Is This Fish Edible? Carp Catch and Cook

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 18 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 1,6 тыс.

  • @catfishchronicles3282
    @catfishchronicles3282 6 месяцев назад +499

    I just found this video. I’ve eaten carp all my life. My dad’s parents are from Czech. He taught me how they cooked it back in the old country. My favorite way is get about a 5-10 pounder. Fillet n cut out mud vein. Leave in big chunks. Roast w whole tomatoes cabbage garlic onion n some basic other Italian seasoning. Cook on low for several hours. Bones become like canned salmon soft n easily eaten. Meat tastes like mild beef. Great w mashed potatoes or homemade black bread.

    • @jayrowe6473
      @jayrowe6473 5 месяцев назад +7

      That sounds good!

    • @fredstriker2042
      @fredstriker2042 5 месяцев назад +8

      Sounds delicious, appreciate the recipe brother!

    • @sawssman965
      @sawssman965 5 месяцев назад +2

      never had car a day in my life, but that sounds really good actually.

    • @eddigsdiscoveries1332
      @eddigsdiscoveries1332 5 месяцев назад +5

      My dad was from Germany and they did the same. Always ate carp and they really enjoyed it.

    • @bdaddy503
      @bdaddy503 5 месяцев назад +1

      Sounds good. What temp do you set the oven and for how long?

  • @harrisonbosley6812
    @harrisonbosley6812 5 месяцев назад +283

    I knew a old guy years ago that would catch carp and he had a flowing well with a big steel tank to collect the water. He would put the carp in it and feed them canned corn for about a week, then clean and cook them. They tasted as mild as bluegill or perch, the corn cleaned the mud taste out of them.

    • @guyhmajor
      @guyhmajor 5 месяцев назад +21

      Good point!! In Asia where grass carp are very popular they flush them for a week before frying them up with chilli, ginger and garlic. Personally I don't like it and always go for sea fish.

    • @BigBoaby-sg1yo
      @BigBoaby-sg1yo 5 месяцев назад +5

      Best not to feed them ,as they purge themselves out .

    • @barrymayson2492
      @barrymayson2492 5 месяцев назад +5

      The flushing of the fish seems to be the thing seen a couple of times.

    • @ianbruce6515
      @ianbruce6515 5 месяцев назад +10

      Monasteries practiced aquaculture during the Medieval period and had ponds in which they raised eels, carp and pike. Their aquaculture techniques became quite sophisticated with river water channeled through the ponds to maintain water quality.

    • @asymptoticsingularity9281
      @asymptoticsingularity9281 4 месяца назад +3

      Flushing with clean water should be a good idea.

  • @billyfreeman5803
    @billyfreeman5803 3 года назад +238

    It 100% matters where you got the carp from. If they feed by filtering through silt and mud, they aren't going to taste very good. Carp that mostly feed easily in gravely, rocky areas taste much better.

    • @Cyxlion
      @Cyxlion 6 месяцев назад +12

      same for most fish, ive caught quite a few cods and perch in harbors but would never eat them due to the muddy water cuz of dredging and spilled gasolin and trash from the city and so on forth. Would absoulty devour a cod caught 300 meters outside of the harbour tho

    • @jsmythib
      @jsmythib 6 месяцев назад +5

      Smaller carp

    • @casinodelonge
      @casinodelonge 6 месяцев назад +12

      Even mediaeval monks would remove their carp (and tench) from their stew ponds and keep them in flowing water for a few days prior to harvesting them to get rid of that taste. .

    • @Mr.Helper.
      @Mr.Helper. 6 месяцев назад +2

      How did we get here … all of us from this week on a 3 year old video

    • @supertechz6883
      @supertechz6883 5 месяцев назад +1

      Exactly ..if it grows in fresh water it is going to give you good taste

  • @dmplayer79
    @dmplayer79 5 месяцев назад +88

    I'm Romanian, and carp is the most popular fish here. It is commonly found on the menu at most seafood restaurants, usually served fried with a garlic sauce and polenta. You can also find it in most Eastern European countries.

    • @davidrollins4272
      @davidrollins4272 4 месяца назад +3

      My friend and I tried carp filet it in the Czech Republic. It tasted fine, but each bite included bones

    • @ferenc-x7p
      @ferenc-x7p 4 месяца назад +2

      The American version of carp taste a whole lot different (worse), than the carp in Europe.

    • @Jfhejjdshxhs
      @Jfhejjdshxhs 3 месяца назад +2

      @@ferenc-x7pi doubt that since europe is known for lack of seasoning

    • @users4007
      @users4007 3 месяца назад +1

      common food in asia as well, I've had it while in china and it was pretty good, but the ones here in north america are a different species from the ones that are commonly eaten i think

    • @laytonrim1489
      @laytonrim1489 3 месяца назад +5

      ​@@Jfhejjdshxhsthere is no way you just said that without joking

  • @pinhookfishingclub
    @pinhookfishingclub 3 года назад +216

    Carp is eaten quite a bit in Europe during the holidays. Very traditional meal for many. Over in Wisconsin they make lots of smoked or dried Carp and even jerky. Great vid!

    • @rg3291
      @rg3291 3 года назад +6

      I too was thinking that smoking it may be a better way of preparing it

    • @upyoursassmonkey
      @upyoursassmonkey Год назад

      I'm pretty sure all fish taste better smoked.

