Jim Harbaugh potential fit with Bears, is the CFP right without Florida State? | CFB | THE HERD

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 14 янв 2025

Комментарии • 846

  • @TheHerdOnFS1
    @TheHerdOnFS1  Год назад +9

    Watch The Joel Klatt Show: A College Football Podcast: bit.ly/JoelKlattShow

    • @christianmanriquez7022
      @christianmanriquez7022 Год назад

      Statical variance 3:50. I learned a lot low key lol

    • @conor34
      @conor34 Год назад

      Imagine the nfl did this oh mahomes got hurt take them out the playoffs we don’t want to watch them play

    • @arkbama6
      @arkbama6 Год назад

      @@conor34they already have a larger playoff system which would have helped FSU this year but THE ACC commissioner voted against it!!!!!

    • @SpiceofLifeCo
      @SpiceofLifeCo Год назад

      ​@@christianmanriquez7022❤❤❤

    • @RossIsFine
      @RossIsFine Год назад

      Colin and Klatt are slaves, puppets to the network. They aren't an opinion show. They're as fake as CNN. College football, like NFL is as fake and staged as wrestling. It's all about RATINGS. Not about competition.

  • @drunkwizard2362
    @drunkwizard2362 Год назад +192

    People thought that Oregon was going to push UW around as well

    • @joeking433
      @joeking433 Год назад

      @user-tn8uu2cu8g Get behind me, Satan.

    • @scruffd0g193
      @scruffd0g193 Год назад +16

      And that Texas secondary hasn’t seen the NFL WRs Washington has.

    • @IsaacStevensHOA
      @IsaacStevensHOA Год назад

      @user-tn8uu2cu8g ?

    • @jordan12118
      @jordan12118 Год назад +23

      They gave Oregon more credit for losing to Washington the first time than they gave Washington for beating Oregon

    • @RayW....
      @RayW.... Год назад +6

      Lol...Oregon

  • @christopherjackson5612
    @christopherjackson5612 Год назад +175

    Always nice to have Colin spend quality time with his dad

  • @jailbreak852
    @jailbreak852 Год назад +228

    You can sugarcoat the selection process all you want. Thankfully this is the last time we'll have to see a 4 team playoff

    • @quentinzimmerlee7193
      @quentinzimmerlee7193 Год назад +22

      Ya we can't wait to watch 4 sec teams make the final 4 year in and year out

    • @ronaldford-vm1dj
      @ronaldford-vm1dj Год назад +5

      Lol yeah right lol

    • @ionlybringthistoyoubecause1783
      @ionlybringthistoyoubecause1783 Год назад +7

      ​@@quentinzimmerlee7193that will never happen 1 time ever haha. We know you love the SEC, but chill. They'll never ever ever ever be good enough to have 4 final 4 teams.

    • @IWsBIxMuRDeR
      @IWsBIxMuRDeR Год назад +8

      @@quentinzimmerlee7193 people like you are so unbelievably casual its not funny. below .500 last year in bowl games, below .500 this year against power 5 conference. don't speak for the SEC, SEC sucks outside of the top 2 teams. Alabama and Georgia/LSU are the only challenges, beating each other and getting ranked top 15 is wild. get ready to see a lot of SEC losses

    • @manuelriggins2981
      @manuelriggins2981 Год назад +5

      He probably meant that's what they trying to do anyway is have 4 sec teams like no one else matters

  • @DubMiyagi
    @DubMiyagi Год назад +34

    Am I the only one who’s audio sounds weird in Colin’s videos recently ????

  • @FirstNameLastName-hz4kv
    @FirstNameLastName-hz4kv Год назад +112

    How can someone in the same breath say that being undefeated doesn't matter, but also give bama credit for ending a winstreak?

    • @td9046
      @td9046 Год назад +22

      Because they were the two time defending National Champion and were going for a record third championship

    • @db_1337
      @db_1337 Год назад +15

      FSU would get slaughtered against any of those 4 playoff teams. Undefeated isn't the only thing that matters..

    • @kylesawkon4074
      @kylesawkon4074 Год назад

      ⁠@@db_1337I disagree I think fsu could beat Michigan and texas, big 12 and big 10 are dog 💩 conferences. You just can’t stand a low scoring game cus you have autism

    • @kaylamartinez5412
      @kaylamartinez5412 Год назад +3

      SEC

    • @anthonymelendez333
      @anthonymelendez333 Год назад +16

      @@db_1337yea lol like bama slaughtered auburn and usf 😂😂😂

  • @briankelly7978
    @briankelly7978 Год назад +42

    Joel always roasts jmac hahaha thank you Joel

    • @KonaTheDragon
      @KonaTheDragon Год назад

      J-Wack deserves all the smoke. He’s so weak and pathetic. He’s a spineless suck-up cringy dork. “I support the current thing and whatever the important people think at all times! Am I a good boy Colin and producers??” 🤮

    • @AntiPhantom
      @AntiPhantom Год назад

      @user-tn8uu2cu8gAmericans worship Jesus Christ

  • @isaacparry1295
    @isaacparry1295 Год назад +41

    So basically they think that the Bama Michigan game will be like a Big 10 vs SEC type game and Uw vs Texas will be like a PAC 12 vs Big 12 type game. So deep and insightful

    • @sl0thman353
      @sl0thman353 Год назад +2

      I would never expect anything deep or insightful from Colin lmfao

    • @WeaponX702
      @WeaponX702 Год назад +3

      And what do you think those game will be like Mr Insightful?

    • @djacks247
      @djacks247 Год назад +1

      what else is there to say? its college football

    • @ojogbaneamedu2501
      @ojogbaneamedu2501 Год назад

      And they were right...

