My husband and I test drove the RAV4, CRV and the Rogue. Rogue was the clear winner for us and I’m a Honda girl so we were surprised. The RAV4 was comfortable but just too small. We felt like we were on top of each other and the doors were too close. We aren’t big people. We are tall and so are our kids. The kiddos legs had NO ROOM in the back. Hard pass. Loved driving the CRV, plenty of room but the seats felt like concrete so another hard pass. We couldn’t be happier with the Rogue. The driving experience is definitely more luxurious than the others. Reliability? Only time will tell… hoping for the best. I know they have a bad rap but then I also know many people with Nissans and not a single one has had an issue.
I used both Rogue and RAV4 and I liked both for different reasons. 2023 Rogue is definitely a good car with reasonably good power and it gives good mpgs as well. Nissan drastically improved their CVTs and mostly there won't be any issues with regular maintenance. Change the transmission oil for every 25-30k miles.
@@Gopinathk17, currently having issues with a gas smell while idle and in the garage. Had a hose changed which has been a great fix for most but not me and a few others. It helped but definitely wasn’t a fix. They are working on it so we are hoping for something soon. Fingers crossed.
@@shellyhugeback9207 Ah ok.. I heard the same issue from few other people as well in RUclips but I used my 2023 Rogue SV premium for 13 months and drove 11k+ miles and honestly I never had any such gas smell.
Change the fluid of your CVT every 30k or 60k miles and is going to last a long time. Check your owners manual for maintanance information and also care recommendations
@@404notfound..... we actually loved that because I bought it literally to take my kids to and back from school with our dog in tow. For the fun we have our Maserati Grandturismo with a veggie and tree hug lover most hated all gas all power engine.
Get out of here! I did the same thing too! 😂 I went to Yellowstone last May and the Enterprise people gave me the option of renting a Rogue or a RAV. I chose the Rogue, because I had a Sentra at home. After a week of driving it in Wyoming, I fell in love with the car. I so wanted to take it home as a souvenir, but I couldn’t. But I had been contemplating upgrading my Sentra for a while so I decided to buy the 2024 Rogue last week at a nearby Nissan dealer that I like. I went for the SV Premium AWD. Had I not rented that car, I’d have still been considering Subaru Outback or BMW X3. I do have bit of a bias. When it comes to Japanese cars, I tend to rate Nissan as a better car than Toyotas or Hondas.
@@abinashmishra329 that’s hilarious 😂😂😂😂 we were considering another couple of other suvs as well because we have a large dog who couldn’t fit in our car anymore with our 2 kids. That’s the reason we had to rent an suv in the first place, it was such a nice ride, comfortable, great with gas it’s actually nice looking so we thought “screw it let’s get it” 😂😂😂 We bought it in April and it’s been fantastic!!!
I just leased this exact 2023 Rogue SL two weeks ago and absolutely love it! We had a 2018, 2021, and now the 2023 since we lease them. Never had any problems. Fun and comfortable to drive!
This was the best and funny review that I have seen on RUclips in a long time. Great job and thank you for the review. I am in the process of looking at a new vehicle for my wife and these are the 2 that I am looking at.
I just traded my 2019 Rogue SV for a 2024 Rogue SV premium. I’m impressed with the upgrades. The 2024 has more bells and whistles than my old Rogue. And the panoramic window above is a nice touch to have… but not as important to me. I love the heated steering and seats and all the driving assistance options. I love the camera on the 2024. Overall… I was very happy with the 2019 build and stayed loyal to Nissan. Note: I’m not a huge driver… my 2019 had less than 22K miles on it. Never had any problem with it.
I’m going to have to say the 2023 Nissan Rogue because I’ve already bought it. I bought it 3 weeks ago! I’ve had a Toyota Camry and had no trouble with it. Toyota makes good vehicles. I sure hope my Rogue will be a good Nissan too!
I don’t know which trim you got but if you got a high end trim you get the zero gravity seats 💺 which are amazingly comfortable and compare to no other.
I am proud owner of RAV 4 2022 Hybrid XLE, registered on January 2023. Fantastic car, I love it! Thanks Toyota for this product, really economic and useful SUV.
I agreed with Consumer Reports, the Rogue gas is way superior to the outdated Rav4 gas. Rav4 hybrids after the refresh will likely be a nice option, but for now there's a reason the Rogue scored so much higher, and ditto on Motortrend scoring the Rogue so much higher. But some people trust the name Rav4 just based on decades of reputation rather than the actual car.
@@BoopSnootThat's a big gamble when you're spending your hard earned money. I'll stick with years of proven reliability. Nissan needs to get away from the Renault umbrella and start making real Nissans again.
@@DoneDeal2 Actually i have both vehicles in different years, 2018 Rav LE and 2023 Rogue Plat w/1.5T and i have a slight tiny leak coming from the Rav's Trans Pan Gasket, but its also been reliable other than that and same with the Rogue, all reliable except the Fuel Smell coming from the engine, was recalled on a TSB for free fix and all is well.
We started looking for a new vehicle this last Monday. We had talked about the Toyota and some of the reviews made comments about the newer ones being tinny. Then we looked hard at the Mitsubishi Outlander which we liked. It seemed simpler. But then the dealer told me he could do a really good deal on the Nissan! Now in 73 cars we’ve never owned a Nissan so this is new for us. But so far we love it.
