Two times in his interview Afrasiyab sahib presses on Exploring and focusing on Geoeconomics. After a year and a half, Imran khan and his team are now treading the path envisioned by Khattak sahib.
Totally disagree with this fella. He doesnt realize that our issue isnt state sponsored raducalization. That never happened. I grew up in the 80s and 90s. Pakistan was was different place. What happened was during the 90s when i was in school PPP and PMLN governments were making sure more kids my age werent going to school. The result of that is poverty reduction stagnated and literacy growth stagnated. Now we have nearly half our population that is uneducated but they have mobile phones. Conservatism and higher levels of religiousity are correlated with illiteracy and poverty. The fix isnt to concsiously move away from religion. Thats stupid and you are making an enemy out those who hold religion dearly. The state needs to invest heavily in its own people. Their education, their healthcare, provide them safety, security and justice. How do we do this? Simply by fixing our isntitutions that are there for public well being. This is how you tackle the problems of our country. You look at your people as an asset of the state and u invest in this asset primarily by fixing our institutions and secondarily by incentivizing education and good behavior . Guess what is correlated with an educated and skillful laborforce. Less children, less radical youth, and high economic output. None of what this old dude is saying makes any sense. Look the dirty reality of Pakistan is that our institutions are shit. We cant even do law enforcement correctly. We have to fix our institutions. We also are severly in need of religion in the absence of law and order and justice. Religion is a potent controlling mechanism that human society has developed to keep the population in check. This is what has allowed human societies to survive for thousands of years. If we remove religion as the controlling force from Pakistan, we will be fucked. Let me give u a few examples, lets suppose we make alcohol available to all of the public. Nearly half our nation is uneducated and has no sense of self control except what religion forbids. Now imagine this population ending up have access to alcohol. We will have drunkards and addicts everywhere. Since poor people are disproportionately affected by drugs and alcohol, rehabs arent profitable abd u already know our countrt barely has any rehabs, what are we going to do then. Whatever tax we will collect from sale of alcohol we will lose attempting to subsidize healthcare for all the addicts. Not to mention the loss of economic productivity from the labor class. Now lets come to marriage. If we remove religion and make our society sexually liberal. Marriages will decrease and divorce rates will also sky rocket. We know this because we can see what js happening in west. The building block of any society is the basic family unit. Sexually liberating a society will negatively impact the family unit. A few things that are expected to happen. Men will no longer feel obligated to provide for the women and children. With a shit job market like ours, a much higher percentage of women and children would need to have state provided safety nets. There is a cost to the tax payer for these safety nets. Please take a look at our economy and how many of our citizens pay their taxes. We will bot be able to support such women and children. Also, studies show children growing up in single parent house holds are much more likely to commit crimes and end up in prison. Thats another cost for the tax payer. Thats more people being unproductive and the rest of us will be footing their bill. Bottom line: no matter how much you hate religion, it is not to be blamed for majorityof our problems. Removing or forcefully reducing religion will remove it as a factor which keeps a population complacent when the state's institutions are shit. These paindu old school budhay need to disappear. They dont know how to fix our problems. All they can do is regurgitate shit about radicalized Pakistan because Zia. They know nothing. These bhenchod kuttay ke bachay liberal types dont understand social sciences. That is a big problem!. The leftists largely occupy academia, media and social sciences in this country and their evaluation of our issues in nothing more than what they hear sfrom goray. They believe, follow and obey goray with out scrutiny of their ideas. Hoodbhoy is another idiot who bashes religion using his anecdotes with out ever paying attentjon to the causes of our problems. Every liberal leftist thinks removing religion will fix our problems. NO! Removing religion will fix 1 problem and creare a dozen other problems. This is not how state building works. FfS
You raised a few interesting points there, although I'm not sure that at any point the guest argued to remove religion from the society at all. All he pointed out is that religion has been used throughout the history of Pakistan to radicalized and possibly hinder critical thinking. Which are both unfortunately true.
