Karen Read murder trial full closing arguments from defense and prosecution
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 19 авг 2024
- Karen Read's defense and the prosecution made their closing arguments in the high-profile Massachusetts murder trial before the jury began deliberations. Read is accused of hitting and killing her Boston police officer boyfriend John O'Keefe in Canton and leaving him to die in the snow.
Alan Jackson did a BRILLIANT job in his closing argument!! I somehow also think a lot of what he said was also in reference to Aunt Bev! “Conflict of interest?! Look the other way” “You have been lied to in this courtroom”! Looking at YOU Aunt Bev! She is an insult to the bench and should NEVER have been allowed to preside over this kangaroo case! Her behavior, along with the Alberts, McCabes, Higgins, and Proctor is just gross!
She is guilty. The evidence is overwhelming. The jurors look for FACTS, not for RUclips and media drama.
@@zbigniewrichard8291the two aren't mutually exclusive
@@SeanHenrichs 100😂😂
Thankyou for uploading this. Sometimes hard to find pure closing arguments without the commentary.
The Prosecutor has proven he has no actual case. Women ONLY fight with men to work things out who they love and care about. ALL of Karen's actions show how much she loves(d) and cares about him. Fifty phone calls? She was panicked he hooked up with another woman especially when it's 5:00 in the am and he still hasn't come home. Then, she panics and goes looking for him. If a woman were looking for her own missing baby she would see that baby. Same reason Karen saw him first.
You’re absolutely right. Women who don’t care anymore don’t fight. But, that’s too subtle and psychologically complex for the average person to understand.
If I ever get falsely accused of a crime, I want the defendant’s lawyer. He’s excellent and leagues above the prosecutor. Btw, I’d vote…not guilty. The evidence is overwhelming.
See Brian Albert squirming in the corner is so satisfying. The corruption by this PD is so obvious it's almost comical. The FEDS needs to get involved and get the truth out of all these crony cops. and put some of them behind bars. This is sickening!!
The prosecuter doesnt even believe his own closing.
Who is reversing in a blizzard at 25 mph ?
Blizzard hadn’t started yet- which is why it was testified to that they could see grass under Mr. OKeefe’s body,
Guilty
She wasn’t reversing at 24 mph! They want to hang their hat on that! But the AARCA guys proved this never happened
@@wyndieyWRONG. The evidence shows several inches of snow under him. Jesus
@@AA-cp8ry Witness at the scene reported that she picked up the victim's phone from the grass underneath him. Perhaps just the language used but whether grass or snow, he landed on top of his phone, it wasn't e.g., in his pocket. Also, didn't Ms Nagel see a large black object '5 - 6 feet long' in the snow, about 2am when she left the party, intoxicated and wasn't the victim covered in snow when found 3 hours later?
My heart just breaks over and over for Officer John O'Keefe's family. I cannot even imagine what they must be going through and thinking during this entire trial.
They think she's guilty.
The Norfolk DA, MSP are so despicable.
This could be anyone!
How many times has this happened and no one even knows.
Change is needed immediately.
Obviously you didn't pay any attention to the trial or the details.She is guilty as sin regardless of whatever the outcome is
@@confused86996wow your confused and have the same nasty 6996 in your name like a little boy.
@@confused86996 why do you think that
@@confused86996She is NOT GUILTY whatsoever.
You sound confused. Must have muted the first 1hr closing.
This timeline is stunning, crystal clear and smooth.
Actually someone sabotaged the 5:23 am entry about the voicemail that Karen Read left John O'Keefe after she saw him on the ground. She was crying and said John was that you? This is what she did between 5:18 am and 5:35 am. And Karen Read turned to Alan Jackson with Duper 's Delight smirk on her face when she saw that the 5:23 am entry on the prosecutor's slide was altered.
And the only time he brings it out is for closing arguments? Would have been nice earlier to keep him from jumping back and forth in time.
😢😢
😅
Who's? Prosecutor, huh ya right! If you believe Karen Reed killed the victim, you clearly didn't watch the entire trial. I did. Prosecution did not meet their burden. At all.