I have a 2005 Nissan Altima (19 years old, over 220,000 km) that has been an excellent vehicle for me. I have wanted to purchase the Rogue for at least 5 years, but a new vehicle is out of my reach. My first car in the early 70’s was a Toyota Corolla, which was great - really liked Toyotas. But, somewhere along the line, I’ve discovered Nissan and it has never failed me. My choice ….. Nissan ROGUE. Thank you for your excellent comparison.
@@jareddavis105 over 100K on mine too, 2016. Would buy again-especially when I found out you have to put a $500 dollar NON REFUNDABLE deposit to hold a TOY
Yeah but at least the Nissan is nice. People will buy cars that are less nice and less reliable and more expensive. This is the shock of those who purchase American cars.
I was comparing the two before I bought the Rogue in summer. One of the biggest deciding factor was the second row seat. The Rogue is more comfortable than the RAV4. The interior in overal was better as well. The ride quality on the RAV4 is a bit rough, and the engine is loud. The Rogue is much more refined on this.
Every car is shiny, sparkling and reliable when new. How they will be in 10 years should be considered when buying them. Maybe you can squeeze a few thousand extra kms from the brakes of that RAV4. Maybe you won't have to change the transmission fluid, shocks, bushings and engine mounts that often. It's those little things that make the difference.
Not with the Nissan either, and I don't think a buyer of a Rav4 will keep it for 10 years, anyway, the Rav4 also has its problems, they are not indestructible vehicles.
Tell that to the people with the class action lawsuits from engine failures from sludge problems from 1997-2003 and the people who have had the engines burning oil from 2006-2018 or the people with the new turbo V6 that’s throwing rods at 25k.
GREAT INFORMATIVE VIDEO IVE EVER SEEN ON HERE REGARDING THESE VEHICLES! U did not leave anything out!! Thankyou! U actually helped me to decide. And I decided I’m going to go with the Nissan rogue. I was never a rav4 kinda gal anyways btw your HILARIOUS I love your funny clever musical humor
My wife's 2021 RAV4 XLE Premium AWD is at the dealership getting a new charcoal canister after an incident with running over a deer. Now we have a 24 Rogue SV AWD as a rental. I find the Rogue much more comfortable in the seats and I'm very impressed by the power from the 3 cylinder turbo.... I know Nissan isn't known for long term durability in their power trains but that aside, The Rogue is the power and comfort winner for me.
@@donrandle8999 I've done that Google search before and it seems Google gives the same answer for every make and model including ones that have been known to fail
@@donrandle8999 I learned there are Nissan dealerships that offer lifetime powertrain warrantys free of charge, you just need to keep up on every required maintenance item (which I'm all for). But I do not like the manual saying change engine oil at 7,500 miles. No turbo engine should go beyond 5,000 mile changes and I still personally prefer 3,000 mile changes. Oil is cheaper than an engine and I heard Nissan has updated their CVT design which is good but I would definitely be changing the fluid at 30,000 miles max, not 60,000.
Of the gas versions, I give the RAV4 the edge. They're very close in a lot of the comparisons, but the reliability of the RAV4's 2.5 4-banger over the smaller turbocharged Rogue puts the RAV4 over the top. Personally, I'd go with the hybrid, which would push it even higher. I also find the Toyota instrument/button layout more intuitive for my tastes.
These were both in my potential buy options back in 21 but I ended up going subaru. If forced between these two, the rogue is fine but I just can't help but go for the rav4 primarily because of the difference in overall reputation between the two companies
My 2007 Nissan Altima is on its way out so I'm now looking at getting one of these. Thanks for your overview. I'll see about test drives next week. Wish me luck...
Rav4 all day long and twice on Sundays best selling SUV in USA for a reason, best resell value and most reliable car in the market,, no cvt and no turbo engine what else can you ask for it... 💪
If it’s ready the most reliable car on the market why are you concerned with resale. Toyota is not more reliable than Nissan, it’s a fact. Mechanic logs show that Toyota cost more to maintain, and owners spend more every year on Toyota repairs even with Nissans cvt problems from years ago. I own a repair shop, and I’m not the only mechanic who shows records like this. There are a few on RUclips who report it too. It’s just hearsay that Toyota is more reliable than Nissan.
Resell isn't that different in 10yrs. 4yr old rav4 is $4k more than a 2yr old rogue. Example 2020 rav4 w/ 50k miles - $24-26k +10yrs The 14y/o rav4 will have approx 150k miles and be worth $6k-7k A 22rogue with 40k miles -$20-22k +10yrs The 12y/o rogue with 150k miles will be worth $4500-$5500 Both depreciate down to about $2-3k of each other with the rav4 being worth more but the starting point of a rav4 is also about $4k more. Rogue saves in gas but possibly cost more in maintenance. Tough choice
If your intention is to keep your vehicle a long time, Rav4 is my choice, mainly because of its 2.5's engine reputation, the 8 speed transmission, and the timing chain. The Rogue has a timing belt, and a CVT transmission (basically a belt). Nissan do offer more electronic gizmos, but those gizmos don't make the vehicle trouble free or last any longer. Toyota will get you there reliably, for a VERY long time.
