Sam is such a sweetheart though. I realised it just recently, but everytime you talk to him he always has something nice to say. As opposed to a lot of people in town who are rude right off the bat.
I’d rank Jas F-tier purely because the first time I ever played Stardew Valley I accidentally gifted her the ancient seed on my way to donate it. And she didn’t like it, to add insult to injury.
I actually like Pam a lot, she's trying to get better in her own way. Which is not the best, but it's realistic. And I enjoy talking to her every morning when I got out of the farm, it truly feels like i'm in my village talking to my neighbors. Like a everyday thing.
I will admit that I like Elliot, but that is because he is one of the only people who seems happy to greet the new farmer when you first talk to him I like that he just says nice things to me, and he never gave me creepy vibes like Harvey or Alex
I feel like, the marriage candidates personalities don't really matter once you marry them. They all end up doing basically the same thing, living in your house and maybe water the crops or feeding the animals every once and a while, It's a shame that they don't go out and do stuff once you get married (with a few exceptions).
yeah, this is pretty much it. The only bachelors I've ever gone for are Shane 1st Playthrough and Sebastian in every single subsequent one because INTEREST.
i marry sebastian every time bc lowkey he's just like me lol the cigarettes, (implied) weed, and my dream is to drive around in a jdm car like his motorcycle
@@k1n5h0 probably bc of the hair and the fancy words, but he's a whole writer lol he writes poems and novels, the fancy and complicated words are needed for said profession and also I just like learning new words thanks to him 😌🤌
I know! He makes you coffee and he goes on a book tour and writes you daily while he's gone ND he's just so sweet my little author hubby I love him 😍😍🥺
@@azia2358 and yes he does come back after 5 days I think. I never married him before I got into SVE so I'm not sure if it is base game or if it comes from the mod.
Okay imma be real y’all I have NO CLUE how y’all find Elliott to be pretentious, he’s just a writer who lives on the beach. Even in his heart events he’s not overconfident in his writing abilities and simply does it because he loves it. He speaks in a poetic way because of his passion for those kinds of arts, he’s just a genuine guy who willingly chose odd living conditions because that’s how he wants to live his life. He’s not my favourite marriage candidate, (COUGH SAM PLEAS INTERACT COUGH) but I still love him as a character. I’d love to know how y’all can dislike him so deeply.
He feels shallow, pretentious, whiny. Why do I feel that way? When I talked to him it was always "Oh so hard having pretty hair" or "Waah, sand in my shoes" or "So hard being a writer, must be sooo easy being a low-class peasant farmer" blah blah blah. Dude, I have long hair, I don't complain about it, since, you know, it's MY choice. I'd let it slide if it was one ot two times. It's very much not. Sand in your shoes? Well, ya live on the beach, so yeah. Either be bare foot, or have closed shoes, I mean it's just common sense. Also, come one day on my farm, you'll see how easy it is. I write in my free time, and yes it sometimes feels like a mountain I'll never be able to climb, but don't compare what simply cannot be compared. You know? Like these two activities are just too different to be put in the same category of easy and hard. IMO. When I write it's hard cause sometimes I feel like my brain will leak out of my ears, but I'm comfortably sitting on a desk. When I tend to my garden my brain is resting, but man my body does the work. And my garden is seriously not comparable to my in-game farm. So, yeah, that annoyed me. What really did for me however, was the way he talked to Gus. Who the F do you think you are dude? That was the definitive deal-breaker. Now I ignore him, or give him trash if I run into him after checking my crab pots.
I legit made Willy be one of my characters canonical dad because of how sweet he is. Also thank you for not putting Harvey in like F or D tier because so many people write him off as boring or a creep meanwhile he’s just a nerd who likes planes and is probably tired of people (the farmer) not taking their health as seriously as they should (THE FARMER)
Emily is under-rated. Shes just a nice, weird lady who wants the best for everyone. And she dances like a total lunatic at the slightest opportunity. S tier
my absolute favourite characters are shane and haley because they grow so much as people once you get to know them. Haley was first a bitch and was very superficial but she learned from that and became a better person plus once you marry her she is just the sweetest little baby it is indeed adorable. Shane was also a douche but his storyline is so good it’s the best one out of all of them and he is definitely the most interesting character in this game his growth as a person is really inspiring as well. His room should be nicer especially because he no longer drinks so the beer on the floor just doesn’t work with his character anymore (unless it’s soda). But his whole relationship with Jas as-well is very deep and it’s such a good storyline i cannot stress this enough.
