This is probably the most important Silent Hill 2 video on the entire platform. Really hoping to get an expansion on the Mira/MINMO lore that the series has needed for decades in the upcoming remake. I also do not have dementia.
Thank you for barking the song, that’s what I thought of when seeing the thumbnail and hearing it lovingly reprised was exactly what I needed at the start of the video!! ❤❤❤
I fully support the theory that this is the canon ending, but I always viewed the interpretation differently. In my eyes, this is the only scene set in reality (although the room itself and the dog wearing headphones is James’ dementia). If you look closely at the clues, James and Mary were unable to conceive a child and bought a dog as a fill in. If you zoom in on their carpet, there’s dirty marks that could be muddy paw prints (But tbf it could also be symbolism for vaginas or circumcision). After killing Mary, seeing the dog in the house made James remember how he killed his wife only moments earlier, but instead of taking responsibility he blamed their dog for his guilt and his feelings, causing him to collapse to the floor as his family pet walks up trying to comfort him.
Ah yes, great points! I appreciate you pointing out that James killed Mary, and then immediately forgot until he saw the dog, at which point, he remembered. And then, driving to Silent Hill, he forgot again, and then remembered again when he saw Mira. Perhaps the true dog was the friends we made along the way ❤️
I need to play Control and Alan Wake 2 still. I bought Alan Wake 2 last year and played a few hours of it, but I should actually spend some time with it
damn, so much wrong with this video and all i did was read the title and listen to 40 seconds. Noah, you are illiterate.
Dude you're so real, I have no clue how to read. Tbh I don't know what a dog is either
@@noahmcalister that's very obvious. thanks for ruining the franchise.
All hail Noah Mcalister, the great ruiner of franchises
Dog ending is the only ending, the rest are fake outs for fake silent hill fans who didn't complete the game by getting the real ending.
Wake up new video essay on Silent Hill just dropped
Well, if the art director said that ANY ending of the game can be canon, you know very well what that means. 🐶
This is probably the most important Silent Hill 2 video on the entire platform. Really hoping to get an expansion on the Mira/MINMO lore that the series has needed for decades in the upcoming remake. I also do not have dementia.
Thank you for barking the song, that’s what I thought of when seeing the thumbnail and hearing it lovingly reprised was exactly what I needed at the start of the video!! ❤❤❤
5:04 this frame is something else
good video, i like
I fully support the theory that this is the canon ending, but I always viewed the interpretation differently.
In my eyes, this is the only scene set in reality (although the room itself and the dog wearing headphones is James’ dementia).
If you look closely at the clues, James and Mary were unable to conceive a child and bought a dog as a fill in. If you zoom in on their carpet, there’s dirty marks that could be muddy paw prints (But tbf it could also be symbolism for vaginas or circumcision).
After killing Mary, seeing the dog in the house made James remember how he killed his wife only moments earlier, but instead of taking responsibility he blamed their dog for his guilt and his feelings, causing him to collapse to the floor as his family pet walks up trying to comfort him.
Ah yes, great points! I appreciate you pointing out that James killed Mary, and then immediately forgot until he saw the dog, at which point, he remembered. And then, driving to Silent Hill, he forgot again, and then remembered again when he saw Mira.
Perhaps the true dog was the friends we made along the way ❤️
Man went full schizo and I am all here for it
I don't have dementia
4:50 finally someone who uses actual facts and logic!!
This is the reason why eddie killed the dog.
Absolutely underrated video. Keep it up man 😂
Yes! Speak the truth to the non-believers! Mira supremacy!!!
This honestly makes the dog ending even better
and he speaks... polish??
Send this to Max Derrat.
If someone has his info, be my guest
@@noahmcalister brb doxxing the irl alchemist rn
@@speedstriker not many people realize this, but doxxing is actually the final step in the alchemical process according to Jung
@@noahmcalister as above so below 😔🙏
The Shibe is like Ahti from Control and Alan Wake
I need to play Control and Alan Wake 2 still. I bought Alan Wake 2 last year and played a few hours of it, but I should actually spend some time with it
Very nice lol 🐕