I'm curious if you have noticed the Rogue's turbo having a annoying low grade spinning/grinding/whining sound that shows up between 15-45 mph and more specifically when the car is coasting (foot pressure removed from accelerator pedal)? I bought a 2023 Platinum AWD. I love the car, in general. But I did not hear that awful low grade high pitched grinding whistle before i took the car home. I only noticed at after I had a chance to drive it around town by myself. I took it to the dealer and they tested another one they had there that was just delivered from the factory. It had the same characteristic. I was told it was a characteristic of the turbo design and it was not defective. I'm wondering how many owners of the 2022/2023 version (those are the years with the newer turbo charged engine) have noticed this too? Or if anyone doing reviews has noticed it? The solution is to have music playing all the time, then you don't hear it. Also above 40-45 mpg or on the highway, it's not noticable because of the road and wind noise being louder than the turbo whine.
@@markpelzer725 Even when you have let your foot off the gas? This seems to "whine" related to speed. Faster it goes the higher the pitch. Doesn't seem related to engine RPM.
I love both SUVs 🚙, I love the Rogue for the styling and the technology and the RAV4 for the quality/reliability. I looked at the Tiguan, the CX-5, the Tucson and the CR-V. The CR-V handling was kind of lackluster, the Tiguan the maintenance would be too expensive for me but drove like an Audi and the Tucson was a very smooth ride but the resale value would be not so good along with getting bored 🥱 with it after 3-5 years. The Rogue has impeccable performance, handling and great styling. The RAV4 has the Lexus like handling and some pretty good safety features along with the reliability. I wanted the Rogue but the RAV4 would be more reliable as I heard bad reviews on the Rogue. My final decision is going to be the RAV4 Limited or Lexus NX250 Premium. The CX-5 is a great choice with great performance, reliability and handling along with safety features that are great but it is too cramped for me.
I have a RAV4 2016 not a problem, but dealers' purchase transaction "HELL" on earth. I have three Rogue and purchased transactions easy not many problems.
My wife has a rav 4 2022, my daughter also 2022. Both limited, but both came with different options. This is what tics me coff about toyota/lexus. When you ask for top of the line you expect FULL OPTIONS !!! but not with toyota/lexus. I own a hyundai limited. Full options !!! Remote start, blue link with remote start with 4 options for the different seasons. We take my car 90 % of the time !!! Better ride, smart park, not even close !!!
This was my decision, and I was trying hard to get the rav4 for my wife. But they are very popular and were very inflexible . I got the rogue s for a huge discount brand new and for much less than the rav4.
I’d definitely choose RAV4 over the Nissan here, I like the 2.5 over the 1.5, and could put a turbo on that if you wanted still. Also I do prefer the design of it and the clearance is technically better for the RAV4. I did a lot of looking around before getting my last car, and did get a RAV4, albeit the 2022. I love it and wouldn’t want to change it out for anything really. That said, the fact the Nissan Seats fold down all the way, and that cool storage area under the center console were super rad and I’d love to see those implemented into the RAV. Overall though, I’d say they’re both pretty cool, but final decision considerations I’d be looking into would be the reputation and reliability and at least when I looked into it: The Toyota RAV4 Reliability Rating is 4.0 out of 5.0, which ranks it 3rd out of 26 for compact SUVs, and The Nissan Rogue Reliability Rating is 4.0 out of 5.0, which ranks it 13th out of 26 for compact SUVs.
An alternative to the Rogue is the Mitsubishi Outlander..It's the sister to the Rogue and shares the same platform. However, it has the naturally aspirated 2.5 4 cyl engine used in prior year rogues. It's a bit slower off the line but some consider it more reliable..plus the Outlander is made in Japan and has a gorgeous quiet interior.
Why not use the Base Models ? Both should have been White in color. I've leased several RAV4's. I woulh have leased another but 2004 very hard to get . NISSAN ROGUE had 0% financing for 2 yr, Lease. Only had the ROGUE since Feb. So far I like it !
Going to be selling our old faithful 2013 Subaru Outback limited, and either get another Outback or a Rogue Platinum . We test drove both. 2024 Rogue has some nice changes over the 2023.
Rogue for sure. Tall families fit better in the Rogue. No leg room for my 6’2 boys and 5’10 daughter especially when seated behind their 6’3 father. The front seat is between their knees which could be dangerous in an accident, in my opinion. Not to mention how uncomfortable the ride will be.
Overall better off with the rav 4 because it’s a regular transmission 😮 Nissan has a lot of problems with their cvt transmission. I worked for yellow freight and we had the contract for Nissan and Toyota picking up defective transmissions. I would go to Nissan and some days pick up 10 to 40 transmissions. Toyota would have about one 1️⃣ 😊
Looks goes to Rogue. Rav 4 was cool 6 years back Now, I’d prefer the 2.5 hybrid over the Rogue’s 3 cylinder. Id entertain Leasing the Rogue but I wouldnt want to keep a unique engine long term
What I understood after reading the comments from most of the reviews is..though RAV4 and CRV are the best selling cars but still Rogue and CX5 have a separate fan bases and they like those cars so much for their own reasons 😊
You buy the Toyota, always. The Nissan is alright, but then you still buy the Toyota. Better resale, better reliability, better designed and engineered. You get the Nissan because you inherited it! 😅
Im torn.. I love the look and features of the Rogue but the reliability and longevity of the RAV4. In context, I can easily put 100000 miles on it within a few years.
