今回も楽しい作品をありがとうございました．I saw the light〜につづくピアノのフレーズと，'Cause you walked〜 (1:02)のブレイクがステキです．そして，嵐の中を突き進んで行く緊張感が続いた後，I tried telephone( 1:43)で晴天の穏やかな南国の海に来たような開放感への切り替えが印象に残ります.
Mike, this is absolutely incredible !! How did you do this ? You have given this John Lennon composition a whole new life. You have taken it into a fascinating, rich world of colours, textures, sounds .. a whole galaxy so lush, so beautiful. You are obviously very talented. I hope you attempt to bring your touch to some other Beatles songs. All the best from Australia.
Thank you very much for your great praise. Please refer to the description to find out how Mr.@otokabe_master made this. We are also planning other Beatles songs. Please look forward to it.
MIKE ....THIS VERSION YOU CREATED ...WITH THE ORIGINAL VOCALS FROM THE LADS FROM LIVERPOOL IS ALL THE MORE BEAUTIFUL AND MAGICAL ....THAT PIANO THOUGH 💥🔥💖👍🏻🙏🏻🎵🎵🎵🎵😭😭😭😭😭✌🏻✌🏻✌🏻
@@lduranceau8046 Of course, The Beatles are the band with the most songs I want to turn into Wall of Sound. I already have some ideas, so please look forward to them. I'm really looking forward to them myself.
@@peteroberts4033 Thank you very much for introducing this version. Now I understand why the number of views suddenly increased about a month ago. I look forward to your continued support.
@@zoukyeee That's a relief .. I thought you might block my video !! Thank you..and people have been asking where your video came from. I will always be happy to support your videos ..and have subscribed to your channel.
MIKE - can't believe this is still up. Nice one, mate. Brings me back to Winter of '81 in Luxembourg when everyone in that unfriendly country was nice, nearing Christmas, LOL. Music like this flowed from every restaurant.
@@zoukyeee I would love you to do your Wall of Sound to one of my songs called "Summer Love" by Janson. Is that possible, thank you, Colin (Janson) Rickards
@@colinrickards1247 Thank you very much for your interest in Mr.@otokabe_master's Wall Of Sound. I will convey your intention to him. Please wait for a while for a reply.
@@colinrickards1247 Hello. Thank you very much for your inquiry. We can accept your request, but of course it will cost you a certain amount of money. Do you understand that there will be a certain amount of cost involved? If you still want to make a request, please let me know how to contact you, and if possible a temporary email address, etc.
Aside from the nice melody, etc, it's amazing how tight this band was. Playing four times a day, circa 1959 - 1963, from Hamburg through Liverpool, and lots of places in between, must have helped.. Astounding.
Well done. This could also be considered a "Pet Sounds" style production which could be applied many songs on the Beatles' album "Rubber Soul" and maybe some songs on "Revolver".
Thank you very much. We plan to continue making our classic songs into Wall of Sound, but of course other Beatles songs are also candidates. Please look forward to our future works.
The unique thing about the Wall Of Sound was that it is a combination of vocals, horns, strings, and rhythm instruments. And with the wizardry of a sound engineer, it was literally a living sound that breathed. It strengthened and enhanced the quality of the sound and the song. It can be done today. But I doubt that the artists will like that because they want a relatively clean and simple sound to enhance their lyrics and vocals. Great sound on a great song.😎👍🎷❤️
The other element of Wall of Sound was doubling or tripling instruments like drums, bass, piano. Just sheer sonic, harmonic power by virtue of reinforcement all at once in one room - - and that great Gold Star reverb!
There aren't many alternative Beatle songs which do justice to the original .A great version of I should have know better with strings (which mysteriously disappeared from you tube ) springs to mind but this jolly upbeat version of no reply gives it a whole new lease of life .
@@zoukyeee It was on you tube about 5 years ago but then it couldn't be found .Perhaps for copyright reasons, I'm not sure .The strings came in on the verse " and when I tell you that I love you...ooh " were beautiful and enhanced the song .I hope it resurfaces again soon
Agree, the Mariah Carey treatment is too much and changes the character of the song. Not a fan of remixes of songs where other added instruments are inserted by the producer to a definitive version such as this.
