Yes, she was struggling, but "the waaaayyyyy" (from 3.07 to 3.10) transformed into a downward run is a stroke of pure musical genius and extraordinary vocal skills. Amazing!
Is very odd how she didn't lower the key considering she did struggle, but her tone, agility and power is still impressive. It's even odder how nowadays she doesn't have that elasticity or power, but attempts the higher notes?? I know the key is lower now, but even still.
I guess this was the last time she sang this song in the original key. Don't know why she made the key higher here when she lowered it during the incredible Daydream era...
I don't know a singer with such respect for her fans as Mariah. ALWAYS showed affection for all of us. A great artist, an unparalleled talent. Until today!
This is fully live performance with few notes being dubbed. (I thought some parts are lipped many years ago, but now I changed my mind.) 2:39 E5, one of the parts that many people discuss, is dubbed, the original B4 can be heard if we wear earphones, though it is nearly inaudible.
I love this performance, it's very raw and sincere. It doesn't sound dubbed, because her dubbed performances are flawless and here there are a lot of "flaws" like the run at 3:46. I believe this is completely live, and the notes she hits at 2:38 and 3:12 are surprising considering her voice's condition this night.
Both the notes you mentioned are sadly dubbed… but it does look like she hit the eb5 in ‘lord’! So if we ever find the undubbed we will probably hear an amazing ‘lord’
After watching her Music Box performances, it's really sad to see her how she struggles singing this song here, but it was smart from her to ask the audience to sing along since she couldn't handle the entire song by herself. She would have gotten really tired. Love MC
I watched this decades ago...this in japan live..HERO IS ALWAYS WONDERFUL RAW LIVE🎤🎵🎶👍👍👏...doing promo of CANT TAKE THAT AWAY ( that was dubbed though )
@@ARlANACAREY how do u know if this performance is dubbed and not just lipped? why arent these vocals the raw undubbed vocals that the audience witnessed and heard?
Tone is beautiful. But it just seems so weird to randomly go back to singing it in higher key when it was even lowered in her prime years. She dodged basically the whole song
This performance was so weird!!! Why did she sing it in the higher key but dodged all the high notes? I guess they couldnt find the track with the lower key
I’m guessing she was planning to keep it in original key permanently after the Pavarotti show but then after struggling with this and then her voice tiring out even more from other songs she decided to keep it low, it’s the only thing I can think of
Maybe because at this point her voice was more comfortable with singing more parts in the original key rather than the lowered ver. idk sometimes when I sing too its like this where dending on the day my voice will need a different key but at the same time i would sing better parts of another key.
@@DarrenHazel it's very tricky tbh. At some point the performance sounds like it had dubbed studio vocals over it , and there's a possibility Mariah only did a B4 in 'lord' bc the B4 improv would fit with how she sang 'knows' then they just dubbed it with the studio E5.
sweetheart MARIAH SOUNDED 1 BILLION PERCENT AMAZING WHEN SHE STRUGGLE SINGIN COMPARE TO YOUNGE VOCALIST TODAY KATY PERRY? TAYLOT SWIFT? NAAAAH NOT EVEN CLOSE!
This was also during a very difficult time in her personal life You may find a few similar performances of other songs during the 1999-2001 timeframe (not all songs, just a handful). She was very tired at this time and was not getting adequate nutrition nor rest. I appreciate the performance and I appreciate her stylistic choice to "the way" in a descent of notes. Many artists do not have the range to have that option so kudos to Mariah for that and for giving her best at the time. I enjoy all of her performances.
Is it just me or does it seem like she is suffering from a sort of manic episode during this performance. Her antics and all over the place and kind of random.
@@Fishriah_Ari how do u know if this performance is dubbed and not just lipped? why arent these vocals the raw undubbed vocals that the audience witnessed and heard?
![[HD/UNEDITED VOCALS] Mariah Carey & Pavarotti - Hero live at Pavarotti & Friends, June 1st 1999](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Lv9BaP0gTR4/mqdefault.jpg)
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
![[REMASTERED] Mariah Carey - Hero (Live on Capitol Hill 1996)](/img/1.gif)
Yes, she was struggling, but "the waaaayyyyy" (from 3.07 to 3.10) transformed into a downward run is a stroke of pure musical genius and extraordinary vocal skills. Amazing!
