"Towers of Ivory and Steel": Jewish Scholar Says Israeli Universities Deny Palestinian Freedom
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 мар 2024
- Support our work: www.democracynow.org/donate?c...
Israeli scholar Maya Wind’s new book, Towers of Ivory and Steel: How Israeli Universities Deny Palestinian Freedom, documents how Israeli universities directly constrain Palestinian rights by supporting and even developing the policies of occupation and apartheid used by the Israeli state. “In the West, Israeli universities are considered bastions of pluralism and democracy. But in fact … they are a central pillar of Israel’s regime of oppression against Palestinians,” says Wind. She also discusses Israel’s “scholasticide" in Gaza, the "intentional destruction of Palestinian education,” and the movement of conscientious objectors to Israel’s mandatory conscription, in which she took part when she refused to enlist in the army at age 18 and served 40 days in a military prison.
Democracy Now! is an independent global news hour that airs on over 1,500 TV and radio stations Monday through Friday. Watch our livestream at democracynow.org Mondays to Fridays 8-9 a.m. ET.
Subscribe to our Daily Email Digest: democracynow.org/subscribe
Twitter (X) / democracynow
Instagram / democracynow
“The Nazis made me afraid of being Jewish and the Zionists made me ashamed of being Jewish.” ~ (Dr. Israel Shahak, organic chemistry professor, human and civil rights activist, and Holocaust survivor) "Take the worst thing you can about Hamas multiply it by a thousand times and it still will not meet the Israeli repression and mass killing and dispossession of Palestinians." ~ Gabor Maté Holocaust Survivor
merci. son from Holocaust survivor
Thank you. Best I've heard this put during the whole debate.
@@johnrider4649 You welcome and repost it please if you can.
Israel has lost the conflict in Gaza BOTH IN WORLD OPINION AND ON THE GROUND.The attempted Genocide in Gaza will fail and from the ashes of Gaza will arise a free Palestine : FREE FROM OCCUPATION BY THE BRITISH EMPIRE : Free from Ottoman occupation and
FREE FROM THE BRUTAL ZIONIST OCCUPATION OF THE PAST 75 YEARS .
AND NOT BEFORE TIME
Since October 7th the whole world ,NOT JUST THOSE COUNTRIES THAT HAVE NEVER ,AND WILL NEVER RECOGNISE the Illegal State of Israel THE WHOLE WORLD has come face to face with the MONSTER that was created in Palestine in 1948.
still laughing.
Respect to this woman and all those fighting for justice.
She's funded by HamAS S
LOL!
Lol, Seems like reality and the truth doesn't mean nothing to her.
Indeed. Those female scholars are brave, have integrity & intellectual, moral ...courage to stand up for the truth & justice, while paying the necessary price for that, & no amount of zionist/ western propaganda can change that. Truth & justice will prevail....
@@jozef2630 You don't even know the meaning of "reality".
This is genocide but people are still in denial. How sad for Palestines 🇿🇦🇵🇸
It is war, not genocide.
@@srsmopar3808 okay
@@srsmopar3808not war, geno
@@fatimahlin9630 LOL, You are wrong. It is not geno just because the side you root for is losing.
@@srsmopar3808holocaust was a war
Thank you for giving people like Maya a platform to speak up on aparthied in Israel/ ocupied Palestine.
The author is an assimilated Jew who likes Arab $€£¥
I just need to add to what Maya said that great Israeli scholars like Ilan Pappé, Avi Shlaim and many others have been bullied and threatened that they had to leave Israel.. They teach abroad.
Pappé was recently interrogated by US immigration for a couple of hours on arriving in the country. The US always does apartheid Israel's bidding.
Wow wonderful prof. Thank u for speaking up on behalf of Palestinians, thank u!!
Brave and honest lady
Well done Ms Wind, I thank you from the bottom of my heart,
For following your heart and your humanity, and speaking the truth, no matter the possible reaction.
Their fantasies of having built a 'Perfect society plagued by their uncivilized neighbors...' are just lies built upon lies.
