Dear Friends, If you like my find my videos worthwhile, please share them with your friends and subscribe to the channel. I welcome your comments, but please use civil language. Uncivil language does not make you more convincing. There is no problem if you want to disagree with me or the guest, but please do so without being disagreeable. If you wish to give an opposing view, please send me your contact details. If you want to see my most popular videos, here are the links to them. ruclips.net/video/hWJugbilQd8/видео.html ruclips.net/video/hRDiEe90z6Y/видео.html ruclips.net/video/sqHGMhJkygc/видео.html You are welcome to follow me on Facebook and Twitter. facebook.com/shakil.chaudary twitter.com/ShakChaudhary
Shakil Sahib, your guest is an artist. He has mastered the art of speaking endlessly without conveying anything. I saw you in the audience of ChristopherJafferlot program moderated by Hoodbhoy. I hope you will make a program on that and discuss the hypocrisy of the event and the individuals.
The so called “experts” in Pakistan are so educated and well read that I as a college student know that nearly 50% of the stuff he said was wrong or outdated
In Santana Dharma, there are 4 types of “Antim Sanskara” mentioned. 1- In the water, 2- in the mountain slope, 3- in the plain land (we call it “Samadhi”), 4- Burning (We call it “Dah Sanskara”). It is also mentioned that who will be cremated in which way. Samadhi was for Sadhus, Sanyasis, Rishi, Yogis etc.
Shakil sahab aapse ye ummid nahi thi ki aap ek aise Prof. Ko laye show mai jisko precise knowledge hai hi nahi. Aise Prof. Se jyada knowledge hamare yahan 12th ke student ko hogi
Latest researches have conclusively proved that the Aryans have not come to India from out side. The Aryan or Vedic culture was inherent to India.The Britishers taught us wrong history. Arya means a cultured person.
@@hawkingdawking4572 Then Islam was born yesterday, I wont even give reference to Mahabharat, Ramayan, Vedas, Shiva and how old Sanata Dharma or as west called it as Hindusim. Lets look at Islamic History, 17 times recorded Islamic attacks happened on Hindu Somnath temple was it after 19th century? Then even Quran has multiple reference to Hind and its people Hindu, even Prophet Mohammad said even though he is not born in Hind, he feels he smells of Hind in spirit. was Quran written after 19th century. Sind/Indus was the old river, the land beyond sind river, persians pronounced 'S' with 'H' and hence called all land below Himalayas and after River was called Hind and all people no matter who they worshiped was called Hindu. And this was reference is pre Islamic and even documented within Quran in some places where Hind/Hindu is talked about. Quran has reference to Christians, Jews and Hindus, unless you are saying your Prophet was lying and you are telling truth.
@@sandeepssangha It was Rajaram Mohan Roy in 1812 who coined the term Hinduism. He basically "invented" a new religion for the 19th century, NOT the westerners. There were no 17 Islamic attacks on Somnath. The Somnath was captured by proto-Hindus a few centuries prior from Jains and converted to a shiva temple as it was their norm. Ghori, a minor warlord from Afghanistan was the one who invaded Somnath not the Islamic army. Quran has no reference to Hind or Hindus. There is no hadith on Hind spirit or whatever.
@@sandeepssangha Persian did call the Indian region surrounding(not beyond) the 'great river' and the consonant shift may have happened from S to H. But Persians did and still have S in their language.
Shakil, your whole premise is that why your country/ society couldn't market this heritage for monetary gains. Any civilisation/ country has to own, respect and live their culture in order to market it. Then only others get interested.
Request to all Indians, don't shower abusive comments, kindly listen full show, then make opinion and admire that few Pakistani has still preserved our ancient history..
Acharya chanakya wrote kautalya arthshashtra and chanakya neeti, who was a professor in takshila University, he played a major role in establishing gupta Dynasty which ruled from iran to burma. But the islamic invaders destroyed all old gold heritage of our nalanda and taxshila University which were the greatest of that time. Student's/ scholars all over abroad used to visit to learn study. Religion change hone se heritage change nhi hota, we had the same ancestors.
At least in India, nobody takes Aryan invasion theory seriously. This was a Eurpean conjecture to show that Sanskrit is derived from some central Asian proto-Indo Aryan language. However, Rigveda was composed around Taxila between 2000-1500 B.C..
Another ancient University, Nalanda has been revived and now established with the collaboration of International community. Today Nalanda is a modern and marching towards the reaching to its lost glory.
If Pakistan owns Taksh shila it only mean all of them are converted muslims. 😂😂😂 Most of the Pakistani think they are Arab, turks, Pathan, central Asians etc etc. But 99.99% of muslims are converted during 1000 years of islamic invasion from North Western borders of indian subcontinent. DNA Testing krwa lo sb pata chal jyega. 😂
My Friend ..Either u r an idiot .or you know everything but u r doing this hyprocracy on purpose. You are probably mental slave of Arabs . You cannot tolerate glorious past of Indian History. Of Course Arab Baddos of desert did not know anything apart from bloodshed and looting..😂
@@KashifAli-qv1xoThe Arabs were relatively learned people. The Turks were the problematic. But Takeshita was destroyed by Huns and not Muslims. Nalanda was destroyed by a Turkish Bakhtiyar Khilji.
