Economy will collapse, but 64% of Indian Voters / Population will NOT give a damn. Muslim-Hatred more than compensates for Economic suffering / stagnation.
Gentlemen, you should discuss another aspect of current Indian politics pursued by the ruling class: That is the constant sectarian strife based on religion. Finding mandir under ever mosque ? Now even Gurdwaras are not safe. This politically driven agenda of dividing the nation on religious and racial lines will certainly impact the Economy and the country's reputation abroad. Mind you, I live abroad and I see the growing negativity of India among the educated and even among the not so educated public. Thank you.
Very good discussions on the present situations of economic conditions where it's seems that the present govt busy with hindu muslims hates and not proper planning by the govt it is main Reasons for falling down the economy of country and their suggestion to steps to be taken by the govt to develop the country's economy. EXCELLENT
Why question of coupling or decoupling from Chinese Economy. China didn't build up their Economy to couple or decouple with Economy of other countries, they build up in the interest of their entire Nation. If China don't export to USA or don't import from USA, do u think that Chinese Economy will collapse, in last four months they have sold more than a crore passenger cars in their Domestic Market. They use highest number of Industrial Robotics in the World, they submit highest number of Research Paper on Science and Technology, many of their Universities r treated as high ranking University of the World, do we expect that without USA Chinese Economy will collapse. If entire Nation is conscious, organised, united in the interest of the entire Nation, no external force can harm them.
Our national economy is going downhill rapidly while the one on the driver's seat is busy looking at the rearview mirror. The government of the day is not concerned about the welfare of the people nor the economy at large, as long as they can be ensconced in the seat of power. And power to them means concentration of power, federalism be damned. Divisive politics seems to be the magic formula that provides handsome dividends during elections. Why blame the ruling dispensation when we the electorate are to be squarely blamed. We get what we deserve.
लोकसभा में या पीएम कभी गिरती देश की अर्थव्यवस्था,बेरोजगारी,मणिपुर पर चर्चा करते नहीं दिखते,5ट्रिलियन इकॉनमी, मंदिर मसजिद और 50,साल क्या कांग्रेस ने गलतीयबकी उनकी आलोचना ही करते है।
Most interesting discussion! Dr. Sen, just a piece of information. Tripura State Commissionrates of GST has provided IGST data at 4-digit HSN codes to the state's DES. There are some problems with the data; most importantly, the coverage. For example, agricultural produce are not within the GST system.
A very mature and down to earth (roots of the problem in our economic growth) discussion. My sincere wish is that some people from the Executive clan of the today 's government and with some clout & courage may listen to this discussion and shake our Finance minister to the perils before our country.
Interesting discussion with experts on the subject matter.👏 We’re prisoners of past. Suggest to bring some young forward looking guests who has great talent and ideas and also from current Government regime to see how we’re doing 🙏🏽
Jai Hind sir. Very interesting topic raised by all panelists. Present government is acting just like the proverb remark "self praise has no recommendation. " Analysis on economy of India gives immense pragmatic view as facing from other foreign countries . It will be a challenge if not made rectification soon. But to some extent China at present time is collapsing in terms of geopolitics, geoeconomics and in other field too.
The Bengal coastline is small and a big part of it is the Sundarbans. Moreover the coastline opens into the East, but most of the global economy is, especially where we would like to export is in the Western Hemisphere.
Indian social condition is worsening day by day just to win the elections and that affect Indian economy also. Country can’t make progress if there is unrest in the country due to hatred amongst various communities and casts.
What is called liberalization, liberalization of what? In Fortran Global Companies List 2024, 3 Chinese companies r ranked among top 10 Companies, all 3 r Government Companies. Among top 10 Chinese Companies, 9 r Government Companies and today r serious about what will be happened if Chinese Economy decoupled. If we try to continue present economic system, present type of Government, in coming 25 years we will not be able to cross US Economy though China will be largest Economy if Socialism does not collapse. No economic reforms can help us to progress fast because our present economic system is not in the interest of entire Nation. At present global environment, we can't progress much without involvement of our 95% population. Can u imagine a Foolish Politician is expressing his pride, keeping his head up, for distributing free food to the citizens of the country and the whole world is laughing at the Joker.
For 65+ years that it was in power, the idea of "real" issues like poverty for Congress was about vote bank politics. Interestingly, these "real" issues still remain. Congressis and leftists need these issues to stay in relevance.
Respected sirs Your faculty is sharing immensely important issues elaborated very well But not having Captions in Hindi n regional languages the reachout is denied to majority Indian population Pl. Add captions in easy words for commen men
If Sanjay Baru has these observations from his tenure, then why did he write the crap titled "The Accidental Prime Minister on which that horse shit movie was made?
