“La Campanella is the hardest piece” 🤨

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 11 дек 2024

Комментарии • 62

  • @abderxd1345
    @abderxd1345 Год назад +30

    To be honest, Leslie howard Said About Liszt la campanellla Shouldn't sound very loud many pianists play the " Andante" Ending very loud And I totally Agree with him.

  • @alessandropelizzoli6613
    @alessandropelizzoli6613 Год назад +20

    Liszt 's Campanella is on another Planet, in my opinion...Liszt is so devilish, so elegant, so refined...This present Study by Hamelin could be inventive and rich, but too bombastic and typically american in style...
    Not only! Liszt has left an incredibly difficult version of His La Campanella in the Great " Grande Fantaisie sur la Clochette"... So much more difficult!
    Thanks a lot for this interesting post.

    • @Medtszkowski
      @Medtszkowski  Год назад +4

      If you are taking Liszt’s S.140, or S.420, or S.700a/i, or S.700a/ii, 100% YES, but I believe his S.141 la Campanella is one of his worst pieces

    • @alessandropelizzoli6613
      @alessandropelizzoli6613 Год назад +3

      @@Medtszkowski Grande Fantasie de Bravoure sur la Clochette S.420... absolutely! Very interesting and really really ....difficult.

    • @Franz_Liszt_Korean
      @Franz_Liszt_Korean Год назад +2

      Thank you

    • @Medtszkowski
      @Medtszkowski  Год назад +2

      Listen to his S.700a/i and S.700a/ii if you haven’t :)

    • @alessandropelizzoli6613
      @alessandropelizzoli6613 Год назад +1

      @@Medtszkowski yes! Beautiful!

  • @lmichaelgreenjr
    @lmichaelgreenjr Год назад +7

    Vastly superior technically and vastly inferior musically

    • @Medtszkowski
      @Medtszkowski  Год назад +2

      S.141 is vastly inferior musically to S.700a/ii and S.140

  • @melonica90
    @melonica90 Год назад +3

    You are so talented in terms of creating title 🤣 I can't help laughing. Thank you for posting this ( his etude No.4 is my favorite though)

  • @sebastianortizosorio3480
    @sebastianortizosorio3480 Год назад +6

    Hamelin recording is such an amazing performance

    • @Medtszkowski
      @Medtszkowski  Год назад +1

      Yea, I listened to it yesterday, purchasing all of his Hyperion was a good choice

  • @Medtszkowski
    @Medtszkowski  Год назад +2

    Please listen to Hamelins Hyperion recording of this

  • @LeviSawyerPiano
    @LeviSawyerPiano Год назад +1

    40 hours a day typa piece

  • @Damian_Theodoridis
    @Damian_Theodoridis Год назад +11

    La Campanella if it was written in Ohio 💀☠️☠️☠️

  • @user-fu7zf4ck9z
    @user-fu7zf4ck9z Год назад +4

    That‘s not La Campanella, that‘s La Campana 💀

  • @Bruhm-ms3yn
    @Bruhm-ms3yn Год назад +1

    he maybe cooking up something

  • @whaijorhujishkomunyk
    @whaijorhujishkomunyk Год назад +1

    I wish we had Cziffras as composer and not only the pianist

  • @jannis11
    @jannis11 Год назад +1

    NoIce

  • @mwsc04
    @mwsc04 Год назад +1

    This is one of Marc-Andre Hamelin's better arrangements, IMHO, though you really need to hear the whole thing to appreciate.

    • @Medtszkowski
      @Medtszkowski  Год назад +1

      This, his Alkan etude combination, and his triple Chopin etude. I completely agree with your second point

  • @szilardszilagyicomposer
    @szilardszilagyicomposer Год назад +1

    It is actually Wieland Hoban's when the painting STARTS.(the hardest solo piece on piano) i mean this is subjective.

    • @Medtszkowski
      @Medtszkowski  Год назад +3

      11 staffs, it’s obviously written against piano in every way. It’s easy to write the hardest thing in the world when you write it against the instrument

    • @Medtszkowski
      @Medtszkowski  Год назад +2

      I can list all the hardest pieces when you mention this type of stuff, I actually made my own list once

    • @Medtszkowski
      @Medtszkowski  Год назад +3

      Here it is:
      Barlow Cogluotobusletismesi
      Barrett Tract
      Bussotti Pour Clavier
      Cage Etudes Australes
      Cognizetti Pentaphonic Etude
      Diaz-Infante Solus
      Finnissy all.fall.down.
      Finnissy Solo Concerto No. 4
      Flynn Trinity
      Fox Twenty-Four Etudes
      Fox Sonata No. 2
      Hoban When the Panting Starts
      Martino Pianississimo
      Rzewski "The Road"
      Scelsi Action Music
      Skalkottas 32 Piano Pieces
      Sorabji Sequentia Cyclica Super "Dies Irae" ex Missa pro Defunctis
      Sorabji Sonata No. 5 "Opus Archimagicum"
      Sorabji Symphonic Variations
      Stockhausen Klavierstucke X
      Xenakis Evryali
      Xenakis Sieben Klavierstucke
      Xenakis Synaphai
      Yim :[ten]dril
      Zimmermann Wunsterwanderung

    • @szilardszilagyicomposer
      @szilardszilagyicomposer Год назад +1

      @@Medtszkowski Thank you 😲😀

    • @szilardszilagyicomposer
      @szilardszilagyicomposer Год назад +1

      @@Medtszkowski It is quite written against the piano but more like for a people. Ian Pace. He is probably the best pianist alive.(And he played it).But i agree what are you saying.

  • @TheFallenChérubin
    @TheFallenChérubin 3 месяца назад

    simply piano day 2

  • @kaveekronkusakunrat5905
    @kaveekronkusakunrat5905 8 месяцев назад +1

    What's name song in this wrote

    • @Medtszkowski
      @Medtszkowski  8 месяцев назад +1

      Hamelin etude no.3 is the written of this song.

  • @jakub-or2vk
    @jakub-or2vk Год назад +1

    I have a question. Is there a list of all Liszt works that he " *published* "?

  • @therealransu
    @therealransu Год назад +3

    I hate it when they say that. Like they should get into Liszt's other works (Which are clearly better). Camp' is so overrated to the point I can't stand hearing it. Good video though, I really love Hamelin's style in this etude.

  • @CaasiAndestein
    @CaasiAndestein Год назад +1

    s140 etudes

  • @Jamric-gr8gr
    @Jamric-gr8gr Год назад +1

    Hamelin etude?

  • @Lavirfra
    @Lavirfra 11 месяцев назад +1

    hamelin alkan etude is better than this

    • @Medtszkowski
      @Medtszkowski  11 месяцев назад +1

      It definitely is. Love that piece and hope to play it one day. (I might not in 10-15 years though, as most people who are 30+ for some reason seem to, for lack of better words, “outgrow” that piece)

  • @ralsei217
    @ralsei217 Год назад +1

    Whats the point of this wheres the music

    • @Medtszkowski
      @Medtszkowski  Год назад +1

      It’s an inventive and risk-taken arrangement of an overplayed piece. I guess the point is that the virtuosity is kinda cool