Mil veces oí: "No Reply" Pero, esta version es ORIGINAL y SUPER . Gracias. MIKE: abriste un nuevo camino a editar las otras canciones de The Fab Four. 2:05" Ese sonido de guitarra es tan de George. Mersey sound.
This was a good idea and a good effort. The extra sounds definitely echoed a Ronettes type vibe. A tasty combination. The best things for me were the 12-string guitar solo and the stops before the verses came back. The biggest problem was... It goes on too long. The added jingly stuff becomes really cloying. Keep it the same structure as the original but add in the Rickenbacker solo + the added effects and see how it plays. Maybe double up the vocals and add more reverb, too. Double in a bass part. Needs a bit more girth. Still - - enjoyed it! Very fresh take!
mike whilst i like what you have done im afraid i do prefer the original this version of yours is very disco and would prob work but well done can you do some more
Thank you very much. I have other projects already created and am considering. I personally want to continue this for a long time. Please look forward to it.
That's Excellent - Love It 👏👏👏 [Verse 1: John Lennon with Paul McCartney] This happened once before when I came to your door, no reply They said it wasn't you, but I saw you peep through your window I saw the light, I saw the light I know that you saw me 'cause I looked up to see your face [Verse 2: John Lennon with Paul McCartney] I tried to telephone, they said you were not home. that's a lie 'Cause I know where you've been, I saw you walk in your door I nearly died, I nearly died 'Cause you walked hand in hand with another man in my place [Bridge: John Lennon & Paul McCartney] If I were you, I'd realise that I Love you more than any other guy And I'll forgive the lies that I Heard before, when you gave me no reply [Verse 3: John Lennon with Paul McCartney] I tried to telephone, they said you were not home, that's a lie 'Cause I know where you've been, I saw you walk in your door {Instrumental Break} [Bridge: John Lennon & Paul McCartney] If I were you, I'd realise that I Love you more than any other guy And I'll forgive the lies that I Heard before, when you gave me no reply [Bridge: John Lennon & Paul McCartney] If I were you, I'd realise that I Love you more than any other guy And I'll forgive the lies that I Heard before, when you gave me no reply [Verse 2: John Lennon with Paul McCartney] I tried to telephone, they said you were not home. that's a lie 'Cause I know where you've been, I saw you walk in your door I nearly died, I nearly died 'Cause you walked hand in hand with another man in my place [Outro: John Lennon & Paul McCartney] No reply, no reply No reply, no reply No reply, no reply
Does "Can you download this version?" mean "Can I download this version?" Thank you for your interest. I have uploaded it in high quality, so please enjoy it.
I think it's not that different from the original when it was released. However, if The Beatles had wanted a wall of sound, it would have been very different. Still, if PHIL SPECTOR had done it at that time, it would have been mono, so it would have felt very different from this version. However, if PHIL SPECTOR had done it now in 2024, it might have sounded like this version. Thank you very much for your comment.
I'm very happy to receive such a high praise. When this song was created, the Wall of Sound was still in its infancy. I think this work is the result of the hard work, ideas, and efforts of great predecessors.
The bridge works great but Phil Spector would never have used a stutter snare on a rhythm track like Ringo is playing during the rest of it. But kudos on the bridge!
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
Wow so amazing and love that song no matter how i hear it.
I'm glad you like it.
Es como si la hubiera grabado PHILL SPECTOR en 1964, en su tipico pared de sonido, como el grupo femenino THE CRYSTALS de 1963, 'Then he kissed me'
@@yei-jopbities6100 thanks.
今回も楽しい作品をありがとうございました．I saw the light〜につづくピアノのフレーズと，'Cause you walked〜 (1:02)のブレイクがステキです．そして，嵐の中を突き進んで行く緊張感が続いた後，I tried telephone( 1:43)で晴天の穏やかな南国の海に来たような開放感への切り替えが印象に残ります.
素敵なコメントどうも有難うございます。次回作にご期待ください。
Thank you sir. May I please have another?
This is GREAT! MORE BEATLES ! 👍
Thank you very much. The Beatles is my favorite band.
We have several more ideas so please look forward to it.
This sounds so amazing. All the extra orchestration really makes the song sparkle. I love it!
I'm glad I could share your joy. Thank you very much.
impeccable,tears ,running down my cheek for those who went before
I'm so glad that you liked it. Thank you so much for your touching comment.
