This video is completely wrong. It doesn't take into account the position of the explosives and the person during the explosion. Isn't the plethora of videos where orcs are literally thrown tens of meters into the air enough for you?
i had a workplace accident a automotive gas tank exploded in my face and the force blew me 20 feet across the shop i was on fire but still conscious i managed to extinguish the fire on me i had numerous facial injuries but no internal injuries. i now have ptsd and vertigo along with permanent hearing damage. im just happy to be alive to see my kids grow up
Sounds like you were very lucky it wasn't internal. And now you seem to have a great positive attitude about life. Wishing you more healing and medical advancements in the future.
I think that's why frag grenades are called that, the fragmented bits of metal cause the damage not the explosion. I might be wrong, but I think they are specifically designed to splinter apart in the most violent way possible.
@@himynameis3664 Originally, they were just a thick piece of glass, clay, or iron and they splinthered in a highly unpredictable fashion. They needed to have pressure building up as they relied on black powder. Also, if the grenade breaks on impact, it would at best create a rather harmless fireball... Then in WWI, they started to cut the hull in the hopes of getting a more even distribution of pieces. It still didn't yield the desired results, and they were better off wrapping nails or steel balls around the explosive. Only at the end of WWII the figured out how to cut the hull so that it splinters as desired (inside and not like the old pineapple). Still, adding steel balls has remained the best option.
i've seen enough war footage to say with 100% certainty that explosions do throw people in to the air due to the supersonic pressure wave, the biggest difference with movies however is that there aren't any fireballs created really, it's more like a massive firecracker going off, unless if you're dealing with napalm, phosphorous or thermite, and that they turn you from a person into a lot of flying pieces
something else that often happens with things like airstikes in war is that often the body stays intact but the internal organs are turned to mush from the shockwaves while the external damages often are a result of flying debree and shrapnel
@@pauliusiv6169 I guess it's a solace that if you actually face an explosive point blank its a relatively quick death due to the extent of the brain hemorrhaging and internal bleeding.
and with a 100% certainty we can also conclude that a supersonic pressure wave strong enough to throw an adult human would also be strong enough to pulverize said person's internal organs, even if the body wasn't already turn into giblets yet
I heard his predecessor Rick "the stick" Stickman had to retire do to minor injuries on the job but he got a great retirement plan and should have a very cozy life. We wish Rick a wonderful retirement.
The "it depends" really does matter. I was an underground, hardrock miner for a while, and setting off a charge in a heading with high explosives required that the heading be cleared. I was driving an open cab vehicle past a heading that had a charge going off, and was hit by the shockwave that originated some 200 meters away, around a curve, at the face of the heading. The blast knocked my hardhat off, and felt like a punch to my head, as that shockwave rushed out of the heading (the open area of the cave allowing the wave to travel some distance. So even though the rock that was blasted into many pieces never got near me, I certainly felt the shockwave. Since I was sitting, mostly protected by the body of the vehicle, it didn't affect my body, but I certainly felt that impressive blast on my hardhat and exposed shoulders.
Hey there, EOD here, so you did a pretty common mistake about the difference between high and low explosives (or a detonation and a deflegration). The difference is, as you said, that a detonation is faster than the speed of sound, BUT it does not at all refer to the speed of sound in air which would be around 340m/s. There's lots of deflegrations that are happening way faster than 340m/s. We are actually talking about the speed of sound in the explosives themselves, so about how fast vibrations travel through it which, since they are often solid and therefore much more dense, is way higher then 340m/s. Also, thats only one of many differences. The whole chemical process and the way the reaction occurs and where the gases go etc is quite different and actually not even that well studied since its really hard to study something thats detonating. And a deflegration can almost any time become a detonation if you keep it pressurized in an enclosed space. Thats called the Van Neumann Spike. I hope i could make myself clear since englisch is not my native language. Edit: also, what you often see in Hollywood with big fireballs is in most cases not even a deflegration since a dwflegration would mean, the explosive has its own oxygen chemically bound to it. These big fireballs are just gasoline that regularly burns with the oxygen in the air and is at most propelled around through a small pyrotechnical deflegration.
A few things to add: (including personal experience) 1) deflagrations are slower but can maintain the gas pressure for longer. This can be more damaging to people and buildings. Think of it like this: a HE may shatter things but the effect is highly localized to the point that it may turn your foot into red mist, but even your lower leg is mostly there, albeit very much chewed up and your torso is perfectly fine. Now, if you want to destroy a tank or bunker, you want a HE, but when you want to tear down a large building, you’d need to shell it over and over again with HE until you made enough holes in it to collapse. Meanwhile, a single thermobaric shell could pull down the entire building despite the explosion being a deflagration (similarly a single piece of butter is enough to cause a fat explosion that can completely destroy a cabin! Meanwhile throwing a hand grenade into the cabin would leave it standing…). It’s like an insane storm wind rather than a hit with a wrecking ball. If you’re in a bunker that gets hit by an HE shell it may destroy a part of it and you might be relatively safe around a corner, but a thermobaric explosion can cause symptoms similar to the divers disease even though the bunker wasn’t damaged. In addition to this, you shouldn’t underestimate the heat produced and the possibility that the oxygen gets used up, or you’re breathing in hot air that burns your lungs… 2) As hinted above with the example of the mine, there’s a transition between a pressure wave that shreds things and one that propels things. You can use high explosives to propel projectiles, even though they would normally destroy the barrel and the projectile. You simply would need to downscale the propellant and put it in the center of the chamber. This means that when it explodes it has room to expand before hitting the walls or the projectile. If you wonder if that system was ever used: yep! The most famous example is the under-barrel grenade launcher! 