The revealing of the truth is what terrifies them the most.
I love the way you worded the second paragraph here. Well done.
100% Revealing the truth has always been mossad’s tactic to blackmail people they want to control. Now that they’ve controlled all the western government leaders, they all are terrified of the truth being revealed, so they try to squash the truth by controlling all western media. Now that TikTok users has somewhat shown the truth to the world, they are frantically trying to ban or control TikTok. The truth will all eventually come out, despite their devious plans and manipulations.
If an Israeli academic institution within the U.S. acts like this, they must NOT receive a SINGLE cent of Federal funding.
No religious schools should receive any taxpayer dollars!
the US is a free Country and we are Pro Israel.
dude, you're stating that as if this was an anomaly or something. Born yesterday? Do you think you have any power over your government? You don't.
Thank you to our Israeli sister for speaking up and saying the truth it’s the leaders
No apartheid has a right to exist, period.
It gets more and more like a horror movie what is happening in Palestine while Israel takes the Oscar's for best liars, most cruel and barbaric army, most corrupt israeli politicians, etc, etc.
LOL, maybe you should admit that hamas shouldn't have started this latest war?
@@srsmopar3808and What about all this wars years before October 7 Israel started you just admit That
@@zander-lb1jy I can admit that the arabs started the original war of genocide in 47 and lost. Losing wars often has catastrophic consequences for the losing side.
I am so glad this is being exposed. Truth is being suppressed. And more needs to be done to resist this.
@@srsmopar3808 ahhh so we have another successfully indoctrinated Zio sheep amongst us.
A chilling story of how voices for human rights are attached in Israel, even in their universities.
...attacked...
Tell a Lie often enough, and it becomes Israel's.
Golda Meir said decades ago, if the Arabs lay down their weapons there will be peace within a few months, if the Jews lay down their weapons within a month there will be no Israel.
So true.😢
They dont care about a free Palestinian State, their ultimate goal is to exterminate the State of Israel. They use their freedom and democratic rights to pursue the goal of destroying Israel. Who could be so naive? Or should such hatred be considered normal? This is a war of religion and hatred, but the side that is not ready to compromise is the side that has attacked Israel 4 times to throw it into the sea since the day it was established. This is the truth that is being overlooked by the world by the leftist media and Islamists.
They don't care about a free Palestinian State, their ultimate goal is to destroy the State of Israel. They use their freedom and democratic rights to pursue taht goal. Who could be so naive? Or should such hat*ed be considered normal? The side that is not ready to compromise is the side that has attacked Israel 4 times to throw it into the sea since the day it was established. This is the truth that is being overlooked by the world by the lefti*t media and Islam*sts.
They don't care about a free Palestinian State, their ultimate goal is to exterminate the State of Israel. They use their freedom and democratic rights to pursue the goal of destroying Israel. Who could be so naive? Or should such hat*ed be considered normal? The side that is not ready to compromise is the side that has attacked Israel four times to throw it into the sea since the day it was established. This is the truth that is being overlooked by the world by the lef*ist med*a and Isla*ists.
imagine being in a college and the child murderer returns, and then he will go out and complain that he feels threatened. So non of those children and men and women you killed felt anything you say?
RUclips redirected my comment against a genocide supporter to your comment, this is what they are doing now
You mean like an IDF soldier who as killed arab women and children ? If he has changed asks God for forgiveness athe I don't think the Israeli colleges will reject or threaten him.
Prof Ilan Pappé, author of 'The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine' (2006) faced similar headwinds at the University of Haifa (from about 2000?) and from a wider public, including the posting of human excrements to his home. He eventually left for a UK University (Exeter) in 2008.
IDF soldiers just mailed their diapers to him, I bet.
Wow, Ms. Wind does not look like she is 15yrs removed from the age of having to enter service. Good on her. I'm glad that her convictions have been somewhat rewarded.
Huh? She looks at least 40 or whatever she may be. Are you saying she looks 21?
