My gosh, how this beautiful man has stuffed the most important facts and understandings into one podcast for us is phenomenal. Thanks to all of you! Terrific helpful podcast!
@@den264 Truth by omission you mean. He left out key facts that vilifies Isreal. For instance, Israel did not "invade" Lebanon for no reason. It began with an attempted assassination of the Israeli ambassador in London, Israel attacked PLO targets in Lebanon on June 4, 1982. The PLO responded with rocket and artillery barrages, and Israel retaliated by sending ground troops into Lebanon, in a mission titled “Operation Peace for the Galilee.” There's always "cause and effect", lots of "effects" being mentioned here with the "cause" intentionally left out. Only idiots never ask "why".
@@bri_____1970And he is telling of weaponed power of Israelis, but do not mention the fact that in1948 the biggest and most powerful Arab states started big war against new established state, it was not Arabs of Palestine who fought, it was Transjordan, Syria, Iraq, Lebanon, Egypt. Saudi Arabia, Yemen. United Arab whose forces was double of Israelis. USA didn't supplied Israel with weapon, it was bought from Czech Republic, remnants of old weapons after the war between the USSR and Germany, and everything that could be bought from private sellers of weapons. Israelis was poorly weapons, in the minority, but it was the question of existence, and they won. From Khalidi I did not hear anything near the truth. The result was Israelis gaining of some territories in accordance of international war right as far as the Arabs started it and lost. The other parts of Palestine was taken av Egypt and Jordan, and it was no longer the will of Arabs of Palestine to establish of own start. So it was until in 1968 Arab countries decided to get rid of this tiny problem - Israel. And lost again. I doubt that he does know nothing of it. He just does not give the all facts. Why? The same with other episodes: not whole truth. I am so sorry, because he is not the worst of those who present the story of questions of this region. I expected more honesty, really, from a decent man.
Read his book, The Hundred Years War on Palestine. No longer can I say the issue is complicated. I’ve been eager to learn more about the war on Palestine and am learning about even more issues going on in the US. Not only am I more curious about how I’m able to live the life I lead but am more cautious about information I consume and what I participate in. Thanks again for a great video Tom.
Issue is certainly not complicated. Whether from Biblical or Islamic point of view, Palestine or more appropriately Holy Land is given to only one group of people. That is Israel and Jews. Anyone else, come directly against God Almighty and His promises to His people Israel.
@@truthprevails5173 gods people are not an ethnicity. It was never about that. Gods people are those whose allegiance and believing loyalty are to him.
@@gabrielt721 Yahweh the creator of universe chose Abraham and his descendants for a specific purpose: bless all the families of the planet Earth. That is His decision!
@@truthprevails5173 I am sure God Almighty would approve how Zionists are starving and murdering children. Revelation 3:9 - Behold, I will make them of the synagogue of Satan, which say they are Jews, and are not, but do LIE!!! Revelation 2:9 - I know thy works, and tribulation, and poverty, (but thou art rich) and I know the blasphemy of them which say they are Jews!!! God's chosen people, by who? Satan?
Tom this is awesome.. thanks for doing this.. I will share with many Wasn't expecting a post like this from you but it's absolutely brilliant and I'm pleasantly surprised. I will take one of your tours for sure. Thanks again
This was outstanding, comprehensive, humane, with well articulated historical, and contemporary Contexts just brilliantly done! All parties involved need to hear this!
This was outstanding, comprehensive, humane, with well articulated historical, and contemporary Contexts just brilliantly done! All parties involved need to hear this!
@@annaan8232 too bad people have such little understanding of history and are fooled by these so called professors who speak calmly and seem to be knowledgeable to the unsuspecting individuals
@@madcatter1 You are incorrect. Everything he's saying agrees with what Israeli historians have discovered after the declassification of Israeli and British documents from the mid-40s. See books by Ilan Pappe, Avi Shlaim, and Simha Flappan. (Pappe and Shalim also have RUclips vids.)
@@danaplaczek9664 No, its actually not true. Why cant we find any history on such a nation? Their leaders, kings, rulers, currency, flag, Day of Independence? Biblical sources, Archaeological artifacts etc. Makes you wonder doesnt it?
This video needs to go viral starting with everyone in this chat!❤ I had never come across your channel until today, but when I saw Professor Khalidii’s name in the title, I zoomed in, as I had just finished The Hundred Years War. I have just subscribed and will share this far and wide! Mad respect to both of you!!!
The heart-breaking betrayal of the Palestinian people is that Professor Khalidi, for all his fluency and eloquence, does little more than perpetuate the false promise that the clock can be turned back to pe-1948. I suggest you watch ruclips.net/video/w1Tsl9mEwhE/видео.html for an Israeli centrist's view of the conflict.