The two gentlemen should have called it Takshasila, instead of the Greek Taxila. I also take issue calling King Purushottama as Porus. No apologies if it sounds revivalist.
It is understandable that the Arab Muslim religion & culture doesn’t want to promote or own the great Hindu /Vedic heritage all these prejudices are due to “Hindu phobia “ & Islamic practices of demonising all other religions
By pronouncing it in wrong way as Texila, till you are disowning this University. Please pronounce it in a correct way as takshila. It is correctly spelled as Takshashila in English and in devnagari script written as तक्षशिला. One more spelled version is Taxila, but it is wrong.
Pakistan has failed to develop the Taxila, Harappa & Mohenjo Daro and lost Billions of Dollars of Foreign Exchange while India maintained the Taj Mahal and many other monuments and earned the same.
SC sahab, please note that taxila etc. Is so old that no connection with Islam can be made. Hence, why should ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF PAKISTAN recognize/market it? Everything about your country is about Islam.
It is not Taxila it is "Taksh shila" "Taxshila" (तक्षशीला). This University is 4000+ years old. History found in Hindu religeous books "VEDAS" and others Hindu religious books which are 4000+ years old.
Namashkar Choudhary ji, It is not just Chanakya , It has given many many more scholars and contributed much more things to world. The panchtantra ( jungle book ) was contributed by Acharya of takshila. Contribution to the Grammer of Sanskrit which is considered to be mother of all languages ( by Rishi Panini), philosophy, yog and many more. Unfortunately pakistani scholars can never do justice to this great land. Their inherent hatred for their past and hindus will never make them fair and explore the truth. Migration of Aryans is laughable stuff . Do not try to link any contribution of Islam through this holy land.
Indus civilization cover much bigger area ( ropar punjab, and few places in haryana). Rigveda , Ayurveda and many ancient text were written when there was only santan dharma in whole world. Many thousand years later christian ,Islam etc have come into existence. Had it been arabs , they would have done some justice to research on taxilla. Prof. Rashid khan ,hardly seems to be capable - he is doing research with the essence of Islam and slave mentality. Copy some mischief theories of Europeans and pasting in his work. In the end , you will own only NEGLIGENCE
Chodhary sahab isn't it strange for Pakistani people to be proud of their roots in the history of Pakistan before the creation of Pakistan on the basis of two nations theory. No one in Pakistan dares to claim his or her roots before the advent of Islam. Two nations theory is a failed concept, otherwise why should you Pakistanis migrate to non Islamic countries.Why do you guys use fruits of scientific research and technology developed by non Islamic people.Dont you wonder that the small in size the Jewish people have more than 200 Noble prizes,a very strong research and development base,a strong economy built by the sheer intellectual strength, stands so tall. And your great nation is living on debt and alms.
चौधरी सर आपके लिये हिंदुस्थान मे बहोत सारा प्यार और मोहब्बत है पर अगर ऐसे लोगो को आप यहा लाओगे तो वो प्यार और मोहब्बत कम हो जायेगी ये पक्का. और ये हम नही चाहते कि जो रिस्पेक्ट आपके लिये है हमारे दिल मे वो कम हो जाये.
Gandhar is not in Pakistan. "GANDHAR" is in Afganistan now a days it is called "Kandhar" from where SEETAMATA of RAMA is related. Takshshila is Hindu university.
You are a real idiot. Gandhara is the old name for Punjab and surrounding regions. Hindu claims that Kandahar is Gandhara while their own text books don't have it. Sita and Rama are all fictional stories. It has no link to history. Before the Ramacharita Manas written in the Mughal era of 14th century CE, Ramayana was just folk tales with not much of traction. Rama became a super star after Ramacharita Manas.
Abe jihadi apni maa ke khasam madarsachap, apne hi baap ko paida karne waalo jaha bhi jaate ho badbu hi failate ho. Tujhe apna pta nahi hai aa gaya yaha gyaan dene. Nikal yaha se gutter ke suwar
Shakil ji for the value addition of your knowledge related Harappan culture not limited in Pakistan. In 2022, the latest ASI excavation at Rakhiigarhi village nearby Hissar (Harayana) had revealed wide roads, drainage network, houses and jewelry were similar to Harappan culture. It means that Harappan culture thrived in this village.
Wrong information! Those sites are not Harappan nor have they been independently verified as being 9000 yrs old, this information you are propagating is pure RSS nonsense.
