Dan Domenech Always Dan Domenech Not even just the “don’t open a vein” part. It’s just so colorful the way he sings up to that point. Plus his production was the first I saw and I’m just in love.
1. Dan Domenech ( That riff was PERFECT ) 2. Ryan McCartan ( Do I even have to explain the reason? ) 3. Thomas Sanders ( He lowered the key but still amazing )
While I’m disappointed that Thomas didn’t get all the way up there, I appreciate that he knows his limits and when to take an alternate melody unlike some of these other dudes... But also Dan slays my existence every time.
1.) Ryan McCartan (he’s just the perfect JD imo) 2.) Dan Domeneck (that high note was goals!) 3.) Jamie Muscato (just really solid all around) 4.) Zachariah Sterner (loved the emotion, you could really feel his pain) 5.) Thomas Sanders (that alternative riff he did was beautiful!)
Dan Domenech. Always Dan Domenech. The pain and the emotion in his voice. Just. Just Dan Domenech. Like everyone doing it the same and he’s like nah, I’m gonna hit the high note over here. I can’t even, I’m fangirling so hard. Dan Domenech. (also Thomas Sanders because he’s freaking Thomas Sanders what else should I say tf)
Lol agreed. I liked Dan's because he hit the high notes super well and for Thomas Sanders, his was super unique and smooth. Also, I love Thomas as well so of course he's going to be one of my favs lol ☺
I honestly prefer Dan because he makes it like an actual person. He also has lots of emotion. Next, Ryan because he does it great, and has the psycho part down, but he's more of a character than a person. The others are acceptable, but Dan and Ryan are my favorites.
Why is nobody talking about Zachariah? He was an absoulutley brilliant JD with an amazing voice. Definitely deserves more credit because he fit that role so well.
It was a short clip of each Heathers songs that was put together in a video on Heathers The Musical's official channel. it's not really what you're expecting it is though.
Zachariah Sterner's Heathers production was the first one I watched and I still think he was such a brilliant JD. He perfectly captured the charming but still psychotic charcter that JD is and really was just perfect for the role. Anyone else agree?
Kylie Smith *YESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYES*
My faves: 1. Dan Domenech (homeboy did not have to go that hard on that 'open a vein' but he did and he has earned my respect) 2. Zachariah Sterner (Give. My. Boy. The. Love. He. Deserves. Also the way he sings "back on the road" is amazing) 3. Wendell Scherer (again, boy did not have to go that hard but he did, also I feel like he brings out JD's twitchy insanity) 4. Me in the shower
My favs: Ryan McCartan (because you can’t go wrong with the original), Jeremy Jordan (because he is literally one of my favorite people ever), Thomas Sanders (because Thomas...is there anything more needed to be said), and Zachariah Sterner (because his production was the first I found and I fell in love immediately) Edit: one year later and I didn't realize this comment blew up wow thanks guys!! Also I must now add Jamie Muscato to my list as I found a bootleg of the West End Heathers and let me tell you I had chills going through my entire body when he sang the Freeze Your Brain climax. This video did not do him justice at all.
yeah i love that his voice has a little roughness but it doesn’t stop him from hitting those notes. some of these guys’ voices were just too sweet. strong and hit the notes and everything they just didn’t have the same rasp i always though JD would have.
@@papyrus8983his 'yee haw' is a bunch of accents he put on to show how often jd moves around, he's 100% my favourite jd and the accent adds to much character in my opinion
Aw, wish you guys could hear what Wendell sounded like at every other performance when he nails the high note! Maybe we'll have to record him singing it again...
I actually liked this version, it somehow fit into the character and he's just soooo awesome. Your version is simply uncanny, love you so much. And yesssss record the whole thing as many times as you want, you're both such awesome performers.
0:18 Ryan McCartan 0:42 Cale Singelton 1:06 Stephen Madsen 1:30 Jonathan Markham 1:55 Wendell Scherer 2:21 Sebastian Amoruse 2:48 Dave Thomas Brown 3:14 Ben Brache 3:39 Nathan Cockroft 3:57 Jamie Muscato 4:20 Michael Hajjar 4:46 Kamyar Pagandeh 5:09 Ryan Glander 5:34 Tyler Fernandez 5:58 Travis Ward-Osborne 6:22 Mikey Marmann 6:48 Jeremy Jordan 7:10 Thomas Sanders 7:33 Charlie Meredith 7:57 Chet Davine 8:24 Ian Smith 8:46 Scott Montgomery 9:09 Dan Domeneck 9:34 Zachariah Sterner sorry if I wrote some names wrong
Ryan Mc Cartan 0:18 Cale Singleton 0:41 Stephen Madsed 1:06 Jonathan Markham 1:30 Wendell Scherer 1:55 Sebastian Amoruso 2:20 Dave Thomas Brown 2:48 Ben Brache 3:13 Nathan Cockroft 3:39 Jamie Muscato 3:57 Michael Hajjar 4:20 Kamyar Pazandeh 4:46 Ryan Glander 5:08 Tyler Fernandez 5:34 Travis Ward-Osborne 5:58 Mikey Marmam 6:22 Jeremy Jordan 6:47 Thomas Sanders 7:10 Charlie Meredith 7:34 Chet Davino 7:57 Jan Smith 8:23 Scott Montgomery 8:46 Dan Domenech 9:09 (Omg this is my fav ♥) Zachariah Sterner 9:34 I'm sorry if there's a spelling error or if I'm wrong about something (?
I know Ryan did it really well and most people like him but the way Dan went super hard on that last note and ended it so suddenly was amazing and left the silence afterward so much more stunning. It just has way more impact imo
The pictures taken of him in costume sell it, I don’t doubt his incredible acting for a SECOND but I would commit a murder to see a boot of his performance
4:45 I think this JD's director told him to "EMPITHIS EVERY NOTE" and he took it literally😅 5:58 this sounds like drunk karaoke 8:00 Veronica over here all like. "Yeah JD hurry it up I gotta go have Big Fun!"😏
Personally (coming from someone who has no idea about the technicalities of singing) I believe that Dan had the best vocal approach but nobody really captures JD’s personality like Ryan. The way he sang made him look and feel like a psycho haha. Everyone was amazing vocally but a lot of them forgot that they had to play a character while singing and Ryan just does such a good job of representing JD’s unstableness from the way he never blinks / never breaks eye contact but still moves his head. It’s very well done.
