truongphan90 She hit g#5... which is higher than the album version. Did the high note sound bad to you? To me, it was the 'beyond perfect' part of this performance. I mean, the rest is at perfection.... lol
With such muddy recording we cant hear all that clear. Imma a sound guy and there's no arguing the unedited mix is muddy... I still politely disagree again.
I've never knew Mariah before so basically im not a fan of her, but all of this has changed when I accidentally played her song "Hero" on my brother's phone. As I listening the song, there's something I felt inside me which I couldn't explain. The song got my heart and of course Mariah Carey. So I started to listen all of her songs and I realized how beautiful her voice is and how excellent is she as I singer. Im a great fan of you Mariah Carey 😍
@@jimmyv8238 You are mad. A G5 won't differentiate between a good performance and a perfect one. Go and watch Rotterdam, Paris and Capitol Hill if a G5 is so important for you
This was filmed in late 1995 as a standalone concert. It was the first time she transposed the song down from its original key. Mariah didn't begin incorporating F#5 and G5 notes into her "Hero" arrangement until the Daydream Tour in 1996.
GiuseppePascuale928 I don't know... that high note sounds like a super quick g#5. The Tokyo dome performance from 96' is absolutely amazing... I do agree with Ari.
Thanks for clarifying when the key change began. I discovered after my original post that she performed it in the original key whilst promoting the single and on the Music Box Tour in 1993 but first lowered the key at St. John the Divine in 1994.
Why do people care so much about the key is high or low... the point is can you sing like her? NO! Can you better than her? HELL NO! So shut up and enjoy this beautiful performance. This is one time and we never find someone sing so effortlestly perfect like her.
Surely 1995-1996 was her prime. Watching her hero lives since she was promoting the music box album you can crearly see that she reached her mark here. Daydream era, even thought it's a underrated era in its time, today we can figure out that she find herself there.
Rowan W To be technical, the term dubbed in music is a sort of layering. I don't get what this person is saying as well. This video is of the undubbed vocals. The polished version is this live vocal track dubbed with another live performance. I think it's the 96' Tokyo performance.
I dont know if the intention of this video is that we think that she´s a bad singer, but when the song ends I just think... she sounds amazing. A mini second doesn't matter when she makes you feel in heaven 4 minutes!!!!!
Julian Candra Mariah as well as her team wanted to picture her as vocal perfection. She is incredible but not perfect...this adds to her self-consiousness about her voice.
but the run was better in this version. they destroyed the run in the dubbed version. it sounds worse there and soooo much better here. i would understand if they would've dubbed it to make it sound better (not possible), but they made it actually sound worse.
MCsVoice97 no. *they* as in columbia/sony. as in the same people that planted a seed of insecurity in mariah to the point that she didn't even think her peerless daydream vocals were good enough when in reality that just wasn't the truth.
@luisjla She did the note here, its hard to hear but it here. She did it at tokyo, rotterdam, london, paris and peace officers memorial. She was in great voice in this era, she didnt start having consistent rough vocal days until 1997 mainly.
It seems as if she touched the G#5 and then descended back down to an F5. Which proves that she did in fact go back in the studio and dub everything over. I hate to admit it, but this is just something that Mariah has always done.
+GeneralRelativity Yeah i just relistened a couple more times to compare and this one she goes high then low. And in the dubbed she just soars way higher. It could just be different performances idk
I think maybe they do different takes on songs and pick what more flattering and combine those into one video. I think i see that on other song before they do many takes of her singing the song over and over.
They added a robotic flavor to the dubbed performances, I was fascinated by those robotic notes on the dubbed versions, I am just a little disappointed cause All the robotic notes I used to be obsessed with were in fact dubbed, it is not here, but DONT get me wrong, that was FUCKING brilliant, OUT OF THIS WORLD!!!
Hi There Again Mariah, I said that I was wondering are you still Definitely sure that you and your Bandmates are going to do some Re-writing, Re-mixing and Re-extending it in the other way round word lyrics and Re-extending the word Lyrics But sing it in you’re own Extended Word Lyrics for all of us fans Pretty Please Mariah Carey? and sing it differently in the exact different versions for all of us Fans and just Reuse the Original extended Background songs For this particular song from the Korgis, Everybody's Got To Learn Sometime, why don’t you and you’re band Replace the Synthesizer Strings Sound for Those Two Deeper Musette Accordion’s and make those Two Musette Accordion’s 4 to 7 and a half times more Deeper then the Original Synthesizer Strings Sound that they have used for this Purticular Extended Type of Original Background Song Called Everybody's got to Learn Sometime From The Korgis Pretty Please Lovely Mariah? and also Replace the Xylophone Sound to a 47 and a Half Times More Lower Chime Bells And Even a 56 and a Half Times More Lower Still Drums Sound Because it is Still one of my Very Very Very Very Very Very Favourite original Extended Type of Background Songs Ever Since I was about 10 Years of Age Thank You Very Very Very Very Very Much for you and your Bandmates support X😉X🎈X 😉X ❤X 😉X🎈X 😉X ❤X😉X ❤X😉X🎈X 😉X🎈X 😉X❤X😉X🎈X😉X❤X😉X
@luisjla WOOWWWW at your comments i just said thats what i heard sounds like she touches it, please i dont not worship the woman she is a human and i know that. Not a delusional fan just someone with opinions. Chill out geez, God is the only person worth worshiping. That was extremely uneccesary you dont need to tell me that smh.
