Excellent and fun analysis. I have read and enjoyed both series, and I agreed with most of your points. Just to add something new, I'll give my vote on Plot, which you decided was a tie. While you made a good case, I'm going to give it to DCC in that it compacts down a large amount of plot in 6 books, while HWFWM might have taken 9 to achieve the same depth.⬅ Suggestion: in all three videos of yours I have watched, you display some really well done illustrations for a number of the characters as you discuss them. If you yourself are the artist, by all means say so. If you have downloaded them from sites like DeviantArt, I suggest adding links, at least going forward, to the artists whose excellent work you share. Most people won't "more" the video notes section to see the links, but some people, like me, do.
Don’t worry I can’t say Dungeon crawler Carl either lol. That was a great video. I like the idea of having two similar stories face off against each other like that. I have not yet read hwfwm but it definitely just moved up on my tbr 👍
Excellent and fun analysis. I have read and enjoyed both series, and I agreed with most of your points. Just to add something new, I'll give my vote on Plot, which you decided was a tie. While you made a good case, I'm going to give it to DCC in that it compacts down a large amount of plot in 6 books, while HWFWM might have taken 9 to achieve the same depth.⬅
Suggestion: in all three videos of yours I have watched, you display some really well done illustrations for a number of the characters as you discuss them. If you yourself are the artist, by all means say so. If you have downloaded them from sites like DeviantArt, I suggest adding links, at least going forward, to the artists whose excellent work you share. Most people won't "more" the video notes section to see the links, but some people, like me, do.
Loved the concept and would like to see more of these please
@@mansoormurad5400 awesome! I’m glad you enjoyed it! Any suggestions for further “battles”?!
Don’t worry I can’t say Dungeon crawler Carl either lol. That was a great video. I like the idea of having two similar stories face off against each other like that. I have not yet read hwfwm but it definitely just moved up on my tbr 👍
@@totallysick88able thanks! It was a fun series to do. I will be doing more like this on the future 👍🏼
Agreed.
@@znighthawk8342 anything you would change or add?!
I can't believe you didn't mention Clive 's wife in HWFWM's characters 🤦😂
@@bobburris4445 well, I didn’t want to spoil any book 11 elements for people who haven’t read it yet! 😂