Ryan: Had the rock-edginess that made him the original Cale: Awesome vocals, but man he should work on his audience-facing movement Stephen: I like the contrast between Roughness and smoothness that he brings but I think he just sounds too mature Johnathan: Not a fan of the choppy diction but the big note was worth it Wendell: He was really taking it a little far with the ad-libs, but I like how he blends his stage charisma with the dark side of JD Sebastian: Lowered it half a step, but the F# sounded well placed and the run after was well executed but man, only having a piano to back sucks Dave: I like how bright his voice sounds but the top note did sound a little whiny and tense Ben: Strikes me as a little inexperienced, but he placed the note pretty well Nathan: Liking the vibrato after, but the top note Just felt a little... Faded? Jamie: Awesome! Effortless placement and awesome growl, and blends the characters anger and vulnerability perfectly. Michael: A little Nasal at the start, but the note came out very good, great vibrato Kamyar: Is the band going too fast or is it him? Every part aside from the big note was great, it just sounded quite tense Other Ryan: Like how he acts the brain-freeze, and the vocal was awesome too, but I guess it felt a bit... Innocent? Tyler: Big note was good, could tone down a little on the vibrato on the other parts Travis: Wish I could say I liked it but man, it just sounded really nasal and uncomfortable Mikey: That was a smooth riff up to Tenor C! Probably my favorite vocal but I got the impression he's just a little-mature sounding for my taste Jeremy: THERE HE IS. So I guess it didn't have a G belt originally, and the run was smooth as butter Thomas: Started off kinda nasaly, really loved the creative swing he had at the climax and it was run expertly. Charlie: Not really feeling this one, sounds kinda whiny and sharp. Wish I could say I liked it but ehhh Chet: Just a little flat, but everything else was fine Ian: Needs to practise singing with his hands in his pockets! Pretty good vocal though Scott: Loud, that's the word. Dan: Great vocal, no idea why he's just stood there neutrally though Zachariah: Tempo is a little underwhelming, vocal was smooth as butter though!
I agree, but you didn't do Dan justice. This riff was everything and his vocals were together with Jamies by far the best! Also that's a live clip from the show, standing there is literally in the choreography!
Everyone was pretty great, I LOVED seeing the different choices some of these guys took for JD's mannerisms during this part. I really liked Stephen, Dave, Ben, Nathan, Travis, Jonathan (proud to have done the show with him!), Mikey, Dan (always liked him better than Ryan), and Zachariah. But the two that really stood out to me were Wendell (his voice may have cracked but man he's got so much power in his voice) and Michael.
Zach, Ryan, and Thomas were my favs. Ryan was the original, so obviously he sings it amazingly. Zach was the first JD i ever heard and so he's still amazing. And Thomas was just as talented!
I know we’re all here for the voices, but I do like looking at the differences in all the costumes. It’s cool to see how different productions handle it :)
*MY OPINIONS* Ryan - beautiful, lovely 8/10 Cale - the last riff on “vein” was a tiny bit out of time I think, but still sooo good - also nice vibrato! 7/10 Stephen - I like the little push and squeak on the last riff 8/10 Jonathan - breathless but obviously I can understand that 8/10 Wendell - a lot of character, the start of the riff was strained but the end was good 7/10 Sebastian - less character but technically good 6/10 Dave - good breath control but he is standing still so 7/10 Ben - good character but some notes were not so good 6/10 Nathan - very good loved it so much! 8/10 Jamie - the JD I saw so maybe I’m biased, but I liked the push behind his notes 9/10 Michael - so so good and smooth, would give it 10 but he’s not dancing or anything so that would be unfair 9/10 Kamyar - his vowel on “vein” sounds weird and it’s very fast but I liked it 7/10 Ryan - good but not like standout 7/10 Tyler - I loved this and I don’t know why 10/10 Travis - his vowels sound weird to me and he’s straining but I like the voice crack 6/10 Mikey - I love the riff at the end!! 8/10 Jeremy - dodged the last riff but it’s actually really good 9/10 Thomas - the riff is interesting and I’m a big fan of the voice crack 10/10 Charlie - i like his voice haha 8/10 Chet - powerful! liked it 8/10 Ian - it’s technically good but it’s not sticking in my brain 7/10 Scott - so so lovely but he’s not moving so I can’t give him 10 8/10 Dan - MY FAVOURITE I love the riff so good and original and he’s just got such a lovely voice that I’m in love with 10/10 Zachariah - characterful, I like it and the little slides and voice cracks he adds in 9/10 All these singers are so so talented, so if my scores seem low it’s because I’m comparing them to each other and not just in general (if I was doing it generally I’d be forced to give them all 9s and 10s)
Dan dom has always been my favorite and he does it so well cause only a few people try to pull off the ruff that specific way and I've also always loved him, I was low key scared that he wouldn't be there cause he was at the end but bless up I love him
I'm pretty sure there is only 2 actors so far that have sung it (George Salazar and then someone else) so i don't think there is enough people available but I may be wrong.
I love that this channel doesn’t actually pick a winner. Most “Who sang it best videos” make it a competition and then pretty much say a bunch of them are shit. Sometimes I just want me a compilation. also wendell scherer was amazing. so was Ryan McCartan. same with Dave Thomas Brown. this was a horrible recording of Jamie Muscato, but he is SOOOO GOOD. He’s my favourite JD ever And so beautiful. If I wasn’t gay before I found him, he would have been my Gay Awakening. Ryan Glander was kinda cute. Tyler Fernandez was good. Smiley Marmann was really good, but he looked a little old..... JEREMY JORDAN WAS AMAZING I LOVE HIM. Thomas Sanders was fantastically beautifully amazing as per usual. Charlie Meredith was absolutely beautiful.