3) Most hand grenades kill by fragmentation. They used to have thick walls that provide the fragments and now have thousands of tiny steel balls instead. They may have up to 200g of explosive filler to propel the fragments forward. On the other hand, there are so-called offensive grenades that do not produce many lethal fragments. The most famous example is the Stiehlhandgranate. The thin metal cover pretty much gets atomized in the explosion and the wooden fragments don’t fly that far and impact relatively lightly. Such grenades tend to have more explosives in them as they kill with their blast, but more importantly, they used to be the predecessor of the flashbang… There’s a third type worth mentioning: the Antitank grenade. It contain so much explosive that even without fragmentation they are a danger to whoever is throwing them, as he can’t throw them far enough unless he throws them off a tall building… Most of them have shaped charges that can punch a whole through armor, but only in one direction. Still, the omnidirectional blast is a threat to humans as far as they can be thrown! 4) Humans respond differently to damage. Someone can get knocked over by a blast and stand up and continue to fight only to later realize that he’s actually been hit by multiple shrapnel and one of them was lodged inside his brain (my grandfather was such a case and he lived another 70 years!). Others get stabbed by a tiny knife in the guts once and instantly drop and don’t get up again until they bleed out and then, well they’re dead… Personally, I’ve been exposed to a deflagration with another 100 people. It was merely a firework that exploded rather than producing a huge spark fountain. Despite the distance, I could feel the heat and air pressure. It temporarily blinded me and my ears were ringing. Once I could see again (I could still not hear properly), I noticed that it had pretty much incapacitated everyone around me, though NONE got injured any more than I did, and that included people closer to the explosion. I felt a bit groggy and tried to check myself for injuries and instinctively wanted to leave the place of the accident (even though I didn’t require immediate medical attention nor expected any further threats), but I couldn’t move because of the people around me. Others just kept sitting frozen in place and others were looking at each other and apparently expecting an explanation of what just had happened, or perhaps they were waiting for the show to continue? It was so out of place that they didn’t know what to do.
As a former mortarman, it actually feels good to hear the idea that most people I dropped hate on, and those of us who recieved it, probably died instantly. I really do think about that. The loss itself is the worst part, but the suffering adds so much. Thank you for this.
I never really paid much attention, but if you look at explosions in movies, only the characters are really thrown away. Windows and other clearly fragile items are broken, but most furniture and similar is simply thrown about in almost random directions most of the time.
One notable example is the film "The Dark Knight" (2008), where the character Harvey Dent, portrayed by Aaron Eckhart, is caught in an explosion that sends him flying through the air. Another example is the movie "Transformers: Dark of the Moon" (2011), where various characters are propelled into the air by explosions during intense action scenes involving massive battles between robots.
Saw a video of 2 Russian soldiers attempting to disarm an anti-tank mine rigged as a bobby trap in UA. One of them did actually get thrown through the air gruesomely(what remained of his body was partially disfigured). Was pretty hard to watch. So yes, military grade explosions can throw people.
I had an opportunity to attend a lecture focused on blast injuries/treatments of about a decade ago… It was a surprise to see that the majority of the damage to humans caused by explosions was due to over pressure and not from heat/shrapnel produced by said blast. The “flying through the air” thing definitely is dependent upon a countless number of variables and is by no means the expected outcome of every explosion.
exactly. These gas tankers/lines blowing up in Johannesburg , Venezuela, etc. are flipping cars and crushing buildings. That means you will wind up in pieces too.
sometimes they do throw you. There are tons of videos from Iraq and Afghanistan of explosions throwing humans quite far at times. But those people were typically dead too. You don't have to ask the survivors. you can ask those of us who witnessed it, or view the video evidence we sometimes managed to record. Easy to get video when you call in an airstrike and are waiting for ordnance to impact the designated target. Sometimes we had cameras mounted on teh vehicles for other purposes too, and gun turret footage (from tanks and CROWS turrets and Gyro Cams).
there are enough witness reports from veterans of both worldwars who talked and wrote about people geting thrown into the air from artillery shells. in WWI it happend quite often that people got "blown out off their clothes", with only shreds of their clothing remainin on the spot, and the formerly wearer of those high up in a tree or meters away (obviously also reduced to pulp and shreds). Also there is a biographie from a WWII vet who got states he got "lifted from his feet and thrown against the churches Brickwall getting knocked out by the impact", he was rescued by medics and recovered in a hospital...
Anyone who has been watching certain drone videos in the last two years can confirm that explosions can indeed throw people into the air. In some cases quite impressively far even.
As someone who survived a terrorist bomb explosion, I approve this video. I wasn't thrown into the air, but it did push me and my aunt who was carrying me (I was 4yo) to fall into the ground. Lucky for us, we were shielded from the shrapnel projectiles and glass, so no serious injuries were sustained. And maybe the explosion wasn't strong enough to cause internal damage either. But the PTSD was real...
I am pretty sure they are supposed to. If you see something about to blow up, your first response will likely be to throw yourself away from it. But i don't think it really helps that much with avoiding the blast, let alone the burn.
I thought Debunked would point out the extra-ridiculousness of that MI scene in the bridge where Tom Cruise is running away from a predictable incoming explosion (😂) and when it explodes at his back, the pseudo-blast wave propels him to his left, against a conveniently placed vehicle 😂 What a ridiculous scene!
i can attest you can be flung by an explosion. definitely a rare thing due to how close i was as well as not catching a lot of shrapnel. The groin protector for vests works well for shrapnel btw x)
I was on a mission in Iraq when an entire house was blown up as we drove by. The blast was behind me and it threw me forward in my 5-point harness (it was a bit loose for comfort). The blast also knocked the wind out of me and stopped my heart for a moment. The "house borne IED" was estimated to be ~2000lb in size
I've heard stories where somebody was thrown back by into a wall by a small explosion. He was able to pick himself up off the floor, look at the people around him, then fell over dead. At least, that's what I've been told...
