Vick should have been on there or a honorable mention at least, he revolutionized running as the Quarterback, first to give the Packers a loss in the playoffs at Lambeau Field, first to have 10,000+ rushing and 30,000+ passing yards in a career, and best comeback season as a quarterback in his first year as a Eagle
This list is absolute shit ahhaa, first off it's just inconsistent. You put Montana at #1, Bradshaw at #7 or 8 meaning you value super bowls but don't put Troy Aikman but then you put Peyton Manning at #2 meaning that you value stats a lot but put Dan Marino outside your top 5 and have Elway inside it and you have Tom Brady at number fucking 3? Brady is arguably statistically better than Manning given that their stats are extremely similar (if you look at how many years they started and compare accordingly) and the only major difference is Manning throwing more interceptions PLUS Brady is tied for most super bowl wins, has been to the most super bowls, has the only unanimous MVP ever, owns all the playoff records, has more goddamn playoff wins than fucking 20 franchises, and despite his career not starting until 2001 while Mannings started in 1998 will in all likelihood break Manning's most wins ever record this fucking year. This list is fucking shit and I lost a lot of respect for this channel.
You can't base QB rankings off one stat. Not one analyst will only look at super bowls, or stats. Its a combo, that's why its this way. If Takenton won a Super Bowl or two, he would be like 5 or 6, his stats were better than many of the other QBs. Bradshaw had ok stats, but two Super bowls. its a combo
Ryan Beattie I'm saying there's no consistency to how they're ranked.. Like Brett Favre was arguably a better playoff QB than Manning and has similarly ridiculous statistics but is ranked #6 to mannings #2. And Bradshaw had 4 super bowls and had terrible stats. Given Peyton Manning atrocious super bowl performances and his consistent choking in the playoffs having him #2 is ridiculous. It's Brady and Montana at 1 and 2 (which is which can be debated) then from there there's room for others. I'd probably put Elway at 3 then Marino at 4. This list just has absolutely no consistency in how it's ranked and is extremely biased towards Manning. Talking about Brady - "Hasn't been bad," fails to mention his best win % of all time for QBs, fails to mention his top 4 spots in career passing stats, his record setting 2011 and 2007 seasons, his most SB appearances of all time, and his absurd amount of playoff wins.. Talking about Manning - "This guy is so good, his last season which was statistically his worst, wound up being a super bowl championship" Due to his all-time great defense he fails to mention. Peyton Manning is not arguable the greatest QB of all time, it is ridiculous to say so. It's Brady or Montana (in the SB era) and then everybody else.
+Tactical Shooter the qb role is to throw the football to his recivers and te so u tellin me its his fault if there droppin passes in a sb no its the recvers and te fault thats what i mean by team stat
+Tactical Shooter and a qb dosent nessicarily lead the team there are good teams that have rb lead like Minnesota teddy is good but he aint all that and ap is there leadee
I dont know why people rate QB's by the # of Bowls or titles they've won. SBowl win rate is no way to judge a QB. The QB's leadership skills often define a teams overall character but it takes *The entire Team working as one unit, to get the QB to that Super Bowl* With this logical view in mind...the QB PASS %, PASS TD, INTERCEPT RATIO & his TotYdsPassn is how you rate QB's.
Manning is better than Brady and here's why 1. Manning never had as good of a defense/offensive line in Indianapolis that Brady had in New England yet he still put up better numbers 2. Manning had the most dominant rookie season in NFL history while Brady sat on the bench 3. Manning is the all time leader in touchdowns, passing yards, and wins by a QB and has 6 30+ touchdown seasons compared to Brady's 2
There is no way on God's green earth that Peyton Manning is a better quarterback than Tom Brady......no way at all. I was thinking about subscribing to this channel but it's clear you guys have no idea what the hell you're talking about.
Skill-wise,Troy Aikman isn't even a top 20 qb ever.Besides,almost any qb can succeed if they had Emmitt Smith as their RB and Michael Irvin as their WR,not to mention a great O-line. Conclusion:Troy Aikman is overrated,and doesn't deserve to be on this list.
+Dunphy3220 But Montanna had the better comeback record, played in a different era, etc. Put Montanna in today's league and he would stand far above everyone else
4-0 just means that Montana and his team weren't good enough to even make it to the Super Bowl. The modern, salary cap era is designed to not have dynasties like in the past. The old 49ers were stacked with the best talent money could buy.
My name's stephen and i love blowing 3-1 leads especially now. He's only 1k yards from breaking all time passing yards and 51 TD passes from breaking all time passing TDs
Best in 2016-2017 Season 1.Tom Brady (I hate him) 2. Aaron Rodgers (Got Shrekt by Atl) 3. Matt Ryan (Mr.Choke) 4.Ben Roethlisberger (Just swag) 5.Dak Presscott (Rookie of the year :D) 6.Russel Wilson (Man) 7.Eli Manning (Tom Brady's Rival) 8.Alex Smith (Lost to all FGS) 9.Drew Brees (Can't make playoffs this time) 10.Kirk Cousins (YOU LIKE DAT!)
Mr. Bighead nope Only in yds but he should be top 5 over there In 2016-17 matt ryan was the best mainly statisticly 2nd in yds 2nd in tds 5 (i guess) in less ints 3rd in comp % 1st in yds/att 1st in passer rating
Riley Comstock the thing about the giants is regardless of how little they win in the future they will always be the 1 team the pats never could Beat in the Superbowl and that's a huge part of Eli Manning's legacy the QB Brady never got the better of
Are you high? Brees is a great quarterback but he's sure as hell not the most accurate I would take Tom Brady Aaron Rodgers Joe Montana Dan Marino Terry Bradshaw Steve Young and Fran Tarkenton before Brees (not in that order though)
Bree’s has the highest completion percentage that’s true, but he’s also thrown 220 interceptions so I would definitely be taking Rodgers who I guarantee u will have WAAAY fewer picks then Brees
Nope someone finally understands how lucky Brady is and how UNlucky Peyton is. Everyone probably (and you'll probably try to use this as a comeback) "he could be 6-0 in Super Bowls", he would have to be even more lucky to get that but he could be 1-5, Malcom Butler saved tom Brady's ass from dropping on everyone else list. And every Pats fan can thank the tuck rule and Vinatari for your rings btw. Meanwhile, Peyton should be 3-1 in SB (he can thank NO Saints and that onside kick). And also everyone says Brady's better because he went in the sixth round, look at the numbers people. Peyton, LeBron, and Ken Griffey Jr. are the only players in major sports to be the number 1 Ovl pick and actually SUCEED those expectations. It's much harder to SUCEED like that bc being drafted #1 Ovl gets you nothing but a bad team and high expectations. Personally total pro sports, I think manning is at #1 but at least u have him over the cheating, whining, lucky Tom Brady. (P.S you wanna argue go ahead)
Alex Hoegler The only reason Peyton has more stats then Brady because he's been there longer but Brady has beat him far more times than Peyton beat Brady beat Peyton 11 times and Peyton beat Brady 6 times
My Top 15: 1. Peyton Manning 2. Dan Marino 3. Tom Brady 4. Brett Favre 5. Drew Brees 6. Johnny Unitas 7. Joe Montana 8. Roger Staubach 9. Otto Graham 10. Warren Moon 11. Aaron Rodgers 12. Ben Roethlisberger 13. Steve Young 14. John Elway 15. Fran Tarkenton Honorable Mentions: Dan Fouts, Kurt Warner, Eli Manning, Donovan McNabb, Drew Bledsoe, Sammy Baugh, Philip Rivers, Bart Starr, Jim Kelly (Based on Indiviual Achievements, winning a SB is a team accomplishment, not an individual one. Dan Marino and Warren Moon > Mark Rypien, Jim McMahon)
Not a bad list but QBs today have their stats padded with new defensive rules so you have to compare eras as well. Switch Brady with Montana, then definitely switch Brees with Elway, and finally switch Marino with Manning.