Beautiful! A classic song and
John’s voice is sheer perfection!
Mike, this is absolutely incredible !! How did you do this ? You have given this John Lennon composition a whole new life. You have taken it into a fascinating, rich world of colours, textures, sounds .. a whole galaxy so lush, so beautiful. You are obviously very talented. I hope you attempt to bring your touch to some other Beatles songs. All the best from Australia.
Thank you very much for your great praise. Please refer to the description to find out how Mr.@otokabe_master made this. We are also planning other Beatles songs. Please look forward to it.
BEATLES FOREVER,RIGHT...MIKE 💖💖💖💖😭😭😭✌🏻🙏🏻AS RINGO AND PAUL SAY...PEACE AND LOVE✌🏻🙏🏻💖
I like the original way better. It was one of my favorite songs back then.
MIKE ....THIS VERSION YOU CREATED ...WITH THE ORIGINAL VOCALS FROM THE LADS FROM LIVERPOOL IS ALL THE MORE BEAUTIFUL AND MAGICAL ....THAT PIANO THOUGH 💥🔥💖👍🏻🙏🏻🎵🎵🎵🎵😭😭😭😭😭✌🏻✌🏻✌🏻
Thank you very much for your comment. I hope you enjoy Wall of Sound.
@@zoukyeee 👍👍💖🙏🏻
Beautiful. The added music adds a fantastic sound. Love it.
thanks.
@@zoukyeee Please do other Beatles songs like this. I suggest that the song 'Please Please me' may be a good start.
@@lduranceau8046 Of course, The Beatles are the band with the most songs I want to turn into Wall of Sound. I already have some ideas, so please look forward to them. I'm really looking forward to them myself.
@@zoukyeee Let us know when the next song comes out. I've subscribed.
@@lduranceau8046 Thank you very much. Please wait patiently.
Awesomely cool and updated. Love it!
I'm glad you liked it. Thank you very much.
It has a certain Christmas feel to it. I like it!
exact
Sounds like a Christmas version 😄
Many of Wall of Sound's songs exude a Christmas atmosphere. I'm glad you accepted this song.
It's always nice hear John Lennon singing, No Reply was a terrific Beatle song.
A mí me gusta mucho. Pero la versión original.
This is now my favorite Christmas song!
BRILLIANT !
thank you!
Love it Mike ..thanks !! 🙂
I'm glad you like it.
@@zoukyeee I have shared it in a Beatles compilation on my channel (Not monetized) ..I hope you don't mind . People seem to love it ..great job. 🙂
@@zoukyeee ruclips.net/video/93ligvXGRUI/видео.html
@@peteroberts4033 Thank you very much for introducing this version. Now I understand why the number of views suddenly increased about a month ago. I look forward to your continued support.
@@zoukyeee That's a relief .. I thought you might block my video !! Thank you..and people have been asking where your video came from. I will always be happy to support your videos ..and have subscribed to your channel.
Very neat idea well-executed!
thank you.
Great version of this fantastic song.
thank you very much. I'm very happy that you liked it.
Wonderful, thanks so much
I'm glad you liked it. Thank you very much for your comment.
すっごくいいアレンジ....！！素晴らしい
どうも有難うございます。喜びを分かち合えてとても嬉しいです。
MIKE - can't believe this is still up.
Nice one, mate. Brings me back to Winter of '81 in Luxembourg when everyone in that unfriendly country was nice, nearing Christmas, LOL. Music like this flowed from every restaurant.
I'm glad this song helped you recall good memories.
素晴らしい！
私は1:09の”If I were you…"のフレーズが大好きなのですが、原曲では1回しか出てきません。
それをいつも物足りなく感じていました。しかし、あなたのアレンジ作品では、後半で何度もそれがリフレインされていて、涙が出るほど嬉しかったです。
私もそうです。この時代は3分を越えるのは敷居が高かったからサビが一回で終わってしまっていたのだと思います。自分で編集してサビを繰り返したりしていたのですが、それでは満足できずこの曲の作成を依頼するに至りました。その辺りのことはブログで記事にしていますので、説明文の中のリンク先も是非読んでみてください。同じ気持ちの方と喜びを共有出来てとても嬉しいです。
@@zoukyeee
ブログ拝見しました。青春時代に友達同士でBeatlesについて「ああだこうだ」と議論したものですが、そんな旧友と数十年を経て再会したような懐かしさと感動を覚えました。
@@べた踏み坂46 どうも有難うございます。こちらも嬉しくなりますね。個人的には是非またビートルズの他の曲にもチャレンジしたいと思っています。
This is absolutely brilliant!