Hey, Stu! (and the rest of the team). Little bit of a request from a random nobody on the internet. Kinda wanna see a Medieval misconceptions in this Debunked format. Considering the middle ages is completely riddled with misconceptions from Fantasy and whatnot, it should be easy to get some good ones in a vid. Anyway, keep doing what you're doing and i'll keep watching regardless
One of my favourite behind-the-scenes footage of explosions is the one from The Doctor Falls, where Cybermen actors used trampolines to simulate being flung into the air.
Great video, and very nice explanations. High explosives at 8km/s is so ridiculously fast, I believe there are some at 10km/s as well. It's so much fun and fascinating to watch detonations and observe the sound delay etc.
Thanks for asking! We design out assets in both Adobe Illustrator and After Effects. We animate each scene in After Effects and then compile the animations, VO, music, sound effects etc in Adobe Premiere.
It's always fun to see though.. ESPECIALY in video games. It use to be the one thing I longed for in video games when I was small for some reason. GTA gave me that fix along with Perfect Dark.
If we want to talk about very very fundamentally, an explosion is merely the separation of something into opposite directions (Conservation of linear momentum and all that)
How you notice you are still a physics nerd: When you are enraged that at 8:12 the shock wave is drawn as a transversal wave, but they are actually longitudinal waves. (But I appreciate that the first ones are easier to convey in a drawing and is what common folk associate with the concept of a wave)
3:00 Isn’t high and low explosives actually defined by the method of ignition? You can make petrol, a low explosive, detonate with a shockwave faster than the speed of sound
my uncle had a ruptured intestine and blood in his lungs from an explosions shockwave. they had to remove a few inches of his intestines to repair the damage
That Mission Impossible clip is hilarious cuz you can freaking SEE that that the explosion is nowhere near the correct angle to push the guy in that direction, unless there's an off screen explosion that for some reason we are not allowed to see, the forbidden explosion if you will.
I know, looks spectacular but makes no sense. I remember watching a 'making of' and that angle isn't a mistake, they knew it was incorrect but the framing worked better 😆
A friend of my mom's, a Ukrainian woman, a civilian, was thrown by a blast and had her knee bent in a way it really shouldn't have, but due to the adrenaline and the shock she still ran for hours until she collapsed and got treatment. Now she lives in a different country and needs a wheelchair. It's amazing what shock and adrenaline can do for you when you need it most, she's lucky to have survived.
There are videos you can research of the Beirut port explosions of people thrown off their feet while being at least 500 meters away from the initial blast. I was 1km away and suffered from glass shrapnels
My uncle drove a box truck with forklift. The forklift was not properly secured and when he applied the brakes suddenly the propane tank was pierced causing an explosion. My uncle had no burns or outside damage but his inside were mush, his passenger survived because he wasn't wearing his seatbelt and got ejected out of the truck. Crazy!
depending on where the explosion occurs and where you stand will give different pressure. if you are inside of a building close do the exit and a bombs goes off inside you probably will be thrown far away. but in a open space you will need a much potent explosion and if that is the case which lift you from ground you are probably dead or will be soon. See the condition change everything. In a closed space there us only one way out , through the exit. So it is sure to build up lot of pressure to move the air in one direction making the flow powerful enough to make you fly without causing death. That means you are safely away from the explosion, but the condition on where that happen that safety distance is not that safe anymore as it would be completely safe if the explosion was in open space.
My uncle survived a direct hit of a nade. About 12 debris penetrated his legs, he got lucky enough to safe them (legs ofc). And, after all, he can easily walk and even run sometimes.
not sure why ive always been a stickler for realism but i always found it disapointing when watching a movie and a simple frag grenade goes off like napalm and throws people like ragdolls. anywhoot great video, here have a like
Then there is the blown through glass window/door thing in movies. I once visited a friend in hospital after they suffered some injury and the next bed neighbour went onto a glass door (not because of an explosion) which shattered on the impact allowing the person to go through. They suffered a large number of cuts and lost so much blood that survival was uncertain for a few days. In movies, such glass would be made of sugar not real glass. It's possible to engineer large panels of what's essentially transparent candy which easily shatter without causing injuries.
Deflagration is not exclusive to low explosives though, high explosives can also deflagrate and this is one of the ways bombs are defused. (I should probably say "dont try this at home" though)
3 days after moving into a quiet town in the middle of the woods, a house at the end of the street exploded. Complete obliteration of the house. The only person inside was an old lady on pure oxygen,who also was a smoker.... It is unknown what else was in the house that could cause such a boom but setting off the oxygen tanks was probably the start of it.
This actually makes me want to ask you to tell us what would happen if an asteroid the size of an arena would hit the earth. What happens to those nearby, further away, etc. (I know this won’t happen because the larger the asteroid the sooner our radars pick it up and we can redirect it away, but still.)
That Beirut explosion also created a lot of "knocked several meters from the window" reports. Guess it was that combination of quite much energy for a large radius, so that there was all that mass around the explosion was not enough for significant shrapnel, and a so big of zones, that you get a big enough zone of enough-energy-to-throw but not-enough-energy-to-instantly-die. But your guess is as good as mine.
That's basically what I expected, though I thought MAYBE it would be even less probable for them to survive if they were thrown into the air, or else that they might definitely become deaf.
Air fuel explosions as in gas leak explosions are very slow deflagrations, the over pressures are quite survivable, the vast majority of injury and death come from being propelled by the blast against something and getting hit by debris, collapsing building or fire.
@@DebunkedOfficial Can you really learn something just by playing videogames (i.e. driving, shooting, etc.)? How much violence can videogames actually cause? I hope you can take these into consideration. But even if you don't, I still look foward to the next video!
Most of the time the shock wave wont kill you, even the fire, but shrapnel is the most dangerous thing. For example a standard US "MK 2" hand grenade doesnt really have a big shockwave, but it has powerful metal fragments going in all directions.
I survived being close enough to have things go flying. We had to immediately get up and get to our armor, because more things where probably going to be lobbed at us. It definitely causes permanent damage.