Ela cantou essa música 100% live, mas a edição cortou alguns pedaços e colocaram a versão de estúdio
"Just hold on" 2:54 I love how she lowers and raises her body in sync with her voice that lowers and rises.
She was picking up a flower that's why 😅
The way she dodge high notes is so amazing. The different tone she mades is like no other.
She is a good musician and know how to arranged melodies especially when she tired
3:07 - 3:10
"I like when I hear you sing..." what a beautiful soul
Is very odd how she didn't lower the key considering she did struggle, but her tone, agility and power is still impressive. It's even odder how nowadays she doesn't have that elasticity or power, but attempts the higher notes?? I know the key is lower now, but even still.
Also Mariah is majestically beautiful here. I still love her look during the Rainbow era.
She wanted to sing like this until she couldnt. :(
700gsteak lmfao. shut up
@@akosiiannn 💀💀
Even though the lower track is lower, I think this key is easier to sing, I don't know how to explain it, but this key is easier 🌟🌟
That "just hold on" at 2:54 is AMAZING.
I guess this was the last time she sang this song in the original key.
Don't know why she made the key higher here when she lowered it during the incredible Daydream era...
She sang hero in the original key also during the Pavarotti and Friends, but in a better way.
I think she lowered it so she can do more vocal acrobatics
@@mariakorrey1875 Exactly
I think she lowered it so she can hit the G5, otherwise it's risky for her to sing a G#5
@@OmarHawari im confused. Why is that?
@@thekarlberonio2139 because the G#5 is higher thus harder
I like this version, His tone is beautiful and the climax lower wow.
cinkey8 Omg LOLOLOL Mariah slayed so much you thought she became a guy?
Maria Korrey lmao
Her
@@DannysKomedy 😂😂😂
@@mariakorrey1875 What do you mean?? Mariah is always a guy.
2:39 the playback on "Lord" blends so well with her voice
0:23 "heart" does too.
Fervid Amid the Dandelions I didn't notice "heart" is also playback😂
Japan is so good at TV editing 😂
Lol 3:13 "comes" is also playback.
SHE NEED TO LIVE IN JAPAN LMAO
I don't know a singer with such respect for her fans as Mariah. ALWAYS showed affection for all of us. A great artist, an unparalleled talent. Until today!
2:38 well that clear E5 was unexpected. The playback kinda blended in with her live vocals
Relik_star22 I think it’s dubbed (the studio vocals appear to random for it to be lipped). She likely did a B4.
Solo12313 yeah probably but like it blends really nicely
Relik_star22 I agree, it reminds me of the “Hold on” attempts in 1998
It’s live, Mariah tends to hit random high not like that, even her vocals tired.
@@martygonzales615 i feel like its dubbed with studio E5 though idk
She sounds so beautiful on the original key
Mariah on her worst day destroys most on their best 😍
Jack Walker not really
Jack Walker Definitely not in this performance
Destroys all
She was tired here, look at her preformance with that guy with the different language
But the question remains why did she not use the other hero track with the lower key
I love "the way"
I love how she made a descending run in the "the way"..
2:42 OMG THAt tone scare me
Was very intense 😂😂
I love that one!!!!!!
I noticed that most of MC’s performances in Japan are live. I envy all of the lambs in Japan who were able to watched her performed live. 😢
That’s because they adore her there unlike here in the US where we scrutinize her for everything.
This is fully live performance with few notes being dubbed. (I thought some parts are lipped many years ago, but now I changed my mind.) 2:39 E5, one of the parts that many people discuss, is dubbed, the original B4 can be heard if we wear earphones, though it is nearly inaudible.
I think this is my favorite performance of Hero. I like they way she sang in the climax in a downward run. Amazing!
I have to agree 100%
Legend says Mariah still haven't brought a person up on that stage to this day.
😂😂😂
He's still waiting in Zurich. :)
"Can I bring somebody else up at the stage... Co'mon." I heard and I understood it... Am I wrong? I'm brazilian.. help.