+greg trust I understand that, and believe me when I tell you I considered it. Which is why I have Marino higher than "stat monsters" like Brees, Rodgers, Favre etc. Pretty much the only reason I had Tom Brady higher than him is because of his consistency, which is top notch. And I have Manning above them both because of the way he revolutionized, so to speak, the QB position. He practically became the coach and I think if he did that back in a Marino or even Unitas or Otto Graham's era, he would've done great still. I could see what you mean about Montana though, and to be honest I really did consider it. Unlike Tom, Joe had never thrown an interception in a Super Bowl, so I think Montana was a better big game QB, slightly. It's just my opinion, but I think Tom is a slightly better all around player than Montana. Then again that can be argued. It's just my opinion but I really am not a big fan of John Elway. He's a fantastic QB no question, and he will always have a spot on a Top 15/10 list, but I really don't think that he's all that. For starters, in the same era he had over 120 less TDs as Marino. My opinion, but I honestly do think that every single one of the QBs I listed above Elway are better than him. Again, he's great, but I just don't think he's the greatest. Another reason I won't switch him and Drew is that TD streak Drew had (which was broken a few weeks after beating Unitas' record), which made me put him above Unitas on the list. Say what you will about rule changes, but that's one record/stat nobody can deny. If you have a different opinion than me that's fine, thank you for complimenting my list, I just wanted to explain my reasons for putting the QBs the way they are.
Why is bart start not considered a goat he won a total of SEVEN championships (2 SBs) (5 NFL championships) more than brady and montana... I don't understand why he is not the GOAT
Starr lead the league in Completion Percentage 4 times and Passer Rating 4 times and a few other things here and there as well. Won an MVP, 1st team All Pro once and 2nd team twice and was on the HOF All 60s team. However to the original post he won 5 championships. You don't double count the NFL championship and Super Bowl in 66 and 67.
Comparing earlier players is difficult, so i'm just gonna go post-1980 1. Peyton Manning 2. Steve Young(yes, not a typo, I have him over Joe cool) 3. Tom Brady 4. John Elway 5. Dan Marino 6. Joe Montana 7. Aaron Rodgers 8. Drew Brees 9. Brett Favre 10. Warren Moon
This is so incorrect my list goes 1. Has to be RG3 2. Guy who stays out of trouble Johnny Football 3. The guy who never gets hurt Sam Bradford 4. How could you forget Ryan Leaf. 5. Last but certainly not least, Mr. Geno Smith
Nope this is we’re it is even now Manning’s clearly much better. Manning has had 5 coaches and won 2 Super Bowls. Brady only had to get used to a new coach once yes he won that year but he wasn’t the reason they won it was the defense. Also the colts without manning are 2-14 and the pats without Brady are 11-5
@@fse2520 www.footballperspective.com/after-17-head-to-head-matchups-a-bradymanning-statistical-analysis/ Brady has won more despite playing worse than Manning. The statistics prove it.
kingolight Farves best receivers were Antonio Freeman and arguably Donald driver, they were good but they didn't compare to Brady's options. The Patriots didn't win 5 superbowls because of Tom Brady. Brady is overrated and Farve was better than brady was in his prime.
Tom Brady's only great WR was Randy Moss and maybe Gronk when he's healthy when Brady won his first 3 his best receiver was Troy Brown then when you gave him Randy Moss he had the greatest single season by a QB ever and went 18-0 and threw 50 TDs. and Brady won the Super Bowl without Gronk this past year and came back from down 25 points. Favre would always throw interceptions in big spots like the 07 and 09 Championship games and he seemed to always choke in the playoffs and not win when it counted I don't know maybe I'm biased because I only saw Favre at the end of his career and I'm a Patriots fan I don't know though.
My top 10 qbs of all time 1. John Elway 2. Brett Favre 3. Peyton Manning 4. Joe Montana 5. Roger Staubach 6. Aaron Rodgers 7. Dan Marino 8. Johnny Unitas 9. Tom Brady 10. Fran Tarkenton
Is it just me or does it seem too much of a coincidence that number 13 on this list (drew brees) wears number 9 and number 9 on this list (dan marino) wears number 13
+Gary Davidson I'm not saying he's the worst he just doesn't deserve 3rd to me there are so many QBs that are in the list that should be higher on the list them him because they aren't know for being a cheating d bag
Peyton can pass for 5,000 yards anytime, but he cracks like an Egg in the biggest games, he won a SB with the lowest passing total and rating in history, why because they gave their Poster boy a Big game cause he couldn't get it himself, to get there, Brady was driving down field, ready to score the Winning TD and threw and INT, yea right, how about setup, he already had his, it was time to give one to Peyton, give me anyone in that top 15 against Peyton in the Big game and I take all other 14, as peyton would be lucky to win 1 or 2 if that out of 14 games against them, he out thinks himself and just cracks in the big ones, I've watched him for years on the sidelines after making that critical mistake, he just looks confused as to why and how it happens, and Favre is too high, he is too risky, he has a tendency to throw that big INT if he is behind and that would happen against at least the top 10, I put him out of the top 10.
ScaryFountain95 NFLFanboy21 Going to 4 and winning all 4 is not as good as going to 6 and losing 2. Brady doesn't hold records cause he didn't start till his second year and he got injured for an entire season (BTW congrats on the SB win I was very happy when the Broncos shut Cam Newton up).