As someone whos been around a lot of explosions, no. you barely feel the thing pushing but you feel the smaller lighter things getting pushed through you and sometimes you feel the air in your lungs trying to escape If the explosion is close enough and powerful enough to throw you you are dead before your body leaves the ground They also don’t throw flames normally Edit: ok correction man made explosives,
Yup. xD As a general rule, if the explosion has enough force to throw you up the air... it's your body going up - you are already dead, as Kenshiro would say. General rule meaning, yes, there are real life exceptions to that - just don't count on it.
“The difference between most people and military persons is as follows- While military folk prop parachutes to concern a hotly debated landing zone, the normie just wants to be able to walk after a gut wrenching backflip”
@@Mr.Spade1 “So I’ve sent out invitations for the next marriage and haven’t yet finalised the divorce….Wait until she finds my next secret stash of cucumber salads” “ _Kermit Shows Off Miss Piggy on Omegle_ ”
11:32, actually i have a very good friend that had an rpg explosion in his armored vehicle and he walked out.. without 3 and a half fingers… Funnily enough most of the others inside survived in varying degrees of injures. Thank god we in israel have the best combat , medics and medical infrastructure in the world the fastest life saving treatments in the world
There was a case where fireman were responding to a burning building then it exploded sending the firemen way into the air some of them survived with severe injuries and a couple of them died.
A low explosive will push, whie a high explosive with cut. A low explosive (an dthey can vary a lot) may throw a person with some injuries. A high explosive that can actually throw you will likely kill you. More often than not, an explosion (that doesn't kill them) would push a person off balance, rather than throw them.
I was on a mission in Iraq when an entire house was blown up as we drove by. The blast was behind me and it threw me forward in my 5-point harness (it was a bit loose for comfort). The blast also knocked the wind out of me and stopped my heart for a moment. The "house borne IED" was estimated to be ~2000lb in size
There's a video called "A Former PLA Soldier Hired By Russians Gives Reality Check on Russia-Ukraine War". At about 1:45, he claims a bomb was set off, and he was hurled to the top of a house. I'm suddenly questioning the authenticity of his testimony because of this video.
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
👉 Help support Debunked by trying out Brilliant for free for 30 days, just visit brilliant.org/debunked/
1 like and no replies let me fix that
There is one thing I want to ask. The whole Zombie concept can you debunk it?
This video is completely wrong. It doesn't take into account the position of the explosives and the person during the explosion. Isn't the plethora of videos where orcs are literally thrown tens of meters into the air enough for you?
@@blackwolf_365 what about orcs?
Hi, great video! I have a question about your animations. In which software do you make them? Can you tell us a bit about your process?
i had a workplace accident a automotive gas tank exploded in my face and the force blew me 20 feet across the shop i was on fire but still conscious i managed to extinguish the fire on me i had numerous facial injuries but no internal injuries. i now have ptsd and vertigo along with permanent hearing damage. im just happy to be alive to see my kids grow up
Wow, thank you for sharing your story. I wish you well 💪
I'm wondering where a gas tank explosion would fit in these categories 🤔 I guess it goes against all of those.
I might have to watch it again...
@@MrPinkfloydian gasoline is considered a low explosive as far as i know. im not exactly sure how it could've blown them 20 feet away though.
That's a deflagration, not a detonation. It's a slow push instead of a shock wave.
Sounds like you were very lucky it wasn't internal. And now you seem to have a great positive attitude about life. Wishing you more healing and medical advancements in the future.
my guess before watching: if a boom is big enough to let you fly, it is also big enough to turn your organs into mush
Pretty much, but some people do survive crazy injuries.
@Utrekzwhat
I think that's why frag grenades are called that, the fragmented bits of metal cause the damage not the explosion. I might be wrong, but I think they are specifically designed to splinter apart in the most violent way possible.
@@himynameis3664 Originally, they were just a thick piece of glass, clay, or iron and they splinthered in a highly unpredictable fashion.
They needed to have pressure building up as they relied on black powder. Also, if the grenade breaks on impact, it would at best create a rather harmless fireball...
Then in WWI, they started to cut the hull in the hopes of getting a more even distribution of pieces. It still didn't yield the desired results, and they were better off wrapping nails or steel balls around the explosive. Only at the end of WWII the figured out how to cut the hull so that it splinters as desired (inside and not like the old pineapple). Still, adding steel balls has remained the best option.
@@EDaley10 to survive crazy injuries, jelly your weenus
This video is a blast
Boom Boom 🤣
absolute genious.
These animations absolutely blew me away. They're so good 😂
The bomb even...
Can’t wait for the view count to explode…
i've seen enough war footage to say with 100% certainty that explosions do throw people in to the air due to the supersonic pressure wave, the biggest difference with movies however is that there aren't any fireballs created really, it's more like a massive firecracker going off, unless if you're dealing with napalm, phosphorous or thermite, and that they turn you from a person into a lot of flying pieces
something else that often happens with things like airstikes in war is that often the body stays intact but the internal organs are turned to mush from the shockwaves while the external damages often are a result of flying debree and shrapnel
@@pauliusiv6169 I guess it's a solace that if you actually face an explosive point blank its a relatively quick death due to the extent of the brain hemorrhaging and internal bleeding.
I've watched enough Golden eye speed runs to know the same thing.
I remember my first war video. I was shocked to see a body cartwheeling through the air after the vehicle struck a mine.
and with a 100% certainty we can also conclude that a supersonic pressure wave strong enough to throw an adult human would also be strong enough to pulverize said person's internal organs, even if the body wasn't already turn into giblets yet
Shoutout to Stick the stuntman. He puts it all on the line for us every episode. He has a family, Stickphanie and stickletts.
😆 Stick is a true hero 💪
Thoughts and prayers going out for old sticky.🙏🏻🙏🏻
if the percussion wave is stong enough it will remove skin frm bine, as they are at different densities and have a different impulse moment.