    • @2wokold889
      @2wokold889 Год назад +4

      carp jerky?? do you have a recipe? i wanna try this next time i catch one

    • @ColtSievers1000
      @ColtSievers1000 6 месяцев назад +2

      Maybe cook it polish Christmas dinner style stuffed carp what's they stuff it with god only knows

    • @tropic2860
      @tropic2860 6 месяцев назад +1

      Where is Wisconsin

  • @horsthorstens3056
    @horsthorstens3056 2 месяца назад +17

    Carp was a traditional christmas dish in my family in germany in the 70s. I remember watching them in the bathtub were they had to stay for some time in fresh water, before being cooked.

  • @derekholife
    @derekholife 3 года назад +745

    I’ve grown up eating carp, it doesn’t taste bad at all, I honestly think it tastes better then trout. The only problem with carp is the amount of bones in it. Carp is an awesome fish for like soups and if you are able to fillet the fish then it’s super flaky and delicous

    • @georgen4010
      @georgen4010 3 года назад +11

      I agree

    • @uwijsmssmsms9925
      @uwijsmssmsms9925 3 года назад +158

      Not bad but better than trout is definitely a stretch lol

    • @derekholife
      @derekholife 3 года назад +105

      @@uwijsmssmsms9925 funny thing is, trout is a trash fish in many parts of Asia and Carp is more liked, really it’s what people are comfortable eating.

    • @king_no_cheat116
      @king_no_cheat116 3 года назад

      your nasty af

    • @jasonb.3874
      @jasonb.3874 3 года назад +6

      @@king_no_cheat116 *you're

  • @birkavese
    @birkavese Год назад +41

    In Hungary, that carp (especially the variant with very few scales) is THE fish, for traditional fish meals, most importantly fish soup. It's the only fish most supermarkets offer live from a tank (now they must kill it before selling) and most people cook soup from it during the holdiay season.

    • @zm_headhunter
      @zm_headhunter 7 дней назад +1

      Your comment and other eastern European comments and encouraging me to try it , as someone from northern Algeria we consume predominantly salt water fish and fresh water fish isn't even sold , carp is all around our fresh bodies of water and i saw a lot of guys catching big ones especially in reservoirs, so i might actually try it .

  • @shcomptech
    @shcomptech 3 года назад +89

    Carp were farmed for food by monks during the middle ages, and in some countries in Eastern Europe they eat carp for Christmas dinner. Top tip - You can make any unpaletable fish taste better if you smoke it.

    • @daddyosink4413
      @daddyosink4413 3 года назад +2

      My Mama loves fried catfish, I cant stand it..... but I will eat a mess of smoked catfish. Skin it, gut it, and throw it on a slow wet smoke and it is AMAZING.

    • @daddyosink4413
      @daddyosink4413 3 года назад +6

      High end restaurants sell "silver fin" which is nothing but the invasive Asian grass carp.

    • @cukman1643
      @cukman1643 2 года назад +2

      @@daddyosink4413 how can’t you stand fried catfish? It tastes fine.

    • @blaccsilverstaff5484
      @blaccsilverstaff5484 2 года назад +2

      Today I fried carp , threw it in soup didn't taste well so I threw it on the grill - delicious

    • @TNAROHfan
      @TNAROHfan 5 месяцев назад +1

      @@daddyosink4413 Catfish are a lot like carp in that they will taste like the body of water they lived in. Both can be bottom feeders or opportunistic feeders which is why neither are my favorite fish. Catfish being worse tasting IMO, the larger they get. Fiddlers or smaller channel cats below 5-6 pounds are great, when filleted, soaked in mustard or salt water brined, then fried. Just remove any of the brown flesh and don't eat any of the fat belly meat, because that is where the toxins are stored.

  • @brianrizzi6321
    @brianrizzi6321 4 месяца назад +46

    Best part of this video is how close this family is. All sat around and ate this sus fish

    • @cnam1258
      @cnam1258 4 месяца назад +1

      Yeah it's nice to see.

    • @MrLilwallace
      @MrLilwallace 3 месяца назад +4

      His younger sister, especially, was amazing, having such an open mind. Kinds that age are often so picky. His brother and his other sister were really cool, too.

  • @seanbailey8545
    @seanbailey8545 2 года назад +163

    Carp is one of those fish that taste like their habitat imo. If you fishing in a muddy lake, it's gonna taste like mud. If it's caught in a clean lake or stream it's gonna be a lovely fish.

    • @lowkeyconvert8971
      @lowkeyconvert8971 Год назад +8

      wouldn't that apply to all fish? for e.g. i'ver had barramundi that tastes a bit chemically and unpleasant but i think it's the soil-y/muddy water they swim in.

    • @Goofygooberston
      @Goofygooberston Год назад +23

      ​@@lowkeyconvert8971 Most bottom feeders & omnivores yes. Predatory fish less so but still a bit.

    • @mikecollins8241
      @mikecollins8241 6 месяцев назад +14

      Old German guy told me years ago to only eat carp from streams and rivers, those from lakes taste "muddy" he was right!

    • @sammylacks4937
      @sammylacks4937 4 месяца назад +1

      I bet if you marinate em
      well with Catalina dressing a couple of Wood Rats would be tasty on the grill.

    • @AdamsOlympia
      @AdamsOlympia 3 месяца назад +1

      you are what you eat.

  • @KeikoMushi
    @KeikoMushi 4 месяца назад +7

    Honesty in discussions over food reduce false expectations. It also gives people the tools for remedying issues.
    The chickens in the yard also made me smile.