We need to target 30 percent growth so that we are at 10 percent. Sounds ridiculous but once the pressure starts, a target is set, only then any taxi driver can take us to our destination. Aiming for 6.5 % will hit less. This has worked even in difficult situations in R&D as well as manufacturing last 30 years.
It is better to explain the Socialist Socioeconomic System of China, how it is beneficial to the entire Nation, why Democracy is nothing but an utopian concept, why the word Secular and Socialist is mentioned in our constitution though our State Machinery is neither Secular nor our Socioeconomic System is Socialist.
Great content, as always! Just a quick off-topic question: I have a SafePal wallet with USDT, and I have the seed phrase. (alarm fetch churn bridge exercise tape speak race clerk couch crater letter). Could you explain how to move them to Binance?
Why they will talk about common people, they r not elected or selected to talk about common people. Our Socio Economic System is Capitalist, the responsibility our State Machinery is to protect our existing Capitalist Socioeconomic System, accordingly our Government, Judiciary System, Administration, Defense r developed for that only, not to think for the common people.
Why should we try to diffentitate or compare Ruling Party and Oppositions Party, it is just like to compare between Black Donkey and White Donkey, they will carry their Masters on their back because their Masters selected them for that purpose only, why they will think for common people.
In my opinion, one reason why the middle class in India is not generating adequate demand, could be the very high cost of education and marriage. Middle class HAS TO save a lot more out of necessity. So If , like in the USA, banks would give easy loans to students and loans for marriages, household demand may increase (more money in the pockets of people) . And obviously better politics and court, as you have aptly discussed, will increase confidence for consumer demand. Thank you.
Excellent questions from Sibal and outstanding guests. I don’t see any concerted and strong actions by the GOI. Actions, if any, are slow. All the noise about the Adanis drives away Bharatiya private investment.
Technological dynamism comes from investment in education, research, by government, Private companies are not investing in research. Even if the private companies want to invest in research, we do not have professionals with the required skills as our education system is not producing them.
Great panel... Thanks to the organiser!! Like France, it seems very shortly we will also enter the recession 😢 Shame Godi Media.. Please focus on this subject.. Save our country!!!
Unless we implement Administrative reforms, the Ease of doing business in India will not improve. Hardly any company that has moved out of China has come to India. Even Apple is adding 4% value to India, and it gets subsidies of 6 %. Moreover, it is setting up a factory to sell in India.
What is the solution for this stagnation economy?? Improve ease of doing . Create a level playing period for new entreprenuers. New technologies, import substitution, Land reforms to get land easilily for SME enterprenuers.Get our infrastructure ready faster.
Why we common people think about what will be happened during the tenure of Newly elected Dictator of USA. Be sure that Newly elected Dictator will not decide how USA Government will protect their Imperialist System as our PM doesn't decide how our Government will protect our Capitalist, they r virtually powerless, for that both USA and India have more powerful people.
It is futile to talk of economy when Rs 100 crore is spent in Ladakh every day a direct consequence of abolishing Article 370.Either act like a superpower with $3 trillion GDP or take care of the economy. Without stopping war against own people there is no road except the downhill road.
Very nice topic chosen for discussion. Please don't speak about the truth and ground realities as India is already a global power house and Vishaw Guru!
You all honourable and respected gentlemen but who will convince the ruling dispensation? Whatever cosmetic innovations and revolution you witness is brought by akin to a daughter- in- law in her first year!
boycott goods from US brands use chinese alternatives, cheaper and reliable. Remember not to buy too cheap chinese. I am talking about established brands. Else try european, japanese or korean. Look at companies treatment of consumers , employees and citizens then decide to buy or if possible boycott. Spread the message
@SrinivasRao-vd4ki Mr troller (andh bhakt by using word KHANgress)see the pendency,and change your mind and see deeply the decision on electoral bond issue only in
If these fellows could digest international scenarios and understand it and predict outcomes, india wouldn't be in this shit shape. Wasting peoples time.
When economy was at peak where was he. When all the parameters of economy was high where was he. Do they have any plan to create 10 -15t gdp. What they have is new dramas in parliament.
learn about wealth, capital distribution pattern not about Net GDP and GDP per capita. These metrics are developed by IMF and World bank for US imperial goals
Kapil Sir, while introducing some high officials like the panel here , is it not something looking not nice calling someone as servant even though in some International organisations.