I would pick Rogue if not for the recent class action lawsuit. This new engine seems to have some problems with gas smell/oil dilution. Hopefully, Nissan will do something about it quickly and I will be able to change my mind.
all the lawsuits are 2018 and older just be nice to your cvt and it will be nice to you. And I have NO relationship to Nissan whatsoever. I just googled when I read your comment.
This is true. My 2023 Platinum Rogue has a gas smell. There was a hose change that was supposed to be a fix. The smell while idle is gone but in the garage is not. It is much less but still there. Apparently they are still working on it as they know it doesn’t help all Rogues so I’m still hoping. Fingers crossed because I LOVE it.
Unfortunately Nissan has lost so much ground since the 70’s. I don’t see them ever catching up again. Long term not many Nissan vehicles keep high values like a Toyota does. The 240Z & Roadster days of the 60’s & 70’s are long gone.
The Rogue is obviously better overall but Toyota is much better at marketing and protecting their brand, giving people the impression their vehicles are more reliable.
@@fallguy4209 ...a lot, actually. While Nissan has had their ups and downs with CVT, prior to the CVT era, their cars were every bit as reliable. In the past Toyota's maintained great reliability for their engines and transmissions, but everything else on them used to break down, from the stereos to the horns, to the cheaply made bumpers.
My 2013 Altima v6 has over 300k, still running strong and fast. The only maintenance was done to it last year was tie rod and lower control arms. My family owns nothing but Nissans since the 80's for the most part all of our cars went over 250k@fallguy4209
I had a 2019 Rogue AWD SV. No rust at all. I just traded it in for a 2024 SV Rogue FWD premium. The vehicle I had was well taken care of. No problems ever.
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
My husband and I test drove the RAV4, CRV and the Rogue. Rogue was the clear winner for us and I’m a Honda girl so we were surprised. The RAV4 was comfortable but just too small. We felt like we were on top of each other and the doors were too close. We aren’t big people. We are tall and so are our kids. The kiddos legs had NO ROOM in the back. Hard pass. Loved driving the CRV, plenty of room but the seats felt like concrete so another hard pass. We couldn’t be happier with the Rogue. The driving experience is definitely more luxurious than the others. Reliability? Only time will tell… hoping for the best. I know they have a bad rap but then I also know many people with Nissans and not a single one has had an issue.
I used both Rogue and RAV4 and I liked both for different reasons. 2023 Rogue is definitely a good car with reasonably good power and it gives good mpgs as well. Nissan drastically improved their CVTs and mostly there won't be any issues with regular maintenance. Change the transmission oil for every 25-30k miles.
@@Gopinathk17, currently having issues with a gas smell while idle and in the garage. Had a hose changed which has been a great fix for most but not me and a few others. It helped but definitely wasn’t a fix. They are working on it so we are hoping for something soon. Fingers crossed.
@@shellyhugeback9207 Ah ok.. I heard the same issue from few other people as well in RUclips but I used my 2023 Rogue SV premium for 13 months and drove 11k+ miles and honestly I never had any such gas smell.
Change the fluid of your CVT every 30k or 60k miles and is going to last a long time. Check your owners manual for maintanance information and also care recommendations
lol won’t be a clear winner in a couple years. You’re gonna wish you bought a RAV4
We rented the Rogue two weeks ago for our spring break trip. We loved it so much we went ahead and bought the premium version today 😂
Wow, that’s awesome. Congratulations!
The problem with the rogue is. It's equipped with a government compliance engine "1.5 turbo".
@@404notfound..... we actually loved that because I bought it literally to take my kids to and back from school with our dog in tow. For the fun we have our Maserati Grandturismo with a veggie and tree hug lover most hated all gas all power engine.
Get out of here! I did the same thing too! 😂 I went to Yellowstone last May and the Enterprise people gave me the option of renting a Rogue or a RAV. I chose the Rogue, because I had a Sentra at home. After a week of driving it in Wyoming, I fell in love with the car. I so wanted to take it home as a souvenir, but I couldn’t. But I had been contemplating upgrading my Sentra for a while so I decided to buy the 2024 Rogue last week at a nearby Nissan dealer that I like. I went for the SV Premium AWD.
Had I not rented that car, I’d have still been considering Subaru Outback or BMW X3.
I do have bit of a bias. When it comes to Japanese cars, I tend to rate Nissan as a better car than Toyotas or Hondas.
@@abinashmishra329 that’s hilarious 😂😂😂😂 we were considering another couple of other suvs as well because we have a large dog who couldn’t fit in our car anymore with our 2 kids. That’s the reason we had to rent an suv in the first place, it was such a nice ride, comfortable, great with gas it’s actually nice looking so we thought “screw it let’s get it” 😂😂😂
We bought it in April and it’s been fantastic!!!
I just leased this exact 2023 Rogue SL two weeks ago and absolutely love it! We had a 2018, 2021, and now the 2023 since we lease them. Never had any problems. Fun and comfortable to drive!
This was the best and funny review that I have seen on RUclips in a long time. Great job and thank you for the review. I am in the process of looking at a new vehicle for my wife and these are the 2 that I am looking at.
I feel the Rogue was a clear winner.
I’ve owned each Toyota and Nissans I feel the engineering always goes a bit further with Nissan.