I heard his predecessor Rick "the stick" Stickman had to retire do to minor injuries on the job but he got a great retirement plan and should have a very cozy life. We wish Rick a wonderful retirement.
@@otepfan8562 Yes. Rick was a legend. A true stick man through and through
The "it depends" really does matter. I was an underground, hardrock miner for a while, and setting off a charge in a heading with high explosives required that the heading be cleared. I was driving an open cab vehicle past a heading that had a charge going off, and was hit by the shockwave that originated some 200 meters away, around a curve, at the face of the heading. The blast knocked my hardhat off, and felt like a punch to my head, as that shockwave rushed out of the heading (the open area of the cave allowing the wave to travel some distance. So even though the rock that was blasted into many pieces never got near me, I certainly felt the shockwave. Since I was sitting, mostly protected by the body of the vehicle, it didn't affect my body, but I certainly felt that impressive blast on my hardhat and exposed shoulders.
Hey there, EOD here, so you did a pretty common mistake about the difference between high and low explosives (or a detonation and a deflegration).
The difference is, as you said, that a detonation is faster than the speed of sound, BUT it does not at all refer to the speed of sound in air which would be around 340m/s. There's lots of deflegrations that are happening way faster than 340m/s.
We are actually talking about the speed of sound in the explosives themselves, so about how fast vibrations travel through it which, since they are often solid and therefore much more dense, is way higher then 340m/s.
Also, thats only one of many differences. The whole chemical process and the way the reaction occurs and where the gases go etc is quite different and actually not even that well studied since its really hard to study something thats detonating. And a deflegration can almost any time become a detonation if you keep it pressurized in an enclosed space. Thats called the Van Neumann Spike.
I hope i could make myself clear since englisch is not my native language.
Edit: also, what you often see in Hollywood with big fireballs is in most cases not even a deflegration since a dwflegration would mean, the explosive has its own oxygen chemically bound to it. These big fireballs are just gasoline that regularly burns with the oxygen in the air and is at most propelled around through a small pyrotechnical deflegration.
Ironic how the only error you made is the spelling of "english"
Deutsch?
Sprechen sie Deutsch?
This should be top comment, and your English is fantastic!
@@Mr.Spade1 Agreed, this should be pinned.
Me standing in the Primary zone:
"Nah, I'd win"
Bro is
him
Karm/anara
Stick of dynamite 🧨: Nah, I’D WIN
Me when i have the manntreads on
A few things to add: (including personal experience)
1) deflagrations are slower but can maintain the gas pressure for longer. This can be more damaging to people and buildings. Think of it like this: a HE may shatter things but the effect is highly localized to the point that it may turn your foot into red mist, but even your lower leg is mostly there, albeit very much chewed up and your torso is perfectly fine. Now, if you want to destroy a tank or bunker, you want a HE, but when you want to tear down a large building, you’d need to shell it over and over again with HE until you made enough holes in it to collapse. Meanwhile, a single thermobaric shell could pull down the entire building despite the explosion being a deflagration (similarly a single piece of butter is enough to cause a fat explosion that can completely destroy a cabin! Meanwhile throwing a hand grenade into the cabin would leave it standing…). It’s like an insane storm wind rather than a hit with a wrecking ball. If you’re in a bunker that gets hit by an HE shell it may destroy a part of it and you might be relatively safe around a corner, but a thermobaric explosion can cause symptoms similar to the divers disease even though the bunker wasn’t damaged. In addition to this, you shouldn’t underestimate the heat produced and the possibility that the oxygen gets used up, or you’re breathing in hot air that burns your lungs…
2) As hinted above with the example of the mine, there’s a transition between a pressure wave that shreds things and one that propels things. You can use high explosives to propel projectiles, even though they would normally destroy the barrel and the projectile. You simply would need to downscale the propellant and put it in the center of the chamber. This means that when it explodes it has room to expand before hitting the walls or the projectile. If you wonder if that system was ever used: yep! The most famous example is the under-barrel grenade launcher!
3) Most hand grenades kill by fragmentation. They used to have thick walls that provide the fragments and now have thousands of tiny steel balls instead. They may have up to 200g of explosive filler to propel the fragments forward. On the other hand, there are so-called offensive grenades that do not produce many lethal fragments. The most famous example is the Stiehlhandgranate. The thin metal cover pretty much gets atomized in the explosion and the wooden fragments don’t fly that far and impact relatively lightly. Such grenades tend to have more explosives in them as they kill with their blast, but more importantly, they used to be the predecessor of the flashbang… There’s a third type worth mentioning: the Antitank grenade. It contain so much explosive that even without fragmentation they are a danger to whoever is throwing them, as he can’t throw them far enough unless he throws them off a tall building… Most of them have shaped charges that can punch a whole through armor, but only in one direction. Still, the omnidirectional blast is a threat to humans as far as they can be thrown!
4) Humans respond differently to damage. Someone can get knocked over by a blast and stand up and continue to fight only to later realize that he’s actually been hit by multiple shrapnel and one of them was lodged inside his brain (my grandfather was such a case and he lived another 70 years!). Others get stabbed by a tiny knife in the guts once and instantly drop and don’t get up again until they bleed out and then, well they’re dead… Personally, I’ve been exposed to a deflagration with another 100 people. It was merely a firework that exploded rather than producing a huge spark fountain. Despite the distance, I could feel the heat and air pressure. It temporarily blinded me and my ears were ringing. Once I could see again (I could still not hear properly), I noticed that it had pretty much incapacitated everyone around me, though NONE got injured any more than I did, and that included people closer to the explosion. I felt a bit groggy and tried to check myself for injuries and instinctively wanted to leave the place of the accident (even though I didn’t require immediate medical attention nor expected any further threats), but I couldn’t move because of the people around me. Others just kept sitting frozen in place and others were looking at each other and apparently expecting an explanation of what just had happened, or perhaps they were waiting for the show to continue? It was so out of place that they didn’t know what to do.
good comment, but it's a bit long. I don't think many people are going to read it
@@vastabyss6496 Yeah, it got longer than expected... Thanks.