As Dollar Will get stronger and stronger, inflation is going to be high. The inflation rate of essential items generally stay above repo rate. Our Repo Rate is 6.5%, can we further increase Repo rate to control inflation, I don't think it is possible at present environment.
Mr Sibal you don't worry about all these aspects. Bharat is under progressive path. And all your concerns and fear are futile. When Modiji is handling the things he will over come all these issues. You focus on your advocate profession. Leave country to Modiji.
Economy will collapse, but 64% of Indian Voters / Population will NOT give a damn.
Muslim-Hatred more than compensates for Economic suffering / stagnation.
Gentlemen, you should discuss another aspect of current Indian politics pursued by the ruling class:
That is the constant sectarian strife based on religion.
Finding mandir under ever mosque ?
Now even Gurdwaras are not safe.
This politically driven agenda of dividing the nation on religious and racial lines will certainly impact the Economy and the country's reputation abroad.
Mind you, I live abroad and I see the growing negativity of India among the educated and even among the not so educated public.
Thank you.
What has mandir masjid got to do with China .......NOTHING
Very good discussions on the present situations of economic conditions where it's seems that the present govt busy with hindu muslims hates and not proper planning by the govt it is main
Reasons for falling down the economy of country and their suggestion to steps to be taken by the govt to develop the country's economy. EXCELLENT
Appreciate.Thanks to the organiser
Good panellist with world 🌎 vision
Congress bhakts. Panel.😢
Superb interview.. great insights
Thank you Sibaljee
Why question of coupling or decoupling from Chinese Economy.
China didn't build up their Economy to couple or decouple with Economy of other countries, they build up in the interest of their entire Nation.
If China don't export to USA or don't import from USA, do u think that Chinese Economy will collapse, in last four months they have sold more than a crore passenger cars in their Domestic Market. They use highest number of Industrial Robotics in the World, they submit highest number of Research Paper on Science and Technology, many of their Universities r treated as high ranking University of the World, do we expect that without USA Chinese Economy will collapse.
If entire Nation is conscious, organised, united in the interest of the entire Nation, no external force can harm them.
Our national economy is going downhill rapidly while the one on the driver's seat is busy looking at the rearview mirror. The government of the day is not concerned about the welfare of the people nor the economy at large, as long as they can be ensconced in the seat of power. And power to them means concentration of power, federalism be damned.
Divisive politics seems to be the magic formula that provides handsome dividends during elections. Why blame the ruling dispensation when we the electorate are to be squarely blamed. We get what we deserve.
what about ECI and EVM
The conclusion after 10 years: NDA Govt failed on multiple fronts in critical sectors
Is that why the economy, and Bharat as a whole, is doing far better than it did in 2014 ?
@@aryaman05How far better?
NDA national daridhra alliance
@@aryaman05 Is it? How far better? Neither the employment data, nor the consumption data, nor still the income distribution data support your claim.
this kind of discussion should happening in all the platform..
लोकसभा में या पीएम कभी गिरती देश की अर्थव्यवस्था,बेरोजगारी,मणिपुर पर चर्चा करते नहीं दिखते,5ट्रिलियन इकॉनमी, मंदिर मसजिद और 50,साल क्या कांग्रेस ने गलतीयबकी उनकी आलोचना ही करते है।
Uncle ji - Haryana aur Maharashtra mei haar hajam kar lo
Very insightful discussion.. Well anchored by Mr Kapil Sibal and the participating luminaries did a great job
The summation summed it all up 😊u
Most interesting discussion! Dr. Sen, just a piece of information. Tripura State Commissionrates of GST has provided IGST data at 4-digit HSN codes to the state's DES. There are some problems with the data; most importantly, the coverage. For example, agricultural produce are not within the GST system.
Why not send an email to Dr. Sen ?
Brilliant
A very mature and down to earth (roots of the problem in our economic growth) discussion. My sincere wish is that some people from the Executive clan of the today 's government and with some clout & courage may listen to this discussion and shake our Finance minister to the perils before our country.
Thanks. Good
What is our export situation
Our growing economy conditions
Our industry conditions
Interesting discussion with experts on the subject matter.👏 We’re prisoners of past. Suggest to bring some young forward looking guests who has great talent and ideas and also from current Government regime to see how we’re doing 🙏🏽
Jai Hind sir. Very interesting topic raised by all panelists. Present government is acting just like the proverb remark "self praise has no recommendation. " Analysis on economy of India gives immense pragmatic view as facing from other foreign countries . It will be a challenge if not made rectification soon. But to some extent China at present time is collapsing in terms of geopolitics, geoeconomics and in other field too.