I just traded my 2019 Rogue SV for a 2024 Rogue SV premium. I’m impressed with the upgrades. The 2024 has more bells and whistles than my old Rogue. And the panoramic window above is a nice touch to have… but not as important to me. I love the heated steering and seats and all the driving assistance options. I love the camera on the 2024. Overall… I was very happy with the 2019 build and stayed loyal to Nissan. Note: I’m not a huge driver… my 2019 had less than 22K miles on it. Never had any problem with it.
2024 is not in the market yet ..how did you get it? Are you from the US?
I’m going to have to say the 2023 Nissan Rogue because I’ve already bought it. I bought it 3 weeks ago! I’ve had a Toyota Camry and had no trouble with it. Toyota makes good vehicles. I sure hope my Rogue will be a good Nissan too!
I don’t know which trim you got but if you got a high end trim you get the zero gravity seats 💺 which are amazingly comfortable and compare to no other.
I am proud owner of RAV 4 2022 Hybrid XLE, registered on January 2023.
Fantastic car, I love it!
Thanks Toyota for this product, really economic and useful SUV.
I have a Ford Escape and I love it, but I just love this guy he has so much energy.
No doubt...Rogue drives gr8.beautifully designed in and out as well.
I am a huge Toyota fan, but I bought a 2023 Rogue. So many more features for the driver that I wanted on the inside of the Rogues.
😂 Your wittiness just won you a new subscriber.
Hi April! You’re awesome and thanks so much!!! See you on RUclips :)
Rogue might be cheaper but I’m taking the RAV4 any day. Can’t go wrong with them.
I agreed with Consumer Reports, the Rogue gas is way superior to the outdated Rav4 gas. Rav4 hybrids after the refresh will likely be a nice option, but for now there's a reason the Rogue scored so much higher, and ditto on Motortrend scoring the Rogue so much higher. But some people trust the name Rav4 just based on decades of reputation rather than the actual car.
@@BoopSnoot exactly!
@@BoopSnootThat's a big gamble when you're spending your hard earned money. I'll stick with years of proven reliability. Nissan needs to get away from the Renault umbrella and start making real Nissans again.
@@DoneDeal2 Actually i have both vehicles in different years, 2018 Rav LE and 2023 Rogue Plat w/1.5T and i have a slight tiny leak coming from the Rav's Trans Pan Gasket, but its also been reliable other than that and same with the Rogue, all reliable except the Fuel Smell coming from the engine, was recalled on a TSB for free fix and all is well.
We started looking for a new vehicle this last Monday. We had talked about the Toyota and some of the reviews made comments about the newer ones being tinny. Then we looked hard at the Mitsubishi Outlander which we liked. It seemed simpler. But then the dealer told me he could do a really good deal on the Nissan! Now in 73 cars we’ve never owned a Nissan so this is new for us. But so far we love it.
Jeff's personality always makes my day. I love watching this dude's vids. 1 point Miyagi Do lmao
Just traded a 2022 rav4 limited with 7800 miles. The rav4 was like driving a cheap rental car. We love our new 2024 rouge platinum. Both good cars...
I have a 2005 Nissan Altima (19 years old, over 220,000 km) that has been an excellent vehicle for me. I have wanted to purchase the Rogue for at least 5 years, but a new vehicle is out of my reach.
My first car in the early 70’s was a Toyota Corolla, which was great - really liked Toyotas. But, somewhere along the line, I’ve discovered Nissan and it has never failed me.
My choice ….. Nissan ROGUE.
Thank you for your excellent comparison.
I’d go with the RAV4 every time, at least by the time you pay it off it’ll still be running.
Yes SIR.
The best overall point to be made.
*"I'll still be running"*
have a 2014 Nissan Rogue that I bought new, it now has 210K miles on it... never had any issues with it so that tempers my view
lmao
@@jareddavis105 over 100K on mine too, 2016. Would buy again-especially when I found out you have to put a $500 dollar NON REFUNDABLE deposit to hold a TOY
Yeah but at least the Nissan is nice. People will buy cars that are less nice and less reliable and more expensive. This is the shock of those who purchase American cars.
Depends if I'm leasing or buying. I would lease Nissan all day, but if I was buying definitely going with Toyota.
I was comparing the two before I bought the Rogue in summer. One of the biggest deciding factor was the second row seat. The Rogue is more comfortable than the RAV4. The interior in overal was better as well. The ride quality on the RAV4 is a bit rough, and the engine is loud. The Rogue is much more refined on this.
Lmao
Every car is shiny, sparkling and reliable when new. How they will be in 10 years should be considered when buying them. Maybe you can squeeze a few thousand extra kms from the brakes of that RAV4. Maybe you won't have to change the transmission fluid, shocks, bushings and engine mounts that often. It's those little things that make the difference.
Not with the Nissan either, and I don't think a buyer of a Rav4 will keep it for 10 years, anyway, the Rav4 also has its problems, they are not indestructible vehicles.
Rogue, hands down winner.
Hands down period💯
Toyota all day, they stand behind their vehicles
Tell that to the people with the class action lawsuits from engine failures from sludge problems from 1997-2003 and the people who have had the engines burning oil from 2006-2018 or the people with the new turbo V6 that’s throwing rods at 25k.
