Brothers life it's numbers. The key is to stay young forever with aches and pains but you are a step ahead of falling and not letting the last stage come any where near you. Amen 🙏
@@waynemoore5467 What I wouldn't give to go back to those simpler, slower, purer, more peaceful times. Wish so much I couldv'e know them both. Will always love Neil and Bob.
Marlon Brando made the presentation at this Snack Festival 1975 and said : The sentiment here today is worth more than all the fuckin' money in the world .
I cannot imagine what my life would have been like if Bob Dylan had not been there to express in poetry and music my every mood. I love every song, every performance from 'Nam in the mid-1960's to today.. He's incomparable.
You got that right. No huger talent. I consider self number 1 fan in universe, my house adorned w Dylan stuff. Saw him 4 times. There will never be a greater genius.
As a college freshman in 1977 I spent countless nights listening to Neil Young. American Stars 'n Bar was released that summer. I played Like a Hurricane over and over.
Man, I was a college freshman in 1977. American Stars and Bars rarely left my turntable! Playing Hurricane over and over!!! Classic. Great taste my friend. Great times!
I agree with you that Bob and Neil are STILL excellent - I'm almost 72, an old hippie, and those 2 are part of the mainstays of music from our generation. And yes, I'm so glad they're still with us and still making great music! Love and Peace!
In honor of my beloved Mom, she passed Nov 16, 2016, Alzheimer's, Helpless fits my Mom's state perfectly, she could do nothing without Help, I miss her everyday so much, 9 years of loving care of Mom, I hope she remembered just a little bit even, her daughter, Cheryl ;-(
In my opinion,the worst thing a person can lose is their memories,but the best thing you can give is your love .You can rest easy,your mother was in good hands.
dear hippiechic, love gets burned on one's soul. she will carry you and your love throughout time. and know this....you are not alone. and we will remember you for her.
hippiechic71 3 years already .The same year my Dad died.Both 😇’s yes she does remember. Her soul did her mind robbed her of memory’s.Its a sad moment in life.She is rejoined with her family.
Neil Young has always been my second favorite musician besides Dylan. His soulful voice and his poetic words bring up so many emotions from the past to my mind from the Viet Nam Era and being a very young married adult in San Francisco with my husband having been Draft age. The late Rick Danko was a gifted accompanist to Dylan and Neil making this a one of a kind performance.
Even though I am now a bit older I thank God I lived in the times of this kind of music! Nothing even compares now. The Music is still the BEST! Helena W Nordgren, Sweden
I discovered this recording a long while ago and really it really helped at a certain time in my life. Great to see that this video still gets traffic and that people listen to this music. I hope that momentum stays for generations to come ❤️
The best place for these old songs is in movies. Then the younger generations will learn what great music is and the songs will be listened to forever. We have get them to listen.
As a teen.. I sang . Help us help us vs helpless lol. It got me past mom's drinking. It's so nice to hear songs that got us through or simply moved our soul. Music today is too manufactured and little is natural talent. Lay lady lay ... blowing in the wind .. good stuff too.
I went to this SNACK Sunday concert at Kezar stadium in SF. I was just a kid. It was only $5 for a ticket. I remember Marlon Brando came out & told us not to do drugs. I didn't realize the significance at the time. I'm now 62 & have great memories of this simple day in the rain.
Gracias, all you folk rockers! I am an old man now and you can still make me cry. Not much time left for us now. May God take us all gently into the night.
I'm with you there, Joe - I'm 74, spending a lonely Sunday night missing my little bride and listening to the music that I grew up with. Its about all we have left now, let's enjoy as long as we can.
Right there with ya! My older brother introduced me to all the BEST MUSIC 🎵 no auto tune in those days and Bob didn't have the best choice not good songs touched my heart. Just lost my brother and he was my rock, listening to the music he showed me is the best therapy tho! God Bless all! 🎵🤗🤩☮️🙏
I was there! I partied all night in Golden Gate Park and was one of the first people in Kezar stadium. I found a spot right in front of the stage and layed on the grass. I fell asleep. When I woke up there was people pressing all around me. There was a sea of people all the way to the top of the stadium and the roofs of the buildings near the stadium. It was one of the best concerts I have ever been to.
With everything in the world these days I think we all just need to listen to real music like this more. Smoke a big joint and reminisce cuz damn life is too short man. Appreciate life while it’s still here
'75 I was a flower child (and still am) and loved these songs, thanks for posting! So proud to see you love our Canadian Neil Young, he has so many messages! Bob Dylan created some of the movement songs that are still relevant to todays turmoil.
Published on my birthday April 13th. Neil Young shaped my life when I was in an Orphanage and I was getting ready for the world. He would be proud of me. I wanted to marry him, he married a pretty celebrity recently!💔
@@2degucitas The song switches from Helpless to Knockin' on beat four of Helpless, which becomes beat two of Knockin' . Its great because the drums have to shift too.
@@TrailheadHaiti there is not that much of a shit tbh cuz both songs work with the same beats and melodies..only played by some different instruments ;) Actually Dylan made Knockin` on to the melodie of helpless..so...