All respect Tom from Egypt, you have done a great efforts to prepare and read about the conflict, thank you for such a great interview and I am one of your followers and admirers from now and on. Thank you again
I am Jewish but I feel great pain for both Palestinians and Israelis. I read Prof. Khalidi's book based on a recommendation from an orthodox rabbi (who was born in Israel and now lives in the U.S.)! I had some issues with the book when I read it (e.g. no mention of all the Jews who were "expelled" from Egypt and Arab countries - about 900,000 I am told, including my ex-wife's family), so I very much appreciate this interview. I think the professor provides excellent history lessons and I appreciate that he acknowledges the pains that Jews have suffered for over 2,000 years. I would love to hear what his ideas are for a peaceful "solution" to this horrible mess. I believe it is a blight on the failure of governments - especially Britain and the U.S.) and the U.N. to have allowed this situation to exist and fester. Yes, "two peoples" with two states (or one if they prefer) but who have equal rights. It is so sad that about 12+ million people, many of them intelligent, family-oriented, loving people, cannot live either side-by-side, or together, and "make their world (and ours ) a better place for all. Too many lives are being wasted when they should be creating and innovating and helping their families, their economies and their "peoples".
Dear. I haven't read his book as yet.. but know already "a little" history of the region.. I recommend you to read about the LAVON AFFAIR of 1954.. I not saying the Jews didn't face harassment at the hands of Egyptians nationalists. But that was after the NAKBA where people started hating Jews in other regions ( if course they were responsible for it ) n plus the Israel state wanted Jews to believe that only the Zionist state n provide security to them.. the LAVON AFFAIR is just one example of it.. Thanks
Such an important interview - to understand the history / background of the war in / on Palestine, and to hear about Dr. Khalidi's own experience. We need more such conversations, and more voices to be heard / featured. So much suffering has been imposed on innocent Palestinian people - and between 30 000 and 40 000 killed since Oct 7, on top of the years of occupation. How can this be justified???!
hes wrong in his history, its obviously a biased view and not factual. How can they be considered occupied when there is no history of such a people, no declaration of Independence, flags, currency, archaeological facts or anything else to back any of these claims?
I'm Italian and until October, I knew nothing about what was really going on, between Palestine and Israel . The Israeli propaganda in Italy is unbelievable. They never taught us about Palestine in school ,about zionism, the partition ,the Nakba. I since have been educating myself ,and I've read 4 essays, and personal experiences of people who were tortured in Israeli prisons, at the end of the seventies. I now have a clear picture of reality,military occupation ,apartheid ,settler colonialism etc .Thank you very much for this informative interview ,I stopped watching mainstream news.
The heart-breaking betrayal of the Palestinian people is that Professor Khalidi, for all his fluency and eloquence, does little more than perpetuate the false promise that the clock can be turned back to pe-1948. I suggest you watch ruclips.net/video/w1Tsl9mEwhE/видео.html for an Israeli centrist's view of the conflict
In fact Palestine does not exist. Palestine is the name given by Roman Emperor Hadrian in the year 134 ad in remembrance of the Philistines who were Mycenaean Greek and Cretan Greek and was the old enemy of the Jews. Emperor Hadrian renamed it from Judea Israel to Palestina as an insult to the Jews after the destruction of the 2nd Jewish temple. Arabs didn’t arrive till 6th century!!!! Jews where there from at least 5,000 years before it is their ancient homeland.
🃏Same for USA--but people know the stats for every ballgame & we know the directions to disney world-from every state in this (dis)union & we know which doctor to call for Diabetes meds 🐑🐑🐑🏀🏈⚾️⛳🤠🧐😪
Thank you, Tom, for interviewing Dr. Khalidi. Your enthusiasm, Tom, towards the information in the book, as well as the mutual respect towards one another, was heartfelt. I am excited about reading the book, so, I, too, can intelligently, and calmly, discuss the issues that many people say is "too complicated" to understand. Perhaps that's just a dismissive excuse to avoid a pertinent conversation.
If the United Nation's continues to waffle on the creation of Palestine, it too deserves Accountability. The UN created Israel. It gave half or more of the Palestinians' territory to Israel. The UN had no right to do this. Ever since the war in Palestine Has been a civil war. The Palestinians are not terrorists. The Palestinians are the legitimate RESISTANCE. ZIONISTS ARE THE INVADERS. THEY ARE COLONISTS. THEY HAVE NO RIGHT TO BE IN PALESTINE.
Appreciate you expanding your channel to have experts and friends in these recent discussions on history and social issues. I am really engaged by your eye for niche content and expanding outside of the NYC tours. Would love to see some walking tours with guests involved. Keep up the great work!
Free Palestine from Hamas, free Palestine from the hatred they have for Jews. Israel will exist and will continue to exist until Islam will obliterate it, just as it obliterated others before it" (The Martyr, Imam Hassan al-Banna, of blessed memory).
@@tdevrywith any luck Israel will cease to exist! Literally a settler colonial project, or did you not watch the video and are choosing to stick with your biases?
Very Educational! I am glad I watched and LISTENED and now I see many sides of this conflict/war. I hope for Peace and a resolution for all people. I wished ALL learn to live together PEACEFULLY. Signed a WASP
So looking forward to watching this very soon, Tom! Just saw it posted & want to wait to watch when I could give it my undivided attention. I got as far as “sorry I’m talking so fast, I drank a lot of coffee.” 😅 I can relate! Hehe
Wow! This is an amazing interview, better than I believe even Christine Amanpour would do. Kudos to you for your interview skills and insightful questions. Wow!