Muslims believe in fiction created by the Abbasids 1. Mecca didn’t exist in the 7th Century (at best a hamlet) A. No archeological evidence B. No historical evidence C. No or very little water 2. Mecca (only mentioned once in the Quran) wasn’t on any historical map until 900. 2. The Quran talks about a fertile place, which is not Mecca. A. A stream B. Fruits C. Olive trees D. Fields etc. None of which Mecca had in the 7th, 8th, 9th 10th, to the late 20th centuries when Saudis started to have water desalination plants built. 3. Medina was an insignificant little place. 4. The term ‘Mohammad’ (Praised One) was first found on a Christian coin in 661 referring to Jesus, the coin had Christian symbols. 5. The term Mohammad was used by Arab Christians for Jesus until the mid-8th century. 6. The Mohammad that Muslims think of was an Abbasid invention in the late 8th century or early 9th century. Mohammad is mentioned four times in the Korans/Qurans, the Muslim/Abbasid Mohammad in the Quran is the last of the four (Surah 33:40), is an Abbasid interpolation, and the first three refer to Jesus. 7. The Dome of the Rock was not a Mosque; it was built by Abdul al-Malik as an anti-trinitarian Christian building. Both Abdul al-Malik and his brother were anti-trinitarian Christians and used Christian symbols on their coins. 8. Abdul al-Malik sent a directive throughout his Kingdom saying that the term ‘Mohammad’ should refer to Jesus. 9. The only original parts of the Dome of the Rock are the inner ambulatories and the Mohammad’s written on them refer to Jesus (in fact the term Jesus is on one of them), and they are decorated with lots of grapes, a Christian symbol. 10. There were no Islamic Korans/Qurans in the 7th Century. The proto-Quran was in fact Christian lectionaries written in Aramaic and old Arabic. This has led to many mistranslations in the much later Islamic/Abbasid Quran. For example, it is not the Virgins that men get in Paradise but Grapes! Conclusion: What Muslims believe today is a fraudulent story started by the Abbasids when they came into power in 749. The Abbasids bastardized the Arab Anti-trinitarian Christian lectionaries (combined with the mistranslations) to form their Qurans to suit their agenda. Pls watch Adam Seeker Urdu RUclips channel for understanding Islam ...
Prof. Khan ko Takshashila (Texila), Punjab, Aryans, Manu aur Vaidik history ke baare me bahut kamzor knowledge hai. Unki baat sun kar indians can laugh only.
Here is a Google search extract : 'Literally meaning “City of Cut Stone” or “Rock of Taksha,” Takshashila (rendered by Greek writers as Taxila) was founded, according to the Indian epic Ramayana, by Bharata, younger brother of Rama, an incarnation of the Hindu god Vishnu. The city was named for Bharata's son Taksha, its first ruler'
Dr. Shakil Chaudhary saheb, we all are indigenous Indians. If foreigners couldn't pronounce Tak-shila that os OK. But why do we say Taxila out of inferiority. I hope you would take it as food for thought and wouldn't mind.
The Mahabharata story was written in a cave in Mana village in Uttarakhand, the evidence of which is still present. Vyas ji spent a lot of his time in this cave and composed many Puranas including Mahabharata. Looking at the Vyas Cave from outside, it appears as if many texts have been placed one above the other, hence it is also called Vyas Pothi. Lord Ganesha blessed the poetic Mahabharata directed by Brahma to be called the world's greatest epic, which was written by him himself.
❤ Thanks Shakil saheb for bringing great truly an intellectual and and an historian. Such subjects if included in Pakistani text books readers can become proud and attach to their land instead of looking to Arab or Turks which they are not
This is medieval history of Hinduism / sanatani dharam. Chanakya was a staunch hindu. After partition the region went to the newly created pakistan. History of Indian civilization is more than 5000+ years. The Pakistanis would not do any research because they would want to hide the deep hindu roots of the land that they now call islamic Pak.. The muslims would not be able to relate to such a rich culture.
This problem is with the Pakistanis alone. The Egyptians and Iranians have not cast away their pre-Islamic histories. Pakistan is a confused nation and vainly keeps looking for an identity, after discarding it’s glorious past.
Aryan never came from outside. They were already here. This myth is bursted by modern historians. Aryan theory was design of british to undetmine hindu ideology.
It is a very interesting discussion; you must do it in more detail program. Please also do this on Mohanjodaro and Harappa. You also discuss Buddhist heritage in KPK, GBT Hindu, Jain, and Sikh heritage in Pakistan.
How pakistan claims the heritage of Takshashila, it will be forced to accept the ancestry of the hardcore enemy of Islam. So it is actually good thing that pakistan is not do so.
True to his faith he want to benefit from the other religions. These guys doesn't know what they have there. Our ancestors must have done a grave crime that these jokers captured our heritage..Sad but true.. India much purchase this from these jokers.
If Pakistan is not interested in early Buddhist sites or artefacts than plz sell all Buddhist artefacts and pay back ur debts will be win-win situation
Mahabharat written by ved vyasa in Sanskrit The authorship of the Mahabharata is often credited to Vysa. Many attempts have been made to decipher its historical development and compositional levels. The Mahabharata was written by a renowned sage named Vyasa, who was the grandfather of the Pandavas and Kauravas.
Sakil Saheb, why your historian guest is not able to express his views in proper chronological order ? Why histrorical research could not be done on Takshashila not Taxila even after 75 yrs of pakistan came into existence ?
Taxila ko sanskrit me asli name Thaksha shila hai.Pakistan woh unfortunate mulkh hai jiske hisse me itna heritage treasure mila uska advantage lene keliye failure raha. Abh dekho taliban bhi budha statutes ko kitne bedardi se barbaad kiya.
Prof. Khan is hesitant to appreciate and honor Chanakya which is much understandable. We wish if Pakistan was a moderate country where people like Prof. Khan could contribute to their maximum.