I thought it very helpful. Incredible real world experience. Thanks for your insights.
I read it and the end is the best part
The first two parts aren't interesting, I skipped to points 3 and 4, good read
As a former mortarman, it actually feels good to hear the idea that most people I dropped hate on, and those of us who recieved it, probably died instantly. I really do think about that. The loss itself is the worst part, but the suffering adds so much. Thank you for this.
Perfect example of how a youtube video is 100% better than any tv broadcast or documentary.
Good job
Such an amazing compliment. Thank you 😊
I never really paid much attention, but if you look at explosions in movies, only the characters are really thrown away.
Windows and other clearly fragile items are broken, but most furniture and similar is simply thrown about in almost random directions most of the time.
Awe, poor lil stick people 😢 . I'm a devotee of warning sign stick people art and I must say, your stick people are pretty darn fun!
What's the most extreme example of this you've seen in a movie / on TV?
One notable example is the film "The Dark Knight" (2008), where the character Harvey Dent, portrayed by Aaron Eckhart, is caught in an explosion that sends him flying through the air.
Another example is the movie "Transformers: Dark of the Moon" (2011), where various characters are propelled into the air by explosions during intense action scenes involving massive battles between robots.
Jojos part 5, mista shooting the gas tank on the boat blowing him to saftey.
Saw a video of 2 Russian soldiers attempting to disarm an anti-tank mine rigged as a bobby trap in UA. One of them did actually get thrown through the air gruesomely(what remained of his body was partially disfigured). Was pretty hard to watch. So yes, military grade explosions can throw people.
Not on tv, but a game.
Tf2's "soldier" class is well known for "rocket jumping" aka propelling himself into the air with rpg explosives
The most dangerous explosion is well... Of course my wive explosion, it throw kitchenware with deadly effect
I had an opportunity to attend a lecture focused on blast injuries/treatments of about a decade ago… It was a surprise to see that the majority of the damage to humans caused by explosions was due to over pressure and not from heat/shrapnel produced by said blast. The “flying through the air” thing definitely is dependent upon a countless number of variables and is by no means the expected outcome of every explosion.
"Films vary in their adherence to realism". 😃 That was a nice euphemism.
DEBUNKED VIDEOS ARE ALWAYS A GREAT EXPERIENCE TO WATCH
Thank you! 😊
So yes, but the person is likely never gonna be able to tell us the experience 😅
exactly. These gas tankers/lines blowing up in Johannesburg , Venezuela, etc. are flipping cars and crushing buildings. That means you will wind up in pieces too.
sometimes they do throw you. There are tons of videos from Iraq and Afghanistan of explosions throwing humans quite far at times. But those people were typically dead too. You don't have to ask the survivors. you can ask those of us who witnessed it, or view the video evidence we sometimes managed to record. Easy to get video when you call in an airstrike and are waiting for ordnance to impact the designated target. Sometimes we had cameras mounted on teh vehicles for other purposes too, and gun turret footage (from tanks and CROWS turrets and Gyro Cams).
Mithbusters: we conducted an experiment because we didn't have volunteers💀 so we used something else
there are enough witness reports from veterans of both worldwars who talked and wrote about people geting thrown into the air from artillery shells. in WWI it happend quite often that people got "blown out off their clothes", with only shreds of their clothing remainin on the spot, and the formerly wearer of those high up in a tree or meters away (obviously also reduced to pulp and shreds).
Also there is a biographie from a WWII vet who got states he got "lifted from his feet and thrown against the churches Brickwall getting knocked out by the impact", he was rescued by medics and recovered in a hospital...
Great to see you releasing regular content again! 👍
Anyone who has been watching certain drone videos in the last two years can confirm that explosions can indeed throw people into the air. In some cases quite impressively far even.
As someone who survived a terrorist bomb explosion, I approve this video.
I wasn't thrown into the air, but it did push me and my aunt who was carrying me (I was 4yo) to fall into the ground. Lucky for us, we were shielded from the shrapnel projectiles and glass, so no serious injuries were sustained. And maybe the explosion wasn't strong enough to cause internal damage either. But the PTSD was real...
you forgot about the inhalation of toxic gas in an explosion which can lead to respiratory faliuar and death
Yet another cool video ! Keep it up ! 😊
Thank you! We will 😊
I thought characters used to jump so they could go far away from the explosion 😅
I am pretty sure they are supposed to.
If you see something about to blow up, your first response will likely be to throw yourself away from it.
But i don't think it really helps that much with avoiding the blast, let alone the burn.
You're not alone 😂 unless they were facing towards the explosion and blown back, I thought they were jumping 😂
I thought Debunked would point out the extra-ridiculousness of that MI scene in the bridge where Tom Cruise is running away from a predictable incoming explosion (😂) and when it explodes at his back, the pseudo-blast wave propels him to his left, against a conveniently placed vehicle 😂 What a ridiculous scene!
This is exactly what I needed for my work break! ❤❤
Enjoy and hope you learn something new 👌
Glad debunked is tagging this topic. It's what we've wanted
Love your vids your truly underrated
Thank you 😊 The channel is growing again so 🤞
i can attest you can be flung by an explosion. definitely a rare thing due to how close i was as well as not catching a lot of shrapnel. The groin protector for vests works well for shrapnel btw x)
😬
I was on a mission in Iraq when an entire house was blown up as we drove by. The blast was behind me and it threw me forward in my 5-point harness (it was a bit loose for comfort). The blast also knocked the wind out of me and stopped my heart for a moment. The "house borne IED" was estimated to be ~2000lb in size
I've heard stories where somebody was thrown back by into a wall by a small explosion. He was able to pick himself up off the floor, look at the people around him, then fell over dead. At least, that's what I've been told...