+LRG Rijkes Hes the most slept on QB in the league. Pretty sure he is the only QB in the league that threw over 300 yards both times he played the #1 defense in the league
(p.s. i copy and paste this whenever i see a patriot bandwagon.) Brady is top ten, hands down, but. Im sorry. Its not him. Its his powerhouse recieving units, Concrete o-line, and a hawk of a db unit. Plus, deflate gate and spygate
Manning was better than Brady. Stat-Wise. Did anyone tell y'all it was more of Bills coaching that y'all won a lot? Explaining that the patriots went 3-1 without Brady.
Blue Hendrix you didn't say it was a team effort you said it was bill who led us. I do agree a little bit, Bill has a great system from qbs but Brady is a huge reason for our success.
Matthew Carpenter most games with 300+ yards most TD passes in a game most consecutive games with a td pass highest completion rate in a season most seasons with 5000+ yards most consecutive games with 20+ completions most consecutive seasons with 4,000+ yards most consecutive seasons with 5,000+ yards most pass attempts in the playoff without an interception all time leader in completion percentage fastest to reach 40,000 50,000 and 60,000 yards most seasons leading in passing yards and the list is still longer
Taylor Suarez Samuel Donlon NFL career passing touchdown record: 539 Most passing yards, career: 71,940 Single season touchdown record (2013): 55 Most passing yards, season (2013): 5,477 Most wins (including playoffs): 200 Most games throwing for 300+ yards: 93 Most passing touchdowns in a single game (tied, 2013): 7 Most games with a passing rating higher than 105: 97 Most games with a perfect passer rating of 158.3: 5 Most seasons with 350+ completions: 10 Most games completing 80-percent passing: 19 Most game-winning drives: 56 Most comeback wins: 45 Highest completion percentage in a postseason game with 450+ yards (2005): 81.8 Highest yards-per-game in a season 342.31 Most games with 4+ touchdown passes: 25 Most seasons passing for 4,000+ yards: 14 Most consecutive seasons with 25+ touchdowns: 13 One of two quarterbacks to ever beat all 32 teams (along with Brett Favre) First quarterback to beat 31 franchises Most Associated Press NFL MVP awards: 5
How you put Peyton Manning over Tom Brady hahahahaha, hahahahaha again, whoever made this Video get off the CRACK!!! It's 2018 November and Tom Brady's still getting it done and is showing no signs of slowing down. Number 1 Quarterback in the History of the N.F.L. TOM BRADY, ✋ Hands Down.
Terry Bradshaw, Roger Staubach, Sammy Baugh, Otto Graham, Brett Favre, Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, Joe Montana, Steve Young, Bart Starr Just 10 good quarterbacks, i missed some i know, and some are in the video, but i think these would fit well in this list ;)
Ronald Soto If you look at Tom Brady's stats compared to Joe Montana, he blows Joe Montana out of the park. Plus, Joe Montana had Jerry Rice who is arguably the best receiver to ever play. Tom Brady didn't have a receiver like Rice besides Randy Moss, but he had him for a couple of years. Even with mediocre recievers, Tom Brady makes them great.
and still has better stats. People just can't stand the fact that he is a successful quarterback. He came out of the 6th round being a nobody and working hard to becoming someone who people talk about.
+Andre Latulippe First off, if you're going to make any argument at all, make sure that if you use an abbreviation that you capitalize the letters. The Rights of Goats Union is appalled that you would compare a whiney and sissy football player to them. Secondly, punctuation is also key in making a strong argument. Here's an example: "The idea that Tom Brady could ever be the best quarterback ever is completely ludicrous. If he were the greatest, wouldn't you think that he would've won his Super Bowls by an enormous amount of points, rather than having to rely on the place kicker or poor play calling by the opponent in the closing seconds of the game? Peyton Manning's intelligence and skill are just a few of the reasons he is the greatest of all time(GOAT). He holds almost every record that can be held by a quarterback, even the ones analysts believed could never be broken. He built a team from the lowest it can be into Super Bowl champions pretty much own his own. He has also never been on a team that has been investigated for cheating...twice."
Nodin Elm I wish that someone could talk some sense into Brady fan girls, but I don’t think you can put some sense in to someone who likes the Patriots
MemeGod get over it he’s not the GOAT. If you take away every NFL player’s rings Manning would be the GOAT I personally agree with the top 3 or 4 people on this list.
Christian Maxwell eh. Probably not. The only reason he's as famous as he is is because of that last name. If it weren't for his father and brother, he wouldn't be anywhere near as famous as he is.
1. Brady
2. Montana
3. P. Manning
4. Favre
5. Brees
6. Rodgers
7. Aikmen
8. Young
9. Marino
10. Bradshaw
11. Staughbach
12. Roethlisberger
13. Warner
14. Kelly
15. Elway
Disgusting that you put Joe in a Chiefs uniform as the first image when you introduced him.
Agreed! #BoltUp
El good Hombre agreed
El good Hombre k
LOL Kansas Kool. Joe Arrowhead. Montana East. Mr. Red n White. The Prairie Pass King. LOL
El very mucho bad Hombre so true
1. Johnny Manziel 2. Ryan Fitzpatrick 3.Ezekeil Elliot 4. Ryan Leaf 5. The Whole Texans Franchise
Mc I agree
you're a moron
You forgot tyreek hill against the broncos this year
Yes
Also add arg 3 and Trent Richardson
Brady: I came back from 25 points in a super bowl. you've never done that Joe.
Joe: I wouldn't have my team in that situation
Pr0 LegeNDD lol
Greatest comment ever
Joe: Im undefeated in the Super Bowl
Brady: that’s cause you lose before the super bowl
Without Edelman Brady is 💩
Without Edelman, gronk, the Defense!!! What is Brady?
Vick should have been on there or a honorable mention at least, he revolutionized running as the Quarterback, first to give the Packers a loss in the playoffs at Lambeau Field, first to have 10,000+ rushing and 30,000+ passing yards in a career, and best comeback season as a quarterback in his first year as a Eagle
gtfo
+TheFantom51 "Woof!"
Lmao Gtfo. Vick overrated As fuck
***** Ikr
+TheFantom51 Leave
Bree’s needs to be higher
Your not really Alvin Kamara right?
