and the good (well, ending the suffering) of a close one. I would do it in the real life, even though I'd get a prison sentence for manslaughter.
@@polymorphesquirrel I did the same here, but in RL it would be a far tougher choice even though I have a suspicion that I'd do the same there.
Besides the obvious helping a friend you'd also have to face the family/partner/whatever and while you and the friend may be ready the others may not, so yeah ... tough shit no matter what you do.
The fate of Artemis in No Man’s Sky deserves an honourable mention, makes me cry every time.
Oh man yeah 1 & 4 were the hardest for me. Lee is an awesome character and I didn’t want him to become a walker. On my first play-through I did let Clementine shoot Lee but I changed my mind because I thought that choice was too dark. As for Mass Effect yeah I like both characters. That was a though one. However I did save Ashley because my Shepard romanced her in 1-3.
I also let Clem shoot Lee. I always thought of it as a last Mercy for Lee and the first time i assumed that later in the story Lee would come back as a walker if you didnt shoot him
@@mzwethu3805 Yeah part of me thought the same thing. Thankfully we never see him as a walker
One thing I've learnt is that when given a chance to save either character A or B is that it doesn't really matter. One of those guys is gone, from a developer point of view unless the characters are interchangeable they aren't going to waste much time further developing a character. Take ME3, it's a big ask for Bioware to have put resources into Ashley when in a lot of people's games she would have been dead for nearly a decade.
Can't believe Far Cry 3 doesn't make it on your list.
And the amount of false advertising and misleading promos in games such as bo2 and others broke me I am serious they give me pain
Yeah that’s a great point, it usually locks in certain design choices. It’s unlikely they’d have two totally different versions of the story structure that play out depending on who you pick. MGS just came down to some cutscene differences, but by the next game it’s clear there was a canon option. Players don’t want to be locked out of parts of the game because of a decision they made 2-3 games ago.
Definitely seen this with character development too, and even in something like Sea of Stars where you pick which one is the party leader but keep both, the characters feel a little generic early on because they need to be interchangeable for story purposes.
You should've put in the list the final Life is Strange choice. Arcadia Bay vs Chloe. You develop a long time bond with Chloe to and is even worse because 90% of the game we fight for her life.
The ending of Grand Theft Auto 4 qualifies here. Especially if you know how the final choice plays out already.
hint: choose Kate. Niko has just spend the better part of a year or whatever reckoning with Roman lying to him about the quality of life in America, dealing with Roman's irresponsibility with his money, and Roman's lack of ambition to do anything, even protect his own relationship. letting Niko live with Kate in the end at least promises a happier life for Niko.
@@quinnmarchese6313 That's what I usually did. Roman was a ponce the entire game.
@@Ferrindel like he's a super well written character, he's get depth and shit, but i found myself constantly annoyed by him in the first half of the game, and in the second half he just always interrupts what im doing asking if i wanna go drinking or something.
@@quinnmarchese6313 “HEY NIKO! LET’S GO BOWLING”
“Bro, I have the army after me because I’m on a crime spree. I’m kinda busy.”
The Shadow decision is pathetically simple in the age of the internet, but when FF6 was new and info about games wasn't really shared around, it was a tough call. You were on the clock, the whole island was tearing itself apart underneath your feet, and yeah.... he cuts it very, VERY close.
Though honestly, I wasn't sure if that was even the Shadow decision you meant, since it's also a tough call whether or not to help him regain his lost memories. Since, ya know.... doing so means he ultimately decides to atone for past sins by sacrificing himself in the ending anyway.
I can't believe a plague tale requiem wasn't on this list... literally had to pause it cause I couldn't stop crying, I still get depressed thinking about the choice at the end 😭
The decision at the start of Wolfenstein was pretty brutal that early in the game.
As a MASSIVE mass effect fan i gotta say the genophage decision in 3 was so much harder!!!
Mordin may you forever find your seashells to analyis😢😢😢
I never really had a hard time with that decision I was always going to let Mordin make up for his past mistakes plus I never let Wrex die so I am not going to sacrifice two amazing characters in vain.
@@jameslars7391 i agree if youve never accidently killed rex it isnt that hard but if you have reave makes such a atrong case for you to keep the genophage and mordins loss is always felt. Ive let him live a few times lol
Heavy Rain was a great game and truly underrated during the PS3 console times
This channel really knows how to rank its stuff
In crookback bog, there's actually a good ending, where the Baron goes with his wife to find the Hermit and the children are put into an orphanage.
I started my first ever Mass Effect playthrough and yeah i clicked on this video to see if it would make the cut and im happy to know this is number 1 since it was so hard knowing its for the rest of the games 😅
I hadn’t played TWD season 1 in soooo long but loved it so much, so when he brought it up I legit shed a tear just thinking abt that final decision.