I admire this woman not for her insights but for her actions, in particular refusing to join the Israeli army. Jails are not harsh for Jewish people in Israel, nothing like the hell holes in America. But the stigma of refusing to go along with the murderous Jewish supremacist regime in Israel seems very formidable. Actions like hers are what is going to fight the evil perpetrated by Israel. Books are fine but actions are far better. We know what's going on. We need to take actions to stop it.
Go and take “action”, sleazy coward.
Good to see fellow Canadian contributing so much to this field. Thank you for having Dr Wind on your channel.
All these “Doctors” need good medical treatment…
@@user-zq7zb6ew8pwhy? Because they don’t believe zionists lies?
💕Was surprised to learn that the West Bank, Gaza and Jerusalem have been under occupation for 55+ years 😵, according to the international law and UN resolutions (1967-2023). I've come to believe that justice needs power to enforce it. ⚖❤
Palestinians' right to resist is inherent to their right to exist as a people. An unlawful act of resistance does not make the resistance unlawful. An unlawful act of an unlawful occupation makes the occupation more unlawful Francesca Albanese, UN Special Rapporteur 2022
I acknowledge your good work. Ok Amy.!!!!
Please abandon all “settlements” and restrictions on the Palestinian people .
LOL good luck with that.
@@srsmopar3808that’s what thieves usually say?
@@eurozone73 LOL, Losers of (repeated) wars are generally not in position to get what they want.
@@srsmopar3808it's taking you 75 years to win against "losers"???
@@sabrinamystified bravo.
Thank you so much Amy for presenting ms Wind to us.... ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Amy Good(wo)man!
Thank you for your show and your guests,
I can't stop crying foe palestinains 😭😭😭💝💝💝🇦🇪🇦🇪🇦🇪🍉🍉💝💝💝
Lol, Why are you gonna cry, The leader of the Hamas Live in qatar and Making billions of dollars from this war..
You obviously don't know nothing about this war ....
Golda Meir said decades ago, if the Arabs lay down their weapons there will be peace within a few months, if the Jews lay down their weapons within a month there will be no Israel.
Zahir Muhsein was a Palestinian leader of the pro-Syria As-Sa'iqa Ba'athist faction of the Palestine Liberation Organization between 1971 and 1979.
In an interview with Trouw Magazine, 31. March 1977 he stated....."The Palestinian people do not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel for our Arab unity. Only for political and tactical reasons do we speak today about the existence of a Palestinian people, since Arab national interests demand that we posit the existence of a distinct "Palestinian people" to oppose Zionism. Yes, the existence of a separate Palestinian identity exists only for tactical reasons. The establishment of a Palestinian state is a new tool to continue the fight against Israel and for Arab unity.
@@JawboneDonkyfalse Israeli propaganda
Humanity must face the fact that there are three stages in Western societies/un civilization. 1) the conquering and genocide of the indigenous people land and culture. 2) setting up colonial governments, institutions and so called democracy. 3) The final stage, outright fascism.
I'll leave you with a poem from the book TRYIN TIMES from the Pyramids to the Projects:
DEMOCRACY
Who told you democracy is ruled by the people? Where does that electoral college come from? Who selects candidates before you elect candidates? Who said build that wall, do your research, Clinton started it. Who said deport those immigrants? Obama, while in office was known as "Deporter and Chief." This one says Republican, the other one says Democrat, they are two sides of the same coin. Who told you this was the best system? You only been taught about those other isms... Democracy on the brink of anarchy... Biden said "democracy is fragile"... how can something be fragile if it's built on solid foundation? Biden said "democracy is precious," to who? The answers are hiding in plain sight. Democracy and Demon have the first four letters in common. They must be rooted in the same, and precious to the demons that control this system.
😂🤣😂🤔😂 That anyone thinks America is either a Democracy or a Republic shows how ignorant and brainwashed y'all are. You live in a Capitalist Oligarchy. The same as all the other western 'Democracies'.
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
So true!