2:10-Wendell- I love the emotion he puts into it 2:53- David Thomson Brown- I like the slight psychotic-ness 6:47 it’s Jeremy frickin Jordan, of course it’s amazing 9:12- Holy Crap
My top five in order: 5. Me in the shower or maybe illegal heathers 4. Ryan McCartan (his is obviously a bit autotuned) 3. Wendell Scherer 2. Jamie Muscato 1. Dan Domenech Can people shut up about Ryan not being autotuned!? He isn't autotuned live, but the clip in this video is from a footage. Footages are supposed to be autotuned, it's fine.
@@kamypark7346 I actaully have seen Heather's 8 Times in New York and 9 Times in London. So yeah I saw Ryan. And this video is a footage and autotuned.
Antonia H. no he sang it live (not in heathers) like just him infront of tons of people and it definitely wasn’t auto tuned because he was talking before it and his voice was completely normal
Me: *Trying to take serious this part of the song * Video: *Savage photo of Thomas appears super happy as the cinnamon roll he is,but singing a depressing thing* Me: *W H E E Z I N G INTENSIFIES*
Jonathan, Ryan, Wendell, Thomas, and Dan did the best. Also, can you do the climax of "Lifeboat" or the climax of "Shine a Light" next? I love these videos.
DUDE HE SURPRISED ME LIKE HE WAS JUST MY GOD AH PERFECT. LIKE WITH NONE OF THE OTHERS DID I ACTUALLY LIKE PHYSICALLY REACT BUT TO HIM I WAS LIKE "0.0♡"
Merrick Baskie It probably didn’t evolve into what it was until the actual show. Jeremy’s version was from a concert in 2010. Kind off like how that concert version of Candy Store was really weak compared to the production
Honestly after listening to the West End cast recording no JD will ever beat Jamie Muscato for me. He manages to make JD pretty awkward and socially inept (as opposed to the charming psychopath you sometimes get) but that only makes him more terrifying in songs like Meant to be Mine - and I’m not exaggerating when I say terrifying, the only way I can describe his voice at some points is a roar - because he switches back and forth so quickly between vulnerable and dangerous, and I honestly think this makes him the most realistic JD as well. I can think of real people I know like this, and that is terrifying
Does your mommy know you eat all that crap?
Mister Golightly lOl nO
When mom was alive, yes.
not anymore
You’re planning your future, Veronica Sawyer
Abigail Acre FREEZE YOUR BRAIIIIIN!!!
the answer is me home alone screaming over the soundtrack
noodler doodler same sister
YASSSS
YEAHHH
The answer is my mom screaming back at me while I'm screaming the lyrics.
Get it right 🙄🙄 kidding 😂
I think that J.D was good, but J.D was better and J.D was my favorite.
Nah, i think J.D was the best.
Reagan Marie26 J.D is definitely the best
J.D is very good to
I have to disagree, I mean, J.D was good, but I think J.D was better.
DID YOU FORGET ABOUT J.D
Ryan McCartan really portrays “psycho” ya know?
But his understudy delivers the punchlines better
Camille The Gacha Queen
Thank you for this blessing
I mean.. He did abuse dove..
Tiffany Rodriguez he did!? I didn’t hear!!! What happened?!
We dont know exactly what happened between them
Dan Domenech
Always Dan Domenech
Not even just the “don’t open a vein” part. It’s just so colorful the way he sings up to that point. Plus his production was the first I saw and I’m just in love.
he plays jd so naturally imo. i know its musical theater but he doesnt seem so...cheesy to me haha I love him as JD
i heard him sing marry a lawyer and was like yup that one
YESS
I AGREE WITH THIS
1. Dan Domenech ( That riff was PERFECT )
2. Ryan McCartan ( Do I even have to explain the reason? )
3. Thomas Sanders ( He lowered the key but still amazing )
I mean, JD's a high tenor, and Thomas is a bass, so it's still super impressive how high he hit!
Agreed
I agree
SugarSweetSofia i have to agree buster
Wait what Ryan and Dan are different people???
Wtfff when i saw a bootleg of it i thought Dan was Ryan ;-----;
Ryan McCartan killed it. It is very had to follow the first person who started the role. Jeremy Jordan is a legend so he was awesome.
Wait but Ryan is the original.
Sorry if I got anything wrong but-
Abritistic Official
that’s why they said “it is very hard to follow the first person who started the role”.
Actually Jeremy is technically the original
erin_ NSU19
how so?
e v a Jeremy was JD in the concert reading in 2010 and in the six track demos in 2009
1. People who did the high riff watched the bootleg.
2. I applaud them for doing it.
Just realized that lol!!
Which ones did?
omg i do the high riff
and i only watched the bootleg
damn you zach!
I love how (almost) all of them were singing the climax the same way and Dan was just like *Nah ima just nail this high note over here*
Queeniebee LOL Dude, he won that for sure
Molk Boi litteraly he is so talebted
That’s why he’s my fav.
Yasss he is my favoriteeee
Dan: hold my slushie I'll show y'all how it's done
Who sings “pew pew pew” better😂
Courtney Michelle omg yes please!!!!!
And BAM BAM BAM
PLEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAASE!!!! XD
*PEW PEW PEW*
I want my ringtone to just be pew pew pew
While I’m disappointed that Thomas didn’t get all the way up there, I appreciate that he knows his limits and when to take an alternate melody unlike some of these other dudes...
But also Dan slays my existence every time.
Agreed. Danny Boi be the best.
Its so impressive what Thomas did with JD, a High Tenor character, when Thomas is a bass. It’s incredible how high he can actually hit
I really Thomas doing this cause I just like how he sings it
AND DAN
Bethany Qian ALWAYS
Thomas is always the best in my eyes!❤🧡💛💚💙💜🖤
1.) Ryan McCartan (he’s just the perfect JD imo)
2.) Dan Domeneck (that high note was goals!)
3.) Jamie Muscato (just really solid all around)
4.) Zachariah Sterner (loved the emotion, you could really feel his pain)
5.) Thomas Sanders (that alternative riff he did was beautiful!)
Dan Domenech. Always Dan Domenech. The pain and the emotion in his voice. Just. Just Dan Domenech.
Like everyone doing it the same and he’s like nah, I’m gonna hit the high note over here. I can’t even, I’m fangirling so hard.