@@winnerski6218 that is simply not true. What radicalization occured? The only thing that happened was our democtractic governments destroyed our institutions. Nepotism and corruption resulted in our kids not hettung educated. We public is dumb because we are illiterate. Because we are illiterate people whi have no good skill will try to manipualte people to earn money. Religion is used by tgeae sorts of people to gain influence over the dumb masses. the issues are very different than what this guy is talking about. Whats worse is he supports PTM. Those dudes are attacking Pakistani soldiers and shit. Their propaganda is coming from NDS offices in Afghanistan. We accept people's difference if opinuons but this guy is straight uo deluded. He thinks our Afghanistan policy was not good. He tried to give the impression that we are at fault and we are the ones who are paranoid. Afghanistam attacked us is 62 to capture kpk. They funded separatism in KPK during the same period. They dont accept our sovereignty over KPK. Soviets as early as 65 were training muktibahini in east Pakistan. They played an important role in the separation of Bangladesh. Why wouldnt we worry about them setting shop ij our backyard. Afghanistan and India have the same problem, they believe they are better than us and that we somehow stole their land. Lol Ofcourse our army is going to work towards saving us. Our army's methods have had detrimental effects to the nation, but if they didnt do what they did, we wouldnt exist as a nation. Balkanization of this nation would continue with out tge efforts of the army
bai bht khob.... koi esa krein humein in paranay politics sy Jan chot Jay.... ye old politics humein mazi mn rakhna chahty hain...khuda raha in say humari jaan churay please....
You are doing a great job and we need guests like these , in future i hope you won't have stupid guests like other podcasts are having like douche celebrities and instagram influencers
So much love to see you doing this... At one end JKT and on very next episode Afrasiyab sahb like intellectual... Please don't be conventional media house... Call every one whome they generally don't like or better say not allowed
اسلام علیکم ، سر مزمل ماشاء اللّٰہ آپ کے پروگرام بہت اچھے ہیں ، میں دو ماہ سے آپ کے پروگرام سن رہا ہوں ۔ سوال کھٹک صاحب کی گفتگو کے متعلق ہے ، کھٹک صاحب نے کہا کہ ہم غلط کو مکمل طور پر غلط نہیں کہتے ہیں ، پھر ایک جگہ ذکر کیا کہ میں اس لیے جیل گیا کیونکہ بھٹو نے NAP کی جمہوری حکومت کو برترف کرکے ، اس کے رہنماؤں کو قید کردیا ۔ اب میرا سوال یہ ہے کہ اس وقت کے رہنماؤں کو ،جو قومی اسمبلی یا صوبائی اسمبلیوں میں موجود تھے ، جمہوری یا عوامی رہنما کہ سکتے ہیں ؟ اس کے برعکس یہ تمام ارکان 1970ء کے انتخابات میں منتخب ہوئے جبکہ 1971ء کے بعد کوئی بھی سیاسی جماعت الیکشن کی طرف نہیں گئی کیونکہ انھیں پتہ تھا کہ اگر ہم اب الیکشن میں جاتے ہیں تو دوبار ہ اقتدار میں نہیں آسکیں گے ، یہاں پر صرف سیاسی رہنماؤں نے صرف اپنے متعلق سوچا ، آپس میں ہی اتحاد کرلیا اور حکومت کرنا شروع کردی اور پھر آپس میں ہی لڑنے لگے ۔ سوال کا جواب پا کر خوشی ہوگی
who is next in line with interview and also do a live broad cast or place a portal so peoples can raise their question regarding that personality and party
Generalized talk. Pinpoint flaws in system & saleable dynasty political parties. Reform the formation system of political parties. No party head should stay more than two terms of 4 years each! This will eliminate hegemony of filthy rich families!
Bhai farogh naseem ko bulain, naeem bukhari ko bulain, yah b sahi hain but mazeed videos upload kray aur en baqy prominent lawyers air politicians ko bulain, aitazaz ahsan sahab ko bulain sir, i hope you read my comment
A tremendous choice for 2nd interview . good job
its always great to listen to Afraiab sahib. Great work by TCM
Two times in his interview Afrasiyab sahib presses on Exploring and focusing on Geoeconomics. After a year and a half, Imran khan and his team are now treading the path envisioned by Khattak sahib.
Afrasiab khatak is best speaker in the anp.he speaks with knowledge
احمد فراز 13:15
گر روشنی یہی ہے تو اے بدنصیب شہر
اب تیرگی ہی تیرا مقدر لگے مجھے
وہ مطمئن کہ سب کی زباں کاٹ دی گئی
ایسی خموشیوں سے مگر ڈر لگے مجھے
Totally disagree with this fella. He doesnt realize that our issue isnt state sponsored raducalization. That never happened. I grew up in the 80s and 90s. Pakistan was was different place. What happened was during the 90s when i was in school PPP and PMLN governments were making sure more kids my age werent going to school. The result of that is poverty reduction stagnated and literacy growth stagnated. Now we have nearly half our population that is uneducated but they have mobile phones. Conservatism and higher levels of religiousity are correlated with illiteracy and poverty. The fix isnt to concsiously move away from religion. Thats stupid and you are making an enemy out those who hold religion dearly. The state needs to invest heavily in its own people. Their education, their healthcare, provide them safety, security and justice. How do we do this? Simply by fixing our isntitutions that are there for public well being. This is how you tackle the problems of our country. You look at your people as an asset of the state and u invest in this asset primarily by fixing our institutions and secondarily by incentivizing education and good behavior
. Guess what is correlated with an educated and skillful laborforce. Less children, less radical youth, and high economic output.
