I'm one of those who are on CPP Disability. I hold two degrees - honours) and never DREAMED this would happen to me. You're damn straight the delivery was seriously low. I've been waiting even before the last election. I am now 64 years of age, and will be collecting CPP / OAS and most likely GIS in Dec. 2025. I paid my tax dollars as a hard working Canadian a received basically @#$% all. When Mr. Trudeau announced $200 starting August 2025, I almost flipped out. The provincial governments will just cut that benefit from their programs and we the disabled will be NO FURTHER AHEAD. Mr. Trudeau wonders why Canadians are so pissed and demanding his resignation. He is OUT OF TOUCH with reality. I'm luck in a sense bc. I don't have to wait much longer for my full pension benefits which will be a substantial increase. I feel the pain of those who have many years even decades to go before they receive what's coming to them. This is one of the reasons I watched this entire video bc. Pierre Poilivere hasn't a clue of what's going on or how to handle it.
Thanks, Nate. Great interview. I think Mark and the liberals need to simplify the messaging for Canadians to win them back. Commingling growth to sustainability, in part, makes perfect sense, but I doubt it would win the votes given how politicised climate change issues are.
Wow. Really? I hope you can find your way back to reality. Liberals as a party have run their course. It's over. Make two columns. Achievements versus disasters. Get back to me when you look at the list. Here's one for you Gender Affirming Care - which column does this go in?
@@ryu_street_fighter561 BINGO! The great news is "Nate and Mark" and the rest of the IL-Liberals will have four years to find a new message. Hopefully they realize putting children on a a path to a sex change is a BAD one and free "safe supply" drugs increase addictions. Why do you think 23 people a day can die of an overdose while addictions increase. The number on the trans youth side are staggering AND its sick
Carney knows what is going on , very smart, very well spoken, he has a sense of humour, .....I do believe trudeau will step done next spring to let Carney come in
Mark Carney you’re great I want you as Leader of the Liberal Party. You are from the NWT no less! But can I plead that you bring it down a notch. Simple is also good. 😊 How can Canada be in a great position on environmental policy when your largest trading partner is Trump, an anti-environmentalist? I think you, Mark Carney, are saying you can make Canada into an environmental leader globally as part of a vision for Canada future. Coming from the NWT, that is very interesting!
I’m impressed! I think given Trudeau is being forced out and we are now headed to the polls I think Carney is our man to ensure PP doesn’t ruin our beloved country! 🇨🇦
@@wendyjardine366 what is left to ruin after 10 years of liberals? Its all of them, not just Trudeau. And Carney is behind them all the time. Freeland sons godfather, talking every day, for sure they talk about godson homework. They are all one big family
Really appreciate your podcast. It's refreshing to see unscripted conversations that reveal what our politicians identify as priorities and how they are thinking about them. Hope other leaders are paying attention 👍
I get things done! Should be is mantra if he goes into politics. Hope he becomes Prime Minister. We need a plan and someone and a party that will make it happen
QUESTION: if you saw Mark’s home or homes where he vacations and how he travels and how much he travels would you believe him, when he says this is important ??????
Thanks for asking the Michael Ignatief comparison question. Also, we need to address the toxic nature of partisan politics, which is the way the political right approaches the popularity question. Conservatives do not respect truth, and their attacks are increasingly personal. America has become so toxic, that you cannot argue in good faith with the other side. Thanks for addressing that concern as an 'academic' having to jump into the mud with them. I would have liked to hear his opinion on Christia Freeland, but then I realized this interview is 2 months old. Hopefully you will do another interview early in the new year.
I'm mindful of Michael Ignatieff... brilliant man but so academic that the Canadian public tuned him out. I would take that as a cautionary tale. (edit: oh you did talk about Michael ^^)
Obviously Mark Carney knows a lot. When you listen to him, it's like listening to a sophisticated university professor. But I'm worried that average Canadians don't have the patience to listen to and understand his sophisticated thinking. Beside, he is soft spoken. I'm not sure if he would have an advantage in debate against Pierre, who is very aggressive.
I agree that more aggression will be needed against Poilievre, but I think that will be ramped up when needed. PP is a paper-tiger and he's surrounded by a lot of kindling compared to MC.
@socialminds9894 Yeh. Even in his mid 40s, PP still sounds like the president of a student union. After all, he only has a bachelor in economics from u of Calgary and never worked outside politics. How sophisticated can he be.
@Uneav-c5x Education isn't everything, but it is something. His bachelor's is his International Relations, but it honestly isn't an excuse for how bad his economics knowledge is; especially being in a Politician. He's basically just a half-baked Harper Jr.
A great interview with lots of insights. Would be great to see follow-ups focused on some key items in more depths, e.g., productivity, housing or green energy.
Carbon taxing the Canadian people how does that help reduce carbon In steel? Focusing on private companies and Global trade which is and will happen makes way more sense. The Liberal Party has done nothing since 2015 except create division in our country, politics ruins everything. Not that I know anything i'm just listening and learning.