There is a town in North Ontario Dream comfort memory to spare And in my mind I still need a place to go All my changes were there Blue, blue windows behind the stars Yellow moon on the rise Big birds flying across the sky Throwing shadows on our eyes Leave us Helpless, helpless, helpless, helpless Babe, can you hear me now? The chains are locked and tied across the door Baby, sing with me somehow 🎵🎶🎵🎶 Blue, blue windows behind the stars Yellow moon on the rise Big birds flying across the sky Throwing shadows on our eyes Leave us Helpless, helpless, helpless, helpless
I felt a sort of Catharsis (purification of soul) listening to this recording. I'm from the 70s, a "dinosaur", so this is my music. Needless to say anything about modern superficial "music", which is so far away from these masterpieces of 70s. That's one of the best things we can experience in life. This night, while listening to "Helpless" again and again I suddenly burst into tears, which is rare for me, and I was feeling an acute pain for the humanity and all cruelty that's happening in this world, strange and wonderful as it is. Perhaps I shouldn't write this, but I can't restrain myself and withhold my emotion. I'm just trying to share it with other lovers of Music on this planet. This kind of sound makes us better human beings and helps us think about higher matters. It's not possible to explain it, I'm sorry... You can just feel it in the music. We are very small and HELPLESS in front of something that's much more powerful than us. We can just admire this sound. It's mind-blowing how Young and Dylan did this magic... No words can explain this. JUST GREATLY THANKFUL TO YOU, DEAR MASTERS OF SOUND. Hats off... We'd be happy to have the 70s with us forever.
I agree completely ,there is a sort of purification of the mind and spirit that one experiences when listening to them ..unfortunately today there is nothing to compare. We are lucky to have them in our memories and to have lived in the moment when people believed in something other than filling their lives up with consumer junk!!
I was a freshman in HS in 1972. I'm so grateful for the rock and roll I had growing up. My 4 older sisters were into the Beatles, then all of those really great bands. Still digging this during our 2020 summer.
Geezus!! This is Gold! My guys go deep and I’m so lucky to have lived to love them since 1965 in Berkeley until now in 2023 in Los Angeles - Go Neil! 9/20/23 at the Roxy with Crazy Horse!
Not to worry about this music being forgotten, I remind my neighbors every weekend . my stereo back yard parties are back on .Btw covid you're not invited. everyone else welcome...
I can relate. I remember being upset that my parents wouldn't let me hitchhike to the Woodstock ( at 12 years old... :) ). I was so bummed. I just knew I was missing out on something huge!
I was about the same age and I wanted to go to but my Dad "Why the hell would you want to go to see a bunch of long haired hippies?" :) Oh well I got to listen to the Woodstock 3 lp records when they came out.
Neil and Bob are freakin ICON's of 60-70s Music and beyond... I saw Neil once guitar jam vs. Stephen Stills for 50 minutes... Stills Young Band... I believe the building has collapsed 'Hartford Civic Center'... it might be the greatest Guitar concert I have seen except for the Outlaws
Hello, Thanks for your nice comments and supports on my post, it's really means a lot to me, your comments and supports brought me this far, I want you to send me a direct message via hangouts using my personal mail that will be indicated below. Also endeavor to add your name to the text so I can know you are the one texting because I don't reply unnecessary messages. Hangout Mail: bobdylan1753@gmail.com
Yes, time has caught up with some of us. But we still have great taste in fabulous music and artists. Thank you to these amazing artists who helped us grow up !
Two men that never followed the norm. Courageous and unwavering their whole life, kicking down the door for all of US who refuse to have life dictate anything to any of us.
I don't take pleasure in saying this but if you care for the truth check the info out for yourselves. Young has and had a nasty and controlling personality. Bands use to fire him. I loved his music throughout the decades, but knowing what he's like, coupled with his current music? No, 👎🏽 I feel kinda sorry for him now, he looks rough and down on his luck☮️
@@pepperann5766 Neil young was way more talented then that loser Dylan. He did better music, was more diversified and gifted. Dylan was a loser made by Joan Baez. Nobel prize in literature?. Makes me wonder what this country has come too, to give it to that scumbag.
Gosh. If WE are lamenting the loss of good times, can you imagine how Bob Dylan and Neil Young feel today? Both still alive, both living in California (as does Joni Mitchell and Joan Baez). What's ironic is that money was far from the motivating factor back then (not like today.) And yet all four of them became immensely rich. Good for them. They gave us A LOT. Thanks Bob, Neil, Joni and Joan. We love you still.
@@juliet3827 I know you must be surprised to get a reply from me right? Well, i actually opened this account as my official chat account so i can have a little time for my fans and know how some of you feel about me.
@@Officialbobdylan0 Well, "Bob" - I think that after a career spanning six decades and millions of records sold, you already know how people feel about you. Thanks for writing!
No worries, cause bar stools, like the blues, are there to support, what takes us through life. Place a stool, pic a chord, see a smile, Rock and Roll has come a live.
I wish I could say goodbye somehow. We met online when I was 13 and he was gone when I was 36. He was a very tortured person but I could talk to him about anything. I miss him very much. If you check out his favorites videos you can see his love of videos. I just don’t want my friend David to be forgotten.
neil young and bob dylan are simple the best there songs will last for ever i am lucky i can understand there lyrics i learn english when i was 20 and i hear them every day bravo to both of them
Love this grew up in the sixties listening to my older brothers Bob Dylan LP's and then in the 70's bought Neil Young's Harvest, which I listened to over and over again. Awesome that they sing this, one of my favourite songs together.