  • @jamalpeoples3736
    @jamalpeoples3736 3 года назад +65

    Ate carp a ton when in Vietnam. Dish fish hold up well to a longer cook time. Especially coated and doubled fried like chicken. Some of the best dishes I have has was a guy who would just cook tons of this every money with the first fry. Come back with the 2nd fry when it was ordered. Then would use a wok to cover in the sauces he had. The best was a singapore crab chili sauce, a coconut curry, and one that tasted just like general tsos

  • @alexgrancharov5109
    @alexgrancharov5109 5 месяцев назад +5

    Carp is probably the most eaten fish here in Bulgaria and in pretty much the whole Balkans. I think it's very good, you can cook it however you want, fried, baked, even stuffed.

  • @rich_v
    @rich_v 3 года назад +65

    Never been a fan of eating carp but catching em is sooooo much fun! They put up such a good fight on lighter line. Biggest carp I've caught was 25 pounds on 12 pound mono line. That big momma took me 1 hour and 30 min to bring in.

    • @IdahoMan007
      @IdahoMan007 2 года назад +1

      Bullcrap

    • @michaelrodriguez2973
      @michaelrodriguez2973 2 года назад +17

      @@IdahoMan007 Bull Carp?

    • @GodGunsGills
      @GodGunsGills 8 месяцев назад

      Caught a 23lb carp on 12lb line

    • @MrHarryMonk
      @MrHarryMonk 6 месяцев назад +3

      Not bullcrap. My pb is 20lb on 12lb mono. My local lake has a rule of 10lb mono minimum line, and it stocks carp upto 35lb.

    • @TrancetasticWilza
      @TrancetasticWilza 5 месяцев назад +1

      ​@@MrHarryMonkthat's because they aren't dragged in and clubbed on the head. 👍

  • @donbolin3450
    @donbolin3450 5 месяцев назад +5

    The best part of this video is where your sister says she likes it. It's even better when she finishes the plate. You should definitely find some more fish for her. Make sure they're safe to eat. Great video!

  • @poseidon5177
    @poseidon5177 3 года назад +119

    My grandma tells me, that cooking carp is simple if you want it to taste good. They threw the meat in a pressure cooker, which separates the bones, and she compares it to the taste of salmon. So this is not a trashy fish in anyway by far.

    • @BuceGar
      @BuceGar 2 года назад +56

      After you cook the carp in the pressure cooker, do you throw out the carp then eat the pressure cooker?

    • @kathrynmcmorrow7170
      @kathrynmcmorrow7170 2 года назад +4

      Sounds like the start of a gefilte fish recipe.

    • @andrewsolano9172
      @andrewsolano9172 Год назад +1

      afterwards do you make patties out of them?

    • @graftedin3
      @graftedin3 5 месяцев назад

      @@kathrynmcmorrow7170 at Passover I use to call them gafilty fish.

    • @kathrynmcmorrow7170
      @kathrynmcmorrow7170 5 месяцев назад

      @@graftedin3 I think I recall that fish dumpling as gefilte fish but have never had it.

  • @keithlocke2205
    @keithlocke2205 Год назад +7

    Interesting and informative. I've eaten carp done as whole crispy fish Chinese style, and had it smoked (sable fish) from a deli. In the middle ages, Carp was a common species in farmed fish ponds.

  • @dustingardner1548
    @dustingardner1548 2 года назад +37

    If coming from a muddy river or lake, I like to let the carp sit in fresh clear in a bucket. Odds are anyways where I fish, it's going to still be alive and I can put it in my big trough at home and let it swim in the clear water. Clear water carp is amazing

    • @keithkarbel2000
      @keithkarbel2000 6 месяцев назад

      I heard of a German woman who put carp in the bathtub overnight to flush out the water

  • @harrybond1485
    @harrybond1485 2 месяца назад +3

    Last night we had deep fried walleye, morel mushrooms,fresh lettuce salad and tomatoes from the garden, along withhomemade bread and butter.For desert we had strawberry shortcake with homemade vanilla ice cream.Enjoy your carp.😊

  • @smarton9540
    @smarton9540 2 года назад +12

    Carp is held in high esteem in eastern Europe. As a Hungarian, I've been eating halászlé, aka Hungarian fish soup, especially as a Christmas dish, of which carp along with catfish is the main component.
    Look it up guys! Only a fraction of people live by the sea, eating local fish is the best you can do to practice sustainability.

  • @denniskelly6359
    @denniskelly6359 2 месяца назад +2

    I grew up eating Carp in Iowa from the Mississippi river. My Father would always bring home Smoked Carp that was smoked by the fish shop by the river. He would bring the Carp home in the butcher paper and we would always eat the smoked carp cold. I miss those days.

  • @snakeheaddefenders2417
    @snakeheaddefenders2417 3 года назад +73

    My girlfriend gave birth today and seeing brenden Miller post made my day even better

    • @Deacon...
      @Deacon... 3 года назад +26

      Shouldn't you be married before having a baby?

    • @snakeheaddefenders2417
      @snakeheaddefenders2417 3 года назад +9

      @@Deacon... nope

    • @Deacon...
      @Deacon... 3 года назад +10

      @@snakeheaddefenders2417 my dad's a pastor and I thought I remember him saying that

    • @ewanchalmin2862
      @ewanchalmin2862 3 года назад +8

      @@Deacon... why should he be married? Plenty of people have children before being married?

    • @fishingwithross8081
      @fishingwithross8081 3 года назад +2

      Congratulations

  • @stevenbrewer8788
    @stevenbrewer8788 4 месяца назад +2

    44 y/o and grew up eating carp regularly in Oklahoma. Usually pressure cooked them, and "caught" them with bowfishing. Always enjoyed the taste.

  • @b5maddog
    @b5maddog 3 года назад +24

    Really enjoyed this episode. It was a little different, with the cooking aspect as well as involving your awesome siblings. It would be nice to see more like this.