Pehle mujhe lagta tha Kapil Sharma ek achha comedian hai but kuchh log us se bhi achhe hai 😅 ....... aapka video bharat me sabko hasane ke kaam aayega ........ keep it up 👍
Even in Hindu religion, there is a custom of samadhi and burial in the ground among saints and some castes. It is not wise to draw any other meaning from this. You should also know so many things. Hindus will be
Unfortunately Pakistanis are proud of the fact as to how many non-muslims recite 'Kalma' through jihad. Nothing else even technological innovation, economic success and heritage do not matter for Pakistanis.
Pakistan and India both owned the same civilization, culture and history. But Muslims disowned the aforesaid heritage after becoming Muslims especially after the creation of Pakistan.
The rajputs are, in my opinion, the caste in Pakistan that is most proud of their history and forebears. Being descended from the legendary vedic warriors makes them proud, and possess the legacy of their ancestors' vedic culture, but just one caste the Rajput caste owns the rich legacy of the Indus Valley. The Rajputs of Pakistan even carry on the rich heritage of their ancestors' names after converting to Islam.
Sach yah hai ki Islam jis jagah se bhi guzra usne us khite ke avam ke religion ko hi nasht nahi kiya usne unki virasat ko kabool karne se mahroom kar diya. Prof. ne sahi kaha par pakistan Govt. aur aaj ke avam ki soch nahi badal sakegi.
Thanks a lot that few Pakistani still believe in his proud Ancient History.. Yes, we hv some difference of opinion but admire to acknowledge proud history..
Mr. Choudhary, kindly call Nilesh Oak from Canada/US on the issue of aryan invasion theory, astrological evidence in Ramayan Mahabharat from where their respective period can be ascertained.
Dear Friends,
If you like my find my videos worthwhile, please share them with your friends and subscribe to the channel.
I welcome your comments, but please use civil language. Uncivil language does not make you more convincing. There is no problem if you want to disagree with me or the guest, but please do so without being disagreeable. If you wish to give an opposing view, please send me your contact details.
If you want to see my most popular videos, here are the links to them.
ruclips.net/video/hWJugbilQd8/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/hRDiEe90z6Y/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/sqHGMhJkygc/видео.html
You are welcome to follow me on Facebook and Twitter.
facebook.com/shakil.chaudary
twitter.com/ShakChaudhary
Shakil Sahib, your guest is an artist. He has mastered the art of speaking endlessly without conveying anything.
I saw you in the audience of ChristopherJafferlot program moderated by Hoodbhoy. I hope you will make a program on that and discuss the hypocrisy of the event and the individuals.
'....make a program.....'
Naa, he won't.
Birds of a feather flock together.
You are right! The guy meandered about without responding directly and succinctly.
@ratnakamal1 Exactly. He does not answer the questions that show any shortcomings of the Pakistani government or thinking.
The so called “experts” in Pakistan are so educated and well read that I as a college student know that nearly 50% of the stuff he said was wrong or outdated
According to this guy, everything was done in Taxila. Meanwhile people in Nalanda & Vikramashila were watching reels on Instagram 😂
There is debate among the historians whether Takshasila can be categorized as a ‘university’ in the modern sense. No such debate about Nalanda.
इन पाकिस्तानियों की बातों को सुनकर ऐसा लग रहा है जैसा की कही का पत्थर कही का रोड और भानुमति ने कुनबा जोड़ा।
Prof can't evenpronounce word it is takshashila it is Sanskrit word
These kind of professors are good for Pakistan 😂😂😂
Phir kehte hai ki Pakistan me tarakki nahi ho rahi 😂😂😂
It is तक्षशिला (e.i. Taksh-Shila)
Chandragupta Maurya, Ashoka were not Aryans, they were sons of India.
chandragupta maurya ,ashoka hindu nahi tha wo log budish tha
This is the level of knowledge these so called Pakistani "scholars" possess
Take it as a humor :-)
Taxila is the older then Islam...👍🏽🇮🇳
😂😂 andhbhakt spotted
In Santana Dharma, there are 4 types of “Antim Sanskara” mentioned. 1- In the water, 2- in the mountain slope, 3- in the plain land (we call it “Samadhi”), 4- Burning (We call it “Dah Sanskara”). It is also mentioned that who will be cremated in which way. Samadhi was for Sadhus, Sanyasis, Rishi, Yogis etc.
Aisa hi hota hai jab kisi madarse Wale ko kisi institute ka head banate hai😅😅😅😅
Shakil sahab aapse ye ummid nahi thi ki aap ek aise Prof. Ko laye show mai jisko precise knowledge hai hi nahi. Aise Prof. Se jyada knowledge hamare yahan 12th ke student ko hogi
Latest researches have conclusively proved that the Aryans have not come to India from out side.
The Aryan or Vedic culture was inherent to India.The Britishers taught us wrong history.
Arya means a cultured person.
*Reason Taxila, Harappa and Mohenjo Daro are Pre-Islamic and part of Hindu/Indian cultural roots*
It has no relation to Hinduism. Hinduism only originated after 19th century.
@@hawkingdawking4572True.