  • @branshep12
    @branshep12 Год назад +32

    They change they're excuses mid point lol. Sometimes its JT is hurts. Sometimes it's the committee making a statement about the ACC. Sometimes it's just because Alabama. Sometimes it's because of TCU and the "business". It would not have mattered if JT was in or not. Klatt said what is probably true. they're not leaving the SEC champ Alabama out, and they cant keep the team that beat them out. In the scenario Alabama won there was never a chance for FSU no matter who they had at QB.

  • @rodolfocastillo598
    @rodolfocastillo598 Год назад +20

    What’s wrong with the Mics ?

    • @kz1000ps
      @kz1000ps Год назад +3

      Phasing issues, a super basic thing in the world of audio production that could be fixed really easily. Apparently FS1 has fallen on hard times and can't afford to pay for a basic technical staff these days...

    • @christopherporter5472
      @christopherporter5472 Год назад +3

      Making sure I wasn't the only one

    • @nickgockel4134
      @nickgockel4134 Год назад +1

      Same thing there’s something wrong here

    • @gargould7186
      @gargould7186 Год назад

      Joel Klatt 💀

  • @MrPureMayhem
    @MrPureMayhem Год назад +44

    Always looking forward to Wednesdays in the fall when Colin and Joel get together. Best segment in sports

  • @Smock27
    @Smock27 Год назад +8

    Audio been off for 2 days now

  • @jaystacks5249
    @jaystacks5249 Год назад +13

    FSU had three weeks to coach the backup up and make history and was denied

    • @loganduncan5335
      @loganduncan5335 Год назад +2

      True but we had a stinker in the championship, probs won’t this year, should b good games all throughout the playoff

  • @adam-thesportsguy6147
    @adam-thesportsguy6147 Год назад +19

    These same geniuses told me last weekend Washington and Bama were not as good as Oregon and UGA. Last playoff they told me TCU had no chance vs Michigan. They suck at picking games so forgive me if I don’t like the idea of them projecting what they think will happen in the playoff and trying to book the best WWE card.

    • @RayW....
      @RayW.... Год назад +2

      You mean they couldn't predict the future that's crazy

    • @tomas746
      @tomas746 Год назад

      Their coverage is determined by being associated with Fox and the Big 10. They pick Michigan every single year. They got lucky when Ryan Day took over at OSU so it has lent some credence to their otherwise facile analysis. Michigan is gonna lose to Alabama and these two will just be like aw shucks

  • @willsportz
    @willsportz Год назад +40

    If Michigan got left out cause of their qb getting hurt, they'd be FURIOUS

    • @rickydavis1051
      @rickydavis1051 Год назад +13

      L Take. Michigans offense is surrounded around the run game. FSU is not. Michigan is head and shoulders better

    • @willsportz
      @willsportz Год назад +8

      @rickydavis1051 Michigan fans say this every year then they lose in the postseason

    • @zotix3855
      @zotix3855 Год назад

      @@rickydavis1051 Lmao, I can't imagine saying "L take" and being taken seriously.

    • @rickydavis1051
      @rickydavis1051 Год назад +6

      @@zotix3855 don’t strain yourself. It ain’t that deep

    • @Reggie2kj
      @Reggie2kj Год назад +2

      If Milroe got hurt Alabama would be 100% not get in…
      FSU’s whole offense was their Qb.Michigan’s isn’t…

  • @Devon6024
    @Devon6024 Год назад +35

    It sickens me that people are okay with FSU being left out.
    All these years and this never happens. Once an SEC team might be left out, they change the rules.

    • @Gx5379
      @Gx5379 Год назад +9

      The rules never changed 🤣
      You just don’t like that the current ones were enforced.

    • @juanspears5567
      @juanspears5567 Год назад +6

      ​@@Gx5379rules haven't changed...you're right...NCAA simply chose to bend it and help Bama get in

    • @Drewstok19
      @Drewstok19 Год назад +4

      ⁠​⁠​⁠@@Gx5379neither bama or Texas deserved to jump fsu. Texas for damn sure shouldn’t be in there. They lost to Oklahoma. They almost lost to Kansas state and tcu(they lost to Colorado that should tell you something). Their conference championship was against a clown show that lost to SOUTH ALABAMA 33-7!! their. Entire. Case. Rests on the fact that they beat Alabama in week 2. It’s funny that we want to reward Texas for beating Alabama that early in the season. And in the same breath give Alabama a pass for the loss because it was so early in the season. FSU deserved to be in. Period. The selection committee is a joke.

    • @jayhagan8151
      @jayhagan8151 Год назад +1

      Stop being so dramatic and calm down. Your sickened by a simple difference in opinion. Grow up. Move on.

    • @OmarFit1
      @OmarFit1 Год назад

      @@Gx5379well how did Cincinnati get in over Michigan 2 years ago?

  • @fsu1jreed
    @fsu1jreed Год назад +87

    The ACC was 6-4 against the SEC and 4-3 against the BIG and has the most bowl eligible teams of any conference...and ESPN started the narrative BEFORE Travis got injured.
    Also the SEC was down this year, 7-9 against other P5 conferences

    • @Football22636
      @Football22636 Год назад +6

      Acc is always bad😂

    • @Cmullet33
      @Cmullet33 Год назад +7

      Thank you! I have been saying the same thing. The committee is corrupt and only cares about money and ratings. Alabama STRUGGLED against Arkansas, South Florida and Auburn and won by a miracle 4th and 31 play at the end! Seminoles won every single game with a backup qb and a 3rd string qb in the championship game. This should ENHANCE our playoff eligibility not hurt us. We have a complete team! Found other ways to win! Defense wins championships!

    • @Football22636
      @Football22636 Год назад +10

      Acc didn’t play ga or Alabama 😂

    • @alvinfew8711
      @alvinfew8711 Год назад +4

      I thought about this yesterday when Colin had his rant about the ACC. He doesn't pay much attention to college football outside of the biggest teams.