Were is proctor hopefully not working on another case dont worry his cases all open and shut,if a woman in involed he will make his slurs
Lally, How do you live with yourself? You couldn't really believe this crap you are trying to sell these jurors. Shame on you.
Crap?? Really?! He is giving simple timeline FACTS.
His timeline conveniently left out how or what time the car supposedly hit him , not withstanding the actual experts who said he was not hit by a car @@wyndiey
Lally is as crooked as Proctor and aunt Bev! He’s just more boring!
I was asking the same of the defendant.
Shame on YOU for looking at drama and not at indisputable facts.
Shame on you Canton!
And what do you know about the police? Are you part of the netflix film production Company we're all police are bad?
If they jury stays awake through Lallys closing argument they will all gather and make a Novena to thank God they wont have to listen to him any longer. When Lally said,,,, could I have hit him...he left the door open for doubt.
Then the mind spinning instructions from the judge- both days.
@@jeannegarrity4852they are all so crooked! Right down to aunt bev!
Exactly
Yes, what happened?Was the officer got in the car backed up and then killed himself and then blamed it on Karen.That's exactly what happened.Brilliant defense thank you so much for your amazing legal mind
Has anyone considered Karen Reed may have been having panic attacks and a major meltdown that morning ? Which is why she repeatedly asked the same question? Finally, not everyone cries - her outlet at that time seemed to be purely confused adrenaline. Not rational. She was slowly losing the relationship with Mr. O’Keefe, then found him close to dying. Doing mouth to mouth and cpr immediately regardless of all the blood. Isn’t it possible at that point of immense grief Karen lost her sense of self? I don’t see her being vindictive.
TRUE
Exactly, and no one around for support.
JEN PLANTED THOSE WORDS...SHE REPEATS HERSELF ....
Yup, they got to you....
Every time I see someone who’s obviously guilty and on the phone with 911 they do anything but give cpr. They’ll pretend to do it. They’ll say the body is cold and it’s obvious they’re already dead.
Why were the Albert’s allowed in the courtroom? They’ve explained this groups power within the area. And they get to just stare at the jury? This case gets better and better. I hope they find her innocent
Exactly...
It absolutely was the man in the yellow hat.She had nothing to do with it.She doesn't even have a lexus and the lexus doesn't even have any tail lights and you're living on mars
It’s truly unreal!
We are still waiting for the evidence from the Prosecutor all he wants to talk about is there fights which we all have
this case is the standard of reasonable doubt. It will long be used as an example for future cases. I think the only question left to answer is how much of a settlement you think she is going to get after she sues civially
ALAN JACKSON AMERICAS ATTORNEY. ❤
not for me . . . cringeworthy with all his theatrics
Yeah! That woman’s taillight was never in that condition when she left home that morning period! 😂
THE POLICE OFFICER DRIVING BEHIND THE TOW TRUCK WAS UNDER OATH SAYING IT WASNT BROKEN
I wonder who removed her tail light
Why when Karen called Higgins to say John had died why didn’t he call her again? He was hot for her and John was gone . He never called her again …
@@hedykarim3614 Maybe because he (Higgins) was involved with John's death.
@@linngal5yup!!!!!
Didn't hear anything about broken bones. Would think if he was hit by a car he'd have some broken bones.
Just zoom in on Brian Albert in the top right corner during defense statement.... Talk about a guilty conscience! He couldn't stop moving around
If guilty was a person it would be him!!😂
Alan Jackson's closing argument couldnt be more clear. NOT GUILTY!
Why was the judge laughing when she told Mr. Jackson he had five minutes? It feels diminishing
Maybe deliriously happy the case end was in sight.
But then she asked Karen why she’s smiling
The Commonwealth did not prove its case, because it couldn’t. I believe the jury is smart, and will know this. Praying for the truth.
Worst investigation and prosecution in the modern history of trials!
Right. Since OJ Simpson. Though lots of cases not sensationalized like this.
