Who Are Pearl's REAL Parents?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 авг 2024
  • I absolutely love SpongeBob SquarePants. As a matter of fact, I reviewed the ENTIRE first season and I'm working on a video covering the first part of season 2 now. Here's a link to my review of season 1 just in case you missed it: • Reviewing The BEST sea...
    Now, as much as I love this show, it always left me with questions. One of the biggest being where did Pearl come from and how did her father end up being a crab? It's a question that's been asked many times and never directly answered, however there have been many theories to pop up on the internet over the years. Today, on our nostalgic walk down memory lane, I'm going to explain my theory AND provide you with evidence to support it.
    Check out my Patreon to support me directly: Patreon.com/dusktillshawn
    Thank you for watching!
    Follow me on Twitter: @DuskTillShawn9
    Ready for another nostalgic walk down memory lane? Check out this playlist:
    • Most Iconic Episodes
    For Business inquiries email: dusktilshawn9@gmail.com

Комментарии • 250

  • @Hack_Man_VII
    @Hack_Man_VII Месяц назад +438

    Since Mr Krabs was in the Navy, I just assumed Pearl was an orphan he adopted.

    • @BrandonScott-mi5pz
      @BrandonScott-mi5pz Месяц назад +2

      GREAT DUSKTILL SHAWN MR.KRAB DAUGHTER PEARL REAL PARENTS VIDEO,

    • @Sasha-vb3mh
      @Sasha-vb3mh Месяц назад +4

      😂😂😂😂

    • @aresrivera9744
      @aresrivera9744 Месяц назад +9

      Yeah, after he killed her mother

    • @bbygrunge
      @bbygrunge Месяц назад +4

      I like this theory :3

    • @Johan_Wolfgang_von_Goethe
      @Johan_Wolfgang_von_Goethe Месяц назад +8

      That would imply that whales are the spongebob equivalent of Vietnamese,as MR Krabs fought in the war(he was born in 1942 so the only war he was able to be enlisted for was the Vietnam war)

  • @kooger888
    @kooger888 Месяц назад +270

    i personally believed since he was a war vet, one of his war buddies died at some point. she had no other family so he etheir choose or was asked to take care of her, and could have helped cure his depression.

    • @Shoebil
      @Shoebil Месяц назад +61

      Orphaned child is far more realistic than the abduction theory.

    • @kathleenwoods8416
      @kathleenwoods8416 Месяц назад +8

      But that's such a normal reason.

    • @Shoebil
      @Shoebil Месяц назад +11

      @@kathleenwoods8416 good point. We love unhinged behaviours.

  • @youtubeuniversity3638
    @youtubeuniversity3638 Месяц назад +158

    "It's a giraffe!" - Patrick Star's only commentary on this video.

  • @izzyrose2424
    @izzyrose2424 Месяц назад +130

    I saw a picture years ago of Mr. Krabs, finding baby Pearl next to her harpooned mother and taking her in. And that has always been the backstory of them in my mind.

    • @btshea9537
      @btshea9537 Месяц назад +21

      I agree with that and I think that’s the backstory. Ever since I was a kid I had a feeling Pearl was always adopted and people always said how does he have a whale for a daughter? I would always say it’s because she’s adopted, but we never knew the backstory to why, but I believe her mother being harpooned is the backstory.

    • @aresrivera9744
      @aresrivera9744 Месяц назад +12

      That was from Alex Bale some he had commissioned to fit his evolution theory .

    • @danmulholland1634
      @danmulholland1634 Месяц назад +7

      Yes I sae that few years ago and im skeptical it seems ti make sense but we do see in 1 episode a picture if mr krabs brining pearl home after she was born so I'm sirta 50/50 on wether it can fit in or not

  • @yaboimccoy8109
    @yaboimccoy8109 Месяц назад +72

    another theory that's plausible is that mr krabs and pearl's dad were in the navy together, and mr krabs is pearl's godfather. pearl's biological dad dies, and mr krabs now has custody of pearl

    • @DuskTillShawn
      @DuskTillShawn  Месяц назад +25

      I can definitely see that being the case! Mr. Krabs was always really close with his Navy buddies!

    • @lukespillman1313
      @lukespillman1313 Месяц назад +6

      @@DuskTillShawn I remember seeing something that someone drew online, and it's a story of how Mr. Krabs adopted Pearl after her biological mother was harpooned to death.

  • @walpoleandworcester
    @walpoleandworcester Месяц назад +140

    I still think Pearl is adopted, just like how Heffer was adopted by the Wolfes.

    •  Месяц назад +2

      What series does that reference?

    • @djmocha7
      @djmocha7 Месяц назад +6

      Rocko’s Modern Life

    •  Месяц назад +2

      @@djmocha7 Thank you.