@@allanlewisorr335 Carbon tax isn't a tax in the normal sense, it simply increases prices of carbon intensive goods or materials, but that tax money is given back to provinces. Provinces such as Ontario, Saskatchewan, Alberta, Manitoba and four maritime provinces, return it all back to the taxpayer. Others use it to reduce carbon emissions. Still consider carbon tax as bad, when this "tax" is returned to the taxpayers?
@@CalBru Here in bc we've had the carbon tax since 2008 it was revenue neutral but that changed with Kristy Clark's government. Show me where this comes back and helps Canadians? I live off grid in rural British Columbia using solar and relying on a generator to get through our winters. This lifestyle is part of my ancestry and culture and constantly being challenged. I can only agree to disagree with you.
Looks like this has been in the plan for quite awhile. As well as the drama trudeau is acting out regarding his refusal to step down. And Irksome-Smith with his Bill C 293 submitted for the approval of all the WEFers he seems to want to impress at the expense of Canadians!
I will vote for him when he will bring China, Brazil India having the same level of pollution Canada has. We are an exemple let’s don’t destroy our future for bankers. So boring. Europe is underwater economically and socially.
It’s unbelievable how irrelevant this whole conversation is to today’s Canada. I don’t think any of these ideas resonate with the average voter, which means the party won’t have a future for at least the next 10 years.
@@sheiladurrant5962 Look at what happened to the liberals in Ontario. Wynn bombed the province SOO bad, no matter how bad Doug Ford gets, Ontarians won't vote liberal. We're at that point with the federal liberals too. What happened to the cons in 2015 is exactly what's coming for the liberals next election. And it'll be a con gov't for at least the next 9 years. Look at Canada's voting history. It's predictable.
@@curtispt1928 Pollievre is a lightweight who"s good at using slogans with the so-called average on-line focused voter. I'd wager that a meaningful debate between Pollievre and Carey would demonstrate how unprepared Pollievre would be if elected. 'Hoping he saves Canada' seems like a nice sentiment. I've never listened to Carey before, and I'm certain that the 'average voter' would likely rather buy-in to the simplistic approach Pollievre proposes than to unpack everything discussed during this overwhelmingly intelligent and forward thinking discussion.
@@Apollo-k1nMark has a very strong message for the middle class. He’s just teasing here. He believes the Social Contract is broken. That capitalism has gone too far, and as a result society as a whole has been corrupted. He’s as well versed in Smith, as he is in Marx. He’s a distributor. Someone from the inside, who’s not happy with what he saw. Because he also sees what’s to come. Now people are right. He’s a self professed technocrat. Which is why Trudeau will be the one selling his message. For the folks where only slogans matter, it’s Trudeau. For the people who care about the details (Blue Grits and Red Tories) they’ll care about the in depth takes. They’ll even out flank the NDP with the promise of Universal Skills Training. Because Mark is a student of Philosophy and History too, he understands that Education is the best antidote to a sick society.
Facile: “(especially of a theory or argument) appearing neat and comprehensive only by ignoring the true complexities of an issue; superficial.’ Oooh - excellent… and so polite ;)
When the Federal Liberals are flirting with absolute political ruin for the next 10-15 years a la the Ontario Liberals, the last thing any voter wants to hear about is how the major ideas the potential next Liberal leader has are ESG development and wealth redistribution. It's unfathomable how tone deaf this party has become. The first thought when improving Canadian productivity shoulnd't be the increase in taxes that the government gets to take, it should be the thriving of the Canadian economy. This is the most out of touch interview I've ever listened to.
Wages are up in Canada, and purchasing power is trending upward fast, though it hasn't fully recovered to pre-pandemic levels. But wages are not rising as much for lower-income earners as they are for higher-income earners. This disparity is a significant factor in growing economic inequality. The affordability issues are impacted greatly by the cost of food. But we have to keep in mind that food price increases due to climate change driven largely by droughts and heatwaves. Droughts cut Spain's olive oil production by nearly 50% in 2023 compared to typical years. Droughts in India and Brazil, major sugar producers, have disrupted harvests, increasing sugar costs. Severe flooding in parts of Asia has damaged rice crops, reducing supply and driving up global prices. Rising temperatures in Brazil and Central America have reduced coffee yields and increased costs due to more frequent droughts and pests like coffee rust... Wealth distribution and climate change are precisely why the middle class is struggling. But it's hard to communicate and it's probably not a good campaign.
@@Drakeneo I listened very carefully. I felt he was describing investing in Canada with long term solutions. Which is what we need….. obviously lack of long term thinking has left us struggling with housing, available healthcare, care and housing the senior population and a much lower population of working age citizens. I heard him wanting to boost investment in small Canadian companies and implementing retraining for people in their 30s up for more advanced technologies in the workplace. I guess different people listen with different intentions. Mine was to learn and have an open mind. What were you listening to hear?
I love these interviews and mark Carney was so well spoken. But Nate I was distressed by the state of the Liberal party and your honest and progressive voice really gives me hope! Well done. And anyone whose in the leadership of the Liberal party reads this. Take note of how Nate is sharing is clear message.
Agreed. Nate has been great at bringing on guests who are interesting, and having honest conversations that we may or may not agree with. Easy to sit back and criticize.