The ugly truth is being revealed by the genocide!
Once again thanks to this media and similar medias for educating the entire world of these atrocities by the Israeli government
They are talking nonsense,
When you live in the middle east you know the truth.
And this is the reason Saudis , egypt jordan bahrain The emirates Want to see hamas out of power and out of gaza They will not.
Say in public
And this is the reason they will not take even one palestinian from gaza refugee,
Learn the history learn who they are.
Before you're talking nonsense.
Golda Meir said decades ago, if the Arabs lay down their weapons there will be peace within a few months, if the Jews lay down their weapons within a month there will be no Israel.
A decent woman
Actually, a fool. Let’s not quibble though.
@@bernieyaphe4366How so?
As we learn more and more it has become so clear that there are two different factions of Zayo nazees:
Those who are denying the Palestinian Hollowcost and those who are insisting to carry on with a Palestinian Hollowcost.
My utmost respect for all Jewish people who reject this racist ideology of Zayoneezm and stay on the side of humanity.
Not only Jewish (with respect)for everyone that defend humanity 💐🤲☝️
Learn to spell adolf.
@@naymatunc-rc6vs Exactly
Wow! Shocker! It's shocking that the professor is even alive! We all know what "they" all are capable of!
2024
As a war resister from the Vietnam era, I commend Maya Wind!
Escolasticide! That is a new term I learned today.
Schlolasticide I think
Thank you Ms. Wind. Sometimes the bravest thing to do is to refuse to pick up a gun. Thank you for not committing genocide on behalf of American and European capitalist eleite interests. I hope you read this.
You're talking nonsense again
Golda Meir said decades ago, if the Arabs lay down their weapons there will be peace within a few months, if the Jews lay down their weapons within a month there will be no Israel.
Netanyahu and Israel has acted with impunity. This will not go unpunished.
Thank you from the bottom of my heart Amy for hosting Maya. And Maya, You are such a rare, upright human being. People like you are proof that all is not lost. Take care of you Maya, I wish you all the Best. To support you Maya, I'll buy your book, as soon as available in german.
Thanks for this information
"Schlasticide" another horror to endure. 😢
Great to see a brave young woman speak her mind and have a real conversation
Students get credits from their university for engaging in war crimes in Gaza? EXCUSE ME WHAT
This RUclips channel is on an absolute roll
Lol, You still buying from the media information , Grow up.
Every channel have his own agenda.
Learn who's behind of Each channel.
Brenda You should be smarter than that .
If you aren't careful, the newspapers will have you hating the people who are being oppressed and loving the people who are doing the oppressing. -Malcolm X
Stay educated before pointing fingers
Thank you for posting!!! Bravo Democracy Now !!!
I wonder how will the film adaptation of that book be like?
1958, President Nasser of Egypt said of the Jews: 'They left here black and came back white'.
Wind is brilliant and brave!! An example.
🙏
Seriously! We would imagine the since the Jews suffered the unthinkable, that they would not impose their suffrage upon others! It’s not so, here we are witnessing this horrific event.
Free Palestine people and give them a fair share of land!
The Jews have tried land for decades of war!
Jews will not live in peace! Be fair and free the Palestinian!
"Free Palestine people and give them a fair share of land! " LOL. Hamas does not want their fair share, they want all of it.
"Jews will not live in peace! " LOL, How is that working out for the Gazans right now?
Not all Jews, but perhaps those who learned about ethnic cleansing and genocide from Nazis and Americans and decided that Zionism allows them to treat "undesirables" or non-Jews as they please.
@@sandal_thong8631 LOL, jews have freedom to speak against their government, Those under the rule of totalitarian hamas do not.
@@srsmopar3808likud's charter: Judea and Samaria will not be handed to any foreign administration; between the Sea and the Jordan there will only be Israeli sovereignty.
Easy solution: admit Israel is a failed experiment and disband it. They had 75 years to learn to live in peace with their neighbours but was too busy assassinating the people they didn't like, sanctioning and meddling in their neighbours politics to deserve any more chances. Anyone who moved there since 1948 is an immigrant - not a native. They should be funded to go back or to whichever country they want who will take them.