Dan Domenech.
(also Thomas Sanders because he’s freaking Thomas Sanders what else should I say tf)
That one Hamilfan that needs Hamilton to breath :v FUCK YES I LOVE DAN 😭💕
Finally someone who said it. Dan fucking killed it. And in the starts, he had the best ending of phrases
True dan is Amazing
THANK YOU. I also love how Barrett is just eating snacks while Dan is bearing his soul. Those two are both my favorite Veronica and JD
Lol agreed. I liked Dan's because he hit the high notes super well and for Thomas Sanders, his was super unique and smooth. Also, I love Thomas as well so of course he's going to be one of my favs lol ☺
You should totally do “Who Yelled SHUT UP HEATHER The Best” Lol you should totally do it.
Adam Derb and they need to add illegal heathers to it
I was going to comment that!
DaniPlaysGamesYT great minds think alike
It’s in the “Who sang the Candy Store Climax better?” Video
I know, but we should just highlight the Shut Up Heather part. :P
ok why didnt you include illegal heathers
Illegal Heathers skipped Freeze Your Brain
Because those cowards didnt do it
We don’t talk about them....
In the depths of hell
They skipped it
I honestly prefer Dan because he makes it like an actual person. He also has lots of emotion. Next, Ryan because he does it great, and has the psycho part down, but he's more of a character than a person. The others are acceptable, but Dan and Ryan are my favorites.
Idk where the others are from but Dan and Ryan are the actual actors (Dan is understudy) in either broadway or west end can’t remember
@@c0dasaurus Pretty sure it's for Broadway there, cause Jamie was the one for West End
@@dysphanic_redshift yeah I think Ryan and Dan are broadway which is sad cuz I love Ryan but I’m seeing it on west end :/
@@c0dasaurus waut a second, is your name cody, are you trans and do u like heathers??? bcs im all of that
@@k4ttzkyo859 omg 💀 yes my names cody I like heathers and I’m trans 😂😂😂 I think we’re soulmates
Why is nobody talking about Zachariah? He was an absoulutley brilliant JD with an amazing voice. Definitely deserves more credit because he fit that role so well.
Kylie Smith YESEYESEYESEYESEYYES
Kylie Smith YES
YASSS
Yeahhhhh
AMEN
where did you get the professionally filmed footage of ryan
*_W H E R E_*
the heathers youtube channel has a video of clips of HD footage from a few songs but the full song isn't posted anywhere as far as I'm concerned
It was a short clip of each Heathers songs that was put together in a video on Heathers The Musical's official channel. it's not really what you're expecting it is though.
Angelica! bro i know!!!!!
Angelica! It’s on RUclips they are released clips
Is there... A full... Slime... tutorial?
My guy Wendell singing a completely different song
yes and it’s perfect
It hurt me a little bit
The pain
My ears
Don’t hate on my boy Wendell
Zachariah Sterner's Heathers production was the first one I watched and I still think he was such a brilliant JD. He perfectly captured the charming but still psychotic charcter that JD is and really was just perfect for the role. Anyone else agree?
Kylie Smith Definitely
100% agree
Kylie Smith *YESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYES*
Absolutely
Okay I'm using men grandma's account but YE FR SAME LIKE
My faves:
1. Dan Domenech (homeboy did not have to go that hard on that 'open a vein' but he did and he has earned my respect)
2. Zachariah Sterner (Give. My. Boy. The. Love. He. Deserves. Also the way he sings "back on the road" is amazing)
3. Wendell Scherer (again, boy did not have to go that hard but he did, also I feel like he brings out JD's twitchy insanity)
4. Me in the shower
I love the way he says "back on the road" it's so good!
Wendell earned ALL my respect, ALL OF IT.
Me in the shower is #1
Ong me in the shower>>>
My favs: Ryan McCartan (because you can’t go wrong with the original), Jeremy Jordan (because he is literally one of my favorite people ever), Thomas Sanders (because Thomas...is there anything more needed to be said), and Zachariah Sterner (because his production was the first I found and I fell in love immediately)
Edit: one year later and I didn't realize this comment blew up wow thanks guys!! Also I must now add Jamie Muscato to my list as I found a bootleg of the West End Heathers and let me tell you I had chills going through my entire body when he sang the Freeze Your Brain climax. This video did not do him justice at all.
Morgan Nelson agreed
Same but I don't like Ryan McCartan because of what Dove said....
Evie Long What did she say?
Lol same
Sometimes they can go wrong with the original... I mean, look at Sierra Boggess being one of the worst Stage Ariels
Honestly my favorite is Jamie Muscato. He added a lot of character to it AND hit the note perfectly
and his "Meant to be Yours" was the best
Papyrus he does kind of sound like goofy. But his meant to be yours as the most emotion. And you may have a different opinion
@Papyrus idk I liked his ‘yee haw-ness’ I loved it when he said “ Las Vegas to Boston” but anyway I think I might be biased because he’s my fave 😅😅
yeah i love that his voice has a little roughness but it doesn’t stop him from hitting those notes. some of these guys’ voices were just too sweet. strong and hit the notes and everything they just didn’t have the same rasp i always though JD would have.
@@papyrus8983his 'yee haw' is a bunch of accents he put on to show how often jd moves around, he's 100% my favourite jd and the accent adds to much character in my opinion
How's about: Who shouted "Veronicaaaaaa-ahhhh-aa!" before Freeze your Brain the best?
Oh I second this.
I third this
I fourth this
No point we all know illegal heathers wins this 😂😂😂
I sixth this
Dan will forever be my favourite JD, he captures an emotion that no others could do. (Plus watching him sing Seventeen makes my heart skip every time)
Because I am what? SICKENING same lol
But, Ryan?!?!?!