Agreed
LALLY PLEASE DO NOT TRY TO BACK UP MCCABES 🐍🐍
Get the feds out of the police departments .They are going by federal guidelines in the academies they have been doing it for decades . That's what tyrannical governments do . Not all the Police officers are bad either It's gotta stop or God help us all .This trial has hurt the accused and her family the victims family police families all over the state .
It’s hysterical that corrupt Lally wants us to believe that she hit him, left the scene, and then came back hours later to make a grand announcement to everyone that she hit him.🤣
The real criminals are always the cops.
Cop's and proctor and prosecutor should be on trial. I feel bad for the family
I used to feel bad but after today, them having the Alberts behind them, after all the evidence is just discussing.
PROCTOR Already has two cases running now
Wish lally dally would get to the end of this boring closing so i can hear the "judge" tell him he has 5 minutes....but she won't. Ridiculous 🙄
Finally she does!! This "judge" wants this done!
They are truly setting it up to make OJO fanily think they did a great job but sorry so sorry the jury didn't get the message.
This is going to be ugly and there will never be any good outcome.
Nasty people that Albert/Daniels/McCabe most of all.
Coke head bullies will get away with it.
The judge should have recused herself. Absolute disgrace of a "judge"
This was breathtaking to listen to. I love it. I would have clapped if in the courtroom.
The TALL BLUE WALL
I think if Karen presented herself a little likeable, but instead she had zero remorse, no empathy, smirking constantly, that doesn't sit well with a jury looking at you in court everyday. Especially women, I could be wrong, but I bet that is what's happening during the deliberations.
I agree 💯. Karen is both not likable and not guilty.
It's bothersome to me that she has shown zero emotion. When they were showing that video of Karen, running around screaming after finding John, I was visibly upset. She really is an ice princess.
@@Krystal_Kleerall people react differently and is no way a reason to not like someone
@@Krystal_Kleer I am certain her attorney instructed his client to show no emotion at all.
The facts destroy your case Common Wealth.
And finally ~
“Mister Lally, such a continuous personal vendetta is hardly conducive to the dignity of your position as District Attorney. The commonwealth and its witnesses have made totally unsupported accusations against my name and John’s. If any of you have one authentic shred of evidence, just one, let them bring it forth! Otherwise, if one more word of this outrageous calumny reaches my ears, I shall sue! I shall take the commonwealth to the supreme court and I shall sue the Boston, Canton, and Massachusetts State Police! I will not stand quietly by and allow myself to be crucified by a deranged mob of sycophantic morons whose fetid frustration has overcome their judgment! If scandal is to your taste, Mr Lally, I shall give you a feast!“
Karen Reed ~
The Prime of Miss Karen Read
huh
Why did Jen wait 4 mins before calling 911 after locating John?
The audacity of Colin Albert, Brian Albert, Jennifer McCabe, & Ms. Roberts to sit directly behind Paul O’Keefe & Erin O’Keefe & the parents of John O’Keefe.
Why Not???
@@ssssss7816because they killed that man and now are there to bully the victims family! 🤷🏽♀️
You people are crazy. They lost a friend to his crazy girlfriend who got herself Harvey Weinstein and Kevin Spaceys Hollywood attorney to come and clean up his professional reputation by pretending to suddenly care about women.
Intimidation 100%.
@tammyslade1375 yes they all backed up their lexus's at 24 MILES PER HOUR...
@ 01:30:00 ... WHY WOULD KAREN DELETE 2 RING CAMERA VIDEOS @ JOHNS HOUSE THAT WOULD HELP HER LALLY?! 😤
What are you lying about that for?
Reasonable doubt all over the place 😢
Where?
EVERYWHERE
@@Jack-bc5xgthe tail light specific for me. How did it end up like that??? At 4 am we have photos of it almost completely in tact. How did that happen????
@flol-x3q what convinces you
@@Jack-bc5xg SO MUCH reasonable doubt it's a long long list that obviously even if it was looted in alll caps you would refute it.
I have never seen a public trial where every comment section that I have looked at during the trial was so universally on the side of the defendant being innocent. Normally even clearly factually innocent people are facing calls to be publicly executed in town squares. That Karen Read is so clearly supported by the public when accused of murdering a cop says all that needs to be said. And if it started that way and continued to be that way after all so called evidence has been presented, that speaks volumes I think.
