“I Have A Very, Very Strong Opinion About This” | Military Historian On Nazi Dress At Festival

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 21 окт 2024

Комментарии • 49

  • @tillyt4054
    @tillyt4054 Год назад +14

    This is ridiculous , Germany did actually play quite a big part in WW2 . Get over it ffs

  • @nickedwards2904
    @nickedwards2904 Год назад +31

    Shall we change history to remove all the bits we dont like then? stupid pathetic attitudes over this.

    • @Jadenbanks8883
      @Jadenbanks8883 Месяц назад +1

      the bad guys always have the cooler costumes anyways

  • @felixrios1600
    @felixrios1600 Год назад +17

    Germany, and Japan is living a lot better than Americans.

  • @dennis13spartan
    @dennis13spartan Год назад +16

    Its been about 80 years, just give it a break. At this point the way people like this historian keep behaving is more disrespectful becaus they go on like snowflake water spouts about anything german but give the soviets a nice clean pass

  • @bigCyril
    @bigCyril Год назад +24

    Who cares, leave people alone. Apparently one person was mouthing off about this . I expect other people would complain if they were wearing Israeli uniforms, but this wouldn’t appear in the media.

    • @ledzebulon6235
      @ledzebulon6235 Год назад +1

      The complainant was😫 probably Karen Karenson

  • @lennon1482
    @lennon1482 Год назад +11

    well there is loads of films in modern times which feature nazis, loads in the last ten years, so it's all right for the luvvies?

  • @stukavonferno8858
    @stukavonferno8858 Год назад +10

    There is nothing wrong dressing in these uniforms, just as there's nothing wrong blacking up or whiting up for a fancy dress party!

    • @davidsummer8631
      @davidsummer8631 Год назад

      Are you seriously comparing blackface with the uniform of the SS who committed some of the worst crimes against humanity in WWII ?

    • @stukavonferno8858
      @stukavonferno8858 Год назад +2

      @@davidsummer8631 Calm down snowflake

    • @MatthewJackson-qb7jt
      @MatthewJackson-qb7jt 10 месяцев назад

      OUT YOU AS A COMMUNIST!@@davidsummer8631

  • @valkyriedd5849
    @valkyriedd5849 Год назад +11

    Was their dress historically acurate? Are you doing historical reenactments? Get on with it.

  • @Horizon344
    @Horizon344 Год назад +14

    Bit of harmless fun

  • @User_Name00
    @User_Name00 Год назад +22

    Does he care about people wearing USSR uniform or is that acceptable because they won WW2?

    • @Mogwai-ug9op
      @Mogwai-ug9op Год назад

      Nobody was wearing USSR uniforms, so why would he be upset about that?

    • @bewilderedbrit8928
      @bewilderedbrit8928 Год назад +1

      ​@@Mogwai-ug9opBut if they did we all know he wouldn't care. Remember: right are the baddies, leftists are the goodies.

  • @jamesolive6475
    @jamesolive6475 Год назад +4

    Didn't Prince Harry wear a German Army uniform. If it is good enough for him it is good enough for me.

  • @nealmcgloin2984
    @nealmcgloin2984 Год назад +4

    I dont know? Yes SS units did commit alot of atrocities and war crimes from the evacuation at Dunkirk, the battle of the bulge to name but two out of many . But? Surely at re enactments there would be no historical and factual elements with just a bunch of old fat guys dressed as us airborne or Tommies?. Without the enemy you dont have a re enactment of a battle scenario,you literally would have a 'Dads army ', training exercise.

  • @09amusement
    @09amusement Год назад +1

    It wasn't the uniforms that did it,, it was the goose stepping and nazi salutes that triggered anger. I was there exhibiting vehicles.

  • @bewilderedbrit8928
    @bewilderedbrit8928 Год назад +6

    I imagine if they had dressed as NKVD officers it wouldn't have ruffled any feathers. Remember everybody: RIGHT WING EXCLUSIVELY BAD, LEFT WING CUDDLY, CUTE AND PROGRESSIVE.

  • @simoncook7456
    @simoncook7456 Год назад +2

    How do I join this group, the ss uniform looks fantastic

  • @jameswest4692
    @jameswest4692 Год назад +1

    I would love it if some people came dressed up as concentration camp victims, star of David and all. Im sure there would be outrage, but then i could call them holocaust deniers and that would be the end of the arguement.

  • @seandobson499
    @seandobson499 Год назад +1

    Personally, I served in two armies and saw active service in both and that was quite enough for me, so I have no interest in such events, having had more than my fill of the real thing and do not even attend Armistice Day events as I do not need to attend parades wearing medals to remember my friends and comrades 365 days a year, but I respect those that do and understand why they do.

  • @loafersheffield
    @loafersheffield Год назад +6

    Leesten veery keerfully. I shal say zis ernlee wharnce.

  • @Madcap247
    @Madcap247 Год назад

    So the historian has a reason not to like German WW2 Reenactment. A valid reason but a biased opinion all the same

  • @raymondturner9441
    @raymondturner9441 Год назад +1

    Wonder if they have Italian tanks from the time. The tanks with one neutral gear and five reverse

    • @jameswest4692
      @jameswest4692 Год назад

      They did have one forward gear, just in case the enemy crept up behind them

  • @rickyj5547
    @rickyj5547 Год назад

    The sovet union had a version of the ss called the nvkd

  • @paulholloway1447
    @paulholloway1447 3 месяца назад

    It’s History .

  • @rickyj5547
    @rickyj5547 Год назад

    Remember history.

  • @rickyj5547
    @rickyj5547 Год назад

    Did they sovet union have the labour camps in the 1930s and 1940s.

  • @dianecameron137
    @dianecameron137 Год назад

    its more about have some bloody respect to the people in this country that fought so our people didnt suffer what those others did its free to just have respect

    • @willsommers6477
      @willsommers6477 Год назад

      Its a ww2 event... the germans were in ww2 or do you want to delete it? What if they dressed as communists, russian troops or even Stalin would that be ok for you?

  • @barrygriffiths4530
    @barrygriffiths4530 Год назад +7

    Na just a laugh