Is it the beginning of the end for Myanmar’s junta?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024
- Subscribe to our RUclips channel for free here:
sc.mp/subscrib...
Read more about the story: sc.mp/hynu
Myanmar rulers are facing the biggest challenge to their authority since the military junta seized power in a 2021 coup. Intense fighting between military forces and rebel groups in the country’s border regions with China, as well as mass desertions of Myanmar soldiers, have been reported since October 2023. After two and a half years of fighting insurgents and with the second anniversary of the coup approaching, some observers say the junta is looking relatively vulnerable.
Related story:
Could Myanmar’s military be deposed by armed groups fighting across the country? sc.mp/hynu
Support us:
subscribe.scmp...
Follow us on:
Website: www.scmp.com
Facebook: / scmp
Twitter: / scmpnews
Instagram: / scmpnews
Linkedin: / south-china-morning-post
#scmp #Asia #Myanmar
A government established forcefully and without its people support will eventually crumble.
Well, the government the junta overthrew was elected by the people and it didn't last, so there's that.
Враньё. Хоть 100 лет без воли народа просуществует.
European governments since the 2000s, would like to have a word with you.
@@magnetospinwell, the current Junta is collapsing. What's your point?
@@triadwarfareThe point is governments with its peoples support could also fall. You can't comprehend?
This military junta has made both China and the United States loathe him. I am unable to understand how he did it.
China supports both sides
there's money and also the genocide of the Rohingya and a Burma saturated with rebellion isn't great for regional stability- which is something both U.S.A and China would like to have
China simply wants its asset (mines, etc.) in Myanmar to be safe. It's playing either side who can keep its interest. Even the latest rebel offensive was approved by China by reasoning of cleaning human trafficking ring targeting Chinese.
@@amaduck2132 Based on your imagination?
@@sei.tsukinoHow could he makes both sides hate him with money? I dont think you understand what you're saying lol
I hope the problems in Myanmar will be resolved quickly
The problems have existed for 80 years. This is not something that will just go away.
@@Mussi93 I know about it but no one knows the future, for that I pray for Myanmar
@@Mussi93 It wont get better. Itll keep going until one group rules. several rulers never ever work.
@@npc_bot u are Puasy 🥴
❤ Love you
Pray for the peace of Myanmar 🇲🇲.. Pray for the welfare of the cities we live in.
I hope the war stops. Praying for our brothers in Myanyar. Sending love and peace from your Asean brothers
War stops, then comes the oppression from the Military ran government, and you know how most of those go, just look at Africa, alot of Dictators ruled through Military, usually ending up in Coup de tats, or resistant fighters and the cycle repeats.
It will stop once the military junta is unseated and democracy is restored. A country should be of the people by the people for the people.
It won't unless someone is undeniably the winner. I don't think Myanmar military expected such thing to happen maybe that's why they are being overrun easily. They are in power far too long that they think they are invincible
Amen brother 🙏😇
why would it stop now? and then what? military dictatorship for ever in peace? dont make sense. obviously they need to win to free Myanmar. I wish them success.
As an indonesian i have to once again thank my former leader soeharto who instead of opting to do what the junta does. he stepped down knowing a messy power struggle that would have ensued if he chose to keep his grip on power. i am feeling sorry for myanmar, the junta could have simply just followed what soeharto did as they have always closely learnt from his successes. I visited the country in 08 and 18. the decade difference was enormous. there was no internet, only a few 4 star hotels and bogyoke market as the biggest shopping center in 08. fast forward 10 years and 4 star hotels are everywhere, about 5 modern shopping malls, and most importantly we got the internet and i was able to travel around the city easily using google maps on foot and by ride sharing. I feel sorry for the people of myanmar just when i thought they were in the right direction the junta drag them down again too soon. They have stolen myanmar's future right under their own people and the world does not have enough time or resources to care.
take him 3 days to step down.
the country is in chaos state.
he step down with at least 35 billion dollar worth of asset (in 1990s). most Indonesian that time life in poverty.
he step down because Indonesian people make him to. protest happened everywhere. Indonesian political leader that time not wanting revolution bc they learned from latin america. and they choose to only reform.
until his death. his crime not yet to be resolve.
and he and his family still owe Indonesia not only money but also the truth.
thanks the protestors not soeharto.
@@batrickpatemanfact💯💯
Honestly i wont really be thanking him for stepping down. He simply did that becasue he no longer had the support from both the military and the parliament, even his closest allies in his government. I think Myanmar case is even worse, since it's the whole military junta having their grasp in every branch of the government, making it impossible to hold a democratic government since the military can just easily invalidate the result of a democratic election.