I have seen people make tier lists and never I have I ever came across a tier list this analyzed and structured. My Stardew Valley character agrees with you
Though I love Elliott I completely understand why people don't like him. He tends to ride the fine line between a lot of self esteem and narcissism, but it's up to perspective. I like him because I've always liked more "out there" and eccentric characters. Other than writer man I agree with everything else.
I haven't seen all of his cutscenes, but he doesn't seem narcissistic to me. He let you choose the genre of his book; wouldn't a narcissistic personality be way less likely to outsource that big of a choice, and to at least make an unsubtle comment about it if he did instead of pulling you aside to say you inspired him and that's why he's dedicating it to you? I can't say for sure
I wonder what would happen if the tier list was more mathematical. So you can assign a score under certain criteria you find important and then assign each rank to a score range. I might do that for fun actually :)
Lewis is an F tier, but not because of the governor. The governor's great, he wears the silly little purple outfit and I love it. Lewis is an F tier because he's damaging the town to benefit himself.
Lewis is F tier because he uses and manipulate Marnie (whom I also dislike but 🤷🏻♀️), literally scams the town out of their money to make a bloody gold statue of himself, let’s the town’s economy and bus go into disrepair and Pam loose her job, and then expects you to sweep in to fix things. He legit sucks so much if I met him I’d sock him in the face. Absolute trash
Justice for Elliott! He was my husband in my first playthrough and he was really sweet, he makes you coffee and waters your plants, I really don't understand all the bashing people give him ☹
90% of people who dislike Elliot don't know anything about him 💀 "he's pretentious!!! 1! " He's wordy when he talks and prefers to be cleanly. He's easily the BEST bachelor, he's one of the only ones who doesn't start out verbally assaulting the farmer, and his dialogue is always pleasant and friendly.
Abigail is a entertaining character and her heart events are my favorite. Did you know that the main character that you play as has a mini harp on them at all times?
As an author and reader, I love Elliott. He is a poetic guy and actually when I got back to Stardew Valley, watching this channel and seeing Elliott bias made me decide to court him. He isn't hard to gift either! Get a fruit bat cave, get a pomegranate tree and you are good to go! I courted him with pomegranate and eventually married him. On Mondays, he goes back to his cabin. You can take the man out of the sea but you can't take the sea out of the man! He also visits the resort sometimes! When you reach 14 hearts, he goes on a book tour and writes you letters every day until he is back. He isn't a snob or pretentious, he is a poetic man and loves his words! I enjoy him so much! In another save, I married with Sebastian, and he is amazing. He works on his motorcycle, we have a frog terrarium, he gives you coffee and monster loot every now and then. He also encourages you to have slimes. I know slime hutch isn't so ideal but I was like "why not" and built one just because Sebastian wanted it as a hobby! He's an interesting character and I don't like that Demetrius treats him unfairly. Like excuse me, Maru may be building robots but Sebastian is doing coding like... How blind are you Demetrius?! And then poor Robin is doing her best to make sure both her children are okay, Robin is a good mom. Only downside I found with Sebastian is his Flower Dance dialogue (we were married when this happened), I asked him to dance and he said something like "do we really have to"... Excuse me Sebastian but you dance with ABIGAIL by default every single Flower Dance and now you tell me this as your wife... *broken heart* TLDR: Justice for Eliiott, he is a poetic guy. Sebastian needs to improve himself in terms of Flower Dance.
I actually agree with majority of your list, except Clint. It’s a hot take now, but I think Clint’s an ok guy. I think he’s just a lonely soul, and he’s stupid bored.