@@1ABNDTAre you referring to the health centre in Toronto? If so I'd simply point out that Doug Ford would be responsible. Perhaps though we can wait for the courts to make a decision as to culpability? Maybe it isn't Ford's fault either.
I really have a hard time trusting Mr Carney. He is an elite business person & may offer some good insight for Canada but he is terribly conflicted. He’s far too committed to clean energy in Canada while supporting oil in other countries. Also if he is an honest good faith Canadian that wants Canada to prosper he would have no reason to avoid disclosure. Mr Carney is choosing not to address conflicts of interest, WEF ties, his century initiative ideological position and this makes him look like more of the same.
Carney is another post-nationalist. Someone who knows he is smarter than the rest of us and know Canadians need to be controlled and "cared for" by government. Ask this guy about Gender Affirming Care, government fuelled drug overdoes and the eradication of Canadian identity.
@@angelahall6461 Scooter has good reason to be. He has seen what an IL-Liberal government is capable of. Carbon Copy Carney (C3) is Justin 2.0 except he has been at the forefront of DEI and ESG on the world stage. Last election 67% of the voters didn't support Trudeau and the IL-Liberals. The election was completely unnecessary but it was a desperate attempt by Trudeau to cling to power. What we got was a bag of really bad ideas. I am sure there are lots of white women that would line up behind Justin all over again - now they can feel better with C3 - Justin 2.0
This guy wants to handicap Oil & Gas in Canada, while his business buys up pipelines in Brazil and UAE, which have much lower environmental and labour standards than Canada 🤡
@@Jasmine-k9m2b actually he did address that in the conversation. He used buying steel from other countries as the example, but basically was explaining that investing with companies focused on clean production is the aim. Pointing out that buying from countries with lower environmental standards does not lower the carbon footprint. Please share a source if you have information that conflicts with his statements. I will happily read or listen…. I don’t side with any party
@@scotthallman9986 A stupid man's report of what a clever man says can never be accurate, because he unconsciously translates what he hears into something he can understand.
This guy seems to have honourable goals for helping fix the environment but to be honest I'm glad he won't be holding the position of finance minister. We have more important things to focus on right now. Edit: ok so after now having listened to the full interview i definitely don't want this guy to be our finance minister. The way that he speaks about "bringing people along" and "the dignity of a job" combined with his lukewarm reception to socialist topics betrays him as exactly the kind of optimistic elitist that you might find in silicon valley. That is my sense after listening to him speak for an hour. On the other hand, I've come out of this video very happy to have Mr. Erskine-Smith as our housing minister. The way that he speaks about housing issues is exactly the kind of thing we need more of in government.
A stupid man's report of what a clever man says can never be accurate, because he unconsciously translates what he hears into something he can understand.
The faith in markets this guy has is really disconcerting. Also, US workers are more "productive"? Look at their quality of life, clearly the benefits of that productivity is not shared in an egalitarian way. This guy has been rubbing shoulders with oligarchs his entire life. He wants to tell us about "inclusive growth"? Give me a break.
So Mark, you are extremely wealthy. Please disclose where all your investments are and what those companies do. I have a strong feeling you invest in foreign energy companies that go against everything you are talking about here. Start with yourself.
@@jinnymay3371 basically those suppositions are based on what I gleaned from talks between Carney and Poilievre somewhere on youtube. We want to paint Canada like a dogooder nation but we have the resources to be much richer, and learn by exploiting them. Good examples are Holland, who refine and export oil on a massive, massive scale. In fact (as I have done whilst working on Holland America cruise ships) if you come into their main cities via sea travel, you can see endless refineries. It's like Mordor. This is not the Hallmark postcard picture of the nation we see broadcasted over the world. They use this wealth to implement strong green initiatives. The point is they access world need for power and take advantage of this. We should do the same. Another examples could easily be Norway, who have a very very strong economy based on northern oil. No one talks about these guys because they keep their heads down and keep to themselves. Live there (I've been to these countries many times) is great. They, for now, are in the now, and acknowledging world needs while keeping an eye on the future and better solutions. It takes money and infrastructure, generations of engineers, scientists to learn through trial and error to get to where we will be down the line. Alberta, Qc, NL have SO much we could use to make a stronger Canadian society, standard of living, strong wages, work for our generations of engineers etc but are shifting the narrative and backhandedly letting shithole countries like Iran, Venezuela so the dirty work.
Banker tied in to the highest lvls. in finance , primary job fix the banks rest smokescreen but could have ideas as Freeland has no qualifications wrote a book added a no. to the gender balanced scam the Libs have been running balance but with qualified people ? lol
This Mark carney guy thinks Pierre Poilievre doesn’t know what he’s doing when he does. Pierre Poilievre has been mentored by Stephan Harper which he is a former well respected PM but also an expert in economics. When you print money to pay the interest payments on the country deficit. Not only does it cause inflation but it also devalues that currency. The more you have of something the less valuable it is. The less you have of something the more valuable it is. This Mark Carney guy should advise this idiot PM that we have now to pay down the country’s deficit. Soft on crime is not good for the economy, high taxes, high bureaucracy, high immigration, a housing crisis, safe injection sites. All of these things are not good for the economy. All under Justin Trudeau.