Tom, thank you for this interview, I’ve gone through so many yet always feel like there is a gap and have to contextualise the pieces together myself. This puts it all in one succinct interview. I just hit subscribe!
Dr. Khalidi, you have a moral responsibility as a Palestine scholar to be more present on social media as an academic. Please continue the education of the public especially the american public. Thank you.
@@seekthetruthandthetruthwil2388 settlements over 2000 years ago, that were destroyed by the way, does not give you any right 2000 years later. The only ones are the natives of any religion. I am free , no worried.
Thanks. Wasnt expecting this from you, Tom. Made me smile. “You cannot continue to victimize someone else just because you yourself were a victim once-there has to be a limit” ― Edward Said
Greetings from Spain! I enjoyed so much this conversation with the professor of Columbia University. My knowledge on this conflict was broadened! Thanks for this opportunity.
@@rolandthethompsongunner64 You did miss something. Prof Khalidi described why the Palestinians are resisting Israeli, and it's not because they're Jews. He uses the hypothetical of Nationalist Danes invading Palestinian lands instead of the Zionists. The Palestinians wouldn't resist based on religion (roughly 20% of Palestinians are Christians), but because resistance to land theft is a natural response to others stealing your land. And your implication that "Muslims" groom their children is rather Islamophobic, and wrong historically. Again, Palestinians are resisting their Occupation, just as the Irish resisted the British occupation. Religion is incidental (though making a good dividing line for lazy thinkers.)
I just read his book and I'm so happy you interviewed him. It helped me re-summarize the book very well and burn it into my memory, as well as he gives great new insights on his writing in this video. Thank you!
Just started listening to Professor Rashidi's book a little while ago and came across this video. Thanks for sharing it Tom, it's very beneficial and I'll be sharing it
I’m a Hispanic with Jewish lenient on my father side. I know nothing of this conflict, but I was interested to learn more about it so I asked an Israeli. I told him that I know it’s a complicated situation and he replied “ no it’s not complicated at all. It’s very simple , Israelis expect Palestinians to get up and leave Palestinian Territories so the Israelis occupy them and Palestinians fight back and that’s why you have the conflict.”
The mainstream media is full of propaganda that is controlled by corporate interests… and corporate interests also control government, because the US is an oligarchy, not a democracy!
I'm a new subscriber here Tom & for good reason, as your videos are fantastic! I love the way that Professor Khalidi clearly & concisely explains what actually transpired between the Palestinian and the Jewish peoples. We will definitely purchase a copy of his book very soon. Thank you for creating & posting this video. Cheers & peace to all viewers here.✌
“I want my legs back,” the girl cried in Arabic. “I want my legs back.” You can’t have your legs back, little girl. They have been eaten by a hungry machine who needs them for fuel to power its gears. The machine needs your legs to keep the sky raining bombs and to make its death robots fly. Your legs power the bulldozers digging mass graves and the tanks blowing holes in the hospitals. A glorious kingdom is held together by the amputated limbs of children. A pentagon-shaped castle is built from the bones of the amputated limbs of children. Wall Street werewolves and bank boys dine on the amputated limbs of children. Movie stars treat their wrinkles with creams made from the amputated limbs of children. Suburban families prop up their smiles with the amputated limbs of children. The news man lies and in his eyes you see the amputated limbs of children. The podium man smirks and between his teeth are the amputated limbs of children. And the little girl cries, and the news man ignores her, and the podium man smirks at her, and the bank boy bites her, and the machine rolls on, limbs fed into its furnace with pitchforks, crushing houses and blackening the sky, poisoning the oceans and bloodying the earth, while the air fills with the crying of children, for limbs that will never come back, for homes that will never come back, for mothers that will never come back, for childhoods that will never come back, for brightness that will never come back, for innocence that will never come back, for dreams that will never come back, for joy that will never come back. And we are here, eating cheesy meatcarbs and watching funny haw-haws and gossiping and prattling and wishing we looked better and trying not to think about all the tiny arms and legs we see covering the earth whenever we step outside. twitter.com/afshinrattansi/status/1768566917055295873 www.caitlinjohnst.one/p/the-amputated-limbs-of-children
It is very rare to hear a Palestinian speaking without hatred about the conflict. We need to dispassionate the debate to see things right. To start to trust each other. Lack of trust is at the root of the problem. A one state solution could be possible giving equal rights for both people if we feel that the will to leave is stronger than the will to die for political or nationalist reasons. These two people have a common ancestor and they could show that their union could make them stronger and better
The heart-breaking betrayal of the Palestinian people is that Professor Khalidi, for all his fluency and eloquence, does little more than perpetuate the false promise that the clock can be turned back to pe-1948. I suggest you watch ruclips.net/video/w1Tsl9mEwhE/видео.html for an Israeli centrist's view of the conflict
Thanx for bringing on Prof Khalidi 👏definitely one of my heroes 🦸 Also love Ilan Pappé + Avi Schlaim (tho they're not in the city) maybe next get some of the local resistance leaders + orgs, ie, JVP + Students for Justice in Palestine ✊
The former Prime Minister of Israel Barak had a habit of saying things that are actually true sometimes: There was no party of God before Israel invaded Lebanon in 1982 because Israel created the party of God since it was a result of Israel’s occupation of Lebanon.
