That was horrible. Like every other rendition I've heard of this song, it took 100% of the soul out of the song and turned it into bubble gum top 40 glee crap.
Well who pissed in your cereal this morning, Mr Grinch? The harmonization is pretty solid, I think your ears are playing tricks on you. As for the singing: we're not all trained singers, this was an amateur project done without ever meeting in person, FYI. Regardless, you can make your point with the bare minimum of courtesy, or can't you?
How did it take 100% of the soul of the song? The Bee Gees themselves sung it Acapella, and they are just so fond of harmonies. You may not like it because you don't like this style, but then again, who pissed in your cereal, Mr. Grinch?
Up until today I find this the finest effort Julien has ever done. The voices all have personality and blend together fantastically. You can hear all of these people's love for music and for this song in particular. It's not pitch perfect, it has clear misses in some of the video-post-synching but boy does it have vibe!!! And soul!!! Dear Sir, I thank you for the opportunity to express once more my deepest appreciation for this wonderful rendition and reminding me for why I come back to it every so often to have another joyful moment of real music.
I sing tenor in many of my videos actually. I sometimes sing in full voice, sometimes in falsetto. I'm probably a baritone, so I manage the tenor part, but it's not the easiest. Glad you enjoy my videos. :)
Apologies for the timely response. But here it goes. I guess I feel most comfortable in JB's lower range. To do your part in this song, I have to do a falsetto but lower it a lot. Can't go high anymore. Can definitely go to Robin's lows with some effort. Still my favourite song to do vocal exercises after all these years. Hope you're all doing well. :)
2019 and I'm JAMMING to this. The baritone part is gorgeous at the chorus! You guys have been one of my biggest inspirations since I found you in 2014. Thank you!
I must say, I definitely have to respect this group for the fact that they do older songs, ranging from Beatles to even this, Bee Gees. I really appreciate that.
I'm very much older than you guys. The original Bee Gees' tune is indelibly etched into my tonal memory from literally hundreds (thousands?) of repeated listenings many years ago. And I gotta say--I like your rendering better. I'm grinning from ear to ear. Simply amazing!
Thanks! We never met in person, everything was done by email. :) Download our song from BandCamp (see link above) & support artists if you want more like this. It's the only way to make it all possible!
That was absolutely gorgeous. I was like, 12 when the BeeGees original version came out, and remember it being all over the radio. Always loved this song.
Gotta love listening to this. I think that one might be my favorite I'm not sure it's like picking a favorite Beatles tunes are all good. Thank You Julian
Julien, I just keep coming back to this song. It is so FULL of soul! I love it and some time next year I'm going to persuade bits of my family to sing this with me.
Thank you! Yes, multitracking is nerdy artistry where you only see the result when everything is already recorded. It requires a bit of anticipation indeed. :)
Yeah, he has an easy natural bass voice. His track is somewhat equalized though, to give it some more depth and power. We probably wouldn't have this sound is us four sang into the same microphone all at once.
this is undoubtably one of not only your better videos but one of the best videos I've ever seen, it sent shivers down my spine. Phenomenal, sheerly phenomenal.
Love this song!!! Reminds me of being a little kid in the back of the car, when my dad would play it on the radio. Love how creative you guys are at sharing your music.
Haha I am probably one of the few people in my age group who know who the Bee Gees are at least at school. Second lol loving the 70s fro there Julien :) You never stop impressing me with your amazing voice and unique taste in fashion :P
Thanks! :) Please check out my Patreon page & tip me just $1 to help me cover production costs & continue making free music on RUclips: patreon.com/trudbol Thanks! :)
Je sais même plus si j'avais commenté sur cette vidéo mais c'est juste impressionnant le taff que vous faites. J'aime beaucoup les Bee Gees et j'ai déjà trouvé pas mal de reprises catastrophiques, mais celle-là... Elle est absolument parfaite !
you, guys, made my day. that was really amazing. it's always great to see how people from different nations are working together to produce such a fine piece of music. Oh and, Julien, Robin please do more collabs.
I really love your rendition of this song. Collectively and individually. The four of you are all great musicians. Thanks for sharing. I do want to do this with friends one day.
And for some reason when Andrew looks forward is when I start singing along! So thanks, Andrew. Thank You to all the other, besides me, Hopeless Romantics who write Love Songs, sing Love Songs that Keep Me Swooning!
Impeccable sur le plan vocal. Robin sonne magistralement, comme si j'avais un caisson de basse alors que je n'ai que des petits baffles pourris sur mon PC. Bravissimo. Excellente reprise.
Loved it guys! I have recently become enthralled with quartet music and Mr. Kesler's performance of "Go the distance" with Rendezvous Quartet is what got me interested in listening to more quartet music. In fact that performance is on my list of Best Songs Ever! I found trudbol a few weeks later and I have been hooked since. Glad to see the collaboration. Wish you both the best of luck in your respective careers.
