Jis Desh Ki Army Aata,Kapada,Saban,Jamin Bechta Hai Or Paise kamate Hai Vo Desh Kaise Aagey Badhega.. Army ka Kam Desh ki Raksha Karna Hota HaI Vahi Army Rajniti Karne Lage Tow Yahi Halat Honge,, Jiska Jo kam Hai Vo Kam Wafadari Nibhaye Tow Tarakki Kar Shakta hai Desh,, YA Fir Army Rules Ke Hisab Se 1 Hi Siyashi Parti Honi Chahiye Usmai Se PM Banaye Taki Army Ka Jyada Time waste Na Ho Rajneeti Ya Civil War Mai Army...
Shehzad bhai, thank you for choosing the book. Ms. Lamb had unparalleled access to “facts” in Pakistan and the machine that worked to generate such facts. Her being an exceptionally smart person who witnessed the inner workings of Pak powerbrokers (all of whom were one and the same) from a unique vantage, her book becomes a must read for every history buff interested in understanding how the wheels within wheels operate in Pakistan. Your narrative is 10 out of 10, but the post production audio editing is 2.5 at best. It appears as if you are running around the stationary microphone, in a closed room and almost out of breath. Please hire a better audio editor.
@@ThePakistanExperience I don’t care about the production quality on RUclips (gift horse, teeth, etc. etc.); but judging from the efforts and intensity your program has become a love affair! I want your show to become the benchmark for quality programming.
Shehzad, you are courageous my friend and I wish I knew you on a personal level. We need more people like you in the subcontinent. Let’s keep the hope alive! Take care, my brother on the other side of the fence .
Shezad great analysis. I read that book and it gave me a deeper understanding of Pakistan's political challenges and Bhutto's complex leadership. Lamb offers a sharp critique of Bhutto's rise and the systemic issues that hindered her success. While I found her insights valuable, at times the analysis felt overly critical, considering the immense constraints Bhutto faced from the military and political establishment.
With our tax money v made Pak Army to buy weapons and now we are scared to face this Army 🤔🤔🤔I’m scared to die but I will live in fear , coming generations will do the same .
I noticed it too. It’s supposed to be “Chris-tina”. Shehzad is mis-pronouncing it. I think he is saying “chris-cheena” but so fast that it sounds like he is saying “Krishna”
Brother why are you getting mad, I’m a proud Jiyala too, I loved how you disagreed with every criticing point of BB and presented an argument in her favor. I appreciate your efforts in creating a new narrative for ppp’s comeback, the left is dead in Pakistan and the only hope are the Bhuttos. Jiye Bhutto, Sindh Khappay. ❤
How da fk was burucracy punjabi dominated in ayub time when it was occupied by paan thukiay mohajir, their overwhelming occupation was what compelled.bhutro.to.enforce quota system, this stupid myth of punjabi dominated amythog .should be debunked, army was under control.of pathans and beiricray was under paan thukiay, there.wqs no punjabi estab
i dont agree with you where you portray positive sides of politicians. Look those politicians came because of the establishment, they knew all the process of how to be on that post.
I think the partition was the biggest blunder/failure of pakistan led by mr jinnah i believe if Pakistan need to change there is only one option left that is the public revolution , which does include people of all background regardless of their ethnicity, religion, caste, etc
@HashimAtif-x9w glad, a fellow Pakistani has realised it, jinnah created Pakistan, but what is pakistans contribution to making life of its people (awam) better & pakistans contribution to the world. (apart from taliban who control 🇦🇫 , ttp, hijbul, jaish etc.) Not to talk that in United India, Muslim would be a force to recon with its 60 Crores combined population.