    • @devincollins9726
      @devincollins9726 Год назад +4

      @@Football22636thank you.. acc never plays highly ranked teams in the SEC and I’m a Miami fan.. Florida State barely beat Louisville and the week before that it was atrocious Florida State deserved to be in but with a competent quarterback no one wants to see them get blown out and they would have gotten blown out look at how they played against Louisville what did you think they would do against Michigan stop… 😂 so I agree with you ACC don’t play no one ..

  • @robertelsaid3396
    @robertelsaid3396 Год назад +27

    I feel for any pure football fan. From grade school we are taught to do our best and earn the rewards. The committee spat on this lesson, also strongly related to the American dream. This is why so many of us (not just FSU fans) feel this decision is so vile at our core.

    • @patscool234
      @patscool234 Год назад +1

      American dream is bs, get real. Welcome to the real world

    • @MichaelLudden
      @MichaelLudden Год назад

      Yup

    • @AlphaDwg
      @AlphaDwg Год назад +2

      lol you will be ok buttercup

    • @deweyfinn1497
      @deweyfinn1497 Год назад

      Fsu can prove everyone wrong and beat Georgia

    • @UFBear15
      @UFBear15 Год назад

      and they can't, and everyone knows that.. including their own fans@@deweyfinn1497

  • @drwinstonOboogi
    @drwinstonOboogi Год назад +23

    The Committee got it 100% correct according to their protocols. CFP Protocol 12 section 1B clearly states:
    "In the event a team coached by *Nick Saban* fails to earn their way into the CFP then that team shall be given a free pass into the CFP's top four over one or more better and/or deserving teams regardless of whether or not that *Nick Saban* coached team won their conference, won their division, or were donkey stomped at home by double digits from ooc competition."

    • @manuelriggins2981
      @manuelriggins2981 Год назад +2

      I forgot about that rule, you right fam

    • @TheBlackSheepReport
      @TheBlackSheepReport Год назад +2

      Good one. 😆

    • @zackjohnson369
      @zackjohnson369 Год назад +5

      10 points is “donkey stomped”? I found another conspiracy theorist! Take off the blinders and admit that Alabama going 12-1 and beating the #1 team in the country is more impressive than FSU playing a Mickey Mouse schedule.

    • @travisoshea
      @travisoshea Год назад +2

      😂😂😂😂

    • @travisoshea
      @travisoshea Год назад +2

      This is awesome!!!!

  • @adam-thesportsguy6147
    @adam-thesportsguy6147 Год назад +27

    I hope we have 3 games 60-0. Not because I give 2 shots about FSU…because these people are so arrogant to think they cam just ignore the season because they know who will win and lose the games.

    • @lanthonybunkley3509
      @lanthonybunkley3509 Год назад

      Right

    • @snave59
      @snave59 Год назад +2

      FSU,has lost it's starting qb,Jordan Travis,for the season.They are not that good anymore.

    • @ThatFalloutGod
      @ThatFalloutGod Год назад +1

      I'm sure you're making heavy bets right now for FSU to at least cover the 13 point spread against Georgia.

    • @anthonymelendez333
      @anthonymelendez333 Год назад

      @@ThatFalloutGod I did lol it’s a buncha backups

  • @TheBanderson22
    @TheBanderson22 Год назад +4

    Why has youtube audio had an an echo this week?

  • @tirrelldaveport3671
    @tirrelldaveport3671 Год назад +21

    My issue is that these two and others want to have their logic both ways. I have no issue with the committee making this decision. But that also has to mean that the games played in the regular season don't matter. You can't have it both ways.

    • @Gx5379
      @Gx5379 Год назад

      The games do matter. One simple question: is FSU the same team without their starting QB?

    • @AlBiv
      @AlBiv Год назад +1

      100% agree and I’ll add this to your point. They both said they expect both Michigan and bama to lean on their offensive Line and great defenses until either imposes their will. Isn’t that what FSU done without their starting QB????? No we better see both teams airing it out and putting their “QB’s” on display all game!

  • @KonaTheDragon
    @KonaTheDragon Год назад +5

    5:10
    “First it’s the shirt..”
    Klatt told J-Wack his shirt was louder than his mouth last week 😂

  • @EricTheGay
    @EricTheGay Год назад +12

    Florida State should have been at 3. The only discussion should have been the 4-spot.

  • @erik22lax
    @erik22lax Год назад +42

    I wanted UW v Michigan and TX v Bama in the semifinals

    • @wongjuan344
      @wongjuan344 Год назад +7

      Big 10 vs SEC future matchup would have been sick. Hope Texas and Bama win

    • @JMichael-xc7uu
      @JMichael-xc7uu Год назад +1

      @@wongjuan344what you want could happen but the 2 best teams are Washington and Michigan but Michigan can’t win a bowl after the Ohio State game

    • @brycehammerton4542
      @brycehammerton4542 Год назад +4

      @@JMichael-xc7uuI feel like bama and Texas are 2 best teams

    • @frankc.astle214
      @frankc.astle214 Год назад +2

      nah we need another TX vs Bama national championship game. Texas finally has a chance for redemption

    • @admiscellaneous1124
      @admiscellaneous1124 Год назад +2

      It's going to be a rematch in the national championship. Alabama v. Texas - with Alabama taking this one. I would love to see UW win it all, but right now in the current situation, Alabama and Texas are the two best.

  • @MacaroniMIke8800
    @MacaroniMIke8800 Год назад +3

    The Bears were not mentioned one time in the Harbough segment

  • @patricktully9661
    @patricktully9661 Год назад +4

    Problem is its subjective. If we're arguing over alabama being better than FSU then you could easily say that Georgia is better than Washington and OSU is better than Texas and just have a Michigan, Georgia, OSU, Alabama/Texas CFP

  • @stt5v2002
    @stt5v2002 Год назад +9

    I think that if Alabama beats Michigan by 7, we should review the game stats. If Michigan gained more yards per play, they should still get to advance to the final. After all, the outcome of the game isn’t really that important and can’t tell you much about who should have been the champion. Just ask Florida State.