I was at the show in the picture. It was one of the Best, and I've seen Dylan more than a dozen times. The Band, was stellar, of course, and Neil was at his Neiliest! It was a "best of", show, waaay before they did that, as the three acts traded hits and backed each other flawlessly. Marlon Brando warmed the crowd before their set. It was really amazing.
John Abramson And it was earthly 1975.... Between the mod 60s and the 80s what ever it was.... Speaking of Bob Dylan and Marlon Brando.... I heard at a Chabad Passover sedar in Santa Monica, the Rabbi said Now, Marlon Brando will read the next passage...Then the rabbi asked Bob Dylan to lead in singing.. The other guests were in for a treat.
This song and many others get me thinking about my dad. A very kind a gentle soul that had endured so much heart ache undeserved. And yet he continues to today at 85 to pour love and kindness out to the cold bitter world that lives within the four wall of his little house in Escondido, Ca. Kind hearts endure much.
Beautiful. Two Giants came together ... each with a song in tow and the "songs" became "one" ... and of course the Band could do anything, so it came together to equal = "Beautiful" ... Thanks.
Two giants? How about 5? The Travelling Wilburys: Roy Orbison, Bob Dylan, Tom Petty from the Heartbreakers, Jeff Lynne from ELO, and George Harrison from the Beatles
With all the cookie cutter American Idol lets all sound alike talented "musicians" today...if you didn't experience the GIANTS of 60's and 70's...you missed it...what a RIDE!!!!
Hello, Thanks for your nice comments and supports on my post, it's really means a lot to me, your comments and supports brought me this far, I want you to send me a direct message via hangouts using my personal mail that will be indicated below. Also endeavor to add your name to the text so I can know you are the one texting because I don't reply unnecessary messages. Hangout Mail: bobdylan1753@gmail.com
avoir 20 ans cette année là,cela aurait été un rêve de voir 2 de mes chanteurs préférés ensemble sur une scène.Quels espoirs a cette époque laissait entrevoir leurs chansons :nous étions conscients des problèmes du monde et avide d'amour et d'amitiés diverses,plein de générosité et de respect de la nature sous toutes ses formes...qu'avons nous fait de nos rêves a courir pour notre bien-être égoistement.Aujourd'hui nous laissons a nos enfants un monde en détresse...puissent ils nous pardonner et trouver les solutions.
I heard this the song Helpless on casette tape in "72 when a friend hiked up where we were staying Big Sur, a trail takes you up , it's kinda steep, and there's water and a place to camp out, I was only 19 and we all listened to Helpless and the rest of that Album from Neil Young, a friend brought a cassette player and tape, with and batteries I thought I'd died and gone to heaven lol, listening to that up in the quiet outside out in the open
1975, I got Drafted to go to Viet Nam. Talk about be "Helpless". I joined the USAF and luck be with me, I was sent to Northern Japan. Thank the Almighty, I am still around and not "knocking on heavens doors". Over 50K took the one way walk, I feel so lucky and so sad. My Mother, love of my Life, Dementia, 100% helpless, it was a horrible sight, to see someone you loved strapped to a wheelchair and not knowing you. Thank the Almighty, She is with my Father and in my World, the two of Them did not have to Knock On Heaven's Doors but for a short rap. I feel like crying.
I become a folk rock musician because of these 2 folk rock gods. I just love both of them, i played both songs all the time, all i need a couple of beers , my Orchestra Model Takamine Pro Series Acoustic guitar and my other lover A Taylor Grand Concert Cut Away Guitar will make my day.
@@TripReviews he was a great singer songwriter probably one of the best poets in the music scene along with Dylan and Neil Young. But Bob Dylan is probably the most important and influential artist along with the Beatles.
@@elston3153 funny that when o was a young kid I liked the Beetles, probably because the adults despised them. As time went on and their music changed I wasn’t a fan of them. Dylan no doubt a big nog influence, but Young’s music had something about it. The story behind his songs, that’s why I say since Dylan has been named the great American poet then Young should could be named the great Canadian…. But that’s all a matter of personal,taste and opinions. Cheers🍻
Well I was only 5 years old in 1975 but that's what's so Awesum about Utube Eh Folks I can listen to these amazing concerts and close my eyes and just imagine how amazing this show must have been.... Love Dylan and Young
When love comes from music the heart respond with the pureness that is from the souls of the singers thank you for the life I live with your music to fulfill it! Bob and Neil will always be with us !!
These songs bring back great memories of being a child in the early 70s. Our house always had these albums on the turntable, along with so many great artists from that era. 🎶 🎵 🪕 🎼 🎸 🎸 🎸
Hello, Thanks for your nice comments and supports on my post, it's really means a lot to me, your comments and supports brought me this far, I want you to send me a direct message via hangouts using my personal mail that will be indicated below. Also endeavor to add your name to the text so I can know you are the one texting because I don't reply unnecessary messages. Hangout Mail: bobdylan1753@gmail.com
![Bob Dylan - Hurricane (Live on PBS, 1975) [RARE ORIGINAL AUDIO]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/voH11xV4AKI/mqdefault.jpg)
Even though I am now old I thank God I lived in the times of this kind of music! Nothing even compares now.