@@hawkingdawking4572 Then Islam was born yesterday, I wont even give reference to Mahabharat, Ramayan, Vedas, Shiva and how old Sanata Dharma or as west called it as Hindusim. Lets look at Islamic History, 17 times recorded Islamic attacks happened on Hindu Somnath temple was it after 19th century? Then even Quran has multiple reference to Hind and its people Hindu, even Prophet Mohammad said even though he is not born in Hind, he feels he smells of Hind in spirit. was Quran written after 19th century. Sind/Indus was the old river, the land beyond sind river, persians pronounced 'S' with 'H' and hence called all land below Himalayas and after River was called Hind and all people no matter who they worshiped was called Hindu. And this was reference is pre Islamic and even documented within Quran in some places where Hind/Hindu is talked about. Quran has reference to Christians, Jews and Hindus, unless you are saying your Prophet was lying and you are telling truth.
@@sandeepssangha
It was Rajaram Mohan Roy in 1812 who coined the term Hinduism. He basically "invented" a new religion for the 19th century, NOT the westerners. There were no 17 Islamic attacks on Somnath. The Somnath was captured by proto-Hindus a few centuries prior from Jains and converted to a shiva temple as it was their norm. Ghori, a minor warlord from Afghanistan was the one who invaded Somnath not the Islamic army. Quran has no reference to Hind or Hindus. There is no hadith on Hind spirit or whatever.
@@sandeepssangha
Persian did call the Indian region surrounding(not beyond) the 'great river' and the consonant shift may have happened from S to H. But Persians did and still have S in their language.
Shakeel Saheb in Hindu even today , Kids and Saint (Holy Man) are still buried. Only adults are burned
Shakil, your whole premise is that why your country/ society couldn't market this heritage for monetary gains. Any civilisation/ country has to own, respect and live their culture in order to market it. Then only others get interested.
Marketing one’s history and culture frankly sounds very crass to me.
THIS IS CALLED HISTORY'S MURDER ! 🗿
3:29 & 4:24 # Takshashila is described in some Jataka Tales (Ancient Buddhist scripts on art and literature) around the 5th century BC
Pakistani selling Lahori Churan 😂😅
Very disappointing...illogical and insignificant replies. Sorry for the interviewer...time wasted.
Request to all Indians, don't shower abusive comments, kindly listen full show, then make opinion and admire that few Pakistani has still preserved our ancient history..
It's not your ancient history, your history belongs in the Ganga and Deccan.
Invective is resorted to when one has nothing meaningful to counter with.
@@rizwanhussain645 You must have read Aitaz Ahsan.
@@ratnakamal1 That and more.
@@ratnakamal1 Invectives are all I hear from the children of the Ganga!
Acharya chanakya wrote kautalya arthshashtra and chanakya neeti, who was a professor in takshila University, he played a major role in establishing gupta Dynasty which ruled from iran to burma. But the islamic invaders destroyed all old gold heritage of our nalanda and taxshila University which were the greatest of that time. Student's/ scholars all over abroad used to visit to learn study. Religion change hone se heritage change nhi hota, we had the same ancestors.
Chanakya helped in the establishment of the Maurya Dynasty: The Gupta Dynasty came 900 years later.
Islam does not talked of Humanity, they talked about only Islamic brotherhood or Islamic humanity.
At least in India, nobody takes Aryan invasion theory seriously. This was a Eurpean conjecture to show that Sanskrit is derived from some central Asian proto-Indo Aryan language. However, Rigveda was composed around Taxila between 2000-1500 B.C..
Another ancient University, Nalanda has been revived and now established with the collaboration of International community. Today Nalanda is a modern and marching towards the reaching to its lost glory.
Indian are interested in Mohan Jo Daro,Harappa and Taxila are the places of Hindu tourism.
Buddha and Mahavir Jain was a Sanatani before he created their own pant
Like Jesus was Jewish.
Shakil choudhay😂 texla university😊. What a shame. Talks about education. He should repair burst tyres instead.
If Pakistan owns Taksh shila it only mean all of them are converted muslims. 😂😂😂
Most of the Pakistani think they are Arab, turks, Pathan, central Asians etc etc. But 99.99% of muslims are converted during 1000 years of islamic invasion from North Western borders of indian subcontinent. DNA Testing krwa lo sb pata chal jyega. 😂
Taxila was never promoted because of its Hindu roots. Even Chanakya was a student and then a teacher there. You're proud to demolish your roots.
It's not Taxila, but Taksha-Shila. Older than the known history.
Expecting a Muslim to appreciate it will be stupidity.
Taxila Mera City ❤
Originally Takshila
Good
The guy is lying through his teeth....he is just hacking his way.
Typical of pakistanis
My Friend ..Either u r an idiot .or you know everything but u r doing this hyprocracy on purpose.
You are probably mental slave of Arabs . You cannot tolerate glorious past of Indian History. Of Course Arab Baddos of desert did not know anything apart from bloodshed and looting..😂
They have habit of stealing from every religion, from Judaism from Christianity and now from Hinduism.
@@KashifAli-qv1xoThe Arabs were relatively learned people. The Turks were the problematic. But Takeshita was destroyed by Huns and not Muslims. Nalanda was destroyed by a Turkish Bakhtiyar Khilji.
The two gentlemen should have called it Takshasila, instead of the Greek Taxila. I also take issue calling King Purushottama as Porus. No apologies if it sounds revivalist.
every Pakistani Prof. bring religion in to their discussion.