    • @andrewkelly1337
      @andrewkelly1337 Год назад +2

      You think you're clever but you actually just somehow don't understand the difference between qualifying for a tournament and winning a game in a tournament

  • @benshumski9290
    @benshumski9290 Год назад +1

    Does the audio sound all weird?

  • @wesleyowens4089
    @wesleyowens4089 Год назад +1

    Colin complaining about the Cincinnati game but not mentioning that Cincinnati was in a one score game in the 4th quarter while Michigan was literally defeated by the end of the first half. I seriously hate when people talk about this stuff but refuse to look at what actually happened

  • @wesleyowens4089
    @wesleyowens4089 Год назад +5

    They say we've always had a stinker but just last year both semifinal games were down to the wire

    • @malachilining2730
      @malachilining2730 Год назад

      There's really no excuse use that's been used that isn't hypocritical. If the idea is to avoid a blowout, just look at the games through a decade and you'll see that half of them have been blowouts with the 4 "best teams". If you use the 4 best teams argument then there's no reason why FSU is ranked over UGA. If it's that they didn't win in convincing fashion then just go look at Alabama. Plain and simple ir had nothing to do with football

  • @tristenvarney8777
    @tristenvarney8777 Год назад +3

    When Colin mentioned traveling I thought Joel was gonna ask if he stayed at Hampton by Hilton

  • @yofetv
    @yofetv Год назад +3

    Cowherd Klatt combo rules

  • @MrCtsSteve
    @MrCtsSteve Год назад +7

    Jim definitely walks to his own beat . He is a different cat .

  • @impactfoto
    @impactfoto Год назад +1

    Is it me, or did they get sidetracked and completely skip the part about whether Harbaugh would be a good fit with the Bears?

  • @marstonmaxers
    @marstonmaxers Год назад +24

    How about this: create 4 powerhouse conferences of 8-12 each within Division 1. Then create a larger second conference. And then a third. Run it the way soccer is run in the UK. The bottom teams in the top conferences move down. The top teams move up. Then, have the top conference teams play only each other...or at least have only the games against each other count for post-season. Playoff from there. That would be some drama. In addition, the top Division teams are allowed fewer scholarships, so they don't keep having an advantage. People want to see the top teams play each other. Not watch a top team pound and blowout the puny DI teams.

    • @KonaTheDragon
      @KonaTheDragon Год назад +4

      I’ve been saying this too ☝️
      Also need to create a payment structure and whatever else necessary to reduce players jumping ship and destroying any and all commitment in a sport that defines sacrifice and commitment.

    • @YourAverageFan
      @YourAverageFan Год назад

      No top team in the country is agreeing to a system involving potential demotion to a smaller league. It would never get enough votes.

    • @davidashton1305
      @davidashton1305 Год назад +2

      No conferences. There should be 8 12-team divisions by region. Each division plays each other and one non-division game, so 12 game season. Top 2 teams play for division title, then the 8 division champs go to an 8-team playoff where they are seeded by SOR rankings.

    • @qwertyutopia4667
      @qwertyutopia4667 Год назад

      Because these are colleges first? It’s not just football other sports move as well. And you have the academic side. The big 10 started as the best academic schools in the northeast.

    • @arthurfonzarelli9828
      @arthurfonzarelli9828 Год назад

      ​@@KonaTheDragonthat'll never fly. You can't tell a kid he can't go away to college. If anything the freedom for these players will continue to get bigger and bigger which has been the case the last decade or two. The courts will never allow for what year talking about there's no shot of that ever happening

  • @BigBoyJay_69
    @BigBoyJay_69 Год назад +5

    Let's just let vegas decide who the champions are at the beginning of the year and call it a day. Games don't matter anymore.

  • @davidkalmes8983
    @davidkalmes8983 Год назад +7

    Topic: Jim Harbaugh could go to NFL to Chicago Bears
    Discussion: Is Jim Harbaugh weird? Should players share in revenue?

    • @KonaTheDragon
      @KonaTheDragon Год назад +2

      They definitely talked about this off camera, and then got too comfortable on camera and started talking about what they wanted to talk about. Bad form, boys, bad form.

  • @jasonmuri9016
    @jasonmuri9016 Год назад +5

    Georgia wasn't nearly as good this year as past. They had the weakest schedule out of top teams and barely won several of them against lower competition much less losing when they finally played a top team like Alabama. I feel Alabama beating Georgia is overrated based on previous Georgia seasons and not this one.

    • @derrickmeade4891
      @derrickmeade4891 Год назад

      Fsu had the worse schedule of top teams but otherwise yes

  • @GoodyearSimp
    @GoodyearSimp Год назад +1

    Sound is off a bit

  • @jamesdo3086
    @jamesdo3086 Год назад +1

    Ending the segment on "I don't even like eggnog" is hilarious

  • @Browns2024
    @Browns2024 Год назад +1

    Is it just me or is the audio quality worse in this video?

  • @josephgreen2824
    @josephgreen2824 Год назад +3

    The ACC was 6-4 against the SEC this year

    • @ryankraft722
      @ryankraft722 Год назад

      and how many of those games were against georgia or alabama?

  • @PurpleHayes0213
    @PurpleHayes0213 Год назад +8

    It'll be a shoot out at the Sugar Bowl, but as I've seen all year long with this Husky team, they always find a way to win no matter what! Washington overall has the better edge over Texas in this game, Huskies win 42-35! GO DAWGS!!!!! 💜💛

  • @scottgeorge6655
    @scottgeorge6655 Год назад +49

    The only controversy in the pick should have been Texas or Alabama. Florida State would have had the better part of a month to coach up their new QB/offense and bolster their defense. The teams we got last weekend will not be the teams we get in January.