@@russellfeldman8819 Ten Bears!!!
Exact !!
I think we're younger in spirit than young people today.
I subscribe with my blood
Falling in love, the good kind of helpless.
i dont like growing old ,but then again ,i wouldnt ever want to have missed this era for anything even if i could be young again.
'total truth 🎵🎶🙏🥀💜
So well said! I'm 50 and I absolutely agree! Much love and light to you and to all!
Brothers life it's numbers. The key is to stay young forever with aches and pains but you are a step ahead of falling and not letting the last stage come any where near you. Amen 🙏
If i were young (50) i would have missed both of these guys when they were young.
The canucks should make neil president, wish we could...
@@johnherrmann5261 Are “canucks” Canadians?
I've heard these songs 100's of times since they were first released and they are just as good today and they were 50 years ago.
Oh yes...!
More so
i am to
1000 years from now in a galaxy far away i guarantee this will be on their playlists...
Yep. These musicians don’t come around much these days. 😞
Bob and Neil. My two favorites. I love that they were totally indifferant to what people expected. They were not bought and sold.
last waltz sic movie too legends the band most underrated rockers greatest Robbie danko jamming with Neil god bless all USA rules summer gonna rock
Exactly the true Greats of a long beautiful ride in our musical era. Singing truths and poetry
La. Pop. Dans. Sont. Excellence..!!!.???...
Never again.was a way of life.I lived it still am at 66 yrs old.
@@waynemoore5467 What I wouldn't give to go back to those simpler, slower, purer, more peaceful times. Wish so much I couldv'e know them both. Will always love Neil and Bob.
They will never get old in the hearts of all us old time hippies!!!!
Music is hearts!!!
AMEN..
Sooo true !! Thanks !!
Yes you are soo right. I am 69 feel the same I hear anyone of these guys.
Amen sister, Amen!!!😎😉🎤🎵
Two of the best songwriters in history share a stage.
3, if you include whomever you want from The Band.
Truer words were never spoken ! ................
joni mitchell?
Always knew that Neil and Bob were buddies but never actually heard them play together. This is great!
Bob Dylan wielding his two edged sword just like so many times before. I love this prophet and priest of The Most High.
Marlon Brando made the presentation at this Snack Festival 1975 and said : The sentiment here today is worth more than all the fuckin' money in the world .
I cannot imagine what my life would have been like if Bob Dylan had not been there to express in poetry and music my every mood. I love every song, every performance from 'Nam in the mid-1960's to today.. He's incomparable.
Agree. I was raised by garbage, but I have some morals and humanity from listening to Young and Dylan.
8u
@@zen9571
Lekkerouderwetsnummertke
You got that right. No huger talent. I consider self number 1 fan in universe, my house adorned w Dylan stuff. Saw him 4 times. There will never be a greater genius.
❤❤❤
The classics never go away. Music is just not as good as it used to be.🎶🎸
I think every generation says that! What did your parents think of your tastes in music..out of curiosity?
I am happy to be still alive to listen to some of my favourites..❤
I was 15 when I saw this show. I'm turning 63 today and I love it more than ever. Knockin on the Dragon's door indeed!
me too, music, really music is the only reason not to give up👍
The two greatest rock poets of my generation,thank you for so many magical songs!
Wish we could relive those days! "Rock"at its finest! Took my son and wife up to Reno in 2008-10 to see them both, brought back memories!
Don't forget Lou reed
As a college freshman in 1977 I spent countless nights listening to Neil Young. American Stars 'n Bar was released that summer. I played Like a Hurricane over and over.
Man, I was a college freshman in 1977. American Stars and Bars rarely left my turntable! Playing Hurricane over and over!!! Classic. Great taste my friend. Great times!
I agree with you that Bob and Neil are STILL excellent - I'm almost 72, an old hippie, and those 2 are part of the mainstays of music from our generation. And yes, I'm so glad they're still with us and still making great music! Love and Peace!
Neil Young... what a voice...special... unique... great talent... thanks for the best music of all time... '60's /'70's were the absolute ultimate...
In honor of my beloved Mom, she passed Nov 16, 2016, Alzheimer's, Helpless fits my Mom's state perfectly, she could do nothing without Help, I miss her everyday so much, 9 years of loving care of Mom, I hope she remembered just a little bit even, her daughter, Cheryl ;-(
In my opinion,the worst thing a person can lose is their memories,but the best thing you can give is your love .You can rest easy,your mother was in good hands.
dear hippiechic, love gets burned on one's soul. she will carry you and your love throughout time. and know this....you are not alone. and we will remember you for her.
your mum was lucky to have you and all the love you gave her!
hippiechic71 3 years already .The same year my Dad died.Both 😇’s yes she does remember. Her soul did her mind robbed her of memory’s.Its a sad moment in life.She is rejoined with her family.
OMG no concert footage so cool
1975 seemed like only yesterday , but a lot has sadly changed since then .... ☮️🎸🏁
may you stay forever young
@@41nakamura ♥️🎖😎🏄♂️🎸
Neil Young has always been my second favorite musician besides Dylan. His soulful voice and his poetic words bring up so many emotions from the past to my mind from the Viet Nam Era and being a very young married adult in San Francisco with my husband having been Draft age. The late Rick Danko was a gifted accompanist to Dylan and Neil making this a one of a kind performance.