    • @danmulholland1634
      @danmulholland1634 Месяц назад +2

      Ever since 1999 when I first sae this show I was always wanting an answer for pearls backstory and 25 years later we still never got it i honestly feel they dont want to explain it since I bet at the time they did not know spongebob would become this big and it prob became ti complex fir them to write sometbing fir it and just keep Pearl an episodic character

  • @supernova4217
    @supernova4217 Месяц назад +70

    I always figured she was a daughter of one of his war buddies who didn’t make it back or was orphaned by the war

    • @danmulholland1634
      @danmulholland1634 Месяц назад +1

      Itd possible i feel after 25 years now without an explanation they might never answer this and leave pearl as a side character it may just be up to us fans to decide

  • @warrenmfouapon
    @warrenmfouapon Месяц назад +189

    I think there should have been more krabs and pearl episodes, with krab being less cheap, and Pearl less bratty.

    • @perrycoffey5410
      @perrycoffey5410 Месяц назад +18

      That would have been pretty cool episodes

    • @coconutrillion7021
      @coconutrillion7021 Месяц назад +8

      Agree.😊

    • @joseph-pf5fr
      @joseph-pf5fr Месяц назад +24

      With a dad that cheap pearl has a right to be bratty

    • @warrenmfouapon
      @warrenmfouapon Месяц назад +11

      @@joseph-pf5fr you're not wrong but hey, remember when Pearl saw her dad choking says "oh dad, you're embarrassing me again", or when mr Krabs gave her and her friends free water, she says thanks dad with a angry look for no reason.
      Or all those times where she act intolerant towards him. And the only times krabs act cheap were The Slumber Party, Whale of Birthday.
      We saw him giving Pearl the shoes she wanted in Squeaky Boots, or when he wasted money for her in Bossy Boots, or when he gave her money without exitation in Tutor Sauce. Krabs is not that horrible as dad, with a few exceptions

    • @chocov1233
      @chocov1233 Месяц назад +9

      They've been flanderized since Season 5, all the characters have. The second movie was good and we had a few good episodes in the 2 or so seasons following it (when Stephen Hillenburg came back to work on the show more, R.I.P), but honestly the show's characters have lost most of the little nuance the had in the first three seasons and the first movie.

  • @jenneacubero1036
    @jenneacubero1036 Месяц назад +40

    Is this why Krabs' family don't seem to know about Pearl? Krabs' grandpa didn't seem to recognize her at all.

    • @danmulholland1634
      @danmulholland1634 Месяц назад +9

      Yes and we never saw mama krabs and pearp together and she seems very close to her son mr krabs my guess is they could see eachither off screen visits but thisnis what happens when a series goes on for so long they change details

  • @sketchyskies8531
    @sketchyskies8531 Месяц назад +60

    I never questioned the thought of how Sandy’s dome got down there but I am now

    • @ZimVader-0017
      @ZimVader-0017 Месяц назад +10

      They did make an episode where it was revealed that she was sent to Bikini Bottom for an extended scientific investigation, so I just always assumed that they sent an entire team of engineers to build the dome down there.

    • @MeanBeanComedy
      @MeanBeanComedy 28 дней назад

      She's an undercover agent. She works with the showrunners to keep things from getting out of control, and keeps SpongeBob from finding out he's on a show.

  • @ivanbluecool
    @ivanbluecool Месяц назад +60

    Mr krabs knows not having pearl would save him money. But he probably doesn't ever think to give her up as that's his dear daughter pearl showing while he loves money pearl is definitely above money

    • @raelogan
      @raelogan Месяц назад +14

      He tore out his own solid gold tooth to bribe Squidward into not calling the police on him while he was raiding Squidward's fridge for Pearl during her growth spurt. He did not even hesitate.
      Krabs definitely cares about Pearl, she's just in competition with his love of money. 👀

  • @lydiajulianprower8356
    @lydiajulianprower8356 Месяц назад +33

    I never really thought of it as a kid. I just assumed that Mr. Krabs had a wife that was a whale, had Pearl, and fell for Mrs Puff some time after the loss of his first wife.

    • @danmulholland1634
      @danmulholland1634 Месяц назад +5

      I think its just as likely nickeldoen or Stephen hillenburg just about never put much thought into it when they started spongebob and they still never really touch on these details and just move forward on the episodic level then real conclusion

  • @warrenmfouapon
    @warrenmfouapon Месяц назад +120

    No, Mr Krabs married a dollar in an episode called married to money

    • @Firestar-TV
      @Firestar-TV Месяц назад +6

      lol that was so damn stupid. How did he even think there's actually living Money?