    • @RJCE420
      @RJCE420 Год назад +18

      You can coach and practice all you want. A full speed game is something you can't prepare for in one month. FSU back up qbs have to go through an entire season to get experience. Full pads at practice isn't going to cut it.

    • @scottgeorge6655
      @scottgeorge6655 Год назад +3

      @@RJCE420 That might be true, but the committee took that chance away from one of the only two undefeated P5 teams in the country. They projected that a flawed Texas and Alabama team would automatically be a better match for Michigan/Wisconsin. As a Big 12 watcher, I can promise you that Texas's win over OK State was not as impressive as it looked. As many others have said, why leave FSU at 5th even if they think they're not good enough to play with the other 3 playoff teams. We think they'll put up a good fight against Georgia but not Alabama?

    • @manuelriggins2981
      @manuelriggins2981 Год назад +2

      Plus the back up would have been healthy by then and they wouldn't still be using a 3rd string QB

    • @RJCE420
      @RJCE420 Год назад +6

      @@scottgeorge6655 Stop. You guys are going up against Georgia they just came off a 29-win streak and two back to back titles. If you want to prove FSU got robbed, then here is your chance. Also, how are Texas and BAMA flawed when they had a higher strength of schedule than FSU. BAMA strength of schedule was 2nd, Texas was 5th, and FSU was 16th.

    • @RJCE420
      @RJCE420 Год назад +2

      @@manuelriggins2981 "backup qbs" includes 2nd and 3rd string. It doesn't matter what you call a spare tire it's still a spare.

  • @joshmartonosi5624
    @joshmartonosi5624 Год назад +4

    Love these guys together!!! 🎉

  • @KazzyOfficial
    @KazzyOfficial Год назад

    What's up with FS1's audio quality lately? It's been awful

  • @daredevilseyes7493
    @daredevilseyes7493 Год назад +2

    I really wanted to see UW vs Mich for a last Pac 12 vs Big 10 Rose Bowl rivalry and Texas vs Bama for that old school blue bloods programs go at it again, but this is great as well.

  • @josephstewart9807
    @josephstewart9807 Год назад +1

    I believe the wrong comparison was made. It should not have been FSU against Bama; rather the comparison should have been between FSU and Michigan. Just compare the two: 1) Both Michigan and FSU were undefeated and won their Conference; 2) Both were in the top 10 at the start of the season (UM #2; FSU #8); 3) Both had 1 win against a top 5 opponent (UM vs. #2 Ohio State; FSU vs. #5 LSU); 4) Both Michigan and FSU had similar strengths of schedules (UM 53; FSU 55); 5) Both Michigan and FSU had similar winning records against ranked opponents when they played them (UM 3-0 against Penn State, Ohio State, & Iowa; FSU 4-0 against LSU, Clemson, Duke, & Louisville); 6) Both have winning records against teams who are ranked at the end of the season (UM 3-0 against Ohio State, Penn State, & Iowa; FSU 3-0 against LSU, Louisville & Clemson) 7) Both have similar offensive numbers (UM averaged 219 passing yards & 162 rushing yards pre game; FSU averaged 260 passing yards & 157 rushing yards per game); 8) Both had sub-par performances from the QB play against their biggest rivals (UM against OSU in the Big House - McCarthy 148 Passing Yards; FSU against Florida in the Swamp - Rodemaker 134 Passing Yards); 9) Both had sub-par performances offensively in their Conference Championship game (UM had 213 Total Yards of Offense; FSU had 219 Total Yards of Offense. 10) Both played average Conference foes in their Championship Game (UM vs. #16 Iowa; FSU vs. #15 Louisville). The comparisons can go on and on, and if you look at the data, they are very similar; so why did the committee not compare them? This should have been the real debate - between FSU and Michigan; not FSU and Bama. Not sure why that never happened?!?

  • @Makers745
    @Makers745 Год назад +3

    Georgia lost their playoff game to Alabama, Ohio State lost theirs to Michigan, Oregon lost theirs to Washington, FSU didn’t have one because their conference and schedule is trash, one step above Liberty, they are trying to claim Florida and LSU as a big wins. Why is this so hard for everyone, kinda sucks for FSU but they get smoked anyway. Committee got it right everyone can stop freaking out

    • @johnstephens6870
      @johnstephens6870 Год назад

      You forgot Alabama lost they're playoff game to Texas and your right fsu didn't struggle with anybody like the committee would have you to believe

    • @Makers745
      @Makers745 Год назад +1

      @@johnstephens6870 hard to struggle against that schedule, that wasn’t a playoff game it was Ike week 2 and the team they lost to made the playoff lol

    • @senpaiofsavage3072
      @senpaiofsavage3072 Год назад +1

      @@johnstephens6870 lmfao, didn't struggle with anybody? We just saw two struggles back to back. Let's not forget needed OT to beat the worst Clemson team in 15 years. And did you forget BC happened?

    • @johnstephens6870
      @johnstephens6870 Год назад

      ​@senpaiofsavage3072 well yeah you got me on the cleamson game and maybe bc. However I don't think they struggled in the swamp, maybe faced a little of adversity until the young quarterback settled down after he was rattled a little the speed of the game was fast, but he overcame it and then went to work and the struggle was over and looked like they were going to win big but he got hit with a cheap shot.