Classics! Thank God they made it through to old age and didn't give up. Bob and Neil will leave a legacy forever
So far out man way cool man
Best fucking shit ever.
Oh yess!!
Agreed brother! They do not make jews like Dylan anymore!
God ain’t got nothing to do with it, anymore than Chevrolet.
NOTHING IN THE WORLD CAN BRING THESE DAYS BACK HOW THESE TUNES WILL LIVE ON 4 EVER PEACE AND LOVE
Two musicians who had a very similar sound at one time but live they are completely different, Neil puts so much energy into his performances.
Time itself is irretrievable
So right, and the feeling they bring.
Forever young.
Two legends and I was fortunate enough to see them in their and my prime. Thank you guys. This is music ❤
what talent musicians,! GOD BLESS NEIL an BOB
Even though I am now a bit older I thank God I lived in the times of this kind of music! Nothing even compares now. The Music is still the BEST! Helena W Nordgren, Sweden
Thanks. Wlov. Va. Usa
Two greats singing their hearts out for you. Both are classic legends. We love you Mr Neil. ❤❤❤
Ja
Hello Sharon
How are you doing?
It's nice to have you here!
I discovered this recording a long while ago and really it really helped at a certain time in my life. Great to see that this video still gets traffic and that people listen to this music. I hope that momentum stays for generations to come ❤️
Amazing!
The best place for these old songs is in movies. Then the younger generations will learn what great music is and the songs will be listened to forever. We have get them to listen.
Bob Dylan, Neil Young....the battle in my mind. I love them both so much💞 I don't understand those that don't get them.
As a teen.. I sang . Help us help us vs helpless lol. It got me past mom's drinking.
It's so nice to hear songs that got us through or simply moved our soul.
Music today is too manufactured and little is natural talent.
Lay lady lay ... blowing in the wind .. good stuff too.
I went to this SNACK Sunday concert at Kezar stadium in SF. I was just a kid. It was only $5 for a ticket. I remember Marlon Brando came out & told us not to do drugs. I didn't realize the significance at the time. I'm now 62 & have great memories of this simple day in the rain.
That's the kind of day that comes only once in a lifetime. Seems like everyday back then was that freakin special.
Gracias, all you folk rockers! I am an old man now and you can still make me cry.
Not much time left for us now.
May God take us all gently into the night.
I'm with you there, Joe - I'm 74, spending a lonely Sunday night missing my little bride and listening to the music that I grew up with. Its about all we have left now, let's enjoy as long as we can.
Right there with ya! My older brother introduced me to all the BEST MUSIC 🎵 no auto tune in those days and Bob didn't have the best choice not good songs touched my heart. Just lost my brother and he was my rock, listening to the music he showed me is the best therapy tho! God Bless all! 🎵🤗🤩☮️🙏
Edit: Dylan had such good words, but not the best"VOICE" ,(swipe typing and didn't proof read). Lol
@@debrajones9741 I will listen again today and perhaps shed a tear for you and your brother. Thank You and I'll pray God might comfort your soul.
@@joejean210 t thanks. You're very kind....
I was there! I partied all night in Golden Gate Park and was one of the first people in Kezar stadium. I found a spot right in front of the stage and layed on the grass. I fell asleep. When I woke up there was people pressing all around me. There was a sea of people all the way to the top of the stadium and the roofs of the buildings near the stadium. It was one of the best concerts I have ever been to.
Must have been a good one if you fell asleep, Joe!
I fell asleep as the stadium was filling up. Dumb ass.
Don't insult my burro! Where I come from them's fighting' words....
You don't look like you can move too fast, Joe.
TheDimachaerus lmao
With everything in the world these days I think we all just need to listen to real music like this more. Smoke a big joint and reminisce cuz damn life is too short man. Appreciate life while it’s still here
I don,t need a Joint. I,m 66 and still happy with this music
Right On brother Derek
I'm desperate for a big fat joint, I NEED ONE 😆
@@tangoliberty2344 where are you let's smoke one
Perfect man.
'75 I was a flower child (and still am) and loved these songs, thanks for posting! So proud to see you love our Canadian Neil Young, he has so many messages! Bob Dylan created some of the movement songs that are still relevant to todays turmoil.
at age 72, i am still enjoying this video...i was at the concert in 1975
Published on my birthday April 13th. Neil Young shaped my life when I was in an Orphanage and I was getting ready for the world. He would be proud of me. I wanted to marry him, he married a pretty celebrity recently!💔
The transition from one song to the other is so perfect you don't even realize what happened at first. The Band are as good as you get.
Love the steel guitar.
@@2degucitas The song switches from Helpless to Knockin' on beat four of Helpless, which becomes beat two of Knockin' . Its great because the drums have to shift too.
@@TrailheadHaiti there is not that much of a shit tbh cuz both songs work with the same beats and melodies..only played by some different instruments ;) Actually Dylan made Knockin` on to the melodie of helpless..so...
@@2degucitas do you know who is playing it?
Don’t you wish you could finesse a lady that smooth lol
There is a town in North Ontario
Dream comfort memory to spare
And in my mind I still need a place to go
All my changes were there
Blue, blue windows behind the stars
Yellow moon on the rise
Big birds flying across the sky
Throwing shadows on our eyes
Leave us
Helpless, helpless, helpless, helpless
Babe, can you hear me now?