If any, you should be 'thanking' Gen. Wiranto of Indonesian Army instead for not taking over the government upon the power vacuum as the result of Soeharto's resignation, even if he had the chance and power to do so. Instead he relinquished the power back to the people. He's the reason we didn't turn into what is Myanmar like today
@@batrickpatemanbut soeharto want to step down not die hard like junta in Myanmar.
And proverty line in soeharto 32 years is in 1967-1998 from 60% to 14% before Asian Monetary crisis
Corruption in Tatmadaw causes problems of logistics and supplies in military operation. The leak of weapons from corrupt officers to the hands of rebels causes demoralisation in Tatmadaw's soldiers.
@@mrzb987 lie. the real story is Christian villager form militia they fight back because Jihadist and Sudan army butcher Christian villager. the one USA support is North Sudan(MUSLIM Politician). even USA is Christian country in general they supporting Sudan Government which today is North Sudan. the South Sudan is the respond for neglecting Religious Freedom in Sudan Years discrimination toward Christian population in the south make People especially the Farmer angry. the USA backing North Sudan because they have a lot of Oil even it was Islamic Government
Коррупционеров и предателей убивать вместе с семьями. Простой рецепт.
@@mrzb987 when muslims will understand who their friend is?
The reason Myanmar conflict is too easy to understand. They have too many different group, on Wiki mostly of rebel against government. But that's not the case, the reason is too many different groups mean different leader, too many leader will lead to different opinions. So who's in charge of this? Of course the government failed to stop many rebel creating group. Look at other countries there only one military, it's called government or state. Myanmar allowed too many rebels, that's won't help Myanmar stop the war or peaceful country. They will against the new government even it's democracy or not. Because of the power want to be in the office.
@@whatareyou1679 They should blame on themselves for not letting democracy process taking place to sort out whom have legitimacy to rule the country through a transparent,fair election. that engaged every people from diverse ethnics groups in the country so that their voices are heard.. instead they resort to junta forcing people to accept them, hence why people opt for the same route to topple gov... There's reactions for actions. this is the case for that.. if you opt for gun barrel to decide then hope for the same in return
Myanmar does NOT "face its biggest challenge".
You meant to say the Myanmar junta.
Can you explain the pro junta Buddhist nationalists protesting at the Chinese embassy for its alleged support of rebels during operation 1027?
Who told you the country’s president is Min Aung Hlaing. He was not a president in the past nor will not be in the future. Please use the words carefully. He is just the head of SAC (State Administration Council) formed after the coup in which contains high rank military officers and some civil persons.
Why cheated in the past election ? Follow the rule of democratic law . Many said buddha has helped the country from the evil and greedy military men.
It is disappointing to see a China publication refer to the illegitimate junta as the official government and the people of Myanmar fighting from their freedom as insurgents.
Only China can help Myanmar people for peace. Not the US the failed democratic system causing chaos in the world.
😂😂😂🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤ HALLELUJAH thk u!!! at LEAST someone KNOWS the evil WICKED history of the Myanmar Atrocities WICKED GAME! !!
Wasnt it the same with thailand when the military took over. Guessed what happened! The military is still current overlord.
Wishing peace for beautiful Myanmar 🇲🇲
Love and support to the Burmese people from the Philippines!
After they overthrow the military government, the different factions will be fighting each other, as it's been like ever since they got "freedom".
Myanmar is one of those countries that were better off under British rule.
Peace in Myanmar. Burmese people are beautiful and kind. Peace in Burma. From California, U.S.A.
The rebels are getting support from USA
@@jacklay8612Lol, you clearly don’t understand the history of Myanmar. The civil war started with a military coup to seize power.
Yeah so much so kind that they literally wiped out rohingas just cause they don't lookalike and practices different faith, imagine if Bangladesh were to do the same with it's hilltracks people who resembles nothing like Bengalis and are mostly related to Burmese ancestry.
Si vis pacem, para bellum
If want peace, prepare for war.
Kind and peaceful? Last time I checked most of them were supporting the rohingya ethic cleansing.
Freedom is worth fighting for.
No
@@Horus-j3f
Choose how you live for the rest of life: Slavery or Freedom!
Glory to the National Unity Government! 🇲🇲🇲🇲
No mention of HOW the brotherhood alliance armies, which previously have been defeated repeatedly and gone into the forest, all of a sudden achieved such success. Chinese media have reported on this. The alliance armies are now armed with many drones and Huawei phones...so take a guess.