@@charlespackwood9219 PP has had one job in life - politician, who tells people simplistic nonsense that they want to hear. No better than Trudeau, and the only reason he isn't worse is because he hasn't been PM - thankfully We need smart leaders, and one of the best was Paul Martin. Carney is off a similar calibre. Let's stop voting for mediocre politicians like JT and PP, and elect some quality.
@ I can’t vote for carney. He’s been an outside adviser for Justin Trudeau for almost 5 years. He has not once told Trudeau that his over spending and money printing is causing inflation, that letting repeat offenders out on bail would cause businesses to close shop due to high insurance premiums, that mass immigration wasn’t the answer to fill jobs during the labour shortage which also caused a housing crisis. This mark carney has supported all these destructive policies of Justin Trudeau that brought Canada to its knees. I want things to go back to the way they were under Stephen Harper. Which is low taxes, tough on crime, Canada first, a balance budget, taking production caps off our oil and gas sector. Even the last liberal government before Justin Trudeau believed in a balanced budget.
@@charlespackwood9219 Huh? I didn't know that Carney had that much impact on JT's decisions as he certainly wasn't at the cabinet table. He didn't tell Trudeau that spending would cause inflation? That may or may not be, but you think JT doesn't know even that? And Dept of Finance or his Finance Minister didn't tell him that? Nah, not buying what you're selling today. And if you want to go back, goback to Paul Martin, who made all that possible for Stephen Harper.
I like Carney, I trust him with the economy but I don't know that I trust him to to root out the intrusive progressive activist policies that are embedded in the current government. I think Canada needs at least 4-years of Poilievre to, in Carney's words, chop things down, before he should come in to "rebuild".
@@malcolmsmith6449 A stupid man's report of what a clever man says can never be accurate, because he unconsciously translates what he hears into something he can understand.
As an economist, Carney makes the best arguments for Canada
Why Isnt anyone talking about how Nate Just announced a spring election??? Thought the schedule was Oct/25
When the budget comes up in April everyone knows this government will not survive - if it even makes it that far.
@@mekan0001 Why?
And here we are with libs on the chopping block
I'm one of those who are on CPP Disability. I hold two degrees - honours) and never DREAMED this would happen to me. You're damn straight the delivery was seriously low. I've been waiting even before the last election. I am now 64 years of age, and will be collecting CPP / OAS and most likely GIS in Dec. 2025.
I paid my tax dollars as a hard working Canadian a received basically @#$% all. When Mr. Trudeau announced $200 starting August 2025, I almost flipped out. The provincial governments will just cut that benefit from their programs and we the disabled will be NO FURTHER AHEAD.
Mr. Trudeau wonders why Canadians are so pissed and demanding his resignation. He is OUT OF TOUCH with reality. I'm luck in a sense bc. I don't have to wait much longer for my full pension benefits which will be a substantial increase. I feel the pain of those who have many years even decades to go before they receive what's coming to them.
This is one of the reasons I watched this entire video bc. Pierre Poilivere hasn't a clue of what's going on or how to handle it.
It’s all liberals, bot just Trudeau. And how PP would know what happening, when liberals hiding everything.
Neither do you
Thanks, Nate. Great interview. I think Mark and the liberals need to simplify the messaging for Canadians to win them back. Commingling growth to sustainability, in part, makes perfect sense, but I doubt it would win the votes given how politicised climate change issues are.
I think all these WEFers should go away!
'Win them back' lol No one with a brain is listening to the Liberals; their policies are garbage.
Wow. Really? I hope you can find your way back to reality. Liberals as a party have run their course. It's over. Make two columns. Achievements versus disasters. Get back to me when you look at the list. Here's one for you Gender Affirming Care - which column does this go in?
More Climate Taxes = More pain for the middle class. No thanks!
@@ryu_street_fighter561 BINGO! The great news is "Nate and Mark" and the rest of the IL-Liberals will have four years to find a new message. Hopefully they realize putting children on a a path to a sex change is a BAD one and free "safe supply" drugs increase addictions. Why do you think 23 people a day can die of an overdose while addictions increase. The number on the trans youth side are staggering AND its sick
I think Mark Carney will be an asset to the Liberal Party and for Canada. Looking forward to him running one day..
He might be the next PM
@@sahilkhurana_ probably, Canada has a reputation for electing traitorous marxists
Never gonna happen 😂@@sahilkhurana_
I love that he is richer than trump lol and its not due to his dad's money!
@@Jasmine-k9m2bboom
Carney knows what is going on , very smart, very well spoken, he has a sense of humour, .....I do believe trudeau will step done next spring to let Carney come in
Hes a traitorous rat, slave to global interests. He would sell canada out it 2 seconds
Of course he knows what’s going on, when he’s behind everything liberals ever done
Literally all those things you named are his criticisms
@@ZenCorvus Carney is worlds ahead of Poilievre
Mark Carney you’re great I want you as Leader of the Liberal Party. You are from the NWT no less! But can I plead that you bring it down a notch. Simple is also good. 😊 How can Canada be in a great position on environmental policy when your largest trading partner is Trump, an anti-environmentalist? I think you, Mark Carney, are saying you can make Canada into an environmental leader globally as part of a vision for Canada future. Coming from the NWT, that is very interesting!