@@SomewhereOnTheOutside that's correct.
@@daydream10.18 Thx very much 😊😊
I love this performance, it's very raw and sincere. It doesn't sound dubbed, because her dubbed performances are flawless and here there are a lot of "flaws" like the run at 3:46. I believe this is completely live, and the notes she hits at 2:38 and 3:12 are surprising considering her voice's condition this night.
Both the notes you mentioned are sadly dubbed… but it does look like she hit the eb5 in ‘lord’! So if we ever find the undubbed we will probably hear an amazing ‘lord’
@@mariahcareyunited are u actually sure it's dubbed? i dont think it's dubbed. She definitely didnt hit the eb5 in lord, it's lipped
@@mariahcareyunited this id not dubbed. Come on she's a mess during a lot of parts.
@@takemyhand1988 It's dubbed from Proctors Theater
@@heeheeriahNot dubbed, lipped.. i think
2:55 issss perfect. 💗
I love how she lowers and raises her body in sync with her voice that lowers and rises.
2:38 Little MiMi fooling us. 🤭
My queen looks so beautiful
I thought you hate her after 96?
@@musicboxtour5854 he stopped with his troll account a few years back
@@rosemont2283 what is it reject, compromise, accept xD
the bridge was a surprise :O
i love when she does 2:54 on "hold on"
2:34 the ascending runs inspired many singers today.
Descending runs in the "the wayyyy"
She looks absolutely pretty her skin FLAWLESS and hair silky shiny
Her tone was incredible❤
She gave a verbal cue in the beginning after "there's a hero" there's a verbal letting out of air she was pissed
On her worst she sounded much better than me on my best days :((
thats what i love about the queen MARIAH CAREY when she struggle she sound extra ordinary unlike other vocalist
After watching her Music Box performances, it's really sad to see her how she struggles singing this song here, but it was smart from her to ask the audience to sing along since she couldn't handle the entire song by herself. She would have gotten really tired. Love MC
癡風迷也愛聽Mariah Carey唱歌😍😘🎤🎵🎶
2:39 wtf just happened. That woke me the fugg up lmao
For me this is being smart. Mariah already proved herself since the 90's that she can SANG the phonebook.
I watched this decades ago...this in japan live..HERO IS ALWAYS WONDERFUL RAW LIVE🎤🎵🎶👍👍👏...doing promo of CANT TAKE THAT AWAY ( that was dubbed though )
Climax "the WAYYYYYYY...." has been lipped for many years.....this LIVE lower register is GOOD!!!infact....
Never seen this. Thought I'd seen them all.
2:39 E5!
Sadly that's playback, it blended really beautifuly tho
@@yuh8946 It blended with her vocal well
Red Segui it can’t be lipped ! You don’t just lip a single note for 1 sec is not how that works 😂! It’s live , just the nodules being strange as usual
Axelito it’s literally the studio version for 1 second LMFAO
@@ARlANACAREY how do u know if this performance is dubbed and not just lipped? why arent these vocals the raw undubbed vocals that the audience witnessed and heard?
She's so funny dodging the high notes by letting the audience sing it lmao
...yet clever...
Hahahhaa love it
yet smart and compassionate
Meu deeussss amooooo
before the climax was so epic :3
2:41 is sooooo goooddddd
Tone is beautiful. But it just seems so weird to randomly go back to singing it in higher key when it was even lowered in her prime years. She dodged basically the whole song
⚜ TH🦋NK YOU FOR THE M🎧SIC ⚜🕊
E3? 3:10
yup
0:20
Back to the original key.
Nanding Antonio ...that she just performed, which is difficult to do, not everyone has that ability to their credit.
3:04
DDRRREEEAaaams r hard to follow ow
but DOON'T YOU LET anyone, what
@@StevenSenjaya just hooold onwon... And their will be tomorrow, and in time you'll find the waaay yeyheheheheheheheheiyei
This performance was so weird!!! Why did she sing it in the higher key but dodged all the high notes? I guess they couldnt find the track with the lower key
mauro gentile this is the original key why she did it no one knows but she sounds good here
I’m guessing she was planning to keep it in original key permanently after the Pavarotti show but then after struggling with this and then her voice tiring out even more from other songs she decided to keep it low, it’s the only thing I can think of
Yeah maybe they just had the album version music.
