Goal Horn Battle NHL17 Vs. 2k11
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 фев 2025
- While going through my collection of older games I stumbled across my copy of NHL 2k11 for the Wii. I wondered how good 2k was at making goal horns. It then turned into this video.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Notes:
-Songs were not taken into account.
-If a horn had changed in the time since NHL 2k11 was released it was not included in this video.
-These are my opinions.
-Horn blast patterns were also not taken into account (aside from Dallas).
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time Stamps:
Anaheim- 00:19
Arizona- 01:09
Boston- 01:48
Buffalo- 02:23
Calgary- 03:01
Carolina- 03:38
Chicago- 04:11
Colorado- 04:50
Columbus- 05:23
Dallas- 05:56 (2 Videos of 2k to demonstrate their implementation of the number of goals=number of blasts pattern)
Detroit- 06:53
Edmonton- 07:33
Florida- 08:05
Los Angeles- 08:47
Minnesota- 09:29
Nashville- 10:07
New Jersey- 10:39
New York (I)- 11:20
New York (R)- 12:01
Ottawa- 12:36
Philadelphia- 13:11
Pittsburgh- 13:42
San Jose- 14:18
St. Louis- 14:50
Tampa Bay- 15:23
Toronto- 16:04
Washington- 16:32
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Final Score:
2k:7
EA:16
Too Close To Call:4
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Song: Welcome to the Jungle-Guns N' Roses(Pep Band)
Next-gen NHL 2K would be lit.
#BringbackNHL2K
ChubNTuck 😈😈😈😈😈😈😈😈😈💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩
I fell for that hashtag and now I’m mad.
Yes! There needs to be an NHL game on the Nintendo Switch. Come on, 2K! Bring back the good old days of playing NHL 2K10 on the Wii!
@@CMac64JayCee123 no
Despite the inaccuracies, EA's horns are just too quiet imo...
Hooded Especially the ducks goal horn.
Unstumpable Trumpable wow. You mean especially the Capitals one
O let’s talk about how you can’t hear a cannon going off in an inclosed building....(blue jackets)
But that’s a slider you can change...
@@mr.cactus9496 Most people don't have the attention span for the options menu. I'm sure you can tell by my profile pic that I do though.
Vancouver and Montreal were not included because their horns changed after NHL 2k11 was released so it wouldn't be remotely fair to compare them. Winnipeg wasn't included because they didn't exist in NHL 2k11.
Not 2 Bohrium Goal Horns what about wiping
Colin Picon at the time, they were the Atlanta thrashers
What about the Vancouver Canucks and Montreal Canadians?
N2B Goal Horns What hockey team do you like?
N2B Goal Horns You could have compared based on how well 2k did Atlanta’s horn and see if EA did a better representation of Winnipeg’s
Minnesota's horn is actually correct in the 2k version. I can't believe that EA still hasn't gotten it right over the years.
Same as Florida's horn. the EXACT same horn.
Oh my god Ikr.
I don't understand why they can't get it right.
Because EA is shit in making horns
2K as the right horn but 2K drags it out where EA plays it at the right stop and go, stop and go again.
3:39 is the most realistic goal I've ever seen, NHL or not.
12:37 is also fairly accurate
DarkReaperz 😂
yep.
DarkReaperz that is true
DarkReaperz 4:11 is even better
I miss the days of NHL2K. These were the golden years !!
Same here, I like NHL2K better then NHL EA Sports because the shooting and passing is easy for pressing buttons. Shooting and passing with the analog sticks for NHL EA Sports is horrible
2K's sound like the old school goal horn recordings from RUclips's early days.
And I love that for no reason.
I think it may have been the other way around, with some of those videos getting the horn sounds from the game.
should have done 2k 11 and nhl 11
I love how the net physics actually work in 2k11 but not even in NHL 19
In NHL 2K11 the net doesn't move but has real physics that you would see in the daily basis
To be fair, when the Penguins moved into CONSOL Energy Center they made the horn sound less raspy, so that's why there is a considerable difference.
A lot of the 2k ones I noticed have a more crisp realistic sound which you hear especially with buffalo
2k should of won for LA Kings. Iv been to Kings games and the 2k one sounds the closet to it.
Hello Grif
I agree. The EA one sounds weak
As a Kings fan I definitely agree. It sounds very similar, and it’s actually an exact copy of the Milwaukee Admirals horn
I think the flames wasn't scored right. Over the years it has kind of changed. In 2011 it sounded exactly the way it was in NHL 2k11 and today it sounds exactly line in NHL17 so to say that EA is correct might be a little off.