2:50 “we don’t see a lot of grandpa, all we see is him just saying like, ‘you’re doing so good! good job! i’m so proud of you!’” and thats not enough reason to put him in S tier? how many other people are saying that to you therm
I can relate to Elliott as a struggling writer but as a character he seems pretty dull I am glad tho that both Shane and Sebby got some spotlight! They are both prime examples of how struggling, misguided characters can be done well and Sebastian happened to be my first bachelor choice :D Also Shane's theme is one of my favorite songs in the game because it's one of the few times the game gets very real, showcasing the struggles of alcoholism and self-insecurity that feel much more deserved than Pam constantly mistreating her amazing daughter
The wizard should be A if Therm likes interesting characters, he basically slept with the entire town women and now isnt sure which of their offspring is his child
Nice tier list, my disagreements are that Krobus needs his own S+ tier and Pierre needs his own F- tier. I haven't interacted with Elliott much so idk bout him. All I really have to say is that Pierre needs more hate
Caroline: Personality: Broken marriage Tier: C Jodi: Personality: Broken marriage/bored housewife/seems lie she'd cheat/run away from her family given the opportunity Tier: B eh?
Ok harvey is not B because have you considered this: I love him And here is why he is amazing: Smart Sweet Has dreams He might not be the most intresting but he is a kind cute anxious guy
bruv i agree with 90% of this list but like, the sheer amount of elliott slander on youtube is astronomical 😭 he is so incredibly chill and sweet, just because he looks like a walking Pantene commercial doesn't mean he's snooty and pretentious except for the elliott injustice, awesome vid, I cried laughing at the pierre part
TBH Demetrius should be in F tier I freaking hate that guy. He's so weird in Maru's first heart event and is obviously a terrible father figure to Sebastian. worst npc easily. Also yes Willy is S tier he's my fave non-romancable NPC!
I'd put the Wizard in A Tier purely because I think him potentially being Abigail's secret father and also having beef with his ex wife (who can literally turn your unwanted children into birds) is HILARIOUS.
I actually like sam because he works very hard for his music more than shane and abigail does, he loves what he do, he's also nice and he likes pizza, i like him more than shane. At first I really love shane in the game, very emo and i really dig the vibe... that is, until I caught him smoking outside by the lake. Minus points for that one. Edit: OHHH MY GOOOD I MEANT SEBASTIAN!! Geeez I always confuse both of them since they both have their own vices lmao, but yeah, I like sam more than sebastian is what I meant.
Personally, my boi is always Sebastian, I start a new save, I get off of the bus, and Sebastian fears me. But then I make him forcefully date me, then marry me, then yell at him to give me a stardrop and then have 2 children... I named them Sacrifice and Failure :)
Granny is in S. I don't need to see or agree with anything else. You are now objectively correct. Also Elliot just kisses you without consent on a boat in the middle of nowhere and you start shaking so that's uncomfortable lol Edit: AND George and Gus. Love this guy 10/10 video
I think Linus deserves an S spot. Hes such a sweetie but yet hes an outkast by society because they dont understand him, when all he wants to do is to be in nature and share his wisdom.
Pierre and Elliot where they belong for sure. I like Pam when she's having a good time but when she's not she's awful way more than necessary so I'd probably have her in D tier. Really surprised not a single love interest in S-tier.
:O hype someone who didnt put haley as the worst. i think she is actually the best marriage candidate, like let's take for example sebastian, if you marry him it's a hostage situation. haley doesn't seem to have any long term goals, and i'm all for it :D
Yeah, I like some of the bachelors a lot, but I hate the idea of committing them to me for life. (so far, i don't know everything) I think it makes more sense for people like Abigail or Shane who don't have much going on and like the idea of being on a farm, but Sebastian?
abigail is S tier because we’re both gay rock eaters who like adventures and swords that’s literally it not to mention she’s the drummer in the valley’s cool little rock band LIKEEEEEEE >>>>>>
Literally the only reason I don't love Linus with all my heart is the part where he hangs out outside of the hot springs in a potentially very creepy manner. Actually, a lot of NPCs are "I'd love them except this one part"
fully convinced that everyone who hates elliott just doesnt know how to read and are therefore intimidated by him
I mean...yeah
I recently married him and his dialogue is 👌🏽😭💕🥰😍
No hes just pretentious
No he’s just an old ginger.