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
Really glad you used your platform to spread truth and information. You have my upmost respect!
My gosh, how this beautiful man has stuffed the most important facts and understandings into one podcast for us is phenomenal. Thanks to all of you! Terrific helpful podcast!
That’s because he has left out lots of facts that could tell a different narrative.
I have studied this subject for over twenty years and can say honestly that everything the professor says is true.
He is the protege of Edward said
@@den264 Truth by omission you mean. He left out key facts that vilifies Isreal. For instance, Israel did not "invade" Lebanon for no reason. It began with an attempted assassination of the Israeli ambassador in London, Israel attacked PLO targets in Lebanon on June 4, 1982. The PLO responded with rocket and artillery barrages, and Israel retaliated by sending ground troops into Lebanon, in a mission titled “Operation Peace for the Galilee.”
There's always "cause and effect", lots of "effects" being mentioned here with the "cause" intentionally left out. Only idiots never ask "why".
@@bri_____1970And he is telling of weaponed power of Israelis, but do not mention the fact that in1948 the biggest and most powerful Arab states started big war against new established state, it was not Arabs of Palestine who fought, it was Transjordan, Syria, Iraq, Lebanon, Egypt. Saudi Arabia, Yemen. United Arab whose forces was double of Israelis. USA didn't supplied Israel with weapon, it was bought from Czech Republic, remnants of old weapons after the war between the USSR and Germany, and everything that could be bought from private sellers of weapons. Israelis was poorly weapons, in the minority, but it was the question of existence, and they won. From Khalidi I did not hear anything near the truth. The result was Israelis gaining of some territories in accordance of international war right as far as the Arabs started it and lost. The other parts of Palestine was taken av Egypt and Jordan, and it was no longer the will of Arabs of Palestine to establish of own start. So it was until in 1968 Arab countries decided to get rid of this tiny problem - Israel. And lost again.
I doubt that he does know nothing of it. He just does not give the all facts.
Why?
The same with other episodes: not whole truth.
I am so sorry, because he is not the worst of those who present the story of questions of this region.
I expected more honesty, really, from a decent man.
Wonderful interview! Thank you, Tom and Prof. Khalidi.
Read his book, The Hundred Years War on Palestine. No longer can I say the issue is complicated. I’ve been eager to learn more about the war on Palestine and am learning about even more issues going on in the US. Not only am I more curious about how I’m able to live the life I lead but am more cautious about information I consume and what I participate in. Thanks again for a great video Tom.
Issue is certainly not complicated. Whether from Biblical or Islamic point of view, Palestine or more appropriately Holy Land is given to only one group of people. That is Israel and Jews.
Anyone else, come directly against God Almighty and His promises to His people Israel.
@@truthprevails5173😂 those are just white western people excuse to colonize land in Asia, Africa and America.
@@truthprevails5173 gods people are not an ethnicity. It was never about that. Gods people are those whose allegiance and believing loyalty are to him.
@@gabrielt721 Yahweh the creator of universe chose Abraham and his descendants for a specific purpose: bless all the families of the planet Earth. That is His decision!
@@truthprevails5173 I am sure God Almighty would approve how Zionists are starving and murdering children. Revelation 3:9 - Behold, I will make them of the synagogue of Satan, which say they are Jews, and are not, but do LIE!!! Revelation 2:9 - I know thy works, and tribulation, and poverty, (but thou art rich) and I know the blasphemy of them which say they are Jews!!! God's chosen people, by who? Satan?
This was really great. Really appreciate you doing this, and orofessor Khalidi for being so generous with time.
Very elucidating. Thank you for this interview with Professor Khalidi.
Professor Khalidi sprinkles truth in his lies. His tenure will finish.
Tom this is awesome.. thanks for doing this.. I will share with many
Wasn't expecting a post like this from you but it's absolutely brilliant and I'm pleasantly surprised.
I will take one of your tours for sure.
Thanks again
This was outstanding, comprehensive, humane, with well articulated historical, and contemporary Contexts just brilliantly done! All parties involved need to hear this!
This was outstanding, comprehensive, humane, with well articulated historical, and contemporary Contexts just brilliantly done! All parties involved need to hear this!
I enjoyed this interview with Prof Khalidi. Thanks Tom
thats because you dont have knowledge on the matter. He gave very misconstrued information
@@madcatter1 One sided.
@@annaan8232 too bad people have such little understanding of history and are fooled by these so called professors who speak calmly and seem to be knowledgeable to the unsuspecting individuals
@@madcatter1 You are incorrect. Everything he's saying agrees with what Israeli historians have discovered after the declassification of Israeli and British documents from the mid-40s. See books by Ilan Pappe, Avi Shlaim, and Simha Flappan. (Pappe and Shalim also have RUclips vids.)