Apki nazar main punjabi gunahgar Baloch pashtoon mazloom hero hain Punjabi buerocracy seriously? Ayoub khan kon tha? Punjabi Is khittay ki locals native sindhi punjabi jamote hindko milkr 80 percent banati mulq ka unka ration to ziada hoga Or punjab developed tha education ziada thi as compared to other (now pakistan) Bro tasveer ka dusra rukh bhi bataya kro
Mother of Taliban Foj k sath deal krny wali, american firm k through lobbying krny wali and now her daughter and son on the same footprints taliban apologists opposition ko crush kr rhy hein or foj ki tangon mai latak k 26 foji amendment pass krwaie
@@ThePakistanExperience Ahmad rashid's book Taliban: Islam, Oil and the New Great Game in Central asia, how she helped molana fazlu to set up thousands of pro taliban madrasas specially dar ul uloom. ye zehar aj tk khtm nhi hva or na ho sakta hai. The time when khan was not even in politics thats how taliban grow in pak but ham ne tw khan ko blame krna hai bcz he is easy target zra muzammil se b kehna is py vlog bnaye.
Ji i think most upright person is khan, as he earned the title of Taliban khan by just patronizing them and suggesting to open their offices in Peshawar. Nah. No way. He is the cleanest.
@@G-raa-c2k yes he is the cleanest. what should he do? ban all these madrasas than he will be labeled as yahoodi agent or crush the taliban bandoqain khol dy un py? tw btao hamari army larh sakti hai kisi se? negotiations is the only solution apki baby bhutto b yhi bol rhi hai. TTP khan ne nhi bnaie foj or bhuttos or pmln ne bnaie thi. Imran khan ne sary madrasy reg kiye under education ministry and your current govt cancel this bill bcz molana helped them in 26 foji amendeamendment
Bro by that logic no one in Pakistan has ever gotten complete majority in the house other than nawaz sharif once in 90s. No pm in history came without a deal with establishment. Also why jumping to benazir? Benazir was a product of z.a bhutto who was himself a product of ayub khan. Thori back calculation karleni thee, peeechay se sab heee askari products hain jani.
Nahee jani ZA Bhutto also went against Ayub and the army . The army was against him in the election. Humari videos dekh lo is par ya kitaabain parh loo
Christina lamb - Pakistan's struggle for democracy WAS there ever democracy in Pakistan 😅😅😅😅😅 My Indian Kashmiri Muslim Friends Mother - Atleast we can select our Leaders 😊😊😊😊😊
Bro ye series khatam nahi honi chahiye. Keep making these types of videos. Hats off to you.
🙌
@@ThePakistanExperienceBenazir instigated Kashmir militants by her PTV broadcast citing Rasool and Islamic history . Check video on you tube
The author’s name Christina is pronounced as “Kris-tina” not “krisheena”
Same 😂 . I heard it as krishna lamb
The baby election date is very funny 😂😂😂
😂
*16 DECEMBER 1971 GLORIOUS VICTORY DAY (MAHAN VIJAY DIWAS) GREETINGS.*
bilkul sahi kehta hai tu shehzaday. khush reh! 👍
Jis Desh Ki Army Aata,Kapada,Saban,Jamin Bechta Hai Or Paise kamate Hai Vo Desh Kaise Aagey Badhega.. Army ka Kam Desh ki Raksha Karna Hota HaI Vahi Army Rajniti Karne Lage Tow Yahi Halat Honge,, Jiska Jo kam Hai Vo Kam Wafadari Nibhaye Tow Tarakki Kar Shakta hai Desh,, YA Fir Army Rules Ke Hisab Se 1 Hi Siyashi Parti Honi Chahiye Usmai Se PM Banaye Taki Army Ka Jyada Time waste Na Ho Rajneeti Ya Civil War Mai Army...
Shehzad bhai, thank you for choosing the book. Ms. Lamb had unparalleled access to “facts” in Pakistan and the machine that worked to generate such facts. Her being an exceptionally smart person who witnessed the inner workings of Pak powerbrokers (all of whom were one and the same) from a unique vantage, her book becomes a must read for every history buff interested in understanding how the wheels within wheels operate in Pakistan.