When Mr Sibal said Hindi heartland he forgot about Bengal which has coastline like south and west india
The Bengal coastline is small and a big part of it is the Sundarbans. Moreover the coastline opens into the East, but most of the global economy is, especially where we would like to export is in the Western Hemisphere.
Indian social condition is worsening day by day just to win the elections and that affect Indian economy also. Country can’t make progress if there is unrest in the country due to hatred amongst various communities and casts.
Question is What is the real definition and size of MSME I forget about government defined
Very true. The economy is the most important subject
This "grumpy old men" concept theme is rather interesting.😊
Keep it up gentlemen👍
What is called liberalization, liberalization of what?
In Fortran Global Companies List 2024, 3 Chinese companies r ranked among top 10 Companies, all 3 r Government Companies.
Among top 10 Chinese Companies, 9 r Government Companies and today r serious about what will be happened if Chinese Economy decoupled.
If we try to continue present economic system, present type of Government, in coming 25 years we will not be able to cross US Economy though China will be largest Economy if Socialism does not collapse.
No economic reforms can help us to progress fast because our present economic system is not in the interest of entire Nation. At present global environment, we can't progress much without involvement of our 95% population.
Can u imagine a Foolish Politician is expressing his pride, keeping his head up, for distributing free food to the citizens of the country and the whole world is laughing at the Joker.
*NAMASHKAR*
At 28 min, a very valid point. We need msme and they take pains in skilling people .
The remaining software will be taken away by AI in next 3-5 years.
For 65+ years that it was in power, the idea of "real" issues like poverty for Congress was about vote bank politics. Interestingly, these "real" issues still remain. Congressis and leftists need these issues to stay in relevance.
I hope you are aware that today, the largest economy in the world in PPP terms is Leftist China.
How about Ambani marriage was carried out and published in front page media and live telecasted several days.
Respected sirs
Your faculty is sharing immensely important issues elaborated very well
But not having Captions in Hindi n regional languages the reachout is denied to majority Indian population
Pl. Add captions in easy words for commen men
If Sanjay Baru has these observations from his tenure, then why did he write the crap titled "The Accidental Prime Minister on which that horse shit movie was made?
We need to target 30 percent growth so that we are at 10 percent. Sounds ridiculous but once the pressure starts, a target is set, only then any taxi driver can take us to our destination. Aiming for 6.5 % will hit less.
This has worked even in difficult situations in R&D as well as manufacturing last 30 years.
Vicious cycle...no demand no sale no money....
Get a dream budget
What is fm doing daily basis..
It is better to explain the Socialist Socioeconomic System of China, how it is beneficial to the entire Nation, why Democracy is nothing but an utopian concept, why the word Secular and Socialist is mentioned in our constitution though our State Machinery is neither Secular nor our Socioeconomic System is Socialist.
Great content, as always! Just a quick off-topic question: I have a SafePal wallet with USDT, and I have the seed phrase. (alarm fetch churn bridge exercise tape speak race clerk couch crater letter). Could you explain how to move them to Binance?
Why they will talk about common people, they r not elected or selected to talk about common people.
Our Socio Economic System is Capitalist, the responsibility our State Machinery is to protect our existing Capitalist Socioeconomic System, accordingly our Government, Judiciary System, Administration, Defense r developed for that only, not to think for the common people.
We are listening to so-called economic experts having Chinese Phobia.
Why should we try to diffentitate or compare Ruling Party and Oppositions Party, it is just like to compare between Black Donkey and White Donkey, they will carry their Masters on their back because their Masters selected them for that purpose only, why they will think for common people.
Change fm please for few years
Through GST intelligence data we can work on domestic import and export data for trade between States. We need to restore genuine federalism.
In my opinion, one reason why the middle class in India is not generating adequate demand, could be the very high cost of education and marriage. Middle class HAS TO save a lot more out of necessity. So If , like in the USA, banks would give easy loans to students and loans for marriages, household demand may increase (more money in the pockets of people) . And obviously better politics and court, as you have aptly discussed, will increase confidence for consumer demand. Thank you.
Excellent questions from Sibal and outstanding guests. I don’t see any concerted and strong actions by the GOI. Actions, if any, are slow. All the noise about the Adanis drives away Bharatiya private investment.
🙏🙏🙏
Technological dynamism comes from investment in education, research, by government, Private companies are not investing in research. Even if the private companies want to invest in research, we do not have professionals with the required skills as our education system is not producing them.
The Sangies have criticised the Nehruvian Non-Alignment policies for decades but are still forced to follow the same guidelines.
Great panel... Thanks to the organiser!! Like France, it seems very shortly we will also enter the recession 😢 Shame Godi Media.. Please focus on this subject.. Save our country!!!