It makes perfect sense from China's perspective. There should be rather easy to find someone them who would after Rebel's victory support close ties with China. On the other hand, Junta that is currently in power is isolationist.
My guess is Huawei phone has better signal reception than those military walkie talkie 😉
华为手机具备的卫星通讯功能，能在亚洲全地域（山地峡谷丛林）使用。除非是中美级别的技术能力，几乎无法被破解监听。@@Buntalman1995
China has asked Myanmar junta government to crackdown crime that spilled to china but they say they unable to do so, but the truth is everyone know those general also profiting from those crimes.
果敢同盟军是当年国民党军队残部，一直受台湾当局领导与支持。所以说，果敢同盟军的武器与手机都是台湾当局提供的
Any argument is pointless if it’s not for the people of Myanmar to be able to live as best they can. No one should care about which country is which. It’s simple. If someone is trying to suppress freedom, theyre enemies of Myanmar’s people.
Every nation suppresses freedom.
@genericscout5408: Some more than others. And, some more violently, and oppressively, than others.
CIA suppresses freedom and true democracy.
@@genericscout5408you’re ignorance is funny, are you trying to imply people in Myanmar or north korea have the freedom like the people in USA?
@@Jangz_ For a million people the answer is yes. It’s not very insignificant to talk about.
Hope peace and unity for Myanmar 🙏❤
I'm live in Myanmar we will not give up we will fight for freedom
Peace in Burma aka Myanmar. I want to return soon to Burma. From California, U.S.A.
keep fighting and stay well you will gain freedom
Eww
@@Horus-j3fgreat joke hahaha
@@Horus-j3f.............
We always support u and prayed for u all people peace force from mizoram all mizo people
The refugee situation is creating a national security risk for the India and China. It is also creating a humanitarian crisis as well.
Why do refugees constitute a national security risk? Surely India and China, each with 1.4 billion people, can handle a few hundred thousand refugees from a neighboring country without risking their national security.
@@pjacobsen1000 China isn't accepting any refugees. The only Burmese they accept are the Jade traders, many of whom are Burmese Muslims, who live and work in Yunnan and speak Mandarin and contribute to the Chinese economy. When it comes to other Burmese, they don't want them.
Chinas fault
The refugee should be sent back to their home and the Myanmar people who captured the refugees land hundreds of years ago should go back to their country and leave the land alone so that Rohingyas can make their own country in their own land and that's how peace can be resolved. They have different cultures, religion, different ethnicity so they cannot co-exist with one another no matter what they do
@@asianbreed3990 Myanmar is a pro China state why tf should india help it’s really just the ccp destroying burma
Myanmar has been facing internal disputes for decades. One of the remaining, critical questions is that if the junta government for example hands over its power to the Myanmar people, will internal conflicts/disputes still exist? For decades, even during the elected democratic party was in power/administration, there were also many internal issues such as the problem of Rohingya, ethnic and other social groups trying to separate from the central government for their own independence, so on and so forth.
In short, Myanmar does not only have problems with the junta, but also internal political and territorial disputes that have lasted for years. The local people need to focus more on addressing their own problems, rather than blaming others and/or external parties. All people's unity is the basic need.
As a neighbour, may i bless Myanmar with peace, unity, security and prosperity, and i do hope things in Myanmar get better soon 🙏
They could form a centralised government that can oversee common issues and the various ethnic states within that coalition being given more autonomy.
A decentralised republic perhaps.
The alternate of breaking into even smaller provincial independent states with some having no sea borders will not only make their existence and progress strenuous but it will set them on a path for future conflicts.
In my opinion they should break up into independent ethnic states under one country. Give each ethnic group a region and say I’m government. Seems the best way. What do you think?
@@erroneous6947that's how we got the Yugoslav wars, the Ethiopian war, the post Soviet wars etc...
It invites division upon ethnic lines, and has led to ethnic genocide.
I see what you mean, and I understand it, but you'd need an international force to oversee it initially and disarm all the ethnic groups.
The reason Myanmar conflict is too easy to understand. They have too many different group, on Wiki mostly of rebel against government. But that's not the case, the reason is too many different groups mean different leader, too many leader will lead to different opinions. So who's in charge of this? Of course the government failed to stop many rebel creating group. Look at other countries there only one military, it's called government or state. Myanmar allowed too many rebels, that's won't help Myanmar stop the war or peaceful country. They will against the new government even it's democracy or not. Because of the power want to be in the office.
@@mr.fantastic7756no u gotta disarm the myanmar military instead cause us ethnic keep our words we don’t want war in the first place
Finally this is discussed, in maynmaar, where no news and any media talk about, no one discuss about whats going on and what miserable happened in maynmaar pastly last year, the civil war killed many ppl😢
I'm glad that you can find information on what is going on. I've also been curious to learn details of what's happening too.