Evidence proves she did NOT delete any ring camera videos. Pay better attention please.
Amazing Job #Free Karen Read
Poor Karen! Now, too she needs to move and look over her shoulder constantly and she has done NOTHING. Poor John - how awful/evil I would NOT want to think these people were on the police force that “served and protected” anyone.
Reasonable doubt for sure
If his outside elbow got hit by the vehicle lol. Then how did he get the damage to his arm with no broken elbow ?
Defense Attorney Alan Jackson and his team dismantled the prosecutor's "blue wall" brick by brick using the truth, the forensic science and an unwavering belief in his client's innocence.
There was Jackson giving a brilliant closing argument in hammering home their case to the jury. Hopefully the real perpetrators will be brought to justice.
That said, in another high profile case in Delphi, In, the defense is facing similar elements: a judge that has demonstrated bias, the possibility of a coverup by officials, etc...
I have no doubt that Defense Attorneys' Baldwin and Rozzi will represent their client with the same passion that Alan Jackson demonstrated to his client.... stay tuned.
Dirty, dirty, dirty! oh that’s right, we have to add a dirty😡
Commonwealth Closing Arguments are boring. No meat on the bones. Just a repeat of timeline. Of course, he may not have anything substantial to stay. IMHO
AJ - 2 words REASONABLE DOUBT! You should have focused more on the evidence and less on the cover up
Check out who is sitting in the back row with his smug face it’s Brian
Jen McCabe is to his left. U forgot to mention her. And they are sitting right behind John O'Keefe's family! How dare they!
@@AA-cp8rythe liars
I saw the injuries no way it was done by a car hitting him
Justice for Karen ❤🙏
She fooled all of you!
ALAN JACKSON 👊👍❤️
Superstar FOR REAL. He is the REAL THING.
It’s so offensive that he uses Jesus Christ as a cuss word!
Look up Sandra Birchmore another Canton cop cover up
AJ to the jury..... "You have most powerful tool known to American jurers prudence because you have your vote! No one! Not him! Not the Common Wealth! Not the court can take that from you!"
The jury is now trying to speak out about their vote! The commonwealth is trying to take it away from them!!!
Yo Boston CBS, how is the state presenting a still photo of the snowy tail light in the closing and making it the smoking gun? How? Both sides are talking about the tail light as the smoking gun but not dissecting it. Why not bring the unbiased cop to verify the photo from either side? How is America missing this?
America isn’t missing it, neither will the jury
Dang Attorney Alan Jackson is the best attorney I have ever seen in my entire long life!
Shouldn't lawyers have to take acting lessons? They are the WORST actors!
NO lawyers are not actors nor should they take acting lessons.
Defense absolutely killed that closing argument. I’ve never seen a case with SO MUCH reasonable doubt. #notguilty #setup #cantonPD
Guilty
1:36:00 yeah they bought him shoes. Blah, blah, blah it's a respect thing. Cough cough.....moving on....! HAHA Hilarious how stupid the common wealth is. Defending murderers who are clearly guilty and trying his best and failing to pin it on Karen.
Imo i believe that the jurors in this case are intimidated by the well awareness of the corruption within the state police department and even the Canton Police department. I am pretty sure their decision on the ultimate fate of Karen Read will not be based on the facts in this case but based on the fear of the jurors safety past this trial and the pure fact that an innocent verdict could potentially put them in a vulnerable state with Law enforcement
Lally one of those DEI hires
Damn Alan, save some reasonable doubt for the rest of us.
If I was the prosecutor I would personally be ashamed of myself or id at least be looking for a new job
Alan Jackson the best defense lawyer I ever seen his amazing . He puts love and hard work into it. I Love him ❤😍
ZERO EVIDENCE. Pathetic.
Of a conspiracy. True.
@@stevenprice6957 the officers in that house wiped their SIM cards, redid the basement, gave the dog away. Suspicious?
Right. Recall Mr. Albert Sr. Did not want to disclose anything about the basement doors and had to be asked over and over. Hmm?