    • @warrenmfouapon
      @warrenmfouapon Месяц назад +3

      @@Firestar-TV it was Plankton disguised to get the formula, yeah another Imitation Krabs rip-off

    • @Firestar-TV
      @Firestar-TV Месяц назад +4

      @@warrenmfouapon I know. But why is Mr. Krabs so delusional.
      The only Animal I know of that are Kind of like Money, are Sand Dollars and they don't even look close.
      Guess they gave him the same Treatment as Squidward in the new Episodes and lobotomized him🙃

    • @pjthemaster1
      @pjthemaster1 Месяц назад +5

      That same episode he says something along the lines of “your finally gonna have a mother pearl”

    • @b0ltun0
      @b0ltun0 Месяц назад +1

      it was probably a dream lmaoooo

  • @TheIntelligentElephant71133
    @TheIntelligentElephant71133 Месяц назад +44

    They need to do a special where they reveal who pearls mom is or I hope they reveal it in the 4th SpongeBob movie

    • @danmulholland1634
      @danmulholland1634 Месяц назад +3

      Ive been waiting for an answer for this and yet 25 years still none I wonder if nickeldoen or Stephen hillenburg ever even thought of this when they started spongebob

  • @ItsSoDane
    @ItsSoDane Месяц назад +24

    Wrong. In SpongeBob SquarePants, Pearl Krabs' mother is a whale. A 2016 skit performed by Lori Alan and Rodger Bumpass at Dragon Con confirmed that Pearl is not adopted and that her mother was a whale. A 2000 trivia book written by former SpongeBob writer David Fain also states that Pearl "takes after her mother," implying that she is Mr. Krabs' biological child with a whale.

    • @Chimeragui
      @Chimeragui Месяц назад +12

      Not to mention Puff is explicitly stated to be a widow in the episode that introduced Krabs’ romantic interest in Puff

    • @maymay5600
      @maymay5600 Месяц назад +6

      i remember that scene which is funny because meaning he knew her mother

  • @tdflky9944
    @tdflky9944 Месяц назад +17

    In the episode, Growth Spout, Mr. Krabs says he got Pearl's bed when she was a newborn.
    In the episode, Whale of a Birthday, there's a banner saying It's a Boy with Boy crossed out and Girl is written. And Mr. Krabs said he got that on the day she was born. If he crossed out Boy, then that must mean he was expecting a baby boy.
    Perhaps there was a surrogate involved? 🤔

    • @danmulholland1634
      @danmulholland1634 Месяц назад +4

      That's possible but when I saw that I just laughed in the sense that he probably got that for free or very maybe he could not find a sign saying its a girl and changed it himself with him being cheap anyway

  • @allysoncashdollar1119
    @allysoncashdollar1119 Месяц назад +11

    I feel like it would be a really good episode of Pearl questioning where she came from and going on an adventure to figure it out.

  • @cofagrigusfan24
    @cofagrigusfan24 Месяц назад +7

    I personally go with the Krabs saving Pearl route
    but instead of poachers, it was Mr. Krabs himself who shot the mother by accident
    he would feel regret and terrible about what he did, so he adopted Pearl and promised himself to give her the best life he could give

  • @bbygrunge
    @bbygrunge Месяц назад +5

    Hear me out hear me out , they went on the run SEPARATELY without knowing where each of them was going, and then when Mrs. Puff went to the Krusty Krab it was their first time seeing each other again since they were on the run, so it was like fate finding each other again, that’s why Mr. Krabs reacted the way he did. He was genuinely excited but knew he had to tell SpongeBob a different story.

  • @lemns8296
    @lemns8296 Месяц назад +15

    they do age, pearl had a 16th birthday, and squidward had a birthday too, maybe pearls mom was a close friend and she died

  • @GnomeCat
    @GnomeCat Месяц назад +13

    I imagine Mr. Crabs steeling Pearl just to not pay child support.

  • @MrJay-nd1rg
    @MrJay-nd1rg Месяц назад +30

    Yes sir he delivers again

  • @JadoDog
    @JadoDog Месяц назад +12

    "Theres never been a time thats shown Mr. Krabs with any other love interest"
    Meanwhile Mr. Krabs has been caught in a hot tub with his money 👀😂

  • @remyoung
    @remyoung Месяц назад +10

    One of my favorite SpongeBob topics, I love weird cartoon theory territory!
    I literally say this almost every time, but I love your videos and am thankful for the fun or sometimes sad walks down memory lane

  • @disthecord5155
    @disthecord5155 Месяц назад +12

    Bro, I’ve always wondered where pearl comes from. There are so many theories on the internet about this that are very interesting. However, in a canonical and non-theoretical sense, I guess it will remain kind of a mystery to everyone

  • @nostalgialodeon9305
    @nostalgialodeon9305 Месяц назад +6

    I’d love to see you talk about Friend or Foe! That’s one of my favorite specials from the series and Its a great episode that focuses on Krabs and Planktons past friendship

  • @OfficialCyaned
    @OfficialCyaned Месяц назад +7

    I remember that animation by Cooler2000 which gave an idea of where Pearl came from. If Pearl was adopted, that would honestly be wholesome.