Great coverage
The same was since 1933 in Germany and Austria
Maya Wind is a truly brave and courageous person. To stand against a right-wing state from the inside is so difficult and dangerous. So much respect and thanks for her research and analysis!
I got it , no matter what country you are born , if you are Jewish you must do what they tell you.
Genociders will say Maya is anti semitic
Amy still hasn't got that closing technique down yet. she's doing better but just not there yet. thanks Amy, for all the great lessons in reality.
Please explain the meaning of life. You have 10 seconds!
@@ronstephen-wy4ib She's still the best.
way too short of a segment
Thanks a lot Dr. Wind!
How can I contribute to translate and make your book available to audience in Norway?
Another Israeli that says it the way really it is! Well said.
Same in the USA.
LOL Hamas has no shame.
@@srsmopar3808 Another troll...boring.
@@astorrian6247 LOL, got a coherent point?
Blacks
What's the difference between how people think of Nazi sympathisers and Israeli sympathisers? 2 years!
It doesn’t suprise me that there is no academic freedom at Israeli Universities. Israel is not a democratic country, but an apartheid regime. To suppose that under these conditions value-free, unbiased and objective research could be carried out is illusionary.
Sure. But somebody has to talk or write about it or else they can keep on pretending that they are a democracy and everybody was free in it. The problem is that they brainwash people into believing things that are not true and thus make sure they are safe to carry on with all that horrible things.
Yet until now this professor did have academic freedom! 30 years? And Palestinians, and Israeli Arabs do attend university. Yet obviously the move to the right has led to more oppression and suppression. Democracy Now also consistently fails to elucidate or probe in interviews about how Palestinian leadership,Islamic Jihad, the genocidal intent of Hamas and Hezbollah played into the increasing repression by the Israeli government and fears in the populace that allows this to grow. That needs to be taken into account, to understand the emotions driving Israeli's, many refugees from both Europe and other Arab and Islamic nations, further away from compassion, and often hardens them from seeking equality and justice for Palestinians. Sad
A MUST BUY!
From Maya Wind!
LOL, She's talking nonsense.
Golda Meir said decades ago, if the Arabs lay down their weapons there will be peace within a few months, if the Jews lay down their weapons within a month there will be no Israel.
Another eye opener from Maya!
Lol, Are you buying information from the media, Maya she's a Maybe one percent of the left wing conspiracy.
Golda Meir said decades ago, if the Arabs lay down their weapons there will be peace within a few months, if the Jews lay down their weapons within a month there will be no Israel.
Courageous and strong women! Thank you!
They do the same in American and European colleges and universities...
Thank you Nadera &. Maya
It is amazing that voices of reason
can still be heard on our media.
Your program and courageous
visitors light up our admiration.
It's not being heard, but intentionally denied on mainstream media, Mainstream media entire agenda is simply to maintain a lie and further Zionist, Israeli proganda...the truth infact is coming out by independent media outlets,
Excellent Maya. When you talked to us last year in our anthro class, your book wasnt out yet, but I am very glad it is now. Where can I buy a copy?
Brave woman, Maya Wind.
❤Maya Wind❤
😢 may we all be free from stiff sadistic dogma and cruel Occupetions . Thank You!
Maya Wind...thank you, dear woman for your bravery of speaking up. Fantastic interview, God Bless you. ♥
Brave woman… I salute you.
Thank you, Amy and Maya, for trying to bring world peace. I love you!
Jewish brothers and sisters are key in the human struggle for liberation of Palestinians. I salute Maya Wind and her work. You not only help liberate Palestinians but yourselves as well. Together you will transform the Middle East.
And Harvard, Yale, MIT foster critical thinking and dissent, they don’t push their own revisionist, interpretivist critical race theory to the max 😂?
Love & respect for Author Maya Wind for being an honest voice against Israel's oppression,
& injustices against Palestinians thus, she gives some hope for the people of Palestine.