I just think he's a little bit pretentious
Sam is such a sweetheart though.
I realised it just recently, but everytime you talk to him he always has something nice to say. As opposed to a lot of people in town who are rude right off the bat.
i just got him up to 9 hearts and he is really a sweetheart. LMao a lil trauma dumping at times with his dad in the war but its valid
Very good boy
I’d rank Jas F-tier purely because the first time I ever played Stardew Valley I accidentally gifted her the ancient seed on my way to donate it. And she didn’t like it, to add insult to injury.
She and Vincent gift dirt.
who needs fatherly love when i have a virtual grandpa to tell me he’s proud of me
This hit wayy too close to home lmfao
Relatable
I like Abigail just because she's the easiest to gain friendship with. Because she eats rocks.
Willy will forever have my heart, love this man
true i think willy is the nicest character in the game with krobus
same he weas the first character that i maxed out 10 hearts
Willy is my dad fr
@@kallm6263 That piece of shit makes me pay 1000 to use a boat I provided all the resources for!
I KNEW THERE WAS GOING TO BE SILENCE WHEN YOU DRAGGED ELLIOT TO F TIER LOL
the only right way to do such a thing is with silence
I actually like Pam a lot, she's trying to get better in her own way. Which is not the best, but it's realistic. And I enjoy talking to her every morning when I got out of the farm, it truly feels like i'm in my village talking to my neighbors. Like a everyday thing.
Yes! It's part of my routine when I leave the farm to greet Pam, she's one of my best friends because of it XD
i hate pam because penny is my wife
I mean I like her cuz she’s nice to me when you befriend her and I like the wine aunt vibe she gives off
I will admit that I like Elliot, but that is because he is one of the only people who seems happy to greet the new farmer when you first talk to him
I like that he just says nice things to me, and he never gave me creepy vibes like Harvey or Alex
YESSS and I marry with him for this reason and he is adorable
Hahah I love Elliot! He’s a nice guy
Yes! And his marriage dialogue is the sweetest ever
wait i'm curious, what creepy vibes do you get from Harvey? coming from who has married only Harvey
@@robbiefroggy8568 Maru works for him and feels very young, but he talks about wanting to rub lotion on her back, etc.
I feel like, the marriage candidates personalities don't really matter once you marry them. They all end up doing basically the same thing, living in your house and maybe water the crops or feeding the animals every once and a while, It's a shame that they don't go out and do stuff once you get married (with a few exceptions).
therm is really putting out an insane amount of content before college gets too much damnnnnn
yeah, this is pretty much it. The only bachelors I've ever gone for are Shane 1st Playthrough and Sebastian in every single subsequent one because INTEREST.
i marry sebastian every time bc lowkey he's just like me lol the cigarettes, (implied) weed, and my dream is to drive around in a jdm car like his motorcycle
I don't understand why people don't like Elliot. He speaks in the nice way and he has a super cool beach cabin and nice hair. He's sweet
pretentious
He's just boring to me and because he lives by willy's shop, I don't see him much cause I HATE fishing in this game
@@glassesspokesperson6824 how?
Yeeees exactly :D go Elliott
@@k1n5h0 probably bc of the hair and the fancy words, but he's a whole writer lol he writes poems and novels, the fancy and complicated words are needed for said profession and also I just like learning new words thanks to him 😌🤌
so what i learned was that therm loves senior citizens and beings from the shadow world
the governor gets bumped down to D because WHY HASN'T HE BOUGHT HIS VACATION HOUSE YET
I wanna sell him starfruit wine at an insane markup
I don’t understand why some people hate Elliot so much. He’s literally a sweetie pie if you marry him.