It's in their blood.
It is understandable that the Arab Muslim religion & culture doesn’t want to promote or own the great Hindu /Vedic heritage all these prejudices are due to “Hindu phobia “ & Islamic practices of demonising all other religions
By pronouncing it in wrong way as Texila, till you are disowning this University. Please pronounce it in a correct way as takshila. It is correctly spelled as Takshashila in English and in devnagari script written as तक्षशिला. One more spelled version is Taxila, but it is wrong.
This man is under threat. Not answering as truthful historian. It is escapist. Regards.
Comedy never ends in Pakistan
Question: hamare students yahan aate hai toh woh kya sochte hain, do they own it?
Answer: jalebi, jalebi aur jalebi!
Pakistan has failed to develop the Taxila, Harappa & Mohenjo Daro and lost Billions of Dollars of Foreign Exchange while India maintained the Taj Mahal and many other monuments and earned the same.
SC sahab, please note that taxila etc. Is so old that no connection with Islam can be made. Hence, why should ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF PAKISTAN recognize/market it? Everything about your country is about Islam.
It is not Taxila it is "Taksh shila" "Taxshila" (तक्षशीला). This University is 4000+ years old. History found in Hindu religeous books "VEDAS" and others Hindu religious books which are 4000+ years old.
It wasn't a university and not 4000 years old. Plus the name is unproven. Your own Khichdi language has no distinction between 'Sh', 'S', 'ßh'.
MUSLIM SHOUL BE PROUD OF RISHI PANANNI WHO CREATED THE SANSKIRT LANGUAGE HE WAS FROM SUWAT VALLY
Namashkar Choudhary ji,
It is not just Chanakya ,
It has given many many more scholars and contributed much more things to world.
The panchtantra ( jungle book ) was contributed by Acharya of takshila.
Contribution to the Grammer of Sanskrit which is considered to be mother of all languages ( by Rishi Panini), philosophy, yog and many more.
Unfortunately pakistani scholars can never do justice to this great land.
Their inherent hatred for their past and hindus will never make them fair and explore the truth.
Migration of Aryans is laughable stuff . Do not try to link any contribution of Islam through this holy land.
Indus civilization cover much bigger area ( ropar punjab, and few places in haryana).
Rigveda , Ayurveda and many ancient text were written when there was only santan dharma in whole world.
Many thousand years later christian ,Islam etc have come into existence.
Had it been arabs , they would have done some justice to research on taxilla.
Prof. Rashid khan ,hardly seems to be capable - he is doing research with the essence of Islam and slave mentality. Copy some mischief theories of Europeans and pasting in his work.
In the end , you will own only NEGLIGENCE
Chodhary sahab isn't it strange for Pakistani people to be proud of their roots in the history of Pakistan before the creation of Pakistan on the basis of two nations theory. No one in Pakistan dares to claim his or her roots before the advent of Islam. Two nations theory is a failed concept, otherwise why should you Pakistanis migrate to non Islamic countries.Why do you guys use fruits of scientific research and technology developed by non Islamic people.Dont you wonder that the small in size the Jewish people have more than 200 Noble prizes,a very strong research and development base,a strong economy built by the sheer intellectual strength, stands so tall. And your great nation is living on debt and alms.
चौधरी सर आपके लिये हिंदुस्थान मे बहोत सारा प्यार और मोहब्बत है पर अगर ऐसे लोगो को आप यहा लाओगे तो वो प्यार और मोहब्बत कम हो जायेगी ये पक्का. और ये हम नही चाहते कि जो रिस्पेक्ट आपके लिये है हमारे दिल मे वो कम हो जाये.
Gandhar is not in Pakistan. "GANDHAR" is in Afganistan now a days it is called "Kandhar" from where SEETAMATA of RAMA is related.
Takshshila is Hindu university.
And Ghandhari of Mahabhart
You are a real idiot. Gandhara is the old name for Punjab and surrounding regions. Hindu claims that Kandahar is Gandhara while their own text books don't have it. Sita and Rama are all fictional stories. It has no link to history. Before the Ramacharita Manas written in the Mughal era of 14th century CE, Ramayana was just folk tales with not much of traction. Rama became a super star after Ramacharita Manas.
Abe jihadi apni maa ke khasam madarsachap, apne hi baap ko paida karne waalo jaha bhi jaate ho badbu hi failate ho. Tujhe apna pta nahi hai aa gaya yaha gyaan dene. Nikal yaha se gutter ke suwar
Uffff, your ignorance is astounding.
The Nepalese claim that Mata Sita was from their country.
Shakil ji for the value addition of your knowledge related Harappan culture not limited in Pakistan. In 2022, the latest ASI excavation at Rakhiigarhi village nearby Hissar (Harayana) had revealed wide roads, drainage network, houses and jewelry were similar to Harappan culture. It means that Harappan culture thrived in this village.
Wrong information! Those sites are not Harappan nor have they been independently verified as being 9000 yrs old, this information you are propagating is pure RSS nonsense.