None of what this old dude is saying makes any sense.
Look the dirty reality of Pakistan is that our institutions are shit. We cant even do law enforcement correctly. We have to fix our institutions. We also are severly in need of religion in the absence of law and order and justice. Religion is a potent controlling mechanism that human society has developed to keep the population in check. This is what has allowed human societies to survive for thousands of years. If we remove religion as the controlling force from Pakistan, we will be fucked. Let me give u a few examples, lets suppose we make alcohol available to all of the public. Nearly half our nation is uneducated and has no sense of self control except what religion forbids. Now imagine this population ending up have access to alcohol. We will have drunkards and addicts everywhere. Since poor people are disproportionately affected by drugs and alcohol, rehabs arent profitable abd u already know our countrt barely has any rehabs, what are we going to do then. Whatever tax we will collect from sale of alcohol we will lose attempting to subsidize healthcare for all the addicts. Not to mention the loss of economic productivity from the labor class.
Now lets come to marriage. If we remove religion and make our society sexually liberal. Marriages will decrease and divorce rates will also sky rocket. We know this because we can see what js happening in west. The building block of any society is the basic family unit. Sexually liberating a society will negatively impact the family unit. A few things that are expected to happen. Men will no longer feel obligated to provide for the women and children. With a shit job market like ours, a much higher percentage of women and children would need to have state provided safety nets. There is a cost to the tax payer for these safety nets. Please take a look at our economy and how many of our citizens pay their taxes. We will bot be able to support such women and children. Also, studies show children growing up in single parent house holds are much more likely to commit crimes and end up in prison. Thats another cost for the tax payer. Thats more people being unproductive and the rest of us will be footing their bill.
Bottom line: no matter how much you hate religion, it is not to be blamed for majorityof our problems. Removing or forcefully reducing religion will remove it as a factor which keeps a population complacent when the state's institutions are shit.
These paindu old school budhay need to disappear. They dont know how to fix our problems. All they can do is regurgitate shit about radicalized Pakistan because Zia. They know nothing. These bhenchod kuttay ke bachay liberal types dont understand social sciences. That is a big problem!. The leftists largely occupy academia, media and social sciences in this country and their evaluation of our issues in nothing more than what they hear sfrom goray. They believe, follow and obey goray with out scrutiny of their ideas.
Hoodbhoy is another idiot who bashes religion using his anecdotes with out ever paying attentjon to the causes of our problems. Every liberal leftist thinks removing religion will fix our problems. NO! Removing religion will fix 1 problem and creare a dozen other problems. This is not how state building works. FfS
Wow how much time did you took to writr it?
Hmmm.. not really
You raised a few interesting points there, although I'm not sure that at any point the guest argued to remove religion from the society at all. All he pointed out is that religion has been used throughout the history of Pakistan to radicalized and possibly hinder critical thinking. Which are both unfortunately true.
@@winnerski6218 that is simply not true. What radicalization occured? The only thing that happened was our democtractic governments destroyed our institutions. Nepotism and corruption resulted in our kids not hettung educated. We public is dumb because we are illiterate. Because we are illiterate people whi have no good skill will try to manipualte people to earn money. Religion is used by tgeae sorts of people to gain influence over the dumb masses. the issues are very different than what this guy is talking about. Whats worse is he supports PTM. Those dudes are attacking Pakistani soldiers and shit. Their propaganda is coming from NDS offices in Afghanistan.
We accept people's difference if opinuons but this guy is straight uo deluded. He thinks our Afghanistan policy was not good. He tried to give the impression that we are at fault and we are the ones who are paranoid. Afghanistam attacked us is 62 to capture kpk. They funded separatism in KPK during the same period. They dont accept our sovereignty over KPK. Soviets as early as 65 were training muktibahini in east Pakistan. They played an important role in the separation of Bangladesh. Why wouldnt we worry about them setting shop ij our backyard.
Afghanistan and India have the same problem, they believe they are better than us and that we somehow stole their land. Lol
Ofcourse our army is going to work towards saving us.