Great interview!
I really hope you run with Carney, Nate!
I’m impressed! I think given Trudeau is being forced out and we are now headed to the polls I think Carney is our man to ensure PP doesn’t ruin our beloved country! 🇨🇦
@@wendyjardine366 what’s more left to ruin after Trudeau?
Trudeau and the Liberals ruined our country... and you want Carney to win? Carney = Trudeau 2.0
Why would PP ruin it ?
@@wendyjardine366 what is left to ruin after 10 years of liberals? Its all of them, not just Trudeau.
And Carney is behind them all the time. Freeland sons godfather, talking every day, for sure they talk about godson homework.
They are all one big family
The bot said as canada is swimming in debt, has no future, and is tanking
Mark Carney is the first politician I’ve ever been excited to vote for.
😂😂 yeah, vote for the guy who owns a mega-REIT
Rich arrogant noob, don’t know to talk with regular people, but main thing he have some crumbs to offer you, if he ever notice you
Ya excited about the guy who shut down oil in canada and profits on it everywhere else
congrats on breaking the news that Carney will be the next leader of the Liberal party
Installed. Not elected.
Like kamala
The left loves it
Thank you Nate Erskine- Smith! Great interview!!!
He’ll be a great liberal leader if he can simplify his lamguage
Exactly the common man won’t understand him
He will be worse than the current government and would ruin canada but support the rich guy
Really appreciate your podcast. It's refreshing to see unscripted conversations that reveal what our politicians identify as priorities and how they are thinking about them. Hope other leaders are paying attention 👍
A fringe of politicians 😅
I get things done! Should be is mantra if he goes into politics. Hope he becomes Prime Minister. We need a plan and someone and a party that will make it happen
QUESTION: if you saw Mark’s home or homes where he vacations and how he travels and how much he travels would you believe him, when he says this is important
??????
Im really hoping that Nate hasn't given up on running for OLP leadership. Crombie is uninspiring. And Nate is more well known now.
Thanks for asking the Michael Ignatief comparison question. Also, we need to address the toxic nature of partisan politics, which is the way the political right approaches the popularity question. Conservatives do not respect truth, and their attacks are increasingly personal. America has become so toxic, that you cannot argue in good faith with the other side. Thanks for addressing that concern as an 'academic' having to jump into the mud with them. I would have liked to hear his opinion on Christia Freeland, but then I realized this interview is 2 months old. Hopefully you will do another interview early in the new year.
I hope you can find your way back to reality.
Where in the video is the Ignatieff question?
@ashtviceland Close to the beginning. 'how does an intellectual win over the masses, when Ignatieff couldn't do it...?'
I'm mindful of Michael Ignatieff... brilliant man but so academic that the Canadian public tuned him out. I would take that as a cautionary tale. (edit: oh you did talk about Michael ^^)
Canada always works hard to trash of brightest and best. All the neocons on here likely did not listen beyond the introduction.
Obviously Mark Carney knows a lot. When you listen to him, it's like listening to a sophisticated university professor. But I'm worried that average Canadians don't have the patience to listen to and understand his sophisticated thinking. Beside, he is soft spoken. I'm not sure if he would have an advantage in debate against Pierre, who is very aggressive.
I agree that more aggression will be needed against Poilievre, but I think that will be ramped up when needed. PP is a paper-tiger and he's surrounded by a lot of kindling compared to MC.
Tell me you had a crap education without saying it.
@@trivialgravitas9581 who has crap education?
@socialminds9894 Yeh. Even in his mid 40s, PP still sounds like the president of a student union. After all, he only has a bachelor in economics from u of Calgary and never worked outside politics. How sophisticated can he be.
@Uneav-c5x Education isn't everything, but it is something. His bachelor's is his International Relations, but it honestly isn't an excuse for how bad his economics knowledge is; especially being in a Politician. He's basically just a half-baked Harper Jr.
A great interview with lots of insights. Would be great to see follow-ups focused on some key items in more depths, e.g., productivity, housing or green energy.
I'm amazed at all the haters that watch and comment. It's great - they might learn something. :)
Idiot.
Haters because don't fall from crap served to them?
@@MrDjohi I don't understand what you're trying to say?
Doubtful, They call it up and make nasty comments they have heard from fellow right-wingers and oil apologists.
Probably a typo. Point is that it’s time for Pollievre and Change before Canada is irreversibly destroyed.
Carbon taxing the Canadian people how does that help reduce carbon In steel? Focusing on private companies and Global trade which is and will happen makes way more sense. The Liberal Party has done nothing since 2015 except create division in our country, politics ruins everything. Not that I know anything i'm just listening and learning.
@@allanlewisorr335 Carbon tax isn't a tax in the normal sense, it simply increases prices of carbon intensive goods or materials, but that tax money is given back to provinces. Provinces such as Ontario, Saskatchewan, Alberta, Manitoba and four maritime provinces, return it all back to the taxpayer. Others use it to reduce carbon emissions.
