Amazing list! Mario Galaxy 2 is my favorite Mario game and in my top 5 favorite games of all time! I also love Mario Galaxy 1, Odyssey, New Super Mario Bros Wii/U, 64 DS, Super Mario Bros 3, Mario World and every other game! Great video!
Love the writing in this. You explained the goods and bads in each game far better than I ever could. Here's my personally ranking: S Tier 1. Super Mario Odyssey 2. Super Mario Galaxy 3. Super Mario Galaxy 2 4. Super Mario 64 A Tier 5. Super Mario 3D World + Bowser's Fury 6. New Super Mario Bros. Wii 7. New Super Mario Bros. 8. Super Mario World 9. Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island (Yes I count this as a mainline title) 10. Super Mario Bros. 3 B Tier 11. New Super Mario Bros.2 12. Super Mario Sunshine 13. New Super Mario Bros. U 14. Super Mario Bros. 2 15. Super Mario 64 DS 16. Super Mario 3D Land C Tier 17. Super Mario Bros. 18. Super Mario Land 2 19. Super Mario Land F Tier 20. Super Mario Bros. The Lost Levels
Didn’t know what to expect with a ranking video from a small channel, but I have to say, I was super impressed with this video and enjoyed every minute of it. Great commentary, great energy, and actually funny bits.
I'm so happy I'm not the only one who prefers the DS version of Mario 64 over the original. Hell, I personally don't mind the controls. (Must be because I grew up playing the remake before the original)
I actually grew up with both versions at a similar time. I should be more nostalgic with the n64 version but the extra stuff makes the remake worthy and it improves on the few issues that I had with the original sm64. The fact that 3dland controls exactly how people tend to describe how 64ds controls is still weird to me. (64ds has the spyro dpad controls while 3dland has the crash bandicoot dpad controls.)
Here are my 10 favourites: - Super Mario Bros. - Super Mario Bros. 2 (Lost Levels) - Super Mario Bros. 2 (USA) - Super Mario Bros. 3 - Super Mario World - Super Mario 64 - New Super Mario Bros. Wii - Super Mario Galaxy - Super Mario Galaxy 2 - Super Mario Odyssey
My definitive ranking: 1) Super Mario Galaxy 2 2) Super Mario 64 3) Super Mario Galaxy 4) Super Mario Odyssey 5) Super Mario World 6) Super Mario Bros 3 7) Super Mario Sunshine 8) Super Mario 3D World 9) Super Mario 3D Land 10) New Super Mario Bros DS 11) New Super Mario Bros Wii 12) Super Mario Bros 13) New Super Mario Bros U/New Super Luigi U 14) Super Mario Bros 2 15) New Super Mario Bros 2 16) Super Mario Land 2 17) Super Mario Bros The Lost Levels 18) Super Mario Land
@@anordinaryuser5818As someone who didn’t grow up with SMB1 and doesn’t have any nostalgia for it, I honestly would put it that high, maybe even higher, because I like games that are very simple and easy to breeze through, plus I really like the way it controls (at first I didn’t, but once I got used to the way it controls it felt satisfying moving and breezing through the levels). I kind of liked that it didn’t have any flying power-ups, no overworld, no item houses, no ghost houses, no rideable companion even though I like Yoshi as a character, no collectibles/Star Coins, and no secret exits aside from the warp zones. I also liked how simple its level design was, and the length of its levels felt perfect to me.
while i agree overall on all of the choices, mario 3 is way... WAY too high. Its way worse than any new super mario bros game in my opinion. Did it invent the world map? yeah but thats not really a good point when mario 1 invented everything and yet its not that high up, and also the maps are way better in every new super mario bros game. Same with the themed worlds, it is very nice, but every game since then has done it better. Like giant world is a copy and paste of the first world with big blocks and enemies. Wow so original. While there technically are more powerups, most of them are kinda meh or have been improved in later games. The tanooki suit is just the super leaf, the super leaf is kinda fine but the cape feather is much better, the frog suit is only nieche in 10% of the levels, the goomba shoe is used in 1 LEVEL and the hammer suit is the only good power up in this game. The bosses argument is also kinda dumb. half of them are the same fight with boom boom, nothing even changes, all the nsmb games had way better bosses. The controls, at least in my opinion feel really dated. Mario only has 1 move... 1! The nsmb games have so much better controls. You can triple jump, ground-pound, wall jump, spin jump, and most importantly, twirl in the air! Oh and dont you dare say "it was good at the time" by that logic, tenis for 2 is the best video game, because there truly was no game like it and it was the best game when it came out. Mario 3 is just meh, i think every nsmb game is MILES ahed of it
Dude, was it so hard to make a section for Luigi U? I mean, you made a section for a remake and another DLC (yes, Bowser's Fury is basicly DLC due to it not being sold separately). Plus, you ranked NSMB lower than SML, wich doesn't makes sense, like, it's way more important to the franchiese, has better levels, it controls better, is longer, and has tuxedo Luigi!