And Rodgers
This list is absolute shit ahhaa, first off it's just inconsistent. You put Montana at #1, Bradshaw at #7 or 8 meaning you value super bowls but don't put Troy Aikman but then you put Peyton Manning at #2 meaning that you value stats a lot but put Dan Marino outside your top 5 and have Elway inside it and you have Tom Brady at number fucking 3? Brady is arguably statistically better than Manning given that their stats are extremely similar (if you look at how many years they started and compare accordingly) and the only major difference is Manning throwing more interceptions PLUS Brady is tied for most super bowl wins, has been to the most super bowls, has the only unanimous MVP ever, owns all the playoff records, has more goddamn playoff wins than fucking 20 franchises, and despite his career not starting until 2001 while Mannings started in 1998 will in all likelihood break Manning's most wins ever record this fucking year. This list is fucking shit and I lost a lot of respect for this channel.
Lmao and he couldn't even get Brady's stats right. "Two Super Bowl mvps"
+G-FORCE / GJLCurtis01 3
stole my words
You can't base QB rankings off one stat. Not one analyst will only look at super bowls, or stats. Its a combo, that's why its this way. If Takenton won a Super Bowl or two, he would be like 5 or 6, his stats were better than many of the other QBs. Bradshaw had ok stats, but two Super bowls. its a combo
Ryan Beattie I'm saying there's no consistency to how they're ranked.. Like Brett Favre was arguably a better playoff QB than Manning and has similarly ridiculous statistics but is ranked #6 to mannings #2. And Bradshaw had 4 super bowls and had terrible stats. Given Peyton Manning atrocious super bowl performances and his consistent choking in the playoffs having him #2 is ridiculous. It's Brady and Montana at 1 and 2 (which is which can be debated) then from there there's room for others. I'd probably put Elway at 3 then Marino at 4. This list just has absolutely no consistency in how it's ranked and is extremely biased towards Manning. Talking about Brady - "Hasn't been bad," fails to mention his best win % of all time for QBs, fails to mention his top 4 spots in career passing stats, his record setting 2011 and 2007 seasons, his most SB appearances of all time, and his absurd amount of playoff wins.. Talking about Manning - "This guy is so good, his last season which was statistically his worst, wound up being a super bowl championship" Due to his all-time great defense he fails to mention. Peyton Manning is not arguable the greatest QB of all time, it is ridiculous to say so. It's Brady or Montana (in the SB era) and then everybody else.
Where's Sammy Baugh? He played QB, S, and K and played until he was 47. He has to deserve a honorable mention.
Trevor Stephens he's the most underrated player ever
No Troy Aikman?
And John Elway sucks
I know right
JJ Haddad true
I admit Troy should be on there but no Elway don't suck. He was a good QB just got dumped on in the Super Bowls until the last two.
JJ Haddad I agree
Rings don't determine whether you are the best quarterback. It's stats
Yea
rings are a team stat not a player stat
+Aaron Rodgers #Adeezy #thereala-rod #12hunnit the qb's role is to lead the team rings make a qb
+Tactical Shooter the qb role is to throw the football to his recivers and te so u tellin me its his fault if there droppin passes in a sb no its the recvers and te fault thats what i mean by team stat
+Tactical Shooter and a qb dosent nessicarily lead the team there are good teams that have rb lead like Minnesota teddy is good but he aint all that and ap is there leadee
I dont know why people rate QB's by the # of Bowls or titles they've won. SBowl win rate is no way to judge a QB. The QB's leadership skills often define a teams overall character but it takes *The entire Team working as one unit, to get the QB to that Super Bowl* With this logical view in mind...the QB PASS %, PASS TD, INTERCEPT RATIO & his TotYdsPassn is how you rate QB's.
Then Brees would be 1 or 2
Nova 2x Possibility in 10 yrs.
Nova 2x But, Young, Favre, Manning, Marino & Brady will be tough to surpass.
very true. much true
so super bowls don't matter uh yeah it does matter cause who will pass the best kicker will though off every time all maters
Rodgers is 14th and Brees is 13th wtf they should be higher, brady isnt number one
Why all these pats fans making fake accounts saying there fans of other teams that think Brady's the goat, y'all not fooling no one.
andromeda gen lol laughed so hard at this
I'm so happy that Peyton Manning was above Tom, I hate Tom and I love the Broncos
You like him but that doesn't make him the 2nd best.
That my friend is being biased and Tom will always be better than Manning whether you like it or not
Manning isnt better.
TPS just hates the patriots. Tom is the best. That's why he is called " The Goat "
Greatest
Of
All
Time
Manning is better than Brady and here's why
1. Manning never had as good of a defense/offensive line in Indianapolis that Brady had in New England yet he still put up better numbers
2. Manning had the most dominant rookie season in NFL history while Brady sat on the bench
3. Manning is the all time leader in touchdowns, passing yards, and wins by a QB and has 6 30+ touchdown seasons compared to Brady's 2
Excatly
Brady sat on the bench because no one knew the potential that Brady had.
Also Brady had a worse offense when he started and still won the Super Bowl
+UTubezGaming But that Defense
Peyton manning did have the Denver defense last year
Josh McCown top QB of all time. Like if you (dis)agree.
My Top 151. Brady, 2. Montana, 3. Staubach, 4. Elway 5. Marino 6. Favre 7. Manning 8. Aikman 9. Bradshaw 10. Rodgers 11. Moon 12. Unitas 13. Young 14. Brees 15. Graham
Stoner?
You have to have Tarkenton there. He has better stats than half of them and reinvented the QB position
+Ryan Beattie
yea, and johnny unitas is the GOAT.
It's true tom is awesome
ok
I'm that one bears fan who actually thinks Farve is the best...😰
Nayr same except I’m a Cowboys fan
There is no way on God's green earth that Peyton Manning is a better quarterback than Tom Brady......no way at all. I was thinking about subscribing to this channel but it's clear you guys have no idea what the hell you're talking about.
There is
For all of those who dislike, remember that this video was uplouded 4 years ago
where the hell is Troy Aikman!?
Daniel Hawkins they are haters that's why. We know Troy Aikman deserves to be on this list
BOIII, he was the Cowboys best QB. In the 1990
I agree
Skill-wise,Troy Aikman isn't even a top 20 qb ever.Besides,almost any qb can succeed if they had Emmitt Smith as their RB and Michael Irvin as their WR,not to mention a great O-line.
Conclusion:Troy Aikman is overrated,and doesn't deserve to be on this list.
Aikmen is better than stauchback
How is Montana ranked better than Manning but Brady isn't Brady has better stats than Montana with same amount of rings smh stupid list
***** Stfu
+Chance Flint that 4-2 record just means that he has more super bowl appearances then Montana
+Dunphy3220 But Montanna had the better comeback record, played in a different era, etc. Put Montanna in today's league and he would stand far above everyone else
They played in two different eras and the nfl today is way more pass happy and more wr friendly
4-0 just means that Montana and his team weren't good enough to even make it to the Super Bowl. The modern, salary cap era is designed to not have dynasties like in the past. The old 49ers were stacked with the best talent money could buy.