    • @otismichael2583
      @otismichael2583 Год назад

      ​@@senpaiofsavage3072winning by 2 scores is not struggling

  • @yosh7140
    @yosh7140 Год назад +1

    4:55 that was painful parents 😅😢

  • @phgo3336-s7k
    @phgo3336-s7k Год назад +2

    assuming it came down to Bama vs. FSU, does Klatt not think the majority of committee members picked Bama? does he really believe, lets say, 5 wanted Bama and 8 wanted FSU, but because, "path of least resistance," they picked Bama? if not, why not just say the majority of committee members picked Bama over FSU. seems like the only way to make a difficult, subjective decision between these 2 teams.

  • @Adam-xo5iq
    @Adam-xo5iq Год назад +2

    I like Joel, but a larger committee or more data will not change this for the better. A bracket larger than four teams is all that is needed.

  • @johnparkhurst3506
    @johnparkhurst3506 Год назад +1

    This is the same sport that used to vote on who was the national champion

  • @jkaise42
    @jkaise42 Год назад +1

    Why does every act like the 29 game winning atreak is the aame team from the last 2 years?? 10 of their 11 starters are in the NFL

  • @jefferybarefield6372
    @jefferybarefield6372 Год назад +3

    Its not a playoff if you have a selection committee.. this is a tournament

  • @Shortstop803
    @Shortstop803 Год назад +1

    Am I crazy or has the audio been off on this show lately?

  • @jaystacks5249
    @jaystacks5249 Год назад +2

    Listening to all these analysts try to clean this up is hilarious

  • @davidn.527
    @davidn.527 Год назад +2

    There will always be controversy with the committee. You need to have a legit playoff system. Next season will be more interesting when more teams get to play for the Natty.

  • @BraeDilley
    @BraeDilley Год назад +1

    I find it odd when people are at the same time complaining about how sometimes games in the playoffs have been blowout, but are also pitching for more teams, inevitably leading to even more blowouts

    • @HamMaker-mh7bu
      @HamMaker-mh7bu Год назад

      This isn’t complicated, with 4 teams if one game is a blowout than 1/3rd of the entire playoff is blowouts. With 12 teams it would take a ton of blowouts for 1/3rd of the entire playoffs to be blowouts.

    • @BraeDilley
      @BraeDilley Год назад

      ⁠​⁠@@HamMaker-mh7buit would take 4 games to be blowouts to be about the same. If matchups between teams ranked 1-4 consistently produces blowouts, what about 5v12? 6v11? It will now be 1v8 or 9 in round two, do we not think that could be a blowout?

    • @RD-wg9em
      @RD-wg9em Год назад

      @@BraeDilley better to play out on the field. Letting a team get blown out is better than leaving a team out for a hypothetical one

  • @Blizznor
    @Blizznor Год назад +3

    I like how they are feeding Florida state to Georgia

    • @powell4661
      @powell4661 Год назад +2

      Uga's hungry. He will eat Sammy Seminole and his renegade horse too.

    • @DreyfusLagoon
      @DreyfusLagoon Год назад

      FSU is either going to try to prove they deserve to be in playoffs or they are going to let the horrible decision get in their heads and sit a majority of their starters who are eligible for the draft I.e all their starting receivers and most of their defense.
      Wouldn’t blame them for sitting players and making the bowl game a joke, the decision was a joke anyway

    • @powell4661
      @powell4661 Год назад

      @chasecantin8141 the Orange Bowl has always been the premier bowl for the ACC, and it is an honor to be selected for it. Your post reads like a fan who knows his team shall be destroyed and is already crying and making lame excuses.

    • @DreyfusLagoon
      @DreyfusLagoon Год назад

      @@powell4661 lmao I’m just being real. I think fsu will beat ga if they start everyone, but it’s not an “honor” to be in the orange bowl it’s actually a dishonor to not be in the playoffs when the school knows damn well they belong there and it’s unrealistic to think that wouldn’t impact their play on the field. All a win in the orange bowl does for the school is prove something that everyone knows already and that’s that they deserve to be in the cfp, unfortunately winning that game won’t actually get them there anymore. It would be an absolute embarrassment to the selection committee if that happens though.
      And realistically FSU does match up worse against Georgia than any other team that was in the running for playoffs hold maybe Texas.

  • @gunguru7020
    @gunguru7020 Год назад +1

    The CFP has always been the most deserving followed by "the best" when determining a tie-breaker for the final spot. Bama should be on the outside looking in.

  • @ThatFalloutGod
    @ThatFalloutGod Год назад

    Notice how they want you to believe that JJ McCarthy is a Day 1, or even Day 2 pick, yet in Fox's graphic, they show every other team's QB outside of Michigan's. Can we please stop lying to ourselves about so many these QBs when they're not half of what they're hyped to be?

  • @cd-vq6dz
    @cd-vq6dz Год назад +3

    glad someone else pointed out that the ACC had a winning record as a conference against the SEC & Big Ten this year (and I'm from Tennessee by the way). The SEC is (as usual) over-rated. In 2 of the last 6 yrs they've had a losing record in bowl games as a conference, and if you removed Bama and Georgia from the bowl games last year they would have had yet another losing record overall as a conference. Bama & Georgia saved them from yet another humiliating post season last year. Cowherd NEVER seems to do any research, and his opinions are getting worse as time goes on. Part of me (even though I'm a long suffering Notre Dame fan) hopes that Bama blows Michigan out, if for no other reason than to watch Cowherd wallow in it the day after the game (and if Harbaugh does lose to Bama he will be 1-7 in bowl games as head coach at Michigan).
    Just a couple of weeks ago Cowherd was bloviating about how Oregon was the best team in the nation. Uh....okay Colin.