Same with st louis
Same with San Jose
12:41 - What a goal...
Sucks though 2k will never make another NHL game
zombieguy1987 never know.
zombieguy1987 imagine
I do know since EA has a monopoly on NHL games since 2010
The Blackhawks 2K goal horn was from the earlier 2003-2008 days. And still can't believe FOR almost 30 years of existence, EA still hasn't cracked the Blackhawks goal horn. Or Wild (even though they didn't exist for 30 years), or Islanders, or Panthers, or Sharks.
Same with the goal songs: **LOOKING AT THE DETROIT RED WINGS EA GOAL SONG**
Nhl2k11 goal horns were the best man I miss the old nhl games
2k makes the goal horn sound like its coming from someones house but EA makes it sound like its in the arena
Love how you had Ovi scoring both goals cx
at least 2k got the arena name for the coyotes right
As an Avs fan, it hurts to have my teams goal horn done wrong every year haha
2k11 almost looks like it would be on the original XBOX or PS2.
Nolan Kadinger Because I'm pretty sure this 2K was on the Wii
true
2k10 was on the PS2 and that had better graphics. Ik because of the hours I put into that game
Soviet Re4per lmao same
Nolan Kadinger key number 11
0:25 brings back memories playing NHL 2K11
5:26 sounds like the toronto blue jays home run horn
2K was my favorite game as a younger kid.
The LA horn is the exact recording the Admirals use. Or at least, it sounds identical.
I like the old Nashville predators logo.
most of the horns from 2k11 were the teams old horns back in in 2005 or 2008 why not do Winnipeg jets?
They didn't exist in 2k11
TRASHers
swoot toot III the jets did exist in 2011
Parker Rhode They started at the 2011-2012 season i beleive
HUNDRED BEAST KAIDO Great job. You made yourself look stupid and ignorant at the same time with only one comment.
2k hockey games were more fun in my opinion.
13:14 Just an slightly extended, edited version of 2k's St. Louis horn!!
Best part is that you can add new goal horns to replace the old ones in 2k. EA you can't.
NHL 2k7 for Xbox 360 an PS3 had the most realistic goal horns ever.
Some of these teams have different goal horns so I mean of course the current year game sounds closer
I think 2K should've beaten EA for the Capitals goal horn
JP Nics 11 no its just because capital's goal horn changed
ELeCtro now it sounds like the panther's with a siren
So glad that the last version of 2K was the season the Bruins won the Cup
Younus Bendame why
I’m confused how does EA win in the Columbus comparison? You can’t even hear the cannon going off...
Strange comparison, however these coincidentally are the only nhl game I own
It’s funny how 2k11 has better kinda horns then NHL17
Buffalos horn and siren in 2K sounds like one of those air raid horns in Britain in World war 2
This is awesome thanks for doing this
5:44 that Blue Jackets horn sounds different than the one in NHL 17.
the horn has changed that is why.
Gotta say the Kings horn in 2k is MILES better than the one in NHL17, it’s not close
I love Buffalo so much the goal horn sounds like 2007 and the siren is the best one in this video
Finally someone did it
i used to score so much from right in front of the net on 2K11. just flick the wii stick and it would go in. it's funny, back on that game, i used to like to go down instead of up on the screen.
Bay Area Gaming what was your your gamer tag on the wii?
I think the Sharks one for 2k sounds better
DA Ruiz I agree! Coming from a Sharks fan
The Florida panthers 2K11 goal horn sounds like the Blackhawks goal horn
In 2k nine the Boston horn was the old train horn
NHL 2k11 was the 1st hockey game I had
jackson weaver same
Good idea. But I think Chicago and Columbus used to be slightly different before.
Columbus just had a different start before and Chicago's was changed(new compressor and solenoid valve) in 2009 so 2k had time to make it correct
I like how people judge ea when they actually go to the arena and record it.
Because the Ducks, Capitals and Blackhawks sound so accurate
Can’t forget Florida and the Wild.
14:00 is definitely the better of the two.
You did Dallas twice in 2k.