The chains are locked and tied across the door
Baby, sing with me somehow
🎵🎶🎵🎶
Blue, blue windows behind the stars
Yellow moon on the rise
Big birds flying across the sky
Throwing shadows on our eyes
Leave us
Helpless, helpless, helpless, helpless
I think I hear Rick Danko‘s voice in there too.
Two musicians who had a very similar sound at one time but live they are completely different, Neil puts so much energy into his performances.
I felt a sort of Catharsis (purification of soul) listening to this recording. I'm from the 70s, a "dinosaur", so this is my music. Needless to say anything about modern superficial "music", which is so far away from these masterpieces of 70s. That's one of the best things we can experience in life. This night, while listening to "Helpless" again and again I suddenly burst into tears, which is rare for me, and I was feeling an acute pain for the humanity and all cruelty that's happening in this world, strange and wonderful as it is. Perhaps I shouldn't write this, but I can't restrain myself and withhold my emotion. I'm just trying to share it with other lovers of Music on this planet. This kind of sound makes us better human beings and helps us think about higher matters. It's not possible to explain it, I'm sorry... You can just feel it in the music. We are very small and HELPLESS in front of something that's much more powerful than us. We can just admire this sound. It's mind-blowing how Young and Dylan did this magic... No words can explain this. JUST GREATLY THANKFUL TO YOU, DEAR MASTERS OF SOUND. Hats off... We'd be happy to have the 70s with us forever.
yes hats off to the stranger for telling us!
Solaris Nord ... I share your feelings, and I am SO grateful these two are still around and making new music!
I agree completely ,there is a sort of purification of the mind and spirit that one experiences when listening to them ..unfortunately today there is nothing to compare. We are lucky to have them in our memories and to have lived in the moment when people believed in something other than filling their lives up with consumer junk!!
amen!
Thank you for validating the solarity grief/joy I feel when I hear these magical songs from a magical time.
I was a freshman in HS in 1972. I'm so grateful for the rock and roll I had growing up. My 4 older sisters were into the Beatles, then all of those really great bands. Still digging this during our 2020 summer.
In 1975 I was working in a dead-end job as a Mechanical Engineer. It was music like this from Dylan and Young that kept me alive
This still does this to me at this day.
Mechanical engineer dead end job?
what happened next?
Michael Resch, why are you catfishing with that profile pic, main man?? 🤔🤔
Shouldn't it look like 👴👴👴
Right on
Geezus!! This is Gold! My guys go deep and I’m so lucky to have lived to love them since 1965 in Berkeley until now in 2023 in Los Angeles - Go Neil! 9/20/23 at the Roxy with Crazy Horse!
Hello Suzanne
How are you doing?
It's nice to have you here!
Not to worry about this music being forgotten, I remind my neighbors every weekend . my stereo back yard parties are back on .Btw covid you're not invited. everyone else welcome...
I wish I hadn't been 4 years old at the time. Couldn't find anyone to give me a ride to the show, damn it.
hahaha .. love it
I can relate. I remember being upset that my parents wouldn't let me hitchhike to the Woodstock ( at 12 years old... :) ). I was so bummed. I just knew I was missing out on something huge!
Too bad I'm 60 and bound to miss some great concerts you will get to. It might not be Neil and Bob but something will stir your soul.
Iv never thought of it this way... thank you Jim!
I was about the same age and I wanted to go to but my Dad "Why the hell would you want to go to see a bunch of long haired hippies?" :) Oh well I got to listen to the Woodstock 3 lp records when they came out.
Neil and Bob are freakin ICON's of 60-70s Music and beyond... I saw Neil once guitar jam vs. Stephen Stills for 50 minutes... Stills Young Band... I believe the building has collapsed 'Hartford Civic Center'... it might be the greatest Guitar concert I have seen except for the Outlaws
Two of my favorite songs from the two greatest artist singing and playing them
Blue, blue windows behind the stars,
Yellow moon on the rise,
Big birds flying across the sky,
Throwing shadows on our eyes.
Hi Leonard! My father was Leonard Dixon too, and he was a helluva guy! Joseph Leonard Dixon
Without this beautiful music and my Gramma Eva I wouldn't be here life is worth the journey
Hello, Thanks for your nice comments and supports on my post, it's really means a lot to me, your comments and supports brought me this far, I want you to send me a direct message via hangouts using my personal mail that will be indicated below. Also endeavor to add your name to the text so I can know you are the one texting because I don't reply unnecessary messages.
Hangout Mail: bobdylan1753@gmail.com
I was about 15. All my friends and I went to the Snack concert. We still mention it from time to time.
Dylan and Young best storytellers ever, and their music is Heavenly.🌿🎶
Lot of persons in morocco loves Neil young songs thanks neil
People are legends before dying for a reason, bless all like minded people because at the end it's about u
Helpless. One of the best songs ever. Knockin' on Heaven's door. Another one of the best ever. Brilliant combination!
Yes, time has caught up with some of us. But we still have great taste in fabulous music and artists. Thank you to these amazing artists who helped us grow up !
Two men that never followed the norm. Courageous and unwavering their whole life, kicking down the door for all of US who refuse to have life dictate anything to any of us.