    • @mourka01
      @mourka01 Год назад

      Overrated but always wins what matters 😅

  • @dougsmith3821
    @dougsmith3821 Год назад +1

    The first year of the playoffs was the best year. The games were high profile games period. Fsu, bama, ohio st, and Oregon. Ppl dont talk about that playoff season enough

  • @Ididntaskforahandleyoutube
    @Ididntaskforahandleyoutube Год назад +7

    I said it should have been:
    1) Washington
    2) Michigan
    3) Florida State
    3) Texas
    I said it would be:
    1) Michigan
    2) Washington
    3) Texas
    4) Alabama
    They felt the SEC *had* to have a team in, because reasons. The only way to do that was to eliminate Florida State at all cost. Best teams? Most deserving teams? It depends on how they feel/need to get an SEC team in. Would the Seminoles win or all? Almost certainly not. But that's not the point. What if the '00 Hurricanes, '85 Cornhuskers, or '91 Huskies appeared? With their logic, there's no reason to even have a tournament, right? Cheers

    • @wesleyowens4089
      @wesleyowens4089 Год назад

      I said the same thing as you as to what is should've been but then u said it would actually be
      1. Michigan
      2. Washington
      3. Texas
      4. Fsu
      I was too naive I guess

    • @DIVINECR3ATION
      @DIVINECR3ATION Год назад +1

      4 best teams. Not 4 best deserving. GA and Alabama are without a doubt 1 of the 4 best teams

    • @wesleyowens4089
      @wesleyowens4089 Год назад

      @@DIVINECR3ATION the is plenty of doubt. But if you want to go off the computer power ratings the most common top 4 I've seen are, in no particular order, Michigan, Ohio State, Georgia, and Oregon. I've also seen Penn State in there but I've only seen bama as high as 5

  • @Thex-W.I.T.C.H.-xMaster
    @Thex-W.I.T.C.H.-xMaster Год назад +1

    Don't worry NCAA Committee Michigan is not winning the national championship... because Bama will be...

  • @Nowledgeman
    @Nowledgeman Год назад +3

    Even if you believe fsu should be left out, this narrative that they were so much worse without travis clear. The offense was worse but the defense played better... They only beat miami 27-20

  • @RedPillPlease
    @RedPillPlease Год назад +3

    Not that he would ever give a rip but you’re right your take sucks! Everyone knows what took place is bought and paid for. FSU could have embarrassed any one of those teams but now we will never know. Asterisk for this year crowned champ

  • @thelion7017
    @thelion7017 Год назад

    I didn’t know you put teams in the playoffs based off of what they did in 1998 and who their coaches are. This is a popularity contest not a sport.

  • @legochickenguy4938
    @legochickenguy4938 Год назад

    Colin randomly yelling "I don't even like eggnog" and then the video immediately cutting out is unintentionally hilarious

  • @taylorking1134
    @taylorking1134 Год назад +12

    FSU would've easily had the 2d best if not best defense in the playoffs this year....but the committee made it about style points as if every game FSU needed to score 50+. Shame, they ruined college football and made it about style points not wins.

    • @KonaTheDragon
      @KonaTheDragon Год назад +3

      When you have over 100 teams who play 13 games, it must come down to a vote. We’ve been pulling our hair out about this blatantly flawed system for a century lol

    • @arkbama6
      @arkbama6 Год назад +2

      Bawaha!!!

    • @manuelriggins2981
      @manuelriggins2981 Год назад

      Yea but when you only have 3 of the 5 power 5s go undefeated that's a no brainier the undefeated teams get in not two 1 loss sec teams just to save face. We can take Florida State crying but we couldn't dare hear bama upset they didn't make it. Clowns

    • @senpaiofsavage3072
      @senpaiofsavage3072 Год назад +1

      The only team in the playoffs that FSU has a better defense than is Washington and UW has a much better offense than anything FSU has seen. Michigan, Texas and Alabama have better defenses than FSU. A good defense with no offense will get beat by a team with as good or in this case better defense that has a competent offense.

    • @arkbama6
      @arkbama6 Год назад +2

      @@manuelriggins2981 nope wrong they’re other factors like SOS, best wins, and that pesky little bylaw criteria of injured players or lost coaches. Had FSU smoked its competition like OSU did with their 3rd string qb in 2014 FSU is in no doubt about it. Losing their qb1 materially impacted their ability to dominate. We all hate it for FSU nation but the committee made the hard right call.

  • @tylerwhitworth3797
    @tylerwhitworth3797 Год назад

    Why does the audio sound tinny on all the Cowherd videos now?

  • @samsonite99
    @samsonite99 Год назад +1

    I agree with Colin. "Bama v Alabama will be the same team playing each other"

  • @Superfreq69
    @Superfreq69 Год назад +3

    I thought Alabama had a rule they could not play a game North of the Mason-Dixon Line?

    • @nickfromcal1
      @nickfromcal1 Год назад +1

      This game is not north of the Mason-Dixon line...

  • @Atwater20
    @Atwater20 Год назад +1

    The golden age of college football is over. Money has once again corrupted amateur sports and has taken over. No longer will sports teach teamwork, honor, loyalty and fortitude. The damage has already begun an is massive. One of the most storied conferences in college football, the Pacific Coast Conference will be gone next year and kids are quitting their teams and transferring when times are tough or there’s more money to be made. Many don’t realize what we’re losing and won’t until its gone. Sadly, that is the history of man. Greed wins, humanity loses.

  • @ITrendzI
    @ITrendzI Год назад +1

    College football needs to move to a champions league soccer model. There are too many teams. Each conference essentially represents a countries league. The best from the conference qualify for champions league and those that don’t can compete in a Europa league equivalent. Soccer fans know this makes the most sense for college football

  • @jollysteffen
    @jollysteffen Год назад +1

    Audio has been terrible the past few videos

  • @darkxzero13
    @darkxzero13 Год назад +1

    It's absolutely hilarious that they're finally moving away from 4-team playoffs, just in time for there to only be 4 "Power" conferences left

  • @xandercrews4729
    @xandercrews4729 Год назад +4

    The HS decommits are a major red flag for Colorado

  • @Josh.1923
    @Josh.1923 Год назад +2

    I’m with Klatt 95% of the time, but not here. Atrocious that FSU was left out. Undefeated Power 5 champion, left out for a 1 loss Power 5 champion. In this scenario, Alabama doesn’t deserve to get into the final group of 4. Any other year maybe. Not this year.
    We have taken over the sport and determined that the more entertaining game to watch matters more than what the actual players earn on the turf. Sucks for those athletes so much.