Zachariah is my favorite JD ever, hands down.
emily margaret tea
YES YES YES THANK YOU EXACTLY HE'S SO INSANELY AMAZING
OMG YES
For me:
1. Dan Domenech
2. Ryan McCartan
3. Thomas Sanders and Zachariah Sterner (tie)
i think i’ve seen you somewhere before
(P.S i like your glasses)
I agree I think Dan is has more feeling yes and vibrato yes, also he’s the first one I watched in the musical
Agree and I am Biased towards Ryan
Dan Domenech left me speechless surprises me everytime
AGREED
why is no one taking about jamie muscato? my man is hella talented :(
Sarcasmokay • jamie is the best J.D in my opinion
EXACTLY
I kr it's super sad :"(
He's deffo the best, but it wasn't very a very good quality sound so people haven't heard it properly
He is the best J.D
Aw, wish you guys could hear what Wendell sounded like at every other performance when he nails the high note! Maybe we'll have to record him singing it again...
I loved him!!! He's got so much power in his voice and honestly everyone gets cracks but I enjoyed his performance so much I didn't mind it.
Yeah I kinda felt bad for him at that moment... didn’t go as planned
Yes! Do it!
Olivia Rose Michaels HE HAS ME SHOOK
I actually liked this version, it somehow fit into the character and he's just soooo awesome. Your version is simply uncanny, love you so much.
And yesssss record the whole thing as many times as you want, you're both such awesome performers.
I came here for Thomas, not thinking he would be here-
AND HE'S HERE AND I LOVE HIM SO MUCH
I am 51 like! Hamilton wrote... tHE OTHER 51-
Stupid John Jay
John Jay after writing 5: aight imma head out
Me too!!
Same Gurl-
ryan’s pretty cool, thomas is underrated, but dan gives me chills.
Why is like no one in the comments talking about Dan?!?! His was freaking amazing??
doublepistol.s dude ikr
Dan and Ryan by far are the best I mean who can go wrong with the og cast and understudy 😂
doublepistol.s it was!! And such an original melody change. I noticed some of the others took inspiration from his version!
Not to mention he’s also really cute. I mean they all are but DAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAMMNN
Some people dont watch the whole thing😂
Ryan is the best in my opinion, he sounds so good and he adds a bit of the insane JD with a stable JD and it is just magnificent.
Draco Games do you mean JD?
Arden Barrett Yes, thank you for saving me from the auto correct demon.
I love Ryan too!
Yes! I totally agree
Draco Games He forces and pushes the sound too much. Its not nice to the ears
0:18 Ryan McCartan
0:42 Cale Singelton
1:06 Stephen Madsen
1:30 Jonathan Markham
1:55 Wendell Scherer
2:21 Sebastian Amoruse
2:48 Dave Thomas Brown
3:14 Ben Brache
3:39 Nathan Cockroft
3:57 Jamie Muscato
4:20 Michael Hajjar
4:46 Kamyar Pagandeh
5:09 Ryan Glander
5:34 Tyler Fernandez
5:58 Travis Ward-Osborne
6:22 Mikey Marmann
6:48 Jeremy Jordan
7:10 Thomas Sanders
7:33 Charlie Meredith
7:57 Chet Davine
8:24 Ian Smith
8:46 Scott Montgomery
9:09 Dan Domeneck
9:34 Zachariah Sterner
sorry if I wrote some names wrong
Lorenzo Bonarelli the 3rd, you're appreciated!!!
Thank you for taking the time to do this! 💜
THank you
Thank youuuuu!! You’re a legend!!!!
Thanks!
Dan domenech (9:15) i just love that version there is so much emotion in every song
Ryan,Jamie,Dan and Zach stood out the most for,they honestly all fit the role perfectly
Tbh watched this waiting for Dan Domenech 9:26 bc his riff was different and sounded great (don’t kill me Thomas you were amazing too)
I agree dan is my favorite JD also thomas is too nice he wouldnt kill anyone
Ashleah McComb honestly tho he’s such a cinnamon roll lol
YEAH EXACTLY
Thank you so much for the timestamp jfc!!!
same thats the riff i prefer to sing ehen i sing this song
Ryan Mc Cartan 0:18
Cale Singleton 0:41
Stephen Madsed 1:06
Jonathan Markham 1:30
Wendell Scherer 1:55
Sebastian Amoruso 2:20
Dave Thomas Brown 2:48
Ben Brache 3:13
Nathan Cockroft 3:39
Jamie Muscato 3:57
Michael Hajjar 4:20
Kamyar Pazandeh 4:46
Ryan Glander 5:08
Tyler Fernandez 5:34
Travis Ward-Osborne 5:58
Mikey Marmam 6:22
Jeremy Jordan 6:47
Thomas Sanders 7:10
Charlie Meredith 7:34
Chet Davino 7:57
Jan Smith 8:23
Scott Montgomery 8:46
Dan Domenech 9:09 (Omg this is my fav ♥)
Zachariah Sterner 9:34
I'm sorry if there's a spelling error or if I'm wrong about something (?
Helena ‘Starlight’ dan domenech is my fav too 🥰
DAN IS SO GOOD
Low-key love Zach (9:34) he was the first one I ever heard so maybe I'm biased.
YeS
Helena ‘Starlight’ I love ur name cos it reminds me of one of my fav mcr songs. But I agree with you that dan domench is the best
I know Ryan did it really well and most people like him but the way Dan went super hard on that last note and ended it so suddenly was amazing and left the silence afterward so much more stunning. It just has way more impact imo
I NEVER CLICKED SO FAST! I waited almost 8 minutes to hear Thomas's angel-like voice and I do not regret it.
It's still so jarring seeing that pure face singing this song
MEEEEE
I am you lmao
Haha lol meeeeee
SAME!!!!!!!!!!!!!
*Casually waiting for Zach and he's the very end*
Artemis ye so anoying
Save the best for last right?
Simi & Milli because he’s the best duh
okay but thomas’s picture gives off the most anti JD vibes ever that cinnamon roll!!
Ik his was my favorite, I am a hardcore fander *FOREVER.*
The fact that you are a bnha fan and a heathers fan-
So many people in the fandom are also broadway fans
MintyMoon 100 THERE IS? i nEeD iT
MintyMoon 100 ok thank you
The pictures taken of him in costume sell it, I don’t doubt his incredible acting for a SECOND but I would commit a murder to see a boot of his performance
4:45 I think this JD's director told him to "EMPITHIS EVERY NOTE" and he took it literally😅
5:58 this sounds like drunk karaoke
8:00 Veronica over here all like. "Yeah JD hurry it up I gotta go have Big Fun!"😏
I think 4:45 was just trying to say every word before the song ended. It went so fast.