  • @angeladerby2513
    @angeladerby2513 4 месяца назад +1

    Love Carp! I grew up in Tarboro NC and fished from the Tar River. Caught my first carp near Shiloh Farm Rd where I use to live, right on the river. Caught it, cleaned and ate every last bite. I have No problems with carp at all. I cleaned it much different than you or probably anyone here, but I loved it. I don't take anyone's words for any type of fish or seafood. I try it out for myself. Thank you for sharing your ways of preparing and cooking carp. I enjoyed the video and I agree with your little sis about carp, Love It. Hope you and everyone here and your family has a Safe Blessed and Wonderful day. Will also share your video to let everyone know, at least give it a try.... Thank you again....😊

  • @smidgetsspincast7405
    @smidgetsspincast7405 3 года назад +103

    "I've had catfish that taste worse than that." That's a sin to say in my family buddy. 🤣

    • @fishing-with-jaydenyt874
      @fishing-with-jaydenyt874 3 года назад +10

      Catfish is good

    • @Jonathan-sv6ur
      @Jonathan-sv6ur 3 года назад +7

      ive only had 1 catfish that actually tasted bad, thats probably because i caught it in a spillway from a water treatment/waste management plant.

    • @carterredelings9186
      @carterredelings9186 3 года назад +2

      Catfish is one of.my favorite to catch and cook

    • @fishing-with-jaydenyt874
      @fishing-with-jaydenyt874 3 года назад +6

      @@Jonathan-sv6ur Yeah that's probably why.Lake catfish is great never caught one but have eaten one

    • @toystories235
      @toystories235 3 года назад +2

      Waste management plant?, did you get sick

  • @zacheiriksson
    @zacheiriksson 4 месяца назад +22

    Carp was originally brought over from Europe to be an abundant food source. Then we discovered walleye lol

    • @mihaiilie8808
      @mihaiilie8808 4 месяца назад +1

      In europe we have larger walleye than in USA and the carp is still considered a tasty fish, close to walleye and more expensive than farmed rainbow trout.
      The only carp thats cheaper than rainbow trout is the chinese silver carp, but thats a fish the americans would like more than euro carp because its less fat and doesnt have a strong taste.

    • @cg2566
      @cg2566 3 месяца назад

      Forgive me guys but I always thought that the Carp was an invasive species in the US. Mostly introduced as pets in various aquaria. I personally have never tried it but it looks like an awesome fish.

    • @nicks2581
      @nicks2581 3 месяца назад +2

      ​@@cg2566the common carp is naturalized at this point and thus plays a large part in the ecosystem, especially as a forage fish for predators.

    • @cg2566
      @cg2566 3 месяца назад

      @@nicks2581 Thank you.

  • @teklife
    @teklife Год назад +16

    Your little sister, she made me smile how she liked the carp. Hehehe, God bless her!

  • @kennethboydsr3966
    @kennethboydsr3966 Год назад +2

    I love your show I have family in Nebraska that catch carp and eat them all the time they love them it’s probably lots of was to cook. Great show !!!!

  • @mattbrown5511
    @mattbrown5511 2 года назад +13

    Blackened or Cajun seasoned with malted vinegar is the way I like my carp.

  • @PlatonicVoyeur
    @PlatonicVoyeur Год назад +8

    before you eat carp, make sure you check your state's fish consumption advisory website first. Carp have a tendency to hold onto certain nasty pollutants like PCB's more than other species of fish. PCB's are stored in the fattier areas, so you're at least limiting your exposure by trimming the reddish fatty parts off. Also super important to kill/bleed them quick as you pointed out since they can stay alive for hours out of water, which is a crap way to die AND makes the meat taste horrible.
    ALSO, the best way I've found to eat carp so far is pretty involved, but it's honestly one of the best preparations of fish I've tried. Can the fish in a pressure canner, then when you're ready to cook, open the can and dump into a bowl with egg and seasoning, mix it up and press into a patty. Fry it in a pan with butter and enjoy as a burger. The pressure canning process leaches the collagen from the bones, basically disintegrating them and making them edible. Seriously, it's the best. I've done it with common and grass carp, both were delicious.

  • @ethanbelton9522
    @ethanbelton9522 Год назад +13

    As someone who regularly eats carp from a stock tank the flavor you're tasting that's different is best compared to liver. The inner part of the filet that is reddish has much more of that flavor which is great if you're expecting a fatty liver flavor and could be better enjoyed as a paté, but it's definitely off-putting if you don't know what it is. The water absolutely effects the flavor of the meat and I've found that carp harvested from moving water tends to have a more familiar flavor. Because it's a very fatty fish, I've found it tastes better when that fat is diluted with other oils, e.g. fried in coconut, peanut, olive, and even rendered beef or pork fat. It also works very well as a substitute for pork in dumplings and egg rolls. However you make it, it's important to understand that carp is higher in mercury than a lot of fish and shouldn't be eaten as often. Compare it to tuna with regard to mercury.

    • @robertcherry7190
      @robertcherry7190 Год назад

      Great comment.

    • @woodstream6137
      @woodstream6137 2 месяца назад +2

      I remember growing up near a PCB contaminated, no contact river. No fishing or swimming. After 25 years, the state EPA lowered its danger rating with specific consumption levels. Many fish like carp were 1 meal per month. A few smaller fish were one meal per week.

    • @prehistorymystery
      @prehistorymystery 18 дней назад +1

      @@woodstream6137 still like that in midwest.