Still consider carbon tax as bad, when this "tax" is returned to the taxpayers?
@@CalBru Here in bc we've had the carbon tax since 2008 it was revenue neutral but that changed with Kristy Clark's government. Show me where this comes back and helps Canadians? I live off grid in rural British Columbia using solar and relying on a generator to get through our winters. This lifestyle is part of my ancestry and culture and constantly being challenged. I can only agree to disagree with you.
Smart discussion. Optimistic.
😂😂😂🤐🤯
Thank you for this interview!
Great interview Nate, and I would gladly make phone calls for Mark Carney if he decides to run as a candidate.
Carney has more conflicts of interest than all of parliament COMBINED! I can smell the corruption already!
Yea we need Mark to take us to the world economic forum.
Looks like this has been in the plan for quite awhile. As well as the drama trudeau is acting out regarding his refusal to step down. And Irksome-Smith with his Bill C 293 submitted for the approval of all the WEFers he seems to want to impress at the expense of Canadians!
Hes sharp as a tack.
And as corrupt as they get!
I will vote for him when he will bring China, Brazil India having the same level of pollution Canada has. We are an exemple let’s don’t destroy our future for bankers. So boring. Europe is underwater economically and socially.
It’s unbelievable how irrelevant this whole conversation is to today’s Canada. I don’t think any of these ideas resonate with the average voter, which means the party won’t have a future for at least the next 10 years.
That is rather too bad, don't you think, considering what the world faces in the next ten years?
@@sheiladurrant5962Pollievre will hopefully save Canada…. Certainly not THIS Liberal party!
@@sheiladurrant5962 Look at what happened to the liberals in Ontario. Wynn bombed the province SOO bad, no matter how bad Doug Ford gets, Ontarians won't vote liberal. We're at that point with the federal liberals too. What happened to the cons in 2015 is exactly what's coming for the liberals next election. And it'll be a con gov't for at least the next 9 years. Look at Canada's voting history. It's predictable.
@@curtispt1928 Pollievre is a lightweight who"s good at using slogans with the so-called average on-line focused voter. I'd wager that a meaningful debate between Pollievre and Carey would demonstrate how unprepared Pollievre would be if elected. 'Hoping he saves Canada' seems like a nice sentiment. I've never listened to Carey before, and I'm certain that the 'average voter' would likely rather buy-in to the simplistic approach Pollievre proposes than to unpack everything discussed during this overwhelmingly intelligent and forward thinking discussion.
@@Apollo-k1nMark has a very strong message for the middle class. He’s just teasing here.
He believes the Social Contract is broken. That capitalism has gone too far, and as a result society as a whole has been corrupted. He’s as well versed in Smith, as he is in Marx.
He’s a distributor. Someone from the inside, who’s not happy with what he saw. Because he also sees what’s to come.
Now people are right. He’s a self professed technocrat. Which is why Trudeau will be the one selling his message. For the folks where only slogans matter, it’s Trudeau. For the people who care about the details (Blue Grits and Red Tories) they’ll care about the in depth takes.
They’ll even out flank the NDP with the promise of Universal Skills Training. Because Mark is a student of Philosophy and History too, he understands that Education is the best antidote to a sick society.
John Podesta!!!!!OMG... The swamp is incredibly deep!
We reaslly need people like Nate and Mark Carney to help us face the future. Wish more people would take the time to listen to these podcasts.
Pfft
How willfully ignorant are you?
Facile: “(especially of a theory or argument) appearing neat and comprehensive only by ignoring the true complexities of an issue; superficial.’
Oooh - excellent… and so polite ;)
Hes a globalist traitor elitist. Of course his speech harkens to a college english major who sniffs his own farts
Just got lucky Carney. Ride the wave of good luck learn as you go rub shoulders with some good people and your a genius.
'WEF stooges of a feather flock together'.
We don't need Carney or any Ndp/Liberal.
When the Federal Liberals are flirting with absolute political ruin for the next 10-15 years a la the Ontario Liberals, the last thing any voter wants to hear about is how the major ideas the potential next Liberal leader has are ESG development and wealth redistribution. It's unfathomable how tone deaf this party has become. The first thought when improving Canadian productivity shoulnd't be the increase in taxes that the government gets to take, it should be the thriving of the Canadian economy. This is the most out of touch interview I've ever listened to.
Exactly 😂
Wages are up in Canada, and purchasing power is trending upward fast, though it hasn't fully recovered to pre-pandemic levels. But wages are not rising as much for lower-income earners as they are for higher-income earners. This disparity is a significant factor in growing economic inequality.
The affordability issues are impacted greatly by the cost of food. But we have to keep in mind that food price increases due to climate change driven largely by droughts and heatwaves. Droughts cut Spain's olive oil production by nearly 50% in 2023 compared to typical years. Droughts in India and Brazil, major sugar producers, have disrupted harvests, increasing sugar costs. Severe flooding in parts of Asia has damaged rice crops, reducing supply and driving up global prices. Rising temperatures in Brazil and Central America have reduced coffee yields and increased costs due to more frequent droughts and pests like coffee rust...
