I have heard this song so many times over the years that even just listening to the drums and bass, I could easily picture the Lyrics and guitars. Being a drummer this was great to hear, i actually picked up a bit from this
Yeah, you can really hear how many more bass drum hits he's making on the verses and choruses. And the snare and hat work in the 6/8 section kills me every time!
I still remember when this album originally came out, a local record store had a big sign in front of their store that read, "Rush in for a Permanent Wave". I did, of course. I looked fantastic while jamming out to a great album.
My buddy and I used to get together in my man-cave-think I Love You, Man-and we’d play this song over and over and over (while getting hammered). He played bass and I, the guitar. We kicked ass right up until the guitar solo where we would crash and burn. Fun times. I’m 61 and don’t play anymore, and I don’t really see my buddy anymore. Friends come and go.
Oh wow.....back in the day I played drums and I wished I had buddies to jam with.....I would of loved to have jammed and drink with you guys. Cheers from Texas!
melodic bass, underappreciated. except those of us who can discern the bass out of the entire soundtrack. Rush is masterful. Another line you might try(off topic) is Thompson Twins "Lies Lies Lies" bassline.
I have always thought this was the best Rush album. This album could have been a double album with Moving Pictures. I have always told people that this song exemplifies everything that Rush does well. The solo section may be the best few minutes of Rush music. There is not a bad song on this album! MP is most people's choice for their best, but for my own subjective opinion, this alnum was a little better, and led the way to MP.
Super cool! Definitely helps in deciphering Geddy's lines! Thanks! Anyway you could do Spock's Beard, 'Submerged'? We're covering it in our band, and he's not super forward in the mix to hear all the details. I do believe Dave Meros is ignoring my requests... 😂.
Honestly, I have a much harder time practicing Tom Sawyer than Freewill. The wrist gets so much more strained on Tom Sawyer, and the rhythm is also really complicated.
This does not sound like the original recording...it fades in places. It sounds like an amateur playing along with a programmed drum machine. Is this you?
Hi ! Thanks for your comment. The source used is from a rip of Permanent Waves MFSL album. You can notice some audio artifacts or fades, yeah. That's because of the differents tools I'm using to isolate the different layers of instruments. When the song is very, very busy, it's very difficult to have a 100% clear result so you'll have some artifacts because of frequencies/instruments overlapping each others... it's not Rock Band stems or equivalent. Drum is Neil and bass Geddy 100%. (Tbh I wish it was me playing, lol)
@@GrooveExtractorLab I'm not convinced. I think that you're a bass player with a programmable drum machine. If it's really from the album, go ahead and 'isolate' the guitar parts as well. If you can't, I suspect it's because you don't play guitar, or don't play it well enough to fool anyone. I'll withhold judgement until I see the guitar parts as well. Should I hold my breath?
I have heard this song so many times over the years that even just listening to the drums and bass, I could easily picture the Lyrics and guitars. Being a drummer this was great to hear, i actually picked up a bit from this
Yeah, you can really hear how many more bass drum hits he's making on the verses and choruses. And the snare and hat work in the 6/8 section kills me every time!
Sounds awesome, one of my favorite Geddy Lee bass lines. The jam part is just sick 😎👍
Thank you !
The gritty tone of Geddy Lee's bass is even more amazing when isolated.
Better demonstrating that Rush was always three absolute vituosos... Geddy was/is often unfairly underrated.
So much of the sparkle of this song and album comes from bass tone and upfront crack of the snare drum.
I agree!
Love hearing these. There's more groove to Peart than he gets credit for (newsflash-he gets virtually none!). Excellent work.
Neil's got the Canadian swing.
la villa is pretty gnarly in the groove department in my opinion
I still remember when this album originally came out, a local record store had a big sign in front of their store that read, "Rush in for a Permanent Wave". I did, of course. I looked fantastic while jamming out to a great album.
This was the first new release album I bought after discovering Rush. I then bought every new studio album on release until Clockwork Angels.
Damn, Geddy's playing during the12/8 jam is a solo itself!
This solo is awesome ! I think It's on my top tier list with the solo on Mr BIG by Free and some other.
the series of triplets is fire
More Rush please! Tom sawyer, Limelight, Working man, la Villa Strangiato etc. thanks in advance
One of Rush's greatest songs!!!👍
Truly a masterpiece of musicianship!!!🎓
Makes me realize how much of he sonic range Alex fills.
Great post! Man, those guys were so tight. And I love the sound of Neil’s snare.