  • @thatcanuck5670
    @thatcanuck5670 4 месяца назад +1

    There's an old Iraqi carp dish called Semeç Masgûf, where a carp is butterflied and slow broiled over a low wood or charcoal fire, and it is repeatedly basted with a very flavorful tomato based sauce. The carp is dense and fatty, and holds up to the extended cook time extraordinarily well. It's kind of similar to barbecue, just with fish instead.

  • @thewesternoutdoorsman1055
    @thewesternoutdoorsman1055 3 года назад +12

    You should definitely make more catch and cooks, they are really interesting!

  • @MichaelEastman-e8v
    @MichaelEastman-e8v 5 месяцев назад

    In Germany they are used for Thanksgiving. My grand mother was German and we used carp from the Missouri River caught by commercial fishermen.
    Bleed it while its heart is still beating.

  • @CalisaLynn
    @CalisaLynn 3 года назад +65

    I’ve actually never caught a carp, and Isaiah has grown up.

    • @Chasinchrome
      @Chasinchrome 3 года назад +1

      Brooooo that’s crazy

    • @cukman1643
      @cukman1643 2 года назад

      Do you live in the United States and fish lakes and rivers? I have only targeted carp 1 time and I have caught a ton of carp.

    • @geodude6244
      @geodude6244 2 года назад +1

      Then you haven't really tried go at sunset and sink corn covered hook with a sinker. Caught a 26 pounder today going back tomorrow for more hopefully.

    • @kathrynmcmorrow7170
      @kathrynmcmorrow7170 2 года назад +3

      @@geodude6244 This is my first video seen of this channel. I wished he showed how he bled out his carp after killing it first. Does he ever show that step on another video?

    • @Saucygremlinsks
      @Saucygremlinsks 3 месяца назад

      Ball head jig hook, can of corn, chum the water, rig your hook with a few pieces of 🌽 and cast your hook out in the general vicinity of where you threw your corn and you will have a carp.. thank me later

  • @giganetom
    @giganetom 2 месяца назад +1

    I'm hungarian, and carp is (one of the things) what you buy for Christmas. It's... fine. :)

  • @jamescooper2618
    @jamescooper2618 3 года назад +7

    Wild caught fish can vary in taste widely depending on it's conidiations of course. Cooking techniques can change that.

  • @cobbleup
    @cobbleup 4 месяца назад +1

    I have relatives that used to can carp back in the day. The canning process softened the bones to where they were completely edible. They said the canned carp tasted similar to canned salmon or other canned fish.

    • @TSis76
      @TSis76 3 месяца назад

      Wow! Thank you.

  • @kylejlchen
    @kylejlchen 3 года назад +8

    Chef Miller in the house lol

  • @tigerclaw4537
    @tigerclaw4537 3 месяца назад

    In my youth I was a big Carp Fishermen. Loved catching and releasing these beastly fish. Cooked and ate a few of the larger ones and they tasted fine, but the terrible smell of cleaning them prior to cooking them is hard to forget.

  • @cedricborkholder712
    @cedricborkholder712 3 года назад +6

    “A Devine culinary experience”... 😂👌🏻

  • @MattRaynor-t4y
    @MattRaynor-t4y 2 месяца назад

    Had a nice old man on my paper route way back when. Instead of dropping off the paper I'd just walk it in to him. He had some smoked carp. Never in a million years would I thought I'd have carp. I enjoyed it. Always loved fishing for them and yes, the corn is the magic bait

  • @adrianstutzman
    @adrianstutzman 3 года назад +8

    Honestly, I've never even caught a carp before! I guess that tells you how much I fish. But the joke about the carp at the beginning I had heard about eating a possum. Great Video!

    • @charliesommers9599
      @charliesommers9599 2 года назад

      Possum is possibly the best tasting wild meat, those who avoid it because of its eating habits should also avoid free range chicken and crabs. 😃

    • @Goofygooberston
      @Goofygooberston Год назад

      Carp fishing is pretty much the be all end all of high end fishing here in Europe. Give it a shot. Just rig up a bottom rig and have some corn on hand.

    • @ironmatic1
      @ironmatic1 Год назад

      @@charliesommers9599What do you mean by wild, though? Like are you saying I can go .22 the ugly thing in my backyard that annoys my cat and eat it?!

  • @NoMoreBsPlease
    @NoMoreBsPlease 4 месяца назад +1

    Carp is eaten in the US. It's sometimes cooked in WV, but they ALWAYS tell you to cut the "mud line" out. It's just as he described and it's just cooked like any other fish after that.

  • @stevesmith8399
    @stevesmith8399 3 года назад +5

    Isaiah is really looking like Rob since he’s growing up.

  • @EchoSigma6
    @EchoSigma6 Год назад

    I searched the carp thing, stumbled on your video and enjoyed the segment with your family. You all seem like very nice folks. Carp is the everyday protein for those that can afford it. Season it with garlic, chili, oil, soy sauce, and vinegar and it’s okay. Serve over rice and a plate of veggies. Nothing really gourmet about it. Respects from Los Angeles.

  • @Bensteudle
    @Bensteudle 3 года назад +4

    Dude this is such a coincidence I just caught my first carp in a while

  • @astraldrag8562
    @astraldrag8562 3 дня назад

    A fun fact for carp fishing: some states here in the United States have made it illegal to chum the water. They consider it littering, even if it's just corn. A good loophole around this would be pack bait or dough bait. Once you add your bait to whatever device you choose for your hair rig, you just simply add your hook to the ball of bait. Technically, that would consider your bait added to your hook and is not legally considered chumming the water. It slowly releases bait for the fish to eat. Most of the time, it only takes about 30 to 40 minutes for the fish to eat all of the bait. Always check your states' Game & Wildlife or DNR to see if chumming is legal in your state.