If I rank every Paper Mario game, I'll have to rank the rest of the Mario RPGs with it, namely the SNES game, the Mario and Luigi series, and Mario + Rabbids.
I'm gonna make a list only on how fun these games are to me and not how influential they are and these are my personal opinions (I don't really like open world games) 18: Super Mario Bros 2 aka SMB the lost levels 17: New Super Mario Bros 2 aka COINS 16: Super Mario Land 15: Super Mario Bros aka the first game 14: Super Mario Bros 2 aka Doki Doki panic 13: Super Mario 3D land AKA reminder that the 3DS has 3D 12: New Super Mario Bros Wii aka just a 2D Mario game to me 11: New Super Mario Bros aka the revive of the series 10: Super Mario Odyssey aka the most loved Mario game and IMO the most overrated Mario game 9: Super Mario Land 2 aka one of the most underrated Mario games 8: New Super Mario Bros U aka the ranking I'm gonna get the most hate for but I weirdly love it 7: Super Mario 64 aka The first Mario 3D game 6: Super Mario Sunshine aka Bowser can talk also unique in a great way 5: Super Mario World aka the most loved 2D Mario game 4: Super Mario Bros 3 aka another on of the most loved 2d Mario games 3 Super Mario Galaxy aka Mario kart 8 2: Super Mario 3D World aka 2D Mario game in 3D 1: Super Mario Galaxy 2. Do I really need to say more about mario galaxy 2
I completely agree with Odyssey. Imo it's the total definition of good but not great. For me, the main game was way too easy (I beat it in an afternoon). And the post game was really tedious and a total waste of time.
Probably between 3D World and 64. Even then, I consider it a Yoshi game rather than a mainline Mario game (“Super Mario World 2” was slapped on the title for branding)
These non-criterion lists are stupid. What is the criteria for putting super mario land 1 and 2 ahead of super mario 3d land? If it's for what they represented in their time, SMB 1 and SM64 were the first two on the list. Super Mario Galaxy 1 and 2 for me are undoubtedly the best, but the criterion doesn't exist unless it's just personal opinion.
Everyone saying that fucking super mario world is the best mario game and 2d platformer in the series makes me wanna say it's the most overrated Mario platformer
Ngl, I deadass thought you were Schaffrillas Productions and I was like “I knew that Galaxy star ranking meant something”
Amazing list! Mario Galaxy 2 is my favorite Mario game and in my top 5 favorite games of all time! I also love Mario Galaxy 1, Odyssey, New Super Mario Bros Wii/U, 64 DS, Super Mario Bros 3, Mario World and every other game! Great video!
Great video! I love this franchise so much. Really need Mario's next mainline adventure already. And I really hope its a fresh and exciting one.
Love the writing in this. You explained the goods and bads in each game far better than I ever could.
Here's my personally ranking:
S Tier
1. Super Mario Odyssey
2. Super Mario Galaxy
3. Super Mario Galaxy 2
4. Super Mario 64
A Tier
5. Super Mario 3D World + Bowser's Fury
6. New Super Mario Bros. Wii
7. New Super Mario Bros.
8. Super Mario World
9. Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island (Yes I count this as a mainline title)
10. Super Mario Bros. 3
B Tier
11. New Super Mario Bros.2
12. Super Mario Sunshine
13. New Super Mario Bros. U
14. Super Mario Bros. 2
15. Super Mario 64 DS
16. Super Mario 3D Land
C Tier
17. Super Mario Bros.
18. Super Mario Land 2
19. Super Mario Land
F Tier
20. Super Mario Bros. The Lost Levels
Didn’t know what to expect with a ranking video from a small channel, but I have to say, I was super impressed with this video and enjoyed every minute of it. Great commentary, great energy, and actually funny bits.
You haven’t lived if you’ve never played super Mario world
Love the video! I can’t wait for the next mainline Mario game
I was also thinking about the whole "Why do we still NSMB New" thing in how it's over a decade and a half old.