I know! He makes you coffee and he goes on a book tour and writes you daily while he's gone ND he's just so sweet my little author hubby I love him 😍😍🥺
@@SilverWolf_-cj4qn wait u fr? He leaves the farm? Is that a mod or like it’s really the game? And does he come back??
@@azia2358 um it might be a stardew valley expanded thing in that case? When I married him he left the farm for a book tour and wrote everyday.
@@azia2358 and yes he does come back after 5 days I think. I never married him before I got into SVE so I'm not sure if it is base game or if it comes from the mod.
@@SilverWolf_-cj4qn oh okay because I’m always going after seb 😭😭 and I was like that’s so sweet that he writes you daily! I have SVE but thanks!
I mostly agree with this, happy you put willy in S or I was about to throw hands
The fact that you put Haley in D tier and HARVEY in B tier 😭😭😭 We playing 2 different games
LMAO YEA
Okay imma be real y’all I have NO CLUE how y’all find Elliott to be pretentious, he’s just a writer who lives on the beach. Even in his heart events he’s not overconfident in his writing abilities and simply does it because he loves it. He speaks in a poetic way because of his passion for those kinds of arts, he’s just a genuine guy who willingly chose odd living conditions because that’s how he wants to live his life.
He’s not my favourite marriage candidate, (COUGH SAM PLEAS INTERACT COUGH) but I still love him as a character. I’d love to know how y’all can dislike him so deeply.
He feels shallow, pretentious, whiny. Why do I feel that way? When I talked to him it was always "Oh so hard having pretty hair" or "Waah, sand in my shoes" or "So hard being a writer, must be sooo easy being a low-class peasant farmer" blah blah blah. Dude, I have long hair, I don't complain about it, since, you know, it's MY choice. I'd let it slide if it was one ot two times. It's very much not. Sand in your shoes? Well, ya live on the beach, so yeah. Either be bare foot, or have closed shoes, I mean it's just common sense. Also, come one day on my farm, you'll see how easy it is. I write in my free time, and yes it sometimes feels like a mountain I'll never be able to climb, but don't compare what simply cannot be compared. You know? Like these two activities are just too different to be put in the same category of easy and hard. IMO. When I write it's hard cause sometimes I feel like my brain will leak out of my ears, but I'm comfortably sitting on a desk. When I tend to my garden my brain is resting, but man my body does the work. And my garden is seriously not comparable to my in-game farm. So, yeah, that annoyed me.
What really did for me however, was the way he talked to Gus. Who the F do you think you are dude? That was the definitive deal-breaker. Now I ignore him, or give him trash if I run into him after checking my crab pots.
@@lou582clearly can’t read
@@flarthemself Absolutely, I never learned how, and am soooo easily intimidated by school smart people, they make me realise how dumb I actually am.
@@lou582 jeez, just a joke man
i howled with laughter when u said that sam and abigail are nothing to you and said it like it was nothing LMAOOO
I legit made Willy be one of my characters canonical dad because of how sweet he is. Also thank you for not putting Harvey in like F or D tier because so many people write him off as boring or a creep meanwhile he’s just a nerd who likes planes and is probably tired of people (the farmer) not taking their health as seriously as they should (THE FARMER)
HOW YOU GONNA DO MY BOY HENCHMAN LIKE THAT AND NOT EVEN REMEMBER HIS NAME
I 100% agree Mr Dew. Henchman deserves way better
Emily is under-rated. Shes just a nice, weird lady who wants the best for everyone. And she dances like a total lunatic at the slightest opportunity. S tier
my absolute favourite characters are shane and haley because they grow so much as people once you get to know them. Haley was first a bitch and was very superficial but she learned from that and became a better person plus once you marry her she is just the sweetest little baby it is indeed adorable. Shane was also a douche but his storyline is so good it’s the best one out of all of them and he is definitely the most interesting character in this game his growth as a person is really inspiring as well. His room should be nicer especially because he no longer drinks so the beer on the floor just doesn’t work with his character anymore (unless it’s soda). But his whole relationship with Jas as-well is very deep and it’s such a good storyline i cannot stress this enough.
completely agree, they're my two favourites for that reason too!