  • @kennycook359
    @kennycook359 Год назад +3

    Carp is a very good fish to eat. Its according to where the fish comes from. Rivers and streams are the better choice for eating. When you go to bleed the carp pop the gills while the fish is alive to bleed it out for best results. After you fillet the fish put the fillets in a bowl and add a small amount of salt water and vinegar. Let soak for several hours. Blackened is very good, but also beer batter is great too. Love from the ole hillbilly Kenny, peace!

  • @ullo-ragnartelliskivi4639
    @ullo-ragnartelliskivi4639 4 месяца назад

    when i was fishing a lot i kept the carp in running water for a week and then smoked them. amazing! i recommend STRONGLY!

  • @russellesimonetta9071
    @russellesimonetta9071 6 месяцев назад +7

    Uhh, we ate carp all the time when I was a kid. The old timers put them into horse trough s with circulating fresh water for like two weeks and fed feed corn. After two weeks it was time for a community fish fry. It was good but boney.

  • @knoptop
    @knoptop 3 года назад +7

    The real question... how do you know what that body of water tastes like? 😅

  • @AndyJack00
    @AndyJack00 4 месяца назад +1

    Been eating carp all my life, it tasted amazing each time.

  • @sarahparkergrubenhoff4660
    @sarahparkergrubenhoff4660 3 года назад +5

    Please, rod and reel arsenal!!!

  • @mrcheese3981
    @mrcheese3981 3 месяца назад

    In Alsace they eat "Carpe frites", which is basically just fish and chips, but much nicer, because rather than British soggy chips they're French fries. The carp are kept in purging tanks for a few days so they don't taste muddy, then they're filleted, battered and deep fried. Served with a beautiful Alsace Muscat it's divine.

  • @WoodboogerFishing
    @WoodboogerFishing 3 года назад +4

    I was very curious about this one. Great video idea....still not eating carp. But great idea! Thanks for taking one for the team, sir.

  • @TheDemonGamerOfFleetStreet
    @TheDemonGamerOfFleetStreet 5 месяцев назад +1

    Interesting fact: when most of the western world is tucking into Chicken, Turkey, Goose and whatever else on Christmas day, the Polish eat carp. I've seen them do it on Christmas day they eat carp.

  • @mtac.JesusisKing
    @mtac.JesusisKing 3 года назад +10

    Carp are so delicious out of every freshwater fish I have eaten carp was the best even better than trout in my opinion 👍👍👍

    • @martingingerich8830
      @martingingerich8830 4 месяца назад +1

      That might be a stretch...Perch and Walleye are better.no?

    • @mtac.JesusisKing
      @mtac.JesusisKing 4 месяца назад +1

      @@martingingerich8830 depends, smaller the carp the more delicious and especially the cleanness of water will make a difference on how carp taste, but if the water is clean and the carp is 10 lb less and u keep it in ice fresh, it’s delicious, my favourite is baked carp, but perch and walleye are tastier but imo carp are more enjoyable, but definitely try a small carp if you haven’t but if you do make sure to keep it fresh and I recommend you baking it,

    • @ayaanbadal6748
      @ayaanbadal6748 Месяц назад

      ​@@martingingerich8830if you're ever eaten asp, carp just tastes like a more mild asp with a boney consistency

  • @someguy-k2h
    @someguy-k2h 2 месяца назад

    Such an adorable family. They are the best part of the video.

  • @randallpinkfloyd7225
    @randallpinkfloyd7225 3 года назад +10

    Pan fried, deep fried, stir-fried. There's pineapple carp, lemon carp, coconut carp, pepper carp, carp soup, carp stew, carp salad, carp and potatoes, carp burger, carp sandwich. That- that's about it.

  • @marksieving7925
    @marksieving7925 20 дней назад

    We ate a lot of carp when I was a kid. Dad would filet the fish and score the filets, making parallel cuts about a quarter inch apart down to the skin. Carp is a bony fish and scoring the filets gets rid of the bones in the flesh. Mom would then bread the filets and fry them. I thought it was pretty good.
    Carp is a bottom feeding fish and if you get it from dirty water it will have eaten all the dirt that settles to the bottom. Catch it from clean water and it tastes better.

  • @jonathand9793
    @jonathand9793 6 месяцев назад +5

    I wonder if purging the fish in clean water for a few hours would help any

  • @rexpolka
    @rexpolka Год назад

    cold water season is better than warm water seasons for their flavor -- we also hang / nail them to a tree by the mouth/lip and cut off tail to bleed them, and after skinning/filleting them, we cut the dark meat strip out and toss. What's left it terrific. Smoke carp and pressure canned are other great ways of preserving this. Yes, my german and bohemian friends have recipes for baked carp with cream and dill sauce, with potato dumplings on the side, and kolach for dessert. R

  • @rousefire
    @rousefire 5 месяцев назад

    I live in a river town and there use to be fish markets here. They sold tons of carp, They would scour them then when deep fried the bones would disappear. Carp fish fries were common. A carp sandwich on a hot day with a cold beer was a delight.

  • @motherslittlehelper8055
    @motherslittlehelper8055 Месяц назад +1

    Like the video haha! Nice part when your kinds tried it. You could also make lots of cuts in the filets, rub the flesh with salt, white pepper and cornmeal and then fry it. serve with mayonaise with garlick or aioli or something like that.