I don't take pleasure in saying this but if you care for the truth check the info out for yourselves. Young has and had a nasty and controlling personality. Bands use to fire him. I loved his music throughout the decades, but knowing what he's like, coupled with his current music? No, 👎🏽 I feel kinda sorry for him now, he looks rough and down on his luck☮️
Far out man
@@pepperann5766 Neil young was way more talented then that loser Dylan. He did better music, was more diversified and gifted. Dylan was a loser made by Joan Baez. Nobel prize in literature?. Makes me wonder what this country has come too, to give it to that scumbag.
@@dananderson3410 da
and they add new words to the norm versions--but I can't hear them clearly can you tell me what these new words are?
This has got to be my favorite of the obscure recordings I've come across on youtube. Hope someday someone posts the whole concert.
Punk was still a rumour . Bob , Neil Young and Santana really mattered in a way they havent since 1978 .
Gosh. If WE are lamenting the loss of good times, can you imagine how Bob Dylan and Neil Young feel today? Both still alive, both living in California (as does Joni Mitchell and Joan Baez). What's ironic is that money was far from the motivating factor back then (not like today.) And yet all four of them became immensely rich. Good for them. They gave us A LOT. Thanks Bob, Neil, Joni and Joan. We love you still.
Hello Juliet
How are you doing?
It's nice to have you here!
@@Officialbobdylan0 Thanks. Who are you?
@@juliet3827 I know you must be surprised to get a reply from me right?
Well, i actually opened this account as my official chat account so i can have a little time for my fans and know how some of you feel about me.
@@Officialbobdylan0 Well, "Bob" - I think that after a career spanning six decades and millions of records sold, you already know how people feel about you. Thanks for writing!
@@juliet3827 that's cool 💝,
Where are you commenting from and how long have you been a fan?
🔊It's Neil and Bob can i say anymore!!! The greats songwriters/singers of our times🎶
Peace
Katharine Renner hello
You forget Sir Van Morrison!
Been listening to Bob Dyland and Niel Young for over 60 years. Amazing and I love it.
No worries, cause bar stools, like the blues, are there to support, what takes us through life. Place a stool, pic a chord, see a smile, Rock and Roll has come a live.
Pure legends. utmost respect.
Greatest music ever made , greatest artist to grace this planet !! 60's ,70's ,80's !!!
This channels creator loved Neil Young and classic rock in general. He passed away a year ago. RIP David.
I wish I could say goodbye somehow. We met online when I was 13 and he was gone when I was 36. He was a very tortured person but I could talk to him about anything. I miss him very much. If you check out his favorites videos you can see his love of videos. I just don’t want my friend David to be forgotten.
You can see his love of music I mean. Oops
first heard this 1976 ❤️takes me right back to my youth to my friends that are no longer here 💔 to the good times may they last my friends
Early 70s while i was studying Chemical Engineering this song was my favorite now iam a grandpa and still listening to this classic.
Absolutely brilliant! Two musical legends together!
neil young and bob dylan are simple the best there songs will last for ever i am lucky i can understand there lyrics i learn english when i was 20 and i hear them every day bravo to both of them
Neil Young. Hail too the 60's. Universal music, I don't know anyone that doesn't like music from the 60's !✌
Love this grew up in the sixties listening to my older brothers Bob Dylan LP's and then in the 70's bought Neil Young's Harvest, which I listened to over and over again. Awesome that they sing this, one of my favourite songs together.
All my boys together.....made our lives sooooo much richer! What a ride its been!
I was at the show in the picture. It was one of the Best, and I've seen Dylan more than a dozen times. The Band, was stellar, of course, and Neil was at his Neiliest! It was a "best of", show, waaay before they did that, as the three acts traded hits and backed each other flawlessly. Marlon Brando warmed the crowd before their set. It was really amazing.
John Abramson b cnn
John Abramson
And it was earthly 1975....
Between the mod 60s and the 80s what ever it was....
Speaking of Bob Dylan and Marlon Brando....
I heard at a Chabad Passover sedar in Santa Monica, the Rabbi said Now, Marlon Brando will read the next passage...Then the rabbi asked Bob Dylan to lead in singing..
The other guests were in for a treat.
Thanks for Sharing That John!! Wow! You are so Fortunate to have been at that Show!! Would have loved to have seen it Live!!! Best, Ray!!!
Danielchai S
John Abramson
This song and many others get me thinking about my dad. A very kind a gentle soul that had endured so much heart ache undeserved. And yet he continues to today at 85 to pour love and kindness out to the cold bitter world that lives within the four wall of his little house in Escondido, Ca. Kind hearts endure much.
This is not pop, this is heaven. Spiritual.
Estou em FLORIPA numa sacada com a lua cheia curtindo este som! 65 anos agradecidos a estes mestres!
Beautiful. Two Giants came together
... each with a song in tow and the "songs" became "one" ... and of course the Band could do anything, so it came together to equal = "Beautiful" ... Thanks.
Two giants? How about 5? The Travelling Wilburys: Roy Orbison, Bob Dylan, Tom Petty from the Heartbreakers, Jeff Lynne from ELO, and George Harrison from the Beatles
Beautiful
Beautiful
in my mind, I still need a place to go.all my changes were there...