This is exactly why it's so important for journalists to have freedoms to share information on what's happening without governments restricting them.
Without this,
the news and information you get is nothing or extremely filtered based on what the government wants or doesn't want the people to hear.
I'm truly sorry for the bad situation in Myanmar..
The military junta currently running the country out of Naypyidaw has no jurisdiction. The UN does not recognise this regime. The State Administration Council has no legitimacy, and it has no legal authority over the citizens of Myanmar. _Chairman_ Min Aung Hlaing is *NOT* the Prime Minister of Myanmar. That title belongs to Mr. Mahn Win Khaing Than, leader of the National Unity Government.
The NUG is the true, legitimate government of Myanmar, fighting against the SAC terrorist insurgents. The “Rebels” you are referring to are the “People’s Defence Force”, the legitimate military of the Myanmar State.
Your journalistic rigour leaves much to be desired. Stop spreading propaganda, and start spreading the truth!
Words and labels used by journalists, always expose the bias.
Thank you for your clarification.
ဥပဒေ မဲ့ NUGသည်ငါတို့အစိုးရမဟုတ်ပါ သင်သုံးသပ်ချက်လွဲမှားနေပြီ ဥပမာ-မိမိ၏အကျင့်ကိုမိမိသာအသိဆုံးဖြစ်သည် l AM. MYANMAR
☝️ The comment above is a perfect example of the effect of propaganda. Don’t fall for the lies. The SAC has no legal right to power in Myanmar.
The SAC is a terrorist state illegally occupying Myanmar. The NUG is - by national and international law - the *rightful* government of Myanmar.
@@YoonMyat-us3jp မင်းပြောသလိုဆိုမင်းပထွေးစစ်ခွေးကလည်းငါတို့ပြည်သူတွေရဲ့အစိုးရမဟုတ်ပါအကြမ်းဖက်ဖက်ဆစ်သူခိုးဓါးမြမုဒိမ်းကောင်တွေနဲ့ဖွဲ့စည်းထားတဲ့သူခိုးအဖွဲ့သာဖြစ်ပါသည်
@@khinmg8731 မိမိ ယုံကြည်ရာပဲလေ နင်လည်းနင့်ယုံကြည်ရာ ငါလည်းငါ့ယုံကြည်ရာရိုင်းစိုင်းတဲ့စကားလုံးတွေတော့ ငါပထွေးမသင်ပေးဘူး ok
After overthrowing the Junta military. The 3 brotherhoods will wage war against each other for power. I just feel it.
Very much true 👍
When were you in Myanmar last ? I just came back from Mandalay 48 hours ago ..... My actual opinion is very different than the media news regarding the evolution of this conflict ....
Media is paid bro
do share
Support myanmar democratic from philippines
Хорошо под американцами лежать?
Myanmar will become like Yugoslavia. Separated into many nations.
Right 👍👍
People like to think the more the better, but trying to force many different nations into a single country is pointless when you can only do it through military subjugation, in the end there will be only conflict. And a lot of the former yugoslavian states are better off as their own country anyway
These border regions have been in conflict with the central government almost since the creation of modern Myanmar, except for when aung san suu kyi was in power... They'd be better off independent and Myanmar's neighbours will be better off as well.
May the people find peace, prosperity, assurance, and closure.
So mamy ethnic groups oppose junta's rule it seems
A corrupt army supported by a corrupt government controlled by an even more corrupt neighbor. Power to the people of Myanmar ✊🏻, it's liberation is coming soon!!
啊对对对，我们腐败的很，每天都吃不饱住山洞躲炸弹，现在我就在防空洞里回你评论🙄🙄
@@ahahamie8842打到美帝国主义！ 解放亚洲！
@@ahahamie8842人家说的是印度
@@user-oo8up3ko6l 哦好吧
They aren't the rebel. They are the legitimate democratically elected government of Myanmar!
This report isn’t accurate. It says the fighting is happening in the “poorest” part of Myanmar. Kokang is actually the 2nd richest part of Myanmar, just behind neighboring Wa State, which is already autonomous. It’s a Chinese-majority area and was self governed from 1989 to 2009. This is not the Myanmar government collapsing, it’s a well funded, PRC-backed militia re establishing an autonomous government in 1 corner of the country while the military is weak.