@@danaplaczek9664 No, its actually not true. Why cant we find any history on such a nation? Their leaders, kings, rulers, currency, flag, Day of Independence? Biblical sources, Archaeological artifacts etc. Makes you wonder doesnt it?
This video needs to go viral starting with everyone in this chat!❤
I had never come across your channel until today, but when I saw Professor Khalidii’s name in the title, I zoomed in, as I had just finished The Hundred Years War. I have just subscribed and will share this far and wide! Mad respect to both of you!!!
Yet Allah never mentions Palestine even once. Still calls the land Israel
Great video, Tom! Incredibly informative. I would love to see more videos like this from you in the future
Great interview, Tom. Thank you for acknowledging and having the guts to address the this oppressing situation.
Excellent discussion! Best summary of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict I’ve encountered.
Avi Shlaim, Miko Peled, and Ilan Pappé also give excellent interviews on the history of
❤ good to get the story summarized by one who really knows. This was the best khalidi interview -for my needs - that I have heard.
Lol, very one sided partisan narrative of history.
The truth doesn't take sides.
The heart-breaking betrayal of the Palestinian people is that Professor Khalidi, for all his fluency and eloquence, does little more than perpetuate the false promise that the clock can be turned back to pe-1948.
I suggest you watch ruclips.net/video/w1Tsl9mEwhE/видео.html for an Israeli centrist's view of the conflict.
Congrats Tom, you're raising the bar with each video. It seems like the law degree is coming in handy after all 😊 Keep up the great work 👏👏👏
Excellent guest and interview - thanks so much for posting this Tom
as a social scientist, congratulations for posting this video, Tom! cheers from Brazil
All respect Tom from Egypt, you have done a great efforts to prepare and read about the conflict, thank you for such a great interview and I am one of your followers and admirers from now and on. Thank you again
I've watched a lot of your work in the past but today I have a whole new respect for you and your channel
This is BS please try to look at other sources
This was a fantastic interview. Highly recommend the full interview. Its so eye opening
I am Jewish but I feel great pain for both Palestinians and Israelis. I read Prof. Khalidi's book based on a recommendation from an orthodox rabbi (who was born in Israel and now lives in the U.S.)! I had some issues with the book when I read it (e.g. no mention of all the Jews who were "expelled" from Egypt and Arab countries - about 900,000 I am told, including my ex-wife's family), so I very much appreciate this interview. I think the professor provides excellent history lessons and I appreciate that he acknowledges the pains that Jews have suffered for over 2,000 years. I would love to hear what his ideas are for a peaceful "solution" to this horrible mess. I believe it is a blight on the failure of governments - especially Britain and the U.S.) and the U.N. to have allowed this situation to exist and fester. Yes, "two peoples" with two states (or one if they prefer) but who have equal rights. It is so sad that about 12+ million people, many of them intelligent, family-oriented, loving people, cannot live either side-by-side, or together, and "make their world (and ours ) a better place for all. Too many lives are being wasted when they should be creating and innovating and helping their families, their economies and their "peoples".
Dear. I haven't read his book as yet.. but know already "a little" history of the region.. I recommend you to read about the LAVON AFFAIR of 1954.. I not saying the Jews didn't face harassment at the hands of Egyptians nationalists. But that was after the NAKBA where people started hating Jews in other regions ( if course they were responsible for it ) n plus the Israel state wanted Jews to believe that only the Zionist state n provide security to them.. the LAVON AFFAIR is just one example of it..
Thanks
@@Buddha-007-l7jthere were similar events in Baghdad to ‘persuade’ the Iraqi Jews to leave. Avi Shlaim writes and talks about them extensively.
Very informative video, thank you to both.
Great job Tom! Massive respect for you. Needed a video on this topic
Thank you so much for posting this.
Such an important interview - to understand the history / background of the war in / on Palestine, and to hear about Dr. Khalidi's own experience. We need more such conversations, and more voices to be heard / featured.
So much suffering has been imposed on innocent Palestinian people - and between 30 000 and 40 000 killed since Oct 7, on top of the years of occupation. How can this be justified???!
Urban warfare is a horrible thing
Please try to find examples of urban warfare being “humane” or better targeting fighters vs civilians.
doesn’t exist
hes wrong in his history, its obviously a biased view and not factual. How can they be considered occupied when there is no history of such a people, no declaration of Independence, flags, currency, archaeological facts or anything else to back any of these claims?
@@madcatter1
You are joking right
@@ElvisBosnjakovic-dc3hy why am i joking? Is it because you know there are no answers?
If you look you'll find. PLENTY! But you prefer to be blind when it comes to Palestine and Palestinians. @@madcatter1
This was amazing, please do interviews like this more often
Ok, I really never thought I'd get this crossover.
I have just read Doctor Rashid Khalidi's book 'The Hundred Years' War on Palestine,' part autobiography, part, history,
it is beautifully written.
I'm Italian and until October, I knew nothing about what was
really going on, between Palestine and Israel .