Muslims believe in fiction created by the Abbasids
1. Mecca didn’t exist in the 7th Century (at best a hamlet)
A. No archeological evidence
B. No historical evidence
C. No or very little water
2. Mecca (only mentioned once in the Quran) wasn’t on any historical map until 900.
2. The Quran talks about a fertile place, which is not Mecca.
A. A stream
B. Fruits
C. Olive trees
D. Fields etc.
None of which Mecca had in the 7th, 8th, 9th 10th, to the late 20th centuries when Saudis started to have water desalination plants built.
3. Medina was an insignificant little place.
4. The term ‘Mohammad’ (Praised One) was first found on a Christian coin in 661 referring to Jesus, the coin had Christian symbols.
5. The term Mohammad was used by Arab Christians for Jesus until the mid-8th century.
6. The Mohammad that Muslims think of was an Abbasid invention in the late 8th century or early 9th century.
Mohammad is mentioned four times in the Korans/Qurans, the Muslim/Abbasid Mohammad in the Quran is the last of the four (Surah 33:40), is an Abbasid interpolation, and the first three refer to Jesus.
7. The Dome of the Rock was not a Mosque; it was built by Abdul al-Malik as an anti-trinitarian Christian building.
Both Abdul al-Malik and his brother were anti-trinitarian Christians and used Christian symbols on their coins.
8. Abdul al-Malik sent a directive throughout his Kingdom saying that the term ‘Mohammad’ should refer to Jesus.
9. The only original parts of the Dome of the Rock are the inner ambulatories and the Mohammad’s written on them refer to Jesus (in fact the term Jesus is on one of them), and they are decorated with lots of grapes, a Christian symbol.
10. There were no Islamic Korans/Qurans in the 7th Century. The proto-Quran was in fact Christian lectionaries written in Aramaic and old Arabic. This has led to many mistranslations in the much later Islamic/Abbasid Quran. For example, it is not the Virgins that men get in Paradise but Grapes!
Conclusion: What Muslims believe today is a fraudulent story started by the Abbasids when they came into power in 749.
The Abbasids bastardized the Arab Anti-trinitarian Christian lectionaries (combined with the mistranslations) to form their Qurans to suit their agenda.
Pls watch Adam Seeker Urdu RUclips channel for understanding Islam ...
There was no Hinduism before 19th century. The 5000 years 'civilization' claim is also fake.
@@hawkingdawking4572 what a joke that is sanatan dharam
Prof. Khan ko Takshashila (Texila), Punjab, Aryans, Manu aur Vaidik history ke baare me bahut kamzor knowledge hai.
Unki baat sun kar indians can laugh only.
18:27 … rafoo chakkar ho gaya … .
This is the language of a Prof.!
Toh kya hua ? Don't try to be oversmart
@@gurugantaal5782
Abe Chu+*^#ye, pehele Ghantaal likhna seekh!
Gantaal kya apne pichwade se nikala hai?
It is not TAXshila it is TAKH-SHEELA
Here is a Google search extract : 'Literally meaning “City of Cut Stone” or “Rock of Taksha,” Takshashila (rendered by Greek writers as Taxila) was founded, according to the Indian epic Ramayana, by Bharata, younger brother of Rama, an incarnation of the Hindu god Vishnu. The city was named for Bharata's son Taksha, its first ruler'
Lol.
@@rizwanhussain645 Lol at your beliefs.
It is not Taxila, it is Takshshila
Don't worry this both of Muslims pronounced problems 😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
Good yo see Shakil Bhai after s long time. Prof surely provides some enlightenment.
Alexander came here much before Chanakya
Only 50% fact is right other is just a pakistani point of view 👍👍👍
It is Takshila not texla
First of all it is not Taxila. It is Takshashila meaning Rock of Taksha.Taxila was name used by the Greeks.
Dr. Shakil Chaudhary saheb, we all are indigenous Indians. If foreigners couldn't pronounce Tak-shila that os OK. But why do we say Taxila out of inferiority.
I hope you would take it as food for thought and wouldn't mind.
Lahori churan😀😀
The Mahabharata story was written in a cave in Mana village in Uttarakhand, the evidence of which is still present. Vyas ji spent a lot of his time in this cave and composed many Puranas including Mahabharata. Looking at the Vyas Cave from outside, it appears as if many texts have been placed one above the other, hence it is also called Vyas Pothi. Lord Ganesha blessed the poetic Mahabharata directed by Brahma to be called the world's greatest epic, which was written by him himself.
❤ Thanks Shakil saheb for bringing great truly an intellectual and and an historian.
Such subjects if included in Pakistani text books readers can become proud and attach to their land instead of looking to Arab or Turks which they are not
It's not Texla, it's Taksh Shila.
Unless Pakistan renounce I$lam, Taxila will not be revived. There is always a serious danger from radicals.
Shakil sir, with due respect its TAKSHASHILA, not TAXILA. You people have killed the history behind it, atleast pronounce it properly.
अरे भाई बोले की दिक्कत नहीं है तक्षशिला कहने में इनकी अकड़ जाती है इसके पीछे की सोच इस्लामी है
This is medieval history of Hinduism / sanatani dharam. Chanakya was a staunch hindu. After partition the region went to the newly created pakistan. History of Indian civilization is more than 5000+ years. The Pakistanis would not do any research because they would want to hide the deep hindu roots of the land that they now call islamic Pak.. The muslims would not be able to relate to such a rich culture.