Our army's methods have had detrimental effects to the nation, but if they didnt do what they did, we wouldnt exist as a nation. Balkanization of this nation would continue with out tge efforts of the army
He's way too leftist , and far from reality. ANP was the most corrupted party in KP
bai bht khob.... koi esa krein humein in paranay politics sy Jan chot Jay.... ye old politics humein mazi mn rakhna chahty hain...khuda raha in say humari jaan churay please....
Really interesting talk and very good guest. I don't agree with everything he says but he has some very good insights.
You are doing a great job and we need guests like these , in future i hope you won't have stupid guests like other podcasts are having like douche celebrities and instagram influencers
So much love to see you doing this... At one end JKT and on very next episode Afrasiyab sahb like intellectual... Please don't be conventional media house... Call every one whome they generally don't like or better say not allowed
Please also do podcast with Asad Umar, Dr. Atta ur Rehman and Dr. Sania Nishtar
Afrsiab is an intellectual.
Great talk. Keep continuing the good work!
Best opinion.....pakistan Havn't foriegn policy .....
Khattak sir weldone....like that peoples have to come to lead ...✌
thanks brother thankx for your work
Beautiful👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
Ma sha Allah, Keep it up, sir.
In unboxing Pakistan videos the people who you interview can you please write the designation of these people
Please syed naeem bukhari adv ko zuroor bulaye.. He is the great personality ❤️❤️❤️
Such intelectual personality
اسلام علیکم ،
سر مزمل ماشاء اللّٰہ آپ کے پروگرام بہت اچھے ہیں ، میں دو ماہ سے آپ کے پروگرام سن رہا ہوں ۔
سوال کھٹک صاحب کی گفتگو کے متعلق ہے ، کھٹک صاحب نے کہا کہ ہم غلط کو مکمل طور پر غلط نہیں کہتے ہیں ، پھر ایک جگہ ذکر کیا کہ میں اس لیے جیل گیا کیونکہ بھٹو نے NAP کی جمہوری حکومت کو برترف کرکے ، اس کے رہنماؤں کو قید کردیا ۔
اب میرا سوال یہ ہے کہ اس وقت کے رہنماؤں کو ،جو قومی اسمبلی یا صوبائی اسمبلیوں میں موجود تھے ، جمہوری یا عوامی رہنما کہ سکتے ہیں ؟
اس کے برعکس یہ تمام ارکان 1970ء کے انتخابات میں منتخب ہوئے جبکہ 1971ء کے بعد کوئی بھی سیاسی جماعت الیکشن کی طرف نہیں گئی کیونکہ انھیں پتہ تھا کہ اگر ہم اب الیکشن میں جاتے ہیں تو دوبار ہ اقتدار میں نہیں آسکیں گے ، یہاں پر صرف سیاسی رہنماؤں نے صرف اپنے متعلق سوچا ، آپس میں ہی اتحاد کرلیا اور حکومت کرنا شروع کردی اور پھر آپس میں ہی لڑنے لگے ۔
سوال کا جواب پا کر خوشی ہوگی
who is next in line with interview and also do a live broad cast or place a portal so peoples can raise their question regarding that personality and party
Keep up the great work !
Top show, thanks for sharing.
Great work TCM
Generalized talk. Pinpoint flaws in system & saleable dynasty political parties. Reform the formation system of political parties. No party head should stay more than two terms of 4 years each! This will eliminate hegemony of filthy rich families!
Please Mohsin dawar ko bula lain
Bhut he zbrdst
Enemy of Pakistan. Foreign agent working against the solidarity of Muslims . Fitnagar !
are u on twitter Muzamil??? plz share ur handle...
Pearls of wisdom ,PTI & Army must consider all this
❤❤❤
Bohat achi debate kar raha han
Love Afrasiab sab
Bravo
Fan
Bhai farogh naseem ko bulain, naeem bukhari ko bulain, yah b sahi hain but mazeed videos upload kray aur en baqy prominent lawyers air politicians ko bulain, aitazaz ahsan sahab ko bulain sir, i hope you read my comment
Please call Dr Aata ur Rehman
subscribed u after watching asad umer's podcast and now unsubscribing u after this
Hassaan Malik dont worry i’ve subscribed now watching this. Pareshan na for channel many more will join
Why?
Regarding Karl Marx you are wrong, the system he gave to humanity didn't fail, actually that system never was enacted with very spirits.
Today you are fairly argued,but actually you are also comrade. And ANP destroyed because of you.this is begum Naseem statement.
Lannatt