Because when they scored multiple times, they blast the horn 3 or 5 times if they scored 3 or 5 times
on the blues goal horn the 2k11 version is the same as the 2k10 version. ea sports got it rite it jus needs to be a tad bit louder so u can actually hear it and the crowd at the same time
Why is it so freaking hard for EA to get Colorado's goal horn right. It sounds like shit
Detroit Red Wings 2K horn is the one they had from 95-2004, which actually sounds better but EA has the modern one.
Does anyone know the song in goal horns from nhl2k11, such as Buffalo's and Calgary's?
the blue jackets had a different horn in 2011, they changed it in like 2012 or 2013 I think
*achievement unlocked* Btw, great vid
2:08 that's a tip in not a one timer
Patrick Kane's mug in 2k11.
RIP
imo.....
Anaheim: tie
Arizona: 2k
Boston: tie
Buffalo: too close to call
Calgary: EA
Carolina: tie
Chicago: tie
Columbus: EA
Colorado: tie
Dallas: too close to call
Detroit: EA
Edmonton: tie
Florida: EA
Los Angeles: too close to call
Minnesota: tie
Nashville: EA
New Jersey: tie
Uniondale Islanders: tie
City Rangers: EA [Would've said too close to call with that one, but the EA one is so crisp and booming. The best type of Rangers goal horn!]
Ottawa: tie
Philadelphia: EA
Pittsburgh: tie
San Jose: tie
St Louis: just meh
Tampa Bay: tie
Toronto: tie
Washington: tie [even though the EA version is quite dim]
Yeah, it's subjective, I don't care.
Lmao EA bias.
The devils goal horn has 3 blasts on their horn not 4!
Are you kidding me?! The NHL 2K11 goal horn for the Colorado Avalanche was so off. I live in Colorado and have been to games. The NHL 17 one is so much more accurate.
I disagree only because the 2k horn is off in its pitch. EA may have a lower horn, but 2k has a more authentic sound.
Jack Wildhirt EA's horn is taken straight from Kahlenbergs website.
2k columbus horn is kinda fire
Oilers horn sounds more authentic in 2K.
+Andrew J this was made before we knew what their horn sounded like in the new arena
Love the Oilers horn in NHL 2k7 on Xbox 360
2K has the old Capitals one and EA has one that sounds like the real one.. btw where is the Habs one?
Gimpy Not there because it's changed since then, but he still did the Kings anyway and gave EA the point even though the 2k horn was definitely more accurate for its time...
9:50 The xbox achievement
Even though it was a 17 vs 2k11 and my comment does not make sense there's a idea for a goal horn battle in 2k11 vs NHL 11
Great video!
Lol what a stupid animation in 2k, ever time you score the goalie briefly goes in position to make a save
wolfpacindahouse1 yeah
Well they don’t actually save anything
Why Did The Horns In The 2K Games Sound Like They Were Stock Audio, Or If They Were Recorded?
Rangers in EA was the best in my opinion, and so was Carolina's for both. As a Caps fan, neither 2k or EA got the horn right. It sounded too high pitched
EA and 2K: *has the same horn for Dallas*
N2B: Hmmm. 2K.
Columbus’s horn was different in 2011 then it is now in 2018
2k: okay here you go!
Ea: ok that wi be 899.99
Good Video
Some horns were added from the video clips
How did 2k win for the panthers
Also, as much as I hate them, the Penguins definitely have the best goal horn
EA should have won for the Avalanche
Relationship Goals: *TBL Goal Horn*
N2B Goal horns the blue jackets goal horns were different in those games.
One came out in 2016 and the other came out in 2010...
How about are the NHL 18 Goal Horns Accurate
they need to fix the panthers, red wings, ducks, canadiens, and capitals horn on ea nhl17
and Minnesota
What is the song for the sabres goal horn in NHL17? Thx
When Ottawa Scored in 2k11🤣🤣🤣
Carolina hurricanes has a song to the end of the horn wtf why are they making it look bad
You said you weren't going to compare horns that had changed since then but did it anyways with LA... 2k11 goal horn for LA was definitely more accurate for 2011 than NHL 17 horn for LA in the present, yet you gave EA the point.
nhl 2k have some inaccurate but at least they are loud and crisp
Where is the Winnipeg jets?
I think you should've done 2k11 vs NHL 11. See who got it better at the time.
Smiling Cat 2K would've won that easily
NHL17
Thank god you don’t put Montreal canadiens
You did Calgary vs Edmonton was that intentional
Goool !
no way the 2k penguins goal horn is worse than ea’s
EA definitely won for the flyers goal horn