Correction, please. This is not an insurgency. It is a an armed revolution called by the people as Spring Revolution
The junta has been around since the 1960's. In recent years, the country enjoyed a brief semidemocracy due to political reforms. The military again grabbed power after losing to Aung San Suu Kyi's democratic party by a landslide. The junta wants dominance of the resource-rich country. The junta in fact controls much of the economy from beverage, real estate, transportation, communication, gems and minerals, banking, trade, and oil and gas.
The people and their duly elected officials have had enough of the greed and brutality of the junta. Thus, this revolution.
How does China and India involve in this?
I hope certain ethnic groups would find closure to decades-long under-representation in Myanmar. Perhaps independence or secession is the only way forward instead of being under military rule over and over again.
Wouldn't that mean splitting up to like 7 different states?
@@atomica0914 in their constitution, these states can secede anytime if the unitary gov't doesn't work. Throughout their turbulent history, they already wanted to secede because these ethnic groups are neglected. However, the country has been ruled by the military since its first coup, so their request to secede was not being recognized. These frustrations for generations is only reaching a tipping point. Either Myanmar rids itself of military rule and minimize their power or secede into different countries.
You are exactly what the junta forces want.
@@jorgethegreat most likely latter because there is no way you can remove a nail without bending the wood
From the looks of it, the rebels' priority right now is to sever the Tatmadaw's logistics coming from any external country bordering Myanmar so as to impede the junta. That, coupled with corruption in the Junta, could be the perfect recipe for its collapse.
Why does military keep interferring in governing their country? Do they know that military should only protect the country sovereignty and do not interfer in any internal government affairs?
The lure of power and the possibilities for wealth that go with it. Not for much longer, one hopes.
Myanmar's military had experience about that kinds of battles since beginning of independent. No need to worry about that and i''m also from Myanmar. Now this is major concern in our country but these rebels groups were always seek their own intrests and they take arms not because to protect civilian but to trade
drugs since before military take control government power.They had support advance technology like drones make difficult for military .That's all.
They were also killed many troops too.
I am Chinese. What do you think China should do to help Myanmar? I mean lasting peace and stability.
Correct this same rebel community causing conflicts even in manipur India
KNA KAREN are the real villian
What the associate professor Enze Han doesn't understand is that while the opposition doesn't have the hardware to "roll into" the capital like a foreign invading force like in the WW2 with tanks, the nature of asymmetric warfare will still result in the overthrow of the junta, and the capital will still fall, although not in the conventional sense of rolling tanks and armored vehicles. Our most recent assymetric example would be in Afghanistan, where a better equipped and trained Afghan army easily surrendered to the lightly equipped but highly motivated Taliban (not a comparison, just an example of asymmetry).
He did, which was why he mentioned it was hard for the 3 rebel forces to stage a take over for the heartland.
May be motivated... but such cases are only for power & resources... wait till they fi g8 themselves.... havnt learned from examples bcs dont want to
just look at syria before saying anything
@@weirdshit that is what he misunderstood also. The northern brotherhood alliance is not interested in capturing the capital, so they won't. They will hold the North. It is the southern forces and the PDF who will capture the capital.
@@NeverClimbing Syria is a very different dynamic. But the danger is there.
Whether the junta wins or loses, Myanmar has a tough future ahead
Stand tall , for you are the rightful, elected representatives of your country!
1. Everyone is six connections away 2. access anything in the world both digital and physical and 3. control the supply!!!!!!!!!
Change this headline! "Myanmar's" rule isn't being challenged. The genocidal junta is being challenged...BY MYANMAR.
This is democratic world , no Junta ,fight for your freedom ❤
Myanmar will be free!
Rakhaine will be a independent country.
Myanmar needs stability, give the military a chance to build a better future. Apart from that, if the military lose, all rebel factions will immediately fight each other.
Sure. The military dictstoeship will build a great future for their children living in europe
i hope Arakan can get back independent and rohingya people can safely return their homeland
You guys need to know arakan kingdoom is buddhusm rakhine kingdoom and 7 kinds if arakan officely belong it not rohingyas the imgriants bengalis
Please note. Min Aung Hlaing is not a country"s president. He is a criminal and military leader of a coup in 2021.
The NUG is the legitimate government of Myanmar and the president is U Win Myint, and the vice-president is Duwa Lashi Lais. The European Parliament has recognized the NUG as the legitimate government of Myanmar.in September 2021, the NUG established representative offices in the United States, United Kingdom, Norway, France, Czech Republic, Australia, and South Korea.
The junta are the rebels ...
These so-called analysts are so out of touch with the reality on the ground. Even Bamar people want the military eliminated and they have also been fighting the junta for more than 2 years now.