Great video comparing the two SUVs the Rouge for me 👍
Bought a 2020 rav 4 hybrid for my wife 40 mpg and its comfortable but I like the rogue I test drove it was nice
GREAT INFORMATIVE VIDEO IVE EVER SEEN ON HERE REGARDING THESE VEHICLES! U did not leave anything out!! Thankyou! U actually helped me to decide. And I decided I’m going to go with the Nissan rogue. I was never a rav4 kinda gal anyways btw your HILARIOUS I love your funny clever musical humor
My wife's 2021 RAV4 XLE Premium AWD is at the dealership getting a new charcoal canister after an incident with running over a deer. Now we have a 24 Rogue SV AWD as a rental. I find the Rogue much more comfortable in the seats and I'm very impressed by the power from the 3 cylinder turbo.... I know Nissan isn't known for long term durability in their power trains but that aside, The Rogue is the power and comfort winner for me.
Google how long Nissan engines last, and Google how long Toyota engines last. Nissan is definitely know for power train durability and technology.
@@donrandle8999 I've done that Google search before and it seems Google gives the same answer for every make and model including ones that have been known to fail
@@donrandle8999 I learned there are Nissan dealerships that offer lifetime powertrain warrantys free of charge, you just need to keep up on every required maintenance item (which I'm all for). But I do not like the manual saying change engine oil at 7,500 miles. No turbo engine should go beyond 5,000 mile changes and I still personally prefer 3,000 mile changes. Oil is cheaper than an engine and I heard Nissan has updated their CVT design which is good but I would definitely be changing the fluid at 30,000 miles max, not 60,000.
Of the gas versions, I give the RAV4 the edge.
They're very close in a lot of the comparisons, but the reliability of the RAV4's 2.5 4-banger over the smaller turbocharged Rogue puts the RAV4 over the top. Personally, I'd go with the hybrid, which would push it even higher. I also find the Toyota instrument/button layout more intuitive for my tastes.
These were both in my potential buy options back in 21 but I ended up going subaru. If forced between these two, the rogue is fine but I just can't help but go for the rav4 primarily because of the difference in overall reputation between the two companies
My 2007 Nissan Altima is on its way out so I'm now looking at getting one of these. Thanks for your overview. I'll see about test drives next week. Wish me luck...
I love Toyota but I like the ride on the Nissan better
Love the Rouge ❤
Hands down, Rogue
Rav4 all day long and twice on Sundays best selling SUV in USA for a reason, best resell value and most reliable car in the market,, no cvt and no turbo engine what else can you ask for it... 💪
If it’s ready the most reliable car on the market why are you concerned with resale. Toyota is not more reliable than Nissan, it’s a fact. Mechanic logs show that Toyota cost more to maintain, and owners spend more every year on Toyota repairs even with Nissans cvt problems from years ago. I own a repair shop, and I’m not the only mechanic who shows records like this. There are a few on RUclips who report it too. It’s just hearsay that Toyota is more reliable than Nissan.
@donrandle8999 you're wrong. Toyota/Lexus is #1 in reliability. Nissan is not even on the top 10 lol
Resell isn't that different in 10yrs.
4yr old rav4 is $4k more than a 2yr old rogue.
Example
2020 rav4 w/ 50k miles - $24-26k
+10yrs
The 14y/o rav4 will have approx 150k miles and be worth $6k-7k
A 22rogue with 40k miles -$20-22k
+10yrs
The 12y/o rogue with 150k miles will be worth $4500-$5500
Both depreciate down to about $2-3k of each other with the rav4 being worth more but the starting point of a rav4 is also about $4k more. Rogue saves in gas but possibly cost more in maintenance.
Tough choice
The Rav4 is LOUD inside. It feels like a child's toy. Rogue has the better engine and interior.
Better engine 😅 stay a way from Cvt and turbo engines take my word I learned the hard way...
If your intention is to keep your vehicle a long time, Rav4 is my choice, mainly because of its 2.5's engine reputation, the 8 speed transmission, and the timing chain. The Rogue has a timing belt, and a CVT transmission (basically a belt). Nissan do offer more electronic gizmos, but those gizmos don't make the vehicle trouble free or last any longer. Toyota will get you there reliably, for a VERY long time.
I'm curious if you have noticed the Rogue's turbo having a annoying low grade spinning/grinding/whining sound that shows up between 15-45 mph and more specifically when the car is coasting (foot pressure removed from accelerator pedal)? I bought a 2023 Platinum AWD. I love the car, in general. But I did not hear that awful low grade high pitched grinding whistle before i took the car home. I only noticed at after I had a chance to drive it around town by myself. I took it to the dealer and they tested another one they had there that was just delivered from the factory. It had the same characteristic. I was told it was a characteristic of the turbo design and it was not defective. I'm wondering how many owners of the 2022/2023 version (those are the years with the newer turbo charged engine) have noticed this too? Or if anyone doing reviews has noticed it? The solution is to have music playing all the time, then you don't hear it. Also above 40-45 mpg or on the highway, it's not noticable because of the road and wind noise being louder than the turbo whine.
It's normal for turbochargers to make a whirring/whining sound. The vehicle could probably use some better sound insulation.
Turbos whine
@@markpelzer725 Even when you have let your foot off the gas? This seems to "whine" related to speed. Faster it goes the higher the pitch. Doesn't seem related to engine RPM.
rogue my love
Rogue!!