Maybe because at this point her voice was more comfortable with singing more parts in the original key rather than the lowered ver. idk sometimes when I sing too its like this where dending on the day my voice will need a different key but at the same time i would sing better parts of another key.
The way she signed at 0:20 always takes me off 😅
❤
That voice 😭😭😭😭
Ended 2006 Mariah
SHE'S FOREVER FAMOUS
👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿
I heard " see lordd" was superb
Hibbie A, reminds me of Octopus Garden Song from Doodle Do
Original key!!!
FYI She did a duet with Mizuki Ichiro in July 1999
I can't find any footage of it 😢😢😢😢
Just imagine this would happen before 1998 or her prime 🤣🤣🤣
0:23 music box vibes
because it is- its lipped lmao
@@mariahcareyunited it's dubbed
She Sounds Like Chioma
1:21
Her strange behavior makes me think this was the onset of her breakdown that was in full swing a year or so later.
@@ii7670 ikr people be over analyzing it’s disgusting
Instrumental original
Yes, she sang it in original key
FYI instrumental original doesn’t has any background vocals
0:33 2:38
🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷❤️❤️❤️
Lord Know playback or live? Wow
izad Azmi everything was live but this was dubbed.
Cloud of Reverie comes in last chorus is dubbed too ;)
And the little "heart" at 0:24 hahaa so funny
Cloud of Reverie it’s not dubbed. It’s lipped.
@@DarrenHazel it's very tricky tbh. At some point the performance sounds like it had dubbed studio vocals over it , and there's a possibility Mariah only did a B4 in 'lord' bc the B4 improv would fit with how she sang 'knows' then they just dubbed it with the studio E5.
... 1:03
The way she sang this more powerful and masterfully than anything from 2018- on she just is so lazy with this song now
What show was this?
The “lord” was lipped?
Dubbed
Is it me or she's already sick of the song already that she had to ask for audiences participants to sing along....
The tone was great but that's about it. She's struggling. At-least she looked great.
All singers have weak and strong points. Mariah has given more than enough great live vocal performannces to prove she is one of the greats.
I don’t see and feel any struggle here. this is 1999-riah’s brand... dodging notes in exchange of creative runs, her musicality is great haha
I see this more as changing the original, which I like. Her voice and tone is sooo soo beautifully
sweetheart MARIAH SOUNDED 1 BILLION PERCENT AMAZING WHEN SHE STRUGGLE SINGIN COMPARE TO YOUNGE VOCALIST TODAY KATY PERRY? TAYLOT SWIFT? NAAAAH NOT EVEN CLOSE!
Wkwkwkkwkw she couldn’t reach the high notes 😅
Singing is not about high notes. Singing is about interpretation of the song. Singera choose notes which they think suits the interpretation.
she cant even hit the high note, What problem with her voice?
Her voice was really exhausted then
This was also during a very difficult time in her personal life You may find a few similar performances of other songs during the 1999-2001 timeframe (not all songs, just a handful). She was very tired at this time and was not getting adequate nutrition nor rest.
I appreciate the performance and I appreciate her stylistic choice to "the way" in a descent of notes. Many artists do not have the range to have that option so kudos to Mariah for that and for giving her best at the time. I enjoy all of her performances.
Is it just me or does it seem like she is suffering from a sort of manic episode during this performance. Her antics and all over the place and kind of random.
Nope just you. Your biased view is leading to delusions and paranoia.
No, but she is nervous and tired. she starts sighing at 0:20, because the key is original from the studio...
Many parts were lipped
@@ii7670 Just information.
They were dubbed with studio vocals
@@Fishriah_Ari how do u know if this performance is dubbed and not just lipped? why arent these vocals the raw undubbed vocals that the audience witnessed and heard?
@@Fishriah_Ari they weren't dubbed because the lipped parts suffer the same distortion as the live parts and it has the same stadium echo.
@@vg6761 it’s dubbed lol
2:38
3:13
2:39