What about Alex?
All I've learned is that Therm likes redheads. Even the redhead who dyes his hair black (I have no idea if that's canon or not, I don't remember).
I have seen people make tier lists and never I have I ever came across a tier list this analyzed and structured. My Stardew Valley character agrees with you
Though I love Elliott I completely understand why people don't like him. He tends to ride the fine line between a lot of self esteem and narcissism, but it's up to perspective. I like him because I've always liked more "out there" and eccentric characters. Other than writer man I agree with everything else.
I haven't seen all of his cutscenes, but he doesn't seem narcissistic to me. He let you choose the genre of his book; wouldn't a narcissistic personality be way less likely to outsource that big of a choice, and to at least make an unsubtle comment about it if he did instead of pulling you aside to say you inspired him and that's why he's dedicating it to you? I can't say for sure
I wonder what would happen if the tier list was more mathematical. So you can assign a score under certain criteria you find important and then assign each rank to a score range. I might do that for fun actually :)
My man grandpa gives you a farm and like everything on it and gets B
IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS
ME TOOO LETS GOOOOO
My only big disagreement is that Elliott is my favorite bachelor
ew
same, he's so down to earth
Gus will always be my guy. He's just the GOAT.
Didn't expect Therm to look like knock off MatPat but here we are
Lewis is like an F tier, just cause he's literally a pawn for the Governor. :(
Lewis is an F tier, but not because of the governor. The governor's great, he wears the silly little purple outfit and I love it. Lewis is an F tier because he's damaging the town to benefit himself.
Lewis is F tier because he uses and manipulate Marnie (whom I also dislike but 🤷🏻♀️), literally scams the town out of their money to make a bloody gold statue of himself, let’s the town’s economy and bus go into disrepair and Pam loose her job, and then expects you to sweep in to fix things. He legit sucks so much if I met him I’d sock him in the face. Absolute trash
THERM. Come on bro. Elliott's great, why does everyone hate him?! 🤣😭
Justice for Elliott! He was my husband in my first playthrough and he was really sweet, he makes you coffee and waters your plants, I really don't understand all the bashing people give him ☹
He was my favorite too 😢
90% of people who dislike Elliot don't know anything about him 💀 "he's pretentious!!! 1! " He's wordy when he talks and prefers to be cleanly. He's easily the BEST bachelor, he's one of the only ones who doesn't start out verbally assaulting the farmer, and his dialogue is always pleasant and friendly.
@@roachwater EXACTLY. We need justice for Elliot. My husband needs justice
He's also my favorite! He is honestly such a healthy choice for a relationship, just making is best to become an author and achieve his dreams!
no hate on eliiot but many sposes water your plants fed your animals and some make you coffee too
Abigail is a entertaining character and her heart events are my favorite. Did you know that the main character that you play as has a mini harp on them at all times?
As an author and reader, I love Elliott. He is a poetic guy and actually when I got back to Stardew Valley, watching this channel and seeing Elliott bias made me decide to court him. He isn't hard to gift either! Get a fruit bat cave, get a pomegranate tree and you are good to go! I courted him with pomegranate and eventually married him. On Mondays, he goes back to his cabin. You can take the man out of the sea but you can't take the sea out of the man! He also visits the resort sometimes! When you reach 14 hearts, he goes on a book tour and writes you letters every day until he is back. He isn't a snob or pretentious, he is a poetic man and loves his words! I enjoy him so much!
In another save, I married with Sebastian, and he is amazing. He works on his motorcycle, we have a frog terrarium, he gives you coffee and monster loot every now and then. He also encourages you to have slimes. I know slime hutch isn't so ideal but I was like "why not" and built one just because Sebastian wanted it as a hobby! He's an interesting character and I don't like that Demetrius treats him unfairly. Like excuse me, Maru may be building robots but Sebastian is doing coding like... How blind are you Demetrius?! And then poor Robin is doing her best to make sure both her children are okay, Robin is a good mom. Only downside I found with Sebastian is his Flower Dance dialogue (we were married when this happened), I asked him to dance and he said something like "do we really have to"... Excuse me Sebastian but you dance with ABIGAIL by default every single Flower Dance and now you tell me this as your wife... *broken heart*
TLDR: Justice for Eliiott, he is a poetic guy. Sebastian needs to improve himself in terms of Flower Dance.
sam & abigail getting C tier? robbed.