I'm so happy I'm not the only one who prefers the DS version of Mario 64 over the original. Hell, I personally don't mind the controls. (Must be because I grew up playing the remake before the original)
I actually grew up with both versions at a similar time. I should be more nostalgic with the n64 version but the extra stuff makes the remake worthy and it improves on the few issues that I had with the original sm64.
The fact that 3dland controls exactly how people tend to describe how 64ds controls is still weird to me. (64ds has the spyro dpad controls while 3dland has the crash bandicoot dpad controls.)
Mario Galaxy is genuinely a masterpiece. It had a good story, the soundtrack is amazing, and the first video game to ever make me cry, ya not kidding
Believe it or not, I also cried when I beat it.
@@lightrxvers3888 yeah man I rarely cry at video games but this was one of the few that genuinely got me
I was 22 when it came out and bought it on boxing day. So much fun. Felt like I was 12 all over again
how the hell do you only have 770 subs i thought it said 770k your editing is crazy good and the voice over is super high quality
Here are my 10 favourites:
- Super Mario Bros.
- Super Mario Bros. 2 (Lost Levels)
- Super Mario Bros. 2 (USA)
- Super Mario Bros. 3
- Super Mario World
- Super Mario 64
- New Super Mario Bros. Wii
- Super Mario Galaxy
- Super Mario Galaxy 2
- Super Mario Odyssey
I got Galaxy for my 6th birthday in 2009, and I’ve always loved it, I don’t have anything new to say about the game
This is brilliant
My definitive ranking:
1) Super Mario Galaxy 2
2) Super Mario 64
3) Super Mario Galaxy
4) Super Mario Odyssey
5) Super Mario World
6) Super Mario Bros 3
7) Super Mario Sunshine
8) Super Mario 3D World
9) Super Mario 3D Land
10) New Super Mario Bros DS
11) New Super Mario Bros Wii
12) Super Mario Bros
13) New Super Mario Bros U/New Super Luigi U
14) Super Mario Bros 2
15) New Super Mario Bros 2
16) Super Mario Land 2
17) Super Mario Bros The Lost Levels
18) Super Mario Land
Good list, Happy Mar10 Day🥳🥳🥳
My Ranking:
18.Lost Levels
17.NSMB2
16.NSMBU
15.SMB2
14.SML2
13.SML
12.NSMB
11.3D Land
10.Odyssey
9.Sunshine
8.NSMBW
7.SMW
6.64
5.SMG2
4.SMG
3.SMB
2.SMB3
1.3D World
There's no way SMB 1 is that high 💀
@@anordinaryuser5818As someone who didn’t grow up with SMB1 and doesn’t have any nostalgia for it, I honestly would put it that high, maybe even higher, because I like games that are very simple and easy to breeze through, plus I really like the way it controls (at first I didn’t, but once I got used to the way it controls it felt satisfying moving and breezing through the levels). I kind of liked that it didn’t have any flying power-ups, no overworld, no item houses, no ghost houses, no rideable companion even though I like Yoshi as a character, no collectibles/Star Coins, and no secret exits aside from the warp zones. I also liked how simple its level design was, and the length of its levels felt perfect to me.
If I wasn't Super Mario World I was gonna report this video as a hate crime lol
I’m so unbelievably flabbergasted how I’m the actual fuck is super Mario 3D land so loa
I smell lots of Tamatoa in this video, lol
I have yet to see a ranking video of Mario games that doesn’t say “the one that started it all”
Jokes aside, great list.
Hey, did you base your ranking format off of Schaffrillas Productions? I dig it, if so.
while i agree overall on all of the choices, mario 3 is way... WAY too high. Its way worse than any new super mario bros game in my opinion. Did it invent the world map? yeah but thats not really a good point when mario 1 invented everything and yet its not that high up, and also the maps are way better in every new super mario bros game. Same with the themed worlds, it is very nice, but every game since then has done it better. Like giant world is a copy and paste of the first world with big blocks and enemies. Wow so original. While there technically are more powerups, most of them are kinda meh or have been improved in later games. The tanooki suit is just the super leaf, the super leaf is kinda fine but the cape feather is much better, the frog suit is only nieche in 10% of the levels, the goomba shoe is used in 1 LEVEL and the hammer suit is the only good power up in this game. The bosses argument is also kinda dumb. half of them are the same fight with boom boom, nothing even changes, all the nsmb games had way better bosses. The controls, at least in my opinion feel really dated. Mario only has 1 move... 1! The nsmb games have so much better controls. You can triple jump, ground-pound, wall jump, spin jump, and most importantly, twirl in the air! Oh and dont you dare say "it was good at the time" by that logic, tenis for 2 is the best video game, because there truly was no game like it and it was the best game when it came out. Mario 3 is just meh, i think every nsmb game is MILES ahed of it
This is a good video
Happy Mario Day!