@luisjla aww its ok i understand there alot of really annoying mariah stans out there, they can be pretty sick and have no life. I understand no worries :)
@WhitneyElizabethH Yeah, maybe she hitted... It's a little confused... But I don't care... It's great here... The only thing that I'm sure she didn't hit was the F5 at "you can survive"
![[Unedited vocals] Without You - Mariah Carey (live at Madison Square Garden) 1995](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/znJdyvWKGQI/mqdefault.jpg)
I don't care about the high note, the performance is beyond perfection. Her voice was so smooth, high or low.
truongphan90 She hit g#5... which is higher than the album version. Did the high note sound bad to you? To me, it was the 'beyond perfect' part of this performance. I mean, the rest is at perfection.... lol
Kurtis Edwards The G#5 was not found in this performance :(
I disagree.
There is actually no G#5 belt in this performance. The belt was only an F5(though it's really good)
With such muddy recording we cant hear all that clear. Imma a sound guy and there's no arguing the unedited mix is muddy... I still politely disagree again.
I've never knew Mariah before so basically im not a fan of her, but all of this has changed when I accidentally played her song "Hero" on my brother's phone. As I listening the song, there's something I felt inside me which I couldn't explain. The song got my heart and of course Mariah Carey. So I started to listen all of her songs and I realized how beautiful her voice is and how excellent is she as I singer. Im a great fan of you Mariah Carey 😍
me too
WE HAD THE SAME EXPERIENCE 😭❤❤❤❤❤
I had heard about her in the 90s but didn't appreciate her then .i rediscovered her talent recently after listening to without you.
So did I!
awww. good for you!! 🙌🏽
3:39 is one of the best runs I've ever heard her do
Scott D 😰
it’s really beautiful it has so much depth!
Fans screaming for her worth million dollar cause she is LEGEND!
Even better than the dubbed version !! This is what i call *PERFECTION* !! ;[ For sure Mariah is an angel sent from God to the mankind !!! ~L4L~
Nope, and she fooled people. There was NO G5. I prefer her singing hero in music box era rather than faking the G5 note. High note is NOT everything.
@@jimmyv8238 You are mad. A G5 won't differentiate between a good performance and a perfect one. Go and watch Rotterdam, Paris and Capitol Hill if a G5 is so important for you
@@jimmyv8238 she does it live here:ruclips.net/video/MazFJlpU4mU/видео.html so what’s your point? We know she could do it
There's no fucking need to dubb this performance. So clean and perfect.
Oh no the way she sang " look inside you and be strong" in the last part really got me!!!
Ikr 😭😭😭😭 she has only done that once
😭😭😭😭 huhu
its true what I heard, that mariahs real voice is so Olympics🏆
Trueeeee
Her headvoice/falsetto at 3:28 is IMMACULATE!
And that RUN at 3:39 WOW
3:29
yes.. totally love it. i thought this was the only concert she sung thay way.
LGsingz I had to replay that part a lot. It's better than the dubbed version. Love how agile her voice is.
I had to replay that part..... it was my first time hearing that runs in this song! It was so good!!
❤️
This was filmed in late 1995 as a standalone concert. It was the first time she transposed the song down from its original key. Mariah didn't begin incorporating F#5 and G5 notes into her "Hero" arrangement until the Daydream Tour in 1996.
GiuseppePascuale928 I don't know... that high note sounds like a super quick g#5. The Tokyo dome performance from 96' is absolutely amazing... I do agree with Ari.
She sang it in the lower key during the Music Box tour too.
She have sung the climax to Eb5 in 94 many times
the first time she started lowering the key on this song was at the St John the Divine.
Thanks for clarifying when the key change began. I discovered after my original post that she performed it in the original key whilst promoting the single and on the Music Box Tour in 1993 but first lowered the key at St. John the Divine in 1994.
Why do people care so much about the key is high or low... the point is can you sing like her? NO! Can you better than her? HELL NO! So shut up and enjoy this beautiful performance. This is one time and we never find someone sing so effortlestly perfect like her.