HOW DARE YOU DO MY HUSBAND ELIOTT LIKE THAT
I actually agree with majority of your list, except Clint. It’s a hot take now, but I think Clint’s an ok guy. I think he’s just a lonely soul, and he’s stupid bored.
i like his awkwardness too :)
I absolutely lost it when you put goblin in c tier 🤣
I've watched multiple of these tier list videos and no one explains why they hate Elliott
2:50 “we don’t see a lot of grandpa, all we see is him just saying like, ‘you’re doing so good! good job! i’m so proud of you!’” and thats not enough reason to put him in S tier? how many other people are saying that to you therm
I can relate to Elliott as a struggling writer but as a character he seems pretty dull
I am glad tho that both Shane and Sebby got some spotlight! They are both prime examples of how struggling, misguided characters can be done well and Sebastian happened to be my first bachelor choice :D Also Shane's theme is one of my favorite songs in the game because it's one of the few times the game gets very real, showcasing the struggles of alcoholism and self-insecurity that feel much more deserved than Pam constantly mistreating her amazing daughter
I literally love Shanes Theme so much. I listen to it like everyday!
Therms nightmare character; Pieam.
The wizard should be A if Therm likes interesting characters, he basically slept with the entire town women and now isnt sure which of their offspring is his child
Nice tier list, my disagreements are that Krobus needs his own S+ tier and Pierre needs his own F- tier. I haven't interacted with Elliott much so idk bout him.
All I really have to say is that Pierre needs more hate
Puts everyone in C Tier and lower in the first 3 minutes and proceeds to put George in S Tier is this real
Caroline:
Personality: Broken marriage
Tier: C
Jodi:
Personality: Broken marriage/bored housewife/seems lie she'd cheat/run away from her family given the opportunity
Tier: B
eh?
Ok harvey is not B because have you considered this: I love him
And here is why he is amazing:
Smart
Sweet
Has dreams
He might not be the most intresting but he is a kind cute anxious guy
If there's anything I realised about this game, it's that I have a thing for gingers.
I agree with your S tier, but I would add Sebastian because he’s the loml. But that’s a topic for another day.
Haley slander was insane
i played as a boy and married and alex, and when you do that, george doesn't like you because he says homosexuality is unnatural. He is an F for me.
“He’s the direct midpoint between Jeff Bezos and Mr Peanut” really got me I’ve been laughing for like 5 minutes straight
8:18 That Pierre comment caught me off guard and I laughed so hard at it. Also based
JUSTICE FOR ELLIOTT
"this has been a while in the making" *also places gil in B tier*
The silence when you put Elliot on F tier 😭😂😂😂😂
elliott does not deserve this pam/pierre slander!
Elliott is a bit unrealistic but I am extremely romantic and he just does it for me. Best spouse.
First tier list that I actually agree with
Something bad about George: if ur a male and you marry Alex he is against it :(
#CancelGeorge #GeorgeGate
well.
** trashes all the leeks i have **
meh, hes old, and in a weelchair, get roasted George.
George changes his mind later on when you get 10 hearts with him.
damn therm with the content 😍
Out of all these characters… ur the cutest Therm
Glad you're giving respect to my boy Willy
bruv i agree with 90% of this list but like, the sheer amount of elliott slander on youtube is astronomical 😭 he is so incredibly chill and sweet, just because he looks like a walking Pantene commercial doesn't mean he's snooty and pretentious
except for the elliott injustice, awesome vid, I cried laughing at the pierre part
I am completely on board with your rankings, Therm. Obviously you are quite cultured~
I would've put Marnie in F, she's gonna fucking kill my animals in winter
Elliot S tier 🙏
I like most of the characters outside of Pierre! Frick that guy
OMG Therm you are so cute I never got to see the person behind the screen!!!
super pumped about this one man - lovin the content!!