No Jim Kelly? I'm a lifelong Packers fan but dude.......the hell?
GreenAndGold4-12 I was thinking that too
Your rankings are screwed up. Also where is Troy Aikman with 3 rings ?
Tom first i'm a Giants fan and I now this he's the best I've ever seen
Thank you that's why I like objective Giants fans majority of them will say he's not
+Juwle Teah ok i hate tom brady and im a giants fan but i think he should be 2nd Joe Montana is best but Peyton Manning just racked up stats
Michael Vick was Better than tom brady
+Archer 505 are you kidding me?! "just racked up stats" cause that's so fuckin easy to do. idiot
What are you 5?
Switch brees and Bradshaw. Also after Super Bowl 51 there's no doubt Brady is #1
1. brady quinn 2. tim tebow 3. kirk cousins 4. troy smith and # 5 that badddd mannnn jamarcus russell
lol oh man.
Ballin Too you can't have a top 5 without favre
Ballin Too lololloloololololololololololololol
Kirk cousins in that list is a joke
NoisyOne HD so is Tim Tebow
Update: Drew Brees is likely going to beat the records set by Peyton Manning.
Has
@@DrPhil-fn1mv I posted this 2 years ago. Please...
No correction was needed.
@@WesGTheFootballGuy I was just saying that he already has
Update: Tom Brady has now broken those records.
@@BrentBridgeman He’s also played 2 more seasons… With more consistent teams… And less injuries…
Sorry, had to dislike. We all know that Ryan Leaf was the G.O.A.T.
Lmfao
Mark Sanchez dumb ass
+J.J.Watt #Can't Escape From Me #99 HA!!! WHAT A NERD!!! HE THINKS MARK SANCHEZ IS THE GREATEST EVER, WE ALL KNOW KYRIE IRVING IS THE G.O.A.T LOL
No joe Montana
Anthony longoria You forgot Johnny Manziel
Talk about a tough list, only 15 spots to squeeze so many names
Brady at 3 is just disrespectful
This channel must really hate the Patriots and Brady
+Kevin Kwak probably. I understand Montana, but Peyton? Noo
I agree he shouldn't even be on the list
+AustinKills this comment is what dislike buttons are for haha
This list is perfect joe Montana is the best ab of all time and Peyton manning is better than tom brady
I would like you to do a video of the best quarterback from each team in the NFL
1. Brady 2. Montana 3. Peyton 4. Marino 5. Favre 6. Unitas 7. Elway 8. Bradshaw 9. Staubach 10. Young
yep
nope
you forgot donavan McNabb
Brady is the third best of all time Peyton and Montana
+Madden mobile Pick6 No, Brady is like the 9th.
Brees is top 5
My name's stephen and i love blowing 3-1 leads especially now. He's only 1k yards from breaking all time passing yards and 51 TD passes from breaking all time passing TDs
Should be number one
My name's stephen and i love blowing 3-1 leads true
Yea
No he's not
How about Len Dawson?
Best in 2016-2017 Season
1.Tom Brady (I hate him)
2. Aaron Rodgers (Got Shrekt by Atl)
3. Matt Ryan (Mr.Choke)
4.Ben Roethlisberger (Just swag)
5.Dak Presscott (Rookie of the year :D)
6.Russel Wilson (Man)
7.Eli Manning (Tom Brady's Rival)
8.Alex Smith (Lost to all FGS)
9.Drew Brees (Can't make playoffs this time)
10.Kirk Cousins (YOU LIKE DAT!)
Brees at number 9 HOLD THIS L
Riley Comstock statistically drew was #1
Mr. Bighead nope
Only in yds but he should be top 5 over there
In 2016-17 matt ryan was the best mainly statisticly
2nd in yds
2nd in tds
5 (i guess) in less ints
3rd in comp %
1st in yds/att
1st in passer rating
Riley Comstock the thing about the giants is regardless of how little they win in the future they will always be the 1 team the pats never could Beat in the Superbowl and that's a huge part of Eli Manning's legacy the QB Brady never got the better of
Derek Carr? Man could’ve gone farther if he didn’t get injured
#1-15: Montana, *Brady, Unitas, Favre, Manning, Graham, Elway, Young, Staubach, Aikman, Marino, Moon, Tarkington, *Rodgers, Griese; **#16-32**: *Brees, *Rothlisberger, *R. Wilson, Bledsoe, Luckman, Starr, Bradshaw, *Newton, Kelly, Stabler, Simms, Warner, *E. Manning, *Rivers, McNabb, Fouts, *Palmer...(* = Active)
Is that of all time...?
How is manning not better than favre?
your list is just completely wrong
bruh palmer should be way up there
That's terrible silly pats fan. Unitas has to be #1, plain and simple.
Brees should be higher, he's the single most accurate quarterback to ever play...
Are you high? Brees is a great quarterback but he's sure as hell not the most accurate I would take Tom Brady Aaron Rodgers Joe Montana Dan Marino Terry Bradshaw Steve Young and Fran Tarkenton before Brees (not in that order though)
Scrub Lord12 dude drew should be at least #6
Jason Lestander you're a saints fan obviously
Scrub Lord12 he’s literally the most accurate qb ever dumbass. Look it up fuckwad.
Bree’s has the highest completion percentage that’s true, but he’s also thrown 220 interceptions so I would definitely be taking Rodgers who I guarantee u will have WAAAY fewer picks then Brees
1.tom Brady
2.joe Montana
3.terry Bradshaw
4.bart Starr
5.jonny Unitas
well now that..was a damn good list. thank you.
Come on man you and me both know Tom Brady is better than Peyton Manning
^
+Question Guy?!? Not what the video says. So I don't think everyone agrees with you.