Zachariah Sterner omfg 🥴 I’m in love with his voice not to mention his looks holy crap
Edit: Heres a free replay for his voice 💞 9:34
k a i t e e yes
I came here for him ♡ he's my favorite J.D
Sis iagree
k a i t e e i’d let him jd me
Thank you!!!! He's my 2nd favorite JD //Next to Ryan of course//
Y'all obviously dont know who Jamie Muscato is and thats sad.
Huxleigh agreed he’s my favourite 🥺
I only watched this for him tbh, disappointed with the lack of comments bout him
literally he´s the best JD ever and nobodys talking about him
Huxleigh yea that whole cast with Carrie and t’shan and Sophie and Jodie x
The best JD and that’s that
dan domenech is my absolute fave, but jeremy jordan was also bomb (as usual lol)
Celina Rafala it would be swapped for me, but I agree VERY heavily
Yes defo
Yes!! I love Dan
I love how you used "bomb"
Zoe101 👌👌💣💣
Personally (coming from someone who has no idea about the technicalities of singing) I believe that Dan had the best vocal approach but nobody really captures JD’s personality like Ryan. The way he sang made him look and feel like a psycho haha. Everyone was amazing vocally but a lot of them forgot that they had to play a character while singing and Ryan just does such a good job of representing JD’s unstableness from the way he never blinks / never breaks eye contact but still moves his head. It’s very well done.
Ryan is good, but DAN FOREVER AND ALWAYS! The other Ryan and Mikey did pretty good as well. Tbh, this is a hard climax, and everyone here killed it!
It’s only F# unless they do the riff. Not saying they didn’t kill it but it’s not that difficult.
3:33 did not do a good job u a lie
I look at all these innocent young men then I remember dead girl walking is a thing and suddenly they aren’t innocent anymore XD
My boi zach tho
Florence Gregory and all the murdering and stuff
Sophie Luvs Books that is also true
Oh God no Thomas Sanders
Florence Gregory Thomas
Trey Atkins the best part: he's gay😂
Ryan: Had the rock-edginess that made him the original
Cale: Awesome vocals, but man he should work on his audience-facing movement
Stephen: I like the contrast between Roughness and smoothness that he brings but I think he just sounds too mature
Johnathan: Not a fan of the choppy diction but the big note was worth it
Wendell: He was really taking it a little far with the ad-libs, but I like how he blends his stage charisma with the dark side of JD
Sebastian: Lowered it half a step, but the F# sounded well placed and the run after was well executed but man, only having a piano to back sucks
Dave: I like how bright his voice sounds but the top note did sound a little whiny and tense
Ben: Strikes me as a little inexperienced, but he placed the note pretty well
Nathan: Liking the vibrato after, but the top note Just felt a little... Faded?
Jamie: Awesome! Effortless placement and awesome growl, and blends the characters anger and vulnerability perfectly.
Michael: A little Nasal at the start, but the note came out very good, great vibrato
Kamyar: Is the band going too fast or is it him? Every part aside from the big note was great, it just sounded quite tense
Other Ryan: Like how he acts the brain-freeze, and the vocal was awesome too, but I guess it felt a bit... Innocent?
Tyler: Big note was good, could tone down a little on the vibrato on the other parts
Travis: Wish I could say I liked it but man, it just sounded really nasal and uncomfortable
Mikey: That was a smooth riff up to Tenor C! Probably my favorite vocal but I got the impression he's just a little-mature sounding for my taste
Jeremy: THERE HE IS. So I guess it didn't have a G belt originally, and the run was smooth as butter
Thomas: Started off kinda nasaly, really loved the creative swing he had at the climax and it was run expertly.
Charlie: Not really feeling this one, sounds kinda whiny and sharp. Wish I could say I liked it but ehhh
Chet: Just a little flat, but everything else was fine
Ian: Needs to practise singing with his hands in his pockets! Pretty good vocal though
Scott: Loud, that's the word.
Dan: Great vocal, no idea why he's just stood there neutrally though
Zachariah: Tempo is a little underwhelming, vocal was smooth as butter though!
I agree, but you didn't do Dan justice. This riff was everything and his vocals were together with Jamies by far the best! Also that's a live clip from the show, standing there is literally in the choreography!
@@antheiheiant I agree with that
With other ryan, i think it was the glasses that made it not so sycopathic, and the voice.
When you don't understand any of that 😦
Idk. I feel like it adds much more when they use their hands without noticing
I personally liked Jamie Muscato most as JD, just because he genuinely seems psycotic in the musical and his voice portrays it as well.
Zachariah sterner and Thomas sanders both have amazing voices and I have a crush on both of them
Emma Louise same. also im bi
Zachariah is so cute aha
I regret to inform you that thomas is Big Gay my dude
NightSoCoolioYep actually, Bi, so....:3
@@alissawilliams3435 no... hes literally said hes gay on all his social media and in his videos so...
Top 5 , in no particular order, are...
1. Thomas Sanders
2. Jeremy Jordan
3. Dan Domenech
4. Zachariah Sterner
5. Ryan McCartan
Tbh Thomas didn’t do as well as he could have but the rest I definitely agree with
Ryan is so good!!!
mxshii q. Why cause he didn’t hit the highnot
In my opinion Dan is the best JD, Rayan comes in second place.
I just have an unhealthy addiction to Jeremy jordan
Ryan McCartan, Cale Singleton, Thomas Sanders, Jeremy Jordan, Scott Montgomery, and Zachariah Sterner
For those who don’t know Jamie Muscato played JD on west end and lemme tell ya HE WAS GOOD
So glad Zachariah sterner' s on this it's my favourite one tbh
Same I love it
Everyone was pretty great, I LOVED seeing the different choices some of these guys took for JD's mannerisms during this part. I really liked Stephen, Dave, Ben, Nathan, Travis, Jonathan (proud to have done the show with him!), Mikey, Dan (always liked him better than Ryan), and Zachariah. But the two that really stood out to me were Wendell (his voice may have cracked but man he's got so much power in his voice) and Michael.