Thank you so much, I'm so glad you liked it.
@@zoukyeee I would love you to do your Wall of Sound to one of my songs called "Summer Love" by Janson. Is that possible, thank you, Colin (Janson) Rickards
@@colinrickards1247 Thank you very much for your interest in Mr.@otokabe_master's Wall Of Sound. I will convey your intention to him. Please wait for a while for a reply.
@@colinrickards1247 Hello. Thank you very much for your inquiry.
We can accept your request, but of course it will cost you a certain amount of money.
Do you understand that there will be a certain amount of cost involved?
If you still want to make a request, please let me know how to contact you, and if possible a temporary email address, etc.
@@zoukyeee Thank you my friend, I will think about it.
Glad you added some of Hal Blains drumming!!
thank you.
@ Hal Blaine was a friend of mine. We lived out here in California. I’m also a Drummer.
@@friz1948 I also like his drumming. He is popular among Japanese people too.
It is !!
thanks.
This is pretty creative. Love it!
Thanks for posting
You're welcome. I'm glad you liked it.
If you like it, please add this version to your "The Beatles New Remixes" playlist.
@@zoukyeee Done!!
これは凄い‼︎ 原曲の良さが倍増されている。
どうも有難うございます。とても光栄に思います。
Great version 🤩
thank you very much. I'm very happy that you liked it.
love this, its all about the voice, let it be project showed us that, I would buy this
Very Nice!!!
thank you.
Fantastic
thank you.
.... man . .... the best version ever .... you are absolutely genius. ....
Really? I'm very happy. Please enjoy other "Wall of Sound" works created by @otokabe_master.
.... thank you very much for your kind reply. .... I am very much looking forward to. ....
"I saw the light" _ I got goosebumps, like any other guy = NO REPLY: I nearly die!
Aside from the nice melody, etc, it's amazing how tight this band was. Playing four times a day, circa 1959 - 1963, from Hamburg through Liverpool, and lots of places in between, must have helped.. Astounding.
Well done. This could also be considered a "Pet Sounds" style production which could be applied many songs on the Beatles' album "Rubber Soul" and maybe some songs on "Revolver".
Thank you very much. We plan to continue making our classic songs into Wall of Sound, but of course other Beatles songs are also candidates. Please look forward to our future works.
Brian Wilson was deeply influenced by Phil Spector.
Brian Wilson IS the reason the Beatles and George Martin changed up their formula and thus came Sgt Pepper and Magical Mystery Tour.
The unique thing about the Wall Of Sound was that it is a combination of vocals, horns, strings, and rhythm instruments. And with the wizardry of a sound engineer, it was literally a living sound that breathed. It strengthened and enhanced the quality of the sound and the song. It can be done today. But I doubt that the artists will like that because they want a relatively clean and simple sound to enhance their lyrics and vocals.
Great sound on a great song.😎👍🎷❤️
thank you for your comment.
The other element of Wall of Sound was doubling or tripling instruments like drums, bass, piano. Just sheer sonic, harmonic power by virtue of reinforcement all at once in one room - - and that great Gold Star reverb!
Phil Spector Sound....He worked on Let It Be... amazing 😊
thank you.
Fantastic 0h boy keep rockin cheers dan
thank you very much.
Beatles forever❤❤❤
One of the most beautiful songs of The Beatles.
COOOoooLLL...!!! 🙂👍👍 -70SomethingGuy
THANKS
Works nicely )
THANKS
基本的にビートルズの曲をイジるのには反対派ですがこれは｢アリ｣でしょう！
どうも有難うございます。
I am a Beatles fan. I thought I would hate this but it’s is pretty interesting
thanks.
面白い！j-pop風なアレンジですね
どうも有難うございます。
Oh‼great John's voices.
WOW !!!
What a song
Sounds like a Christmas version. I like it!
thanks.