Wealth distribution and climate change are precisely why the middle class is struggling. But it's hard to communicate and it's probably not a good campaign.
@@DidierPilon NO MORE SOCIALISM!! Trudeau did this for 10 years and tanked our economy. NO MORE LIBERALS
@@Drakeneo I listened very carefully. I felt he was describing investing in Canada with long term solutions. Which is what we need….. obviously lack of long term thinking has left us struggling with housing, available healthcare, care and housing the senior population and a much lower population of working age citizens. I heard him wanting to boost investment in small Canadian companies and implementing retraining for people in their 30s up for more advanced technologies in the workplace. I guess different people listen with different intentions. Mine was to learn and have an open mind. What were you listening to hear?
I love these interviews and mark Carney was so well spoken. But Nate I was distressed by the state of the Liberal party and your honest and progressive voice really gives me hope! Well done. And anyone whose in the leadership of the Liberal party reads this. Take note of how Nate is sharing is clear message.
How much are they paying you?
Agreed. Nate has been great at bringing on guests who are interesting, and having honest conversations that we may or may not agree with.
Easy to sit back and criticize.
@@CalBru Another paid shill, sheesh. What are they paying you clowns?
@@1ABNDTAre you referring to the health centre in Toronto? If so I'd simply point out that Doug Ford would be responsible.
Perhaps though we can wait for the courts to make a decision as to culpability? Maybe it isn't Ford's fault either.
@@1ABNDT That is the best response you have? 🤣🤣 You are certainly better than that, come on! :)
Terrific interview!! Thanks so much!!
Being in the trenches is great, trying to make coffee when it's cold with cream and sugar. Drink it black, that is my advice
I really have a hard time trusting Mr Carney. He is an elite business person & may offer some good insight for Canada but he is terribly conflicted.
He’s far too committed to clean energy in Canada while supporting oil in other countries. Also if he is an honest good faith Canadian that wants Canada to prosper he would have no reason to avoid disclosure.
Mr Carney is choosing not to address conflicts of interest, WEF ties, his century initiative ideological position and this makes him look like more of the same.
Don't TRUST Carney ....
Exactly!
Carney is another post-nationalist. Someone who knows he is smarter than the rest of us and know Canadians need to be controlled and "cared for" by government. Ask this guy about Gender Affirming Care, government fuelled drug overdoes and the eradication of Canadian identity.
You seem a little worried there Scooter 😂
@@angelahall6461 Scooter has good reason to be. He has seen what an IL-Liberal government is capable of. Carbon Copy Carney (C3) is Justin 2.0 except he has been at the forefront of DEI and ESG on the world stage. Last election 67% of the voters didn't support Trudeau and the IL-Liberals. The election was completely unnecessary but it was a desperate attempt by Trudeau to cling to power. What we got was a bag of really bad ideas. I am sure there are lots of white women that would line up behind Justin all over again - now they can feel better with C3 - Justin 2.0
I will support Mark Carney for 🇨🇦 Finance Minister, to bring our INFLATION DOWN. 🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦👏👏👏👏👏👏
a worthy listen--thanks
@@redislandphotographer more they open mouth, more support they loose. So it's excellent interview
This guy wants to handicap Oil & Gas in Canada, while his business buys up pipelines in Brazil and UAE, which have much lower environmental and labour standards than Canada 🤡
Source please, I couldn't find anything on that. Are you a bot or a troll?
@@Jasmine-k9m2b actually he did address that in the conversation. He used buying steel from other countries as the example, but basically was explaining that investing with companies focused on clean production is the aim. Pointing out that buying from countries with lower environmental standards does not lower the carbon footprint. Please share a source if you have information that conflicts with his statements. I will happily read or listen…. I don’t side with any party
There are scientist that put forward data that the level of CO2 this businessman wants to achieve is incompatible with humans life
I'd love to read about it, what was your source because a general search didn't bring anything up.
@ Again, we need sources because this mans position with the UN is special envoy for climate and finance. What you are saying does not compute
Ignatieff 2.0
Yup 😂😂😂
clearly you didn't watch the video
@@scotthallman9986 A stupid man's report of what a clever man says can never be accurate, because he unconsciously translates what he hears into something he can understand.
Hey Nate, are you running for re-election lmao
This guy seems to have honourable goals for helping fix the environment but to be honest I'm glad he won't be holding the position of finance minister. We have more important things to focus on right now.
Edit: ok so after now having listened to the full interview i definitely don't want this guy to be our finance minister. The way that he speaks about "bringing people along" and "the dignity of a job" combined with his lukewarm reception to socialist topics betrays him as exactly the kind of optimistic elitist that you might find in silicon valley. That is my sense after listening to him speak for an hour.
On the other hand, I've come out of this video very happy to have Mr. Erskine-Smith as our housing minister. The way that he speaks about housing issues is exactly the kind of thing we need more of in government.
😂😂😂 housing minister while the Liberal party falls apart
A stupid man's report of what a clever man says can never be accurate, because he unconsciously translates what he hears into something he can understand.