LittleBallOfGiggles yeah Wendell’s voice cracked but it was so good!!!!
LittleBallOfGiggles which one is the final? 😓 I don't know the name of any of them but still love the musical ♡
Michael's at 4:26
Ooooo the name are in the up part 😅😅
LittleBallOfGiggles this is when I wish you'd have seen literally EVERY other performance where he NAILS that high note XD
It's so weird that I'm in this video!!! That's pretty awesome
I really liked you're version of J.D! One of my favorites actually.
U have a great vocal range
this song is what started my love for jamie muscato like he genuinely has one of the best voices i’ve ever heard
EXCUSE ME?? JEREMY AND THOMAS RIGHT NEXT TO EACHOTHER DON'T DO THIS TO MY FANGIRLING HEART
Also Dan Domenech mastered the higher riff the best imo.
Kris Jenner works hard but Mister Golightly works harder
Mister Golightly Kris Jenner ain't got nothing on you 😝
Dan was really good!!!!
WHEN I SAW THEM NEXT TO EACH OTHER I STARTED SQUEALING
who sings the ending to waving through a window better
are there many versions to compare?
What versions are there to compare? Basement dear Evan hansen was taken down
There's so many covers though...
Ryan Brown a billion post waving through a window covers
Vianney Aguilar covers, talent shows etc
Zach, Ryan, and Thomas were my favs. Ryan was the original, so obviously he sings it amazingly. Zach was the first JD i ever heard and so he's still amazing. And Thomas was just as talented!
attxntionreadxr bruv don’t forget dan
ryan isn't original. dan domenech is original
vio things no its ryan. But dan was his understudy i think and replaced him
@@elizakay9119 i think dan is first and original, so,,,
vio things the original recordings are all Ryan. I’m pretty sure Dan was the understudy
I know we’re all here for the voices, but I do like looking at the differences in all the costumes. It’s cool to see how different productions handle it :)
Especially with a limited budget!
Zachariah Sterner's Heathers production is the actual best Heathers production except for the original.
Pokemonster1210 we all know the best heathers production was illegal heathers don’t @ me
OMG I completely forgot about that! Illegal Heathers is SOOO SOO GOOD! I can't believe they wanted an encore performance!
this is my exact thinking lol. i love zachariah and ryan mccartans performances
Zachariah IS BAE
Pokemonster1210 I totally agree!
Dan is my favorite, like he really belts that last note
*MY OPINIONS*
Ryan - beautiful, lovely 8/10
Cale - the last riff on “vein” was a tiny bit out of time I think, but still sooo good - also nice vibrato! 7/10
Stephen - I like the little push and squeak on the last riff 8/10
Jonathan - breathless but obviously I can understand that 8/10
Wendell - a lot of character, the start of the riff was strained but the end was good 7/10
Sebastian - less character but technically good 6/10
Dave - good breath control but he is standing still so 7/10
Ben - good character but some notes were not so good 6/10
Nathan - very good loved it so much! 8/10
Jamie - the JD I saw so maybe I’m biased, but I liked the push behind his notes 9/10
Michael - so so good and smooth, would give it 10 but he’s not dancing or anything so that would be unfair 9/10
Kamyar - his vowel on “vein” sounds weird and it’s very fast but I liked it 7/10
Ryan - good but not like standout 7/10
Tyler - I loved this and I don’t know why 10/10
Travis - his vowels sound weird to me and he’s straining but I like the voice crack 6/10
Mikey - I love the riff at the end!! 8/10
Jeremy - dodged the last riff but it’s actually really good 9/10
Thomas - the riff is interesting and I’m a big fan of the voice crack 10/10
Charlie - i like his voice haha 8/10
Chet - powerful! liked it 8/10
Ian - it’s technically good but it’s not sticking in my brain 7/10
Scott - so so lovely but he’s not moving so I can’t give him 10 8/10
Dan - MY FAVOURITE I love the riff so good and original and he’s just got such a lovely voice that I’m in love with 10/10
Zachariah - characterful, I like it and the little slides and voice cracks he adds in 9/10
All these singers are so so talented, so if my scores seem low it’s because I’m comparing them to each other and not just in general (if I was doing it generally I’d be forced to give them all 9s and 10s)
Travis sounded like he had a cold
Peachy! I liked Chet, but that last note really ruined it for me 8:15
@@cherrypick520 lol yeah
Omg I loved zachariah
Why dosnt this have more likes?
Ryan's got a special place in my heart, but Dan's notes are my absolute favorite
They were all great, but props to the ones who went for the C5 riff
agreed 👏🏼
Dan dom has always been my favorite and he does it so well cause only a few people try to pull off the ruff that specific way and I've also always loved him, I was low key scared that he wouldn't be there cause he was at the end but bless up I love him
i'm giving props to ryan mccartan, dan and zachariah
Jamie will always be my favourite for the emotion he puts into it 🥺
You should do the Michael in bathroom climax!
Some Crazed Nerd yes they should I need it
Yes!!!!!!!!!
I'm pretty sure there is only 2 actors so far that have sung it (George Salazar and then someone else) so i don't think there is enough people available but I may be wrong.
I NEED THIS
Only George Salazar has done it and maybe one other
You should do one on the “Kindergarten Boyfriend” climax.
Cheese Sneeze YESS
Yee.
Dan, Ryan and Zachariah are definitely my top three!!!
5:46 Veronica casually snacking popcorn while JD is having a panic attack
ZACHARIAH STERNER OH MY GOD is this even a question???
Lisa717 YESSSSSSSSSASSA I LOOOOOVE ZACHARIAH!!!!!
Shophia, A Sans Fangirl Also tries to draw girl same, I dmed he once and he replied- highlight of my life
OMG YES I FUCKING LOVE ZACH AHHHHHHHH
AHHHHHH OH MY GOD FINALLY SOMEONE SOMEONE WHO AGREES
Obviously ❤️😍
Either Thomas Sanders or Zachariah Sterner
Thomas Thomas Thomas Thomas!
THOMAS
You should you do who sang the “Fight for me” climax/long note.