  • @masonkooistra3854
    @masonkooistra3854 Месяц назад +15

    Am I the only one who never questioned it as kid and completely accepted that a crab had a whale as a daughter? 😂

    • @chocov1233
      @chocov1233 Месяц назад +2

      I thought she was an adopted orphan like Dick Grayson Robin when I was younger.

    • @shadenox8164
      @shadenox8164 Месяц назад +2

      I still do that. It doesn't matter to them, so why should it matter to me? Who is Pearl's real parents? Mr. Krabs obviously.

  • @cranberrycracker6847
    @cranberrycracker6847 Месяц назад +5

    These are the kind of youtube theories I miss from 2012 to 2016 growing up. Love these vids

  • @kaylagaymon4873
    @kaylagaymon4873 Месяц назад +10

    I really want to know what happens to Pearl's mother. Krabs and Mrs. Puffs had a beautiful relationship
    🤔🤔🤔💖💖💖

  • @Backwood_Barbie
    @Backwood_Barbie Месяц назад +6

    I’ve been binge watching your channel for days now. Thank you for another upload!

  • @giovanniorellana2200
    @giovanniorellana2200 Месяц назад +7

    Thanks for another great video Shawn!

  • @pembrokelove
    @pembrokelove Месяц назад +3

    I just always assumed that Pearl was his adopted- or step- daughter, and that her mother died some time before the start of the show.

    • @danmulholland1634
      @danmulholland1634 Месяц назад +1

      Its possible but I wonder if they'll ever explain after 25 years prob not leaving it to us to decide

  • @the1magageneral323
    @the1magageneral323 Месяц назад +6

    I take the side of the theory that Mr. Krab took part in a war where he murdered a whale that turned out to be Pearl's mother, adopted the orphan whale. Also I think the Krabby patty is made out of whale meat, because it sounds like Krabby doing that.

  • @Tessu434
    @Tessu434 Месяц назад +3

    I'd like to direct your attention to Season 1 Episode 20 "Hooky" as Mr. Krabs at least knowing of Pearl's mom. He gets poked by one of the hooks while lecturing SpongeBob and Patrick and screams, "AH! Mother of Pearl! Fire on the poop deck."
    As far as I can remember that was the first mention of Pearl's mom. Even if it was for a more comedic effect.
    Even Spongebob repeats this in Season 2 Episode 12 The Smoking Peanut when he reacts to the oyster's pearl hatching at the end of the episode and exclaiming " Mother of Pearl! The oyster's a mother!" Now granted I'm sure Spongebob only said this after hearing Mr. Krabs shout it first in a prior episode, so we can't confirm he knows her personally.
    But seeing as both instances were uttered as a quick reaction, I can imagine this was the way the show went for the character to exclaim the equivalent of "Holy crap!" or some other saying I'm not aware of with the words, "Mother of". "god" perhaps? Idk.
    Maybe there was some form of extreme when it came to Pearl's mom, either through her actions or personality wise. What can you imagine would make you exclaim something out loud related about your child's mom like it was a thing to do? Was she infamous/famous? Just something to think about.
    Anyways that was my 2 cents and just happened to swing by through the recommended feed. I used to binge SpongeBob with one of my oldest friends back when we were kids and I happened to remember those specific lines. Hope this helps! Sorry if it doesn't!
    But also do NOT expect continuity in this show, especially with the constant change of hands and the original creator no longer able to work on the show. RIP

    • @lizzybeary
      @lizzybeary Месяц назад +2

      Mother of pearl is a type of material. So im thinking its just an exclamation with a sea theme.

    • @Tessu434
      @Tessu434 Месяц назад +1

      @@lizzybeary I see what you're saying 'Nacre' aka mother of pearl. That was an interesting search and it really does fit the theme of the ocean.
      Still find it an odd choice of words as it was used in the show as seen in my previous post, especially if it is related to that material.
      Here my child brain was thinking they were making a joke of someone's mom, but you certainly could be correct!

  • @warrenmfouapon
    @warrenmfouapon Месяц назад +6

    Mr Krabs and Mrs Puff love story was forgotten, but in the newer seasons there will be a lot of episodes with them

    • @danmulholland1634
      @danmulholland1634 Месяц назад

      Yeah I thought they were done and was sirta fine with that seems wierd to ke they left it alone for a long time and just brought it back

  • @ivanbluecool
    @ivanbluecool Месяц назад +12

    I always guessed he probably found her after the war as a baby or at the tail end of it all before he went back home to bikini bottom.
    Mr krabs is very old while pearl is only 16 so it's possible

  • @sciencehumanmeatpatty
    @sciencehumanmeatpatty Месяц назад +1

    I never questioned it as a child and at that point in my life, I liked it that way because it showed that not all families look the same and not all people have two parents. I also assumed that he named her and gave her the name of a precious material because he valued her as much as he valued money.