Nissan, like Kia Hyundai has Slick interior but comes up short on the drivetrain.
Thanks for doing this comparison. I wonder if you can do a review of the latest Toyota Corolla Cross?
Yep I can do that for you next week for sure!
I love both SUVs 🚙, I love the Rogue for the styling and the technology and the RAV4 for the quality/reliability. I looked at the Tiguan, the CX-5, the Tucson and the CR-V. The CR-V handling was kind of lackluster, the Tiguan the maintenance would be too expensive for me but drove like an Audi and the Tucson was a very smooth ride but the resale value would be not so good along with getting bored 🥱 with it after 3-5 years. The Rogue has impeccable performance, handling and great styling. The RAV4 has the Lexus like handling and some pretty good safety features along with the reliability. I wanted the Rogue but the RAV4 would be more reliable as I heard bad reviews on the Rogue. My final decision is going to be the RAV4 Limited or Lexus NX250 Premium. The CX-5 is a great choice with great performance, reliability and handling along with safety features that are great but it is too cramped for me.
My ADHD has the same energy level as your ADHD and so I watched a 27 minute video and it wasn't horrible and I subscribed.
Really wish more car makers put a power passenger seat in mid-trim levels
They dont even compare anymore. The crv and rogue are the finest options.
I have a RAV4 2016 not a problem, but dealers' purchase transaction "HELL" on earth. I have three Rogue and purchased transactions easy not many problems.
Rav4, definitely.
My wife has a rav 4 2022, my daughter also 2022. Both limited, but both came with different options. This is what tics me coff about toyota/lexus. When you ask for top of the line you expect FULL OPTIONS !!! but not with toyota/lexus. I own a hyundai limited. Full options !!! Remote start, blue link with remote start with 4 options for the different seasons. We take my car 90 % of the time !!! Better ride, smart park, not even close !!!
This was my decision, and I was trying hard to get the rav4 for my wife. But they are very popular and were very inflexible . I got the rogue s for a huge discount brand new and for much less than the rav4.
How the rogue been treating you??
@@felixmendozarodriguez1189 it’s drives smooth and back seat space is enormous. She also gets 31 combined mpg with 95% city driving.
The Rogue with a 3 cylinder turbo engine and cvt transmission, I expect the Toyota will have better long term reliability.
Not
Thanks for the video! My heart would go for the Rogue but my brain would go for the RAV4 despite its flaws.
Good thoughts thank you!
Me too ❤
Like the dance. Good information
I’d definitely choose RAV4 over the Nissan here, I like the 2.5 over the 1.5, and could put a turbo on that if you wanted still. Also I do prefer the design of it and the clearance is technically better for the RAV4. I did a lot of looking around before getting my last car, and did get a RAV4, albeit the 2022. I love it and wouldn’t want to change it out for anything really. That said, the fact the Nissan Seats fold down all the way, and that cool storage area under the center console were super rad and I’d love to see those implemented into the RAV. Overall though, I’d say they’re both pretty cool, but final decision considerations I’d be looking into would be the reputation and reliability and at least when I looked into it: The Toyota RAV4 Reliability Rating is 4.0 out of 5.0, which ranks it 3rd out of 26 for compact SUVs, and The Nissan Rogue Reliability Rating is 4.0 out of 5.0, which ranks it 13th out of 26 for compact SUVs.
According to which rating source? Who rated those cars?
Rogue for one or two years. The RAV4 if you want something reliable after that.
One or two years? At least be honest and make some sense.
The rav4's interior looks chunky. I like the rogue overall
An alternative to the Rogue is the Mitsubishi Outlander..It's the sister to the Rogue and shares the same platform. However, it has the naturally aspirated 2.5 4 cyl engine used in prior year rogues. It's a bit slower off the line but some consider it more reliable..plus the Outlander is made in Japan and has a gorgeous quiet interior.
It doesn’t come with a spare tire.
Why not use the Base Models ? Both should have been White in color. I've leased several RAV4's. I woulh have leased another but 2004 very hard to get . NISSAN ROGUE had 0% financing for 2 yr, Lease. Only had the ROGUE since Feb. So far I like it !
I like how you consider these being "small SUVs" :). In Europe this Rogue (Xtrail) is the biggest Nissan you can buy.
Yeah isn’t that weird how vehicle size is so different between countries
Europe's Xtrail is 3row SUV right?
Yes, if you want to buy this option. But the 2 extra seats are only for kids. No legs room for adults.
Going to be selling our old faithful 2013 Subaru Outback limited, and either get another Outback or a Rogue Platinum . We test drove both. 2024 Rogue has some nice changes over the 2023.
Jeff, will you do a comparison between the 2024 RAV4 and the 2024 Venza Limited??
Oh that’s an interesting one. I wonder when the 2024 will start showing up at dealers
This guy is so much fun 💪
Nissan rogue ❤
Leaning towards Roque❤❤❤
Everyone always says Toyota has the best engines, but I’ve never been a fan on how Toyota cars look…
Rav4 will last 10 yrs problem free
Wow, tough choice. Who is your winner?
Toyota 🎉
Edge to RAV4. Big edge if it's the hybrid version.
Rogue for sure. Tall families fit better in the Rogue. No leg room for my 6’2 boys and 5’10 daughter especially when seated behind their 6’3 father. The front seat is between their knees which could be dangerous in an accident, in my opinion. Not to mention how uncomfortable the ride will be.