Nope someone finally understands how lucky Brady is and how UNlucky Peyton is. Everyone probably (and you'll probably try to use this as a comeback) "he could be 6-0 in Super Bowls", he would have to be even more lucky to get that but he could be 1-5, Malcom Butler saved tom Brady's ass from dropping on everyone else list. And every Pats fan can thank the tuck rule and Vinatari for your rings btw. Meanwhile, Peyton should be 3-1 in SB (he can thank NO Saints and that onside kick). And also everyone says Brady's better because he went in the sixth round, look at the numbers people. Peyton, LeBron, and Ken Griffey Jr. are the only players in major sports to be the number 1 Ovl pick and actually SUCEED those expectations. It's much harder to SUCEED like that bc being drafted #1 Ovl gets you nothing but a bad team and high expectations. Personally total pro sports, I think manning is at #1 but at least u have him over the cheating, whining, lucky Tom Brady. (P.S you wanna argue go ahead)
Alex Hoegler The only reason Peyton has more stats then Brady because he's been there longer but Brady has beat him far more times than Peyton beat Brady beat Peyton 11 times and Peyton beat Brady 6 times
Dude Perfect Jr. Thing is this
Brady 11
Peyton 6
My Top 15: 1. Peyton Manning
2. Dan Marino
3. Tom Brady
4. Brett Favre
5. Drew Brees
6. Johnny Unitas
7. Joe Montana
8. Roger Staubach
9. Otto Graham
10. Warren Moon
11. Aaron Rodgers
12. Ben Roethlisberger
13. Steve Young
14. John Elway
15. Fran Tarkenton
Honorable Mentions: Dan Fouts, Kurt Warner, Eli Manning, Donovan McNabb, Drew Bledsoe, Sammy Baugh, Philip Rivers, Bart Starr, Jim Kelly
(Based on Indiviual Achievements, winning a SB is a team accomplishment, not an individual one. Dan Marino and Warren Moon > Mark Rypien, Jim McMahon)
So happy you put Warren Moon on there.
+Jaune Arc Thank you, I think he's overlooked
Not a bad list but QBs today have their stats padded with new defensive rules so you have to compare eras as well. Switch Brady with Montana, then definitely switch Brees with Elway, and finally switch Marino with Manning.
+greg trust I understand that, and believe me when I tell you I considered it. Which is why I have Marino higher than "stat monsters" like Brees, Rodgers, Favre etc. Pretty much the only reason I had Tom Brady higher than him is because of his consistency, which is top notch. And I have Manning above them both because of the way he revolutionized, so to speak, the QB position. He practically became the coach and I think if he did that back in a Marino or even Unitas or Otto Graham's era, he would've done great still.
I could see what you mean about Montana though, and to be honest I really did consider it. Unlike Tom, Joe had never thrown an interception in a Super Bowl, so I think Montana was a better big game QB, slightly. It's just my opinion, but I think Tom is a slightly better all around player than Montana. Then again that can be argued.
It's just my opinion but I really am not a big fan of John Elway. He's a fantastic QB no question, and he will always have a spot on a Top 15/10 list, but I really don't think that he's all that. For starters, in the same era he had over 120 less TDs as Marino. My opinion, but I honestly do think that every single one of the QBs I listed above Elway are better than him. Again, he's great, but I just don't think he's the greatest. Another reason I won't switch him and Drew is that TD streak Drew had (which was broken a few weeks after beating Unitas' record), which made me put him above Unitas on the list. Say what you will about rule changes, but that's one record/stat nobody can deny.
If you have a different opinion than me that's fine, thank you for complimenting my list, I just wanted to explain my reasons for putting the QBs the way they are.
+greg trust Sorry for putting a huge paragraph, I just wanted to put what I was thinking when I made a that list. And I stand by it.
Why is bart start not considered a goat he won a total of SEVEN championships (2 SBs) (5 NFL championships) more than brady and montana... I don't understand why he is not the GOAT
Starr lead the league in Completion Percentage 4 times and Passer Rating 4 times and a few other things here and there as well.
Won an MVP, 1st team All Pro once and 2nd team twice and was on the HOF All 60s team.
However to the original post he won 5 championships. You don't double count the NFL championship and Super Bowl in 66 and 67.
He had some of the best teams ever
Comparing earlier players is difficult, so i'm just gonna go post-1980
1. Peyton Manning
2. Steve Young(yes, not a typo, I have him over Joe cool)
3. Tom Brady
4. John Elway
5. Dan Marino
6. Joe Montana
7. Aaron Rodgers
8. Drew Brees
9. Brett Favre
10. Warren Moon
I thought mike Vick would be in like top 5 but not even top 15 wow
This is so incorrect my list goes 1. Has to be RG3 2. Guy who stays out of trouble Johnny Football 3. The guy who never gets hurt Sam Bradford 4. How could you forget Ryan Leaf. 5. Last but certainly not least, Mr. Geno Smith
What about Tim Tebow??
you forget Kapernick
Jamarcus Russel?
Lmao
tim tebow?
Where the heck was Troy Aikman?
Jorge Barbosa Troy Aikman deserves to be on this list
Top ten Runningbacks of all time or top ten defensive players of all time. You'd get a lot of likes and hits either way!
Top 5
1.Tom Brady
2. Brett Favre
3. Joe Montana
4. Peyton Manning
5. Dan Marino
6. Drew Brees
Switch Joe and Farve
Peyton Manning is b t b
Top 5
1. Brett Favre
2. Joe Montana
3. Johnny Unitas
4. Aaron Rodgers
5. John Elway
Switch Montana and Brady and switch Favre with Manning then it’s perfect
Really Aaron Rodgers is the best in NFL history
packer fan here, no, brees is
Aaron Rodgers= GOAT
Drew Brees- OVERRATED
Thought this was crazy, then realized this was made 2 years ago. Brady is clearly established at #1 now.
To the average stupid ass NFL fan, yeah
Nope this is we’re it is even now Manning’s clearly much better. Manning has had 5 coaches and won 2 Super Bowls. Brady only had to get used to a new coach once yes he won that year but he wasn’t the reason they won it was the defense. Also the colts without manning are 2-14 and the pats without Brady are 11-5
Do you edit your Voice? It sounds weird computerish
I put Brady above Peyton, but keep Montana at number 1.
Nah, Manning > brady in the reg and postseason statistically
@@tommyrosati9326 Brady much better in super bowls and in late game moments during the SB/Playoffs
@@fse2520 He is a bit better in super bowls, but performs worse in the playoffs as a whole, even when you put higher weights on super bowl games.
@@tommyrosati9326 Brady has beaten Peyton many times in shootouts
@@fse2520 www.footballperspective.com/after-17-head-to-head-matchups-a-bradymanning-statistical-analysis/
Brady has won more despite playing worse than Manning. The statistics prove it.
10 biggest drops in NFL history
Troy Aikman. No disrespect but he was a better quarterback than Steve Young
Crack is Wack my friend.
I'm glad they didn't put overrated Tom Brady at #1 Go Michael Vick!
Mason Dalbey I agree
This list is the dumbest list Bree's not even top 10
cmfxg ikr
were is warron moon???
yup. bout to comment that too..
Moon, Aikman and Griese...ALL LEGITIMATELY TOP-15! No question about it.
would you trade sonny jurgeson for griese?
Kurt Warner?