Two outstanding guests. Thank you for btinging them in.
Even without this book, the world knew it all, since the beginning. But what happened?
Books written in Israel, say that killing or driving out others from israel are everywhere, buts universty scholars are writing them.
Thanks you for your devotion and hard work to present a balanced view, to present information different from and alongside the mainstream accepted political path.
While living in nyc, a Jewish person told me the many cool “earthy” last names of euro-Jews - like wind, wolf, fox, lake, stone, fish, etc - derive from pagan-Ukrainian-Jews back in day. They ditched their signifying last names and took “earthy sur names”, which is BEYOND cool and fascinating! Wish there was essay on this…!!
The Israeli, Britain and American state administration must be held accountable for the genocide committed in Gaza.
In the world we have created, education will by necessity require inclusion and tolerance. Rigid structures, that exclude anyone, will be left behind.
LOL, Hamas has no 'tolerance' for living jews.
Maya Wind is a beautiful woman who has integrity and wisdom.
This rabbit hole just goes deeper and deeper
It's built in their society
Thank you for your book Ms Wind. She would never be allowed on CNN or MSNBC.
Why is this literally the ONLY video on this book that I can find on RUclips???
In the name of God, the most gracious, the most merciful
Those to whom the people said, “The people have gathered against you, so fear them,” and it increased their faith, and they said, “Allah is sufficient for us, and He is the best disposer of affairs.”
Great truth of God
May God be for you and with you against your enemies, O people of Gaza, Palestine, Lebanon, Yemen, Egypt, Jordan, Sudan, Libya, Syria and Iraq.
May God have mercy on your dead and accept them as martyrs along with the prophets and the truthful
May God let down those who let you down!
To me, Maya and prof. Nadera kivorkian are beacons of hope and fearless voices of truth for decent academia to celebrate all over the world…. ❤
Isn’t Nadera the one that was arrested by the Israeli military?
Thank you for speaking up on behalf of the palestininies .This should be send to the international court to see the crimes
It would be news to Israeli universities that they were responsible for granting _anyone_ freedom, never mind a people who aren't even Israeli.
People like her who not only refuse conscription but go onto stand firm with their consciences deserve everybody's praise and solidarity!
Nice interviews. I wish ya'll would time things better so people don't get cut off mid-sentence. Or just let them keep going and put the whole thing online.
I am so glad the plight of other suppressed peoples was mentioned by Dr Nadera such as the Rohingya who are also being persecuted and facing genocide.
Thank you for telling the truth that no one would believe if it was coming from a Palestinian
Thank you. ❤
thank you
Amy interrupting and cutting Nadera’s response that way is a horrible performative failure!
UK doctors involved in climate protests face threat of being struck off
GPs with convictions over protests face tribunals to determine whether they can keep licence to practise
war and dialogue seem to have fundamentally very different ways, war is about elimination of "the enemy" which so is "the other" and fueled by a mixture of hatred, anger and fear, only one of the two involved parties has to be the dominant force, dialogue is about granting space to one-another on equal level, absence of violence, the willingness to mirror one-another, the willingness to wholeheartedly listen to one-another, compassion-based a completely different dimension than war
Thank you Amy!
Good on you, Maya, for your exposé of Israeli universities. I can only imagine that this information will improve and strengthen Israel's university system!
That's the nature of a robust democratic society and economy. You're free to criticize without worrying about your safety, and in the end improve the system. Try this in Saudi Arabia or Yemen!
In fact, I wonder if you would be interested in applying your set of standards to the best Palestinian universities the west bank? --Al-Quds University, or Syria? --Damascus University , or Yemen? --Al-Razi University, or Saudi Arabia? --King AbdulAziz University, etc. etc.
Do you think these universities, in contrast to of course Hebrew University, Tel Aviv U and the Weizmann, are bastions of Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (a Western notion)?
God bless you Amy for the wonderful work that you are doing , my hats off to you !!