  • @AwkwardSegway95
    @AwkwardSegway95 Месяц назад +1

    I like the theory in one of Alex Bale's videos that Mr. Krabs killed Pearl's mom in the war, then found Pearl and adopted her because he felt bad about causing her to be an orphan.

  • @Sojoboscribe
    @Sojoboscribe Месяц назад +2

    Here's my theory.
    Mr. Krabs is Pearl's stepdad. Pearl's mother was very rich, and Mr. Krabs married her for her money. When she died, Mr. Krabs discovered she had actually left the money to Pearl's, with him as custodian and executor until Pearl turned 18.
    This explains why, even though he tries to be as cheap with her as with everyone else, he occasionally has to buckle and spend money keeping her happy. His time is running out (by show canon, Pearl is actually now seventeen). He gets out of line, and she's out of there, taking the majority of his fortune with her. His ability to stay well off relies on staying in Pearl's good graces.
    The Mrs. Puff dating thing is probably either a timing error on the part of the show creators. Or a product of the time limbo of the cartoon (the same as the fact that, under my theory, since Pearl was 16-17 the first time we saw her, she'd have WELL passed the age of majority by now;she'd be in her thirties.)

  • @madnessjones9996
    @madnessjones9996 Месяц назад +4

    Yay! You’ve added theories to the types of videos you’re willing to make 😁

    • @DuskTillShawn
      @DuskTillShawn  Месяц назад +2

      I had so much fun working on this one! It's a lot different to approach from my usual content and it's always great to try something new :D

  • @akganimationstudioproducti3779
    @akganimationstudioproducti3779 Месяц назад +3

    I know Hillenburg made a rule NOT to reveal Pearl’s mother, but after all these years, would it hurt to have an official explanation?

  • @AliciaNyblade
    @AliciaNyblade Месяц назад +2

    This is now my headcanon, too. You're a genius, This is brilliant.

    • @DuskTillShawn
      @DuskTillShawn  Месяц назад +1

      Thanks friend! :D
      I'm glad you enjoyed the video.

  • @patcahill3724
    @patcahill3724 Месяц назад +4

    Can you please cover the marvelous misadventures of flapjack someday, cover mechanical genie island

  • @amandanye4087
    @amandanye4087 Месяц назад +1

    I love your take on this Shawn! Thank you as always for your content

  • @AllenVoidUTAU
    @AllenVoidUTAU Месяц назад +1

    the theories themself are really interesting, so on that aspect, great work! I think looking into the criminal history aspect of both Mrs. Puff and Mr. Krabs is a very interesting dive to take, and it does still leave so much room for future evaluation on both sides.
    Video wise, I feel like each point was a bit too short to split up as frequently as they were in the video. I feel like a few minutes to a few smaller points/theories that fit together and separating based on general time (say like- first few years, after the adoption, etc.) would flow a lot better, and would prevent the amount of frequent transitions present in the video. While the presence of transitions to points isn't at all bad, it just gets a little jarring when every 1 to 2 minutes, or say- every 1 or 2 statements, there's another transition. It makes it a bit hard to focus, whether as background noise or as someone fully engaging.
    Overall, you're doing really well in your experimentation with your videos, and I do hope it's been fun for you! Keep up the great work, and I hope to see more in the future!

  • @BeeKee404
    @BeeKee404 Месяц назад +2

    Now I wanna see someone make a fan made film on this theory! Come to think of it, I don't I ever had any actual theories on how Krabs got Pearl. The ones that come to mind where from other people like Pearl's parents were killed and Krabs took her in or he once dated a whale. However, a theory I just now came up with is suppose Pearl isn't a whale at all. The reason I say this is cause in the episode The Algae's Always Greener, Plankton remarks about Krabs' daughter by saying "look at his daughter she's as big as a whale." Suppose she's only seen as a whale by the other characters because of her large and strong appearance and she's been a victim of body shaming. This is probably a major reach but it's just a random thing that came to mind as I was writing this comment. 😂

  • @youtubeuniversity3638
    @youtubeuniversity3638 Месяц назад +1

    20:40 Could also be she remarried as part of the cover up and disposed of him herself after, wanting him for the cover up value but not wanting him to pry too much through her past.

  • @KamikazeDreamer
    @KamikazeDreamer Месяц назад +2

    I love that Pearl's VA was also The Boss from Metal Gear Solid 3

  • @Jordan-k1f
    @Jordan-k1f Месяц назад +3

    One thing to prove mr krabs and ms puff knew eachother is in camp coral he runs a food truck in the camp ms puff owns meaning they would’ve had to interact

  • @larryjester
    @larryjester Месяц назад +1

    Maybe Mr. Krabs was good friends with Pearls mom. Not in a friends with benefits kind of way. Or maybe he served with her real dad in the war, he was killed and upon delivering the news to his widow, she died of heartache. Krabs noticed they had a daughter and he adopted her from there... or just took her.