The Israeli propaganda in Italy is unbelievable. They never taught us about Palestine in school ,about zionism, the partition ,the Nakba.
I since have been educating myself ,and I've read 4 essays, and personal experiences of people who were tortured in Israeli prisons, at the end of the seventies.
I now have a clear picture of reality,military occupation ,apartheid ,settler colonialism etc .Thank you very much for this informative interview ,I stopped watching mainstream news.
I am italian too and now I realize that have been completely manipulated for years.
you still know nothing if you listen to this BS .
The heart-breaking betrayal of the Palestinian people is that Professor Khalidi, for all his fluency and eloquence, does little more than perpetuate the false promise that the clock can be turned back to pe-1948.
I suggest you watch ruclips.net/video/w1Tsl9mEwhE/видео.html for an Israeli centrist's view of the conflict
In fact Palestine does not exist. Palestine is the name given by Roman Emperor Hadrian in the year 134 ad in remembrance of the Philistines who were Mycenaean Greek and Cretan Greek and was the old enemy of the Jews. Emperor Hadrian renamed it from Judea Israel to Palestina as an insult to the Jews after the destruction of the 2nd Jewish temple. Arabs didn’t arrive till 6th century!!!! Jews where there from at least 5,000 years before it is their ancient homeland.
🃏Same for USA--but people know the stats for every ballgame & we know the directions to disney world-from every state in this (dis)union & we know which doctor to call for Diabetes meds 🐑🐑🐑🏀🏈⚾️⛳🤠🧐😪
Thank you, Tom, for interviewing Dr. Khalidi. Your enthusiasm, Tom, towards the information in the book, as well as the mutual respect towards one another, was heartfelt. I am excited about reading the book, so, I, too, can intelligently, and calmly, discuss the issues that many people say is "too complicated" to understand. Perhaps that's just a dismissive excuse to avoid a pertinent conversation.
Came for the neighborhood tours. Staying for the enlightenment on current events. You are becoming something more, Tom. Congrats
If the United Nation's continues to waffle on the creation of Palestine, it too deserves Accountability.
The UN created Israel.
It gave half or more of the Palestinians' territory to Israel.
The UN had no right to do this.
Ever since the war in Palestine
Has been a civil war.
The Palestinians are not terrorists.
The Palestinians are the legitimate
RESISTANCE.
ZIONISTS ARE THE INVADERS.
THEY ARE COLONISTS.
THEY HAVE NO RIGHT TO BE IN PALESTINE.
I'm so happy tom talked about this! God bless you Tom
THANK YOU, for a very informative interview. PLEASE SHARE THIS FAR & WIDE, thank you.
Appreciate you expanding your channel to have experts and friends in these recent discussions on history and social issues. I am really engaged by your eye for niche content and expanding outside of the NYC tours. Would love to see some walking tours with guests involved. Keep up the great work!
Hey Tom! Wow! So fabulous interview and a great professor as well !!!
I am happy you talked about Palestine in your platform and helped to raise awareness. #free Palestine
Free Palestine from Hamas, free Palestine from the hatred they have for Jews. Israel will exist and will continue to exist until Islam will obliterate it, just as it obliterated others before it" (The Martyr, Imam Hassan al-Banna, of blessed memory).
@JB-kf8sf You are serious? Obviously, you have never studied Islam.
@@tdevry how would you know that 😂. So weird.
@@tdevrywith any luck Israel will cease to exist! Literally a settler colonial project, or did you not watch the video and are choosing to stick with your biases?
@@tdevry did you even watch the video?
Extraordinary interview. Thank you.
Very Educational! I am glad I watched and LISTENED and now I see many sides of this conflict/war. I hope for Peace and a resolution for all people. I wished ALL learn to live together PEACEFULLY. Signed a WASP
very very very educational. thanks to you and Rashid.
Best wishes
this was a beautiful and very impactful video. thank you for your awareness and passion to spread information❤
Reading his book right now. What a great interview
So looking forward to watching this very soon, Tom! Just saw it posted & want to wait to watch when I could give it my undivided attention. I got as far as “sorry I’m talking so fast, I drank a lot of coffee.” 😅 I can relate! Hehe
Wow! This is an amazing interview, better than I believe even Christine Amanpour would do. Kudos to you for your interview skills and insightful questions. Wow!
Tom, thank you for this interview, I’ve gone through so many yet always feel like there is a gap and have to contextualise the pieces together myself. This puts it all in one succinct interview. I just hit subscribe!
Miko Peled's "The General's Son", is worth a read.
also ilan pappe book , the ethic cleansing of Palestine
@@taherabunama4559noam chomsky is a living encyclopedia
It's a Propaganda book
And you are a propaganda troll
Have you read the Bible the greatest book on earth... It will help you get life eternal!
thank to inviting the professor,
as a Palestinian in Gaza his family refugeed from masmyea village 1948
Dr. Khalidi, you have a moral responsibility as a Palestine scholar to be more present on social media as an academic. Please continue the education of the public especially the american public. Thank you.