Hey, Stu! (and the rest of the team). Little bit of a request from a random nobody on the internet. Kinda wanna see a Medieval misconceptions in this Debunked format.
Considering the middle ages is completely riddled with misconceptions from Fantasy and whatnot, it should be easy to get some good ones in a vid.
Anyway, keep doing what you're doing and i'll keep watching regardless
Thanks for your suggestion 👍
One of my favourite behind-the-scenes footage of explosions is the one from The Doctor Falls, where Cybermen actors used trampolines to simulate being flung into the air.
Great video, and very nice explanations. High explosives at 8km/s is so ridiculously fast, I believe there are some at 10km/s as well. It's so much fun and fascinating to watch detonations and observe the sound delay etc.
Keep going mate, your channel is amazing, and your slowly but surely getting there💯💪
Thank you so much for your comment 😊
Hi, great video! I have a question about your animations. In which software do you make them? Can you tell us a bit about your process?
Thanks for asking! We design out assets in both Adobe Illustrator and After Effects. We animate each scene in After Effects and then compile the animations, VO, music, sound effects etc in Adobe Premiere.
It's always fun to see though.. ESPECIALY in video games. It use to be the one thing I longed for in video games when I was small for some reason.
GTA gave me that fix along with Perfect Dark.
Loved the video Stu!
Thank you 😊
If we want to talk about very very fundamentally, an explosion is merely the separation of something into opposite directions
(Conservation of linear momentum and all that)
This is the most underrated channel on RUclips!
How you notice you are still a physics nerd: When you are enraged that at 8:12 the shock wave is drawn as a transversal wave, but they are actually longitudinal waves. (But I appreciate that the first ones are easier to convey in a drawing and is what common folk associate with the concept of a wave)
0:32 I never quite understood how that explosion blew him sideways!
3:00 Isn’t high and low explosives actually defined by the method of ignition? You can make petrol, a low explosive, detonate with a shockwave faster than the speed of sound
my uncle had a ruptured intestine and blood in his lungs from an explosions shockwave. they had to remove a few inches of his intestines to repair the damage
How close was he to the explosion
this channle explains every questions I got in midschool in the way of professional physics
One of my favorite channels indeed👍🏻
Thank you so much 😊
Like your videos. Again, a topic that interested me and that you discussed exhaustively.
We do our best to cover all aspect 😊whilst still keeping it entertaining.
That Mission Impossible clip is hilarious cuz you can freaking SEE that that the explosion is nowhere near the correct angle to push the guy in that direction, unless there's an off screen explosion that for some reason we are not allowed to see, the forbidden explosion if you will.
I know, looks spectacular but makes no sense. I remember watching a 'making of' and that angle isn't a mistake, they knew it was incorrect but the framing worked better 😆
I like the smooth animation of this stick dude, the smile the look the eyes, wonderful
Thank you 😊
I just subscribed because I learned new things and it helps to learn English by watching your videos.Hehehe!
Thanks for subscribing and make sure you check out our other videos 👍 Is this the first time you've watched Debunked?
4:42 “for instant” love you guys, but had to point it out
Doh! We had that marked for a VO Pick up and the note must have got lost. Sorry about that.
@@DebunkedOfficial I just thought it was funny, it’s all good!! Great video
A friend of my mom's, a Ukrainian woman, a civilian, was thrown by a blast and had her knee bent in a way it really shouldn't have, but due to the adrenaline and the shock she still ran for hours until she collapsed and got treatment. Now she lives in a different country and needs a wheelchair. It's amazing what shock and adrenaline can do for you when you need it most, she's lucky to have survived.
Hero only gets blown up if he accidentally looks at the explosion...
There are videos you can research of the Beirut port explosions of people thrown off their feet while being at least 500 meters away from the initial blast. I was 1km away and suffered from glass shrapnels
My uncle drove a box truck with forklift. The forklift was not properly secured and when he applied the brakes suddenly the propane tank was pierced causing an explosion. My uncle had no burns or outside damage but his inside were mush, his passenger survived because he wasn't wearing his seatbelt and got ejected out of the truck. Crazy!
Those animations are hilarious 😂🤣😂 Thank you!
Glad you enjoyed them 😁
Half the time, the proos around the explostions dint even fly outward, but the guy just gets freaking THROWN
They can, but they usually don't.
Timesaved: 13:13
depending on where the explosion occurs and where you stand will give different pressure.
if you are inside of a building close do the exit and a bombs goes off inside you probably will be thrown far away.
but in a open space you will need a much potent explosion and if that is the case which lift you from ground you are probably dead or will be soon.
See the condition change everything.
In a closed space there us only one way out , through the exit. So it is sure to build up lot of pressure to move the air in one direction making the flow powerful enough to make you fly without causing death. That means you are safely away from the explosion, but the condition on where that happen that safety distance is not that safe anymore as it would be completely safe if the explosion was in open space.
7:48 so close to making a PM reference
My uncle survived a direct hit of a nade. About 12 debris penetrated his legs, he got lucky enough to safe them (legs ofc). And, after all, he can easily walk and even run sometimes.
not sure why ive always been a stickler for realism but i always found it disapointing when watching a movie and a simple frag grenade goes off like napalm and throws people like ragdolls. anywhoot great video, here have a like
awesome video !
Working on an old Tube TV with 3 humongous capacitors hidden under the front panel, that does Throw you up in the air and back.
i’ve watched a bit of combat footage myself, and been surprised by the sheer airtime achieved by bodies
Great info
Thank you! I’m glad you enjoyed it and hope you learned something new 👍
I paused the video after an explosion, and heard a car alarm going off down the street.
Coincidence?
Probably, but I'd like to think not.