I wonder how the US is going to play though. This is clearly backed by China . Myanmar military never has a complete control over those areas and i wondered what made China pushed the button to approve the act of 1027 . Myanmar military never liked Chins but Myanmar has never choices. Now Russia is favoring Myanmar in these past months. I have no doubt that this will absolutely do nothing. Now AA can't support the whole Rakhine and so do for other ethic armed groups. Both of the soldiers from ethic armed groups are the usual Framers or wagers( not for AA I guess. AA always has so much soldiers that it is not able to support the whole chain). This is not sustainable for both sides. This definitely asked a lot of questions to upper seniors of Myanmar military's .
I support you all my brother who fight for you country democracy , you are all an inspiration ❤❤❤❤
I recently read a little bit from an article by the council of Foreign Relations about how if Myanmar experiences a state collapse, the U.S should be prepared to help out.
Really though, if Myanmar experiences state collapse, wouldn't this be the perfect opportunity for the United Nations to gain a little bit of legitimacy again? After Covid, Ukraine V. Russia, and Israel V. Hamas, and the various set backs the UN has experienced there, I think this would be the perfect place for them to shine.
We are fighting on our pwn but we need supporting in humanitarian aids and related assistance.
Are you still trying to introduce American power? Myanmar’s largest donor is China. China will not allow a pro-Western regime to emerge in Myanmar. If the Myanmar government is wise enough, it will not be unilaterally pro-Western, but will maintain friendly relations with both parties. No matter who is in power in the Myanmar government and has a bad relationship with China, the regime will It won't be stable.
@@user-ct3zo5kt1q And that's why Russia and china prompted the junta to go forward with the coup. I still remember the assistance china was providing the junta with the internet so that the people were cut off and information out of the country could be carefully controlled.
What a coincidence that the junta should take power right on the precipice of higher international cooperation…
Don't forget Myanmar is an ally of Israel, Russia, China and others. The collapse won't happen any time soon.
Myanmar will come under democracy. All the best👍
The beginning is when the rebels wins. The country will probably break into pieces with its own independant ethnic countries. They all speak different languages and has its own unique culture. Everybody in the country must speak burmese or english if they all want to unite under one banner.
Yes, in order to keep a country in one piece, it needs a unified language to start with.
The alliance will fight amongst themselves for power once they overthrow the Junta.
Fighting will go on in Myanmar in the future
@@iamvengeance7159that or they will make Suu Kyi president, already a popular figure.
@@PRubin-rh4sr she may be popular but her worth is diminishing day by day.
China won't allow that to happen.
Myanmar junta took their inspiratiom from Indonesia during Soeharto's era who got support from the West. After the fall of Soviet, the West no longer have interest to keep all military dictatorship government around the world.
Existential ?
An understatement
Congratulations
We, Myanmar People Strongly support.
Terrorist attacking Myanmar Army?
@@blackcoder5603 Myanmar army is and was always a terrorists group , the worst ever. we people have our elected government and all are against Myanmar so called army so this battles are there.
@@blackcoder5603 Right
The rebel's choice of flag is somewhat ominous!
Hopefully things calm down in a democratic direction....
Time for a change in regime
Seems like a wink of fate how their flag contains the current flag of Vietnam, itself the child of its Revolutionary forefathers, the Vietcong and Vietminh.
I think a decentralized Myanmar is what will be the best option. Letting each respective minorities have more autonomy and influence over their own region would make it easier to avoid a civil war. A semi copy of how the US is currently running their own country, just don't spend as much on the military. And most importantly a strong educational system so Myanmar wont have future generations romanticize the dictatorship, similiar to how Germany, Japan and Italy have done.
That’s what happened when a military general who is clueless on how to run a country took over the country of its peaceful citizens by force. Ask Thailand! The country is too volatile for economic growth and foreign investment.,, Military coup every few years? Sad!
India supports the freedom fighters. May you get freedom.
Ok Kashmir ,naga land and Khalistan must also be supported by the world
Kashmir, Manipur and Khalistan wants their freedom as well, hypocrite
@@AbuShivaToyibpakistan belongs to india
@@tukaidas1272 yes your mom said so too🤣😂🤣
Indian government support the junta government.
I don´t think it´s helpful to add obnoxious music to a serious video
việt nam ❤❤❤❤❤❤ myanmar
outside people do not know how people in myanmar living in poverty,fear,and injustic under military junta.
YES!... GLORY TO FREE MYANMAR!! 💪 FREEDOM WARRIORS!
The people united, can never be defeated.
Those militiamen have come a long way since the first weeks of the coup.