Your narrative is 10 out of 10, but the post production audio editing is 2.5 at best. It appears as if you are running around the stationary microphone, in a closed room and almost out of breath. Please hire a better audio editor.
🙌
On it
@@ThePakistanExperience I don’t care about the production quality on RUclips (gift horse, teeth, etc. etc.); but judging from the efforts and intensity your program has become a love affair! I want your show to become the benchmark for quality programming.
Shehzad, you are courageous my friend and I wish I knew you on a personal level. We need more people like you in the subcontinent. Let’s keep the hope alive! Take care, my brother on the other side of the fence .
🙌
Shezad great analysis. I read that book and it gave me a deeper understanding of Pakistan's political challenges and Bhutto's complex leadership. Lamb offers a sharp critique of Bhutto's rise and the systemic issues that hindered her success. While I found her insights valuable, at times the analysis felt overly critical, considering the immense constraints Bhutto faced from the military and political establishment.
🙌
please make a video on recent tragic boat incident near Greece and educate people about not to choose the dunki route for better future
Brilliant analysis❤❤
❤️
I enjoyed reading The Man from Pakistan: The true Story of the World's Most Dangerous Nuclear Smuggler by Frantz and Collins
With our tax money v made Pak Army to buy weapons and now we are scared to face this Army 🤔🤔🤔I’m scared to die but I will live in fear , coming generations will do the same .
Good stuff!
🙌
Is it Krishna lamb or Chris-tina Lamb?
I noticed it too. It’s supposed to be “Chris-tina”. Shehzad is mis-pronouncing it.
I think he is saying “chris-cheena” but so fast that it sounds like he is saying “Krishna”
Very interesting vlog.
The hold of the Pakistani Army over the country is scary.
🙌
Good video shahzad bhai love from india.
❤️
very Courageous.......said very scary things
🙌
@@ThePakistanExperience Please take care of yourself.
Great video as always, bro but after the 97th time, I heard the words “Christina Lamb likhti hain” I had to quit
🙌😂
Pehla Azeem tareen Pakistani qoomi badkirdar, badkirdar janab Ayoo khuna ......
Good ❤
❤️
Book Recommendation: The Pakistan Paradox by Christophe Jaffrelot
please make a video on Sindhi muhajir conflict, who was responsible for it. very good content
We have a podcast with NFP on it
Good video
🙌
Next book : Pak studies punjab textbook board by Lumber 1 😂
Pakistan is a peaceful country
Pyare lg rhe ho ap, & informative Analysis.
🙌
Book recommemded / requesting to do next
End of the Past (Nadeem Farooq Paracha)
Shehzad’s love letter to BB and PPP.❤
Suna wuna hay nahee kuch bus comment kar Kay troll karo jahil raho aapka books say kya kaam? Youthtubers say history seekho
Brother why are you getting mad, I’m a proud Jiyala too, I loved how you disagreed with every criticing point of BB and presented an argument in her favor. I appreciate your efforts in creating a new narrative for ppp’s comeback, the left is dead in Pakistan and the only hope are the Bhuttos. Jiye Bhutto, Sindh Khappay. ❤
❤❤❤
❤️🙌
How da fk was burucracy punjabi dominated in ayub time when it was occupied by paan thukiay mohajir, their overwhelming occupation was what compelled.bhutro.to.enforce quota system, this stupid myth of punjabi dominated amythog .should be debunked, army was under control.of pathans and beiricray was under paan thukiay, there.wqs no punjabi estab
i dont agree with you where you portray positive sides of politicians. Look those politicians came because of the establishment, they knew all the process of how to be on that post.
❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
❤️
I think the partition was the biggest blunder/failure of pakistan led by mr jinnah i believe if Pakistan need to change there is only one option left that is the public revolution , which does include people of all background regardless of their ethnicity, religion, caste, etc
@HashimAtif-x9w glad, a fellow Pakistani has realised it, jinnah created Pakistan, but what is pakistans contribution to making life of its people (awam) better & pakistans contribution to the world. (apart from taliban who control 🇦🇫 , ttp, hijbul, jaish etc.) Not to talk that in United India, Muslim would be a force to recon with its 60 Crores combined population.
SORRY IT WAS NOT PUNJABI IT WAS "URDU SPEAKING", IN WAH CANTT ON ALL K POSITIONS WERE "URDU SPEAKERS".
Please Read this book "Pakistan the Balochistan Conundrum" and share your perspective
Ok
Write another book:- Rise and fall of pakistan,, waiting for Kashmir 😂😂😂
Rise?
@nevergiveup19841 Rise ,,दिल बहलाने को ख्याल अच्छा है ग़ालिब,,,,
🙏🙏
🙌🙌
Apki nazar main punjabi gunahgar Baloch pashtoon mazloom hero hain
Punjabi buerocracy seriously?
Ayoub khan kon tha? Punjabi
Is khittay ki locals native sindhi punjabi jamote hindko milkr 80 percent banati mulq ka unka ration to ziada hoga
Or punjab developed tha education ziada thi as compared to other (now pakistan)
Bro tasveer ka dusra rukh bhi bataya kro
Next book Pakistan a Garisson State by DR Istikar.
Mother of Taliban Foj k sath deal krny wali, american firm k through lobbying krny wali and now her daughter and son on the same footprints taliban apologists opposition ko crush kr rhy hein or foj ki tangon mai latak k 26 foji amendment pass krwaie
Was Benazir Bhutto the Mother of the Taliban? - Waiting for Allah by Christina Lamb #TPE Book Club
ruclips.net/video/-WtS16B7X0Y/видео.html
@@ThePakistanExperience Ahmad rashid's book Taliban: Islam, Oil and the New Great Game in Central asia, how she helped molana fazlu to set up thousands of pro taliban madrasas specially dar ul uloom. ye zehar aj tk khtm nhi hva or na ho sakta hai. The time when khan was not even in politics thats how taliban grow in pak but ham ne tw khan ko blame krna hai bcz he is easy target zra muzammil se b kehna is py vlog bnaye.
Ji i think most upright person is khan, as he earned the title of Taliban khan by just patronizing them and suggesting to open their offices in Peshawar. Nah. No way. He is the cleanest.
@@G-raa-c2k yes he is the cleanest. what should he do? ban all these madrasas than he will be labeled as yahoodi agent or crush the taliban bandoqain khol dy un py? tw btao hamari army larh sakti hai kisi se? negotiations is the only solution apki baby bhutto b yhi bol rhi hai. TTP khan ne nhi bnaie foj or bhuttos or pmln ne bnaie thi. Imran khan ne sary madrasy reg kiye under education ministry and your current govt cancel this bill bcz molana helped them in 26 foji amendeamendment
Sorry, but it's pronounced like Kristina not crisheena !🤔
Bro by that logic no one in Pakistan has ever gotten complete majority in the house other than nawaz sharif once in 90s.
No pm in history came without a deal with establishment.
Also why jumping to benazir? Benazir was a product of z.a bhutto who was himself a product of ayub khan.
Thori back calculation karleni thee, peeechay se sab heee askari products hain jani.
Nahee jani
ZA Bhutto also went against Ayub and the army . The army was against him in the election. Humari videos dekh lo is par ya kitaabain parh loo
Was she contesting elections while pregnant? That's funny. 🤣
Yes
Christina lamb - Pakistan's struggle for democracy
WAS there ever democracy in Pakistan 😅😅😅😅😅
My Indian Kashmiri Muslim Friends Mother - Atleast we can select our Leaders 😊😊😊😊😊
Hope you are not in Pakistan? otherwise unknown man may come. anytime . Although topic is intresting.
I am here in Pakistan
🤓🤓🤓
🙌