  • @tomshif
    @tomshif 6 месяцев назад

    I've done a lot of aid work in Iraq, and carp is considered the "national food" of Iraq (called "masgouf"). It's absolutely incredible...I think it comes down to how it's cooked. There, they gut it, then cut the fish in half lengthwise and cook it around an open fire (scale side away from fire, propped up with sticks). I wasn't convinced before trying it, but it probably my favorite type of fish to eat.

  • @richardorchard8554
    @richardorchard8554 Месяц назад +1

    I guess if you didn’t like the flavour/texture- whacking it in the food processor, and seasoning like a crazy man to make something like a Thai fish cake- that’s gunna make an awesome fish cake. I remember having it when my brother in law caught it when I was a kid, and thought nothing of it- just fish. That was from a clear lake though. They are a very prolific invasive species in SE Australia, they are very common.

  • @karlaf1843
    @karlaf1843 3 месяца назад

    One of the best videos about carp meat flavor. Very well made.

  • @oakenstake4948
    @oakenstake4948 3 месяца назад

    I live in Indonesia and this fish is one of the staple foods in my country. It is probably also one of the most commonly farmed fish alongside catfish. We usually deep fry them or grill them with sweet soy sauce. I think the water and the type of feeds play huge part on how the fish tastes, because I've tasted both wild caught and farmed ones and I can notice some differences.

  • @expatalan6511
    @expatalan6511 22 дня назад +1

    Great video!
    Compared to a nice tasting fish a carp doesn’t compare. That’s why people don’t keep them.
    I don’t like them. I tried cooking them a variety of ways and I couldn’t make it taste good at all.
    In a survival situation I would keep one 🤣☝🏻
    👍🏻

  • @dominicregos4902
    @dominicregos4902 6 месяцев назад

    I was once told that the secret to making carp is to do this:
    Go into the mountains and find a good spring that runs cold and clear. Build a small pool big enough to hold a couple of fish. Then go down to the muddy river and catch some carp. Quickly transport them alive to the pool you built in the spring. Leave them there a couple of days and the cold clean water will flush the bad taste out of the carp. Firms up the flesh and takes the muddy flavor away. I do have to say I have never tried it, but it makes perfectly good sense to me.

  • @misticismoNATURAL
    @misticismoNATURAL Месяц назад

    Here, in my city in RJ, Brazil, people answer the problem of the spikes in carp meat by making a bunch of parallel cuts before frying (yeah, they only make it deep fried). The heat from oil cook better the chunks of spikes and then it can be ate without fear (almost). Other solution is cook the fish in water, steam, or roast in he oven and then take off the spikes easily. Then mix the meat with smashed potatos or cassava or bread crumbs to make kind of crockets.

  • @ralphgreenjr.2466
    @ralphgreenjr.2466 6 месяцев назад

    I spent a lot of time in Europe in my 30 year Army career. Carp is very common in European Rivers. The Czechs, Hungarians, Poles, Ukrainians, and Jews, just to name the ones I ate carp with, have national dishes made with carp, catfish, and sturgeon. Hungarian fish soup is my favorite. My Mother was from Poland and would bring every carp I caught home. She would grind the meat, mix it with bread crumbs, and seasoning and fry it. WOW, is that good.

  • @darksyed
    @darksyed 6 месяцев назад

    Good analysis of the taste. In Southeast Asia, carp is a highly prized fish, especially the river variety. The reason for this, as you correctly state, is that you can taste the water the carp has come from in their flesh. Although they are omnivorous column feeders, they are normally caught by legering. Their mouths have a downward slant that make them ideal for sucking feed off the bottom. Hence, the flavour of the lake bed.

  • @soldtobediers
    @soldtobediers 5 месяцев назад +1

    Thanks to the shore fishing Heron we have many of our fish species, who's fertilized eggs sticking to their legs ,get deposited to all sectors of ponds.

  • @Justacook74
    @Justacook74 6 месяцев назад

    While deployed in Iraq, the Iraqis would prepare Masgoof on special occasions. It’s split and skewered carp roasted over/near a fire served over a bed of pilaf and it is quite good actually.

  • @Thrunabulax10
    @Thrunabulax10 5 месяцев назад +1

    carp cooked up crispy chinese style is WONDERFUL.

  • @tangoindiamike9189
    @tangoindiamike9189 6 месяцев назад +1

    I would have to be crazy hungry to eat a carp. Interesting side note: Lobster used to be considered a garbage food and was mainly fed to prison inmates in Maine and the New England area. Somewhere along the way, lobster became a glamor food.

  • @KeithWF
    @KeithWF 6 месяцев назад

    Carp is a traditional German Holiday meal. Generally, I was informed that Germans keep a Carp for week in fresh water for it to clean itself, before cooking. Very similar to snails (Escargot) which are also kept isolated for several days before eating, in order for them to clean themselves out.

  • @user-sx7fo3ic9p
    @user-sx7fo3ic9p 5 месяцев назад +1

    When I can limit out on walleye every trip to Lake Erie or pompano in south west Florida I don’t see myself ever trying carp. Used to shoot them with bows as a kid. Turned them into fish oil for trapping bait.

  • @alexanderhartman1931
    @alexanderhartman1931 5 месяцев назад

    😂 Feeds each member of his family pieces of a fish and then proudly exclaims how he fished it out of the dirtiest lake in the entire region! Someone please give this man a medal for his dedication to science!

  • @joenava2679
    @joenava2679 2 месяца назад

    Brendan Miller, the best way to eat carp is butter fly the small carp about 6/8 inch or 12 inch max and add lemon and salt and air dry to get all the moisture out than fry them in oil and eat it with crispy bones and all, amazing.