You guys are all terrific :) . My dad loves the Bee Gees and he enjoyed this video too. Also, I can't help but feel that JB's voice sounds pretty close to the Bee Gees themselves. And I wish I had a deeper voice like Robin's while maintaining the upper register of my voice.
I've listened to ALL of your stuff, Julien, not just this one. Still, the blend you guys achieve just sends me. And your voice sounds like a cello among woodwinds, which just makes the blend more astonishing, and makes you stand out in your solo :)
Oh God, I started stalking your channel. >.< I come here every day and listen to this gorgeous music of yours - and I just can't get enough of it! You guys are so amazing. All of you.
Thanks! I'll surely be making more A Cappella videos (and I have since this video was published, just have a look). As for making another collab, we'll try, but everyone has a busy music life and I can assure you that putting these projects together when everyone lives in a different place and speaks a different language is quite a bit of work.:)
The sound you guys achieved reminds very much of one of my personal favorite a capella groups: Rockapella. Believe me when I say that this is high praise coming from me! Amazing job you four! I hope to hear more from you!
this is nice. it reminded me of that song "more than words" well at least jb voice the way he sings this song. i never thought how this song is perfect to cover. this my first time hearing a cover for a how deep is your love. your harmonizing is really good too. this is SUPERB
OmsL :D (Oh my sweet Lord! :D), you guys actually brought me to that point when I felt almost embarrassed for singing so LOUDLY along with you! I haven't heared this song in a million years or it just seems so! You brought it back to life! Thank you, thank you, THANK Y. O. U.!!! :D
Omg! One of my favorite songs of all time! You guys nailed it! It's interesting to see trudbol do something different too. Especially if it involves one of my favorite artists the Bee Gees!
Oh my goodness such a beautiful sound I'm flabbergasted! Pitch perfect and so strong! The way your voices blend is remarkable and such a beautiful tone quality!
came back here after I realized that they made this video without physical contact, everything thru the internet which is basically the norm today due to the pandemic these guys are so ahead of their time
That was horrible. Like every other rendition I've heard of this song, it took 100% of the soul out of the song and turned it into bubble gum top 40 glee crap.
Well who pissed in your cereal this morning, Mr Grinch?
The harmonization is pretty solid, I think your ears are playing tricks on you.
As for the singing: we're not all trained singers, this was an amateur project done without ever meeting in person, FYI.
Regardless, you can make your point with the bare minimum of courtesy, or can't you?
How did it take 100% of the soul of the song? The Bee Gees themselves sung it Acapella, and they are just so fond of harmonies. You may not like it because you don't like this style, but then again, who pissed in your cereal, Mr. Grinch?
Atleast the harmonization better than the one video you have on your channel.
You sound like you must just be a ray of sunshine in the lives of everyone around you. They're *_so_* lucky!
Up until today I find this the finest effort Julien has ever done. The voices all have personality and blend together fantastically. You can hear all of these people's love for music and for this song in particular. It's not pitch perfect, it has clear misses in some of the video-post-synching but boy does it have vibe!!! And soul!!!
Dear Sir, I thank you for the opportunity to express once more my deepest appreciation for this wonderful rendition and reminding me for why I come back to it every so often to have another joyful moment of real music.
Robin has that 70's look down perfectly.
I sing tenor in many of my videos actually. I sometimes sing in full voice, sometimes in falsetto. I'm probably a baritone, so I manage the tenor part, but it's not the easiest.
Glad you enjoy my videos. :)
Why are the comments and replies separated on old videos? Also, great video, A Capella Trudbol!
Apologies for the timely response. But here it goes. I guess I feel most comfortable in JB's lower range. To do your part in this song, I have to do a falsetto but lower it a lot. Can't go high anymore. Can definitely go to Robin's lows with some effort. Still my favourite song to do vocal exercises after all these years. Hope you're all doing well. :)
It’s difficult to figure out range.
Robin carries a wicked bass line.
still listening to this on the eve of 2019. Too beautiful!
This is seriously good. What a lovely arrangement! Respect
Thanks! My arrangement is available for sale along with the audio learning tracks on my website: julienneel.com
How about the music sheet, are you also selling?
I have listened to this several times and discovered it YEARS ago. Still amazing.
Excellent! Not only is the harmony great, but I can actually understand the words!
2019 and I'm JAMMING to this. The baritone part is gorgeous at the chorus! You guys have been one of my biggest inspirations since I found you in 2014. Thank you!
I must say, I definitely have to respect this group for the fact that they do older songs, ranging from Beatles to even this, Bee Gees. I really appreciate that.
still listening to this
Woohoo! :)
dito
...yeah...me too :-)
Naziira Rachel
JB is amazing. That vocal is wonderful.