I remember when they are literally civilians with guns, whatever guns they can get.
Then I remember when they seek refuge with other minority freedom fighters, now they are this powerful, that they are leading to the destruxtion if Myanmar's Junta.
Dont forget that China supplied military hardware & equipment to the junta including fighter planes that was used against its people.
China supplied and supported Pol Pot’s regime and look what happened there.
Meanwhile people complain about US supporting Israel. What China is doing is no better
You are so smart. However, China will sell to anyone who can pay for them...'Art of business.'
You are farting. China supports the Three Brothers Alliance. They have no international knowledge at all and they just come out to tell jokes!
That is what democracy is about, inclusive participation and mutual cooperation. To benefit all the people.
Myanmar's Situation is the only thing where you'll actually support the rebels instead of the Gov't
i support govt Rebels will regret destroying their own country. they say they want freedom but they want chaos and myanmar to stop existing
@@Horus-j3fCry more dictator shill.
Why is the flag of the revolutionary similar to the flag of Vietnam?
Restoration of Democracy is the only answer to stop conflict in Mynmar.
lol. Democracy is what is wrong in this world
Copyright strike on the MNDAA flag for being too similar to Vietnam💀
Military still never learnt any lessons. Just to used power and soldiers to crush the people with different ethnic background will not help at all. They should learn from their neighbours like Thailand which have multi ethnic societies and yet they can co-exist with each other. Modernized Thailand. But Myanmar is really backwards and that's the prob. Military might will not help in long term.
agree, military junta should seek peace with the different rebel groups or atleast with majority of them and provide support for elections to reinstate a public government. the longer they wait, more complex the problem becomes since rebels are getting armed and corruption is will become widespread during conflict
Vietnam also has 54 ethnic groups coexisting, and the government is making every effort to ensure social security and support for minority ethnic groups.
At the Vietnamese point of view, I see that the Myanmar military government enjoys many privileges and economic benefits. That is a reason why Aung San Suu Kyi cannot control the situation, unable to use the military force to maintain security, and difficult to unify Myanmar when there are too many regional warlords.
@@kzamno1 I agreed about the multi ethnic groups in Vietnam. But as for Burma or Myanmar, they have long history in fighting among themselves and the junta military that suppressed and oppressed its own people. That's why there is wars everyway now in that country.
It is refreshing to see people defending their freedom.
All the best for MNDAA 💪 We are same fellow Han Nations, proud to be Chinese Descendants 🎉
Look at 2021, how many Burmese people paid for their life in this revolution. Junta are so brutal, they killed people in the middle of the street without any sign of warning. No one will know how Burmese people are suffering right now, hope justice will bring upon to Myanmar 🫶🏻
Pray for Myanmar, support for Myanmar
No matter who is in charge, Myanmar will always be a brutal dictatorship. Just ask the Rohingya who suffered genocide under the Aung San Suu Kyi government before it was overthrown. I honestly don't care who wins this fight.
No one asked you.😂 Myanmar was military dictatorship since 1962. In 2016, they handed over to suu kyi government just to overcome anger of public but actual control in hands of military. That was military who fled illegally migrated Rohingya bengolis in Myanmar. There was no genocide.
I think you should be aware that, the military under the ASSK government was in itself a rogue entity, it doesn't answer to civilians, it also held control of crucial departments in the government even though they weren't voted on to those offices(immigration, defense, etc...). What's sad is that the Rohinja are not the only ones being discriminated against, but also numerous other ethnicities who also happen to be christian, of course it doesn't fit your agenda(of the western media's). You should also look up on the massacre of 99 Hindu women under the Rohinja militants and the Rohingya's kidnapping and beheadeding of Buddhist monks, which you could say these are some of the factors that sparked the genocide which unfortunately targeted people nothing to do with those attacks.
@@kevincrest2608If she is a military puppet, then it is not a very smart move for the military to launch a coup and overthrow their puppet.
I mean, that's the whole reason for the start of the civil war, right?
Lol,the rohingya were terrorists they were a major security threat you should definitely search about the rohingya terror group and it's activities 😂
@@SirisenaDhammarakhita The Rohingyas are not illegals. They were considered indigenous to Myanmar until the Tatmadaw came to power. Aung San Suu Kyi's NUG literally has a Rohingya minister in her political party. There was a genocide and the Tatmadaw are behind it, ordinary Burmese realise what the Tatmadaw did and now support them.