MUHAMMAD FAREEZ lol I’m a Mariah fan and I didn’t even notice the key was lowered, I was distracted by how good she sounded. She’s a queen indeed
I prefer this over the edited version
the run at 3:39 is crazy amazing
Surely 1995-1996 was her prime. Watching her hero lives since she was promoting the music box album you can crearly see that she reached her mark here. Daydream era, even thought it's a underrated era in its time, today we can figure out that she find herself there.
Her first prom is music box-daydream and her second prime is glitter-emancipation of mimi
No, her prime is obviously 1990-1991. Her Emotions live were far superior in the first two years.
@@Lanny985 I disagree, music box is so connected and vocally balanced
who cares if it's dubbed or not, she still sounds amazing.
"who cares if it's dubbed or not, she still sounds amazing."
Sentence makes no sense at all. dubbed , sounds.. thats the whole point dumbass
exactly!
Rowan W To be technical, the term dubbed in music is a sort of layering. I don't get what this person is saying as well. This video is of the undubbed vocals. The polished version is this live vocal track dubbed with another live performance. I think it's the 96' Tokyo performance.
Kurtis Edwards Nonsense. She couldn't have dubbed this with Tokyo Dome because this was released in late '95 and Tokyo Dome wasn't until March '96.
This production and vhs wasn't released until 97'
RAWriah over DUBBEDriah, any day.
at tokyo dome is her very best performance ever
try her daydream rotterdam , she hit the G5 twice :-)
@@heartache091298 she only hits G5 in rotterdam once. "The way" was a F#5.
@@heartache091298 she only hits G5 in rotterdam once. "The way" was a F#5.
This can't be anymore perfect.
I dont know if the intention of this video is that we think that she´s a bad singer, but when the song ends I just think... she sounds amazing. A mini second doesn't matter when she makes you feel in heaven 4 minutes!!!!!
oh no this was definitely to prove her wildly perfect vocals
she's the best vocalist!
Definitely one of the best singers EVER
she is the best singer who ever walked on this planet...
Did anyone notice the run at 3:31? It was beautiful. I dont know why they dubbed these part
Julian Candra Mariah as well as her team wanted to picture her as vocal perfection. She is incredible but not perfect...this adds to her self-consiousness about her voice.
Sony. That's why.
You forgot, she wasn't signed under a Record label, she was signed under a Corporation.
but the run was better in this version. they destroyed the run in the dubbed version. it sounds worse there and soooo much better here. i would understand if they would've dubbed it to make it sound better (not possible), but they made it actually sound worse.
"they destroyed"? no. she. they didn't force her to sing another run.
MCsVoice97 no. *they* as in columbia/sony. as in the same people that planted a seed of insecurity in mariah to the point that she didn't even think her peerless daydream vocals were good enough when in reality that just wasn't the truth.
So beautiful, powerful and resonant!❤️👌 Gave me goosebumps!😱
That flair at 1:43-1:46
finally i found the version...when i was a kid i watched this on a VCD...but with better sound effect and edit...damn
fantastic voice !! She is alive legend !!
omg, this sounds better than the dubbed version. why the hell would they dub it? its so beautiful & perfect!
This concert was dubbed cuz of all the crazy fans screaming in the background lol 0:41
Wft that makes no sense at all.
This audio is from an amateur recording.
The professional undubbed footage would have sound cleaner and you wouldn't hear the audience that loud.
It's normal for a show. Cuz there's Mariah in front of them.
Mariah is very pretty.. I love you Mariah. My hi school crush in the 90s. I missed those days
even better than dubbed!
Whoever posted this video, whoever you are, god bless you
That TONE alone is enough for me ❤️
Her voice still was just as good, it was even better she still was hitting F5's , F#5's, G5's and even G#5's effortlessly!
No G#5
@luisjla She did the note here, its hard to hear but it here. She did it at tokyo, rotterdam, london, paris and peace officers memorial. She was in great voice in this era, she didnt start having consistent rough vocal days until 1997 mainly.
I love mariah but she never hit the G5 in MSG. It was clearly a F5. Its true that the rest of her tour concerts she did reach the note
Voice of an angel
The undubbed "the wayayaaaayaYayaYay" is much better than dubbed ones.
Breathtaking
Mariah is magic ✨️
Angel voice ❤❤❤❤
3:30. I know...it's been said. 3:30. I'm dead.
Imagine doing this soulful artwork for so long and then someone who was born yesterday comes saying you cannot do it…
wow..thank you MLCQUOTES!!!...I LOVE IT!
@jmgomez007 you are so right, anyway the "dubbed" version sounded exactly like this, only without the stupid background noises.
This is really nice!