This problem is with the Pakistanis alone. The Egyptians and Iranians have not cast away their pre-Islamic histories. Pakistan is a confused nation and vainly keeps looking for an identity, after discarding it’s glorious past.
@@ratnakamal1 So true.
Aryan never came from outside. They were already here. This myth is bursted by modern historians. Aryan theory was design of british to undetmine hindu ideology.
It is a very interesting discussion; you must do it in more detail program. Please also do this on Mohanjodaro and Harappa. You also discuss Buddhist heritage in KPK, GBT Hindu, Jain, and Sikh heritage in Pakistan.
How pakistan claims the heritage of Takshashila, it will be forced to accept the ancestry of the hardcore enemy of Islam. So it is actually good thing that pakistan is not do so.
True to his faith he want to benefit from the other religions. These guys doesn't know what they have there. Our ancestors must have done a grave crime that these jokers captured our heritage..Sad but true.. India much purchase this from these jokers.
If Pakistan is not interested in early Buddhist sites or artefacts than plz sell all Buddhist artefacts and pay back ur debts will be win-win situation
TAKSH+ SHILA=TAKAHSILA, instead of TAXLA. don't pronounce like a western name.
How do you know which one is right?
Regards to Prof Rashid Khan.🙏🙏🙏🙏
Mahabharat written by ved vyasa in Sanskrit
The authorship of the Mahabharata is often credited to Vysa. Many attempts have been made to decipher its historical development and compositional levels. The Mahabharata was written by a renowned sage named Vyasa, who was the grandfather of the Pandavas and Kauravas.
Sakil Saheb, why your historian guest is not able to express his views in proper chronological order ? Why histrorical research could not be done on Takshashila not Taxila even after 75 yrs of pakistan came into existence ?
Taxila ko sanskrit me asli name Thaksha shila hai.Pakistan woh unfortunate mulkh hai jiske hisse me itna heritage treasure mila uska advantage lene keliye failure raha. Abh dekho taliban bhi budha statutes ko kitne bedardi se barbaad kiya.
Prof. Khan is hesitant to appreciate and honor Chanakya which is much understandable. We wish if Pakistan was a moderate country where people like Prof. Khan could contribute to their maximum.
अरे तुम पाकिस्तानियों को तक्षशिला कहने में भी अपनी अकड़ ढीली होती दिखती है
Pehle mujhe lagta tha Kapil Sharma ek achha comedian hai but kuchh log us se bhi achhe hai 😅 ....... aapka video bharat me sabko hasane ke kaam aayega ........ keep it up 👍
Even in Hindu religion, there is a custom of samadhi and burial in the ground among saints and some castes. It is not wise to draw any other meaning from this. You should also know so many things. Hindus will be
Like Pakistan it's Historians have also very shallow knowledge
Unfortunately Pakistanis are proud of the fact as to how many non-muslims recite 'Kalma' through jihad. Nothing else even technological innovation, economic success and heritage do not matter for Pakistanis.
It's not Taxila. It's Taksh-shila.
Expert who can't even pronounce the name correctly 😅...do some basic research first naaaa..... can't stop laughing through out the conversation...
It's called Takshashila not texla..in modern term it refers as taxila...again not texla...
Pakistan and India both owned the same civilization, culture and history. But Muslims disowned the aforesaid heritage after becoming Muslims especially after the creation of Pakistan.
And it's right because either they have to accept Islam or accept Takshshila means sanatan dharma
Fake scholaar
The rajputs are, in my opinion, the caste in Pakistan that is most proud of their history and forebears. Being descended from the legendary vedic warriors makes them proud, and possess the legacy of their ancestors' vedic culture, but just one caste the Rajput caste owns the rich legacy of the Indus Valley. The Rajputs of Pakistan even carry on the rich heritage of their ancestors' names after converting to Islam.
Islam ke ek aayat bata jo Insaniyat ki baat karta ho Mai 20 aayat batata hu tumko jusme allah rasul kafiro ki katal ki baat karte hai
Sach yah hai ki Islam jis jagah se bhi guzra usne us khite ke avam ke religion ko hi nasht nahi kiya usne unki virasat ko kabool karne se mahroom kar diya. Prof. ne sahi kaha par pakistan Govt. aur aaj ke avam ki soch nahi badal sakegi.
Muslim muhmmad se suru hota he or muhmmad pr KHATTTTTAM😂
You don't have a culture or religion to claim for.
तक्षशिला
Thanks a lot that few Pakistani still believe in his proud Ancient History.. Yes, we hv some difference of opinion but admire to acknowledge proud history..
Momin sab kuch islamic chashme se dekhta hain. Duniyavi najariye se dekho momino.
PAKISTAN CAN BECOME RICH OVERNIGHT IF ALLOWED HINDHU TOURISTS,
You can provide contact information of Rashid khan.
Mr. Choudhary, kindly call Nilesh Oak from Canada/US on the issue of aryan invasion theory, astrological evidence in Ramayan Mahabharat from where their respective period can be ascertained.
Yes call Nilesh Oak
Very nice discussion, thank you both Sir, we are most prefer to humanity