2020, this harmony still touches my soul
This is probably the best thing I've ever heard.
Wow, you all sound great. Andrew has an amazing voice. JB as well.
Impressionante. O barítono é perfeito! Estão de parabéns.
I'm very much older than you guys. The original Bee Gees' tune is indelibly etched into my tonal memory from literally hundreds (thousands?) of repeated listenings many years ago. And I gotta say--I like your rendering better. I'm grinning from ear to ear. Simply amazing!
Thanks! We never met in person, everything was done by email. :)
Download our song from BandCamp (see link above) & support artists if you want more like this. It's the only way to make it all possible!
That was absolutely gorgeous. I was like, 12 when the BeeGees original version came out, and remember it being all over the radio. Always loved this song.
2019 ✌
Very good,congratulations 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏.
I watching from 🇧🇷.
I'm Brazilian and I loved this song sung by you all.
Congratulations!
Gotta love listening to this. I think that one might be my favorite I'm not sure it's like picking a favorite Beatles tunes are all good. Thank You Julian
best colab ever. quite touching. the bee gees would be proud.
you guys should make more songs....this is incredible!!!!!!!!!!
Julien, I just keep coming back to this song. It is so FULL of soul! I love it and some time next year I'm going to persuade bits of my family to sing this with me.
Thank you! Yes, multitracking is nerdy artistry where you only see the result when everything is already recorded. It requires a bit of anticipation indeed. :)
Just found these folks. Simple, honest-to-goodness straight up harmony. So sweet I am smiling through the song.
Yeah, he has an easy natural bass voice. His track is somewhat equalized though, to give it some more depth and power. We probably wouldn't have this sound is us four sang into the same microphone all at once.
still a banger almost 11 years later, that bari part goes hard
Stumbled across this randomly and now have it on repeat, literally shedding tears at the perfection. 🥹
so i was looking of how "deep is your love" cover and i found this, 1 word : Amazing
for*
this is undoubtably one of not only your better videos but one of the best videos I've ever seen, it sent shivers down my spine. Phenomenal, sheerly phenomenal.
I want my own personal Julien, so he can sing to me for the rest of my days!
Love this song!!! Reminds me of being a little kid in the back of the car, when my dad would play it on the radio. Love how creative you guys are at sharing your music.
THIS PRETTY. YOU GUYS SHOULD DO MORE COLLAB
This is possibly the best and most precise arrangement of this song I've ever heard ... other than the Bee Gees, of course (probably?)
amazing!
I'm taking incentive so that when this gets recommended I'll get likes yeah babyyyyy
Long time Trudbol fan here, but I have to say that Robin's bass is GORGEOUS! Thanks for making this, guys.
holy shit that is awesome
Thanks!
Harmonisation of Julien was CRAZY!!
Haha I am probably one of the few people in my age group who know who the Bee Gees are at least at school. Second lol loving the 70s fro there Julien :) You never stop impressing me with your amazing voice and unique taste in fashion :P
Thanks! :)
Please check out my Patreon page & tip me just $1 to help me cover production costs & continue making free music on RUclips: patreon.com/trudbol
Thanks! :)
man you guys need to be on the radio or on an album or something you guys are great!!
Is it sad that I like this better than the original version?
Thanks! Why sad?
Sad that the Bee Gees dont sound like the Bee Gees in the original
This is my absolute favourite Bee Gees song and this is a great arrangement.
Not bad. Very groovy.
my goodness gracious jb's voice is so soothing
I actually like this version more than the original :'D
Laura same
Me too, it's so beautiful!! :D
Robin and Julien!! How long have I waited for that combination!!
2018 - "...."
(edt)
Time flies, i came back to check who i was here, stil no girlfriend haha
2019 😆👍
me too
What??? Its been a year haahaha
You guys made this video almost 6 years ago and I still listen to it like everyday!!! So good!!!
You should dress like this more often
It gets better every time I listen, the falsetto is just perfect!
dudududu dududududu wakbar
pretty much every time trudbol has guest singers the quality drops by at least 50%.
beegees did some of the best music ever written - you do them justice! love it!
I've been listening this version for years and now I can say I can reach all the ranges of the song
that's what i call the power of the voice! it really lifted my spirit!
L' écoute de votre chant, est un vrai plaisir !
Merci les gars et bonne année !
That's heavenly, gentlemen. Can't praise you enough.
Je sais même plus si j'avais commenté sur cette vidéo mais c'est juste impressionnant le taff que vous faites. J'aime beaucoup les Bee Gees et j'ai déjà trouvé pas mal de reprises catastrophiques, mais celle-là... Elle est absolument parfaite !
you, guys, made my day. that was really amazing. it's always great to see how people from different nations are working together to produce such a fine piece of music. Oh and, Julien, Robin please do more collabs.