My buddy and I used to get together in my man-cave-think I Love You, Man-and we’d play this song over and over and over (while getting hammered). He played bass and I, the guitar. We kicked ass right up until the guitar solo where we would crash and burn. Fun times. I’m 61 and don’t play anymore, and I don’t really see my buddy anymore. Friends come and go.
Wonderful story ! Maybe just send him the Rush track, good old memories never fade
Oh wow.....back in the day I played drums and I wished I had buddies to jam with.....I would of loved to have jammed and drink with you guys. Cheers from Texas!
Geddy Lee 🤟😊
gosh this is peak. Gedd's string of triplets in the jam!
This is probably their best-ever jam when all three were at their technical max simultaneously.
Great work. Its amazing to hear how Geddy plays the vocal melody on Bass whilst he's singing it.
Awesome Instrumental...
melodic bass, underappreciated. except those of us who can discern the bass out of the entire soundtrack. Rush is masterful. Another line you might try(off topic) is Thompson Twins "Lies Lies Lies" bassline.
Hi, thank for your comment and I can give it a try !
yo this is cool...& don't care if it's fake...sounds legit to me
I have always thought this was the best Rush album. This album could have been a double album with Moving Pictures. I have always told people that this song exemplifies everything that Rush does well. The solo section may be the best few minutes of Rush music. There is not a bad song on this album! MP is most people's choice for their best, but for my own subjective opinion, this alnum was a little better, and led the way to MP.
I agree, It's one of my favorite album !
Super cool! Definitely helps in deciphering Geddy's lines! Thanks!
Anyway you could do Spock's Beard, 'Submerged'? We're covering it in our band, and he's not super forward in the mix to hear all the details.
I do believe Dave Meros is ignoring my requests... 😂.
Hi there, check my last upload !
@@GrooveExtractorLab Breaux, if you're ever in the central Ohio area, I owe you a beer, or two. 🍻
I'll never understand how (according to Neil), Tom Sawyer is harder than this. I think this is their most complex and difficult song.
Honestly, I have a much harder time practicing Tom Sawyer than Freewill. The wrist gets so much more strained on Tom Sawyer, and the rhythm is also really complicated.
3:01 is when we get busy!
DANG!
la villa strangiato please!
LA VILLA STRANGIATO BASS & DRUMS isolated: ruclips.net/video/8U_wn_8h2M4/видео.html
probably means The Strange Village. like a certain "Big Valley" episode with Lee Majors and Leslie Nelson. concerning two crazy women!
Probably Geddy's simplest bass line. Still brilliant
🤯
Any chance of getting just the guitar solo? I have to learn it for our tribute band. Great job, btw!
Hello, I can give you the guitar part, send me an email (my mail in my profile) ! Thank you for your comment !
do mudvayne pls
Stay tuned, Mudvayne might be on track very soon !
@@GrooveExtractorLab ty
Always wondered what the bass sounded like under
The solo
I assume you mean the guitar solo? Well I wouldn't even say the bass is underneath it!!!
The method of extraction seems to squeeze the growl & the twang out of the bass.
Yeah, some parts are altered and some not, I'm working on fine tuning the results :)
Sounds pretty good but can you extract the guitar without artifacts?
Geddy actually upstages Alex during the guitar solo lol
As much as I love Alex, I think Geddy is THE man for the entire solo!
😊
3:03 MY GOD
Yeah that's what he said too!!!
What an incredibly nerdy concept this is.. just listen to the f**king song.
This does not sound like the original recording...it fades in places. It sounds like an amateur playing along with a programmed drum machine. Is this you?
I don't know how OP does it, but these stems often come from Rock Band, etc., so they might be variations from the original album versions.
Hi ! Thanks for your comment. The source used is from a rip of Permanent Waves MFSL album. You can notice some audio artifacts or fades, yeah. That's because of the differents tools I'm using to isolate the different layers of instruments. When the song is very, very busy, it's very difficult to have a 100% clear result so you'll have some artifacts because of frequencies/instruments overlapping each others... it's not Rock Band stems or equivalent. Drum is Neil and bass Geddy 100%. (Tbh I wish it was me playing, lol)
@@GrooveExtractorLab I'm not convinced. I think that you're a bass player with a programmable drum machine. If it's really from the album, go ahead and 'isolate' the guitar parts as well. If you can't, I suspect it's because you don't play guitar, or don't play it well enough to fool anyone. I'll withhold judgement until I see the guitar parts as well. Should I hold my breath?
@@GrooveExtractorLab Yeah that's Geddy. I know every inch of that bass line during the guitar solo.
@@ritparent7239 Please do.
This sounds 1000x better WITHOUT the screeching , overbearing guitar.
No
How many of us were singing " each of us, a cell of awareness, imperfect and incomplete "
No