Unless we implement Administrative reforms, the Ease of doing business in India will not improve. Hardly any company that has moved out of China has come to India. Even Apple is adding 4% value to India, and it gets subsidies of 6 %. Moreover, it is setting up a factory to sell in India.
U gave the maximum scenario of economy including Modi’s favourite Adani & Ambani.
Until and unless India dumps the Policy of "Kid in a Candy Store Synonym" there is no way that it can avoid being "Caught with Pants Down" 😂😅❤
The main reason for the Parliament’s preoccupation with non-issues is the Opposition, lead by RAGA.
Present govt is busy defaming n containing RaGa
What is the solution for this stagnation economy?? Improve ease of doing . Create a level playing period for new entreprenuers. New technologies, import substitution, Land reforms to get land easilily for SME enterprenuers.Get our infrastructure ready faster.
Why we common people think about what will be happened during the tenure of Newly elected Dictator of USA.
Be sure that Newly elected Dictator will not decide how USA Government will protect their Imperialist System as our PM doesn't decide how our Government will protect our Capitalist, they r virtually powerless, for that both USA and India have more powerful people.
Very interesting that Modi did not find much direct mention in your discussion, Are you afraid of Modi regime?
Non-BJP govt will also have the same problems.
The debate is sounding like Chai pe charcha of ultra left ideologues
It is futile to talk of economy when Rs 100 crore is spent in Ladakh every day a direct consequence of abolishing Article 370.Either act like a superpower with $3 trillion GDP or take care of the economy. Without stopping war against own people there is no road except the downhill road.
Very nice topic chosen for discussion. Please don't speak about the truth and ground realities as India is already a global power house and Vishaw Guru!
You all honourable and respected gentlemen but who will convince the ruling dispensation? Whatever cosmetic innovations and revolution you witness is brought by akin to a daughter- in- law in her first year!
How can he support Antonia Gandos in her treasonous threat to Bharat?
boycott goods from US brands use chinese alternatives, cheaper and reliable. Remember not to buy too cheap chinese. I am talking about established brands. Else try european, japanese or korean. Look at companies treatment of consumers , employees and citizens then decide to buy or if possible boycott. Spread the message
Seems like we are stuck with the BJP. People have complaints, but they feel bjp is a Hindu party. Wow, it was great while it lasted.
Sir,also discuss about condition of judiciary,how it can be corrected and improve
Judiciary is doing fine and has come out of the clutches of KHANgress😅😅
@SrinivasRao-vd4ki Mr troller (andh bhakt by using word KHANgress)see the pendency,and change your mind and see deeply the decision on electoral bond issue only in
@SrinivasRao-vd4ki Mr troller,explain what is KHANgress
A panel comprising of neo liberals. Kapil Sibal it would be more exciting to watch with a more diverse panel
If these fellows could digest international scenarios and understand it and predict outcomes, india wouldn't be in this shit shape. Wasting peoples time.
When economy was at peak where was he. When all the parameters of economy was high where was he. Do they have any plan to create 10 -15t gdp. What they have is new dramas in parliament.
learn about wealth, capital distribution pattern not about Net GDP and GDP per capita. These metrics are developed by IMF and World bank for US imperial goals
Kapil Sir, while introducing some high officials like the panel here , is it not something looking not nice calling someone as servant even though in some International organisations.
As Dollar Will get stronger and stronger, inflation is going to be high.
The inflation rate of essential items generally stay above repo rate. Our Repo Rate is 6.5%, can we further increase Repo rate to control inflation, I don't think it is possible at present environment.
This kind of discussions are completely futile. A waste of your yime ans ours. Have the courage to call a spade a spade
Only bhakts like discussion on loose Wire. 😮
What is the out come of this talk ????
What is the solution????
If u don't have any solution then it's a waist of time.....
Think
accidental economist but HIRED AUTHOR OF BJP SHAME SHAME
Only two types business are flourishing in india , one is manufacturing nagpur half knickers and other one selling gomuthra in the bottle
Very well said😅😅😊
Incentivise people to leave india😂
Sanjay Baru a agent and opportunist writer?😮😮😮 He should have been kept out of Indian economic discussions.
shame in you to include a ungrateful turncoat who dlsucked up those in power
Umar Khalid zindabad 🎉🎉
Mr Sibal you don't worry about all these aspects. Bharat is under progressive path. And all your concerns and fear are futile. When Modiji is handling the things he will over come all these issues. You focus on your advocate profession. Leave country to Modiji.
What about other economists saying on the show? Are they lying?