  • @Bugaboo173
    @Bugaboo173 Месяц назад +2

    What if Pearl is his stepdaughter? What if Mr. Krabs fell in love with Pearl's mom, got married, and then Pearl's mom died or left? And for some reason or another Pearl's dad isn't involved and Mr. Krabs got custody of her and raised and loved her as his own?

  • @VanillaBelleASMR
    @VanillaBelleASMR Месяц назад +1

    I think it was a fan art but it was Mr. Krabs finding Pearl under her dead mother’s body after the mom was killed by whalers and he adopted her. I believe that one personally 🥰

  • @ashesandroses7485
    @ashesandroses7485 Месяц назад +1

    Very regular viewer here! I’m so happy you’re talking more about SpongeBob! My favorite videos of yours have been about the wild thornberrys and rugrats. I love Klasky Csupo so much :) I loved this new style of video, I thought the title cards were so fun, even though I’m usually just an audio only viewer. Have a good night!

  • @Sojoboscribe
    @Sojoboscribe Месяц назад +1

    One big problem with a former life for Mr. Krabs. Unlike Mrs. Puff, Mr. Krabs has FAMILY living in Bikini Bottom. We've seen his mother, his father and his grandfather on different occasions, and at least his mother appears to be a permanent resident. If he had started a new life with a new name, he'd have had to drag ALL of them with him; setting up new homes and identities for his parents and letting his grandpa know where he was. Plus, we know Mr. Krabs and Plankton have known each other since childhood. This all points to Mr. Krabs being a born resident of Bikini Bottom.

  • @john-davidmorris7200
    @john-davidmorris7200 Месяц назад +1

    Is everyone forgetting about one of the newer episodes where SpongeBob and Patrick go to prison thinking it’s summer camp and there was a whale with the prisoners aka pearls dad

  • @SoulKrosis
    @SoulKrosis Месяц назад

    I love videos like this. Presenting an angle that wouldn't be in the show but is totally in character. Love it!

  • @deandredukes95
    @deandredukes95 Месяц назад +3

    Unfortunately, mayonnaise isn’t a instrument nor is horse radish sadly 😢

  • @cmtvable1
    @cmtvable1 Месяц назад +1

    If Brian Griffin can have a human son (who is also a teen), it's not beyond the realms of SpongeBob logic that Pearl really is Mr Krabs' daughter.

    • @danmulholland1634
      @danmulholland1634 Месяц назад

      Yeah cartoon logic can go anyway compared to ours

  • @charlesnewman6468
    @charlesnewman6468 Месяц назад +1

    The secret recipe is
    Whale meat! How do you think Crabs can have that much meat in his restaurant? And Mr. Krabs' returning from war or being depressed after the war is why he has Pearl he killed her parents and is using Pearl to fatten her up and then if there is a shortage at the restaurant, he could just use.....Pearl.

  • @ZimVader-0017
    @ZimVader-0017 Месяц назад +1

    From the episode where Mr. Krabs and Mrs. Puff were dating, I always assumed that they were both widows who were just starting to take steps into dating again, which is really cute. I wish they showed them together in the background more often other than just those two episodes. (The second one I wasn't aware of until now since I haven't watched Spongebob for several years, so thanks fo that 😄).
    I say widows because of that one gag where Krabs asks what happened to Mr. Puff, and they just show a lamp made out of a puffer fish and Spongebob being like, "She doesn't like to talk about it." (Come to think of it, maybe that's why she moved to Bikini Bottom with a new name? 🤔)
    Maybe he was married at some point with Pearl's mother, or, as others have mentioned, another favorite theory is that Pearl's adopted. Whatever it is, something happened to Pearl's mother, which caused her to be out of the picture.
    (About your comment on it not being easy to kidnap a baby from a hospital. It has happened. Several times. There was even a whole scandal in Spain where the church was involved where they would tell the mothers that their newborn babies had died, when in reality they were being taken and sold to multimillionaires back during the 50s and 60s. There was a case some years back where a girl found out that she had been stolen from the hospital as a baby. Her kidnapper disguised herself as a nurse and took her. It would probably be very difficult now because of the cameras everywhere and because it's virtually impossible to NOT leave a paper trail after you these days, but back then it was certainly possible.)

  • @ethbeatthem4836
    @ethbeatthem4836 Месяц назад +1

    I mean, Mr. Krabs could have been through a Godfather system for Pearl, if Pearl birth parents are no longer in the picture, then Mr. Krabs take over as Pearl guardian, what if Pearl the daughter of old Navy friend that Krabs knew, but when passing with his wife (or in-prison if one Idea is though true) then Krabs take in Pearl as his own Child.