Yes they blow you into the air… but you probably won’t be in 1 piece…
I just watched a YT video of a Russian orc trying to move an anti-tank mine. He did, in fact, get blown into the air. Way way into the air.
He probably also won a Darwin award..
Link?
Then there is the blown through glass window/door thing in movies. I once visited a friend in hospital after they suffered some injury and the next bed neighbour went onto a glass door (not because of an explosion) which shattered on the impact allowing the person to go through. They suffered a large number of cuts and lost so much blood that survival was uncertain for a few days. In movies, such glass would be made of sugar not real glass. It's possible to engineer large panels of what's essentially transparent candy which easily shatter without causing injuries.
Dang, 1:50 was brutal. 💀
Deflagration is not exclusive to low explosives though, high explosives can also deflagrate and this is one of the ways bombs are defused. (I should probably say "dont try this at home" though)
How long will the offer be
3 days after moving into a quiet town in the middle of the woods, a house at the end of the street exploded. Complete obliteration of the house. The only person inside was an old lady on pure oxygen,who also was a smoker.... It is unknown what else was in the house that could cause such a boom but setting off the oxygen tanks was probably the start of it.
This actually makes me want to ask you to tell us what would happen if an asteroid the size of an arena would hit the earth. What happens to those nearby, further away, etc. (I know this won’t happen because the larger the asteroid the sooner our radars pick it up and we can redirect it away, but still.)
That Beirut explosion also created a lot of "knocked several meters from the window" reports. Guess it was that combination of quite much energy for a large radius, so that there was all that mass around the explosion was not enough for significant shrapnel, and a so big of zones, that you get a big enough zone of enough-energy-to-throw but not-enough-energy-to-instantly-die. But your guess is as good as mine.
unfirtunately i can only give one thumb up.. loved it..
a 13 minute video for "yes, it can, sometimes"
That's basically what I expected, though I thought MAYBE it would be even less probable for them to survive if they were thrown into the air, or else that they might definitely become deaf.
Breaking bad El Paso explosion really shocked me because they really did the realism with the leg breaking off
TL;DW: Yes it's possible but highly exaggerated in movies and depends on a range of factors.
Nice job 👍🏻
Thanks for watching and commenting 👍
Damn, I just wanted to rocket jump.
Air fuel explosions as in gas leak explosions are very slow deflagrations, the over pressures are quite survivable, the vast majority of injury and death come from being propelled by the blast against something and getting hit by debris, collapsing building or fire.
Maybe also adress facts and misconceptions based on videogames aswell? Would be great!
Can you think of any real big ones that you'd like to see? Thanks for watching and commenting 👍
@@DebunkedOfficial Can you really learn something just by playing videogames (i.e. driving, shooting, etc.)?
How much violence can videogames actually cause?
I hope you can take these into consideration. But even if you don't, I still look foward to the next video!
Most of the time the shock wave wont kill you, even the fire, but shrapnel is the most dangerous thing. For example a standard US "MK 2" hand grenade doesnt really have a big shockwave, but it has powerful metal fragments going in all directions.
I survived being close enough to have things go flying. We had to immediately get up and get to our armor, because more things where probably going to be lobbed at us. It definitely causes permanent damage.
As someone whos been around a lot of explosions, no. you barely feel the thing pushing but you feel the smaller lighter things getting pushed through you and sometimes you feel the air in your lungs trying to escape
If the explosion is close enough and powerful enough to throw you you are dead before your body leaves the ground
They also don’t throw flames normally
Edit: ok correction man made explosives,
You should do a video about lasers in media vs real life
"Do you expect me to talk?!"
"No Mr Bond I expect you to die."
😉
Yup. xD
As a general rule, if the explosion has enough force to throw you up the air... it's your body going up - you are already dead, as Kenshiro would say. General rule meaning, yes, there are real life exceptions to that - just don't count on it.
“The difference between most people and military persons is as follows- While military folk prop parachutes to concern a hotly debated landing zone, the normie just wants to be able to walk after a gut wrenching backflip”
What does this have to do with the video lol
@@Mr.Spade1 “I could say the same about the vacuum and the broom- which is more sound during a cleanup at the library”
@@jeskoumm “ah yes I travel hither and thither”
@@Mr.Spade1 “So I’ve sent out invitations for the next marriage and haven’t yet finalised the divorce….Wait until she finds my next secret stash of cucumber salads”
“ _Kermit Shows Off Miss Piggy on Omegle_ ”
Red - you're dead.
Blue - you're through.
Yellow - you're mellow.
~ _Carl Winslow_
11:32, actually i have a very good friend that had an rpg explosion in his armored vehicle and he walked out.. without 3 and a half fingers… Funnily enough most of the others inside survived in varying degrees of injures.
Thank god we in israel have the best combat , medics and medical infrastructure in the world the fastest life saving treatments in the world
There was a case where fireman were responding to a burning building then it exploded sending the firemen way into the air some of them survived with severe injuries and a couple of them died.
A low explosive will push, whie a high explosive with cut. A low explosive (an dthey can vary a lot) may throw a person with some injuries. A high explosive that can actually throw you will likely kill you.
More often than not, an explosion (that doesn't kill them) would push a person off balance, rather than throw them.
7:30 I didn’t know gojo was in this video
I was on a mission in Iraq when an entire house was blown up as we drove by. The blast was behind me and it threw me forward in my 5-point harness (it was a bit loose for comfort). The blast also knocked the wind out of me and stopped my heart for a moment. The "house borne IED" was estimated to be ~2000lb in size
As someone who plays a lot of TF2, i can confirm that explosions can, in fact, propel you. You can most likely survive as well!
There's a video called "A Former PLA Soldier Hired By Russians Gives Reality Check on Russia-Ukraine War". At about 1:45, he claims a bomb was set off, and he was hurled to the top of a house. I'm suddenly questioning the authenticity of his testimony because of this video.
love the boom booms🤩💣💥