I'm just playing through the life is strange series now. I'd already heard of the decision you need to make, and knew which was the right outcome. But after the before the storm prequel and all 5 chapters in the original, I'd spent 20 + hours getting to know Chloe. Spoiler alert for a near 10 year old game:
It was hard to let Nathan pull the trigger
I made the same decision. But I'm convinced now it is the wrong one. Look at Joel Miller. This is not a Trolley Problem. The whole world can go to hell if its about someone I truly care about.
The second Life is Strange literally ripped my heart out of its chest and curbstomped it
Losing Lee really was tough. Did a play through earlier this year and it still is heart felt
I only missed the choice at the ending of Life is Strange. Well it's basically the whole game for the trolley problem, but it was hard nonetheless.
Great list! Could have a 10 more list in the future.
It was kind of cheap, because it was basically the end of the game. Reload and you do both ;) In a very old adventure (point and click) Sword of Shannara there is a similar choice, but in the middle of the game: save your love interest and end the game, knowing you won't save the world and likely have only a few years for each other, or continue playing. These are heart-wrenching moments, but easy choices, really. It's like having a third choice: just turn off the game and never return to it. I can see myself doing it in certain moments in GTA games, but I have no desire to play them, so no problem.
I wish rockstar gave an option not to visit Thomas Downes in RDR 2 for the loansharking mission. We could've saved Arthur from Tuberculosis 😭
send micha
When you said The Witcher 3 I thought you were going for the "throw the baby in the oven" question ahahah
Omg that was such a tough one
Another thing to note in the BG2 choice is that certain character classes, like paladin and monk, lose their abilities if they shift alignments like that. So you have to lose someone else and lose all your abilities or you lose levels and stats.
What happens if choose the other door? its been like a decade since I've played it. :) Can't even remember what i chose.
@@auric180 One door has you lose permanent stats and a bunch of levels. The other door has you lose a party member and shift your alignment to evil.
@@Spotastic9 Thanks, think most likely i chose the stats one.
There was also an exploit so that, if you were a mage and cast "Spell Immunity from Abjuration" or something like that on yourself, you were simply immune to the Dexterity reduction... I don't know if that also stopped the alignment shift, but it probably did.
@highdefinist9697 Oh yeah. I remember doing that now that you mention it. 😄
The biggest struggle I have on Virmire is not leaving both of them behind.
I was about to say the same thing. The difficulty in my choice came not from who I wanted to save more but who I wanted to get rid of more. It was a tough choice.
@@Ivotas rude
This War of Mine should be a MUST when talking about tough decisions in videogames. Also Papers Please
I have the game along with all the expansions thanks to the final cut
I think, you never played "Spec Ops: The Line" ? The hardest game with most saddest choices ever made... but still good list :)
Save chloe or save arcadia bay?
Chloe!!! Game is pointless otherwise lol.
When you can't pickup that new weapon you just found because you're over encumbered.
Choosing what to throw away is the hardest choice for me 😂
There is more to that choice in the witcher 3. If you save the kids, the spirit also kills all the people in the village close by a bit later in the story.
So the real choice becomes, a village worth of people vs the handful of kids.
I forgot the reasoning, but I chose the kids.
Are they my kids?
Nope?
Cheerio you creepy little shites!
I mean those villagers willingly sacrificed children and people to Crones. The choice wasn't that hard. They deserved it.
@pekmenfan63 how much of it is their freewill, and how much of it is the control of the crones? Correct me if I'm wrong, but they hold power over the entire land. If the villagers don't "honor" the crones, then what would their punishment be? Would they even be allowed to flee if they tried? It seems to me that they were prisoners of circumstance.
Man... Just watching that end scene with Lee caused me to tear up just now. I'd be hard pressed to find a game ending that's affected me that much...
IIRC the Bloody Baron got his name not from being especially cruel, but from a war fight he managed to survive - it is like Gerald being the "Butcher of Vladiken". The brilliant quest line intermingling main and side quests in a very clever way does not necessarily end with the Barons demise. The "best" ending (for the Baron) one can get is having the Baron taking his wife gone crazy to the "Blue Mountains" searching for a hermit to cure her. Drawback of that ending: the children abducted by the witches died horribly.
Alot of Far Cry Games actually have you choose between two ending . They are always both ''bad ending '' tho .
FC4 is especially nasty with that.
fc4 having you to choose betwen killing amita or kabal and killing or sparing pagan is just devious
@@gdxnsk and on the second playthrough, knowing the outcome - letting Amita or Cabal *live* is a hard choice.
Imagine if the Virmire choice was Garrus or Tali. Or even Liara. That would make the decision truly hard.
I'd rather that instead bc I rather like Ashley and kaiden but if tali was an option I'd choose her every time