@closemyeyes94 and also Mariah Carey At Tokyo Dome 1996 DVD is turly live
It seems as if she touched the G#5 and then descended back down to an F5. Which proves that she did in fact go back in the studio and dub everything over. I hate to admit it, but this is just something that Mariah has always done.
No G#5. It’s F#5
Featuring unedited original screams from audience
there no different on dubbed version, just make clearly audition to hear that function on dubbed
the undubbed version is so much better because
the dubbed is all out of order and doesnt seem right haha
Wait, I know it's accepted "the way" in this undubbed is an F5, but does anyone else hear a brief G/G#5 with earphones??
ilovetati91 “tear them away” and “survive” are very disappointing compare to the edited version
@@brucish Tear them away is better undubbed for me
ilovetati91 why is that?
in the dubbed version at 3:06 why did they add in that higher note?
They didn't add the note it is there but not very loud so they made it more audible. Listen carefully.
+GeneralRelativity Yeah i just relistened a couple more times to compare and this one she goes high then low. And in the dubbed she just soars way higher. It could just be different performances idk
Crissy Y of course they did, in this version the high note is an F#5 in the dubbed version they changed to G#5
@@nikolasmattos7895 the high note here is F5. The dubbed version had G5.
@RomuloVideos2
She did it, you just cant hear it that well
I’m sorry but this is definitely better than the “refined” version.
I think maybe they do different takes on songs and pick what more flattering and combine those into one video. I think i see that on other song before they do many takes of her singing the song over and over.
The infamous high note still there just shorter.
They added a robotic flavor to the dubbed performances, I was fascinated by those robotic notes on the dubbed versions, I am just a little disappointed cause All the robotic notes I used to be obsessed with were in fact dubbed, it is not here, but DONT get me wrong, that was FUCKING brilliant, OUT OF THIS WORLD!!!
2:39 she sang the original key..
+Andrey Baldove No, its higher then a b4, it peaked F5
zanoa ses I just realized that months ago :)
+zanoa ses peak at g5
@@wadahitil2245 it was F5. Didnt peak G5. "The way" is also F5.
Hi There Again Mariah, I said that I was wondering are you still Definitely sure that you and your Bandmates are going to do some Re-writing, Re-mixing and Re-extending it in the other way round word lyrics and Re-extending the word Lyrics But sing it in you’re own Extended Word Lyrics for all of us fans Pretty Please Mariah Carey? and sing it differently in the exact different versions for all of us Fans and just Reuse the Original extended Background songs For this particular song from the Korgis, Everybody's Got To Learn Sometime, why don’t you and you’re band Replace the Synthesizer Strings Sound for Those Two Deeper Musette Accordion’s and make those Two Musette Accordion’s 4 to 7 and a half times more Deeper then the Original Synthesizer Strings Sound that they have used for this Purticular Extended Type of Original Background Song Called Everybody's got to Learn Sometime From The Korgis Pretty Please Lovely Mariah? and also Replace the Xylophone Sound to a 47 and a Half Times More Lower Chime Bells And Even a 56 and a Half Times More Lower Still Drums Sound Because it is Still one of my Very Very Very Very Very Very Favourite original Extended Type of Background Songs Ever Since I was about 10 Years of Age Thank You Very Very Very Very Very Much for you and your Bandmates support X😉X🎈X 😉X ❤X 😉X🎈X 😉X ❤X😉X ❤X😉X🎈X 😉X🎈X 😉X❤X😉X🎈X😉X❤X😉X
@luisjla WOOWWWW at your comments i just said thats what i heard sounds like she touches it, please i dont not worship the woman she is a human and i know that. Not a delusional fan just someone with opinions. Chill out geez, God is the only person worth worshiping. That was extremely uneccesary you dont need to tell me that smh.
I think in 3:27 when she switches to falseto she hit the wrong note and fixed it with that beautiful run, that is why she dubbed it
3:06 so it wasn't a G#5 after all, it was a F#5
she hit f/f#5 on the way part I confirmed it
F5.
You have to dub and edit this performance to get rid of the wild screaming fans
@luisjla aww its ok i understand there alot of really annoying mariah stans out there, they can be pretty sick and have no life. I understand no worries :)
This was mariah's prime era
where is her G#5 note???
You make me laugh about explanation about notes g5 ect...😂😂😂😂 I don t think most of the people care about all those technics things ...
Then why did she dub tho? This was decent enough.
I still sad that they dubbed this performance 😭
They whole concert was dubbed. They took out the entire verse on Always Be My Baby as well
I love both version.. as long as it is her voice.
@WhitneyElizabethH Yeah, maybe she hitted... It's a little confused...
But I don't care... It's great here... The only thing that I'm sure she didn't hit was the F5 at "you can survive"
Rômulo Rocha
she didnt hit it
Her voice sounds whiny and annoying in the dubbed version. I prefer this one.