I enjoyed that sooo much! JB's voice is like butter when he comes in. The whole thing is fantastic! Wonderful job!
Came here for Andrew Kesler, and thoroughly enjoyed everyone in the video. Amazing work, fellows!
Really wonderful collaboration Julien and all. This to me is the definitive version of the song. Much admiration. -Ron
WOW!
I can't even count how many times I've listened to this song and your other songs.
I really love your rendition of this song. Collectively and individually. The four of you are all great musicians. Thanks for sharing. I do want to do this with friends one day.
And for some reason when Andrew looks forward is when I start singing along! So thanks, Andrew. Thank You to all the other, besides me, Hopeless Romantics who write Love Songs, sing Love Songs that Keep Me Swooning!
Impeccable sur le plan vocal. Robin sonne magistralement, comme si j'avais un caisson de basse alors que je n'ai que des petits baffles pourris sur mon PC.
Bravissimo. Excellente reprise.
Loved it guys! I have recently become enthralled with quartet music and Mr. Kesler's performance of "Go the distance" with Rendezvous Quartet is what got me interested in listening to more quartet music. In fact that performance is on my list of Best Songs Ever! I found trudbol a few weeks later and I have been hooked since. Glad to see the collaboration. Wish you both the best of luck in your respective careers.
You guys are all terrific :) . My dad loves the Bee Gees and he enjoyed this video too. Also, I can't help but feel that JB's voice sounds pretty close to the Bee Gees themselves. And I wish I had a deeper voice like Robin's while maintaining the upper register of my voice.
That middle harmony is something special.
This and "Hello Mary Lou" --my favorites of your collaborations.
I love this stuff.
Its sad that no one pointed out how nice JB is with that 1st lead! Great job sir!
I've listened to ALL of your stuff, Julien, not just this one. Still, the blend you guys achieve just sends me. And your voice sounds like a cello among woodwinds, which just makes the blend more astonishing, and makes you stand out in your solo :)
C'est génial je sais plus comment j'ai découvert cette chaine mais vraiment, quel plaisir!
Amazing cover!!!
Oh God, I started stalking your channel. >.<
I come here every day and listen to this gorgeous music of yours - and I just can't get enough of it! You guys are so amazing. All of you.
Thanks! I'll surely be making more A Cappella videos (and I have since this video was published, just have a look). As for making another collab, we'll try, but everyone has a busy music life and I can assure you that putting these projects together when everyone lives in a different place and speaks a different language is quite a bit of work.:)
soothing is the blend of it....so greatly amazing. thanks mister neel.
Very smooth, professional performance.
Superb! Would love to see more Bee Gees from you guys!
The harmonies are so amazing here
Julien has perfect pronunciation. And he sounds straight out of a barbershop quartet. Love him.
i could listen to your songs for days
Gee, JB, your falsetto sounds like Claude McK iii, and Julien, you crack me up every time! Great collaboration, you managed to unite 400% talent!
Thankyou so much for posting this. This was one of my dad's favorite songs.
I still remember hearing their songs through my dad and I loved them as much as I love your version of it nice job
WONDERFUL! One of my favorite songs of all time!
The sound you guys achieved reminds very much of one of my personal favorite a capella groups: Rockapella. Believe me when I say that this is high praise coming from me! Amazing job you four! I hope to hear more from you!
this is nice. it reminded me of that song "more than words" well at least jb voice the way he sings this song. i never thought how this song is perfect to cover. this my first time hearing a cover for a how deep is your love. your harmonizing is really good too. this is SUPERB
OmsL :D (Oh my sweet Lord! :D), you guys actually brought me to that point when I felt almost embarrassed for singing so LOUDLY along with you! I haven't heared this song in a million years or it just seems so! You brought it back to life! Thank you, thank you, THANK Y. O. U.!!! :D
one of my favorite songs of all time! Im sharing with the world! Keep it up Julien!!
Dont know how I got here, but Im glad I passed by. This was amazing.
Omg! One of my favorite songs of all time! You guys nailed it! It's interesting to see trudbol do something different too. Especially if it involves one of my favorite artists the Bee Gees!
Oh my goodness such a beautiful sound I'm flabbergasted! Pitch perfect and so strong! The way your voices blend is remarkable and such a beautiful tone quality!
came back here after I realized that they made this video without physical contact, everything thru the internet which is basically the norm today due to the pandemic
these guys are so ahead of their time
Just found this gem yesterday. Great job!
I love Robin's voice!
This is INCREDIBLE! and all of your outfits ROCK
Flashy les coloris, super l'arrangement et l'interprétation, un plus pour la perruque afro de Julien !