  • @amandaandherstuffedanimals1308
    @amandaandherstuffedanimals1308 Месяц назад +1

    I always thought that maybe Mr. Krabs found pearl during the time when he was in the Navy. She found her as an orphan with a dead whale during the war and she was all alone till mr. Krabs as her own blaming himself for what
    happened at the same time wanted a child and Mrs. puff so half of this could be true and soon later, he probably found out that part of his Krabby Patty recipe was whale to eat plans to maybe kill pearl later on and make more cry patties. I’m not sure if that’s true but it could be he does like me a quick buck

  • @hexxidelux6224
    @hexxidelux6224 Месяц назад +2

    Real world crabs and puffers can't breed, no, but this is a cartoon - one meant to NOT make sense, at that. I'd say all 3 are likely:
    1, She might be a secret love child btween the two, because cartoon logic exists in that world.
    2 Mr. Krabs could have kidnapped her
    3. *and possibly the most likely one) Pearl was a war orphan Mr. Krabs adopted in the Navy

  • @austinlee4156
    @austinlee4156 Месяц назад

    Bro u chose the best scene when talking about Pearl, SpongeBob's expression fits 10000% God choice dude

  • @joseph-pf5fr
    @joseph-pf5fr Месяц назад +1

    I think pearls mother is that squirrel from the episode pull up a barrel because"land mammal,marine creature,marine mammal,math"it is kind of implied that's how that universe works considering that thought bubble in the episode where spongebob and Patrick take of that baby scalup

  • @happi0420
    @happi0420 Месяц назад +1

    Pearls was the daughter of a navy buddy. He went to jail and krabs took her in. You can see him in the newer jail episodes. And in navy buddy pictures

  • @jenneacubero1036
    @jenneacubero1036 Месяц назад +1

    Another thepry is that Pearl is Krabs and Puff bio kid but the reason why she's born a whale was due to Krabs having whales in his family. How else would he aware of Pearl's growth spurt?

  • @Gadgetman1989
    @Gadgetman1989 Месяц назад +1

    13 secs ago!!! Gotta say to you Shawn, I love and adore your deep dives and I'm so proud of how you've been keeping up with everything and love all you post, it's always so nice to watch your videos!

  • @user-kz4ro9uq4q
    @user-kz4ro9uq4q Месяц назад +1

    the abduction theory doesn't really work with the characters. the timeline also most likely doesn't follow our own so the first meeting most likely be the actual first meeting. another thing is that peral would of still stand out fro being the only whale, also doubt the mother whale would of allowed her baby to be taken since the mother whale would be much bigger then the both of them.
    I think it more likely that crab did adopt peral or took her in as a orphan. are we sure that she was with crab as a newborn or later on? he would of have money or he wouldn't of got the restaurant. another thing is that if they did kidnap peral why would they commit crimes, it would give them a lot of attention which would lead to peral's discovery even in a small town.

  • @Samsyoutube-bk4rg
    @Samsyoutube-bk4rg Месяц назад

    17:36 this could also be why spongebob never passes his driving test. It's a connection to Mr crabs and pearl that isn't suspicious

  • @oldjebidiahbrown2454
    @oldjebidiahbrown2454 Месяц назад +1

    So where does Plankton fit into the equation? Because I'm pretty sure it's hinted at that Krabs and Plankton have always had a lifelong feud. If Plankton and Krabs have been enemies for so long, then Plankton would of used the leverage of witnessing Krab's heinous acts in order to get the formula, no? Just a thought idk

  • @user-ej2nd1xe7f
    @user-ej2nd1xe7f Месяц назад +1

    A void to be full

  • @Fallenvalkyriealyss
    @Fallenvalkyriealyss Месяц назад +2

    I feel like I haven't seen your videos in forever..

    • @DuskTillShawn
      @DuskTillShawn  Месяц назад +1

      Thank you so much for checking this one out, friend! :D

  • @zoroarkling
    @zoroarkling Месяц назад

    Definitely a great theory, gives more life and ideas about the lives in Bikini Bottom behind closed doors

  • @normaperez3084
    @normaperez3084 Месяц назад

    I know what Patrick would say about this channel.
    "hahahaha its a giraffe!"

  • @MrMike855
    @MrMike855 Месяц назад

    This sounds like a great idea for a fanfiction.

  • @TheDanishGuyReviews
    @TheDanishGuyReviews Месяц назад +1

    I saw the community post, and l was like "Spilling the Milk collab?"

  • @erirausa7841
    @erirausa7841 Месяц назад

    So ive followed you fir some time now and this was not a video i was expecting. Very happy you released it though. I love it. Glad to see you bramching out, even if its just a small SpongeBob theory lol

  • @KylerWulff
    @KylerWulff Месяц назад +1

    I once heard somebody suggest the possible theory that the male whale we frequently see at the Bikini Bottom jail (heh, that rhymes) is Pearl's real dad. That's the one I'd like to believe.

  • @michaelfritz5816
    @michaelfritz5816 Месяц назад +2

    Let's be real. The real question, is mayonnaise an instrument?