Me gustó!! Cuando repite el estribillo es como que explota. Y la frase de piano muy buena .
Thank you so much. I'm so happy to share your joy.
切り口が素晴らしい
楽しめました
楽しんで頂けて何よりです。
awasome
thanks
As a decades long Beatles fan, I really like this! Not as much as the original, but I am really enjoying listening to it!
I am also a long-time Beatles fan, and I am very happy to be able to share the joy with fans all over the world.
Un véritable bijoux
THANK YOU.
Parmi les autres...
There aren't many alternative Beatle songs which do justice to the original .A great version of I should have know better with strings (which mysteriously disappeared from you tube ) springs to mind but this jolly upbeat version of no reply gives it a whole new lease of life .
I'm very happy that you appreciated it. Thank you very much.(I want to listen I should have know better with strings!)
@@zoukyeee It was on you tube about 5 years ago but then it couldn't be found .Perhaps for copyright reasons, I'm not sure .The strings came in on the verse " and when I tell you that I love you...ooh " were beautiful and enhanced the song .I hope it resurfaces again soon
@@StephenHaaugh Thank you very much. I will wait patiently.
I nearly DIED!
Agree, the Mariah Carey treatment is too much and changes the character of the song. Not a fan of remixes of songs where other added instruments are inserted by the producer to a definitive version such as this.
Mil veces oí: "No Reply" Pero, esta version es ORIGINAL y SUPER . Gracias. MIKE: abriste un nuevo camino a editar las otras canciones de The Fab Four. 2:05" Ese sonido de guitarra es tan de George. Mersey sound.
I took your words as the highest compliment. I am very happy. Thank you very much.
ロネッツがカバーしたら、こんな感じになるんだろうな〜という机上実験ですね。面白いです。
どうも有難うございます。
This was a good idea and a good effort. The extra sounds definitely echoed a Ronettes type vibe. A tasty combination. The best things for me were the 12-string guitar solo and the stops before the verses came back. The biggest problem was... It goes on too long. The added jingly stuff becomes really cloying. Keep it the same structure as the original but add in the Rickenbacker solo + the added effects and see how it plays. Maybe double up the vocals and add more reverb, too. Double in a bass part. Needs a bit more girth. Still - - enjoyed it! Very fresh take!
I appreciate your detailed impressions. Thank you very much. Please look forward to the next Beatles work.
ビートルズを大滝詠一さんがアレンジしたよう。素敵な音楽をありがとうございます。
大滝詠一さんという偉大な存在がいなければ、このバージョンは生まれなかったと思います。気に入って頂けてとても嬉しいです。どうも有難うございました。
Sounds like a mixture of Muzak and the real thing at Christmas !
Makes it sound like a Christmas song.
sleigh bells!
The Beatles get the Phil Spector treatment.
Thank you very much. Of course I respect Phil Spector.
@@zoukyeeeAs an artist, yes. As a human being, hell no.
@@RayMusicman9 He turned out to be a murderer. Shame, after all the great things he did. He died from covid complications.
mike whilst i like what you have done im afraid i do prefer the original this version of yours is very disco and would prob work but well done can you do some more
Thank you very much. I have other projects already created and am considering. I personally want to continue this for a long time. Please look forward to it.
Got the Ronettes sound.
yes.
Ficou simplesmente fantástico.
thank you very much.
Dzisiaj usłyszałem to po raz pierwszy,brzmi świetnie ale jednak orginał brzmi jakoś lepiej
That VOICE, enough said.
That's Excellent - Love It 👏👏👏
[Verse 1: John Lennon with Paul McCartney]
This happened once before when I came to your door, no reply
They said it wasn't you, but I saw you peep through your window
I saw the light, I saw the light
I know that you saw me 'cause I looked up to see your face
[Verse 2: John Lennon with Paul McCartney]
I tried to telephone, they said you were not home. that's a lie
'Cause I know where you've been, I saw you walk in your door
I nearly died, I nearly died
'Cause you walked hand in hand with another man in my place
[Bridge: John Lennon & Paul McCartney]
If I were you, I'd realise that I
Love you more than any other guy
And I'll forgive the lies that I
Heard before, when you gave me no reply
[Verse 3: John Lennon with Paul McCartney]
I tried to telephone, they said you were not home, that's a lie
'Cause I know where you've been, I saw you walk in your door
{Instrumental Break}
[Bridge: John Lennon & Paul McCartney]
If I were you, I'd realise that I
Love you more than any other guy
And I'll forgive the lies that I
Heard before, when you gave me no reply
[Bridge: John Lennon & Paul McCartney]
If I were you, I'd realise that I
Love you more than any other guy
And I'll forgive the lies that I
Heard before, when you gave me no reply
[Verse 2: John Lennon with Paul McCartney]
I tried to telephone, they said you were not home. that's a lie
'Cause I know where you've been, I saw you walk in your door
I nearly died, I nearly died
'Cause you walked hand in hand with another man in my place
[Outro: John Lennon & Paul McCartney]
No reply, no reply
No reply, no reply
No reply, no reply
thank you very much.