The faith in markets this guy has is really disconcerting. Also, US workers are more "productive"? Look at their quality of life, clearly the benefits of that productivity is not shared in an egalitarian way. This guy has been rubbing shoulders with oligarchs his entire life. He wants to tell us about "inclusive growth"? Give me a break.
Carney don't want to put in the hand work he must not be elected to lead the liberal party.
What an absolute communist.
So Mark, you are extremely wealthy. Please disclose where all your investments are and what those companies do. I have a strong feeling you invest in foreign energy companies that go against everything you are talking about here. Start with yourself.
@@04eire really? Can you share your sources? I would like to read about it
@@jinnymay3371 basically those suppositions are based on what I gleaned from talks between Carney and Poilievre somewhere on youtube. We want to paint Canada like a dogooder nation but we have the resources to be much richer, and learn by exploiting them. Good examples are Holland, who refine and export oil on a massive, massive scale. In fact (as I have done whilst working on Holland America cruise ships) if you come into their main cities via sea travel, you can see endless refineries. It's like Mordor. This is not the Hallmark postcard picture of the nation we see broadcasted over the world. They use this wealth to implement strong green initiatives. The point is they access world need for power and take advantage of this. We should do the same. Another examples could easily be Norway, who have a very very strong economy based on northern oil. No one talks about these guys because they keep their heads down and keep to themselves. Live there (I've been to these countries many times) is great. They, for now, are in the now, and acknowledging world needs while keeping an eye on the future and better solutions. It takes money and infrastructure, generations of engineers, scientists to learn through trial and error to get to where we will be down the line. Alberta, Qc, NL have SO much we could use to make a stronger Canadian society, standard of living, strong wages, work for our generations of engineers etc but are shifting the narrative and backhandedly letting shithole countries like Iran, Venezuela so the dirty work.
He needs a wardrobe manager. The Captain Kirk look isn't doing it.
Mark Carney is great. PM has not stepped down. Pressure??
Carney is a nut job who has MORE conflicts of interest than the entire parliament of MP's COMBINED!!
Banker tied in to the highest lvls. in finance , primary job fix the banks rest smokescreen but could have ideas as Freeland has no qualifications wrote a book added a no. to the gender balanced scam the Libs have been running balance but with qualified people ? lol
Carney = Trudeau 2.0, why don't more people understand that?
You are right. He talk is all about global stuff. I want a PM who puts Canada first.
This Mark carney guy thinks Pierre Poilievre doesn’t know what he’s doing when he does. Pierre Poilievre has been mentored by Stephan Harper which he is a former well respected PM but also an expert in economics. When you print money to pay the interest payments on the country deficit. Not only does it cause inflation but it also devalues that currency. The more you have of something the less valuable it is. The less you have of something the more valuable it is. This Mark Carney guy should advise this idiot PM that we have now to pay down the country’s deficit. Soft on crime is not good for the economy, high taxes, high bureaucracy, high immigration, a housing crisis, safe injection sites. All of these things are not good for the economy. All under Justin Trudeau.
@@charlespackwood9219 PP has had one job in life - politician, who tells people simplistic nonsense that they want to hear. No better than Trudeau, and the only reason he isn't worse is because he hasn't been PM - thankfully
We need smart leaders, and one of the best was Paul Martin. Carney is off a similar calibre. Let's stop voting for mediocre politicians like JT and PP, and elect some quality.
@ I can’t vote for carney. He’s been an outside adviser for Justin Trudeau for almost 5 years. He has not once told Trudeau that his over spending and money printing is causing inflation, that letting repeat offenders out on bail would cause businesses to close shop due to high insurance premiums, that mass immigration wasn’t the answer to fill jobs during the labour shortage which also caused a housing crisis. This mark carney has supported all these destructive policies of Justin Trudeau that brought Canada to its knees. I want things to go back to the way they were under Stephen Harper. Which is low taxes, tough on crime, Canada first, a balance budget, taking production caps off our oil and gas sector. Even the last liberal government before Justin Trudeau believed in a balanced budget.
@@charlespackwood9219 Huh? I didn't know that Carney had that much impact on JT's decisions as he certainly wasn't at the cabinet table.
He didn't tell Trudeau that spending would cause inflation? That may or may not be, but you think JT doesn't know even that? And Dept of Finance or his Finance Minister didn't tell him that?
Nah, not buying what you're selling today. And if you want to go back, goback to Paul Martin, who made all that possible for Stephen Harper.
I like Carney, I trust him with the economy but I don't know that I trust him to to root out the intrusive progressive activist policies that are embedded in the current government. I think Canada needs at least 4-years of Poilievre to, in Carney's words, chop things down, before he should come in to "rebuild".
That’s the stupidest logic I’ve ever heard in my life.
@malcolmsmith6449 thanks for letting me know how you feel, which part(s) specifically do you take issue with?
Carney has more conflicts of interests than all of parliament COMBINED!
@@malcolmsmith6449 A stupid man's report of what a clever man says can never be accurate, because he unconsciously translates what he hears into something he can understand.