I love that this channel doesn’t actually pick a winner. Most “Who sang it best videos” make it a competition and then pretty much say a bunch of them are shit. Sometimes I just want me a compilation.
also wendell scherer was amazing.
so was Ryan McCartan.
same with Dave Thomas Brown.
this was a horrible recording of Jamie Muscato, but he is SOOOO GOOD. He’s my favourite JD ever And so beautiful. If I wasn’t gay before I found him, he would have been my Gay Awakening.
Ryan Glander was kinda cute.
Tyler Fernandez was good.
Smiley Marmann was really good, but he looked a little old.....
JEREMY JORDAN WAS AMAZING I LOVE HIM.
Thomas Sanders was fantastically beautifully amazing as per usual.
Charlie Meredith was absolutely beautiful.
I loved Thomas's changes to the riff!
2:10-Wendell- I love the emotion he puts into it
2:53- David Thomson Brown- I like the slight psychotic-ness
6:47 it’s Jeremy frickin Jordan, of course it’s amazing
9:12- Holy Crap
Thomas Sanders, Ryan McCartan, and Dan Domenech are amazing! Dan will always be my favorite JD, though ♥︎
Antwondi
You’re literally the first person I’ve seen talk about Ryan. I was wondering why no one likes him! He’s runner up to Dan in my mind.
AND ZACH???
My top five in order:
5. Me in the shower or maybe illegal heathers
4. Ryan McCartan (his is obviously a bit autotuned)
3. Wendell Scherer
2. Jamie Muscato
1. Dan Domenech
Can people shut up about Ryan not being autotuned!? He isn't autotuned live, but the clip in this video is from a footage. Footages are supposed to be autotuned, it's fine.
Antonia H. Ryan’s isn’t auto tuned have you seen his live performances
@@kamypark7346 I actaully have seen Heather's 8 Times in New York and 9 Times in London. So yeah I saw Ryan. And this video is a footage and autotuned.
@@antheiheiant No it's not.
Antonia H. no he sang it live (not in heathers) like just him infront of tons of people and it definitely wasn’t auto tuned because he was talking before it and his voice was completely normal
@@PewAngell Oof, I'm talking about the clip of him in this video!!! And that's not the clip you are talking about 🙄
Dan’s riff at the end giving me chills every time
Dan Domenech because that’s my fav version basically the whole play❤️❤️❤️
Ryan Glander, Mikey Marmann, Thomas Sanders (my baby), Jan Smith, Scott Montgomery, Dan Domenech, and Zachariah Sterner.
My Favs! All were amazing tho
Gray Anonymous I will politely negotiate with you for the right to call Thomas Sanders their baby.
HiMyNameisPeter I politely deny your negotiations, as Thomas has always been and will always be my Senpai.
Gray Anonymous wait you can’t call someone your a baby and then your senpai XD that’s a contradictory statement
Noted
he is both tho
he's just that amazing
Gray Anonymous I agree
Me: *Trying to take serious this part of the song *
Video: *Savage photo of Thomas appears super happy as the cinnamon roll he is,but singing a depressing thing*
Me: *W H E E Z I N G INTENSIFIES*
Jonathan, Ryan, Wendell, Thomas, and Dan did the best.
Also, can you do the climax of "Lifeboat" or the climax of "Shine a Light" next? I love these videos.
bimbo thank you! I appreciate that!!
*waits for Thomas Sanders*
Regina Maes Same
Same bro
ruclips.net/video/IJEPVnq8kA4/видео.html
honestly me
Me
why is no one talking about Zacahria? he's incredible.
spencer's tambourine I COMPLETELY AGREE
HE IS MY ABSOLUTE FAVORITE FOREVER
DUDE HE SURPRISED ME LIKE HE WAS JUST MY GOD AH PERFECT. LIKE WITH NONE OF THE OTHERS DID I ACTUALLY LIKE PHYSICALLY REACT BUT TO HIM I WAS LIKE "0.0♡"
yess zacariah sterner is my favorite
spencer's tambourine *YESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYESYES*
Yes his version was the one I watched first and I absolutely love it
I’m pretty sure there’s actually something wrong with y’all not saying jamie
yea i mean he's jamie he's amazing-
No, I love Jamie, he is my close second after Dan
Sorry I just don't like him.
Now I'm going to wait for Meant To Be Yours 😂 more Heathers please 💖
Super surprised Jeremy Jordan didn't go for that not considering how high and powerful his belts are.
Merrick Baskie It probably didn’t evolve into what it was until the actual show. Jeremy’s version was from a concert in 2010. Kind off like how that concert version of Candy Store was really weak compared to the production
breastfeeded ah ok that makes more sense.
Merrick Baskie that was the workshop tho so maybe that’s how it was originally written and Ryan’s the one that changed it
i've seen a video from the full concert in 2010 and a lot of the songs were really different
Zachariah Sterner actually did really good!! 👏🏼👏🏼 (9:35)
Sophia Wilson yeah
Sophia Wilson look at veroicas cloths tho
Dan Domenecks really hurts me for some reason, I love it
zachariah... altho im biased bc he was the first person ive seen as JD
thatmcdfangirl me too
thatmcdfangirl me too
Honestly after listening to the West End cast recording no JD will ever beat Jamie Muscato for me. He manages to make JD pretty awkward and socially inept (as opposed to the charming psychopath you sometimes get) but that only makes him more terrifying in songs like Meant to be Mine - and I’m not exaggerating when I say terrifying, the only way I can describe his voice at some points is a roar - because he switches back and forth so quickly between vulnerable and dangerous, and I honestly think this makes him the most realistic JD as well. I can think of real people I know like this, and that is terrifying
I wish there were more bootlegs of Thomas playing J.D.
Same man
@LordOfTheLies yea look up tomas sanders heathers and theres a playlist
there's a whole ass soundcloud somewhere
Sameeeeeeee
Here! ruclips.net/video/dQw4w9WgXcQ/видео.html
My favorites:
For #1 I have to go with my boi Ryan
Then dan
Then Thomas
(But they were all good and portrayed JD pretty well)
dan always. that high note. wow