I have a lot of disagreements, but good video!
Dude, was it so hard to make a section for Luigi U? I mean, you made a section for a remake and another DLC (yes, Bowser's Fury is basicly DLC due to it not being sold separately). Plus, you ranked NSMB lower than SML, wich doesn't makes sense, like, it's way more important to the franchiese, has better levels, it controls better, is longer, and has tuxedo Luigi!
Paper Mario ranking video?
YOU HAVE TO
If I rank every Paper Mario game, I'll have to rank the rest of the Mario RPGs with it, namely the SNES game, the Mario and Luigi series, and Mario + Rabbids.
@@platy4700 YOU KNOW WHAT THAT MEANS
ITS TIME TO FACE YOUR WORSE ENEMY
@@wakspacific6928 I’m not replaying all of them for the video. Besides, I played far enough into Color Splash for THAT to count.
New Super Mario Bros. U is one of the best 2D Mario games, dare I say top 3 with Super Mario Bros. 3 and Super Mario World.
I'm gonna make a list only on how fun these games are to me and not how influential they are and these are my personal opinions (I don't really like open world games)
18: Super Mario Bros 2 aka SMB the lost levels
17: New Super Mario Bros 2 aka COINS
16: Super Mario Land
15: Super Mario Bros aka the first game
14: Super Mario Bros 2 aka Doki Doki panic
13: Super Mario 3D land AKA reminder that the 3DS has 3D
12: New Super Mario Bros Wii aka just a 2D Mario game to me
11: New Super Mario Bros aka the revive of the series
10: Super Mario Odyssey aka the most loved Mario game and IMO the most overrated Mario game
9: Super Mario Land 2 aka one of the most underrated Mario games
8: New Super Mario Bros U aka the ranking I'm gonna get the most hate for but I weirdly love it
7: Super Mario 64 aka The first Mario 3D game
6: Super Mario Sunshine aka Bowser can talk also unique in a great way
5: Super Mario World aka the most loved 2D Mario game
4: Super Mario Bros 3 aka another on of the most loved 2d Mario games
3 Super Mario Galaxy aka Mario kart 8
2: Super Mario 3D World aka 2D Mario game in 3D
1: Super Mario Galaxy 2. Do I really need to say more about mario galaxy 2
I completely agree with Odyssey. Imo it's the total definition of good but not great. For me, the main game was way too easy (I beat it in an afternoon). And the post game was really tedious and a total waste of time.
Happy Mar10
0:10 HEY! NOT EVERYONE HAS AN NINTENDO!!!!! so NOT EVERYONE CAN PLAY MARIO!!!!! @PALTYY!!🤬
I was about to say that lol true 👍
But you've at least heard of Mario or seen gameplay of it (Or used an emulator)
Curious where would you put Yoshi’s Island in this list? It IS Super Mario World 2 after all.
Probably between 3D World and 64. Even then, I consider it a Yoshi game rather than a mainline Mario game (“Super Mario World 2” was slapped on the title for branding)
13:59 🍄💨
AINT NO WAY BRO PUT SUPER MARIO BROS ABOVE NSMB, NSMB2, AND NSMBU💀💀💀
Thoughts on a “Cars is an underrated Classic” video?
I doubt it at this rate, to be honest.
These non-criterion lists are stupid. What is the criteria for putting super mario land 1 and 2 ahead of super mario 3d land? If it's for what they represented in their time, SMB 1 and SM64 were the first two on the list. Super Mario Galaxy 1 and 2 for me are undoubtedly the best, but the criterion doesn't exist unless it's just personal opinion.
Have you considered getting some editors.
I have, but my following is limited, and I doubt I can even pay them a sufficient amount. So I just break my back editing my videos myself.
The lost levels is one of my favorites. It's not that damm hard if you practice jfc
And besides I prefer (super Mario bros 3) and (new super mario bros wii) anyways
Everyone saying that fucking super mario world is the best mario game and 2d platformer in the series makes me wanna say it's the most overrated Mario platformer
12:00 what the heck was that?
Jibanyan from Yo-Kai Watch
My brother is infinix and infinity sega pls upload my brothers game
NOW LOADING…
Sooo where's that Zelda ranking?
Still working on it
11:10
Bad list