Yet Allah never mentions Palestine even once. Still calls the land Israel
@@seekthetruthandthetruthwil2388
Allah is an Arabic word. In English Allah means God.
@@seekthetruthandthetruthwil2388Israel was a person , not a land
@@Bewareinjustice 5:21 and 17:104 is the land too
@@seekthetruthandthetruthwil2388 settlements over 2000 years ago, that were destroyed by the way, does not give you any right 2000 years later. The only ones are the natives of any religion. I am free , no worried.
Way to go Tom! So refreshing to see you shed light on this situation! The narrative has been one-sided for far too long.
Propoganda.
Rashid Khalidi is an encyclopedia of interesting history and facts
Yet Allah never mentions Palestine even once. Still calls the land Israel
@@seekthetruthandthetruthwil2388aren’t you bored of yourself yet? I am
@@halifaxeh you bored because you have no answer
@@seekthetruthandthetruthwil2388 nope, I’m bored by your repetitive nonsense
Thanks. Wasnt expecting this from you, Tom. Made me smile.
“You cannot continue to victimize someone else just because you yourself were a victim once-there has to be a limit”
― Edward Said
Yet Allah never mentions Palestine even once. Still calls the land Israel
I went to Columbia ❤…freshman dorm to the left, sophomore to the right and senior behind the middle building 😊
you want a prize for that?
@@jimbean7652 my prize was my degree
@@ksmith1728 you went to columbia and that was the answer you came up with? and dont type you did not come up with it because it's the truth.
@@jimbean7652 you didn’t attend Columbia so I don’t think you would understand my reply or my original post.
@@ksmith1728 How would you know?? don't assume that will only make you a jack***
Greetings from Spain! I enjoyed so much this conversation with the professor of Columbia University.
My knowledge on this conflict was broadened!
Thanks for this opportunity.
Thank you both!
This was such a beautiful conversation.
Ireland here. This is what education should be like.
💚🇮🇪💚🇵🇸💚🇿🇦💚
We know from several CENTURIES of occupation, dispossession and repression my sept’s lands in Gleannfeisc
The Irish aren’t Muslims. Ridiculous comparison. The Irish don’t groom their children to become martyrs. Unless I missed something?
@@rolandthethompsongunner64 You did miss something. Prof Khalidi described why the Palestinians are resisting Israeli, and it's not because they're Jews. He uses the hypothetical of Nationalist Danes invading Palestinian lands instead of the Zionists. The Palestinians wouldn't resist based on religion (roughly 20% of Palestinians are Christians), but because resistance to land theft is a natural response to others stealing your land.
And your implication that "Muslims" groom their children is rather Islamophobic, and wrong historically. Again, Palestinians are resisting their Occupation, just as the Irish resisted the British occupation. Religion is incidental (though making a good dividing line for lazy thinkers.)
Excellent Interview 😊WatchShare😊😊😊😊
very educational. thank you both.
This was so informative and helpful - thank you
I've read two of his books. He's clear and insightful.
I just read his book and I'm so happy you interviewed him. It helped me re-summarize the book very well and burn it into my memory, as well as he gives great new insights on his writing in this video. Thank you!
The most comprehensive analysis of the Palestinian issue, factual, historical and intelligent!
I'm so glad I listened to this interview. I learned a lot. Next step will be reading the professors' book. Thank you!
Fabulous interview. Amazing professor. Brilliant individual.
Just started listening to Professor Rashidi's book a little while ago and came across this video. Thanks for sharing it Tom, it's very beneficial and I'll be sharing it
Thank you Tom ❤
Thank you! So grateful. It's these podcasts that help open the path to essential immediate change.
I’m a Hispanic with Jewish lenient on my father side. I know nothing of this conflict, but I was interested to learn more about it so I asked an Israeli. I told him that I know it’s a complicated situation and he replied “ no it’s not complicated at all. It’s very simple , Israelis expect Palestinians to get up and leave Palestinian Territories so the Israelis occupy them and Palestinians fight back and that’s why you have the conflict.”
Thank you for shedding light on this.
Thanks Tom for this ❤
What an amazingly detailed, nuanced and necessary discussion. Thank you very much for this. Free Free Palestine! 🇵🇸
This is very educational Tom
Illan Pappe's books are also very good!
Ilan’s The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine is a must read.
Benny Morris is three foremost authority on the subject.
Not these other grifters and political activists.
@@farzana6676😂😂😂😂 Benny Morris’ early work - when he told the truth about what he read in the archives. No longer. Now he’s a right wing fascist.
Miko Peled’s The General’s Son is also excellent!
@@farzana6676 These Finkelstein fan boys do not understand how their 'historians' are wilfully ignorant.
Wow really informative! Will share!
One of the most balanced and comprehensive interviews on this topic to date. thank you
This is not balanced
@@77kromah in what way is it not balanced?
It is unbelievable how little of the truth is known. I now believe that most news we consume is generated by PR concerns.
You won’t get this perspective in the mainstream media!
Yet Allah never mentions Palestine even once. Still calls the land Israel
The mainstream media is full of propaganda that is controlled by corporate interests… and corporate interests also control government, because the US is an oligarchy, not a democracy!