    • @DuskTillShawn
      @DuskTillShawn  Месяц назад +1

      This needs to be studied further 🧐

    • @OnTheThirdDay
      @OnTheThirdDay Месяц назад

      This has already been solved.
      There is a video of someone playing this instrument.

  • @user-ej2nd1xe7f
    @user-ej2nd1xe7f Месяц назад +1

    Whale 🐋 and crab 🦀 living together 11:30

  • @lindseymoore4460
    @lindseymoore4460 Месяц назад +1

    I always thought that Mr.Krabs had been marred to Mrs.Krabs. Mrs Krabs was a whale and they had their daughter Parl. Mrs. Krabs suddenly died. 🧐🤨!

  • @michaelablair5659
    @michaelablair5659 Месяц назад

    Amazing theory! I always wondered about this as a kid. Would you ever be open to sharing your thoughts on the episode Rock Bottom? It's such a creepy episode with really weird implications. I would love to hear what you'd have to say about it

  • @Cipherkat
    @Cipherkat Месяц назад

    As a kid, I 100% just accepted Pearl as Mr Krabs' biological daughter.
    The furthest I thought about it was, "oh! Pearl's mom is probably a whale."

  • @user-zg9fe6jz3x
    @user-zg9fe6jz3x Месяц назад +2

    I still think mr krabs is a sugar daddy because think about it pearl always calls him daddy daddy dadddy and only appears whenever pearl want something and mr krabs just always gives her whatever she wants think about it people think lol i no sounds absurd but is true

  • @b0ltun0
    @b0ltun0 Месяц назад

    also i just saw this clip of bobs dad smooching mrs puffs hand for a little too long, wich freaks me out a little lmao

  • @youtubeuniversity3638
    @youtubeuniversity3638 Месяц назад

    All in all: Very entertaining and more beluevable than you seem to even realize. I feel your case coulda been made a tad bit smoother, but your points ultimately make good sense..
    Do wish a bit you looked at what 2000 Spongebob episode most closely lined up with the 16 years comment just for laughs, but I can see how that would be too low relevance to matter.

  • @yamato9753
    @yamato9753 Месяц назад

    To be honest, I was kinda "panicking" when you asked the Questions about Pearl, the secret formula and Mrs Puffs past in the same minute...
    Alex bales darkest Theories are the ones that answer these very Questions and they are disturbing (even if in a good way). But I'm really that you build your own Theory!

  • @alcarbo8613
    @alcarbo8613 25 дней назад

    The problem with this theory is it’s very well established Mr. Krabs is from Bikini Bottom given his life long friendship with Plankton and his Mother living not too far away

  • @n_hasss4280
    @n_hasss4280 Месяц назад +2

    Please make more theory videos

  • @DarkMagicianGirl0
    @DarkMagicianGirl0 Месяц назад

    Spectacular theory

  • @mariosportsmaster7662
    @mariosportsmaster7662 Месяц назад

    I don't even think Pearl and Mrs. Puff have ever had one single interaction, on screen, with each other through the 25 years SpongeBob has been on the air. If they were together before the show started and abducted Pearl and Krabs still has feelings for Puff, I highly doubt that Krabs wouldn't have had at least one Freudian slip and let slip that Puff is her "mother".

  • @skylarmclean8239
    @skylarmclean8239 23 дня назад

    Weirdly enough the writers involved in the patrick star show made it seem like he killed Pearl's mom and at most used her body in early krabby patties

  • @eelsonwheels8187
    @eelsonwheels8187 Месяц назад

    Love it when there's a new Dusk video :)

  • @36inc
    @36inc Месяц назад +1

    just gotta point out this ;
    { ms puff about changing her identity a second time
    " no, not again."(ominous even)
    then shawn goes
    " as you can see shes unafraid to change her identity,live a new life and it wouldnt even be the first time..."}
    tho she is unafraid to commit crime to risk life altering decisions so the general overhead point proven anyway. i would said " shes not afraid tobreak the law and even had to change her id already"
    is this a nitpick and did i stop the video just to say this? of course ,carry on.

  • @Father_of_Death
    @Father_of_Death Месяц назад

    The editing here is very well done.

  • @user-ej2nd1xe7f
    @user-ej2nd1xe7f Месяц назад +1

    Is Pearl really mr. Krabs daughter 0:28

  • @SpoonbillSnooze
    @SpoonbillSnooze Месяц назад +1

    Mayonnaise IS an instrument.

  • @Bird-wz7nx
    @Bird-wz7nx Месяц назад

    I bet he found a random whale and kept it to harvest Ambergris from, as its extremely valuable stuff. (It doesn't have to harm the whale to expel the Ambergris, in theory)
    ... Except it turns out it was a baby, and before he knew it, he was doting on his new daughter.
    I could potentially see a whole episode about it, where he greedily takes a whale, is eaten up by his guilt, only to find that she was, in fact, an orphan.