8:00
JOHN O'KEEFE WAS IN THE ALBERT'S HOUSE ON JANUARY 29TH.
something happened
KR is NOT GUILTY
Albert sitting opposite the jury isn't intimidating at all...
1:35:57 If I saw my loved one passed out and injured in the snow the first thing I would fear is “ARE THEY DEAD!!?!”
I too wouldn’t be asking “are they okay? “Could they be taking a nap?”
That was such a ridiculous argument because her reaction was obviously one of a woman who was genuinely afraid that her boyfriend who she loves [obviously] may be dead!
You never know what you would do . My family member was a military soldier on a restricted base when 911 happened and when we didn’t hear from him we were thinking is he dead? We didn’t know if he was at the pentagon or outside .
Inverted Video.
Listen don’t you dare blame that dog
Reasonable doubt. Unreasonable doubt. God damn certainty. Woman is innocent of these charges. Period.
He used the same witness who said that she couldn’t have cracked her twilight by bumping johns car to prove he wasn’t hit by Karen. Pretty disingenuous.
phraseology ?!? Are you trying to win at Scrabble?
Good story but only speculation to make jurors have doubts.
Guilty
AJ is manipulating the facts just like he’s accusing others of doing.
I haven't followed this case very closely.
Mainly because the defendant is so unlikable and arrogant.
I really didn't care how things turned out for her.
Reguarding these two closing arguements......
No comparison.
One was precise, passionate, fully engaged, believable, compelling, professional, sucsint, and had composed his closing argument to conclude within the alloted time frame.
Exceptionally well done.
The other was indifferent, seemed board, scattered, misleading, not engaged with the jury, avoided the jury panel., unprofessional, and based on his notes, he had compiled about two or three pages more than he could ever have had time to say within the time allowed.
He ended sloppy and poorly.
He left me with the impression that he didn't enjoy carrying the water for the unspoken murderer/s.
I believe she will be found
NOT GUILTY.
Hopefully she will be required to forfeit her drivers license.
The time line that Lally points out is convincing. I agree Lally’s case is sloppy with a lot of questionable procedures and behavior from the commonwealth case however there is a lot of damning evidence. If you chose to accept the Lallys time line generated from Okeefes phone then it’s gonna be a difficult prove Karen’s innocence. I heard both side based on scientific facts Karen is Innocent. However based on Lallys narrative Karen is guilty. The time line he laid out in the beginning of his closing is very damning for the defense
He left OFF the TIME when KR struck OKeefe! Not on his closing timeline 🤷🏻♀️🤷🏻♀️🤷🏻♀️
22:22
I didn't know this. I missed alot of things.
A vehicle blocked the area they dumped a police officer who they were hoping would finish dying by hypothermia!!!
KR is NOT GUILTY!
Sounds like a brilliant defense. Trump could have used that same speech
Why did they want to cover up so badly ? Maybe one of their friends are guilty .
GUILTY
Guilty
Cover page looks cozy😮
Higgins gone to rehab ..lol he’s trying to save his job and get his retirement. They can’t fire him if he has medical problems
A pet is like a child part of the family and they got rid of her , poor dog losing her family and home she was with them for. 7 years
Emerald tablet 😮is real 1#quote...must what go up must come down
2#quore ..Don't say frivolous things
I can’t call this one.
He’s magnificent so intelligent.
Guilty...
GUILTY
GUILTY!
I can't stand listening to Alan Jackson. He's very annoying imo.
My folder 📂 and evidence disappeared 😮😢
Yes absolutely! If she meant to drive off and leave him dying she wouldnt have been saying I hit him!
Do for BLM not just whites facts
Karen was home do
Was there tears in the long sleeve shirt from dog and did they test marks on arm for dog dna?
No, they did not swab the injuries for DNA.....WHY DIDN'T THEY????
But the holes in the shirt are UNMISTAKABLE. They were made by the teeth of a large dog!
Karen is guilty as sin
Guilty
Read admitting hitting John 4 X
Framingham MCI shortly
She has No soul!!
🤬