If Myanmar 🇲🇲 are fighting for democracy 🤣 they soon find out democracy isn’t for them 🙏
The royal family of Burma 🇲🇲 needs to reinstated to stop the civil war
Poor suggestion
@@mawitevandir4986 give a rational
@@jamaicasysbm2580ah no. The junte just needs to return Burma to democrscy and there is peace
@@sH-ed5yf th country of Burma was quite okay until the imperial Britain 🇬🇧 depose the royal family which lead to a civil war in 🇲🇲 culminating in this military dictatorship and civil war.
@@jamaicasysbm2580 kid. Blaming the west for every conflict in the world is getting silly.
Why is one of the rebel force flag look like… Vietnam?
One of the Alliance group MNDAA was part of the former Communist Party of Burma (CPB)'s rebel forces during the Cold War. Back then the Military Junta followed the Marxism and CPB sided with the Maoists China during Sino-Soviet Split.
So a lot of communist related flag in Asia have similar designs.
Myanmar was forcefully "made "into a country by the British, however, with the nullification of the treaty that formed the Federation of Burma in the 1948 (by the Central Government themselves), the legitimacy of Myanmar no longer existed, and all provinces automatically revert back to their original state of self-government and sovereignty. Any military attack on these independent provinces therefore is an act of aggression.
Nonsense as an Indian there were various Burmese Empire
1. Everyone is six connections away 2. Access anything in the world both digital and physical and 3. control the supply chain!!!!
Kachins and Karens fought well under US Command (notably OSS Detachment 101) against the Japanese and Burmese forces during WW2. I'm surprised the US isn't trying harder to rekindle that relationship as a means to spread their influence, but I guess most people don't know that part of history.
Myenmar has some beautiful people . Stop this nonsense and treat them right ❤ recover your country to thrive
A Federal Parliamentary Government System must establish in Myanmar after the Junta's downfall
The ethnic groups want something in return, an autonomous rule in their region
So a Federal Government is the best answer to that
This SCMP news own’s by West?
Where is the WA state sponsored by China. 😂
China does not care who is in charge as long as there is a flow of goods
They are one of the many rebel groups.
2 Very important things MUST HAPPEN.. 1 ) Capture and arrest min aung Hlaing; 2 ) Release Daw Aung San Suu Kyi,and U Win Myint.
A paid posting, no doubt. Is SCMP on-site, or is it just reporting what it is being paid for?
Both
You don't like the reporting, why?
Perhaps you can point out any inaccuracies in the report?
@@pjacobsen1000 I think he’s mad that they get paid for their news stories.
It's now a fight against Tyranny of the military. Just hope the tribes don't fight among themselves after that!
When I hear this name, Myanmar, I remember all the massacres, torment, and injustice that our Rohingya Muslim brothers endured, and how their bodies were set on fire, reviving any human being who could do this to an innocent person. 😔
The Rohingyas were aggressors instead of victims. Check out what they did to the other races/ethnic groups first in Rakhine state.
@@perrycheong1058 lol 😂
😂😂😂 rohingya muslim brother ??? Really ?
The army led by the junta leaders committed atrocious war crimes on the Rohingya. It was not Myanmar, but the army generals who did not have to report to the civilian government.
@@perrycheong1058Yes, this is the state of the hypocritical, racist world. They commit crimes and then pin charges on the oppressed and condemn him because he does not follow their beliefs. They want him to renounce his nature, deny himself, and follow others as if he were a flock that must be led as they please.
The blood of innocents will not go in vain. Remember this well that the justice of the Creator will avenge these innocent Rohingya Muslims.
The tatamadaw Military Junta - SAC wants to live a Myanmar Life of a 1902s Kingdom of Dynasty... and still after 119 years?
US is silence with this 🙄🙄
Scared of China 😂😂
No, they are discreetly arming the rebel group with weapons
Northern Chinese warlords (who were called rebels) and the junta government. It will be so awkward and funny if US support any side of them. Lol😂🎉
Thanks 🙏
This is an unfortunate situation for India, on either sides of our borders there’s military conflicts. On the west, Pakistan and it’s military than owns the country. On the north, China and the CCP that rules with an iron fist and huge army. In the east, we have Myanmar and the Junta. Be fantastic if all these issues get sorted so we can get to development and integration of the sub-continent with SE Asia and bring benefits for one and all.
You could take in lots of refugees. Do it
im sorry for missing it
Biased and misinformed.
@@virgiliomateus4239 nope it's true
Next will be northeast India 💪💪💪 free northeast from Hindu cows
Let's eat beef steak
1967 1000 Chinese killed by Indians and lost Sikkim
@@misterbig9025 after independent surely 😂
@@Bootymoneycreditsqaud 1963 900million India surrender to china