+Gary Garren Don't forget The Band
With all the cookie cutter American Idol lets all sound alike talented "musicians" today...if you didn't experience the GIANTS of 60's and 70's...you missed it...what a RIDE!!!!
I think that the guys don't realize how their songs reached our hearts I listen all the time so awesome
Life is GOOD.. got my Dylan in my ear 👂
Thank you brother
Hello, Thanks for your nice comments and supports on my post, it's really means a lot to me, your comments and supports brought me this far, I want you to send me a direct message via hangouts using my personal mail that will be indicated below. Also endeavor to add your name to the text so I can know you are the one texting because I don't reply unnecessary messages.
Hangout Mail: bobdylan1753@gmail.com
avoir 20 ans cette année là,cela aurait été un rêve de voir 2 de mes chanteurs préférés ensemble sur une scène.Quels espoirs a cette époque laissait entrevoir leurs chansons :nous étions conscients des problèmes du monde et avide d'amour et d'amitiés diverses,plein de générosité et de respect de la nature sous toutes ses formes...qu'avons nous fait de nos rêves a courir pour notre bien-être égoistement.Aujourd'hui nous laissons a nos enfants un monde en détresse...puissent ils nous pardonner et trouver les solutions.
I heard this the song Helpless on casette tape in "72 when a friend hiked up where we were staying Big Sur, a trail takes you up , it's kinda steep, and there's water and a place to camp out, I was only 19 and we all listened to Helpless and the rest of that Album from Neil Young, a friend brought a cassette player and tape, with and batteries I thought I'd died and gone to heaven lol, listening to that up in the quiet outside out in the open
I’m not very old but still love the oldies,my wish is that the our kids will find a way to continue the classics
They will, baby :D I'm still loving the classics from 1800's 20's 30's 40's They're not going anywhere! :D
1975, I got Drafted to go to Viet Nam. Talk about be "Helpless". I joined the USAF and luck be with me, I was sent to Northern Japan. Thank the Almighty, I am still around and not "knocking on heavens doors". Over 50K took the one way walk, I feel so lucky and so sad. My Mother, love of my Life, Dementia, 100% helpless, it was a horrible sight, to see someone you loved strapped to a wheelchair and not knowing you. Thank the Almighty, She is with my Father and in my World, the two of Them did not have to Knock On Heaven's Doors but for a short rap. I feel like crying.
Bless
I become a folk rock musician because of these 2 folk rock gods. I just love both of them, i played both songs all the time, all i need a couple of beers , my Orchestra Model Takamine Pro Series Acoustic guitar and my other lover A Taylor Grand Concert Cut Away Guitar will make my day.
These musicians not only shaped my love of music, their music helped shape my life.
Helpless made my heart ache . Thank lord I lived in these days .
Dylan, the great American poet.......Neil Young, the great Canadian poet. Both together such a fantastic meeting.
I think Leonard Cohen would have something to say about that.
@@elston3153 I could say that of I liked him, never heard of him until he passed away. May he r.I.p
@@TripReviews he was a great singer songwriter probably one of the best poets in the music scene along with Dylan and Neil Young. But Bob Dylan is probably the most important and influential artist along with the Beatles.
@@elston3153 funny that when o was a young kid I liked the Beetles, probably because the adults despised them. As time went on and their music changed I wasn’t a fan of them. Dylan no doubt a big nog influence, but Young’s music had something about it. The story behind his songs, that’s why I say since Dylan has been named the great American poet then Young should could be named the great Canadian…. But that’s all a matter of personal,taste and opinions. Cheers🍻
I would have loved seeing this concert. Saw Dylan years ago. Saw Neil Young years ago...But never saw them together!
Well I was only 5 years old in 1975 but that's what's so Awesum about Utube Eh Folks I can listen to these amazing concerts and close my eyes and just imagine how amazing this show must have been.... Love Dylan and Young
Nobody comes close to these two legends. Absolutely stunning
When love comes from music the heart respond with the pureness that is from the souls of the singers thank you for the life I live with your music to fulfill it! Bob and Neil will always be with us !!
So grateful I lived in this era of the best music ever to be written!
nothing beats pure, genuine and original rockers
@ dante Salvador
Couldn't agree with you more.
Truth.
Long live the young .. the good die young . We.just lost my mother in law rip mammi.
Their writings have brought peace to people of the world that no military force could ever hope to achieve.
I grew up with this in the 80s and 90s because my dad was an (ex) hippie. All the classics from the 60s and early 70s were on the playlist.
These songs bring back great memories of being a child in the early 70s. Our house always had these albums on the turntable, along with so many great artists from that era. 🎶 🎵 🪕 🎼 🎸 🎸 🎸
Hello, Thanks for your nice comments and supports on my post, it's really means a lot to me, your comments and supports brought me this far, I want you to send me a direct message via hangouts using my personal mail that will be indicated below. Also endeavor to add your name to the text so I can know you are the one texting because I don't reply unnecessary messages.
Hangout Mail: bobdylan1753@gmail.com
I was there with my friend Glenda who sadly is passed away but what a great time we had!
OH TO BE AT KEZAR STADIUM AND 20 YRS OLD again. GREAT DAY IN GOLDEN GATE PARK. thanks for posting this
Heaven is always on our minds ❤🙏