I love the Onnet theme at the end
Am i the only one who just found amusement in Clint's depressing life and escapades?
Haley is annoying at first but she has the most marrige gifts and they are almost all cooked dishes
TBH Demetrius should be in F tier I freaking hate that guy. He's so weird in Maru's first heart event and is obviously a terrible father figure to Sebastian. worst npc easily. Also yes Willy is S tier he's my fave non-romancable NPC!
I'd put the Wizard in A Tier purely because I think him potentially being Abigail's secret father and also having beef with his ex wife (who can literally turn your unwanted children into birds) is HILARIOUS.
I actually like sam because he works very hard for his music more than shane and abigail does, he loves what he do, he's also nice and he likes pizza, i like him more than shane. At first I really love shane in the game, very emo and i really dig the vibe... that is, until I caught him smoking outside by the lake. Minus points for that one.
Edit: OHHH MY GOOOD I MEANT SEBASTIAN!! Geeez I always confuse both of them since they both have their own vices lmao, but yeah, I like sam more than sebastian is what I meant.
For me Leah,Krobus and Gus would have their own tier.
Personally, my boi is always Sebastian, I start a new save, I get off of the bus, and Sebastian fears me. But then I make him forcefully date me, then marry me, then yell at him to give me a stardrop and then have 2 children... I named them Sacrifice and Failure :)
Therm lookin like a fresh boi!
I’m one of the few people who likes Elliott, as a poetic dork myself it’s just natural
Granny is in S. I don't need to see or agree with anything else. You are now objectively correct.
Also Elliot just kisses you without consent on a boat in the middle of nowhere and you start shaking so that's uncomfortable lol
Edit: AND George and Gus. Love this guy 10/10 video
YESSS
I've been waiting for this ❤❤
Always. Count Krobus as a Bachelor. Always. Krobus is the best
It's so funny to me that Therm doesn't know of so many characters' growth just bc he doesn't ever romance them 😭😭
This dood looks like Shane
I think Linus deserves an S spot. Hes such a sweetie but yet hes an outkast by society because they dont understand him, when all he wants to do is to be in nature and share his wisdom.
OH MY GOD WAIT IDK IF THIS IS A FACE REVEAL BUT THE FIRST TIME I'VE SEEN THERM AND RAAKEJF;AEWKJF;AFD WHY HE ACTUALLY SO PRETTY WHAT
i
You lost me putting Pam down the bottom... But then you put Pierre down there, and won me back pretty hard.
Controversial takes, but very valid my good sir.
Pierre and Elliot where they belong for sure. I like Pam when she's having a good time but when she's not she's awful way more than necessary so I'd probably have her in D tier. Really surprised not a single love interest in S-tier.
:O hype someone who didnt put haley as the worst. i think she is actually the best marriage candidate, like let's take for example sebastian, if you marry him it's a hostage situation. haley doesn't seem to have any long term goals, and i'm all for it :D
Yeah, I like some of the bachelors a lot, but I hate the idea of committing them to me for life. (so far, i don't know everything) I think it makes more sense for people like Abigail or Shane who don't have much going on and like the idea of being on a farm, but Sebastian?
abigail is S tier because we’re both gay rock eaters who like adventures and swords that’s literally it not to mention she’s the drummer in the valley’s cool little rock band LIKEEEEEEE >>>>>>
I headcannon taking her out to the mines for cute caving together, she has a lot of interests that overlap with the player character's
The other day i was doing Shane his hart events inbetween things and they hit a little to close to home for me.... ill just stick with krobus
Elliot was the first marriage candidate I met on my first playthrough and it was love at first sight. Can't relate
Top tier is my jam.
The second he put krobus on s tier he got a new sub.
Literally the only reason I don't love Linus with all my heart is the part where he hangs out outside of the hot springs in a potentially very creepy manner. Actually, a lot of NPCs are "I'd love them except this one part"