Other excellent channels for truth: the Intercept, The Real News Network (especially with Chris Hedges), electric intifada, Katie Halper, Zeteo.
@@seekthetruthandthetruthwil2388Neither did God mention the Ottoman or British Empire.
Amazing video Tom, following you since 2000 before my trip to NYC. Eye opening and educational. ❤️🍉
Great coverage Tom 👏👏
Thank you for this- I will direct people to listen to this much needed information
Excellent interview….thank you
Currently reading his book, so helpful to understand what is going on right now. I've recommended it to everyone I know
That was an exceptional analysis. Thanks.
Prof. Khalidi is a giant. Great interview, thank you!
Information and Truth ,One has to face before the rebuild of trust and Share
Thank for this interview, I’m reading Khalidi’s book right now. Would be great if you could do another one with Benny Morris!
Great video, Tom! Congratulation!
may Absolute Unbiased. Honest and Objective TRUTH and JUSTICE prevail
Prime minister Olmet offered east Jerusalem as a Palestinian capital.
So much to learn. Thank you
Just got the book
Very good interview. Thank you. Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Free Palestine from the Arabs who would destroy it, you're right.
From Ireland
Great interview. Thanks
💚🇮🇪💚🇵🇸💚🇿🇦💚
I'm a new subscriber here Tom & for good reason, as your videos are fantastic!
I love the way that Professor Khalidi clearly & concisely explains what actually transpired between the Palestinian and the Jewish peoples.
We will definitely purchase a copy of his book very soon.
Thank you for creating & posting this video.
Cheers & peace to all viewers here.✌
“I want my legs back,” the girl cried in Arabic.
“I want my legs back.”
You can’t have your legs back, little girl.
They have been eaten by a hungry machine
who needs them for fuel to power its gears.
The machine needs your legs to keep the sky raining bombs
and to make its death robots fly.
Your legs power the bulldozers digging mass graves
and the tanks blowing holes in the hospitals.
A glorious kingdom is held together
by the amputated limbs of children.
A pentagon-shaped castle is built from the bones
of the amputated limbs of children.
Wall Street werewolves and bank boys dine
on the amputated limbs of children.
Movie stars treat their wrinkles with creams
made from the amputated limbs of children.
Suburban families prop up their smiles
with the amputated limbs of children.
The news man lies and in his eyes
you see the amputated limbs of children.
The podium man smirks and between his teeth
are the amputated limbs of children.
And the little girl cries,
and the news man ignores her,
and the podium man smirks at her,
and the bank boy bites her,
and the machine rolls on,
limbs fed into its furnace with pitchforks,
crushing houses and blackening the sky,
poisoning the oceans and bloodying the earth,
while the air fills with the crying of children,
for limbs that will never come back,
for homes that will never come back,
for mothers that will never come back,
for childhoods that will never come back,
for brightness that will never come back,
for innocence that will never come back,
for dreams that will never come back,
for joy that will never come back.
And we are here,
eating cheesy meatcarbs and watching funny haw-haws
and gossiping and prattling and wishing we looked better
and trying not to think about all the tiny arms and legs
we see covering the earth
whenever we step outside.
twitter.com/afshinrattansi/status/1768566917055295873
www.caitlinjohnst.one/p/the-amputated-limbs-of-children
It is very rare to hear a Palestinian speaking without hatred about the conflict. We need to dispassionate the debate to see things right. To start to trust each other. Lack of trust is at the root of the problem. A one state solution could be possible giving equal rights for both people if we feel that the will to leave is stronger than the will to die for political or nationalist reasons. These two people have a common ancestor and they could show that their union could make them stronger and better
The will to live…
The heart-breaking betrayal of the Palestinian people is that Professor Khalidi, for all his fluency and eloquence, does little more than perpetuate the false promise that the clock can be turned back to pe-1948.
I suggest you watch ruclips.net/video/w1Tsl9mEwhE/видео.html for an Israeli centrist's view of the conflict
Thanx for bringing on Prof Khalidi 👏definitely one of my heroes 🦸 Also love Ilan Pappé + Avi Schlaim (tho they're not in the city) maybe next get some of the local resistance leaders + orgs, ie, JVP + Students for Justice in Palestine ✊
Miko Peled and Diana Buttu are other great ones!
Ifnotnow and Noam Chomsky are good
Loved his book, the way he explains history is both so clear but with such academic rigor. Rashid Khalidi has become a referent for me!
Freedom for Palestine now Stop genocide now Long live Aaron Bushnell. Just read his book..its greatly appreciated...
Yes, wonderful and easy to follow, understand the historical conflict from, thank you!
Good stuff Tom. And Rashid. God bless the son ;) And Cameron the cameraman :)
First time ever on this channel, Tom seems like a really nice guy
The former Prime Minister of Israel Barak had a habit of saying things that are actually true sometimes:
There was no party of God before Israel invaded Lebanon in 1982 because Israel created the party of God since it was a result of Israel’s occupation of Lebanon.