    • @user-tz2zz5ij1s
      @user-tz2zz5ij1s Год назад +1

      You need to change your argument to two 1 loss teams. It’s not just that Alabama took their spot, it’s Texas and Alabama. If you argue 13-0 you should argue that they should have at least the 3rd spot, not the 4th spot.

  • @ChuckH2901
    @ChuckH2901 Год назад +3

    4 spots and 5 conferences???
    Increase playoff spots to 8 and each conference champ gets in, and then 3 "wild card" spots for those er...loose ends?

    • @ChuckH2901
      @ChuckH2901 Год назад

      Dude - Don't talk to me in the name of allah before I tell you where you can go - since you will only experience it in heaven -- and it won't be done by virgins

    • @kylesawkon4074
      @kylesawkon4074 Год назад

      That’s only a problem if they’re all undefeated, bama should’ve been left out. They lost texas that’s the tie breaker. Gifting a spot to bama is just bias and takes all integrity out of college football. Objectively speaking

  • @deveronlee
    @deveronlee Год назад

    What’s up with the audio on RUclips lately with the show.

  • @EliteSports24
    @EliteSports24 Год назад

    Is the audio messed up for anyone else?

  • @rileyperrin4964
    @rileyperrin4964 Год назад +1

    audio is awful today

  • @thefishingcouple
    @thefishingcouple Год назад

    Why is the audio so weird recently?

  • @Slobo182
    @Slobo182 Год назад +3

    Colin, its been two days, you work for Fox, FIX YOUR MIC.

  • @drayn1923
    @drayn1923 Год назад +5

    He said it was a clear distinction of a FSU without Travis vs what they are now. Was there a clear destination from two weeks ago when Alabama needed a prayer to beat Auburn (who was beaten two weeks earlier 31-10 by New Mexico State again New Mexico State) and Georgia who beat Georgia Tech by 8 pts and was a bottom tier ACC team.

    • @jamalstrickland1
      @jamalstrickland1 Год назад +1

      I’m actually with this. The narrative has been very focused on how bad FSU looked while MASSIVELY overrating Bama.
      They’re a young team and they don’t have the talent they’ve had in the past. But, they still beat Georgia so Idk how you leave them out fr

  • @adamking4184
    @adamking4184 Год назад

    Im a huge Texas fan and I am concerned due to our pass defense. We need our stable of backs to have a huge game control the clock and get after Penix in the pass rush. We have to pin our ears back and go. I believe its going to be a 48-45 game. It will be decided by a field goal.

  • @Shawntraci
    @Shawntraci Год назад +4

    I find it hard to go with leaving a FSU team out that was undefeated. You can’t make this ok with any excuse. Someone’s palms got greased…

  • @kencornia3333
    @kencornia3333 Год назад +1

    FSU: The experts had Oregon by 9.5 points and they lost by 3 to Washington. That's why the games are played on the field.
    Jim Harbaugh: Perhaps his revenue sharing comments were made to create a much needed diversion during the bowl season.
    Revenue Sharing: First NILs, next revenue sharing, followed by college football becoming the paid players NFL minor leagues.

  • @libertynow4047
    @libertynow4047 Год назад +5

    Washington’s OL are beasts and will control the line of scrimmage. Their DL has a secret weapon who’ll play New Years Day

    • @TexasNightmare210
      @TexasNightmare210 Год назад

      Lol @ anyone controlling T Sweat and Byron Murphy. Washington is not gonna run the ball on us.

    • @libertynow4047
      @libertynow4047 Год назад

      @@TexasNightmare210 we shall see

  • @lamontshavers3751
    @lamontshavers3751 Год назад

    Is it just me, or has the audio on the herd sounded more hollow the last few days?

  • @bearded_beagle
    @bearded_beagle Год назад

    Is the audio weird?

  • @dpo1168
    @dpo1168 Год назад +12

    All that matters is Michigan will be national champions at the end of the year and Harbaugh will be extended.

    • @spenser6353
      @spenser6353 Год назад +5

      Michigan wont be national champions. They always wet the bed in the playoffs

    • @mrcanman20
      @mrcanman20 Год назад

      bama is smoking them

    • @dylanforche8244
      @dylanforche8244 Год назад

      @@spenser6353people say always like it’s not only happened twice people also said Kirby would never win the national championship because he couldn’t beat saban. Just because something hasn’t happened doesn’t mean it can’t

    • @redeyejedi4400
      @redeyejedi4400 Год назад +1

      Alabama is gonna destroy them Michigan cant pass the ball

    • @Ed.01
      @Ed.01 Год назад

      ​@@redeyejedi4400Bama can't stop the run.

  • @kanyehess33
    @kanyehess33 Год назад

    Is the audio quality weird for anyone else?

  • @jordan12118
    @jordan12118 Год назад

    Best segment is all of sports

  • @joegardner851
    @joegardner851 Год назад +2

    I kinda forgot about Colorado 😂
    They aren’t a good team, we shouldn’t focus on below average teams. If they ever get good, then we should talk above him.

  • @paulfolden3173
    @paulfolden3173 Год назад +1

    Take the bowl games and turn them into part of the college football playoffs

  • @michaelwoody2111
    @michaelwoody2111 Год назад

    Love how Colin says, Whose got it better than us?