  • @36ydna
    @36ydna 5 месяцев назад +1

    Most of Eastern and Central Europe eat carp, and it is sold in most large supermarkets.

  • @debowiec3
    @debowiec3 9 месяцев назад

    Amazing how much work he put into this whole carp eating experience!!!!!

  • @BerryMike-d9v
    @BerryMike-d9v Месяц назад

    Sweet and sour carp from yellow river is one of the famous dish of China, covered with thick paste and dip fried to crispy then covered with sweet and sour sauce…. It is a mouthwatering dish all the time.

  • @pichiticivita4234
    @pichiticivita4234 5 месяцев назад

    in our region we cooking carp common use hole fish :first salted in ginger、onion、chives,crash it then added rice wine ,soak it 30min,then clean up all excess water give it nice Beatiful knife partten,next we heat the wok to 150℃,deep fry it until it's sealed,and the stir fry useing homemade colza oil with rough choped ginger+garlic,add meat&bone soup about 1/3 wok,then fish、sweet fermented flour sause 3tsp+dark aged soy sauce 2tsp,low heat till the water equal to fish's high take out the fish plating,added fine choped carrot marbled meat and green beans,till it's reduce when u can see the sauce a little stick on spatula,seasoning,Dizzle over the fish,serve🎉

  • @short-hand4312
    @short-hand4312 3 месяца назад

    my family has eaten carp for decades, if not more. Interesting approach. you mix your chemistry altering their effectiveness and function. Below is how we prepared our carp: we process it like you. remove dark fat and mud vein. soak overnight in salt water. rinse and soak overnight in baking soda. rinse and finally soak overnight in buttermilk. rinse, pat dry, and roll in your favorite catfish coating. deep fry until golden brown. drain and cool. just like walleye. processing the fish and omitting the coating you can pressure cook them for a couple minutes. any bones become mush. safe to eat. good source of minerals.

  • @Unapproachable_Light
    @Unapproachable_Light 2 месяца назад

    The common carp was brought to North America for food purposes. I've eaten small crucian carp from a spring-fed pond, cooked over an open fire. It wasn't bad. I've eaten smoked carp and it wasn't bad. If a fish has a strong flavor that you would like to do away with, try ginger. I met an angler from Korea once on a bank somewhere and he suggested ginger to me. I found it makes a huge difference.
    As far as eating carp goes, I prefer bass, walleye, and trout. And bluegill, perch, and crappie. And salmon, pike and even rock bass.

    • @Dwayne4007
      @Dwayne4007 Месяц назад

      But the crucian carp isn't that bad? They eat that in Europe and Russia, correct? Grass carp/ American carp is nasty huh?

  • @giuseppelogiurato5718
    @giuseppelogiurato5718 4 месяца назад

    I had carp once at a Korean "Doljanchi" (baby's first birthday party), when I was a young teen... It was gutted (in the kitchen, not at the party lol), scaled, (and ?), and the sides were deeply scored in a crisscross pattern. It was dipped in some kind of batter (the whole fish, head, fins, and tail!) and deep fried until it looked like a cross between a pineapple and a monster fish from hell; really cool looking... It was served with a typical Korean assortment of sauces and special pickles. It was the final dish served at the banquet, and each table got it's own fish, presented beautifully, in the center of the table on a "Lazy Susan". We sat there for hours, picking at the fish with chopsticks and watching the adults get hammered. Anyway, I remember it being absolutely DELICIOUS, and I crave it to this day.

  • @Helpline5815
    @Helpline5815 7 месяцев назад

    Drum and carp are two fish people wouldn't normally eat and cook, but they're both very good. You can eat everything except the guts on carp, it's a bit gamey though but delicious. Drum aren't as gamey, it's like perch. Catfish is a lot like carp with how they feed and people still eat them, they're a delicacy.

  • @shadowplay-y5g
    @shadowplay-y5g Год назад

    my dads recipe, soak the carp in beer, bake in oven on a wooden slab for 20 minutes, then eat the wood.

  • @Elrond_Hubbard1
    @Elrond_Hubbard1 5 месяцев назад

    Carp caught early in the spring before the spawn are actually pretty good. I'd definitely say that carp shines when battered and deep fried. The batter goes a long way in counteracting the swamp flavor.

  • @Louis-kk3to
    @Louis-kk3to 4 месяца назад

    A kid from Cambodia ,one of the boat people , in the 70s came to Roanoke Rapids North Carolina with his family to live and i saw him and his brother fishing in the pot- holes ,behind the RR DAM and they had a stringer of carp, he told me they taste better than the carp of his land 😮

  • @gunterbecker8528
    @gunterbecker8528 4 месяца назад +1

    Great presentation, even more beautiful family, u definitely have to like Carp ,we in Europe love Carp ! Great video mate 😊

  • @gaylanbishop1641
    @gaylanbishop1641 4 месяца назад

    Great video. I love how you incorporated your family in it.

  • @raymondyeo6507
    @raymondyeo6507 Месяц назад +1

    Carp taste good. Just probably the recipe those who didn't like it is not suitable

  • @MrGaborseres
    @MrGaborseres 3 месяца назад

    Carp is by far the favorite fish to eat in Hungary.....my favorite way is breaded and fried. and there is stewed carp.....heavenly 👌👍.

  • @gogadgetgo3125
    @gogadgetgo3125 4 месяца назад

    Love Carp. Curried and/or seasoned with tumeric, garlic then pan fried with onions, peppers, chillies, tomatoes. Its a staple.
    Good eating everyone!