I SO AGREE BUT BRADY IS THE BEST
1.Brady
2.Montana
3.Brees
4.Manning
5.Favre
The fuck Brett Farve number five , you smoking
Do a video on best kicker hits on punts kick offs! Like how the Cowboys punter killed the lions returner
Brady over farve??? are you high?
5>1
kingolight Farves best receivers were Antonio Freeman and arguably Donald driver, they were good but they didn't compare to Brady's options. The Patriots didn't win 5 superbowls because of Tom Brady. Brady is overrated and Farve was better than brady was in his prime.
Tom Brady's only great WR was Randy Moss and maybe Gronk when he's healthy when Brady won his first 3 his best receiver was Troy Brown then when you gave him Randy Moss he had the greatest single season by a QB ever and went 18-0 and threw 50 TDs. and Brady won the Super Bowl without Gronk this past year and came back from down 25 points. Favre would always throw interceptions in big spots like the 07 and 09 Championship games and he seemed to always choke in the playoffs and not win when it counted I don't know maybe I'm biased because I only saw Favre at the end of his career and I'm a Patriots fan I don't know though.
kingolight lmao Df those WR are good dipshit
Yomama RBX I know thats what I was saying
Tom Brady should be #1
L
W
y he shit
+DeadlyBluJay he a proven cheater
+Joe Collas What your favorite team?
Johnny Manziel should be number 1.
lol never he's lazy
Dumbass
+batman91500 chill it was a joke
+batman91500 it's just a prank bro the camera is right there ->
Johnny Manziel use to be good now he sucks
My top 10 qbs of all time
1. John Elway
2. Brett Favre
3. Peyton Manning
4. Joe Montana
5. Roger Staubach
6. Aaron Rodgers
7. Dan Marino
8. Johnny Unitas
9. Tom Brady
10. Fran Tarkenton
GCV HAPPY your high I’m a dolphins fan but Brady is the goat
No Aikman that's bs
Matthew Gonzalez agree
I agree
Matthew Gonzalez indeed
Troy Aikman? Randall Cummingham? Michael Vick?
Tem Gaming WTF?
+Ndudi Enwereuzor or Bledsoe or McNabb
Project Plays yeah
WERE IS MIKE VICK,DONOVAN MCNABB
L
what you mean by that?
+PHEONIXTITAN8888 he's saying it shouldn't be
maybe top 20
this isn't madden
Is it just me or does it seem too much of a coincidence that number 13 on this list (drew brees) wears number 9 and number 9 on this list (dan marino) wears number 13
Where is Troy Aikmen 😒😡
Wuble Bubber Troy Aikman deserves to be on this list
TPS are Cowboys haters :(
And jim kelly should be on the list
Tom brady should be first
That cheater shouldn't even have got 3rd joe Montana is a million times better the Brady
I agree Brady is the greatest of all time
+Bronco gaming stop hating
+Gary Davidson I'm not saying he's the worst he just doesn't deserve 3rd to me there are so many QBs that are in the list that should be higher on the list them him because they aren't know for being a cheating d bag
+Panda Man what you been smoking
Brady is better than Montana and Manning
No, Montana never lost a super bowl unlike Brady, who lost 2 Super Bowls to the Giants and P.Manning holds every single NFL record
Peyton can pass for 5,000 yards anytime, but he cracks like an Egg in the biggest games, he won a SB with the lowest passing total and rating in history, why because they gave their Poster boy a Big game cause he couldn't get it himself, to get there, Brady was driving down field, ready to score the Winning TD and threw and INT, yea right, how about setup, he already had his, it was time to give one to Peyton, give me anyone in that top 15 against Peyton in the Big game and I take all other 14, as peyton would be lucky to win 1 or 2 if that out of 14 games against them, he out thinks himself and just cracks in the big ones, I've watched him for years on the sidelines after making that critical mistake, he just looks confused as to why and how it happens, and Favre is too high, he is too risky, he has a tendency to throw that big INT if he is behind and that would happen against at least the top 10, I put him out of the top 10.
+ScaryFountain95 NFLFanboy21 not the most playoff wins
ScaryFountain95 NFLFanboy21 Going to 4 and winning all 4 is not as good as going to 6 and losing 2. Brady doesn't hold records cause he didn't start till his second year and he got injured for an entire season (BTW congrats on the SB win I was very happy when the Broncos shut Cam Newton up).
+smudge1130 manning also sat out an entire season because of injuries
After Brady fifth ring 💍 He's number 1 right now
first should be Favre
+Aaron Ponce Packers fan... Makes sense!
favre isn't that good
I'm a Vikings fan and I agree
+Total Pro Sports I'm a Vikings fan and I agree
No he should not
YOU MISSED BEN ROETHLISBURGER
Lol
No he didn't
Your kidding, right?
Get the fuck out
+LRG Rijkes Hes the most slept on QB in the league. Pretty sure he is the only QB in the league that threw over 300 yards both times he played the #1 defense in the league
Seriously!!! You won't let go!! Fucking admit it already, Tom Brady is and always will be the best quarterback in nfl history.
SO TRUE
W
ya
(p.s. i copy and paste this whenever i see a patriot bandwagon.) Brady is top ten, hands down, but. Im sorry. Its not him. Its his powerhouse recieving units, Concrete o-line, and a hawk of a db unit. Plus, deflate gate and spygate
The Real JrB Tom had nothing to do with spygate and Tom had only 2 Hall of famers as Receivers 😂
Tom Brady should be #1 on every list, he’s earned it. (Vikings fan)
Manning was better than Brady. Stat-Wise. Did anyone tell y'all it was more of Bills coaching that y'all won a lot? Explaining that the patriots went 3-1 without Brady.
Blue Hendrix their defense is solid and receivers/offensive line are very strong.
D3cline ツ which proves my point that winning Super Bowls are a TEAM effort.
Blue Hendrix you didn't say it was a team effort you said it was bill who led us. I do agree a little bit, Bill has a great system from qbs but Brady is a huge reason for our success.
Dolan Tramp the afc east is trash and thats why the pats get 12 wins every year
Blue Hendrix That doesn't explain why they WIN the super bowl. and they aren't AFC east.
Brees has the most records of any other QB but he isn't the best? Yeah okay.