Go for Rav4! I used to have driving the nissan and once day when I was driving on road the molding body was dropped off ! It was ridiculous!
I see this after I bought it! I certainly hope the 2023 Nissan Rogue has improved!
@@deannacox6434don't listen to clowns the Rouge is nicer and drives way better than the rough riding Rav4.
Definitely roque i got 2023 midnight edition i love it
Overall better off with the rav 4 because it’s a regular transmission 😮 Nissan has a lot of problems with their cvt transmission. I worked for yellow freight and we had the contract for Nissan and Toyota picking up defective transmissions. I would go to Nissan and some days pick up 10 to 40 transmissions. Toyota would have about one 1️⃣ 😊
I own a 2023 rogue and my wife owns the 2023 rav 4. Ibwould say that Rav is a little coatful for what you get. Both reliable though.
Good comparision, i gots the plats with 1.5T and its so fully loaded feature's don't think the Rav can even compare on that trim level.
Rogue by far !!!
You don't want a turbo or CVT transmission. Both will bring you trouble. The Toyota will outlast the Nissan hands down.
Turbos and cvts aren’t the worse, only bad on Nissans lol
I like how the Rogue looks both exterior & interior. But I like RAV4’s engine better.
Looks goes to Rogue. Rav 4 was cool 6 years back
Now, I’d prefer the 2.5 hybrid over the Rogue’s 3 cylinder. Id entertain Leasing the Rogue but I wouldnt want to keep a unique engine long term
Did I miss it...does the driver's seat adjust up and down? (I know the passenger front seat does not)
Rav4 is a good choice
Cant stand Toyota's vehicle designs. Style i like Nissan, but overall Totota has higher quality. However Scotty Kilmer says these new Rav4s are crap.
Toyota is more reliable
Rogue - Good interior, comfort and smooth riding.
RAV4 - Reliability, better resale and good mpgs on hybrid trims.
What I understood after reading the comments from most of the reviews is..though RAV4 and CRV are the best selling cars but still Rogue and CX5 have a separate fan bases and they like those cars so much for their own reasons 😊
Jeff you still work for Toyota?
You buy the Toyota, always. The Nissan is alright, but then you still buy the Toyota. Better resale, better reliability, better designed and engineered. You get the Nissan because you inherited it! 😅
Im torn.. I love the look and features of the Rogue but the reliability and longevity of the RAV4. In context, I can easily put 100000 miles on it within a few years.
The one without CVT
The Rav 4 is FUGLY! The Rogue looks hip and fresh. The Rav 4 looks old and dated.
Nissan wins until the moment the CVT breaks...
Toyota's dependable for 200,000 miles easy Nissan I have to research
I would pick Rogue if not for the recent class action lawsuit. This new engine seems to have some problems with gas smell/oil dilution. Hopefully, Nissan will do something about it quickly and I will be able to change my mind.
all the lawsuits are 2018 and older just be nice to your cvt and it will be nice to you. And I have NO relationship to Nissan whatsoever. I just googled when I read your comment.
I know some people complained about it but I never had any such smell with my 2023 Rogue.
@froofycat I posted link to the lawsuit but it was removed. So I'm not going to do it again. It can be easily found. And it includes 2023 Rogue.
This is true. My 2023 Platinum Rogue has a gas smell. There was a hose change that was supposed to be a fix. The smell while idle is gone but in the garage is not. It is much less but still there. Apparently they are still working on it as they know it doesn’t help all Rogues so I’m still hoping. Fingers crossed because I LOVE it.
Jeff, The RAV4 Hybrid is the clear winner.
Thx sir
Unfortunately Nissan has lost so much ground since the 70’s. I don’t see them ever catching up again. Long term not many Nissan vehicles keep high values like a Toyota does. The 240Z & Roadster days of the 60’s & 70’s are long gone.
Well, there are many people who buy vehicles to enjoy them (Nissan) and there are others who buy because they plan to sell them quickly (Toyota)
The Rogue looks like it's smiling. The RAV4 looks like a scowl.
The Rogue is obviously better overall but Toyota is much better at marketing and protecting their brand, giving people the impression their vehicles are more reliable.
That’s because Toyota is more reliable. How many Nissans do you see with over 300,000 miles
@@fallguy4209 ...a lot, actually. While Nissan has had their ups and downs with CVT, prior to the CVT era, their cars were every bit as reliable. In the past Toyota's maintained great reliability for their engines and transmissions, but everything else on them used to break down, from the stereos to the horns, to the cheaply made bumpers.
My 2013 Altima v6 has over 300k, still running strong and fast. The only maintenance was done to it last year was tie rod and lower control arms. My family owns nothing but Nissans since the 80's for the most part all of our cars went over 250k@fallguy4209
Of course the rav wins….rav will be on the road longer
Rogue
Nissan will break before it reaches 100k. Rav4 will probably outlive you.
Rogue gets a lot rust underneath within 2year of being new.
I had a 2019 Rogue AWD SV. No rust at all. I just traded it in for a 2024 SV Rogue FWD premium. The vehicle I had was well taken care of. No problems ever.
That's true, I didn't check underneath but the wheels were rusting faster..I wrote a review about this to Nissan.
Roge