you should keeping do this to many beatles songs
Thank you very much. I would like to try other Beatles songs.
THE BEATLES #1 4EVER❤❤
SIEMPRE q sea beatles..lo mejor d lo mejor..
Happy Xmas to all of you ;-)
Should be released as a single .
Thank you so much. I hope that becomes official.
...this version is like ... being in a dream and not wanting to awake...
...the coda twice times...the best ...!
t h a n k y o u v e r y m u c h ! ! !
I'm glad you like it. Thank you very much.
@@zoukyeee It's very addicting to listen to it over and over again.....I have to admit.
Thank you very much. Wall of Sound is highly addictive. Please enjoy other Wall of Sound works.
Try the same experiment on their song "WAIT", from rubber soul, i think a new instrumental could make it more catchy and powerful
Thank you for your opinion. I would like to try other songs, so I will take your opinion into consideration.
"This happened once before"...
Great and very interesting version of this great beatles song (unfortunately overlooked most of the time)
Thank you very much. I'm glad you like it.
@@zoukyeee Thank you so much!
원곡하고 다른 환상적인 분위기에 매료됐어요
I'm very happy that you liked it.
Can you download this version?
Does "Can you download this version?" mean "Can I download this version?" Thank you for your interest. I have uploaded it in high quality, so please enjoy it.
Nice, but take out the Christmas bells. But I like it. It extends the song, which I love.
I'm glad you liked it.
Whoever made this production should have taken notes on when Phil Spector had come in to reproduce the “Get Back” sessions for “Let It Be!!!”
The guitar thing adds a lot
Thank you very much. I'm very happy that you praised the sound of this guitar.
If Phil Spector had gotten his hands on this song:
I think it's not that different from the original when it was released. However, if The Beatles had wanted a wall of sound, it would have been very different. Still, if PHIL SPECTOR had done it at that time, it would have been mono, so it would have felt very different from this version. However, if PHIL SPECTOR had done it now in 2024, it might have sounded like this version. Thank you very much for your comment.
He definitely got his hands on Lennon later on.
@@patricksmith4424 yes, he did.
Es como si la hubiera grabado PHILL SPECTOR en 1964, en su tipico pared de sonido, como el grupo femenino THE CRYSTALS de 1963, 'Then he kissed me
Thank you very much. I hope that WALL OF SOUND, developed by PHIL SPECTOR, will continue to develop.
Merry Xmas dudes!!!
Yesh, Merry Xmas in August!
Ah les Beatles indétronables
Sounds like an old time tack piano. Fits the No Reply song perfectly. Phil Spector could not have made this better.
I'm very happy to receive such a high praise. When this song was created, the Wall of Sound was still in its infancy. I think this work is the result of the hard work, ideas, and efforts of great predecessors.
Very Nice. 原曲にない間奏がいい。
楽しんで頂けて良かったです。どうも有難うございます。
Xmas time
Enjoyable
thank you.
The bridge works great but Phil Spector would never have used a stutter snare on a rhythm track like Ringo is playing during the rest of it. But kudos on the bridge!
THANKS.
This is from that great Beatles album, "Pet Sounds for sale". Love it
I don't think so.
@@lduranceau8046 It was a joke, parça
Like a jeff Lynne production
thank you very much.
How.Did.You.Do.This??
It's written in the description section, so please click "See more" to see it. Thank you very much.
А что ?Не плохо , не плохо - что только не придумают , не плохо .
Reminds me of a Burt Bacharach production.