Peyton Manning has the most records bro
Matthew Carpenter
most games with 300+ yards
most TD passes in a game
most consecutive games with a td pass
highest completion rate in a season
most seasons with 5000+ yards
most consecutive games with 20+ completions
most consecutive seasons with 4,000+ yards
most consecutive seasons with 5,000+ yards
most pass attempts in the playoff without an interception
all time leader in completion percentage
fastest to reach 40,000 50,000 and 60,000 yards
most seasons leading in passing yards
and the list is still longer
+Taylor Suarez Brees steals Payton's records
+Taylor Suarez Brees steals Payton's records
Taylor Suarez Samuel Donlon
NFL career passing touchdown record: 539
Most passing yards, career: 71,940
Single season touchdown record (2013): 55
Most passing yards, season (2013): 5,477
Most wins (including playoffs): 200
Most games throwing for 300+ yards: 93
Most passing touchdowns in a single game (tied, 2013): 7
Most games with a passing rating higher than 105: 97
Most games with a perfect passer rating of 158.3: 5
Most seasons with 350+ completions: 10
Most games completing 80-percent passing: 19
Most game-winning drives: 56
Most comeback wins: 45
Highest completion percentage in a postseason game with 450+ yards (2005): 81.8
Highest yards-per-game in a season 342.31
Most games with 4+ touchdown passes: 25
Most seasons passing for 4,000+ yards: 14
Most consecutive seasons with 25+ touchdowns: 13
One of two quarterbacks to ever beat all 32 teams (along with Brett Favre)
First quarterback to beat 31 franchises
Most Associated Press NFL MVP awards: 5
No Jarmarcis Russel. WTF UN SUBING
he was the worst qb
Jamarcus Russel? Lol u r high
+Der Hedrites ik right mark Sanchez all the way
+Shady ahahahhahahaha that made my day, that was a great joke
wo wo wo Bradys the best here's my list of 3 3.peytonmanning 2 Joe Montana 1tombrady
I think manning is better than Montana
+OdysT Danger but manning can't throw he just can read the defense
+Ken Sparks true
+OdysT Danger Well...
+Carson Chiasson not restarted as u have u watched Peyton play he can't throw as good as J cool or the golden boy
Brady should be first he beat all of joe Montanas records and will ovr pass to passes
did not u freaking idiot
+Jordan Rechal Yes he did you idiot
+Jordan Rechal oh but he did
How you put Peyton Manning over Tom Brady hahahahaha, hahahahaha again, whoever made this Video get off the CRACK!!! It's 2018 November and Tom Brady's still getting it done and is showing no signs of slowing down. Number 1 Quarterback in the History of the N.F.L. TOM BRADY, ✋ Hands Down.
Was juluamaine Brooks I agree Peyton’s good but Brady has much better stats
Brady’s not even top 5
Brady is the most overrated qb i have ever seen
Terry Bradshaw, Roger Staubach, Sammy Baugh, Otto Graham, Brett Favre, Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, Joe Montana, Steve Young, Bart Starr
Just 10 good quarterbacks, i missed some i know, and some are in the video, but i think these would fit well in this list ;)
Peyton Goat
Everybody just stop hating joe Montana will always be the best
No he won't.....
for real
not anymore brady is
Joe Montana is not better than Tom brady
Tom Brady is a bad
+Seth Seay " Tom Brady is a bad " best sentence ever
What joe is so much better than tom just learn about him
Ronald Soto If you look at Tom Brady's stats compared to Joe Montana, he blows Joe Montana out of the park. Plus, Joe Montana had Jerry Rice who is arguably the best receiver to ever play. Tom Brady didn't have a receiver like Rice besides Randy Moss, but he had him for a couple of years. Even with mediocre recievers, Tom Brady makes them great.
and still has better stats. People just can't stand the fact that he is a successful quarterback. He came out of the 6th round being a nobody and working hard to becoming someone who people talk about.
Rivers is not here but yet he has in the top ten stats in all of history
Tom Brady is the goat this video was disrespectful unlike
Lol syke he is a cheater
+Seth Lopez *you're. You're making us Brady haters look bad m4206911.
+Andre Latulippe First off, if you're going to make any argument at all, make sure that if you use an abbreviation that you capitalize the letters. The Rights of Goats Union is appalled that you would compare a whiney and sissy football player to them. Secondly, punctuation is also key in making a strong argument. Here's an example: "The idea that Tom Brady could ever be the best quarterback ever is completely ludicrous. If he were the greatest, wouldn't you think that he would've won his Super Bowls by an enormous amount of points, rather than having to rely on the place kicker or poor play calling by the opponent in the closing seconds of the game? Peyton Manning's intelligence and skill are just a few of the reasons he is the greatest of all time(GOAT). He holds almost every record that can be held by a quarterback, even the ones analysts believed could never be broken. He built a team from the lowest it can be into Super Bowl champions pretty much own his own. He has also never been on a team that has been investigated for cheating...twice."
LOLOLLLLOLOLOLOLOL I'm done:
iiiikkkkrrrrr
Rodgers 14?
the_shantilly I feel like he should be higher on the list
the_shantilly he's bad
Arianna Vega how did you smoke?
Nodin Elm I wish that someone could talk some sense into Brady fan girls, but I don’t think you can put some sense in to someone who likes the Patriots
TPS you definitely could have included Warren Moon, he's a easy top 5
Tony Romo is underrated
DREW BREES THE GOAT
to me Montana is first and Brady second Peyton third
Kenneth Holt , Joe did not play as long as Brady and Joe had to sit out a lot of games because of injuries.
Tom Brady #3 check again
MemeGod get over it he’s not the GOAT. If you take away every NFL player’s rings Manning would be the GOAT I personally agree with the top 3 or 4 people on this list.
Tom Brady stinks
ThatKidWhoLiesAboutHisAge OnTheInternet Tom Brady knows about throwing picks Peyton is better
1. Tom Brady
2. Joe Montana
3. Peyton Manning
I'm about to get slaughtered for this.
1.Peyton Manning
2.Tom Brady
3. Joe Montana
joe cool all the way
@Brandon Rose no
YEAH AARON RODGERS THE G.O.A.T
@Maximos O'Brien no Eli manning is
He bullshited his way around the season and somehow beat tom brady
Also no way favre is worse than fucking johnny unitas
Eli Manning
Racing Blind He won't be a hofer
cowboys_ newz yes eil will be a hall of famer
Christian Maxwell eh. Probably not. The only reason he's as famous as he is is because of that last name. If it weren't for his father and brother, he wouldn't be anywhere near as famous as he is.
Racing Blind Eli Manning sucks
Yeah, Gonna have to update this after the most amazing comeback in Superbowl History...BRADY is #1 Without question, without argument. PERIOD.
1.brett Favre
2.joe Montana
3.jhon elway
4,peyton manning
5,Derrick carr
6.kurt warner
ThatKidWhoLiesAboutHisAge OnTheInternet Brady might not even be a top 5 QB.
Someone on some good kush joe Montana is number 1
Derek Carr , know he's bad